Calcium-regulated photoproteins of marine coelenterates

Ca(2+)-regulated photoproteins are bioluminescent proteins responsible for bioluminescence of marine coelenterates. The photoprotein molecule is a stable enzyme-substrate complex consisting of a single polypeptide chain and an oxygen "pre-activated" substrate, 2-hydroperoxycoelenterazine, which is tightly but non-covalently bound with a protein. The bioluminescence is triggered by calcium ions and originates from an oxidative decarboxylation of a protein bound substrate. The review provides current data on the photoproteins structure, the mechanism of bioluminescent reaction, the function of some amino acid residues of an active site in the catalysis and the formation of the emitter, as well as on applications of these proteins in a bioluminescent analysis.     

Semi-synthetic aequorins with improved sensitivity to Ca2+ ions.

Thirty-seven coelenterazine analogues were synthesized and incorporated into apo-aequorin, yielding 30 semi-synthetic aequorins that have the capacity to emit a significant amount of light in the presence of Ca2+. The properties of resultant photoproteins were investigated. The most prominent feature of those photoproteins was the wide range in their sensitivities to Ca2+ concentration. The relative intensity of Ca2+-triggered luminescence of the photoproteins ranged from 0.01 to 190 when compared with natural aequorin (relative intensity 1.0) at pCa 6 for the cases where the relative intensity is less than 1 and at pCa 7 for the cases where the relative intensity is higher than 1. Eight of the semi-synthetic aequorins belonged to the class of e-aequorin. With two of those photoproteins, the degree of dependence of the luminescence intensity ratio I400/I465 on pCa was greater than that with e-aequorin, suggesting that these two photoproteins are possibly superior to e-aequorin in measuring Ca2+ concentration by the ratio method.     

Comparative aspects of the calcium-sensitive photoproteins aequorin and obelin.

1. The calcium-dependency of the process of light emission has been investigated for the photoproteins aequorin and obelin. 2. The experimental curves of light production, expressed as a percentage of the maximal rate of utilisation, versus pCa are accurately predicted by the cooperative action of at least 2Ca-2+ for aequorin and at least 3Ca-2+ for obelin. 3. At low total monovalent cation concentrations, a pH change from 6.8 to 7.1 shifts the light production vs pCa curve by approx. 0.2 pCa units to the right for aequorin, while that for obelin is shifted by some 0.37 pCa units. 4. Other monovalent cations, such as Na+ are able to compete with Ca-2+ for the active sites of aequorin and also shift the light production vs pCa curve to the right. There is no apparent change in the calcium stoichiometry for light production under these conditions. 5. The same calcium stoichiometry for light emission was also obtained for aequorin or obelin in the presence of either unbuffered Ca-2+ solutions or of calcium/EGTA buffers.     

Regulation of 22Na+ transport by calcium in an established kidney epithelial cell line.

The role of calcium in regulating the Na+ channel in an established kidney epithelial cell line has been examined. Extracellular calcium was inhibitory to Na+ uptake, and a Dixon plot of the initial Na+ uptake rate in the presence of Ca2+ was nonlinear, suggesting a mixed pattern of inhibition. Similar patterns of inhibition were also observed for other divalent cations, including Ba2+, Mg2+, and Mn2+. In contrast elevated concentrations of intracellular calcium resulted in a stimulation of Na+ entry. This intracellular effect was specific to calcium, with Mg2+ and Mn2+ appearing much less effective. Lineweaver-Burk plots of Na+ influx in calcium-loaded and unloaded cells were linear, suggesting that under both conditions a single system transported Na+. Although Na+ entry was stimulated by intracellular Ca2+, the cells did not exhibit other counter transport phenomena reported with cell types in which a Na+/Ca2+ exchange system is operative. Thus, the results indicate that calcium acts as an allosteric regulator of Na+ transport by the Na+ channel.     

