Fine needle aspiration of breast masses. An analysis of 276 aspirates

A study of 276 consecutive fine needle aspirations (FNAs) of the breast in 240 cases is presented. Of these cases, 108 underwent subsequent biopsy of the breast; correlations between the FNA cytology and the surgical pathology findings revealed that FNA had a sensitivity of 79.4%, a specificity of 100% and a predictive value of a positive diagnosis of 100%. The overall diagnostic accuracy was 92.4%. These results are compared with those in other published series, and the pitfalls in and methods of improvement of breast FNA are discussed.     

Fine needle aspiration of palpable breast lesions. Results obtained with cytocentrifuge preparation of aspirates

The use of cytocentrifugation in the preparation of fine needle aspiration (FNA) specimens from the breast was evaluated. A total of 174 fine needle aspirates of breast masses were flushed into cytospin Collection Fluid, from which Papanicolaou-stained Cytospin preparations were made in the laboratory. Comparison of these preparations to conventional smears of aspirates showed no significant differences in the number or morphology of the cells. In 148 cases, the FNA cytologic study was followed up by excisional biopsy, Tru-Cut biopsy and/or a combination of mammography and clinical follow-up of two to nine months. Of 36 verified carcinomas, 31 (86%) were correctly diagnosed, with a zero false-positive rate. Among the 74 cytologically benign aspirates, 2 carcinomas were found on open biopsy, giving a false-negative rate of 3%. Lipomas were not diagnosable with this technique. This technique should be considered in institutions with a high turnover of junior staff members, which frequently results in a higher number of poorly smeared specimens or in poorly fixed/air-dried specimens that give suboptimal results with the Papanicolaou stain. With this method, there is less risk of creation of potentially hazardous aerosols and further preparations for additional studies may be made if required.     

Metastatic tumors in fine needle aspiration biopsy of the thyroid

A series of almost 25,000 thyroids examined by fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy was reviewed to ascertain the incidence and presentation of metastatic cancers in thyroid FNA samples. Metastatic cancers in FNA samples from the thyroid were identified in 25 cases (0.1%); the primary tumors were carcinomas of the kidney (8 cases), lung (7 cases), breast (5 cases), cervix uteri (1 case) and colon (1 case) and 1 case each of malignant melanoma, malignant pleural mesothelioma and rhabdomyosarcoma. FNA cytology was positive in all 25 cases. In 11 cases, the primary tumor was clinically known at the time of FNA biopsy; of the other 14 cases, cytology suggested that the malignancy was metastatic in only 5. Metastases of renal and mammary adenocarcinomas were almost indistinguishable from follicular and papillary thyroid carcinomas on cytologic grounds. The results demonstrate the rarity of this finding and the difficulty of diagnosing a metastatic tumor in the thyroid by FNA biopsy, in the absence of a clinical history of a prior primary neoplasm.     

Diagnostic use of mean nuclear area and nuclear DNA content in preoperative breast cancer cytology

OBJECTIVE: Fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology of breast lumps is a routine procedure, and the diagnostic accuracy can be 95%. Occasional discrepancies arise, and it would be valuable to have additional parameters for accurate diagnosis. We evaluated nuclear DNA content and mean nuclear area (MNA) using image cytometry in the diagnosis of preoperative breast cancers by FNA in those with a discrepancy between clinical, radiologic and cytologic diagnoses. STUDY DESIGN: One hundred eighteen consecutive preoperative FNA samples were evaluated for nuclear DNA and MNA and were compared to cytologic and postoperative histologic diagnoses. RESULTS: Sensitivity, accuracy and positive predictive value of routine cytology were 95%, 90%, 95% as compared to nuclear DNA (66%, 66%, 96%) and MNA (61%, 61%, 97%). Combining these 3 parameters gave a sensitivity of 97%, accuracy of 94% and positive predictive value of 99%. CONCLUSION: These results demonstrate that nuclear DNA and MNA combined with routine cytology may be useful adjuncts in preoperative breast cancer cytologic diagnosis when discrepancies arise. This may lead to better and more accurate planning of treatment regimens in preoperative breast cancer patients.     

