Transition of Hox expression during limb cartilage development

Hox genes belonging to the Abd-B subfamily of the HoxA and HoxD clusters play a crucial role in cartilage formation both in patterning and growth/differentiation phases during limb development. We re-examined the expression profiles of Hoxa-13, Hox-d13, Hoxa-11 and Hoxd-11 during the cartilage growth/differentiation phase of limb cartilage formation. The expression profiles of these Hox genes were analyzed by in situ hybridization and immunohistochemistry on serial sections by comparing the expression patterns with well-characterized signaling molecules, e.g. Bmp-2, -4, Patched (Ptc) and Indian Hedgehog (IHH). In contrast to earlier reports, these Hox genes were expressed in the mesenchymal cell layer closely adjacent to the growing cartilage, but not in the perichondrium of the cartilage. This result prompts us to reconsider the mode of Hox function during cartilage growth and differentiation phase.     

Evidence that Hoxa expression domains are evolutionarily transposed in spinal ganglia, and are established by forward spreading in paraxial mesoderm.

Transposition of anatomical structures along the anteroposterior axis has been a commonly used mechanism for changing body proportions during the course of evolutionary time. Earlier work (Gaunt, S.J., 1994. Conservation in the Hox code during morphological evolution. Int. J. Dev. Biol. 38, 549-552; Burke, A.C., Nelson, C.E., Morgan, B.A., Tabin, C., 1995. Hox genes and the evolution of vertebrate axial morphology. Development 121, 333-346) showed how transposition in mesodermal derivatives (vertebrae) could be attributed to transposition in the expression of Hox genes along the axial series of somites. We now show how transposition in the segmental arrangement of the spinal nerves can also be correlated with shifts in the expression domains of Hox genes. Specifically, we show how the expression domains of Hoxa-7, a-9 and a-10 in spinal ganglia correspond similarly in both mouse and chick with the positions of the brachial and lumbosacral plexuses, and that this is true even though the brachial plexus of chick is shifted posteriorly, relative to mouse, by seven segmental units. In spite of these marked species differences in the boundaries of Hoxa-7 expression, cis regulatory elements located up to 5 kb upstream of the chick Hoxa-7 gene showed much functional and structural conservation with those described in the mouse (Puschel, A.W., Balling, R., Gruss, P., 1991. Separate elements cause lineage restriction and specify boundaries of Hox-1.1 expression. Development 112, 279-287; Knittel, T., Kessel, M., Kim, M.H., Gruss, P., 1995. A conserved enhancer of the human and murine Hoxa-7 gene specifies the anterior boundary of expression during embryonal development. Development 121, 1077-1088). We also show that chick Hoxa-7 and a-10 expression domains spread forward into regions of somites that are initially negative for the expression of these genes. We discuss this as evidence that Hox expression in paraxial mesoderm spreads forward, as earlier found for neurectoderm and lateral plate mesoderm, in a process that occurs independently of cell movement.     

Retinoic acid given at late embryonic stage depresses sonic hedgehog and Hoxd-4 expression in the pharyngeal area and induces skeletal malformation in flounder (Paralichthys olivaceus) embryos

During the development of pharyngeal cartilages, signal molecules, including sonic hedgehog (shh) and various growth factors, as well as Hox genes are expressed in the pharyngeal area. To elucidate whether shh and Hoxd-4 function in pharyngeal cartilage formation in teleost jaw and gill primordia, spatial and temporal patterns of shh expression in flounder (Paralichthys olivaceus) embryonic pharynx were examined. The effects of retinoic acid (RA) on shh and Hoxd-4 expression and the patterning of pharyngeal cartilages were analyzed. At the prim-5 stage, when cartilage precursor cells aggregate in the pharyngeal primordia, pharyngeal endoderm expressed shh in two domains, in portions of the mandibular and hyoid primordia and in the gill primordia. After a further 40 h, shh domains expanded at the posterior edge of the endoderm of each mandibular, hyoid and gill primordium, concurrent with the growth of the primordia. A new shh expression domain appeared at the endodermal border of the mouth. Retinoic acid treatment depressed shh and Hoxd-4 expression, and also reduced the amount of expansion of the shh expression domains. Pharyngeal cartilages that formed in these embryos were malformed; their growth direction was shifted posteriorly and size was reduced. This provides the possibility that shh and Hoxd-4 regulate the growth and direction of pharyngeal cartilage precursor cells and that RA disturbs their expression, causing skeletal malformation.     

