Analysis of Gene Expressions during Xenopus Forelimb Regeneration

Xenopus laevis can regenerate an amputated limb completely at early limb bud stages, but the metamorphosed froglet gradually loses this capacity and can regenerate only a spike-like structure. We show that the spike formation in a Xenopus froglet is nerve dependent as is limb regeneration in urodeles, since denervation concomitant with amputation is sufficient to inhibit the initiation of blastema formation and fgf8 expression in the epidermis. Furthermore, in order to determine the cause of the reduction in regenerative capacity, we examined the expression patterns of several key genes for limb patterning during the spike-like structure formation, and we compared them with those in developing and regenerating limb buds that produce a complete limb structure. We cloned Xenopus HoxA13, a marker of the prospective autopodium region, and the expression pattern suggested that the spike-like structure in froglets is accompanied by elongation and patterning along the proximodistal (PD) axis. On the other hand, shh expression was not detected in the froglet blastema, which expresses fgf8 and msx1. Thus, although the wound epidermis probably induces outgrowth of the froglet blastema, the polarizing activity that organizes the anteroposterior (AP) axis formation is likely to be absent there. Our results demonstrate that the lost region in froglet limbs is regenerated along the PD axis and that the failure of organization of the AP pattern gives rise to a spike-like incomplete structure in the froglet, suggesting a relationship between regenerative capacity and AP patterning. These findings lead us to conclude that the spike formation in postometamorphic Xenopus limbs is epimorphic regeneration.     

Evidence that regenerative ability is an intrinsic property of limb cells in Xenopus

Xenopus laevis exhibits an ontogenetic decline in the ability to regenerate its limbs: Young tadpoles can completely regenerate an amputated limb, whereas post metamorphic froglets regenerate at most a cartilagenous "spike." We have tested the regenerative competence of normally regenerating limb buds of stage 52-53 Xenopus tadpoles grafted onto limb stumps of postmetamorphic froglets. The limb buds become vascularized and innervated by the host and, when amputated, regenerate limbs with normal or slightly less than normal numbers of tadpole hindlimb digits. Reciprocal grafts of froglet forelimb blastemas onto tadpole hindlimb stumps resulted in either autonomous development of tadpole hindlimb structures and/or formation of a cartilaginous spike typical of froglet forelimb regeneration. Our results suggest that the Xenopus froglet host environment is completely permissive for regeneration and that the ability to regenerate a complete limb pattern is an intrinsic property of young tadpole limb cells, a property that is lost during ontogenesis.     

Analysis of gene expressions during Xenopus forelimb regeneration

Xenopus laevis can regenerate an amputated limb completely at early limb bud stages, but the metamorphosed froglet gradually loses this capacity and can regenerate only a spike-like structure. We show that the spike formation in a Xenopus froglet is nerve dependent as is limb regeneration in urodeles, since denervation concomitant with amputation is sufficient to inhibit the initiation of blastema formation and fgf8 expression in the epidermis. Furthermore, in order to determine the cause of the reduction in regenerative capacity, we examined the expression patterns of several key genes for limb patterning during the spike-like structure formation, and we compared them with those in developing and regenerating limb buds that produce a complete limb structure. We cloned Xenopus HoxA13, a marker of the prospective autopodium region, and the expression pattern suggested that the spike-like structure in froglets is accompanied by elongation and patterning along the proximodistal (PD) axis. On the other hand, shh expression was not detected in the froglet blastema, which expresses fgf8 and msx1. Thus, although the wound epidermis probably induces outgrowth of the froglet blastema, the polarizing activity that organizes the anteroposterior (AP) axis formation is likely to be absent there. Our results demonstrate that the lost region in froglet limbs is regenerated along the PD axis and that the failure of organization of the AP pattern gives rise to a spike-like incomplete structure in the froglet, suggesting a relationship between regenerative capacity and AP patterning. These findings lead us to conclude that the spike formation in postometamorphic Xenopus limbs is epimorphic regeneration.     