The role of calcium in the initiation of superoxide release from alveolar macrophages

The role of calcium in the release of superoxide anion (O2-) was examined in alveolar macrophages after stimulation with the soluble stimuli: concanavalin A (Con A), N-formyl methionyl phenylalanine (FMP), and the calcium ionophore. A23187. The release of O2- by Con A was unaffected over a wide range of extracellular calcium concentrations (20 microM to 3 mM), whereas increasing the extracellular calcium above 2 mM inhibited FMP-stimulated O2- release. In contrast, A23187 did not stimulate O2- release in calcium-free medium (less than or equal to 30 microM). The addition of EGTA (50 microM) to calcium-free medium had no effect on Con A stimulation of O2- release or FMP-stimulated O2- release. These results suggest that, for the three soluble stimuli, there are different roles for Ca+2 in the activation and transmission of stimulatory signals across the cell membrane. Con A- or FMP-stimulated calcium efflux from calcium-loaded cells in either calcium-free medium or 0.5 mM calcium-containing medium. In calcium-free medium, FMP transiently retarded 45Ca+2 uptake, while in 0.5 mM calcium-containing medium, FMP transiently stimulated 45Ca+2 uptake. For either Con A or FMP, calcium efflux preceded O2- release by 30-45 sec. Quinine, an agent that blocks membrane hyperpolarization in macrophages, completely blocked O2- release by concanavalin A or FMP and inhibited 45CA+2 efflux by 50% or more for both agents. These results support the hypothesis that redistribution of cellular Ca+2 is one of the initial steps leading to the release of O2-.     

Calcium-regulated photoproteins of marine coelenterates

Calcium-regulated photoproteins are bioluminescent proteins that are responsible for the luminescence of marine coelenterates. A photoprotein molecule is a stable enzyme-substrate complex consisting of a single polypeptide chain and an oxygen-preactivated substrate, 2-hydroperoxycoelenterazine, which is tightly but noncovalently bound with the protein. Bioluminescence is triggered by Ca²⁺ and results from decarboxylation of the substrate bound with the protein. This review considers the current information about the structure of photoproteins, the mechanism of the bioluminescent reaction, the function of particular amino acid residues of the active center in catalysis and the formation of the emitter, and the use of photoproteins in bioluminescent microanalysis.     

The light-sensitive photoprotein berovin from the bioluminescent ctenophore Beroe abyssicola: a novel type of Ca(2+) -regulated photoprotein

Light-sensitive Ca(2+) -regulated photoproteins are responsible for the bright bioluminescence of ctenophores. Using functional screening, four full-size cDNA genes encoding the same 208-amino-acid polypeptide were isolated from two independent cDNA libraries prepared from two Beroe abyssicola specimens. Sequence analysis revealed three canonical EF-hand calcium-binding sites characteristic of Ca(2+) -regulated photoproteins, but a very low degree of sequence identity (27-29%) with aequorin-type photoproteins, despite functional similarities. Recombinant berovin was expressed in Escherichia coli cells, purified, converted to active photoprotein and characterized. Active berovin has absorption maxima at 280 and 437 nm. The Ca(2+) -discharged protein loses visible absorption, but exhibits a new absorption maximum at 335 nm. The berovin bioluminescence is blue (λ(max) = 491 nm) and a change in pH over the range 6.0-9.5 has no significant effect on the light emission spectrum. By contrast, the fluorescence of Ca(2+) -discharged protein (λ(ex) = 350 nm) is pH sensitive: at neutral pH the maximum is at 420 nm and at alkaline pH there are two maxima at 410 and 485 nm. Like native ctenophore photoproteins, recombinant berovin is also inactivated by light. The Ca(2+) concentration-effect curve is a sigmoid with a slope on a log-log plot of ～ 2.5. Although this curve for berovin is very similar to those obtained for obelin and aequorin, there are evident distinctions: berovin responds to calcium changes at lower concentrations than jellyfish photoproteins and its Ca(2+) -independent luminescence is low. Recombinant berovin was successfully expressed in mammalian cells, thereby demonstrating potential for monitoring intracellular calcium. Database The nucleotide sequences have been deposited in the GenBankTM/EBI Data Bank with accession numbers: apoberovin cDNA genes, JN673813 (BA1), JN673814 (BA2), JN673815 (BA3), JN673816 (BA4); fragment 18S rRNA, JN673817 (BA-rRNA5).     

Apo calmodulin binding to the L-type voltage-gated calcium channel Cav1.2 IQ peptide

The influx of calcium through the L-type voltage-gated calcium channels (LTCCs) is the trigger for the process of calcium-induced calcium release (CICR) from the sarcoplasmic reticulum, an essential step for cardiac contraction. There are two feedback mechanisms that regulate LTCC activity: calcium-dependent inactivation (CDI) and calcium-dependent facilitation (CDF), both of which are mediated by calmodulin (CaM) binding. The IQ domain (aa 1645-1668) housed within the cytoplasmic domain of the LTCC Cav1.2 subunit has been shown to bind both calcium-loaded (Ca2+CaM ) and calcium-free CaM (apoCaM). Here, we provide new data for the structural basis for the interaction of apoCaM with the IQ peptide using NMR, revealing that the apoCaM C-lobe residues are most significantly perturbed upon complex formation. In addition, we have employed transmission electron microscopy of purified LTCC complexes which shows that both apoCaM and Ca2+CaM can bind to the intact channel.     

