Cross-linking of soluble extensin in isolated cell walls

The extensin component of primary cell walls has generally been considered to be an intrinsically insoluble cell wall glycoprotein. Recent data have established that cell wall extensin is in fact secreted in a soluble monomeric form which slowly becomes insolubilized in the cell wall probably through the oxidative formation of isodityrosine cross-links. We now show that isolated cell walls from aerated root slices of Daucus carota have the capacity to insolubilize extensin through the formation of isodityrosine. This in vitro cross-linking is specific for the extensin glycoprotein, as other wall proteins are not cross-linked by the isolated wall system. Although extensin can be cross-linked in solution by peroxidase and H₂O₂, dityrosine and not isodityrosine is the phenolic cross-link formed. Wall-catalyzed cross-linking of soluble extensin is inhibited by l-ascorbate, and both the initial rate and total extent of cross-linking are inhibited by acidic pH in the physiological range (pH 4 to 6). We suggest several mechanisms by which acid might inhibit cross-linking and propose that cytoplasmic factors (ascorbate and/or hydrogen ions) may regulate the solubility of extensin in vivo.     

Di-isodityrosine is the intermolecular cross-link of isodityrosine-rich extensin analogs cross-linked in vitro

Extensins are cell wall hydroxyproline-rich glycoproteins that form covalent networks putatively involving tyrosyl and lysyl residues in cross-links catalyzed by one or more extensin peroxidases. The precise cross-links remain to be chemically identified both as network components in muro and as enzymic products generated in vitro with native extensin monomers as substrates. However, some extensin monomers contain variations within their putative cross-linking motifs that complicate cross-link identification. Other simpler extensins are recalcitrant to isolation including the ubiquitous P3-type extensin whose major repetitive motif, Hyp)(4)-Ser-Hyp-Ser-(Hyp)(4)-Tyr-Tyr-Tyr-Lys, is of particular interest, not least because its Tyr-Tyr-Tyr intramolecular isodityrosine cross-link motifs are also putative candidates for further intermolecular cross-linking to form di-isodityrosine. Therefore, we designed a set of extensin analogs encoding tandem repeats of the P3 motif, including Tyr --> Phe and Lys --> Leu variations. Expression of these P3 analogs in Nicotiana tabacum cells yielded glycoproteins with virtually all Pro residues hydroxylated and subsequently arabinosylated and with likely galactosylated Ser residues. This was consistent with earlier analyses of P3 glycopeptides isolated from cell wall digests and the predictions of the Hyp contiguity hypothesis. The tyrosine-rich P3 analogs also contained isodityrosine, formed in vivo. Significantly, these isodityrosine-containing analogs were further cross-linked in vitro by an extensin peroxidase to form the tetra-tyrosine intermolecular cross-link amino acid di-isodityrosine. This is the first identification of an inter-molecular cross-link amino acid in an extensin module and corroborates earlier suggestions that di-isodityrosine represents one mechanism for cross-linking extensins in muro.     

Extensin—a major cell wall glycoprotein

Abstract The structure of extensin is described in detail. It has a hydroxyproline-rich backbone, which contains repeating peptides glycosylated by short side chains and it adopts a polyproline II helical conformation. The glycoprotein is synthesized intracellularly and soluble precursors are secreted to the wall, where they are bound, perhaps, by the formation of isodityrosine cross-links. The various hypotheses, including the most recent ‘warp and weft’ model, which have been suggested to explain the attachment of extensin to the other wall polymers are discussed. The possible functions of extensin in defence and in the control of extension growth are described in addition to its probable structural role. Other glycoproteins which resemble extensin are also mentioned.     

