Les formules gonosomiques dites aberrantes chez les Mammifères Euthériens

The chromosome complement of the sloth Choloepus hoffmanni Peters has been investigated in mitosis and also in male meiosis. The karyotype for both males and females is characterized by a diploid number of 49 chromosomes. In the male the Y-material is translocated on an autosome but the meiotic behavior of the gonosomes is normal and therefore the sex determining mechanism may be normal too, despite the translocation. The females have an XO sex-chromosome constitution in somatic cells. An hypothesis, based on a slight deviation of a normal phenomenon is proposed to explain as regular such a formula in normal animals. — Relating to these conclusions, other known deviations of the standard XX/XY sex chromosome constitution in placental mammals are discussed (multiple sexchromosomes, composite gonosomes and XO female formula). The general conclusion is that despite an apparent variability of sex chromosome morphology, all placental mammals seem to retain a truly XX/XY sex constitution.     

Conditional lethal mutations shift the genome from stability to instability

The phenomenology of genomic destabilization is described in Drosophila melanogaster mutants containing radiation-induced conditional dominant lethals in the X chromosome and in autosome 2. Destabilization manifests itself as (1) the loss or decrease of lethality of previously lethal mutations; (2) the loss of expression of visible dominant mutations in an opposite homolog; (3) chromosomal instability resulting in the loss of the X chromosome in germline and somatic cells; (4) the occurrence of novel mutations (secondary mutagenesis); (5) the occurrence of single and mass modifications; (6) disturbances in individual development (formation of morphoses). The key event for the shift of the genome from the stable state into the unstable one is the occurrence of a conditional dominant lethal mutation.     

Parental Age Affects Somatic Mutation Rates in the Progeny of Flowering Plants

In humans, it is well known that the parental reproductive age has a strong influence on mutations transmitted to their progeny. Meiotic nondisjunction is known to increase in older mothers, and base substitutions tend to go up with paternal reproductive age. Hence, it is clear that the germinal mutation rates are a function of both maternal and paternal ages in humans. In contrast, it is unknown whether the parental reproductive age has an effect on somatic mutation rates in the progeny, because these are rare and difficult to detect. To address this question, we took advantage of the plant model system Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana), where mutation detector lines allow for an easy quantitation of somatic mutations, to test the effect of parental age on somatic mutation rates in the progeny. Although we found no significant effect of parental age on base substitutions, we found that frameshift mutations and transposition events increased in the progeny of older parents, an effect that is stronger through the maternal line. In contrast, intrachromosomal recombination events in the progeny decrease with the age of the parents in a parent-of-origin-dependent manner. Our results clearly show that parental reproductive age affects somatic mutation rates in the progeny and, thus, that some form of age-dependent information, which affects the frequency of double-strand breaks and possibly other processes involved in maintaining genome integrity, is transmitted through the gametes.In humans, it has long been recognized that the reproductive age of the parents has an influence on the health of their progeny. An older reproductive age of the mother is known to increase the fraction of aneuploid gamete formation (Hurles, 2012). For instance, the risk for a trisomy increases from 2% to 3% for mothers in their 20s to more than 30% for mothers in their 40s (Hassold and Hunt, 2009). The age of the father also has an effect on the frequency of spontaneous congenital disorders and common complex diseases, such as autism and some cancers (Goriely and Wilkie, 2012). Indeed, sperm from 36- to 57-year-old men have more double-strand breaks (DSBs) than those of 20- to 35-year-old individuals (Singh et al., 2003). Similarly, the efficiency of DSB repair was reported to decrease with age in vegetative tissues of the plant model system Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana; Boyko et al., 2006).Owing to the continuous divisions of spermatogonial stem cells, the male germline of humans is thought to be more mutagenic than the female germline. Indeed, it was shown that the paternal germline is more mutagenic than the maternal one with respect to base substitutions (Kong et al., 2012) and replication slippage errors at microsatellites (Sun et al., 2012). It is also known that carriers of germline mutations in mismatch repair (MMR) genes in humans are prone to get colorectal cancer and that the risk depends on the parent-of-origin of the mutation (van Vliet et al., 2011). The molecular basis of these parental effects is not entirely clear but is likely to involve higher rates of nondisjunction during female meiosis, higher mutation rates during spermatogenesis, and probably additional effects of aging.In contrast to the effect of parental age on germline mutations, not much is known about potential effects of parental reproductive age on somatic mutation rates in the offspring. However, it has been shown in animal studies that radiation of males can lead to somatic mutations in their progeny—and subsequent generations—that cannot be attributed to mutations in the paternal germline (for review, see Little et al., 2013). Moreover, several recent studies have illustrated the existence of complex parental and transgenerational effects in humans, although their molecular basis is not clear (Grossniklaus et al., 2013). These effects can be of either genetic nature (but the effect is seen even in offspring that did not inherit the genetic variant from their parents; for review, see Nadeau, 2009) or epigenetic nature (where environmental influences can possibly exert effects on subsequent generations; for review, see Pembrey et al., 2006; Pembrey, 2010; Curley et al., 2011). It is currently not known whether such parental effects affect the somatic mutation rates in the offspring or whether the effects are modulated by parental age.Taking advantage of the plant model system Arabidopsis, in which various somatic mutation rates can readily be assessed (Bashir et al., 2014), we investigated the effects of parental reproductive age on somatic mutation rates in the progeny. We report that there is a pronounced effect of parental age on somatic mutation rates in their offspring in a parent-of-origin-dependent fashion. Thus, some form of parental information, which is inherited through the gametes to the next generation, seems to alter the somatic mutation rates in the progeny and changes with parental reproductive age.     