Coelenterate photoproteins as indicators of cytoplasmic free Ca2+ in small cells

The Ca2+-activated photoproteins aequorin and obelin are capable of detecting rapid changes in free Ca2+ over the range 10nM-100uM. Whilst they have been used to quantify free Ca transients in giant cells for some time, their use in small mammalian cells has been restricted because of the difficulty of incorporating them into live cells without impairment of cell function. We have developed three methods for incorporating photoproteins into small cells (a) reversible cell swelling (b) membrane fusion and (c) intracellular release from pinocytotic vesicles. Formation of the membrane attack complex of complement (C5b6789), via a specific cell surface antibody to activate complement, causes a rapid increase in cytoplasmic Ca2+ detectable within 5-10 s. It provides a specific method for quantifying cytoplasmic photoprotein. As a result new insights into the role of intracellular Ca2+ in cell physiology and pathology have been established.     

The time-course of Ca2+ exchange with calmodulin, troponin, parvalbumin, and myosin in response to transient increases in Ca2+.

We have modeled the time-course of Ca2+ binding to calmodulin, troponin, parvalbumin, and myosin in response to trains of transient increases in the free myoplasmic calcium ion concentration (pCa). A simple mathematical expression was used to describe each pCa transient, the shape and duration of which is qualitatively similar to those thought to occur in vivo. These calculations assumed that all individual metal binding sites are noninteracting and that Ca2+ bind competitively to the Ca2+-Mg2+ sites of troponin, parvalbumin, and myosin. All the on-and-off rate constants for both Ca2+ and Mg2+ were obtained either from the literature or from our own research. The percent saturation of the Ca2+-Mg2+ sites with Ca2+ was found to change very little in response to each pCa transient in the presence of 2.5 X 10(-3)M Mg2+. Our analysis suggests that the Ca2+ content of these sites is a measure of the intensity and frequency of recent muscle activity because large changes in the Ca2+ occupancy of these sites can occur with repeated stimulation. In contrast, large rapid changes in the amount of Ca2+ bound to the Ca2+-specific sites of troponin and calmodulin are induced by each pCa transient. Thus, only sites of the "Ca2+-specific" type can act as rapid Ca2+-regulatory sites in muscle. Fluctuation in the total amount of Ca2+ bound to these sites in response to various types of pCa transients further suggests that in vivo only about one-half to one-third of the total steady-state myofibrillar Ca2+-binding capacity exchanges Ca2+ during any single transient.     

Evidence of a calcium-induced structural change in the ATP-binding site of the sarcoplasmic-reticulum Ca2+-ATPase using terbium formycin triphosphate as an analogue of Mg-ATP

Terbium ions and terbium formycin triphosphate have been used to investigate the interactions between the cation and nucleotide binding sites of the sarcoplasmic reticulum Ca2+-ATPase. Three classes of Tb3+-binding sites have been found: a first class of low-affinity (Kd = 10 microM) corresponds to magnesium binding sites, located near a tryptophan residue of the protein; a second class of much higher affinity (less than 0.1 microM) corresponds to the calcium transport sites, their occupancy by terbium induces the E1 to E2 conformational change of the Ca2+-ATPase; a third class of sites is revealed by following the fluorescence transfer from formycin triphosphate (FTP) to terbium, evidencing that terbium ions can also bind into the nucleotide binding site at the same time as FTP. Substitution of H2O by D2O shows that Tb-FTP binding to the enzyme nucleotide site is associated with an important dehydration of the terbium ions associated with FTP. Two terbium ions, at least, bind to the Ca2+-ATPase in the close vicinity of FTP when this nucleotide is bound to the ATPase nucleotide site. Addition of calcium quenches the fluorescence signal of the terbium-FTP complex bound to the enzyme. Calcium concentration dependence shows that this effect is associated with the replacement of terbium by calcium in the transport sites, inducing the E2----E1 transconformation when calcium is bound. One interpretation of this fluorescence quenching is that the E1----E2 transition induces an important structural change in the nucleotide site. Another interpretation is that the high-affinity calcium sites are located very close to the Tb-FTP complex bound to the nucleotide site.     

