Independent analysis of T helper and T killer cell function in young and old NZB mice.

With age, NZB mice lose their ability to develop a cytotoxic response after alloimmunization in vitro. This decline is shown to coincide with a diminution of T-helper cell activity as assessed by proliferation in mixed lymphocyte culture or in response to PHA. When cytotoxic T cell precursors are activated with the polyclonal activator Con A, there is no reduction in the number of cytotoxic effector T cells that develop. No autoreactive cytotoxic cells are seen in Con A-activated cultures. These findings are related to previous work on cell-mediated immunity in NZB and B/W mice.     

Establishment of a nucleoside-specific suppressor T cell line from SLE prone (NZB/NZW)F1 mice

A long-term cultured suppressor T cell line (GTS-124) was established from an autoimmune mouse strain, (NZB X NZW)F1, by a two-part procedure: a) B/W F1 mice were made tolerant to guanosine (G) by administration of a tolerogen, the G-modified copolymer of D-glutamic acid and D-lysine (G-D-GL); and b) the spleen cells obtained from tolerant mice were repeatedly stimulated with mitomycin C-treated G-modified syngeneic spleen cells. The GTS-124 cells suppressed the secondary in vitro response to G-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (G-KLH) but did not suppress the response to unrelated antigens, sheep erythrocytes (SRBC), or trinitrophenyl-KLH (TNP-KLH). The expression of Thy-1 antigen on the cell surface of GTS-124 was demonstrated by flow cytometry. Growth of GTS-124 cells was dependent on IL 2. To determine whether GTS-124 cells could suppress the response to nucleosides other than G, KLH coupled with four nucleosides (adenosine [A], G, cytidine [C], and thymine riboside [T]) collectively (AGCT-KLH) was first used as the antigen in the assay system. The PFC response to the individual nucleosides (anti-A, -G, -C, and -T PFC) were effectively inhibited by GTS-124 cells, suggesting that the GTS-124 cells mediated cross-suppression toward all four nucleosides. A more stringent cross-suppression test was conducted by using only the T moiety bound to KLH (T-KLH) as antigen. The results showed that GTS-124 cells were capable of suppressing the T-specific response. The cross-suppression could be seen after repeated selection on a G-BSA-coated dish. These results provide direct evidence that the suppressor T cells induced by in vitro stimulation with G-modified self can indeed suppress the response to nucleosides other than G.     

Transferred B cells from autoimmune NZB/N mice fail to activate T suppressor cells

T-cell-mediated suppression of the antibody response of autoimmune NZB/N mice to Type III pneumococcal polysaccharide (SSS-III) can readily be induced in situ by priming with a subimmunogenic dose of SSS-III; however, the transfer of either "young" (8 weeks old) or "old" (42 weeks old) SSS-III-primed B cells, which activates suppressor T cells in normal BALB/cByJ mice, fails to induce suppression of the antibody response in recipient NZB/N mice, regardless of the number of cells transferred or the time interval between transfer and immunization. Transfer of 51Cr-labeled B cells demonstrated that syngeneic primed B cells home to the spleens of NZB/N mice in somewhat lower numbers than in BALB/cByJ mice, although the differences observed may not be sufficient to explain the complete absence of activation of suppressor T cells. These findings suggest that B cells from autoimmune NZB/N mice are unable to activate T suppressor cells upon transfer; this disorder in a normal regulatory mechanism may be important in the pathogenesis of disease.     

NZB mice exhibit a primary T cell defect in fetal thymic organ culture

Defects in T cell development have been suggested to be a factor in the development of systemic autoimmunity in NZB mice. However, the suggestion of a primary T cell defect has often been by extrapolation, and few direct observations of T cell precursors in NZB mice have been performed. Moreover, the capacity of NZB bone marrow T cell precursors to colonize the thymus and the ability of the NZB thymic microenvironment to support T lymphopoiesis have not been analyzed. To address this important issue, we employed the fetal thymic organ culture system to examine NZB T cell development. Our data demonstrated that NZB bone marrow cells were less efficient at colonizing fetal thymic lobes than those of control BALB/c or C57BL/6 mice. In addition, NZB bone marrow cells did not differentiate into mature T cells as efficiently as bone marrow cells from BALB/c or C57BL/6 mice. Further analysis revealed that this defect resulted from an intrinsic deficiency in the NZB Lin-Sca-1+c-kit+ bone marrow stem cell pool to differentiate into T cells in fetal thymic organ culture. Taken together, the data document heretofore unappreciated deficiencies in T cell development that may contribute to the development of the autoimmune phenotype in NZB mice.     