Hoxa-11 and Hoxa-13 are involved in repression of MyoD during limb muscle development

Under the influence of the limb mesenchyme, Hoxa-11 is expressed in migrating and proliferating premyoblasts in the limb field and Hoxa-13 is induced in subdomains of congregated limb muscle masses. To evaluate the roles of Hoxa-11 and Hoxa-13 in myogenesis of the limb, we performed electroporation in ovo to force expression of these Hox genes in limb muscle precursors. In the presence of ectopic Hoxa-11, expression of MyoD was blocked transiently. In C2C12 myoblasts, transfection of Hoxa-11 also repressed the expression of endogenous MyoD. Forced expression of Hoxa-13 resulted in more pronounced repression of MyoD in both limb and C2C12 myoblasts. In contrast, targeted disruption of Hoxa-13 gave rise to enhanced expression of MyoD in the flexor carpi radialis muscle, a forearm muscle that normally expressed Hoxa-13. These results suggest that Hoxa-11 and Hoxa-13 are involved in the negative regulation of MyoD expression in limb muscle precursors.     

Conservation of a functional hierarchy between mammalian and insect Hox/HOM genes.

We have generated several transgenic Drosophila strains containing different mouse Hox genes under heat shock control and studied how their generalized expression affects Drosophila larval patterns. We find that they have spatially restricted effects which correlate with their genetic order and expression pattern in the mouse; as they are expressed more posteriorly in the mouse, they have more extensive effects in Drosophila. The generalized expressions of Hoxd-8 and d-9 modify Drosophila anterior head segment(s), but have no effect in the rest of the body. Hoxd-10 expression affects head and thorax, but not the abdomen. Finally, Hoxd-11 alters head, thorax not the abdomen. Finally, Hoxd-11 alters head, thorax and abdomen. The developmental effect of the Hox genes consists of a homeotic transformation of the affected segment(s), which exhibit a 'ground' pattern similar to that obtained in the absence of homeotic information, suggesting that Hox genes are able to inactivate Drosophila homeotic genes, but do not specify a pattern of their own. A partial exception is Hoxd-11 which, even though it has a general suppressing effect, can also activate the resident Abdominal-B and empty spiracles genes in ectopic positions. Our results strongly suggest a general conservation of the functional hierarchy of homeotic genes that correlates with genetic order and expression patterns.     

Vitamin A deficiency in the late gastrula stage rat embryo results in a one to two vertebral anteriorization that extends throughout the axial skeleton

Vitamin A and its metabolites are known to be involved in patterning the vertebrate embryo. Study of the effect of vitamin A on axial skeletal patterning has been hindered by the fact that deficient embryos do not survive past midgestation. In this study, pregnant vitamin A-deficient rats were maintained on a purified diet containing limiting amounts of all-trans retinoic acid (12 microg atRA/g diet) and given a daily oral bolus dose of retinol starting at embryonic day 0.5, 8.25, 8.5, 8.75, 9.25, 9.5, 9.75, or 10.5. Embryos were recovered at E21.5 for analysis of the skeleton and at earlier times for analysis of select mRNAs. Normal axial skeletal development and patterning were observed in embryos from pregnant animals receiving retinol starting on or before E8.75. Delay of retinol supplementation to E9.5 or later resulted in a marked increase in both occurrence and severity of skeletal malformations, extending from the craniocervical to sacral regions. Embryos from the groups receiving retinol starting at E9.5 and E9.75 had one-vertebral anterior transformations of the cervical, thoracic, lumbar, and sacral vertebrae. Few embryos survived in the E10.5 group, but these embryos yielded the most severe and extensive anteriorization events. The skeletal alterations seen in vitamin A deficiency are associated with posterior shifts in the mesodermal expression of Hoxa-4, Hoxb-3, Hoxd-3, Hoxd-4, and Hoxa-9 mRNAs, whereas the anterior domains of Hoxb-4 and Cdx2 expression are unaltered. This work defines a critical window of development in the late gastrula-stage embryo when vitamin A is essential for normal axial skeletal patterning and shows that vitamin A deficiency causes anterior homeotic transformations extending from the cervical to lumbosacral regions.     