Crystal structure of a Ca2+-discharged photoprotein: implications for mechanisms of the calcium trigger and bioluminescence

Ca2+-regulated photoproteins are members of the EF-hand calcium-binding protein family. The addition of Ca2+ produces a blue bioluminescence by triggering a decarboxylation reaction of protein-bound hydroperoxycoelenterazine to form the product, coelenteramide, in an excited state. Based on the spatial structures of aequorin and several obelins, we have postulated mechanisms for the Ca2+ trigger and for generation of the different excited states that are the origin of the different colors of bioluminescence. Here we report the crystal structure of the Ca2+-discharged photoprotein obelin at 1.96-A resolution. The results lend support to the proposed mechanisms and provide new structural insight into details of these processes. Global conformational changes caused by Ca2+ association are typical of the class of calcium signal modulators within the EF-hand protein superfamily. Accommodation of the Ca2+ ions into the loops of the EF-hands is seen to propagate into the active site of the protein now occupied by the coelenteramide where there is a significant repositioning and flipping of the His-175 imidazole ring as crucially required in the trigger hypothesis. Also the H-bonding between His-22 and the coelenterazine found in the active photoprotein is preserved at the equivalent position of coelenteramide, confirming the proposed rapid excited state proton transfer that would lead to the excited state of the phenolate ion pair, which is responsible for the blue emission of bioluminescence.     

Sequential mechanism of calcium binding and translocation in sarcoplasmic reticulum adenosine triphosphatase

Cooperative calcium binding (apparent Kd = 1.04 X 10(-6) M) to the ATPase of sarcoplasmic reticulum vesicles occurs with a maximal stoichiometry of 2 mols of divalent cation/mol of enzyme in the absence of ATP. The bound calcium is distributed into two pools which undergo fast or slow isotopic exchange, respectively. The two pools retain a 1:1 molar ratio under various conditions and are both located within a protein crevice, as suggested by their cooperative interaction and exchange kinetics. Following enzyme phosphorylation by ATP, both pools of bound calcium are "internalized" (cannot be displaced by quench reagents). If following 45Ca2+ binding, isotopic dilution is obtained in the medium by adding 40Ca2+ with ATP, internalization of both pools of bound 45Ca2+ (2 mol/mol of phosphoenzyme) is still observed within the first enzyme cycle. When the cycle is reversed by addition of excess ADP soon after ATP, only half of the internalized 45Ca2+ is released from the enzyme into the medium outside the vesicles, while the other half remains with the vesicles. If half of the bound 45Ca2+ is exchanged (fast exchange) with 40Ca2+ previous to the addition of ATP, none of the remaining 45Ca2+ is released outside the vesicles upon reversal of the enzyme cycle. Therefore, the pool of bound calcium which undergoes slower exchange with the outside medium, is the first to be released inside the vesicles upon enzyme phosphorylation. A sequential mechanism of calcium binding and translocation is proposed, that accounts for binding cooperativity and exchange kinetics, presteady state transients following addition of ATP, and the Ca2+ concentration dependence of ATPase activity in steady state.     

Dynamic and structural properties of the calcium binding site of bovine serine proteases and their zymogens. A multinuclear nuclear magnetic resonance and stopped-flow study

The combined use of 43Ca and 113Cd nuclear magnetic resonance (n.m.r.) has provided information on the structural and dynamic properties of the calcium binding site located in homologous positions in bovine beta-trypsin, alpha-chymotrypsin and their zymogens. The 43Ca and 113Cd n.m.r. chemical shifts are consistent with an octahedral symmetry of the binding site and with the substitution of one of the two carboxylate ligands present in trypsin(ogen) with a neutral ligand in chymotrypsin(ogen). The constancy of the 113Cd n.m.r. chemical shifts upon binding of the pancreatic trypsin inhibitor and/or the dipeptide Ile-Val to trypsinogen confirms that structural changes in the activation domain do not affect the calcium binding site. The exchange between bound and "free" (solvated) Ca2+ is slow on the 43Ca n.m.r. time-scale for trypsin(ogen), but falls in the intermediate exchange region for chymotrypsin(ogen). In trypsin, the Ca2+ off-rate was measured by stopped-flow making use of the calcium indicator 1,2-bis(o-aminophenoxy)-ethane-N,N,N',N'-tetraacetic acid and was found to be 3(+/- 1) s-1. In chymotrypsin(ogen) the off-rates calculated from the 43Ca n.m.r. data are 70 s-1 and 350 s-1, respectively. The dynamic properties of the calcium binding site of serine (pro)enzymes have been related to the flexibility of the binding site itself and have been compared to those of other extracellular and intracellular calcium binding proteins.     