Expression of functional alpha beta T cell receptor gene rearrangements in suppressor T cell hybridomas correlates with antigen binding, but not with suppressor cell function

We have examined the expression of TCR genes in 4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl-acetyl (NP)-specific Ts cell hybridomas. Each of three independently isolated hybridomas expressed in-frame TCR alpha-chain rearrangements derived from the original suppressor Ts cell. Different V alpha and J alpha gene segments were rearranged and expressed in each Ts cell line. The only TCR beta-chain expressed in these cells was derived from the BW5147 fusion partner. Expression of the BW5147 beta-chain was found to correlate with cell surface Ag binding, inasmuch as subclones derived from one of the original Ts lines expressed greatly reduced levels of beta-chain mRNA and no longer bound to NP-coupled RBC. Subclones that continued to express beta-chain mRNA did bind to NP-coupled RBC. This suggests that the Ag receptor on Ts hybridomas is a TCR-alpha beta dimer composed of a unique alpha-chain and the BW5147 beta-chain. Ag binding could be modulated by preincubation of Ts hybridoma cells with anti-TCR-alpha beta antibody, thereby supporting this conclusion. Suppressor factor activity was measured in the conditioned media of Ts subclones that differed by 250-fold in levels of beta-chain mRNA expression. No difference in suppressor factor activity was found; conditioned media from these subclones suppressed both plaque-forming cell responses and delayed-type hypersensitivity responses at approximately equivalent dilutions. Suppressor factor activity in the conditioned media of both a beta-chain negative subclone and a beta-chain positive subclone could be absorbed with an antibody that recognizes the TCR alpha-chain, but not with an antibody that recognizes the TCR beta-chain. We conclude that suppressor factor activity in the conditioned media of these Ts hybridomas is not derived from surface TCR-alpha beta receptors, although it does share TCR alpha-chain determinants.     

Demonstration of active suppressor cells in spleens of young NZB mice

NZB mice, a strain prone to the development of autoimmune disease, have during the first 2 weeks of life suppressor cells in their spleens which can in coculture with adult spleen cells suppress the antibody response to sheep red blood cells (SRBC) generated in culture by the adult cells. The suppressive activity of spleen cells from NZB mice in the first week after birth is similar to that of spleen cells from 4-day-old C57BL/6 mice, a strain which does not spontaneously develop autoimmune disease. As in “normal” strains of mice, suppressor cell activity in NZB mice is diminished at 2 weeks and undetectable at 3 weeks of age. The data indicate that there is no defect inherent in the suppressor cells detected in the spleens of newborn and young NZB mice and suggest that the development of autoimmune responses does not result from a lack of suppressor cells in the young animals.     

Sarcoidosis is not associated with a generalized defect in T cell suppressor function