Successive formative stages of precartilaginous mesenchymal condensations in vitro: Modulation of cell adhesion by Wnt-7A and BMP-2

High-density chick limb bud cell culture is a useful model to study mesenchymal condensatifons and chondrogenesis. Most previous studies have focused on the effects of soluble reagents on terminal chondrogenic differentiation and have not defined the early cellular processes and signaling events. In this study, we defined five successive stages in the differentiation process: 1) dissociated cells, 2) small aggregates, 3) formation of cell clusters, 4) precartilaginous condensations, and 5) cartilage nodule. We used RCAS retrovirus-mediated Wnt-7a gene transduction to test the effect of Wnt-7a on the differentiation process. We found that Wnt-7a suppressed chondrogenic differentiation. Wnt-7a did not inhibit the initiation of condensation formation but blocked the progression of precartilaginous condensations to cartilage nodules. The Wnt-7a-transduced cultures showed characteristics of a less mature culture with persistent expression of NCAM, N-cadherin, wider distribution of integrin β1 and fibronectin, and suppression of tenascin-C. BMP-2 is known to enhance chondrogenic differentiation in these cultures by promoting cell clusters to form continuous sheet-like precartilaginous condensations. However, cultures exposed to both BMP-2 and Wnt-7a showed inhibition of chondrogenic differentiation. Different signaling molecules such as Wnt-7a and BMP-2 may have antagonistic effects on cartilage differentiation and the gradient of the two molecules may be involved in defining the boundaries of the initial precartilaginous condensation. We propose that the shape of the precartilaginous condensations may be modulated by local concentrations of signaling molecules, such as Wnt-7a and BMP-2, which act to alter cell-substrate and cell-cell adhesions. J. Cell. Physiol. 180:314–324, 1999. © 1999 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Loss of Eph-receptor expression correlates with loss of cell adhesion and chondrogenic capacity in Hoxa13 mutant limbs.

Mesenchymal patterning is an active process whereby genetic commands coordinate cell adhesion, sorting and condensation, and thereby direct the formation of morphological structures. In mice that lack the Hoxa13 gene, the mesenchymal condensations that form the autopod skeletal elements are poorly resolved, resulting in missing digit, carpal and tarsal elements. In addition, mesenchymal and endothelial cell layers of the umbilical arteries (UAs) are disorganized, resulting in their stenosis and in embryonic death. To further investigate the role of Hoxa13 in these phenotypes, we generated a loss-of-function allele in which the GFP gene was targeted into the Hoxa13 locus. This allele allowed FACS isolation of mesenchymal cells from Hoxa13 heterozygous and mutant homozygous limb buds. Hoxa13(GFP) expressing mesenchymal cells from Hoxa13 mutant homozygous embryos are defective in forming chondrogenic condensations in vitro. Analysis of pro-adhesion molecules in the autopod of Hoxa13 mutants revealed a marked reduction in EphA7 expression in affected digits, as well as in micromass cell cultures prepared from mutant mesenchymal cells. Finally, antibody blocking of the EphA7 extracellular domain severely inhibits the capacity of Hoxa13(GFP) heterozygous cells to condense and form chondrogenic nodules in vitro, which is consistent with the hypothesis that reduction in EphA7 expression affects the capacity of Hoxa13(-/-) mesenchymal cells to form chondrogenic condensations in vivo and in vitro. EphA7 and EphA4 expression were also decreased in the mesenchymal and endothelial cells that form the umbilical arteries in Hoxa13 mutant homozygous embryos. These results suggest that an important role for Hoxa13 during limb and UA development is to regulate genes whose products are required for mesenchymal cell adhesion, sorting and boundary formation.     

Hoxa-10 regulates uterine stromal cell responsiveness to progesterone during implantation and decidualization in the mouse.

