Implication of an Asp residue in the ribonucleolytic activity of hirsutellin A reveals new electrostatic interactions at the active site of ribotoxins

Ribotoxins are fungal extracellular ribonucleases that specifically cleave ribosomes leading to cell-death via apoptosis. α-Sarcin is the ribotoxin studied in deepest detail, and therefore constitutes the referential protein for the whole family. It has been demonstrated that ribotoxin activity depends on a very precise structural microenvironment in which electrostatic interactions among residues in the active site are of the highest importance. Hirsutellin A (HtA) has been recently described as the smallest ribotoxin known to date, encompassing all the abilities of previously characterized members of this family into a shorter sequence. Comparison of HtA and α-sarcin three-dimensional structures suggested that residues presumably forming the catalytic triad of HtA would be His 42, Glu 66, and His 113. Within this same idea, the presence of an Asp residue (Asp 40) in a position equivalent to α-sarcin Tyr 48 is highlighted as a novelty in this field. In this work, substitution mutants H42Q, E66Q and H113Q, as well as double and triple mutants in all possible combinations, are studied regarding their ribonucleolytic activity and cytotoxicity. Implication of these three residues in the ribotoxin activity of HtA is confirmed, though none of them is strictly essential for ribosomal cleavage. Studies with mutants D40N and D40N/E66Q demonstrate an important role for Asp 40 in the activity of HtA and establish a new set of electrostatic interactions different from the one described for already known ribotoxins.     

Fungal extracellular ribotoxins as insecticidal agents

Fungal ribotoxins were discovered almost 50 years ago as extracellular ribonucleases (RNases) with antitumoral properties. However, the biological function of these toxic proteins has remained elusive. The discovery of the ribotoxin HtA, produced by the invertebrates pathogen Hirsutella thompsonii, revived the old proposal that insecticidal activity would be their long searched function. Unfortunately, HtA is rather singular among all ribotoxins known in terms of sequence and structure similarities. Thus, it was intriguing to answer the question of whether HtA is just an exception or, on the contrary, the paradigmatic example of the ribotoxins function. The work presented uses HtA and α-sarcin, the most representative member of the ribotoxins family, to show their strong toxic action against insect larvae and cells.     

Arginine 121 is a crucial residue for the specific cytotoxic activity of the ribotoxin alpha-sarcin.

Alpha-sarcin, a cyclizing ribonuclease secreted by the mould Aspergillus giganteus, is one of the best characterized members of a family of fungal ribotoxins. This protein induces apoptosis in tumour cells due to its highly specific activity on ribosomes. Fungal ribotoxins display a three-dimensional protein fold similar to those of a larger group of microbial noncytotoxic RNases, represented by RNases T1 and U2. This similarity involves the three catalytic residues and also the Arg121 residue, whose counterpart in RNase T1, Arg77, is located in the vicinity of the substrate phosphate moiety although its potential functional role is not known. In this work, Arg121 of alpha-sarcin has been replaced by Gln or Lys. These two mutations do not modify the conformation of the protein but abolish the ribosome-inactivating activity of alpha-sarcin. In addition, the loss of the positive charge at that position produces dramatic changes on the interaction of alpha-sarcin with phospholipid membranes. It is concluded that Arg121 is a crucial residue for the characteristic cytotoxicity of alpha-sarcin and presumably of the other fungal ribotoxins.     

Similarities between Argonautes and the alpha-sarcin-like ribotoxins: Implications for microRNA action

We report structural, functional, and biochemical similarities between Argonautes, the effector proteins of RNA‐induced silencing complexes (RISCs), and alpha‐sarcin‐like ribotoxins. At the structural level, regions of similarity in the amino acid sequence are located in protein loops both in the ribotoxins and in the Argonautes. In ribotoxins, these protein loops confer specificity for a highly conserved segment of ribosomal RNA, the Sarcin‐Ricin‐Loop (SRL) that undergoes cleavage by the ribotoxin ribonuclease. This leads to suppression of translation. In addition to the structural similarity with ribotoxins, the Argonaute proteins (Ago) show both functional and biochemical parallels. Like the ribotoxins, the Agos exhibit ribonuclease activity and like the ribotoxins, translational suppression mediated by miRISC‐resident Ago is accompanied by intact polysomes. Furthermore, in both translationally suppressed systems, the puromycin reaction, reflecting correct translocation and peptidyl‐transferase activities, is unharmed. These findings support a mechanism for Ago‐miRISCs whereby regulated cleavage of ribosomal RNA leads to translational suppression.     

