Rapid assessment of two major repair activities against DNA double-strand breaks in vertebrate cells

A linearized plasmid DNA, in which tandem repeats of 400bp flank the breakpoints, was transfected into vertebrate cells, and breakpoint junctions of plasmid DNA circularized in the cells were analyzed to assess the repair activities against DNA double-strand break (DSB) by non-homologous end joining and homology-directed repair (i.e., homologous recombinational repair and single-strand annealing). The circularization by non-homologous end joining repair of the breakpoints depended on the expression of DNA-PKcs, while that by homology-directed repair through the repeats depended on the length of the repeats, indicating that these two DSB repair activities can be rapidly assessed by this assay. Predominance in circularization by either non-homologous end joining or homology-directed repair differed among cells examined, and circularization was exclusively undertaken by homology-directed repair in DT40 cells known to show a high homologous recombination rate against gene-targeting vectors. Thus, this assay will be helpful in studies on mechanisms and inter-cellular variations of DSB repair.     

Nonhomologous end joining of complementary and noncomplementary DNA termini in mouse testicular extracts

Mammalian somatic cells are known to repair DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) by nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ) and homologous recombination (HR); however, how male germ cells repair DSBs is not yet characterized. We have previously reported the highly efficient and mostly precise DSB joining ability of mouse testicular germ cell extracts for cohesive and blunt ends, with only a minor fraction undergoing terminal deletion [Mutat. Res. 433 (1999) 1]; however, the precise mechanism of joining was not established. In the present study, we therefore tested the ability of testicular extracts to join noncomplementary ends; we have also sequenced the junctions of both complementary and noncomplementary termini and established the joining mechanisms. While a major proportion of complementary and blunt ends were joined by simple ligation, the small fraction having noncleavable junctions predominantly utilized short stretches of direct repeat homology with limited end processing. For noncomplementary ends, the major mechanism was "blunt-end ligation" subsequent to "fill-in" or "blunting", with no insertions or large deletions; the microhomology-dependent joining with end deletion was less frequent. This is the first functional study of the NHEJ mechanism in mammalian male germ cell extracts. Our results demonstrate that testicular germ cell extracts promote predominantly accurate NHEJ for cohesive ends and very efficient blunt-end ligation, perhaps to preserve the genomic sequence with minimum possible alteration. Further, we demonstrate the ability of the extracts to catalyze in vitro plasmid homologous recombination, which suggests the existence of both NHEJ and HR pathways in germ cells.     

Mouse testicular extracts process DNA double-strand breaks efficiently by DNA end-to-end joining

DNA double-strand break (DSB) processing was studied in mouse testicular extracts using a defined DSB created by cleaving supercoiled pUC12 DNA at a unique site as the substrate, and analysing the processed DNA by gel electrophoresis. Our results demonstrated that enzymatic activity in the extracts promoted multimerization of DNA and suppressed its circularization. This was distinctly different from T4 DNA ligase activity in the control and therefore the process must be more complex than simple ligation. Efficiency of this end-to-end joining was ATP and Mg(2+)-dependent and was much higher with cohesive (especially with 5') than with blunt ends. On recleaving, the joining was predominantly faithful, especially for cohesive ends; but a detectable fraction of DNA had undergone end-processed joining causing junctional deletions, mostly with blunt ends. Redigestion of end-joined products from time course experiments established that the end-deleted joining occurred concurrent to the faithful joining. Junctional segments were cloned and their restriction analysis confirmed the presence of large deletions from both the sides. These results suggested the association of an end-processing activity (exonuclease/helicase + flap endonuclease) along with the end-joining ligase(s). Suppression of end-edited joining on lowering the reaction temperature to 17 degrees or 14 degrees C, despite efficient faithful joining, indicated that this enzymatic activity is retarded at low temperature. Though the efficiency and fidelity of joining were termini-dependent, the orientation of joining was random. Lack of preference for homologous ends (H:H or T:T), as well as efficient joining of heterologous DNA (pUC12/pBR322) having two different blunt termini, showed that the end joining could occur independent of extensive/terminal homology. Retention of radioactivity on end joining of (alpha-32P)dCTP end-filled cohesive termini, and lack of their junctional cleavability, apparently due to restriction site duplication, suggested direct double strand ligation. Thus it is demonstrated that mouse male germ cells possess an efficient DNA end-joining activity, involving either a major pathway of precise joining, or a minor end-deleted joining, and it seems to be achieved by a multienzymatic complex as suggested also for somatic cells by others. These results show that mammalian male germ cells that are proficient in homologous recombination utilize nonhomologous end-joining (NHEJ) mechanism for DSB processing and therefore NHEJ is a conserved, universal pathway for the vital function of DSB repair.     