Evolution of sex-chromosomes and formation of W-chromatin in snakes

The analysis of sex-chromosome complexes and formation of W-chromatin in 16 species of snakes of the families Boidae, Colubridae, Elapidae, and Hydrophiidae, reveal three very pertinent facts. First, the snakes exhibit various states of the differentiation of the Z and W chromosomes, apparently according to the evolutionary status of the families, being homomorphic in primitive families and well differentiated in highly evolved ones. Second, the demonstration of a heteropycnotic body in the interphase nuclei of the families of a large number of species of snakes has definitely shown that the nuclear sexing is possible not only in those species of snakes where the W chromosome is morphologically distinguishable from the Z, but also in those species where it is not so, but shows an asynchrony in the replicating pattern of W. It is suggested that development of allocycly rather than establishment of structural changes is the first step in the differentiation of the W from the Z in snakes. Third, the absence of coexistence of nucleolus and W-chromatin in a condensed state in the interphase nuclei of different tissues in a few species of snakes reported in this paper suggests that the W-chromatin is responsible for the synthesis of the nucleolus in these snakes.Paper presented at the Third Oxford Chromosome Conference, September, 1970.     

Chromosome nondisjunction in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Drosophila</Emphasis> strains mutant for tumor suppressor Merlin

The effect of mutation for gene Merlin on chromosome disjunction in Drosophila during meiosis was genetically studied. Chromosome nondisjunction was not registered in females heterozygous for this mutation and containing structurally normal X chromosomes. In cases when these females additionally contained inversion in one of chromosomes X, a tendency toward the appearance of nondisjunction events was observed in individuals containing mutation in the heterozygote. The genetic construct was obtained allowing the overexpression of protein corresponding to a sterile allele Mer ³ in the germ cell line. This construct relieves the lethal effect of Mer ⁴ mutation. The ectopic expression of this mutant protein leads to chromosome nondisjunction in male meiosis.     

Patterns of Somatic Mutations in Immunoglobulin Variable Genes

The mechanism responsible for somatic mutation in the variable genes of antibodies is unknown and may differ from previously described mechanisms that produce mutation in DNA. We have analyzed 421 somatic mutations from the rearranged immunoglobulin variable genes of mice to determine if the nucleotide substitutions differ from those generated during meiosis and if the presence of nearby direct and inverted repeated sequences could template mutations around the variable gene. The results reveal a difference in the pattern of substitutions obtained from somatic mutations vs. meiotic mutations. An increased frequency of T:A to C:G transitions and a decreased frequency of mutations involving a G in the somatic mutants compared to the meiotic mutants is indicated. This suggests that the mutational processes responsible for somatic mutations in antibody genes differs from that responsible for mutation during meiosis. An analysis of the local DNA sequences revealed many direct repeats and palindromic sequences that were capable of templating some of the known mutations. Although additional factors may be involved in targeting mutations to the variable gene, mistemplating by nearby repeats may provide a mechanism for the enhancement of somatic mutation.     