Conserved asparagine residue 54 of alpha-sarcin plays a role in protein stability and enzyme activity

Asparagine 54 of alpha-sarcin is a conserved residue within the proteins of the ribotoxin family of microbial ribonucleases. It is located in loop 2 of the protein, which lacks repetitive secondary structure elements but exhibits a well-defined conformation. Five mutant variants at this residue have been produced and characterized. The spectroscopic characterization of these proteins indicates that the overall conformation is not changed upon mutation. Activity and denaturation assays show that Asn-54 largely contributes to protein stability, and its presence is a requirement for the highly specific inhibitory activity of these ribotoxins on ribosomes.     

Molecular dissection of mitogillin reveals that the fungal ribotoxins are a family of natural genetically engineered ribonucleases

Mitogillin and the related fungal ribotoxins are highly specific ribonucleases which inactivate the ribosome enzymatically by cleaving the 23-28 S RNA of the large ribosomal subunit at a single phosphodiester bond. The site of cleavage occurs between G4325 and A4326 (rat ribosome numbering) which are present in one of the most conserved sequences (the alpha-sarcin loop) among the large subunit ribosomal RNAs of all living species. Amino acid sequence comparison of ribotoxins and guanyl/purine ribonucleases have identified domains or residues likely involved in ribonucleolytic activity or cleavage specificity. Fifteen deletion mutants (each 4 to 8 amino acid deletions) in motifs of mitogillin showing little amino acid sequence homology with guanyl/purine ribonucleases were constructed by site-directed mutagenesis. Analyses of the purified mutant proteins identified those regions in fungal ribotoxins contributing to ribosome targeting and modulating the catalytic activity of the toxin; some of the identified motifs are homologous to sequences in ribosomal proteins and elongation factors. This mutational study of mitogillin together with the recently published x-ray structure of restrictocin (a close relative of mitogillin) supports the hypothesis that the specific cleavage properties of ribotoxins are the result of natural genetic engineering in which the ribosomal targeting elements of ribosome-associated proteins were inserted into nonessential regions of T1-like ribonucleases.     

A non-cytotoxic but ribonucleolytically specific ribotoxin variant: implication of tryptophan residues in the cytotoxicity of hirsutellin A

Ribotoxins are a family of toxic proteins that exert a highly specific cleavage at the universally conserved sarcin/ricin loop (SRL) of the larger rRNA molecule. Before this ribonucleolytic action, passage through the cell membrane is a necessary step for ribotoxin internalization and the limiting factor for cytotoxicity. Although extensive knowledge of their ribonucleolytic activity and substrate recognition has been accumulated, little is known about the mechanisms of cell entry of ribotoxins. Hirsutellin A (HtA) is a recently described member of this family, which accommodates the main abilities of previously characterized ribotoxins into a shorter sequence, but exhibits some differences regarding membrane interaction properties. This work investigates the contribution of tryptophan (Trp) residues 71 and 78 to both endoribonucleolytic activity and cellular toxicity of this ribotoxin. Substitution mutants W71F and W78F, as well as the double mutant W71/78F, were obtained and assayed against isolated ribosomes, synthetic SRL, and human tumor cells. The results provide evidence that cell membrane passage and internalization, as well as substrate-specific recognition, require the participation of the region involving both Trp 71 and Trp 78. Additionally, the mutant W71/78F is the first non-cytotoxic but specific ribosome-cleaving ribotoxin mutant obtained to date.     

Tyr-48, a conserved residue in ribotoxins, is involved in the RNA-degrading activity of alpha-sarcin

Residue Tyr-48 in alpha-sarcin is conserved not only within the ribotoxin family, but also within the larger group of extracellular fungal ribonucleases, best represented by RNase T1. A mutant protein in which this Tyr residue was substituted by Phe has been produced and isolated to homogeneity. It was spectroscopically analyzed by means of circular dichroism, fluorescence emission and NMR. Taken together, these results and those from enzyme characterization have revealed the essential role of the -OH group from the Tyr-48 phenolic ring in the cleavage of polymeric RNA substrates, including the ribosome-embedded 28S rRNA, the natural substrate of ribotoxins. Thus, the mutant protein does not degrade its natural ribosomal RNA substrate. However, it has been shown that this Y48F mutant still retains its ability to cleave a phosphodiester bond in a minimal substrate such as the dinucleoside phosphate ApA. The role of different alpha-sarcin residues within the enzyme reaction catalyzed by this protein is discussed.     