Hyperinnervation improves Xenopus laevis limb regeneration

Xenopus laevis (an anuran amphibian) shows limb regeneration ability between that of urodele amphibians and that of amniotes. Xenopus frogs can initiate limb regeneration but fail to form patterned limbs. Regenerated limbs mainly consist of cone-shaped cartilage without any joints or branches. These pattern defects are thought to be caused by loss of proper expressions of patterning-related genes. This study shows that hyperinnervation surgery resulted in the induction of a branching regenerate. The hyperinnervated blastema allows the identification and functional analysis of the molecules controlling this patterning of limb regeneration. This paper focuses on the nerve affects to improve Xenopus limb patterning ability during regeneration. The nerve molecules, which regulate limb patterning, were also investigated. Blastemas grown in a hyperinnervated forelimb upregulate limb patterning-related genes (shh, lmx1b, and hoxa13). Nerves projecting their axons to limbs express some growth factors (bmp7, fgf2, fgf8, and shh). Inputs of these factors to a blastema upregulated some limb patterning-related genes and resulted in changes in the cartilage patterns in the regenerates. These results indicate that additional nerve factors enhance Xenopus limb patterning-related gene expressions and limb regeneration ability, and that bmp, fgf, and shh are candidate nerve substitute factors.     

Wnt/beta-catenin signaling has an essential role in the initiation of limb regeneration

Anuran (frog) tadpoles and urodeles (newts and salamanders) are the only vertebrates capable of fully regenerating amputated limbs. During the early stages of regeneration these amphibians form a "blastema", a group of mesenchymal progenitor cells that specifically directs the regrowth of the limb. We report that wnt-3a is expressed in the apical epithelium of regenerating Xenopus laevis limb buds, at the appropriate time and place to play a role during blastema formation. To test whether Wnt/beta-catenin signaling is required for limb regeneration, we created transgenic X. laevis tadpoles that express Dickkopf-1 (Dkk1), a specific inhibitor of Wnt/beta-catenin signaling, under the control of a heat-shock promoter. Heat-shock immediately before limb amputation or during early blastema formation blocked limb regeneration but did not affect the development of contralateral, un-amputated limb buds. When the transgenic tadpoles were heat-shocked following the formation of a blastema, however, they retained the ability to regenerate partial hindlimb structures. Furthermore, heat-shock induced Dkk1 blocked fgf-8 but not fgf-10 expression in the blastema. We conclude that Wnt/beta-catenin signaling has an essential role during the early stages of limb regeneration, but is not absolutely required after blastema formation.     

Nerve-induced ectopic limb blastemas in the Axolotl are equivalent to amputation-induced blastemas

Adult urodeles (salamanders) are unique in their ability to regenerate complex organs perfectly. The recently developed Accessory Limb Model (ALM) in the axolotl provides an opportunity to identify and characterize the essential signaling events that control the early steps in limb regeneration. The ALM demonstrates that limb regeneration progresses in a stepwise fashion that is dependent on signals from the wound epidermis, nerves and dermal fibroblasts from opposite sides of the limb. When all the signals are present, a limb is formed de novo. The ALM thus provides an opportunity to identify and characterize the signaling pathways that control blastema morphogenesis and limb regeneration. Our previous study provided data on cell contribution, cell migration and nerve dependency indicating that an ectopic blastema is equivalent to an amputation-induced blastema. In the present study, we have determined that formation of both ectopic blastemas and amputation-induced blastemas is regulated by the same molecular mechanisms, and that both types of blastema cells exhibit the same functions in controlling growth and pattern formation. We have identified and validated five marker genes for the early stages of wound healing, dedifferentiation and blastema formation, and have discovered that the expression of each of these markers is the same for both ectopic and amputation-induced blastemas. In addition, ectopic blastema cells interact coordinately with amputation-induced blastema cells to form a regenerated limb. Therefore, the ALM is appropriate for identifying the signaling pathways regulating the early events of tetrapod limb regeneration.     