Nonhomologous DNA end joining in Schizosaccharomyces pombe efficiently eliminates DNA double-strand-breaks from haploid sequences.

Cells of higher eucaryotes are known to possess mechanisms of illegitimate recombination which promote the joining between nonhomologous ends of broken DNA and thus may serve as basic tools of double-strand-break (DSB) repair. Here we show that cells of the fission yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe also contain activities of nonhomologous DNA end joining resembling the ones found in higher eucaryotes. Nonhomologous end joining activities were detected by transformation of linearized self-replicating plasmids in yeast cells employing a selection procedure which only propagates transformants carrying recircularized plasmid molecules. Linear plasmid substrates were generated by duplicate restriction cuts carrying either blunt ends or 3' or 5' protruding single strands (PSS) of 4 nt which were efficiently joined in any tested combination. Sequence analysis of joined products revealed that junctional sequences were shortened by 1 to 14 nt. Two mechanisms may account for junction formation (i) loss of terminal nucleotides from PSS tails to produce blunt ends which can be joined to abutting ends and (ii) interactions of DNA termini at patches of sequence homologies (1-4 bp) by formation of overlap intermediates which are subsequently processed. A general feature of the yeast joining system is that end joining can only be detected in the absence of sequence homology between the linear substrate and host genome. In the presence of homology, nonhomologous DNA end joining is efficiently competed by activities of homologous recombination.     

Nonhomologous recombination in mammalian cells: role for short sequence homologies in the joining reaction.

Although DNA breakage and reunion in nonhomologous recombination are poorly understood, previous work suggests that short sequence homologies may play a role in the end-joining step in mammalian cells. To study the mechanism of end joining in more detail, we inserted a polylinker into the simian virus 40 T-antigen intron, cleaved the polylinker with different pairs of restriction enzymes, and transfected the resulting linear molecules into monkey cells. Analysis of 199 independent junctional sequences from seven constructs with different mismatched ends indicates that single-stranded extensions are relatively stable in monkey cells and that the terminal few nucleotides are critical for cell-mediated end joining. Furthermore, these studies define three mechanisms for end joining: single-strand, template-directed, and postrepair ligations. The latter two mechanisms depend on homologous pairing of one to six complementary bases to position the junction. All three mechanisms operate with similar overall efficiencies. The relevance of this work to targeted integration in mammalian cells is discussed.     

FAM35A associates with REV7 and modulates DNA damage responses of normal and BRCA1‐defective cells

To exploit vulnerabilities of tumors, it is urgent to identify associated defects in genome maintenance. One unsolved problem is the mechanism of regulation of DNA double‐strand break repair by REV7 in complex with 53BP1 and RIF1, and its influence on repair pathway choice between homologous recombination and non‐homologous end‐joining. We searched for REV7‐associated factors in human cells and found FAM35A, a previously unstudied protein with an unstructured N‐terminal region and a C‐terminal region harboring three OB‐fold domains similar to single‐stranded DNA‐binding protein RPA, as novel interactor of REV7/RIF1/53BP1. FAM35A re‐localized in damaged cell nuclei, and its knockdown caused sensitivity to DNA‐damaging agents. In a BRCA1‐mutant cell line, however, depletion of FAM35A increased resistance to camptothecin, suggesting that FAM35A participates in processing of DNA ends to allow more efficient DNA repair. We found FAM35A absent in one widely used BRCA1‐mutant cancer cell line (HCC1937) with anomalous resistance to PARP inhibitors. A survey of FAM35A alterations revealed that the gene is altered at the highest frequency in prostate cancers (up to 13%) and significantly less expressed in metastatic cases, revealing promise for FAM35A as a therapeutically relevant cancer marker.     