Cross-linking patterns in salt-extractable extensin from carrot cell walls

Extensins are hydroxyproline-rich glycoproteins (HRGPs) found in the primary cell walls of dicots. Extensin monomers are secreted into the wall and covalently bound to each other, presumably by isodityrosine (IDT) cross-links, to form a rigid matrix. Expression of the extensin matrix is correlated with inhibition of cell elongation during normal development and with increased resistance to virulent pathogens. We have isolated extensin from carrot root tissue (Daucus carota L.) by published techniques and have used gel filtration chromatography to purify fractions enriched in monomers and oligomers. We refer to this protein as “extensin-1” to distinguish it from “extensin-2,” a second extensin-like HRGP from carrot which we will describe later. We prepared extensin-1 for electron microscopy by shadowing it with platinum. Monomers are highly elongated (84 nanometers) and kinked at several sites. Kinks occur at all sites on molecules with nearly equal probability, but do not appear to occur at their ends. The distribution of kinks is similar to that of tyrosine-lysine-tyrosine sequences, which have been shown to be capable of forming intramolecular IDT cross-links, so we suggest that kinks are visible manifestations of intramolecular IDTs. Oligomers likely result from IDT cross-links between monomers, and may be regarded as transient precursors of the fully cross-linked matrix. Nearly 60% of cross-links involve the ends of molecules while the rest are scattered among internal sites. We discuss how the relative positions and proportions of intra- and intermolecular cross-links in extensin-1 may affect the structure, and in turn the function, of the extensin matrix.     

Peptides isolated from cell walls of Medicago truncatula nodules and uninfected root

The hydroxyproline-rich root nodules of legumes provide a microaerobic niche for symbiotic nitrogen-fixing Rhizobacteria. The contributions of the cell wall and associated structural proteins, particularly the hydroxyproline-rich glycoproteins (HRGPs), are therefore of interest. Our approach involved identification of the protein components by direct chemical analysis of the insoluble wall. Chymotryptic peptide mapping showed a "P3-type" extensin containing the highly arabinosylated Ser-Hyp4-Ser-Hyp-Ser-Hyp4-Tyr3-Lys motif as a major component. Cell wall amino acid analyses and quantitative hydroxyproline arabinoside profiles, predominantly of tri- and tetraarabinosides, confirmed this extensin as the major structural protein in the cell walls of both root nodules and uninfected roots. On the other hand, judging from the Pro, Glu and non-glycosylated Hyp content, the nodule-specific proline-rich glycoproteins, such as the early nodulins (ENOD-PRPs), are present in much lesser amounts. Although we isolated no PRP peptides from nodule cell walls, a single PRP peptide from root cell walls confirmed the presence of a PRP in roots and represented the first direct evidence for a crosslinked PRP in muro. Compared with root cell walls (approximately 7% protein dry weight) nodule cell walls contained significantly more protein (approximately 13% dry weight) with an overall amino acid and peptide composition indicating the presence of structural protein unrelated to the HRGPs.     

Antibody localization of extensin in cell walls of carrot storage roots

The accumulation and cross-linking of hydroxyproline-rich glycoproteins (HRGPs) in cell walls of dicotyledonous plants has been correlated with a number of wall-strengthening phenomena. Polyclonal antibodies raised against glycosylated extensin-1, the most abundant HRGP in carrot (Daucus carota L.) cell walls, recognize this antigen on gel and dot blots and on thin sections of epoxy-embedded carrot-root cell walls. Since wall labeling can be largely reduced by preincubating the antibodies with purified extensin-1, most labeling can be attributed to recognition of this antigen. The remaining label may be the result of recognition of extensin-2, a second carrot HRGP, or other wall components (cellulose, hemicellulose and pectin are not recognized). Extensin-1 label was distributed quite uniformly across the cell wall but was absent from the expanded middle lamella at the intersection of three or more cells and was reduced in the narrow middle lamella between two cells. This distribution is essentially the same as that of cellulose. Because of limitations of this labeling technique, it is not possible to construct a complete model of the structure of the cross-linked extensin matrix. Nonetheless, short, linear arrays of gold particles may represent small portions of the extensin matrix or of individual extensin molecules as they are exposed on the surface of sections. These and other results presented here indicate that: a) newly synthesized extensin is added to the wall by intussusception; b) extensin cannot cross the middle lamella separating the walls of adjacent cells; and c) incorporation of extensin is a late event in the development of phloem-parenchyma cell walls in carrot.Abbreviations dE-1 antibodies antibodies raised against deglycosylated extensin 1 - ELISA enzyme-linked immunosorbant assay - gE-1 antibodies antibodies raised against glycosylated extensin 1 - HRGP hydroxyproline-rich glycoprotein - PAGE polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis - RG-1 rhamnogalacturonan I - SDS sodium dodecyl sulfate     