In pulmonary sarcoidosis, the marked expansion of CD4+ (helper/inducer) T cells in the alveolar structures of the lung is maintained by local IL-2 release by activated CD4+ HLA-DR+ T cells without concomitant expansion and activation of CD8+ (suppressor/cytotoxic) T cells, suggesting that sarcoid may be associated with a generalized abnormality of CD8+ T cells. Consistent with this concept, evaluation of the expression of the IL-2R on fresh lung T cells from individuals with active sarcoidosis demonstrated that 7 +/- 1% of sarcoid lung CD4+ T cells are spontaneously expressing the IL-2R compared with only 1 +/- 1% lung CD8+ T cells (p less than 0.01). However, stimulation of purified sarcoid blood CD8+ T cells with the anti-T3/TCR complex mAb OKT3 was followed by the normal expression of IL-2R (p greater than 0.1) and proliferation (p greater than 0.1). In addition, lung sarcoid CD8+ T cells responded to OKT3 similarly to normal lung CD8+ T cells and to autologous blood CD8+ T cells as regards expression of IL-2R (p greater than 0.1) and proliferation (p greater than 0.1). Finally, using CD4+ cells activated with allogenic Ag to induce, in coculture, fresh autologous CD8+ cells to suppress proliferation of fresh autologous CD4+ cells to the same Ag, sarcoid CD8+ T cells suppressed CD4+ cell proliferation in a normal fashion (p greater than 0.1). These results demonstrate that sarcoid CD8+ (suppressor/cytotoxic) T cells are competent to respond to a proliferation signal normally and can be induced to normally suppress CD4+ T cell proliferation to Ag, suggesting that the expansion of activated CD4+ T cells in pulmonary sarcoidosis is not due to a generalized abnormality of CD8+ T cells or of their suppressor T cell function.     

Extrathymic T cell maturation. Phenotypic analysis of T cell subsets in nude mice as a function of age.

T cell maturation in an extrathymic environment has been studied using as a model the congenitally athymic nude mouse. Phenotypic analyses as a function of age were conducted on lymphocytes obtained from the spleens and lymph nodes of nude mice through use of mAb recognizing T cell surface markers and multiparameter flow cytometry. The data show that nude mice accumulate increasing numbers of lymphocytes bearing Thy-1, CD3, CD4, and CD8 with age characterized by a progression from heterogeneous dim to more homogeneous bright expression. In contrast, the expression of heat-stable Ag (HSA), a marker of immature thymocytes, decreases with age. By analogy to intrathymic maturation, spleens and lymph nodes in nude mice contain T cells defined as immature, transitional, and mature based on the expression of these markers. Although the proportion of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells associated with bright CD3 expression increases with age, at no age are significant numbers of CD4+8+ cells observed, in contrast to intrathymic T cell maturation. In addition to the frequently observed inversion in the ratio of CD4 to CD8, the CD8 T cell subpopulation in older nude mice contains mainly mature cells (CD8+, CD3+, HSA-) whereas only 50% of CD4+ T cells express the mature (CD4+, CD3+, HSA-) phenotype. At any age, the spectrum of phenotypes observed indicates that lymph nodes contain more mature T cells than spleen, suggesting a role for environmental Ag in driving extrathymic maturation, a process occurring most efficiently among CD8+ T cells. Because extrathymic maturation mirrors some but not all aspects of the intrathymic pathway, we propose that the nude mouse may be a useful model for further dissecting those interactions crucial to establishing the T cell repertoire in euthymic individuals as well as elucidating the contribution of extrathymically derived T cells to the peripheral immune system.     

Modulation of autoimmunity in NZB mice by cyclophosphamide-induced, nonspecific suppressor cells

A group of NZB mice received six biweekly injections of cyclophosphamide-induced nonspecific suppressor cells, with treatment commencing at 2 mo of age. Mice were evaluated for Coombs and natural thymocytotoxic antibody at 6-wk intervals thereafter, and for anti-DNA autoantibodies, total IgM and IgG levels, and renal histology at selected time points. The administration of suppressor cells resulted in marked and prolonged suppression of both Coombs and natural thymocytotoxic antibody reactivity in the majority of animals while not measurably affecting the levels of anti-DNA autoantibodies, the total IgM and IgG levels, or the life span of the mice.     