CBL Is Frequently Altered in Lung Cancers: Its Relationship to Mutations in MET and EGFR Tyrosine Kinases

Background

Non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) is a heterogeneous group of disorders with a number of genetic and proteomic alterations. c-CBL is an E3 ubiquitin ligase and adaptor molecule important in normal homeostasis and cancer. We determined the genetic variations of c-CBL, relationship to receptor tyrosine kinases (EGFR and MET), and functionality in NSCLC.

Methods and Findings

Using archival formalin-fixed paraffin embedded (FFPE) extracted genomic DNA, we show that c-CBL mutations occur in somatic fashion for lung cancers. c-CBL mutations were not mutually exclusive of MET or EGFR mutations; however they were independent of p53 and KRAS mutations. In normal/tumor pairwise analysis, there was significant loss of heterozygosity (LOH) for the c-CBL locus (22%, n = 8/37) and none of these samples revealed any mutation in the remaining copy of c-CBL. The c-CBL LOH also positively correlated with EGFR and MET mutations observed in the same samples. Using select c-CBL somatic mutations such as S80N/H94Y, Q249E and W802* (obtained from Caucasian, Taiwanese and African-American samples, respectively) transfected in NSCLC cell lines, there was increased cell viability and cell motility.

Conclusions

Taking the overall mutation rate of c-CBL to be a combination as somatic missense mutation and LOH, it is clear that c-CBL is highly mutated in lung cancers and may play an essential role in lung tumorigenesis and metastasis.     

Gattaca: Base-Pair Resolution Mutation Tracking for Somatic Evolution Studies using Agent-based Models

Research over the past two decades has made substantial inroads into our understanding of somatic mutations. Recently, these studies have focused on understanding their presence in homeostatic tissue. In parallel, agent-based mechanistic models have emerged as an important tool for understanding somatic mutation in tissue; yet no common methodology currently exists to provide base-pair resolution data for these models. Here, we present Gattaca as the first method for introducing and tracking somatic mutations at the base-pair resolution within agent-based models that typically lack nuclei. With nuclei that incorporate human reference genomes, mutational context, and sequence coverage/error information, Gattaca is able to realistically evolve sequence data, facilitating comparisons between in silico cell tissue modeling with experimental human somatic mutation data. This user-friendly method, incorporated into each in silico cell, allows us to fully capture somatic mutation spectra and evolution.     

The Lethal(1)tw-6(cs) Mutation of Drosophila Melanogaster Is a Dominant Antimorphic Allele of Nod and Is Associated with a Single Base Change in the Putative Atp-Binding Domain

The l(1)TW-6cs mutation is a cold-sensitive recessive lethal mutation in Drosophila melanogaster, that affects both meiotic and mitotic chromosome segregation. We report the isolation of three revertants of this mutation. All three revert both the meiotic and mitotic effects as well as the cold sensitivity, demonstrating that all three phenotypes are due to a single lesion. We further show that these revertants fail to complement an amorphic allele of the nod (no distributive disjunction) locus, which encodes a kinesin-like protein. These experiments demonstrate that l(1)TW-6cs is an antimorphic allele of nod, and we rename it nodDTW. Sequencing of the nod locus on a nodDTW-bearing chromosome reveals a single base change in the putative ATP-binding region of the motor domain of nod. Recessive, loss-of-function mutations at the nod locus specifically disrupt the segregation of nonexchange chromosomes in female meiosis. We demonstrate that, at 23.5 degrees, the meiotic defects in nodDTW/+ females are similar to those observed in nod/nod females; that is, the segregation of nonexchange chromosomes is abnormal. However, in nodDTW/nodDTW females, or in nodDTW/+ females at 18 degrees, we observe a more severe meiotic defect that apparently affects the segregation of both exchange and nonexchange chromosomes. In addition, nodDTW homozygotes and hemizygous males have previously been shown to exhibit mitotic defects including somatic chromosome breakage and loss. We propose that the defective protein encoded by the nodDTW allele interferes with proper chromosome movement during both meiosis and mitosis, perhaps by binding irreversibly to microtubules.     