Routine audit of breast fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology specimens and aspirator inadequate rates

Routine audit of breast fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology specimens and aspirator inadequate rates In an attempt to improve the quality of the breast FNA specimens we instigated a continuing audit of this procedure in this hospital. All FNAs since 1990 have had the following recorded: mode of aspiration, e.g. freehand or image guided, patient presentation (screening or symptomatic), patient diagnostic category, cytological diagnosis and final histological diagnosis. Aspirator performance was assessed by means of the inadequate aspiration rate (IR) of FNAs performed on patients with a final diagnosis of cancer (FDC) and diagnostic category A patients (clinically or radiologically malignant lesions). An ongoing annual review of the performance of all the aspirators was undertaken, all of whom received individual feedback. Counselling and further training were offered where indicated by poor performance. Over the period 1990–1995 a total of 13 537 FNAs were performed by 27 aspirators. The IR on category A and FDC cases over this period was 16.0% and 18.1%. The best performance achieved by an aspirator in a calendar year was an IR of 3.6% with no inadequate specimens in either FDC or category A lesions, and the best performance over the entire period was an average IR of 11.75% and 14.25% for FDC and category A groups, respectively. The overall IR on category A patients ranged from 15.9% to 23.8% and on FDC cases from 12.2% to 21.7%. There was a significant improvement in individual junior aspirator performance when their first year was compared with their last year on the unit. In some cases a deterioration in intra-aspirator performance was observed, from an IR of 6% to 33%. The overall IR rate of the unit remained stable for FDC patients, 15.5% in 1990 compared with 15.1% in 1995. This appeared to be largely due to a high proportion of the aspirations being performed by experienced personnel with consistent IRs. However, concealed within the overall rate there were some poor performers who benefited from counselling and/or further training. These results indicate an important role for audit in identifying poor aspirators who benefit from targeted training and advice, thereby improving the quality of FNA specimens, and ultimately patient care.     

Fine needle aspiration cytology of "minimal" breast cancer

The value of fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology in the diagnosis of "minimal" breast cancer was studied. Sixteen (76.2%) of 21 cases of invasive breast cancer less than 1.0 cm in diameter and 14 (73.3%) of 19 cases of noninvasive breast carcinoma were given a positive diagnosis by FNA cytology. One "suspicious" and the five false-negative diagnoses occurred in cases of invasive carcinoma; the reasons were considered to be either a faulty technique of needling the tumor or the presence of prominent fibrosis in the tumor. In noninvasive carcinoma, atypical cells were misdiagnosed in two of the five smears that had been originally reported as negative. The results of the retrospective analysis showed that FNA cytology had a higher accuracy in the diagnosis of small lesions than did radiologic and echographic criteria, and FNA cytology was thus used as the main criterion for deciding on the necessity for preoperative surgical biopsies.     

Inflammatory myofibroblastic tumor of the breast. A case report

BACKGROUND: Inflammatory myofibroblastic tumor (IMT) of the breast is a very rare tumor like lesion with only 6 previously reported cases. Very little is known about the cytology of IMT. We present the fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology of a case of recurrent, bilateral IMT of the breast and detail the clinical course, radiologic findings, morphologic appearances and immunohistochemical profile of the lesion. CASE: A 79-year-old female was initially seen in 1991 because of a suspicious mammographic abnormality in her right breast. Ultrasound-guided FNA cytology showed an unusual "inflammatory" lesion with occasional aggregates of cellular connective tissue fragments, sheets of uniform ductal epithelial cells with myoepithelial cells, spindle cells, lymphocytes and histiocytelike cells. The lesion was excised, and histology confirmed a benign process with spindle cells, lymphocytes and histiocytes. No malignant features were noted. During follow-up many new lesions appeared in both breasts, and after several FNA procedures and local excisions, bilateral mastectomy was performed at the patient's urging. She remained disease free. CONCLUSION: Although IMT of the breast has benign cytology and histology, clinically and on imaging, it resembles carcinoma. Awareness of the condition may help prevent a false diagnosis of carcinoma.     