Decline in the production of interleukin-3 with age in mice

Previously, we and others have found that the ability to produce interleukin-1 (IL-1) and interleukin-2 (IL-2) declines with age in mice. The purpose of this study was to determine the influence of age on the capacity of mice to produce interleukin-3 (IL-3). Splenic cells (5 X 10(6)/ml) from young (3-4 months) and old (24-32 months) C57BL/6 mice were first assessed for their IL-3-producing capacities in response to varying doses of concanavalin A (Con A; 2-20 micrograms/ml) in a time-dependent manner. The results showed that the production of IL-3 by both young and old C57BL/6 mice was maximal on Days 3 and 4 in response to 20 micrograms/ml of Con A, and that of IL-2 was minimal (activity was less than 0.1 unit) on Day 4. Consequently, Day 4, was selected to assess the effect of age on IL-3 production by splenic cells. The results showed a twofold reduction in IL-3 production with age (P less than 0.05). Young-old splenic cell mixture experiments at ratios of 1:0, 3:1, 1:1, 1:3, and 0:1 indicated that the decrease in IL-3 production with age was not due to an increase in suppressor cell activity. Experiments based on mixtures of nylon wool-enriched splenic T-cell and adherent cells and on anti-MAC-1 plus complement-treated spleen cells indicated that (a) adherent cells are not required for T-cell production of IL-3, unlike IL-2 production, and (b) the decrease in IL-3 production with age is due solely to alteration in IL-3-producing T cells. Finally, a strong correlation was demonstrated between the production of IL-2 and IL-3 by spleen cells of individual young and old mice (r = 0.92, P less than 0.01). That production of both IL-2 and IL-3 is affected in a similar manner by age would suggest that a single class of helper T cells may be responsible for production of both lymphokines.     

Defective activation of T suppressor cell function in nonobese diabetic mice. Potential relation to cytokine deficiencies

Nonobese diabetic (NOD) is an inbred mouse strain susceptible to development of T cell-mediated autoimmune diabetes. The strain is characterized by high percentages of T lymphocytes in lymphoid organs. The syngeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction (SMLR), a T cell response to self MHC class II Ag, is reportedly involved in the generation of a number of immunoregulatory cells, including suppressor inducers. A severely depressed SMLR characteristic of certain other autoimmune strains was found in NOD but not in nonautoimmune SWR/Bm mice. Moreover, IL-2 produced by NOD T cells at day 6 in an SMLR was at least one hundredfold reduced compared with SWR, and NOD T cells harvested from an SMLR at day 6 were functionally defective when tested for ability to induce suppression of an allogeneic MLR. However, functionally competent suppressor T cells were generated in NOD splenic leukocyte cultures in response to Con A, and IL-2 release from these was equivalent to that released by Con A-stimulated SWR splenocytes. A deficiency in cytokine release was not limited to IL-2, because peritoneal exudate cells from NOD exhibited a greatly diminished sensitivity to LPS-stimulated IL-1 release in comparison to SWR mice. IL-2 supplementation both in vitro and in vivo restored the ability of NOD T cells to respond in a SMLR, with production of cells capable of inducing suppression. Like SMLR-activated T cells from untreated SWR controls, SMLR blasts from IL-2-treated NOD mice were enriched for the L3T4 phenotype. IL-1 supplementation in vitro resulted in partial restoration of T suppressor activation in a SMLR. The depressed SMLR exhibited by NOD mice was apparently a stimulator cell dysfunction, because NOD stimulator cells failed to activate T cells from (SWR x NOD)F1 mice, whereas stimulators from SWR or F1 mice were capable of doing so. Collectively, these results suggest a defect in suppressor cell activation rather than an absence of this immunoregulatory cell population.     

An NZB virus or NZB mice with viral infections?

Evidence for and against the possibility that the autoimmune disease of NZB mice has a viral aetiology is presented. It is considered that the case for a viral aetiology is unproven, although the possibility exists that virus may be present in incomplete form. Widely varying experimental results can be expected in experiments involving NZB mice until acceptable standards of mouse strain definition are laid down. Thus the comparison of results obtained from studies of NZB mice of diverse origin may invite misleading conclusions.     