Altered somatic mutation level and DNA repair gene expression in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Arabidopsis thaliana</Emphasis> exposed to ultraviolet C,salt, and cadmium stresses

It is known that somatic mutations arising during animal growth and ageing contribute to the development of neurodegenerative and other animal diseases. For plants, several studies showed that small-scale somatic DNA mutations accumulated during Arabidopsis life cycle. However, there is a lack of data on the influence of environmental stresses on somatic DNA mutagenesis in plants. In this study, we analyzed the effects of ultraviolet C (UV-C) irradiation, high soil salinity, and cadmium (CdI₃) stresses on the level of small-scale somatic DNA mutations in Arabidopsis thaliana. The number of DNA mutations was examined in the Actin2 3′UTR (Actin-U1), ITS1-5.8rRNA-ITS2 (ITS), and ribulose-1,5-biphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (rbcL) DNA regions. We found that somatic mutation levels considerably increased in CdI₃-treated Arabidopsis plants, while the mutation levels declined in the UV-C- and NaCl-treated A. thaliana. Cadmium is a mutagen that is known to inhibit DNA repair processes. The detected stress-induced alterations in somatic DNA mutation levels were accompanied by markedly increased expression of base excision repair genes (AtARP, AtDME, AtDML2, AtDML3, AtMBD4, AtROS, AtUNG, and AtZDP), nucleotide excision repair genes (AtDDB1a, AtRad4, and AtRad23a), mismatch repair genes (AtMSH2, AtMSH3, and AtMSH7), and photoreactivation genes (AtUVR2, AtUVR3). Thus, the results demonstrated that UV-C, high soil salinity, and cadmium stresses influence both the level of DNA mutations and expression of DNA repair genes. Salt- and UV-induced activation of DNA repair genes could contribute to the stress-induced decrease in somatic mutation level.     

Mismatch repair as a source of mutations in non-dividing cells

This paper describes a mechanism which permits somatic cells to generate random mutations in the complete absence of cell proliferation. The mechanism itself is remarkably simple, involving a well-known cellular process (mismatch repair or MMR) which is primarily associated with mutation avoidance, but which is also capable of generating mutations when circumstances are not ideal for avoidance. When MMR operates in its so-called methylation-instructed mode to remove mismatches from newly-replicated portions of genomic DNA, it does so in a way which serves to minimize mutation yields. By contrast, when MMR operates in a non-instructed or randomly-templated way to remove mismatches from DNA molecules, it does so without distinguishing between the two strands of DNA that contain the mismatched bases. Randomly-templated mismatch repair (RT-MMR) therefore generates new and complete mutations whenever it removes the correct bases from either base-pair mismatches or frameshift mispairs and replaces them without incorrect bases or sequences. Wider recognition of the existence of this mechanism — and especially of its proclivity for mutation generation when it is operating in non-dividing cells—should help us to develop a better understanding of a number of important biological phenomena, and may be of particular value in our attempts to explain the origins of many human cancers.     

Frequency of EGFR Mutations in 907 Lung Adenocarcioma Patients of Indian Ethnicity

Background

During the past decade, the incidence of EGFR mutation has been shown to vary across different ethnicities. It occurs at the rate of 10–15% in North Americans and Europeans, 19% in African-Americans, 20–30% in various East Asian series including Chinese, Koreans, and Japanese. Frequency of EGFR mutations in India however remains sparsely explored.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We report 23% incidence of Epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) mutations in 907 Non small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) patients of Indian ethnicity, in contrast to 10–15% known in Caucasians and 27–62% among East Asians. In this study, EGFR mutations were found to be more common in never-smokers 29.4% as compared to smokers 15.3%. Consistent with other populations, mutation rates among adenocarcinoma-males were predominantly lower than females with 32% incidence. However unlike Caucasians, EGFR mutation rate among adenocarcinoma-never-smoker females were comparable to males suggesting lack of gender bias among never smokers likely to benefit from EGFR targeted therapy.

Conclusions/Significance

This study has an overall implication for establishing relevance for routine EGFR mutation diagnostics for NSCLC patients in clinics and emphasizes effectiveness for adoption of EGFR inhibitors as the first line treatment among Indian population. The intermediate frequency of EGFR mutation among Indian population compared to Caucasians and East Asians is reminiscent of an ancestral admixture of genetic influence from Middle Easterners, Central Asians, and Europeans on modern- Indian population that may confer differential susceptibility to somatic mutations in EGFR.     

