P‐26CONVENTIONAL V THIN LAYER TECHNIQUES: A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF BRONCHIAL SPECIMENS USING CONVENTIONAL AND TWO LBC METHODS,THINPREP AND SUREPATH

Introduction: There is ongoing debate about the terminology used in the classification of dyskaryosis, including whether BNA smears should be classified according to whether koilocytes are present or not. We explored the effect of koilocytosis in the management experiences and clinical outcomes of women with a single BNA smear. Methods: This study includes 410 women aged 20–59 years, resident in Tayside who had an ‘baseline’ BNA smear between 31/10/1999 and 31/10/2002 who were eligible for the TOMBOLA trial but who did not participate. Recommended follow‐up for these women was a repeat smear in six months. Up to three‐years follow‐up data was collected on subsequent cytological smears, colposcopy examinations and any related histology. The baseline smear was re‐read for the presence or absence of koilocytes. Women were classified according to their clinical outcomes during their three years. Results: 47% (192/410) of women were classified as having koilocytosis at baseline. The mean age was lower among these women (25 years) compared to those without koilocytosis (35 years). 55% (105/192) of women with koilocytosis at baseline had one or more negative smears and no further abnormal smears, compared to 63% (137/218) of those without koilocytosis, the difference was not statistically significant. 28% (53/192) of women with koilocytosis at baseline were referred to colposcopy after subsequent low‐grade or high‐grade smears compared to 19% (42/218) of those without koilocytosis; the difference was statistically significant. 14% (27/192) of women with koilocytosis at baseline were diagnosed with CIN2/3 or worse during follow‐up compared to 10% (21/218) of women without koilocytosis; the difference was not statistically significant. Discussion: Our results suggest that the presence or absence of koilocytosis has little impact on the clinical outcomes of women with a BNA smear.     

O-2Preliminary results of the ARTISTIC study: a randomised trial in screening to improve cytology

Annually in the UK around 250 000 cervical smears show low-grade abnormalities. Alternative management policies following a low-grade smear are cytological surveillance or referral for colposcopy. Their effectiveness and cost-effectiveness, and the potential for human papillomavirus (HPV) testing to triage women to either management, has been debated. Trial of management of borderline and other low-grade abnormal smears (TOMBOLA) (a large RCT) addresses these uncertainties, considering clinical, psychosocial and economic outcomes. 4439 women aged 20–59, resident in Grampian, Tayside or Nottingham with a low-grade smear were randomised to cytological surveillance (six-monthly smears in primary care) or hospital-based colposcopy. At colposcopy, women with visible abnormality were randomised to immediate treatment or biopsy and recall for treatment if necessary. Recruitment HPV status was assessed using PCR techniques. Women were followed for three years to an exit colposcopy. Cumulative incidence of CIN2 or more severe disease (CIN2+) in the colposcopy arm was 7.9% per year, higher than in cytological surveillance (5.8%; OR = 1.43, 95% CI 1.23–1.67). This difference was less marked for CIN3+ (OR = 1.27, 1.04–1.55), suggesting spontaneous regression of some CIN2, and that initial colposcopy can lead to over-treatment. There was little difference in psychosocial outcomes between arms. In comparison of biopsy and recall versus immediate treatment, there was no difference in cumulative incidence of CIN2+ or psychosocial outcomes. There was over-treatment and increased frequency/duration of bleeding with immediate treatment. There was no compelling economic reason to favour any one management method. Testing for HPV does not appear to be effective in triage. Based on these findings, we make management recommendations for women with low-grade smears.     

Five-year follow-up of women with borderline and mildly dyskaryotic cervical smears

This study investigated the 5-year follow-up status of women with cervical smears showing borderline nuclear changes (BNC) or mild dyskaryosis and the effect of koilocytosis on the outcome. Thirteen per cent of women with cervical smears showing BNC had high-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN). In contrast, 28% of women with cervical smears showing mild dyskaryosis had high-grade CIN. The presence of koilocytosis (24% for borderline smears and 34% for mild dyskaryotic smears) did not appear to influence the risk of developing high-grade CIN. Our results suggest that the simultaneous implementation of the British Society for Clinical Cytology proposed terminology and the colposcopy guidelines from the British Society for Colposcopy and Cervical Pathology could have an impact on colposcopy services.     