Fine needle aspiration cytology in the management of palpable benign and malignant breast disease. Correlation with clinical and mammographic findings

Two surgeons in a health maintenance organization group practice performed 280 fine needle aspirations (FNAs) on 257 palpable breast lesions in 200 patients. The cytology was interpreted by four pathologists at a community hospital. FNA cytology had a sensitivity of 96% and a specificity of 94% in these cases; there were no false-positive diagnoses of cancer. FNA cytology improved the identification of benign disease and decreased the risk of missing cancers. FNA cytology also improved the predictive value of mammographic information and was more helpful than mammography in demonstrating the need for biopsy of small palpable lesions that turned out to be "minimal" breast cancers.     

Analysis of fine needle aspiration cytology of the breast: a review of 1,297 cases and correlation with histologic diagnoses

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the accuracy of fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology of the breast and to ascertain its usefulness. STUDY DESIGN: The authors reviewed 1,297 cases of FNA cytology of the breast which were performed at Chonnam National University Hospital from 1999 to 2002. Cytologic diagnoses were compared with histologic diagnoses in 457 cases that underwent both cytologic and histologic examination. RESULTS: Of 1,297 cases, 1,201 (92.6%) were satisfactory and 96 (7.4%) unsatisfactory. Subsequent histologic examination was performed on 291 cases (29.7%) out of 981 "benign" lesions, 28 (73.7%) of 38 "suspicious," 124 (68.1%) of 182 "malignant" and 14 (14.6%) of 96 "unsatisfactory." FNA cytology revealed 77.7% sensitivity, 99.2% specificity, 98.4% positive predictive value and 88.0% negative predictive value. Diagnostic accuracy was 91.1%. Of the 291 benign cases on cytology, 35 cases were malignancy on histology. Of the 124 cases reported as malignant, 2 were benign. Interpretive error was the leading cause of false positive diagnoses. CONCLUSION: Although FNA cytology is a useful diagnostic procedure for the evaluation of breast lesions, it should be combined with other diagnostic modalities, such as physical examination, ultrasonography and mammography.     

Inflammatory Lesions of the Breast: Diagnosis By Fine Needle Aspiration

Amongst 1061 breast lesions diagnosed by fine needle aspiration (FNA) over a period of 6 years (1985-1990), 128 were reported to be showing changes consistent with an inflammatory lesion. On review, the cytodiagnosis was found to be inaccurate in 31 cases. The cytological features of the 97 cases that were correctly reported are described in this report. The cytological diagnoses issued in these 97 cases were acute mastitis or breast abscess (57 cases) and tuberculous mastitis (30 cases). Non-specific chronic mastitis and miscellaneous conditions accounted for four and six cases respectively. Acid fast bacilli (AFB) were demonstrated in 28.0% of tuberculous mastitis cases and 10.0% of those diagnosed as acute mastitis or breast abscess. FNA cytology was found to be useful for the diagnosis of inflammatory lesions of breast and their classification, as only five out of 57 cases of acute mastitis/breast abscess and one out of 30 tuberculous mastitis cases were suspected on clinical grounds.     

The use of cytospin monolayer technique in the cytological diagnosis of vulval and anal disease

This pilot study investigated the use of the non-invasive cytospin monolayer technique in the diagnosis and screening of neoplastic and non-neoplastic vulval disease. Twenty-three patients (age range 34-86 years) attending a vulval disease clinic had brush cytology performed. The samples were prepared with a cytospin monolayer technique and the slides Papanicolaou-stained. Subsequent cytological interpretation and diagnosis were performed without knowledge of the clinical history and correlated with follow-up biopsy histopathology from each patient. Twenty-eight cytospin samples were analysed in total, of which 11 (39%) contained dyskaryotic cells which were assessed and a predicted VIN/AIN grade given. Ten of 11 samples (91%) reported as dyskaryotic had VIN/AIN on biopsy histology. One of 11 samples (9%) was reported as containing occasional squamous cells with borderline nuclear features and, although the corresponding biopsy did not show VIN, basal atypia was reported. One patient had features suggesting invasive carcinoma on cytology which was verified on subsequent biopsy. The 15 cases in which no dyskaryotic cells were identified did not show VIN or AIN on subsequent histology. Two cases were acellular and considered inadequate for cytological interpretation. The cytospin monolayer technique allows the diagnosis of neoplastic from non-neoplastic vulval disease. It is a quick, inexpensive and non-invasive method that may have a role in diagnosis, screening and surveillance of patients.     