Spontaneous frequency of a developmental mutant in Volvox

Two types of mutants, those resistant to the base analog 5-bromo-2′-deoxyuridine (BrdU) and somatic regenerator (SR) mutants, have been analyzed in Volvox carteri. In somatic regenerator mutants, the somatic cells which are normally terminally differentiated dedifferentiate and regenerate gonidia [Sessoms, A., and Huskey, R. J. (1973). Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA70, 1335–1338; Starr, R. C. (1970). Develop. Biol. Suppl.4, 59–100]. The SR phenotype allows recovery of SR mutations arising in somatic cells, since such somatic cells would regenerate gonidia and give rise to mutant clones. Mutants of any phenotype other than SR can only be recovered if the mutation first appears in a gonidium. Since the somatic cells are 100-fold more numerous than reproductive cells (gonidia), we have determined the spontaneous frequency of both somatic regenerator mutants and mutations to BrdU resistance in order to determine if the SR mutation exerts its effect in the gonidium or in the somatic cell. The two frequencies were found to be nearly identical, suggesting that the SR mutation must first appear in a gonidium in order to be expressed.     

The X-autosome translocation in the common shrew (Sorex araneus L.): late replication in female somatic cells and pairing in male meiosis

Common shrews have an XX/XY₁Y₂ sex chromosome system, with the X chromosome being a translocation (tandem fusion) between the original X and an autosome; in males this autosome is represented by the Y₂ chromosome. From G-banded chromosomes, the Y₂ is homologous to the long arm and centromeric part of the short arm of the X. The region of the X that is homologous to the Y₂ and also the telomeric region of the short arm of the X were found to be early replicating in somatic cells from a female shrew after 5-bromo-2-deoxyuridine (BrdU) treatment in vitro. The remainder of the short arm of the X was shown to be late replicating. Electron microscopic examination of synaptonemal complexes in males at pachytene revealed pairing of the Y₂ axis with the long arm of the X, and Y₁ with the short arm. At early stages of pachytene, there is apparently extensive nonhomologous pairing between the X and Y₁. In essence, the short arm of the shrew X chromosome behaves like a typical eutherian X chromosome (it is inactivated in female somatic cells and is paried with the Y₁ during male meiosis) while the long arm behaves like an autosome (escapes the inactivation and pairs with the Y₂).     

Investigating somatic aneuploidy in the brain: why we need a new model

The steady occurrence of DNA mutations is a key source for evolution, generating the genomic variation in the population upon which natural selection acts. Mutations driving evolution have to occur in the oocytes and sperm in order to be transmitted to the next generation. Through similar mechanisms, mutations also accumulate in somatic cells (e.g., skin cells, neurons, lymphocytes) during development and adult life. The concept that somatic cells can collect new mutations with time suggests that we are a mosaic of cells with different genomic compositions. Particular attention has been recently paid to somatic mutations in the brain, with a focus on the relationship between this phenomenon and the origin of human diseases. Given this progressive accumulation of mutations, it is likely that an increased load of somatic mutations is present later in life and that this could be associated with late-life diseases and aging. In this review, we focus on a particular type of mutation: the loss and/or gain of whole chromosomes (i.e., aneuploidy) caused by errors in chromosomes segregation in neurons and glia. Currently, it is hard to grasp the functional impact of somatic mutation in the brain because we lack reliable estimates of the proportion of aneuploid cells in the normal brain across different ages. Here, we revisit the key studies that attempted to quantify the proportion of aneuploid cells in both normal and diseased brains and highlight the deep inconsistencies among the different studies done in the last 15 years. Finally, our review highlights several limitations of studies performed in human and rodent models and explores a possible translational role for non-human primates.     

Somatic mutations in mitochondrial genome and their potential roles in the progression of human gastric cancer

Background

Somatic mutation in mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) has been proposed to contribute to initiation and progression of human cancer. In our previous study, high frequency of somatic mutations was found in the D-loop region of mtDNA of gastric cancers. However, it is unclear whether somatic mutations occur in the coding region of mtDNA of gastric cancers.

Methods

Using DNA sequencing, we studied 31 gastric cancer specimens and corresponding non-cancerous stomach tissues. Moreover, a human gastric cancer SC-M1 cell line was treated with oligomycin to induce mitochondrial dysfunction. Cisplatin sensitivity and cell migration were analyzed.