P-5AN UNUSUAL FORM OF THYROID PAPILLARY CARCINOMA: COLUMNAR CELL VARIANT WITH NEUROENDOCRINE FEATURES

Introduction:  Quality assurance guidelines for the UK cervical screening programme recommend that more than 80% of cervical samples from women aged 20–50 years should contain adequate numbers of Transformation zone (TZ) cells i.e. 10 or more endocervical or squamous metaplastic cells. This study was conducted to assess the frequency of TZ component in Liquid Based Cytology (LBC) both for ThinPrep (TP) and SurePath (SP) LBC. Also to assess the degree to which this is recorded by individual screeners and to determine the percentage of samples with evidence of TZ component for the different smear takers.
Method:  All LBC cervical specimens received at a tertiary cytology centre in the year 2004 from women aged 20–50 years were included in the study. Evidence of TZ sampling was recorded as: TP = TZ present (10 or more TZ cells)TA = TZ absentTS = TZ scanty (less than 10 TZ cells)TN = atrophic smears, TZ cells not recognisable
Results:  The total number of LBC cervical cases was 7445. TP = 4300 (mostly primary care) and SP = 3145 (mostly colposcopy). Overall TZ sampling rate in LBC was 82%. TP = 77.17%; SP = 88.24%. When scanty TZ was included, the standard was met for both systems (TP = 93.7%; SP = 88.24%). Presence/absence of TZ component was recorded in 6370 cases (85.1%); range 0%–97.79%. 56.7% of smear takers achieved the minimum standard for TZ sampling.
Discussion:  The percentage of ThinPrep samples containing adequate TZ cells was 77.17% compared to SurePath, which was 88.24%. This may be due to different patient populations i.e. primary care versus colposcopy. Screeners recorded TZ sampling in approximately 85% of samples. 56.7% of smear takers met the standard for TZ sampling.     

The inadequate smear: does it matter?

The objective of this study was to quantify the incidence of underlying cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) among women referred for colposcopy with three consecutive inadequate smears. The design was a retrospective cohort study analysing data from a regional colposcopy database at Cervical Screening Wales. Women who were referred to all the colposcopy clinics in Wales with three consecutive inadequate smears, the third inadequate smear being taken between 1 April 2001 and 31 March 2002 constituted the study population. The results of the fourth smear taken at the colposcopy clinic after three consecutive inadequate smears, the worst biopsy results from any of the subsequent colposcopies and the relationship between the result of the fourth smear taken at colposcopy clinic and any histology result were the main outcome measures. The accuracy of the colposcopic opinion was also examined. Of the 433 women identified as having been referred because of three consecutive inadequate smears, 302 were linked to either a subsequent smear and/or a biopsy result. An adequate smear result was available for 85% of these women when the smear was taken in the colposcopy clinic; 77% were reported as negative and 8% were abnormal. Of the 347 women seen in the colposcopy clinic, high-grade CIN was seen in 3% and low-grade lesion in 8%. The sensitivity and specificity of the fourth inadequate smear test in predicting underlying CIN were 15% and 84% respectively, with a positive predictive value of 8%. The sensitivity and specificity of colposcopy in predicting histological CIN among patients with three inadequate smears was 70% and 49%, respectively, and the positive predictive value was 44%. This study raises the question as to whether three consecutive inadequate smears should be considered as an indication for colposcopy, or merely for a further smear to be taken in circumstances where there is a greater likelihood getting an adequate result.     