The interaction between the blastema and stump in the establishment of the anterior-posterior and proximal-distal organization of the limb regenerate

Interactions between the limb stump and the developing regenerate were studied in the limbs of adult newts, Notophthalmus viridescens. Forelimb blastemas at various stages were transplanted to the contralateral forelimb such that the anterior-posterior axes of stump and blastema were opposed. The blastemas were transplanted either from a proximal to distal, distal to proximal, proximal to proximal, or distal to distal level limb stump. The results indicate that at the earliest stage studied the anterior-posterior axis of the blastema is established but is not stable. An interection between the stump and blastema at this early stage results in the production of a variety of limbs intermediate in polarity between the graft and the stump. At all later stages, the original anterior-posterior axis of the blastema can be retained, although under certain grafting conditions the stump can still exert considerable influence over the anterior-posterior organization of the final regenerate. In those circumstances in which the blastema retains its original handedness, the interaction between stump and blastema results in the production of separate anterior and posterior supernumerary regenerates.The results of transplanting proximal blastemas to a distal limb level indicate that the proximal boundary of the blastema has been established by the earliest stage studied, leading to the production of limbs with serially duplicated segments. However, irrespective of the stage of a blastema transplanted from a distal to proximal level, there are no deleted structures in the proximal-distal axis of the resulting limb. From both histological examination of transplanted regenerates and the arrangement of skeletal elements of the resulting limbs, it is postulated that the stump plays an important role in the production of the intercalary regenerate.     

Regulation after proximal or distal transposition of limb regeneration blastemas and determination of the proximal boundary of the regenerate.

When blastemas of several stages of differentiation were grafted in normal orientation to stump levels proximal or distal to their level of origin, normal limbs regenerated. Histological and autoradiographic studies of the development of these regulated limbs showed that the grafted blastemas formed only structures normally distal to their level of origin. In the case of a blastema transplanted proximally, regulation occurred by intercalary regeneration from the stump, whereas, when blastemas were transplanted distally, regulation appeared to take place within the blastema itself by a distal shift in its pattern of organization. The results suggest that the proximal limit of the limb regenerate is determined by level-specific properties of the limb cells but that these properties allow for interactions leading to regulation when different levels of stump and blastema are brought together.     

Cloning and neuronal expression of a type III newt neuregulin and rescue of denervated,nerve‐dependent newt limb blastemas by rhGGF2

Urodele amphibians are the only vertebrates that can regenerate their limbs throughout their life. The critical feature of limb regeneration is the formation of a blastema, a process that requires an intact nerve supply. Nerves appear to provide an unidentified factor, known as the neurotrophic factor (NTF), which stimulates cycling of blastema cells. One candidate NTF is glial growth factor (GGF), a member of the neuregulin (NRG) growth factor family. NRGs are both survival factors and mitogens to glial cells, including Schwann cells. All forms of NRGs contain an EGF‐like domain that is sufficient to activate NRG receptors erbB2, erbB3, and erbB4. To investigate the involvement of neuregulin in newt limb regeneration, we cloned and characterized one neuregulin isoform, a neuregulin with a cysteine‐rich domain (CRD‐NRG), from newt (Notophthalmus viridescens) spinal cord. Results of in situ hybridization showed that the newt CRD‐NRG is highly expressed in dorsal root ganglia and spinal cord neurons that innervate the limbs. We also demonstrated the biological activity of recombinant human GGF2 (rhGGF2) in urodele limb regeneration. When rhGGF2 was injected into denervated, nerve‐dependent axolotl blastemas, the labeling index (LI) of blastema cells was maintained at a level near to that of control, innervated blastemas, whereas without rhGGF2 the LI decreased significantly. In another experiment, rhGGF2 was delivered into denervated, nerve‐dependent blastemas either by direct infusion into blastemas or by injection into the intraperitoneal cavity. The denervated blastemas were rescued into a regeneration response. © 2000 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Neurobiol 43: 150–158, 2000     

Morphogenetic interactions occurring between blastemas and stumps after exchanging blastemas between normal and double-half forelimbs in the axolotl, Ambystoma mexicanum.