Ca2+ binding to calbindin D9k strongly affects backbone dynamics: measurements of exchange rates of individual amide protons using 1H NMR

One- and two-dimensional 1H NMR have been used to study the backbone dynamics in Ca2(+)-free (apo) and Ca2(+)-loaded (Ca2) calbindin D9k at pH 7.5 and 25 degrees C. Hydrogen exchange rates of all 71 backbone amide protons (NH's) have been measured for the Ca2 form by both a direct exchange-out experiment and another experiment that measures the transfer of saturation from water protons to amide protons. A large number of NH's are found to be highly protected against exchange with solvent protons. The results for the Ca2 form are related to solvent accessibility and hydrogen bonding obtained in molecular dynamics simulations of calcium-loaded calbindin. The correlation with these parameters is strong within the N-terminal half of calbindin, which is found to be more stable than the C-terminal half. The amide proton exchange in the apo form is much faster than in the Ca2 form and was studied in a series of experiments in which the exchange was quenched after different times by Ca2+ addition. This experiment is applicable to all amide hydrogens that exchange slowly in the Ca2 form. For these NH's the effects of Ca2+ removal span from a 10(2)-fold decrease to a 10(5)-fold increase of the exchange rate, and the average is a 220-fold increase. The effects on individual NH exchange rates show that the four alpha-helices are almost intact after calcium removal and that the changes in dynamics involve not only the Ca2(+)-binding region. Hydrogen bonds involving backbone NH's in the Ca2+ loops appear to be broken or weakened when calbindin releases Ca2+, whereas the beta-sheet between the Ca2+ loops is found to be present in both the Ca2 and apo forms. Large Ca2(+)-induced effects on NH exchange rates were measured for a few residues at alpha-helix ends far from the two Ca2(+)-binding sites. This may be the result of a change in interhelix angles (or the rate of interhelix angle fluctuations) on calcium binding.     

Tightly bound calcium of adenosine triphosphatase in sarcoplasmic reticulum from rabbit skeletal muscle

Sarcoplasmic reticulum vesicles were shown to possess a class of tightly bound calcium ions, inaccessible to the chelator, ethylene glycol bis(beta-aminoethyl ether) N,N,N',N'-tetraacetic acid at 0 degrees C or 25 degrees C, amounting to 4.5 nmol/mg of protein (approximately 0.5 mol/mol (Ca2+,Mg2+)-ATPase). The calcium ionophores, A23187 and X537A, induced rapid exchange of tightly bound calcium in the presence of chelator. Chelator alone at 37 degrees C, caused irreversible loss of bound calcium, which correlated with uncoupling of transport from (Ca2+,Mg2+)-ATPase activity. Uncoupling was not accompanied by increased permeability to [14C]inulin. Slow exchange of tightly bound calcium with medium calcium was unaffected by turnover of the ATPase or by tryptic cleavage into 55,000- and 45,000-dalton fragments. Binding studies with labeled calcium suggested that tight binding involves a two-step process: Ca2+ + E in equilibrium K E . Ca2+ leads to E < Ca2+ where E and < Ca2+ represent the ATPase and tightly bound calcium, and K = 1.6 X 10(3) M-1. It is suggested that tightly bound calcium is located in a hydrophobic pocket in, or in close proximity to the ATPase, and, together with tightly bound adenine nucleotides (Aderem, A., McIntosh, D. B., and Berman, M. C. (1979) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 76, 3622-03632), is related to the ability of the ATPase to couple hydrolysis of ATP to vectorial transfer of calcium across the membrane.     

Semi-synthetic aequorin. An improved tool for the measurement of calcium ion concentration.

The photoprotein aequorin isolated from the jellyfish Aequorea emits blue light in the presence of Ca2+ by an intramolecular process that involves chemical transformation of the coelenterazine moiety into coelenteramide and CO2. Because of its high sensitivity to Ca2+, aequorin has widely been used as a Ca2+ indicator in various biological systems. We have replaced the coelenterazine moiety in the protein with several synthetic coelenterazine analogues, providing semi-synthetic Ca2+-sensitive photoproteins. One of the semi-synthetic photoproteins, derived from coelenterazine analogue (II) (with an extra ethano group), showed highly promising properties for the measurement of Ca2+, namely (1) the rise time of luminescence in response to Ca2+ was shortened by approx. 4-fold compared with native aequorin and (2) the luminescence spectrum showed two peaks at 405 nm and 465 nm and the ratio of their peak heights was dependent on Ca2+ concentration in the range of pCa 5-7, thus allowing the determination of [Ca2+] directly from the ratio of two peak intensities. Coelenterazine analogue (I) (with a hydroxy group replaced by an amino group) was also incorporated into apo-aequorin, yielding a Ca2+-sensitive photoprotein, which indicates that an electrostatic interaction between the phenolate group in the coelenterazine moiety and some cationic centre in apo-aequorin is not important in native aequorin, contrary to a previous suggestion.     