Direct repeats of the herpes simplex virus a sequence promote nonconservative homologous recombination that is not dependent on XPF/ERCC4.

We have examined mechanisms of recombination in mammalian cells infected with herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1). Amplification of plasmids containing a viral origin of replication, oriS, in cells superinfected with HSV-1 revealed that linear DNA could be efficiently converted to templates for replication. Two distinct pathways were observed: imprecise end joining and nonconservative homologous recombination. We noted that direct repeats of the viral a sequence promoted efficient nonconservative homologous recombination in BHK cells as well as human repair-proficient 1BR.3N cells and xeroderma pigmentosum group F (XP-F) cells. The reaction gave rise to functional a sequences supporting the formation of defective viruses. It did not seem to proceed by single-strand annealing since it occurred in the absence of XPF/ERCC4, the mammalian homolog of the Rad1 endonuclease from Saccharomyces cerevisiae. In contrast, direct repeats of a 161-bp nonviral sequence did not take part in nonconservative homologous recombination in XP-F cells. Our results suggest that homologous recombination may be involved in the circularization of viral genomes. Furthermore, they demonstrate that amplification of recombination products supported by HSV-1 allows a direct examination of pathways for double-strand-break repair in human cells.     

V(D)J recombination coding junction formation without DNA homology: processing of coding termini.

Coding junction formation in V(D)J recombination generates diversity in the antigen recognition structures of immunoglobulin and T-cell receptor molecules by combining processes of deletion of terminal coding sequences and addition of nucleotides prior to joining. We have examined the role of coding end DNA composition in junction formation with plasmid substrates containing defined homopolymers flanking the recombination signal sequence elements. We found that coding junctions formed efficiently with or without terminal DNA homology. The extent of junctional deletion was conserved independent of coding ends with increased, partial, or no DNA homology. Interestingly, G/C homopolymer coding ends showed reduced deletion regardless of DNA homology. Therefore, DNA homology cannot be the primary determinant that stabilizes coding end structures for processing and joining.     

Persistently bound Ku at DNA ends attenuates DNA end resection and homologous recombination

DNA double strand breaks (DSBs) are repaired by non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) or homologous recombination (HR). The DNA cell cycle stage and resection of the DSB ends are two key mechanisms which are believed to push DSB repair to the HR pathway. Here, we show that the NHEJ factor Ku80 associates with DSBs in S phase, when HR is thought to be the preferred repair pathway, and its dynamics/kinetics at DSBs is similar to those observed for Ku80 in non-S phase in mammalian cells. A Ku homolog from Mycobacterium tuberculosis binds to and is retained at DSBs in S phase and was used as a tool to determine if blocking DNA ends affects end resection and HR in mammalian cells. A decrease in DNA end resection, as marked by IR-induced RPA, BrdU, and Rad51 focus formation, and HR are observed when Ku deficient rodent cells are complemented with Mt-Ku. Together, this data suggests that Ku70/80 binds to DSBs in all cell cycle stages and is likely actively displaced from DSB ends to free the DNA ends for DNA end resection and thus HR to occur.     

Human RAP1 inhibits non‐homologous end joining at telomeres

Telomeres, the nucleoprotein structures at the ends of linear chromosomes, promote genome stability by distinguishing chromosome termini from DNA double‐strand breaks (DSBs). Cells possess two principal pathways for DSB repair: homologous recombination and non‐homologous end joining (NHEJ). Several studies have implicated TRF2 in the protection of telomeres from NHEJ, but the underlying mechanism remains poorly understood. Here, we show that TRF2 inhibits NHEJ, in part, by recruiting human RAP1 to telomeres. Heterologous targeting of hRAP1 to telomeric DNA was sufficient to bypass the need for TRF2 in protecting telomeric DNA from NHEJ in vitro. On expanding these studies in cells, we find that recruitment of hRAP1 to telomeres prevents chromosome fusions caused by the loss of TRF2/hRAP1 from chromosome ends despite activation of a DNA damage response. These results provide the first evidence that hRAP1 inhibits NHEJ at mammalian telomeres and identify hRAP1 as a mediator of genome stability.     