Results

We identified eight somatic mutations in the coding region of mtDNAs of seven gastric cancer samples (7/31, 22.6%). Patients with somatic mutations in the entire mtDNA of gastric cancers did not show significant association with their clinicopathologic features. Among the eight somatic mutations, five point mutations (G3697A, G4996A, G9986A, C12405T and T13015C) are homoplasmic and three mutations (5895delC, 7472insC and 12418insA) are heteroplasmic. Four (4/8, 50%) of these somatic mutations result in amino acid substitutions in the highly conserved regions of mtDNA, which potentially lead to mitochondrial dysfunction. In addition, in vitro experiments in SC-M1 cells revealed that oligomycin-induced mitochondrial dysfunction promoted resistance to cisplatin and enhanced cell migration. N-acetyl cysteine was effective in the prevention of the oligomycin-enhanced migration, which suggests that reactive oxygen species generated by defective mitochondria may be involved in the enhanced migration of SC-M1 cells.

General Significance

Our results suggest that somatic mtDNA mutations and mitochondrial dysfunction may play an important role in the malignant progression of gastric cancer.     

Mutation and Human Exceptionalism: Our Future Genetic Load

Although the human germline mutation rate is higher than that in any other well-studied species, the rate is not exceptional once the effective genome size and effective population size are taken into consideration. Human somatic mutation rates are substantially elevated above those in the germline, but this is also seen in other species. What is exceptional about humans is the recent detachment from the challenges of the natural environment and the ability to modify phenotypic traits in ways that mitigate the fitness effects of mutations, e.g., precision and personalized medicine. This results in a relaxation of selection against mildly deleterious mutations, including those magnifying the mutation rate itself. The long-term consequence of such effects is an expected genetic deterioration in the baseline human condition, potentially measurable on the timescale of a few generations in westernized societies, and because the brain is a particularly large mutational target, this is of particular concern. Ultimately, the price will have to be covered by further investment in various forms of medical intervention. Resolving the uncertainties of the magnitude and timescale of these effects will require the establishment of stable, standardized, multigenerational measurement procedures for various human traits.MUTATION, the production of heritable changes in DNA, is one of the most fundamental concepts in genetics. Yet, a broad phylogenetic understanding of the rate and molecular spectrum of mutations and the mechanisms driving the evolution of these key parameters has only recently begun to emerge (Baer et al. 2007; Lynch 2010, 2011). Of special concern is the rate at which mutations are arising in our own lineage and their long-term consequences. In terms of cognitive abilities and proclivity for dominating the global ecosystem, humans are clearly exceptional. But how exceptional are we with respect to the genetic machinery that is the key to long-term genome stability and evolutionary flexibility? And in light of our unusual behavioral features, what are the long-term genetic consequences of being a modern human? Will the miracles of molecular biology and modern medicine reduce the incidence and/or effects of genetic afflictions to negligible levels, or might such applications have the opposite effect?Two issues are of central relevance here. First, few other species willingly expose themselves to environmental mutagens to the extent that humans do. Presumably, there is some room for reducing the human mutation rate by minimizing negative environmental effects, e.g., through reductions in exposure to smoke from tobacco and other sources, harmful food additives, radon gas, UV irradiation, etc. What, however, is the lower bound to the achievable mutation rate at both the germline and somatic levels? And do factors that influence the somatic mutation rate also have germline effects and vice versa?Second, owing to the remarkable advances in living conditions and medicine over the past century, and many more likely to come, humans uniquely modify the environment in ways that minimize the consequences of acquired genetic afflictions. Today’s ethical imperative for maximizing individual reproductive potential and longevity independent of genetic background raises significant questions about the future of the human gene pool. Specifically, what are the long-term consequences of the accumulation of mutations whose phenotypic consequences can be transiently minimized through medical intervention and/or a sheltering environment?It is fitting to review both of these issues in the year 2016, as this would have been the 100th birthday of James Crow, who played a central role in the Genetics Society of America and had a long-standing interest in human mutation (Crow 1993, 1997, 2000, 2006). Many of the issues addressed below were raised by Crow prior to the genomics revolution and can now be evaluated in a more quantitative way.