Selective improvement of thymus and some T cell dysfunctions in NZB mice by in utero thymulin treatment

NZB mice were treated during gestation with thymulin, a thymus-secreted, zinc-associated nonapeptide. Control pregnant NZB mice received either zinc alone or saline alone. Offspring from all three groups of NZB mothers, and age-matched DBA/2 mice, were tested for the following immunologic parameters: thymulin serum levels at 2 and 5 wk of age; splenic anti-sheep red blood cell (anti-SRBC) plaque-forming cell (PFC) numbers after immunization at birth or at 2 wk of age; anti-human gamma-globulin (anti-HGG) antibody titers after immunization at 2 wk of age, with or without prior tolerance induction at birth with deaggregated HGG; spontaneous IgM serum levels at 2 and 5 wk of age; spontaneous splenic anti-trinitrophenyl (anti-TNP) PFC numbers at 2 wk of age. As compared with DBA/2 mice, young NZB mice exhibited low circulating thymulin titers, high antibody responses to SRBC and to HGG, resistance to tolerance induction by deaggregated HGG, increased spontaneous IgM serum levels, and increased spontaneous anti-TNP PFC numbers. However, marked reductions in anti-SRBC and anti-HGG antibody production, both thymus-dependent responses, were observed in the young NZB offspring of thymulin-treated mothers as compared with NZB controls born from zinc- or saline-treated mothers. A delay in the postnatal decrease of serum thymulin levels was also noted in the offspring of thymulin-treated mothers. Interestingly, these effects of in utero thymulin treatment tended to become more pronounced with advancing age during the postnatal period. Conversely, IgM serum levels, spontaneous anti-TNP PFC and sensitivity to tolerance induction were not affected by thymulin treatment during fetal life. Taken together, the data suggest that in utero exposure to pharmacologic concentrations of thymulin induces a persistent and selective improvement of some thymus and T cell dysfunctions but has no effect on intrinsic B cell abnormalities of NZB mice.     

Immunological function of kidney-infiltrating lymphocytes from aged NZB mice

A striking aspect of autoimmune kidney disease in the NZB mouse strain is the perivascular infiltration of lymphoid cells. Upon release by enzymatic digestion of kidney tissue from animals 6 months of age or older, these cells have been found to exhibit a high level of immunologic activity not seen in younger mice or in nonautoimmune strains. Kidney-derived cells were found to respond to T and B cell mitogens at levels ranging up to those observed for peripheral blood, and in some cases splenic lymphocytes, from the same animals. An enhanced proliferative response to autologous and allogeneic stimulation was observed compared to these other lymphoid sources. Both spontaneous and LPS-stimulated immunoglobulin synthesis were noted with all three populations, which could be totally or partially blocked by cycloheximide. Selective localization of autoantibody-producing cell populations was observed, with anti-erythrocyte antibody restricted to splenocytes and PBL, and the anti-dsDNA implicated in immune complex formation found only in kidney-derived cell culture supernatants.     

Expansion of myeloid suppressor cells in SHIP-deficient mice represses allogeneic T cell responses

Previously we demonstrated that SHIP(-/-) mice accept allogeneic bone marrow transplants (BMT) without significant acute graft-vs-host disease (GvHD). In this study we show that SHIP(-/-) splenocytes and lymph node cells are poor stimulators of allogeneic T cell responses that cause GvHD. Intriguingly, SHIP(-/-) splenocytes prime naive T cell responses to peptide epitopes, but, conversely, are partially impaired for priming T cell responses to whole Ag. However, dendritic cells (DC) purified from SHIP(-/-) splenocytes prime T cell responses to allogeneic targets, peptide epitopes, and whole Ag as effectively as SHIP(+/+) DC. These findings point to an extrinsic effect on SHIP(-/-) DC that impairs priming of allogeneic T cell responses. Consistent with this extrinsic effect, we found that a dramatic expansion of myeloid suppressor cells in SHIP(-/-) mice impairs priming of allogeneic T cells. These findings suggest that SHIP expression or its activity could be targeted to selectively compromise T cell responses that mediate GvHD and graft rejection.     