Ku86 is not required for protection of signal ends or for formation of nonstandard V(D)J recombination products.

Ku, a heterodimer of 70- and 86-kDa subunits, serves as the DNA binding component of the DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PK). Cells deficient for the 86-kDa subunit of Ku (Ku86-deficient cells) lack Ku DNA end-binding activity and are severely defective for formation of the standard V(D)J recombination products, i.e., signal and coding joints. It has been widely hypothesized that Ku is required for protection of broken DNA ends generated during V(D)J recombination. Here we report the first analysis of V(D)J recombination intermediates in a Ku-deficient cell line. We find that full-length, ligatable signal ends are abundant in these cells. These data show that Ku86 is not required for the protection or stabilization of signal ends, suggesting that other proteins may perform this function. The presence of high levels of signal ends in Ku-deficient cells prompted us to investigate whether these ends could participate in joining reactions. We show that nonstandard V(D)J recombination products (hybrid joints), which involve joining a signal end to a coding end, form with similar efficiencies in Ku-deficient and wild-type fibroblasts. These data support the surprising conclusion that Ku is not required for some types of V(D)J joining events. We propose a novel RAG-mediated joining mechanism, analogous to disintegration reactions performed by retroviral integrases, to explain how formation of hybrid joints can bypass the requirement for Ku and DNA-PK.     

Mechanisms of nonhomologous recombination in mammalian cells.

The primary mechanism of nonhomologous recombination in transfected DNA involves breakage followed by end joining. To probe the joining step in more detail, linear simian virus 40 genomes with mismatched ends were transfected into cultured monkey cells, and individual viable recombinants were analyzed. The transfected genomes carried mismatched ends as a result of cleavage with two restriction enzymes, the recognition sites of which are located in the intron of the gene encoding the T antigen. Because the T antigen gene was split by this cleavage, the transfected genomes were inert until activated by cell-mediated end joining. Clonal descendants of the original recombinants were isolated from 122 plaques and were grouped into four classes based on the electrophoretic mobility of the junction fragment. The structures of representative junctions were determined by nucleotide sequencing. The spectrum of nonhomologous junctions analyzed here along with a large number of previously reported junctions suggest that there are two mechanisms for the linkage of DNA molecules: (i) direct ligation of ends and (ii) repair synthesis primed by terminal homologies of a few nucleotides. A paired-priming model of nonhomologous recombination is discussed.     

Nonhomologous recombination in human cells.

Nonhomologous recombination (NHR) is a major pathway for the repair of chromosomal double-strand breaks in the DNA of somatic cells. In this study, a comparison was made between the nonhomologous end joining of transfected adenovirus DNA fragments in vivo and the ability of purified human proteins to catalyze nonhomologous end joining in vitro. Adenovirus DNA fragments were shown to be efficiently joined in human cells regardless of the structure of the ends. Sequence analysis of these junctions revealed that the two participating ends frequently lost nucleotides from the 3' strands at the site of the joint. To examine the biochemical basis of the end joining, nuclear extracts were prepared from a wide variety of mammalian cell lines and tested for their ability to join test plasmid substrates. Efficient ligation of the linear substrate DNA was observed, the in vitro products being similar to the in vivo products with respect to the loss of 3' nucleotides at the junction. Substantial purification of the end-joining activity was carried out with the human immature T-cell-line HPB-ALL. The protein preparation was found to join all types of linear DNA substrates containing heterologous ends with closely equivalent efficiencies. The in vitro system for end joining does not appear to contain any of the three known DNA ligases, on the basis of a number of criteria, and has been termed the NHR ligase. The enriched activity resides in a high-molecular-weight recombination complex that appears to include and require the human homologous pairing protein HPP-1 as well as the NHR ligase. Characterization of the product molecules of the NHR ligase reaction suggests that they are linear oligomers of the monomer substrate joined nonrandomly head-to-head and/or tail-to-tail. The joined ends of the products were found to be modified by a 3' exonuclease prior to ligation, and no circular DNA molecules were detected. These types of products are similar to those required for the breakage-fusion-bridge cycle, a major NHR pathway for chromosome double-strand break repair.     