The influence of ATP on the binding of aromatic amino acids to the ligand response domain of the tyrosine repressor of Haemophilus influenzae

Mitogillin and related fungal ribotoxins are small basic ribonucleolytic proteins that inhibit protein synthesis by specifically hydrolyzing a single phosphodiester bond in the universally conserved alpha-sarcin/ricin loop (SRL) of large subunit ribosomal RNAs. It was previously shown that mitogillin is a natural derivative of a T1/U2-like ribonuclease with inserted domains that are involved in target selection and specificity. Site-directed mutagenesis was used to substitute single amino acids in the previously identified functional domains Ala1-Tyr24 (B1-L1-B2 domain) and Lys106-Lys113 (L4 region). Examination of the activities of the mutants in the digestion of polyinosinic acid (a ribonuclease substrate) and specific cleavage of the SRL shows that Asn7Ala and Lys111Gln substitutions lead to altered ribonuclease activity and diminished substrate specificity consistent with the proposed functions of these domains.     

Fungal ribotoxins: molecular dissection of a family of natural killers

RNase T1 is the best known representative of a large family of ribonucleolytic proteins secreted by fungi, mostly Aspergillus and Penicillium species. Ribotoxins stand out among them by their cytotoxic character. They exert their toxic action by first entering the cells and then cleaving a single phosphodiester bond located within a universally conserved sequence of the large rRNA gene, known as the sarcin-ricin loop. This cleavage leads to inhibition of protein biosynthesis, followed by cellular death by apoptosis. Although no protein receptor has been found for ribotoxins, they preferentially kill cells showing altered membrane permeability, such as those that are infected with virus or transformed. Many steps of the cytotoxic process have been elucidated at the molecular level by means of a variety of methodological approaches and the construction and purification of different mutant versions of these ribotoxins. Ribotoxins have been used for the construction of immunotoxins, because of their cytotoxicity. Besides this activity, Aspf1, a ribotoxin produced by Aspergillus fumigatus, has been shown to be one of the major allergens involved in allergic aspergillosis-related pathologies. Protein engineering and peptide synthesis have been used in order to understand the basis of these pathogenic mechanisms as well as to produce hypoallergenic proteins with potential diagnostic and immunotherapeutic applications.     

Deletion of the NH2-terminal beta-hairpin of the ribotoxin alpha-sarcin produces a nontoxic but active ribonuclease

Ribotoxins are a family of highly specific fungal ribonucleases that inactivate the ribosomes by hydrolysis of a single phosphodiester bond of the 28 S rRNA. alpha-Sarcin, the best characterized member of this family, is a potent cytotoxin that promotes apoptosis of human tumor cells after internalization via endocytosis. This latter ability is related to its interaction with phospholipid bilayers. These proteins share a common structural core with nontoxic ribonucleases of the RNase T1 family. However, significant structural differences between these two groups of proteins are related to the presence of a long amino-terminal beta-hairpin in ribotoxins and to the different length of their unstructured loops. The amino-terminal deletion mutant Delta(7-22) of alpha-sarcin has been produced in Escherichia coli and purified to homogeneity. It retains the same conformation as the wild-type protein as ascertained by complete spectroscopic characterization based on circular dichroism, fluorescence, and NMR techniques. This mutant exhibits ribonuclease activity against naked rRNA and synthetic substrates but lacks the specific ability of the wild-type protein to degrade rRNA in intact ribosomes. The results indicate that alpha-sarcin interacts with the ribosome at two regions, i.e. the well known sarcin-ricin loop of the rRNA and a different region recognized by the beta-hairpin of the protein. In addition, this latter protein portion is involved in interaction with cell membranes. The mutant displays decreased interaction with lipid vesicles and shows behavior compatible with the absence of one vesicle-interacting region. In agreement with this conclusion, the deletion mutant exhibits a very low cytotoxicity on human rhabdomyosarcoma cells.     

Ribotoxin genes in isolates of Aspergillus section Clavati

Ribotoxins are ribosome inactivator proteins with high specificity against the sarcin/ricin domain of the 28S ribosomal RNA. We examined the presence of ribotoxin genes in isolates of species recently assigned to Aspergillus section Clavati using specific primer pairs. All species assigned to this section have been found to carry ribotoxin genes. Phylogenetic analysis of the sequences of the amplified gene fragments allowed us to classify the genes to different groups including the alpha-sarcin, gigantin, c-sarcin and mitogillin/restrictocin families. Two species, A. longivesica and N. acanthosporus produced ribotoxins which were only distantly related to gigantins and c-sarcins, respectively. Comparison of the protein sequences of the genes to known ribotoxin sequences revealed that all of them carry the presumed catalytic residues of ribotoxins, the cystein residues, and also the two Trp residues of alpha-sarcin conserved in all ribotoxins known so far. These data indicate that these genes probably encode active ribotoxins. Further studies are in progress to examine the secretion and activities of these new ribotoxins.     