Insulin-specific suppressor T cell factors

Murine antibody responses to heterologous insulins are controlled by MHC-linked immune response genes. Although nonresponder mice fail to make antibody when injected with nonimmunogenic variants of insulin, we have recently shown that nonimmunogenic variants stimulate radioresistant, Lyt- 1+2- helper T cells that support secondary antibody responses. However, the helper activity can not be detected unless dominant, radiosensitive Lyt-1-2+, I-J+ suppressor T cells are removed. In this paper we report that extracts of primed Lyt-2+ suppressor T cells contain insulin-specific suppressor factors (TsF) that are capable of replacing the activity of suppressor T cells in vitro. The activity of these factors is restricted by MHC-linked genes that map to the I-J region, and immunoadsorption studies indicated that they bind antigen and bear I-J-encoded determinants. Insulin-specific TsF consists of at least two chains, one-bearing I-J and the other the antigen-binding site. Furthermore, mixing of isolated chains from different strains of mice indicates that the antigenic specificity is determined by the antigen-binding chain and the MHC restriction by the H-2 haplotype of the source of the non-antigen-binding, I-J+ chain. Moreover, mixtures containing antigen-binding chain from allogeneic cell donors and I-J+ chain from responder cell donors have activity in cultures containing responder lymphocytes. This suggests that preferential activation of suppressor T cells, rather than differential sensitivity to suppression, results in the nonresponder phenotype to insulin.     

Defective suppressor cell function mediated by T8+ cell lines from patients with progressive multiple sclerosis

Activated suppressor cell function, induced with either concanavalin A or OKT3 and mediated by either unfractionated mononuclear cells or "panning" enriched T8+ cells, freshly isolated from peripheral blood, is reduced in patients with progressive multiple sclerosis (MS) as compared with control donors. In this study, we generated T8+ cell lines from the peripheral blood of these same patients and controls. Suppressor activity, mediated by T8+ cells exposed to OKT3 on days 1, 7, and 14 of culture and then treated with mitomycin C on day 16, was significantly reduced in the MS group (mean percent suppression 13% +/- 5) as compared with the control group (68% +/- 6, n = 8, p less than 0.001). No differences were noted in [3H]thymidine uptake by the OKT3-stimulated T8+ cell lines of MS and control groups. Mean percent suppression mediated by T4+ cell lines did not differ between MS and control groups (15% +/- 4, n = 3, vs 22% +/- 2, n = 4). These current data suggest that the previously observed defect in T8+ cell-mediated activated suppressor cell function in MS is a persistent one, favoring the postulate that the defect reflects intrinsic alterations in this cell population rather than a transient effect of serum factors on T8+ cell function.     

Impairment of CD8+ T suppressor cell function in patients with active systemic lupus erythematosus

Alteration of T cell suppression function has been recognized in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Recently, CD8(+) T suppressor lymphocytes (CD8(+) Ts) have been generated in vitro by incubating purified CD8(+) T cells with IL-2 and GM-CSF. Using this method, we generated CD8(+) Ts from patients affected by SLE. No major differences were found in the CD8(+) Ts phenotype between SLE patients and healthy subjects. CD8(+) Ts from SLE patients with active disease did not inhibit the anti-CD3 mAb-induced proliferation of autologous PBMC, whereas CD8(+) Ts from SLE patients in remission exerted an inhibitory activity comparable to normal subjects. The inhibitory effect of CD8(+) Ts cells was neither mediated by cytotoxic activity nor by apoptosis induction. Two cytokines, IFN-gamma and IL-6, were found to be responsible for the function of CD8(+) TS: In fact, counteraction of CD8(+) Ts suppression activity was obtained by blocking IFN-gamma with a specific Ab or by inhibiting CD8(+) Ts-mediated IL-6 secretion by an antisense oligonucleotide. Interestingly, CD8(+) Ts from SLE patients showed a peculiar cytokine pattern characterized by an impaired secretion of IL-6 and an increased secretion of IL-12. Thus, it appears that an altered balance between inhibitory (IL-6) and stimulatory (IL-12) cytokines might be responsible for the functional impairment of CD8(+) Ts in SLE patients.