Somatic cells efficiently join unrelated DNA segments end-to-end.

Molecular substrates for probing nonhomologous recombination in somatic cells were constructed by inserting pBR322 sequences at selected sites on the simian virus 40 (SV40) genome. The chimeric products are too large to be packaged into an SV40 capsid. Therefore, production of viable progeny requires that most of the pBR322 sequences be deleted without altering any SV40 sequences that are essential for lytic infection. As judged by plaque assay, these recombination events occur at readily detectable frequencies after transfection into CV1 monkey kidney cells. Depending on the site of pBR322 insertion, the infectivities of the full-length circular or linear chimeras ranged from 0.02 to 2% of the infectivity of linear wild-type SV40 DNA. Nucleotide sequence analysis of several recombinant progeny revealed three distinct classes of recombination junction and indicated that the causative recombination events were minimally dependent on sequence homology. Potential mechanisms involving recombination at internal sites or at ends were distinguished by measuring the infectivity of chimeric molecules from which various lengths of pBR322 had been removed. These data support end-to-end joining as the primary mechanism by which DNA segments recombine nonhomologously in somatic cells. This end joining appears to be very efficient, since SV40 genomes with complementary single-stranded tails or with short non-complementary pBR322 tails were comparably infectious. Overall, this study indicates that mammalian somatic cells are quite efficient at the willy-nilly end-to-end joining of unrelated DNA segments.     

Modulation of DNA end joining by nuclear proteins

DNA double strand breaks in mammalian cells are primarily repaired by homologous recombination and non-homologous end joining (NHEJ). NHEJ may either be error-free or mutagenic with deletions or insertions at the joint. Recent studies showed that DNA ends can also be joined via microhomologous sequences flanking the break point especially when proteins responsible for NHEJ, such as Ku, are absent. Microhomology-mediated end joining (MHEJ) is always accompanied by a deletion that spans one of the two homologous sequences and the intervening sequence, if any. In this study we evaluated several factors affecting the relative contribution of MHEJ to DNA end joining using nuclear extracts and DNA substrates containing 10-bp repeats at the ends. We found that the occurrence of MHEJ is determined by the relative abundance of nuclear proteins. At low DNA/protein ratios, an error-free end-joining mechanism predominated over MHEJ. As the DNA/protein ratio increased, MHEJ became predominant. We show that the nuclear proteins that contribute to the inhibition of the error-prone MHEJ include Ku and histone H1. Treatment of extracts with flap endonuclease 1 antiserum significantly reduced MHEJ. Addition of a 17-bp intervening sequence between the microhomologous sequences significantly reduced the efficiency of MHEJ. Thus, this cell-free assay provides a platform for evaluating factors modulating end joining.     

Mycobacteriophage exploit NHEJ to facilitate genome circularization

Ku-dependent nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ) is a double-strand break repair process conserved in all branches of cellular life but has not previously been implicated in the DNA metabolic processes of viruses. We identified Ku homologs in Corndog and Omega, two related mycobacteriophages of Mycobacterium smegmatis. These proteins formed homodimers and bound DNA ends in a manner identical to other Ku's and stimulated joining of ends by the host NHEJ DNA ligase (LigD). Omega and Corndog are unusual in having short 4 base cos ends that would not be expected to self-anneal and would therefore require NHEJ during phage genome circularization. Consistently, M. smegmatis LigD null strains are entirely and selectively unable to support infection by Corndog or Omega, with concomitant failure of genome circularization. These results establish a new paradigm for sequestration of the host cell NHEJ process by bacteriophage and provide a framework for understanding similar transactions in eukaryotic viral infections.     

Topological requirements for homologous recombination among DNA molecules transfected into mammalian cells.