Prevalence of high-grade CIN following mild dyskaryotic smears in different age groups

OBJECTIVE: The new guidelines of the British Society of Colposcopy and Cervical Pathology suggest that women should be offered colposcopy after only one mildly dyskaryotic smear. This is expected to generate increased workload for the colposcopy clinics, at least in the short term. The main objective of this study was to estimate the incidence of high-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) in women with mildly dyskaryotic smears and investigate whether there is any variation in different age groups. The rationale was to determine whether we could reduce the burden on colposcopy services by prioritizing the mild dyskaryotic referrals by age, as we hypothesized that high-grade CIN is less frequent in younger women. METHODS: The study sample included all women who were referred for colposcopy with a cervical smear suggesting mild dyskaryosis (with or without koilocytosis) from April 2000 to March 2003. RESULTS: We studied 510 women. They were divided into three age groups (<20, 20-25 and >25 years). The overall prevalence of high-grade CIN (CIN II and III) was 28.7%.The positive predictive value of a mildly dyskaryotic smear for high-grade CIN was similar in all groups. CONCLUSIONS: Our results show that we are not in a position to prioritize our referrals by age group and reduce the initial pressure for colposcopies. We are also concerned that with the implementation of the new guidelines, a significant number of women <25 years will be carrying high-grade CIN for more than 5 years before they are first screened.     

The role of cervical cytology and colposcopy in detecting cervical glandular neoplasia

Objective:  To determine the role of cervical cytology and colposcopy in the management of endocervical neoplasia.
Setting:  Colposcopy unit and cytology laboratory in a teaching hospital.
Sample:  Group 1 included 184 smears showing endocervical glandular neoplasia from 129 patients and group 2 included 101 patients with histology showing endocervical abnormalities in a 6-year period (1993–1998). Follow-up of 6–11 years to 2004 was available.
Methods:  Group 1 were identified from the cytology computer records. Group 2 were identified from histology records on the cytology database and a record of histology cases kept for audit purposes. The clinical records were examined retrospectively.
Results:  The positive predictive value (PPV) of abnormal endocervical cells in smears was 81.1% for significant glandular/squamous [cervical glandular intraepithelial neoplasia (CGIN)/cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade2 (CIN2 or worse)] lesions. The PPV of colposcopy was 93.5% for significant glandular/squamous lesions of the cervix. The postcolposcopy probability of a significant lesion when colposcopy was normal was 87.5%. The sensitivity of colposcopy in detecting endocervical lesions was 9.8%. The sensitivity of cervical smears in detecting a significant endocervical abnormality (CGIN or worse) was 66.3%. The false negative rate for cytology of endocervical glandular lesions was 4.0%.
Conclusions:  Endocervical glandular neoplasia detected on cytology is predictive of significant cervical pathology even when colposcopy is normal, which supports excisional biopsy in the primary assessment of these smears. The high concomitant squamous abnormality rate justifies the use of colposcopy to direct biopsies from the ectocervix. Cervical cytology is the only current screening method for cervical glandular abnormalities but sensitivity is poor.     

Cervical smear adequacy: cellularity references were found to increase both interobserver agreement and unsatisfactory rate

Objectives:  To determine the degree of interobserver variation in the assessment of conventional cervical smear adequacy as defined by The Bethesda System (TBS) 2001, and to determine the effect of using reference images of known squamous cellularity when performing squamous adequacy assessments.
Methods:  Experimental pre-test/post-test design utilizing 70 conventionally prepared cervical smears. Sample smears containing scant squamous cellularity were independently rated on two occasions by six cytotechnologists. Time 1 was without the use of reference images, and Time 2 was aided by cellularity reference images. The κ statistic was used to compare rater agreement.
Results:  The level of agreement increased from an average κ of 0.26 (SD 0.10) for Time 1, to an average κ of 0.40 (SD 0.15) for Time 2. The difference in mean κ values at the two assessments was statistically significant ( t  = 3.71; P  = 0.002). Unanimous agreement among the raters was observed for 15 samples (21.42%) at Time 1 (only one of which was classified as unsatisfactory) and 21 samples (30.00%) at Time 2 (12 of which were classified as unsatisfactory).
Conclusion:  Interobserver agreement increased after cellularity reference images were implemented. Using TBS 2001 squamous adequacy criteria and images of known squamous cellularity as references resulted in a decreased number of smears reported as satisfactory.     