Fine Needle Aspiration of Palpable Breast Lumps: A 1-Year Audit Using the Cytospin Method

A fine-needle aspiration (FNA) service for the diagnosis of palpable breast lumps was started at the Royal Preston Hospital, Preston, UK, in November 1989. Over the subsequent year, 407 FNAs were taken from 393 women. A simple technique was used which involved the surgeon flushing the aspirate into 10 ml of Cytospin collection fluid; cytocentrifuge preparations were then safely and conveniently prepared in the laboratory. Slides were stained with Papanicolaou and H&E. The method detected 112 out of a total of 121 cancers (92.6%); of the nine that were undetected, five aspirates were inadequate and four were falsely reported as negative. There were no false positives. The overall inadequate rate was 11.0%. Excluding inadequate samples, the absolute sensitivity was 89.7% and complete sensitivity 96.6% with 94.4% specificity. This 1-year audit has shown the Cytospin method of FNA in palpable breast disease to have a favourable sensitivity and specificity, and therefore to be an alternative to conventional FNA using direct smears.     

Ultrasound guidance improves the adequacy of our preoperative thyroid cytology but not its accuracy

AIMS: Our thyroid cytology audit results of 1990-1995 showed an unsatisfactory rate of 43.1% and prediction of neoplasia with a sensitivity of 86.8%. Increasingly, ultrasound scan (USS)-guided core sampling for cytology is proving a valuable tool instead of freehand fine needle aspiration (FNA) or following unsatisfactory freehand FNA. We present the results of freehand FNA and USS-guided core samples for cytology in two separate patient groups in our centre. METHODS: Patients who had a thyroid resection and preoperative thyroid cytology in our institution between 1996 and 2002 were included. The histological diagnoses were correlated with the preceding cytology results. RESULTS: A total of 450 FNAs were performed on 394 patients. Freehand FNAs were performed for 348 (77.3%) samples and USS-guided core for 102 (22.7%) samples; 121 (26.8%) were repeat aspirates performed on 45 patients. Using aspiration cytology (AC) grading, freehand FNA was cytologically inadequate (AC0 or AC1) in 34.8% cases whereas USS-guided core was inadequate in 17.6% cases (P = 0.001). Freehand FNA (AC3, AC4, AC5) predicted neoplasia with a sensitivity of 83.2%, specificity of 46.6%, accuracy of 63.0%, positive predictive value of 56.0% and negative predictive value of 77.1%. USS-guided core sample for cytology (AC3, AC4, AC5) predicted neoplasia with a sensitivity of 93.5%, specificity of 26.0%, accuracy of 51.9%, positive predictive value of 43.9% and negative predictive value of 86.7%. CONCLUSIONS: Although USS-guided core provides more satisfactory specimens than freehand FNA, in our centre it does not provide increased accuracy.     

Fine needle aspiration as a tool to establish primary human breast cancer cultures in vitro

OBJECTIVE: To verify the potential role of fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology in obtaining malignant cells from primary breast cancer for establishment of a primary breast cancer cell line. STUDY DESIGN: In four patients with primary breast cancer subjected to FNA for diagnostic purposes, we attempted to establish primary cultures. We successfully obtained one primary cell line, originating in micropapillary invasive breast carcinoma. FNA material obtained under sterile conditions was centrifuged, and the cell pellet was washed with Dulbecco Modified Medium. The resulting suspension was seeded in 25-cm2 tissue culture flasks. The flasks were maintained with released caps in a 37 degrees C incubator with a humidified atmosphere of 5% CO2 in air. After one week, cells attached to the bottom of the flasks and began proliferating. When a culture became confluent, the cells were treated with 0.05% trypsin/0.02% EDTA in a PBS solution and subcultured. The flasks were observed daily with an inverted microscope, and culture passages were performed weekly. RESULTS: The cell line obtained was named I2FPRW and exhibited morphologic and immunohistochemical features of epithelial cells of mammary origin. The cells were positive for cytokeratins (AE1/AE3 and CK 7), EMA and c-erbB-2. At this writing, this cell line was in the 15th passage of subculturing in the flasks with 10% FBS. CONCLUSION: In the present study we demonstrated that is possible to establish a breast cancer cell line from material obtained by FNA cytology. FNA seems to be a valuable method of obtaining malignant cells from breast cancer able to grow free of fibroblasts in cell cultures.     