Cultured animal cells rearrange foreign DNA very efficiently by homologous recombination. The individual steps that constitute the mechanism(s) of homologous recombination in transfected DNA are as yet undefined. In this study, we examined the topological requirements by using the genome of simian virus 40 (SV40) as a probe. By assaying homologous recombination between defective SV40 genomes after transfection into CV1 monkey cells, we showed that linear molecules are preferred substrates for homologous exchanges, exchanges are distributed around the SV40 genome, and the frequency of exchange is not diminished significantly by the presence of short stretches of non-SV40 DNA at the ends. These observations are considered in relation to current models of homologous recombination in mammalian cells, and a new model is proposed. The function of somatic cell recombination is discussed.     

Effect of Ku86 and DNA-PKcs deficiency on non-homologous end-joining and homologous recombination using a transient transfection assay

In mammalian cells, DNA double-strand breaks are repaired by non-homologous end-joining and homologous recombination, both pathways being essential for the maintenance of genome integrity. We determined the effect of mutations in Ku86 and DNA-PK on the efficiency and the accuracy of double-strand break repair by non-homologous end-joining and homologous recombination in mammalian cells. We used an assay, based on the transient transfection of a linearized plasmid DNA, designed to simultaneously detect transfection and recombination markers. In agreement with previous results non-homologous end-joining was largely compromised in Ku86 deficient cells, and returned to normal in the Ku86-complemented isogenic cell line. In addition, analysis of DNA plasmids recovered from Ku86 mutant cells showed an increased use of microhomologies at the nonhomologous end joining junctions, and displayed a significantly higher frequency of DNA insertions compared to control cells. On the other hand, the DNA-PKcs deficient cell lines showed efficient double-strand break repair by both mechanisms.     

Survival mechanisms for Streptomyces linear replicons after telomere damage

The ability of linear replicons to propagate their DNA after telomere damage is essential for perpetuation of the genetic information they carry. We introduced deletions at specific locations within telomeres of streptomycete linear plasmids and investigated mechanisms that enable survival. Here, we report that rescue of such plasmids in Streptomyces lividans occurs by three distinct types of events: (i) repair of the damaged telomere by homologous recombination; (ii) circularization of the plasmid by non-homologous end-to-end joining; and (iii) formation of long palindromic linear plasmids that duplicate the intact telomere by a non-recombinational process. The relative frequency of use of these survival mechanisms depended on the location and length of the telomeric DNA deletion. Repair by intermolecular recombination between the telomeres of chromosomes and plasmids, deletion of additional DNA during plasmid circularization, and insertion of chromosomal DNA fragments into plasmids during end-to-end joining were observed. Our results show that damage to telomeres of Streptomyces linear replicons can promote major structural transformations in these replicons as well as genetic exchange between chromosomes and extrachromosomal DNA. Our findings also suggest that spontaneous circularization of linear Streptomyces chromosomes may be a biological response to instances of telomere damage that cannot be repaired by homologous recombination.     

Impact of DNA ligase IV on the fidelity of end joining in human cells

A DNA ligase IV (LIG4)-null human pre-B cell line and human cell lines with hypomorphic mutations in LIG4 are significantly impaired in the frequency and fidelity of end joining using an in vivo plasmid assay. Analysis of the null line demonstrates the existence of an error-prone DNA ligase IV-independent rejoining mechanism in mammalian cells. Analysis of lines with hypomorphic mutations demonstrates that residual DNA ligase IV activity, which is sufficient to promote efficient end joining, nevertheless can result in decreased fidelity of rejoining. Thus, DNA ligase IV is an important factor influencing the fidelity of end joining in vivo. The LIG4-defective cell lines also showed impaired end joining in an in vitro assay using cell-free extracts. Elevated degradation of the terminal nucleotide was observed in a LIG4-defective line, and addition of the DNA ligase IV–XRCC4 complex restored end protection. End protection by DNA ligase IV was not dependent upon ligation. Finally, using purified proteins, we demonstrate that DNA ligase IV–XRCC4 is able to protect DNA ends from degradation by T7 exonuclease. Thus, the ability of DNA ligase IV–XRCC4 to protect DNA ends may contribute to the ability of DNA ligase IV to promote accurate rejoining in vivo.