Regeneration blastemas were exchanged between surgically constructed forelimbs comprised of symmetrical tissues (double-anterior and double-posterior) and normal, unoperated forelimbs. Normal blastemas grafted at the stage of medium bud (MB) onto double-half forelimb stumps regenerated normal skeletal patterns in nearly all cases. Double-half blastemas transplanted at the stage of MB onto normal forelimb stumps did not regenerate complete limb patterns. These results indicate that a double-half blastema cannot be “rescued” by transplantation to a normal stump and that a double-half limb stump does not interfere with the ability of a normal blastema to distally transform. The regeneration blastema possesses sufficient positional information at the stage of MB to permit it to develop autonomously. Supernumerary forelimbs resulted from several types of graft-stump combinations. The location and handedness of these supernumerary limbs are predicted by the rules of a recently presented model for pattern regulation in epimorphic fields [French, V., Bryant, P. J., and Bryant, S. V. (1976). Science193, 969–981].     

Posterior<Emphasis Type="Italic"> hoxa</Emphasis> genes expression during zebrafish bony fin ray development and regeneration suggests their involvement in scleroblast differentiation

Expression of two zebrafish developmental posterior hoxa genes, hoxa11b and hoxa13b, was studied by in situ hybridization during pectoral and caudal fin development and regeneration. Expression was restricted to cells of the bony rays region. During fin development, molecular cytological analysis revealed that a subpopulation of mesenchymal cells expressed these two hoxa genes during their early differentiation in the subapical region of the developing ray. These cells were identified as differentiating dermal bone making cells (scleroblasts). During fin regeneration, hoxa11b and hoxa13b genes are both induced in undifferentiated cells of the distalmost blastema region (DMB) and the proliferating zone (PZ) and later in differentiating bone-forming cells. In addition, the transient regionalization of the hoxa13b expression pattern in differentiated bone-forming cells along the proximodistal axis of the regenerating ray suggests that hoxa13b could participate in ray patterning. This study is the first to establish a correlation between hoxa gene expression and dermal bone cell differentiation.     

von Willebrand factor D and EGF domains is an evolutionarily conserved and required feature of blastemas capable of multitissue appendage regeneration

Regenerative ability varies tremendously across species. A common feature of regeneration of appendages such as limbs, fins, antlers, and tails is the formation of a blastema—a transient structure that houses a pool of progenitor cells that can regenerate the missing tissue. We have identified the expression of von Willebrand factor D and EGF domains (vwde) as a common feature of blastemas capable of regenerating limbs and fins in a variety of highly regenerative species, including axolotl (Ambystoma mexicanum), lungfish (Lepidosiren paradoxa), and Polpyterus (Polypterus senegalus). Further, vwde expression is tightly linked to the ability to regenerate appendages in Xenopus laevis. Functional experiments demonstrate a requirement for vwde in regeneration and indicate that Vwde is a potent growth factor in the blastema. These data identify a key role for vwde in regenerating blastemas and underscore the power of an evolutionarily informed approach for identifying conserved genetic components of regeneration.     

Proximodistal patterning during limb regeneration

Regeneration is an ability that has been observed extensively throughout metazoan phylogeny. Amongst vertebrates, the urodele amphibians stand out for their exceptional capacity to regenerate body parts such as the limb. During this process, only the missing portion of the limb is precisely replaced--amputation in the upper arm results in regeneration of the entire limb, while amputation at the wrist produces a hand. Limb regeneration occurs through the formation of a local proliferative zone called the blastema. Here, we examine how proximodistal identity is established in the blastema. Using cell marking and transplantation experiments, we show that distal identities have already been established in the earliest stages of blastemas examined. Transplantation of cells into new environments is not sufficient to respecify cell identity. However, overexpression of the CD59, a cell surface molecule previously implicated in proximodistal identity during limb regeneration, causes distal blastema cells to translocate to a more proximal location and causes defects in the patterning of the distal elements of the regenerate. We suggest a model for the limb regeneration blastema where by 4 days post-amputation the blastema is already divided into distinct growth zones; the cells of each zone are already specified to give rise to upper arm, lower arm, and hand.     