A second extensin-like hydroxyproline-rich glycoprotein from carrot cell walls

The insoluble extensin matrix of dicot cell walls has been studied most fruitfully by examining the salt-extractable precursors to this matrix. Multiple extensin-like hydroxyproline-rich glycoproteins (HRGPs) have been isolated, or their existence inferred, from tomato, potato, bean, soybean, melon, carrot, and other plants. We and others previously have studied a carrot extensin which we call extensin-1. Here we report on the properties of extensin-2, a second salt-extractable hydroxyproline-rich glycoprotein from carrot. Like extensin-1, extensin-2 contains large amounts of hydroxyproline, serine, histidine, and lysine. In contrast, its tyrosine content is only about one-third that of extensin-1. Arabinose and galactose are the most abundant neutral sugars in both proteins, and nearly identical buoyant densities in CsCl suggest a similar proportion of carbohydrate in each. The size of extensin-2 is about half the size of extensin-1 based on: (a) the measured lengths of shadowed molecules (about 40 versus 84 nanometers); (b) the migration of extensin-2 in acid-urea gels relative to monomers, dimers, and trimers of extensin-1; and (c) the Stokes' radii of these molecules as determined by gel filtration chromatography. Electron microscopy of shadowed extensin-2 molecules indicates that they contain kinks, which may indicate the presence of intramolecular isodityrosine cross-links, but intermolecular cross-links, either with other extensin-2 molecules or extensin-1 molecules, are observed rarely if ever.     

Isodityrosine cross-linking mediates insolubilization of cell walls in Chlamydomonas.

Enzymatic removal of the cell wall induces vegetative Chlamydomonas reinhardtii cells to transcribe wall genes and synthesize new hydroxyproline-rich glycoproteins (HRGPs) related to the extensins found in higher plant cell walls. A cDNA expression library made from such induced cells was screened with antibodies to an oligopeptide containing the (SP)x repetitive domains found in Chlamydomonas wall proteins. One of the selected cDNAs encodes an (SP)x-rich polypeptide that also displays a repeated YGG motif. Ascorbate, a peroxidase inhibitor, and tyrosine derivatives were shown to inhibit insolubilization of both the vegetative and zygotic cell walls of Chlamydomonas, suggesting that oxidative cross-linking of tyrosines is occurring. Moreover, insolubilization of both walls was concomitant with a burst in H2O2 production and in extracellular peroxidase activity. Finally, both isodityrosine and dityrosine were found in hydrolysates of the insolubilized vegetative wall layer. We propose that the formation of tyrosine cross-links is essential to Chlamydomonas HRGP insolubilization.     

A novel wound-inducible extensin gene is expressed early in newly isolated protoplasts of Nicotiana sylvestris

A cDNA clone (6PExt 1.2) encoding a novel extensin was isolated from a cDNA library made from 6 h old mesophyll protoplasts of Nicotiana sylvestris. The screening was performed with a heterologous probe from carrot. The encoded polypeptide showed features characteristic of hydroxyproline-rich glycoproteins such as Ser-(Pro)₄ repeats and a high content in Tyr and Lys residues. The presence of four Tyr-X-Tyr-Lys motifs suggests the possibility for intramolecular isodityrosine cross-links whereas three Val-Tyr-Lys motifs may participate in intermolecular cross-links. The analysis of genomic DNA gel blots using both the N. sylvestris and the carrot clones as probes showed that the 6PExt 1.2 gene belongs to a complex multigene family encoding extensin and extensin-related polypeptides in N. sylvestris as well as in related Nicotianeae including a laboratory hybrid. This was confirmed by the analysis of RNA gel blots: a set of mRNAs ranging in size from 0.3 kb to 3.5 kb was found by the carrot extensin probe. The 6PExt 1.2 probe found a 1.2 kb mRNA in protoplasts and in wounded tissues as well as a 0.9 kb mRNA which seemed to be stem-specific. The gene encoding 6PExt 1.2 was induced by wounding in protoplasts, in leaf strips and after Agrobacterium tumefaciens infection of stems.     