Calcium channels mediate phase shifts of the Bulla circadian pacemaker

1. Light-induced phase advances of the activity rhythm of the Bulla ocular circadian pacemaker are blocked when the extracellular calcium concentration is reduced with EGTA to 0.13 microM. Phase advances are also blocked in low calcium solutions without EGTA [( Ca] less than 50 microM). 2. The dependence of light-induced phase delays on extracellular calcium concentration in EGTA-free seawater was determined. Phase delays are blocked at calcium concentrations below 400 microM, and reduced at concentrations of 1 mM and 3.5 mM (relative to shifts in normal ASW, [Ca] = 10 mM). Phase delays are also reduced and blocked at calcium concentrations higher than normal (60 mM and 110 mM, respectively). 3. Low calcium EGTA also blocked both phase delays and phase advances induced by pulses of depolarizing high K+ seawater. Low calcium EGTA pulses presented alone at the same times did not generate significant phase shifts. 4. The organic calcium channel antagonists verapamil, diltiazem and nitrendipine as well as the inorganic calcium channel antagonists La3+, Co2+, Cd2+, and Mn2+ were applied along with light pulses, however, the treated eyes were either phase shifted by these substances, or these substances were found to be toxic. 5. The inorganic calcium channel antagonist Ni2+ blocked both light-induced phase delays and advances at a concentration of 5 mM. Ni2+ applied alone did not generate significant phase shifts. Phase delays induced by high K+ seawater were blocked in the presence of 50 mM Ni2+ but not in 5 mM Ni2+. The light-induced CAP activity of the putative pacemaker cells was not inhibited by Ni2+, suggesting that its blocking action was probably via its known role as a calcium channel antagonist.     

The calcium loading of secretory granules. A possible key event in stimulus-secretion coupling.

The review focuses on calcium accumulation by secretory organelles. The observation that secretory granules contain variable and often important quantities of calcium (1-200 mM of total calcium) can be interpreted as a maturation index. A progressive loading with calcium would be permitted by a Ca2(+)-transport mechanism on the granular membrane and calcium-binding molecules in the granular core. The saturation of this store by the stimulus-induced calcium transient would permit in mature (calcium-loaded) granules the ionic crisis leading to exocytosis. The inside of secretory organelles being acidic, calcium influx into the granule can be driven by calcium-proton exchange. The calcium-proton exchanger could be a Ca2(+)-ATPase.     

Characterization of the N-terminal half-saturated state of calbindin D9k: NMR studies of the N56A mutant.

Calbindin D9k is a small EF-hand protein that binds two calcium ions with positive cooperativity. The molecular basis of cooperativity for the binding pathway where the first ion binds in the N-terminal site (1) is investigated by NMR experiments on the half-saturated state of the N56A mutant, which exhibits sequential yet cooperative binding (Linse S, Chazin WJ, 1995, Protein Sci 4:1038-1044). Analysis of calcium-induced changes in chemical shifts, amide proton exchange rates, and NOEs indicates that ion binding to the N-terminal binding loop causes significant changes in conformation and/or dynamics throughout the protein. In particular, all three parameters indicate that the hydrophobic core undergoes a change in packing to a conformation very similar to the calcium-loaded state. These results are similar to those observed for the (Cd2+)1 state of the wild-type protein, a model for the complementary half-saturated state with an ion bound in the C-terminal site (II). Thus, with respect to cooperativity in either of the binding pathways, binding of the first ion drives the conformation and dynamics of the protein far toward the (Ca2+)2 state, thereby facilitating binding of the second ion. Comparison with the half-saturated state of the analogous E65Q mutant confirms that mutation of this critical bidentate calcium ligand at position 12 of the consensus EF-hand binding loop causes very significant structural perturbations. This result has important implications regarding numerous studies that have utilized mutation of this critical residue for site deactivation.