Outcome of women referred to colposcopy for persistently inadequate smears

The outcome of referral to colposcopy of 240 women who had persistently inadequate smears was investigated. Of 232 women who attended colposcopy, 214 (92.2%) had a normal outcome, 12 (5.2%) had low grade abnormalities, and six (2.6%) had high grade abnormalities. This group of women therefore has a negligibly increased risk of harbouring cervical neoplasia. Although not directly comparable, women with a history of previous abnormal cytology did not have a higher risk than those without such a history. Unnecessary colposcopy could have been avoided in the majority of cases if a good quality repeat smear had been taken. Improved smear taker training could decrease the number of referrals. A hospital cytology clinic is proposed as a cost-effective alternative to colposcopy at the first attendance.     

Proffered Papers 10.30–11.15 Monday 15 September 2003 3 5 year outcome of women with borderline and mild dyskaryosis smears 3 5 year outcome of women with borderline and mild dyskaryosis smears

Aims

• 1 To identify the outcome status of women with borderline and mild dyskaryosis smears.
• 2 To determine whether the presence or absence of koilocytosis influences the outcome status.
• 3 To identify the proportion of women with borderline smears showing koilocytosis.

Materials and methods Borderline and mild dyskaryosis cervical smears diagnosed during January to March 1997 were identified from the laboratory database. Each slide was reviewed by two researchers independently, who then agreed a final consensus diagnosis. All slides were classified according to the presence or absence of koilocytosis. Slides were excluded from the study if the review diagnosis was negative, inadequate or high‐grade dyskaryosis. The outcome status was classified according to the worst lesion identified histologically and/or cytologically during the 5‐year follow‐up period. Results 1974 women were identified with borderline or mild dyskaryosis cervical smears of which 1597 were included in the study. Table 1 shows the outcome status of these women.

Table 1. . The outcome status of these women

"Nonclassic" cytologic signs of cervical condyloma. A case-control study

The association between "nonclassic" cytologic signs of condyloma and human papillomavirus (HPV) infection in women with negative Papanicolaou smears was analyzed via a case-control study. The cytologic signs considered were mild koilocytosis, mild dyskeratosis, binucleation or multinucleation, cleared cytoplasm and nuclear hyperchromatism. The Papanicolaou smears of 166 cases that showed colposcopic and histologic evidence of HPV infection (but whose smears lacked the classic cytologic signs of condyloma) and 166 controls that were negative colposcopically were randomly admixed and blindly reviewed by a panel of cytologists. A significant association to HPV infection was observed for all of the nonclassic signs studied, but multivariate analysis showed a weakly independent association only for mild koilocytosis. The sensitivity (0.46) and the specificity (0.87) of these nonclassic signs were not satisfactory. The utility of selecting women with negative Papanicolaou smears for colposcopy on the basis of these signs is discussed.     

Management of low‐grade cervical abnormalities detected at screening: which method do women prefer?

Objective:  To establish whether women with low-grade abnormalities detected during screening for cervical cancer prefer to be managed by cytological surveillance or by immediate colposcopy.
Methods:  TOMBOLA (Trial of Management of Borderline and Other Low-grade Abnormal smears) is a randomized controlled trial comparing alternative management strategies following the screen-detection of low-grade cytological abnormalities. At exit, a sample of TOMBOLA women completed a questionnaire eliciting opinions on their management, contingent valuations (CV) of the management methods and preferences. Within-trial quality of life (EQ-5D) data collected for a sample of TOMBOLA women throughout their follow-up enabled the comparison of self-reported health at various time points, by management method.
Results:  Once management had been initiated, self-reported health in the colposcopy arm rose relative to that in the surveillance arm, although the effect was short-term only. For the majority of women, the satisfaction ratings and the CV indicated approval of the management method to which they had been randomized. Of the minority manifesting a preference for the method which they had not experienced, relatively more would have preferred colposcopy than would have preferred surveillance.
Conclusions:  The findings must be interpreted in the light of sample bias with respect to preferences, whereby enthusiasm for colposcopy was probably over-represented amongst trial participants. The study suggests that neither of the management methods is preferred unequivocally; rather, individual women have individual preferences, although many would be indifferent between methods.     