Purification and cloning of cytotoxic ribonucleases from Rana catesbeiana (bullfrog)

Ribonucleases with antitumor activity are mainly found in the oocytes and embryos of frogs, but the role of these ribonucleases in frog development is not clear. Moreover, most frog ribonuclease genes have not been cloned and characterized. In the present study, a group of ribonucleases were isolated from Rana catesbeiana (bullfrog). These ribonucleases in mature oocytes, namely RC-RNase, RC-RNase 2, RC-RNase 3, RC-RNase 4, RC-RNase 5 and RC-RNase 6, as well as liver-specific ribonuclease RC-RNase L1, were purified by column chromatographs and detected by zymogram assay and western blotting. Characterization of these purified ribonucleases revealed that they were highly conserved in amino acid sequence and had a pyroglutamate residue at their N-termini, but possessed different specific activities, base specificities and optimal pH values for their activities. These ribonucleases were cytotoxic to cervical carcinoma HeLa cells, but their cytotoxicities were not closely correlated to their enzymatic specific activities. Some other amino acid residues in addition to their catalytic residues were implicated to be involved in the cytotoxicity of the frog ribonucleases to tumor cells. Because the coding regions lack introns, the ribonuclease genes were cloned by PCR using genomic DNA as template. Their DNA sequences and amino acid sequences are homologous to those of mammalian ribonuclease superfamily, ~50 and ~25%, respectively.     

Three-dimensional crystal structure of human eosinophil cationic protein (RNase 3) at 1.75 A resolution

Eosinophil cationic protein (ECP; RNase 3) is a human ribonuclease found only in eosinophil leukocytes that belongs to the RNase A superfamily. This enzyme is bactericidal, helminthotoxic and cytotoxic to mammalian cells and tissues. The protein has been cloned, heterologously overexpressed, purified and crystallized. Its crystal structure has been determined and refined using data up to 1. 75 A resolution. The molecule displays the alpha+beta folding topology typical for members of the ribonuclease A superfamily. The catalytic active site residues are conserved with respect to other ribonucleases of the superfamily but some differences appear at substrate recognition subsites, which may account, in part, for the low catalytic activity. Most strikingly, 19 surface-located arginine residues confer a strong basic character to the protein. The high concentration of positive charges and the particular orientation of the side-chains of these residues may also be related to the low activity of ECP as a ribonuclease and provides an explanation for its unique cytotoxic role through cell membrane disruption.     

Structural and enzymatic properties of Ageritin,a novel metal-dependent ribotoxin-like protein with antitumor activity

Ageritin has been recently described as the first ribotoxin-like from Basidiomycota division (mushroom Agrocybe aegerita) with known antitumor activity (BBA 2017, 1861: 1113-1121). By investigating structural, catalytic and binding properties, we demonstrate that Ageritin is a unique ribotoxin-like protein. Indeed, typical of the ribotoxin family, it shows the specific ribonucleolytic activity against the ribosomal Sarcin-Ricin Loop in a rabbit reticulocytes assay. However, it displays several elements of novelty, as this activity is strongly metal-dependent and completely suppressed in the presence of EDTA, different from other representative members of the ribotoxin family. Consistently, we prove that Ageritin is able to bind magnesium ions with low micromolar affinity. We also show that Ageritin is significantly more stable than other ribotoxins in thermal and chemical denaturation experiments. These peculiar features make Ageritin the prototype of a new ribotoxin-like family present in basidiomycetes. Finally, given its high stability, this enzyme is a promising candidate as a new tool in immunoconjugates and nanoconstructs.     

Lactococcus lactis as a vehicle for the heterologous expression of fungal ribotoxin variants with reduced IgE-binding affinity

Fungal ribotoxins are a family of extracellular ribonucleases which inhibit protein biosynthesis by inactivating the ribosomes. This inactivation results in the induction of cell death by apoptosis. Ribotoxins show antitumoral properties based on their ability to cross the membrane of some transformed cells. Unfortunately, they also show an unspecific cytotoxicity which has greatly impaired their potential clinical uses. alpha-Sarcin, produced by Aspergillus giganteus, is the best-characterized ribotoxin. Asp f 1, another ribotoxin produced by A. fumigatus, is indeed one of its major allergens. In this work, the Lactococcus lactis MG1363 strain has been engineered to produce and secrete not only wild-type Asp f 1 and alpha-sarcin but also three different mutants with reduced cytotoxicity and/or IgE-binding affinity. The proteins were secreted in native and active form when the extracellular medium employed was buffered at pH values around 8.0. Strains producing the wild-type natural alpha-sarcin were proved to be innocuous when administered intragastrically to mice for a period of 14 days. Overall, the results presented are discussed in terms of its potential application as a vehicle of oral delivery of hypoallergenic variants as well as a starting point to approach the design of strategies to accomplish the safe delivery of these proteins as antitumoral agents.     