Purification and Partial Characterization of Tomato Extensin Peroxidase

Early plant defense response is characterized by elevation of activity of peroxidases and enhanced insolubilization of hydroxyproline-rich glycoproteins, such as extensin, in the cell wall. The insolubilization process (cross-linking between soluble extensin precursor molecules) is catalyzed by extensin peroxidases. We have ionically eluted extensin peroxidases from intact water-washed suspension-cultured tomato (hybrid of Lycopersicon esculentum Mill. and Lycopersicon peruvianum L. [Mill.]) cells and purified them to homogeneity by molecular sieve and cation-exchange chromatography. Four ionic forms of peroxidase (PI,PII,EPIII, and EPIV) were resolved; only the latter two cross-linked tomato soluble extensin. The molecular weight (34,000-37,000), amino acid composition, and isoelectric point (9.0) of the extensin peroxidases were determined. Substrate specificities of the enzymes were investigated: soluble extensin and potato lectin (a hydroxyproline-rich glycoprotein with a domain that strongly resembles extensin) were cross-linked by only two forms of the enzyme, whereas bovine serum albumin, aldolase, insulin, a number of other marker proteins, and proteins eluted from tomato cells (except extensin) could not be cross-linked. We have also isolated a yeast elicitor that enhances total peroxidase activity and extensin insolubilization within 1 h of challenge in cultured cells of tomato. A highly sensitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay technique using polyclonal antiserum raised against soluble tomato extensin was used to demonstrate extensin insolubilization in vivo. A tomato cell-wall peroxidase that cross-links extensin has been purified and may have a role in plant defense.     

Glycoproteins from the cell wall of Phaseolus coccineus.

1. The use of a modified sodium chlorite/acetic acid delignification procedure for the solubilization of a hydroxyproline-rich glycoprotein fraction from the depectinated cell walls of Phaseolus coccineus is described. 2. The crude glycoprotein was associated with some pectic material; hydroxyproline and serine were the most abundant amino acids, and arabinose, galactose and galacturonic acid the predominant monosaccharides. 3. The bulk of the hydroxyproline is O-glycosidically substituted with tetra- and tri-arabinofuranosides. From methylation analysis the linkages in these arabinosides could be inferred. 4. Ion-exchange chromatography of the crude glycoprotein gave one major and two minor hydroxyproline-rich fractions, with similar amino acid but different monosaccharide composition. 5. In the major fraction, serine appears to be O-glycosidically substituted with a single galactopyranoside residue that can be removed by the action of alpha-galactosidase but not beta-galactosidase. Removal of arabinofuranoside residues by partial acid hydrolysis greatly enhanced the action of alpha-galactosidase. 6. Methylation followed by carboxy reduction with LiAl2H4 has shown the presence of (1 leads to 4)-linked galacturonic acid in the crude glycoprotein fraction but not in the major fraction from the ion-exchange column. Hence the bulk of the pectic material is not associated with the major glycoprotein component. It is suggested that the glycoprotein is held in the wall by phenolic cross-links. 7. Similarities with the glycopeptide moiety of potato lectin provides further evidence for a class of hydroxyproline-rich glycoproteins with common features.     

Isodityrosine, a new cross-linking amino acid from plant cell-wall glycoprotein.

1. Cell-wall hydrolysates from calli of all higher plants tested contained a new phenolic amino acid for which the trivial name isodityrosine is proposed. Isodityrosine was shown to be an oxidatively coupled dimer of tyrosine with the two tyrosine units linked by a diphenyl ether bridge. 2. The amount of isodityrosine in sodium dodecyl sulphate-insoluble cell-wall preparations was proportional to the amount of hydroxyproline. 3. Acidified chlorite split the diphenyl ether bridge of isodityrosine, and concomitantly solubilized the cell-wall glycoprotein. 4. Dithiothreitol inhibited isodityrosine synthesis in vivo, and suppressed in parallel the covalent binding of newly synthesized protein in the cell wall. 5. It is suggested that isodityrosine is an inter-polypeptide cross-link responsible for the insolubility of plant cell-wall glycoprotein.     

Extensin,an underestimated key component of cell wall defence?