O-9Uncommon subtypes of borderline nuclear changes: cytological features and predictive value

Introduction:  To establish the significance of cytological features which could predict clinically significant endometrial pathology, and therefore guide reporting practice in cervical samples.
Methods:  A retrospective review of SurePath liquid-based cytology (LBC) cervical samples between 2002 and 2006, obtained at screening and colposcopy. These smears contained normal endometrial cells present at inappropriate times of the menstrual cycle, endometrial cells with atypia (borderline change) and with features suspicious / diagnostic of endometrial carcinoma (glandular neoplasia). False negative and false positive cases detected on subsequent histology were also included. The control group comprised negative samples and a few abnormal smears. All smears were randomly assigned and blinded to menopausal status, age, use of oral contraceptive pill and hormone replacement therapy and presence of intrauterine device. Each smear was reviewed for 16 cytologic criteria and a cytological diagnosis was given for each.
Results:  A total of 219 smears were available for review; 137 were negative, out of which 85 contained normal endometrial cells, 41 contained endometrial cells with atypia, 10 contained endometrial cells with features suggestive of adenocarcinoma and 31 contained endometrial cells with features diagnostic of adenocarcinoma. The feature most associated with benign endometrial cells is top hat with central cell condensation. In contrast, the features associated with malignant endometrial cells are smooth nuclear membrane, pale chromatin, small nucleoli and scalloped borders.
Discussion:  The criteria identified in this study do not definitively define a neoplastic process, but appear to be helpful in individual cases. This study emphasises that endometrial changes should be always interpreted with the relevant clinical information, which would otherwise lead to overdiagnosis in premenopausal women.     

Using the number of koilocytes to predict HIV serostatus in women with HPV-associated SIL

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the relationship between specific cytopathologic changes, koilocyte counts and human papillomavirus (HPV) types in HIV-positive and -negative women. STUDY DESIGN: A cohort of 459 women (266 HIV+ and 193 HIV-), were examined in a multicentric study (Early Diagnosis of Neoplasia in AIDS) involving 14 gynecologic centers. Altogether, 97 women had cervical smears consistent with squamous intraepithelial lesions (SIL). Koilocytes were found in 60/97 SIL slides, subjected to quantitative counting in 30 predetermined fields. HPV genotype was determined by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis. RESULTS: SIL lesions were four times more frequent (29%) in HIV-positive women than in HIV-negative women (10%) (odds ratio = 3.80). HPV DNA was equally frequent in both groups. There was a strong association between the number of koilocytes and HIV serostatus in both high grade and low grade SIL diagnoses. The presence of eight or more koilocytes had a specificity of 93% and sensitivity of 76% toward the diagnosis of HIV-positive status. No HIV-negative woman had a count > 8 koilocytes. No association was shown between koilocyte count and HPV genotype. CONCLUSION: An elevated number of koilocytes could suggest the possibility of HIV infection. Pap smear examination might give the first clue to HIV positivity in otherwise-unsuspected cases.     

A retrospective clinical audit of cervical smears reported as 'glandular neoplasia'.