Cytology of abnormal nipple discharge: a cyto-histological correlation

Spontaneous or expressible nipple discharge may occur in palpable and nonpalpable breast lesions. The aim of the study was to evaluate the sensitivity and specificity of nipple discharge cytology in palpable and nonpalpable breast lesions. One hundred and seventy-four nipple discharge specimens were reviewed, of which 82 had corresponding surgical pathology, including 34 palpable breast lesions and 48 nonpalpable breast lesions. There was good correlation between nipple discharge cytology and concomitant fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology. Nipple discharge cytology is as specific as concomitant FNA cytology but is slightly less sensitive in detecting papillomas or malignant lesions. The sensitivity and specificity of the nonpalpable and palpable breast lesions were similar. Nipple discharge cytology is very helpful in detecting an underlying breast lesion even if the case has no palpable mass in the breast.     

Positive predictive value of fine needle aspiration cytology of breast lesions

The predictive value of fine needle aspiration (FNA) was assessed in 1,181 consecutive cases of breast lesions in which cytologic abnormalities were reported. The positive predictive value (PPV) of an FNA cytologic report of atypia, suspicious or positive was 0.49, 0.95 or 0.996, respectively. In the presence of a suspicious/positive report by both physical examination and mammography, the PPV of a cytologic report of suspicious was 0.99. The PPV was directly correlated with age, partly due to the incidence of fibroadenomas among younger patients; fibroadenomas were present in 53 of 146 cases with a false FNA report of atypia, in 10 of 19 cases with a false FNA report of suspicious and in 2 of 2 cases with a false FNA report of positive. Overall, 93 cases reported as benign by physical examination and mammography were biopsied on the basis of the FNA cytologic report; cancers were diagnosed in 33 of these 93 cases (6 cancers among 42 women less than 40 years old and 27 cancers among 51 women greater than 39 years old). The widespread use of FNA cytology to study breast lesions is thus recommended, without regard to patient age and even in the presence of clinically benign findings, since the increase in the rate of cancer detection is worth the excess of unnecessary biopsies. The predictive value of a positive report of FNA cytology, or even of a suspicious report in the presence of clinical suspicion, is so high that an intraoperative frozen section biopsy might be spared in such cases.     

Triple test approach to inadequate fine needle aspiration biopsies of palpable breast lesions.

OBJECTIVE: To perform a retrospective study evaluating the triple test for inadequate fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsies of palpable breast lesions with a two-year clinical follow-up. STUDY DESIGN: All aspirates were reviewed and assessed for cellular adequacy in a one-year period. Specimen adequacy was based on the most stringent criteria, the presence of six or more epithelial cell clusters composed of at least six cells each. In all cases, clinical and radiologic results were reviewed and compared with the histologic outcome. RESULTS: Aspirates from 61 of 263 (23%) patients with palpable breast lesions that yielded nondiagnostic results were examined. The study showed a misdirected FNA rate of 21% and a misinterpreted rate of 1.6%. The other 77% of cases had benign surgical biopsies and/or clinical follow-up. Three of 61 (4.9%) cases with nondiagnostic smears were found to have cancer; two were inadequate due to misdirected aspirates, and one was misinterpreted microscopically. All cancer cases underwent surgical removal of the mass as a result of clinical or radiologic suspicion. CONCLUSION: We recommend utilizing the three diagnostic parameters of cytology, clinical findings and radiology, the "triple test," to achieve the best diagnostic accuracy in breast FNAs and to enhance patient management.     