Cloning and neuronal expression of a type III newt neuregulin and rescue of denervated, nerve-dependent newt limb blastemas by rhGGF2

Urodele amphibians are the only vertebrates that can regenerate their limbs throughout their life. The critical feature of limb regeneration is the formation of a blastema, a process that requires an intact nerve supply. Nerves appear to provide an unidentified factor, known as the neurotrophic factor (NTF), which stimulates cycling of blastema cells. One candidate NTF is glial growth factor (GGF), a member of the neuregulin (NRG) growth factor family. NRGs are both survival factors and mitogens to glial cells, including Schwann cells. All forms of NRGs contain an EGF-like domain that is sufficient to activate NRG receptors erbB2, erbB3, and erbB4. To investigate the involvement of neuregulin in newt limb regeneration, we cloned and characterized one neuregulin isoform, a neuregulin with a cysteine-rich domain (CRD-NRG), from newt (Notophthalmus viridescens) spinal cord. Results of in situ hybridization showed that the newt CRD-NRG is highly expressed in dorsal root ganglia and spinal cord neurons that innervate the limbs. We also demonstrated the biological activity of recombinant human GGF2 (rhGGF2) in urodele limb regeneration. When rhGGF2 was injected into denervated, nerve-dependent axolotl blastemas, the labeling index (LI) of blastema cells was maintained at a level near to that of control, innervated blastemas, whereas without rhGGF2 the LI decreased significantly. In another experiment, rhGGF2 was delivered into denervated, nerve-dependent blastemas either by direct infusion into blastemas or by injection into the intraperitoneal cavity. The denervated blastemas were rescued into a regeneration response.     

Cellular contribution to supernumerary limbs resulting from the interaction between developing and regenerating tissues in the axolotl

The relationship between limb development and limb regeneration is considered with regard to the mechanisms by which pattern is established during limb outgrowth. In a previous paper (Muneoka, K. and Bryant, S. V. 1982 Nature (London) 298, 369-371) the interaction between cells from the developing limb bud and the regenerating limb blastema was found to result in the production of organized supernumerary limb structures. In this paper the relative cellular contribution from developing and regenerating cells to supernumerary limbs resulting from contralateral grafts between limb buds and blastemas has been analyzed using the triploid cell marker in the axolotl. Results show that there is substantial participation from both developing and regenerating limb cells to all supernumerary limbs analyzed. These data lend further support to the hypothesis that developing and regenerating limbs utilize the same patterning mechanisms during limb outgrowth. This conclusion is discussed in terms of patterning models for developing and regenerating limbs and it is proposed that the rules of the polar coordinate model can best explain the behavior of cells during limb development as well as limb regeneration.     

Developmental aspects of spinal cord and limb regeneration

The ability of birds and mammals to regenerate tissues is limited. By contrast, urodele amphibians can regenerate a variety of injured tissues such as intestine, cardiac muscle, lens and neural retina, as well as entire structures such as limbs, tail and lower jaw. This regenerative capacity is associated with the ability to form masses of mesenchyme cells (blastemas) that differentiate into the missing tissues or parts. Understanding the mechanisms that underlie blastema formation in urodeles will provide valuable tools with which to achieve the goal of stimulating regeneration in mammalian tissues that do not naturally regenerate. Here we discuss an example of tissue regeneration (spinal cord) and an example of epimorphic appendage regeneration (limb) in the axolotl Ambystoma mexicanum , emphasizing analysis of the processes that produce the regeneration blastema and of the tissue interactions and blastemal products that contribute to the regeneration-promoting environment.