Hoxa-10 is an AbdominalB-like homeobox gene that is expressed in the developing genitourinary tract during embryogenesis and in the adult uterus during early pregnancy. Null mutation of Hoxa-10 in the mouse causes both male and female infertility. Defective implantation and decidualization resulting from the loss of maternal Hoxa-10 function in uterine stromal cells is the cause of female infertility. However, the mechanisms by which Hoxa-10 regulates these uterine events are unknown. We have identified two potential mechanisms for these uterine defects in Hoxa-10(-/-) mice. First, two PGE2 receptor subtypes, EP3 and EP4, are aberrantly expressed in the uterine stroma in Hoxa-10(-/-) mice, while expression of several other genes in the stroma (TIMP-2, MMP-2, ER, and PR) and epithelium (LIF, HB-EGF, Ar, and COX-1) are unaffected before implantation. Further, EP3 and EP4 are inappropriately regulated by progesterone (P4) in the absence of Hoxa-10, while PR, Hoxa-11 and c-myc, three other P4-responsive genes respond normally. These results suggest that Hoxa-10 specifically mediates P4 regulation of EP3 and EP4 in the uterine stroma. Second, since Hox genes are implicated in local cell proliferation, we also examined steroid-responsive uterine cell proliferation in Hoxa-10(-/-) mice. Stromal cell proliferation in mutant mice in response to P4 and 17beta-estradiol (E2 was significantly reduced, while epithelial cell proliferation was normal in response to E2. These results suggest that stromal cell responsiveness to P4 with respect to cell proliferation is impaired in Hoxa-10(-/-) mice, and that Hoxa-10 is involved in mediating stromal cell proliferation. Collectively, these results suggest that Hoxa-10 mutation causes specific stromal cell defects that can lead to implantation and decidualization defects apparently without perturbing epithelial cell functions.     

Characterization of Hoxa-10/Hoxa-11 transheterozygotes reveals functional redundancy and regulatory interactions

Hox genes show related sequences and overlapping expression domains that often reflect functional redundancy as well as a common evolutionary origin. To accurately define their functions, it has become necessary to compare phenotypes of mice with single and multiple Hox gene mutations. Here, we focus on two Abd-B-type genes, Hoxa-10 and Hoxa-11, which are coexpressed in developing vertebrae, limbs, and reproductive tracts. To assess possible functional redundancy between these two genes, Hoxa-10/Hoxa-11 transheterozygotes were produced by genetic intercrosses and analyzed. This compound mutation resulted in synergistic defects in transheterozygous limbs and reproductive tracts, but not in vertebrae. In the forelimb, distal radial/ulnar thickening and pisiform/triangular carpal fusion were observed in 35 and 21% of transheterozygotes, respectively, but were effectively absent in Hoxa-10 and Hoxa-11 +/- forelimbs. In the hindlimb, distal tibial/fibular thickening and loss of tibial/fibular fusion were observed in >80% of transheterozygotes but in no Hoxa-10 or Hoxa-11 +/- hindlimbs, and all transheterozygotes displayed reduced medial patellar sesamoids, compared to modest incidences in Hoxa-10 and Hoxa-11 +/- mutants. Furthermore, while the reproductive tracts of Hoxa-10 and Hoxa-11 single heterozygous mutants of both sexes were primarily unaffected, male transheterozygotes displayed cryptorchidism and abnormal tortuosity of the ductus deferens, and female transheterozygotes exhibited abnormal uterotubal junctions and narrowing of the uterus. In addition we observed that the targeted mutations of Hoxa-10 and Hoxa-11 each affected the expression of the other gene in the developing prevertebra and reproductive tracts. These results provide a measure of the functional redundancy of Hoxa-10 and Hoxa-11 and a deeper understanding of the phenotypes resulting in the single mutants and help elucidate the regulatory interactions between these two genes.     

Novel interactions between vertebrate Hox genes

Understanding why metazoan Hox/HOM-C genes are expressed in spatiotemporal sequences showing colinearity with their genomic sequence is a central challenge in developmental biology. Here, we studied the consequences of ectopically expressing Hox genes to investigate whether Hox-Hox interactions might help to order gene expression during very early vertebrate embryogenesis. Our study revealed conserved autoregulatory loops for the Hox4 and Hox7 paralogue groups, detected following ectopic expression Hoxb-4 or HOXD4, and Hoxa-7, respectively. We also detected specific induction of 5' posterior Hox genes; Hoxb-5 to Hoxb-9, following ectopic expression of Hoxb-4/HOXD4; Hoxb-8 and Hoxb-9 following ectopic expression of Hoxa-7. Additionally, we observed specific repression of 3' anterior genes, following ectopic expression of Hox4 and Hox7 paralogues. We found that induction of Hoxb-4 and Hoxb-5 by Hoxb-4 can be direct, whereas induction of Hoxb-7 is indirect, suggesting the possibility of an activating cascade. Finally, we found that activation of Hoxb-4 itself and of posterior Hox genes by Hoxb-4 can be both non-cell-autonomous, as well as direct. We believe that our findings could be important for understanding how a highly ordered Hox expression sequence is set up in the early vertebrate embryo.     