The aims of this study were to review the diagnostic pathway of women with smears reported as 'glandular neoplasia' and to outline the management, colposcopy findings, treatment and final histological diagnosis in these women. The design was a retrospective review. A total of 114 women were identified over a 5-year period from the cytology database at the Royal Liverpool University Hospital Cytology Department, whose hospital case notes were available for review. Methods included a review of the case notes for the demographic details, indication for smear, colposcopic findings, investigation and/or treatment procedures, histology, final diagnosis and current disease status. Of 114 smears reported as 'glandular neoplasia', 67 were reported as consistent with cervical glandular intra-epithelial neoplasia (CGIN), six with endocervical adenocarcinoma, 36 with endometrial adenocarcinoma and five with other glandular neoplastic abnormalities. The average age was 46.5 years. 79 (69.3%) smears were routine call/recall and 36 (30.7%) women were symptomatic. The positive predictive value (PPV) for a significant histological abnormality in the CGIN smear group was 80.6% (23.9% invasive carcinomas, 43.3% CGIN and 13.4% CIN) and the PPV of an 'endometrial adenocarcinoma' smear was 86.1%. Smears indicating glandular neoplasia are associated with a high probability of clinically significant lesions, the PPV of a CGIN smear being over 80%. Immediate referral for colposcopy and assessment by an experienced colposcopist is recommended.     

Management of women with mild and moderate cervical dyskaryosis.

OBJECTIVE--To compare the outcomes in women with mild and moderate dyskaryosis after increasing periods of surveillance and thereby to define a rational protocol for managing such women. DESIGN--Prospective study with randomisation of women to one of four treatment groups, each with a different period of surveillance; one group in which the women were given immediate treatment and three other groups in which the women were under surveillance for six, 12, and 24 months. SETTING--A dedicated colposcopy clinic in Aberdeen, Scotland. SUBJECTS--902 women who presented with a mildly or moderately dyskaryotic smear for the first time. INTERVENTIONS--Cytological and colposcopic examinations at intervals of six months until the allocated period of surveillance was completed, at which time biopsy was performed. Women with severe dyskaryosis were withdrawn from surveillance and a biopsy was performed. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES--The histological findings after punch biopsy or large loop excision of the transformation zone, and the trends in cytological appearances of serial cervical smears. RESULTS--793 women completed the study. In all, 769 women had an adequate final smear, of which 197 were normal cytologically, 328 were still mildly or moderately dyskaryotic, and 244 were severely dyskaryotic. Seventeen of the 67 (25%) women with one repeat smear showing non-dyskaryosis had cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade III compared with only one of the 31 (3%) women with no dyskaryosis in four repeat cervical smears (P < 0.0001). None of the women had invasive cancer. Of 158 women whose index smear showed mild dyskaryosis and who were allocated to the group under surveillance for two years, only 40 had not defaulted or still had dyskaryotic smears by the end of the two years. CONCLUSION--Cytological surveillance, although safe, is not an efficient strategy for managing women with mildly abnormal smears. Women with any degree of dyskaryosis in a smear should be referred for colposcopy.     

Screening for cervical cancer: a new scope for general practitioners? Results of the first year of colposcopy in general practice.

A survey was carried out over one year of all the women who attended a colposcopy clinic in a general practice. During the year 1254 women underwent cytological screening in the practice and 197 of these underwent colposcopy. Of 79 women with abnormal smears that suggested cervical intraepithelial neoplasia, 62 (79%) were confirmed by biopsy to have cervical premalignancy. In addition, the remaining 118 women with normal or inflammatory smears underwent colposcopy either because of their history or because they requested the investigation. A general underestimate of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia when cytology alone was used was discovered. Seven out of 28 women with inflammatory smears were found to have important cervical premalignancy. Mildly dyskaryotic smears led to a falsely reassuring estimate of the degree of severity of cervical lesions. Seven out of 13 patients who underwent colposcopy because they were thought to be at high risk of neoplasia because of a history of genital warts, unexplained recurrent cystitis, heroin abuse, or immunosuppression had cervical intraepithelial neoplasia proved at biopsy. This report shows that both in screening for and in the follow up of known cervical disease a normal smear cannot guarantee normal pathology. Diagnostic colposcopy is a valuable complementary investigation that could be carried out in a general practice.     