Standardization of fine needle aspiration cytology of the breast – comparison of Auto Cyto Fix and conventional smears

In Japan, there are some problems with fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology of the breast, such as insufficient smeared cells, air-drying artefact and excessive erythrocytes. Liquid-based cytology has been found to solve these problems. Equipment for such preparations has been developed, but can be expensive to purchase and operate. We developed Auto Cyto Fix 1000 (ACF), which is inexpensive and automatically smears and fixes cells. The purpose of this study was to compare the various cytological features of conventional and ACF specimens. We evaluated whether the ACF method would be able to replace the conventional method. Forty-eight FNA specimens of breast were studied. All specimens were prepared by the direct smeared (DS) and ACF methods and evaluated for unsatisfactory cell collection, air-drying artefacts, background findings and epithelial cell findings. Although ACF specimens were prepared using the cells remaining in the needle and syringe after preparing DS specimens, the cellularity of two of the ACF specimens was better than that of the corresponding DS specimens. ACF specimens never showed air-drying artefact. Unlike DS specimens, which have many erythrocytes in the background, erythrocytes were filtered out and the background of ACF specimens was clean. We believe that many problems attributable to conventional FNA specimen preparation have been solved in this study. Preparation using the ACF apparatus can reduce running costs and can be used to prepare FNA specimens of the breast for cytological examination as an alternative to the conventional method.     

Standardization of fine needle aspiration cytology of the breast -- comparison of Auto Cyto Fix and conventional smears.

In Japan, there are some problems with fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology of the breast, such as insufficient smeared cells, air-drying artefact and excessive erythrocytes. Liquid-based cytology has been found to solve these problems. Equipment for such preparations has been developed, but can be expensive to purchase and operate. We developed Auto Cyto Fix 1000 (ACF), which is inexpensive and automatically smears and fixes cells. The purpose of this study was to compare the various cytological features of conventional and ACF specimens. We evaluated whether the ACF method would be able to replace the conventional method. Forty-eight FNA specimens of breast were studied. All specimens were prepared by the direct smeared (DS) and ACF methods and evaluated for unsatisfactory cell collection, air-drying artefacts, background findings and epithelial cell findings. Although ACF specimens were prepared using the cells remaining in the needle and syringe after preparing DS specimens, the cellularity of two of the ACF specimens was better than that of the corresponding DS specimens. ACF specimens never showed air-drying artefact. Unlike DS specimens, which have many erythrocytes in the background, erythrocytes were filtered out and the background of ACF specimens was clean. We believe that many problems attributable to conventional FNA specimen preparation have been solved in this study. Preparation using the ACF apparatus can reduce running costs and can be used to prepare FNA specimens of the breast for cytological examination as an alternative to the conventional method.     

Renal fine needle aspiration cytology

OBJECTIVE: To audit and evaluate the pitfalls in renal fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective analysis of 180 renal FNAs from 163 patients, encountered at Canberra Hospital, Australian Capital Territory, between June 1989 and July 1997 was undertaken. The FNA procedures had been performed by radiologists under computed tomography (CT) or ultrasound (US) guidance. The study correlated the FNA results with biopsy findings and clinical outcome. RESULTS: The initial cytologic diagnoses included 84 (47%) benign, 6 (3%) atypical, 7 (4%) suspicious, 70 (39%) malignant and 13 (7%) inadequate. Six of the 13 cytologically inadequate group, on further investigation, had malignant histology. The benign cytologic categories contained 79 benign conditions and 5 cases with a malignant outcome. The atypical cytologic group contained 5 benign and 1 malignant case. All nine cytologically suspicious cases had malignant histology. The cytologically malignant group contained 62 malignant, 7 benign and 1 patient lost to follow-up. The sensitivity was 92.5%, specificity was 91.9%, positive predictive value was 89.9%, negative predictive value was 94.0%, and efficacy of the test was 92.2%. CONCLUSION: Renal FNA can provide an accurate diagnosis in most instances; however, aspiration cytology of the kidney has limitations and pitfalls. Low grade renal cell carcinoma has to be differentiated from oncocytoma, angiomyolipoma, renal infarct and reactive conditions. Renal FNA has a high negative predictive value, which is useful in reassuring patients with radiologically and cytologically benign lesions. Negative FNA does not exclude malignancy in the presence of a radiologic suspicion.