Distinct signaling molecules control Hoxa-11 and Hoxa-13 expression in the muscle precursor and mesenchyme of the chick limb bud.

The limb muscles, originating from the ventrolateral portion of the somites, exhibit position-specific morphological development through successive splitting and growth/differentiation of the muscle masses in a region-specific manner by interacting with the limb mesenchyme and the cartilage elements. The molecular mechanisms that provide positional cues to the muscle precursors are still unknown. We have shown that the expression patterns of Hoxa-11 and Hoxa-13 are correlated with muscle patterning of the limb bud (Yamamoto et al., 1998) and demonstrated that muscular Hox genes are activated by signals from the limb mesenchyme. We dissected the regulatory mechanisms directing the unique expression patterns of Hoxa-11 and Hoxa-13 during limb muscle development. HOXA-11 protein was detected in both the myogenic cells and the zeugopodal mesenchymal cells of the limb bud. The earlier expression of HOXA-11 in both the myogenic precursor cells and the mesenchyme was dependent on the apical ectodermal ridge (AER), but later expression was independent of the AER. HOXA-11 expression in both myogenic precursor cells and mesenchyme was induced by fibroblast growth factor (FGF) signal, whereas hepatocyte growth factor/scatter factor (HGF/SF) maintained HOXA-11 expression in the myogenic precursor cells, but not in the mesenchyme. The distribution of HOXA-13 protein expression in the muscle masses was restricted to the posterior region. We found that HOXA-13 expression in the autopodal mesenchyme was dependent on the AER but not on the polarizing region, whereas expression of HOXA-13 in the posterior muscle masses was dependent on the polarizing region but not on the AER. Administration of BMP-2 at the anterior margin of the limb bud induced ectopic HOXA-13 expression in the anterior region of the muscle masses followed by ectopic muscle formation close to the source of exogenous BMP-2. In addition, NOGGIN/CHORDIN, antagonists of BMP-2 and BMP-4, downregulated the expression of HOXA-13 in the posterior region of the muscle masses and inhibited posterior muscle development. These results suggested that HOXA-13 expression in the posterior muscle masses is activated by the posteriorizing signal from the posterior mesenchyme via BMP-2. On the contrary, the expression of HOXA-13 in the autopodal mesenchyme was affected by neither BMP-2 nor NOGGIN/CHORDIN. Thus, mesenchymal HOXA-13 expression was independent of BMP-2 from polarizing region, but was under the control of as yet unidentified signals from the AER. These results showed that expression of Hox genes is regulated differently in the limb muscle precursor and mesenchymal cells.     

Cytoskeletal Reorganization Drives Mesenchymal Condensation and Regulates Downstream Molecular Signaling

Skeletal condensation occurs when specified mesenchyme cells self-organize over several days to form a distinctive cartilage template. Here, we determine how and when specified mesenchyme cells integrate mechanical and molecular information from their environment, forming cartilage condensations in the pharyngeal arches of chick embryos. By disrupting cytoskeletal reorganization, we demonstrate that dynamic cell shape changes drive condensation and modulate the response of the condensing cells to Fibroblast Growth Factor (FGF), Bone Morphogenetic Protein (BMP) and Transforming Growth Factor beta (TGF-β) signaling pathways. Rho Kinase (ROCK)-driven actomyosin contractions and Myosin II-generated differential cell cortex tension regulate these cell shape changes. Disruption of the condensation process inhibits the differentiation of the mesenchyme cells into chondrocytes, demonstrating that condensation regulates the fate of the mesenchyme cells. We also find that dorsal and ventral condensations undergo distinct cell shape changes. BMP signaling is instructive for dorsal condensation-specific cell shape changes. Moreover, condensations exhibit ventral characteristics in the absence of BMP signaling, suggesting that in the pharyngeal arches ventral morphology is the ground pattern. Overall, this study characterizes the interplay between cytoskeletal dynamics and molecular signaling in a self-organizing system during tissue morphogenesis.