BackgroundExtensins are plant cell wall hydroxyproline-rich glycoproteins known to be involved in cell wall reinforcement in higher plants, and in defence against pathogen attacks. The ability of extensins to form intra- and intermolecular cross-links is directly related to their role in cell wall reinforcement. Formation of such cross-links requires appropriate glycosylation and structural conformation of the glycoprotein.ScopeAlthough the role of cell wall components in plant defence has drawn increasing interest over recent years, relatively little focus has been dedicated to extensins. Nevertheless, new insights were recently provided regarding the structure and the role of extensins and their glycosylation in plant–microbe interactions, stimulating an interesting debate from fellow cell wall community experts. We have previously revealed a distinct distribution of extensin epitopes in Arabidopsis thaliana wild-type roots and in mutants impaired in extensin arabinosylation, in response to elicitation with flagellin 22. That study was recently debated in a Commentary by Tan and Mort (Tan L, Mort A. 2020. Extensins at the front line of plant defence. A commentary on: ‘Extensin arabinosylation is involved in root response to elicitors and limits oomycete colonization’. Annals of Botany 125: vii–viii) and several points regarding our results were discussed. As a response, we herein clarify the points raised by Tan and Mort, and update the possible epitope structure recognized by the anti-extensin monoclonal antibodies. We also provide additional data showing differential distribution of LM1 extensin epitopes in roots between a mutant defective in PEROXIDASES 33 and 34 and the wild type, similarly to previous observations from the rra2 mutant defective in extensin arabinosylation. We propose these two peroxidases as potential candidates to specifically catalyse the cross-linking of extensins within the cell wall.ConclusionsExtensins play a major role within the cell wall to ensure root protection. The cross-linking of extensins, which requires correct glycosylation and specific peroxidases, is most likely to result in modulation of cell wall architecture that allows enhanced protection of root cells against invading pathogens. Study of the relationship between extensin glycosylation and their cross-linking is a very promising approach to further understand how the cell wall influences root immunity.     

Characterization of a tobacco extensin gene and regulation of its gene family in healthy plants and under various stress conditions

A genomic clone (Ext 1.4) encoding an extensin was isolated from a Nicotiana tabacum genomic library. The encoded polypeptide showed features characteristic of extensins such as Ser-(Pro)4 repeats and a high content in Tyr and Lys residues. The presence of one Tyr-Leu-Tyr-Lys motif suggests the possibility for one intramolecular isodityrosine cross-link whereas numerous Val-Tyr-Lys motifs may participate in intermolecular cross-links. This extensin appears to be close to an extensin already characterized in N. tabacum but very different from the Ext 1.2 extensin of N. sylvestris. The analysis of genomic DNA gel blots using probes spanning different parts of the gene showed that the Ext 1.4 gene belongs to a complex multigene family having one member originating from N. sylvestris and three members from N. tomentosiformis. The Ext 1.4 specific probe found a 1.4 kb mRNA in stems, roots, ovaries and germinating seeds of healthy plants. The Ext 1.4 gene family is strongly induced in actively dividing cell suspension cultures and after wounding of leaves or stems in conditions where root formation occurs. On the contrary, it is not induced in leaves in response to a hyperensitive reaction to a viral infection or after elicitor treatment.     

Formation of Isodityrosine by Peroxidase Isozymes

Fry, S. C. 1987. Formation of isodityrosine by peroxidase isozymes.—J.exp. Bot. 38: 853–862. Tyrosine residues of extensin are oxidatively coupled in vivoto form isodityrosine bridges, whereas treatment of purifiedextensin with H₂O₂+ peroxidase in vitro yields only dityrosine.Two explanations for the correct mode of coupling in vivo weretested. The first, that the pH of the cell wall is lower thanthat (pH 9-0) at which in vitro experiments have been conducted,provided part of the answer since treatment of L-tyrosine withH₂O₂+peroxidase in vitro at pH 37–5 yielded some isodityrosine.The second, that the wall contains other isozymes of peroxidasethan the basic isozyme usually studied in vitro, appeared unlikelybecause several sharply contrasting isozymes yielded similarisodityrosine: dityrosine ratios from L-tyrosine+ H₂O₂ at anygiven pH. The isozymes were also similar in their ability tooxidize tyrosine-dimers further to higher polymers. It is concludedthat the formation of isodityrosine in vivo is dictated by neighbouringwall molecules, possibly ionically-bound pectins, which modifythe local environment of the tyrosine residues of extensin. Key words: Isodityrosine, peroxidase isozymes, extensin     