The use of screening episodes linked to CIN3 and invasive cancer registrations to study outcomes from the NHS Cervical Screening Programme

Objective: To examine how NHS cervical screening data can be collected and analysed in order to evaluate women’s screening histories as episodes rather than as individual smears. Design: Analysis of routine cervical screening data grouped into screening episodes for a cohort of women regarding episodes starting in a given year. Setting: NHS Cervical Screening Programme. Population: Data from four Health Authorities (now eight Primary Care Trusts) from the NHS Cervical Screening Programme with primary smears (first in an episode) taken between 1 April 1999 and 31 March 2000. Methods: Cytology information obtained from the call/recall (‘Exeter’) computer system was linked to cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) 3 and invasive cancer outcome information obtained from cancer registries. Screening histories were divided into episodes, each starting with a primary smear that was followed up to episode closure or, for episodes still open followed for an average 4.25 years, from the primary smear. The episode was divided into two parts (up to referral to colposcopy and following the referral). The outcomes of the episodes are described including referral rate to colposcopy and CIN3 and invasive cancer rates by factors such as age. Main outcome measures: Episode histories and rates of referral to colposcopy, CIN3 and invasive cancer. Results: There were 176 923 episodes from 176 319 women (1.003 episodes per woman) followed up to March 2004, the date at which the first phase of information accrual ceased. Of these episodes, 172 100 (97.3%) were closed either by a negative smear referring the woman back to routine recall or by default (defined as no smear recorded within 21 months following a smear requiring an action of repeat or refer to colposcopy). The remaining 4823 (2.7%) of episodes were still open, of which in 3121 (1.8%) the woman had been referred to colposcopy and in 1702 (1.0%) no referral decision had been made. Referral rates to colposcopy varied by age from 5.7% in women aged 20–24 years down to 0.9% in women aged 60–64 years. The overall efficiency of screening was highest for woman aged about 30 years, with a CIN3 detection rate of eight per 1000 women and a positive predictive value (for CIN3 or worse) of referral to colposcopy of 21%. Conclusion: The study has shown that routinely collected NHS cervical screening data can be combined to give information on complete episodes, allowing important performance measures to be studied. We suggest that in future information in the NHS screening system should be structured to facilitate such analysis and to allow cytology and histology information to be readily linked.     

Assessment of the Accuracy of Cytology In Women Referred For Colposcopy and Biopsy: the Results of a 1 Year Audit

The results of weekly colposcopy review meetings have been audited for 1 year and cases where there was a discrepancy between the referral cervical smear and the initial colposcopy biopsy have been analysed. New referrals (n = 476) for colposcopy were studied. In the final outcome 80% of 326 women referred for moderate or severe dyskaryosis were found to have cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) grade II or III or invasive carcinoma. Three women found to have invasive carcinoma had been referred for severely dyskaryotic smears. Twenty women were referred for smears with cell changes suggesting glandular neoplasia: five were found to have adenocarcinoma in situ, whereas eight had CIN and seven had negative biopsies. The results justify the referral policy and demonstrate the need for further investigation when initial colposcopic biopsies are negative.     

Pap smear adequacy--is the assessing criterion including endocervical cells really valid?

The significance of endocervical cylindrical cells (EC) as a criterion of sample adequacy has been established on 1,000 patients by comparing VCE smears (vaginal, cervical, endocervical) with or without EC in relation to prevalence of abnormal cells, prevalence of histological diagnosed lesions and sensitivity and negative predictive value of Pap smear, as well as by comparison of negative findings without EC with control smears with the aim of discovering overlooked lesions. A considerably greater yield of cytological (107/536 in relation to 49/464) and histological (105/536 in relation to 55/464) (p < 0.05) abnormalities in smears with EC support the hypothesis that the presence of EC is strongly and positively associated with prevalence of disease. In contrast, the presence of EC predicts only a moderate improvement in Pap smear quality with a weaker effect on sensitivity (95% in relation to 80%). During two-years monitoring of patients with negative Pap smear and negative colposcopy (403 with EC and 390 without EC in smears), no positive cytology/histology diagnosis was made. Also, because the prevalence of missed lesions among negative Pap smears is extremely low in absolute terms, no appreciable impact on negative predictive value was observed (98.8% in relation to 97.3%).