Role of the basic character of alpha-sarcin's NH2-terminal beta-hairpin in ribosome recognition and phospholipid interaction

Ribotoxins are a family of toxic extracellular fungal RNases that first enter into the cells and then exert a highly specific ribonucleolytic activity on the larger rRNA molecule, leading to protein synthesis inhibition and cell death by apoptosis. α-Sarcin is the best characterized ribotoxin. Previous characterization of a deletion variant of this protein showed that its long NH₂-terminal β-hairpin is essential for its cytotoxicity. Docking, enzymatic, and lipid-protein interaction studies suggested that this β-hairpin establishes specific interactions with ribosomal proteins and that it is a region involved in the interaction with cell membranes. Consequently, in order to assess the influence of the basic character of this NH₂-terminal β-hairpin (there are 1 arginine and 4 lysines along its 16 residues) on the ribotoxins cytotoxic ability, five individual mutants substituting these five basic residues by glutamic acid were produced, purified to homogeneity, and characterized. Regarding ribosomal recognition, all mutants showed a diminished activity in a cell-free reticulocyte lysate, whereas the activity against an oligoribonucleotide mimicking the sarcin/ricin loop rRNA (SRL) or the homopolymer poly(A) remained unaffected, confirming that the mutated basic residues participate in electrostatic interactions with other ribosomal elements apart from this SRL. The study of the interaction with phospholipid vesicles showed that Lys 17, Arg 22, and, most importantly, Lys 14 and Lys 21, are crucial residues in the first stages of the aggregation phenomenon, where protein-vesicle and protein-protein interactions are required. The data obtained reveal that electrostatic interactions involving basic residues of the β-hairpin are required not only for establishing specific interactions with ribosomal regions other than the SRL but also to explain the ability of the protein to interact with acid phospholipid bilayers.     

Tandemization endows bovine pancreatic ribonuclease with cytotoxic activity

Due to their ability to degrade RNA, selected members of the bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A) superfamily are potent cytotoxins. These cytotoxic ribonucleases enter the cytosol of target cells, where they degrade cellular RNA and cause cell death. The cytotoxic activity of most RNases, however, is abolished by the cytosolic ribonuclease inhibitor (RI). Consequently, the development of RNase derivatives with the ability to evade RI binding is a desirable goal. In this study, tandem enzymes consisting of two RNase A units that are bound covalently via a peptide linker were generated by gene duplication. As deduced from the crystal structure of the RNase A.RI complex, one RNase A unit of the tandem enzyme can still be bound by RI. The other unit, however, should remain unbound because of steric hindrance. This free RNase A unit is expected to maintain its activity and to act as a cytotoxic agent. The study of the influence of the linker sequence on the conformation and stability of these constructs revealed that tandemization has only minor effects on the activity and stability of the constructs in comparison to monomeric RNase A. Relative activity was decreased by 10-50% and the melting temperature was decreased by less than 2.5 K. Furthermore, the cytotoxic potency of the RNase A tandem enzymes was investigated. Despite an in vitro inhibition by RI, tandemization was found to endow RNase A with remarkable cytotoxic activity. While monomeric RNase A is not cytotoxic, IC(50) values of the RNase A tandem variants decreased to 70.3-12.9 microM. These findings might establish the development of a new class of chemotherapeutic agents based on pancreatic ribonucleases.     

The electrostatic character of the ribosomal surface enables extraordinarily rapid target location by ribotoxins

Alpha-sarcin ribotoxins comprise a unique family of ribonucleases that cripple the ribosome by catalyzing endoribonucleolytic cleavage of ribosomal RNA at a specific location in the sarcin/ricin loop (SRL). The SRL structure alone is cleaved site-specifically by the ribotoxin, but the ribosomal context enhances the reaction rate by several orders of magnitude. We show that, for the alpha-sarcin-like ribotoxin restrictocin, this catalytic advantage arises from favorable electrostatic interactions with the ribosome. Restrictocin binds at many sites on the ribosomal surface and under certain conditions cleaves the SRL with a second-order rate constant of 1.7 x 10(10) M(-1) s(-1), a value that matches the predicted frequency of random restrictocin-ribosome encounters. The results suggest a mechanism of target location whereby restrictocin encounters ribosomes randomly and diffuses within the ribosomal electrostatic field to the SRL. These studies show a role for electrostatics in protein-ribosome recognition.