Isolation of an enzyme system which will catalyze the glycosylation of extensin

Enzymes which catalyze the glycosylation of the cell wall protein extensin using uridine diphosphate l-arabinose-¹⁴C as a substrate are present in a crude extract prepared from suspension cultured sycamore cells (Acer pseudoplatanus L.). This enzyme system sediments when the crude extract is subjected to centrifugation at 37000g. A base hydrolysate of the product contains a mixture of hydroxyproline-arabinosides which are electrophoretically and chromatographically identical to those obtained by hydrolysis of extensin isolated from the cell wall. The hydroxyproline-rich protein used as an acceptor in the glycosylation reactions is present in the particulate fraction. In addition, evidence is presented which indicates that hydroxyproline-rich tryptic peptides prepared from the cell wall can also be used as an acceptor by this enzyme system. The presence of Mg²⁺ or Mn²⁺ in the reaction mixture increases the enzyme-catalyzed incorporation of arabinose into extensin by about 1.4 times. About two-thirds of the product mixture is composed of arabinose-containing compounds which have not been identified. Some of these products appear to be hydroxyproline-glycosides which have not been previously reported.     

A developmentally regulated hydroxyproline-rich glycoprotein in maize pericarp cell walls

We have studied the accumulation of peptidyl hydroxyproline in the pericarp of developing maize (Zea mays L., Golden cross Bantam sweet corn) kernels. Although this hydroxyproline accumulates throughout development, it is most soluble and its content per milligram dry weight greatest at midmaturation stages of development. Salt-soluble proteins containing this hydroxyproline from isolated cell walls of developing kernels were fractionated on a CsCl density gradient and on a Chromatofocusing column, resulting in the purification of an hydroxyproline-rich glycoprotein, PC-1. PC-1 is a basic protein of approximately 65 to 70 kilodaltons in molecular weight with an isoelectric point of at least 10.2 and a density of 1.38 to 1.39 in CsCl. Amino acid composition data indicate that it is rich in hydroxyproline, threonine, proline, lysine, and glycine. Its relation to dicot extensin is discussed.     

An epitope of rice threonine- and hydroxyproline-rich glycoprotein is common to cell wall and hydrophobic plasma-membrane glycoproteins

A monoclonal antibody, LM1, has been derived that has a high affinity for an epitope of hydroxyproline-rich glycoproteins (HRGPs). In suspension-cultured rice (Oryza sativa L.) cells the epitope is carried by three major proteins with different biochemical properties. The most abundant is the 95-kDa extracellular rice extensin, a threonine- and hydroxyproline-rich glycoprotein (THRGP) occurring in the cell wall and secreted into the medium. This THRGP can be selectively oxidatively cross-linked in the presence of hydrogen peroxide and an endogenous peroxidase with the result that it does not enter a protein gel. A second polypeptide with the LM1 epitope (180 kDa), also occurring in the suspension-cultured cells and medium, is not oxidatively cross-linked. Three further polypeptides (52, 65 and 110 kDa) with the characteristics of hydrophobic proteins of the plasma-membrane also carry the LM1 epitope as determined by immuno-blotting of detergent/aqueous partitions of a plasma-membrane preparation and immuno-fluorescence studies with rice protoplasts. At the rice root apex the LM1 epitope is carried by four glycoproteins and is developmentally regulated. The major locations of the epitope are at the surface of cells associated with the developing protoxylem and metaxylem in the stele, the longitudinal radial walls of epidermal cells and a sheath-like structure at the surface of the root apex.Abbreviations AGP arabinogalactan protein - ELISA enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay - HRGP hydroxyproline-rich glycoprotein - THRGP threonine- and hydroxyproline-rich glycoprotein This work was supported by The Leverhulme Trust. We also acknowledge support from The Royal Society and thank Prof. L.A. Staehelin for the carrot extensin, N. Stacey for the rice cell culture and Dr. J. Keen for protein sequencing.