Quantitative studies on the precursors of cytotoxic lymphocytes. II. Specificity of precursors responsive to alloantigens and to concanavalin A.

A microculture system was used to examine the specificity of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CL) derived from single precursors. Our data indicate that clones derived from single precursors of CL (CLP) are specific. Thus, RNC mice (H-2k) simultaneously stimulated by both H-2d and H-2b antigens produce clones which are specific for either H-2b or H-2d but not for both. In lymph node (LN), the frequency of CLP giving rise to clones specific for H-2d and H-2b is 1/480 and 1/860, respectively. Clonal specificity is also maintained when Con A is used to activate the precursors. With a nonspecific assay of CL, it was found that 2.5% of the cells in LN are stimulated by Con A to produce clones of CL. Among the CLP stimulated by Con A, 2.1% of the clones are specific for H-2d alloantigens. An unexpected finding was that 18% of the clones produced by Con A stimulation lysed EL4 tumor cells, which carry H-2b; however, only a small proportion of these clones were specific for the H-2b alloantigen. The antigen on EL4 which accounts for the high response has not been characterized.     

Quantitative studies on the precursors of cytotoxic lymphocytes. I. Characterization of a clonal assay and determination of the size of clones derived from single precursors.

A microculture system for estimating the frequency of cytotoxic lymphocyte precursors (CLP) to alloantigens is described. Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CL) were generated by culturing limiting numbers of RNC (H-2k)-nu/+lymph node (LN) cells with irradiated C3D2F1 (H-2k/d) spleen cells in the presence of RNC-nu/nu spleen cells for 7 days in microtiter trays. At the end of the culture period, individual wells were assayed for cytotoxic effector cells directed against 51CrP815 (H-2d) target cells. The effector cells generated under these conditions are sensitive to killing by rabbit anti-mouse brain serum and guinea pig complement. The process of differentiation from precursors to CL is radiation sensitive (Do approximately 180 rads). The frequency of precursors for H-2d was calculated by fitting the proportion of nonresponding cultures to the zero order term of the Poisson distribution, Po = e-vn, where Po = per cent nonresponders, v = precursor frequency, and N = number of LN cells cultured per well. The frequency of precursors in the RNC-nu/+LN population responding to the H-2d haplotype was found to be 1 in 776. Under conditions where no backstimulation is possible, the frequency of precursors responding to the H-2d haplotype is 1 in 885 for B6-nu/+LN and 1 in 2550 for B6-nu/+ spleen, respectively. In combination with a visual assay for individual CL, it was found that the average clone size per precursor after 7 days in culture is about 1040. Our assay could detect clones with as few as 40 CL/well. Since the average clone size in 26 times the detection limit, we conclude that the assay for CLP is highly sensitive and does not represent a minimum estimate.     

Recognition by cytotoxic T lymphocytes of Qa-2 antigens. Sensitivity of Qa-2 molecules to phosphatidylinositol-specific phospholipase C

Con A splenic lymphoblasts were incubated with phosphatidyl-inositol specific phospholipase C (PIPLC) derived from Bacillus thuringiensis and subsequently analyzed for Qa-2 Ag with the Qa-2 reactive mAb Qa-m2. This treatment completely removed Qa-2 detectable Ag on lymphoblasts from H-2d animals, indicating that these molecules are likely anchored to the cell membrane through phosphatidyl inositol (PI). Although exposure of lymphoblasts from H-2b mice to PIPLC greatly reduced Qa-2 expression, a subpopulation of cells retained a limited quantity of the Ag. Bulk cultured anti-Qa-2 CTL generated against the Qa-2 region from H-2b haplotype mice lysed Qa-2+ targets from B6.K2 (H-2b) and BALB/cJ (H-2d) animals. Pretreatment of these lymphoblast targets with PIPLC completely abolished lysis of the BALB/cJ target cells, whereas lysis of B6 targets was reduced only slightly. Anti-Qa-2 CTL clones tested against PIPLC-treated B6 target cells revealed two patterns of reactivity. One group of clones was unaffected in its ability to lyse PIPLC-pretreated targets and cross-reacted on Q6d/Ld molecules expressed on transfected L cells. A second group was unable to lyse PIPLC-pretreated lymphoblasts and cross-reacted on Q7d/Ld targets. These data suggest that H-2b-derived lymphoblasts express two different types of Qa-2 molecules with respect to PIPLC sensitivity; one type is sensitive to PIPLC and cross-reactive with Q7d, the other type is resistant to PIPLC and cross-reactive with Q6d. In contrast, H-2d lymphoblasts express only the PIPLC-sensitive type of molecules. It was also noted that bulk cultured anti-Qa-2 CTL more readily lysed H-2b target cells expressing a smaller quantity of PIPLC-resistant Ag than H-2d targets expressing a larger amount of PIPLC-sensitive Ag. Further, anti-Qa-2 CTL clones readily lysed PIPLC-treated target cells expressing very low levels of serologically detectable Qa-2. This suggests that recognition of class I molecules anchored to the membrane via a PIPLC-resistant linkage may more readily activate CTL for expression of lytic activity than molecules anchored through PI.     

Clonal heterogeneity of anti-AKR/gross leukemia virus cytotoxic T lymphocytes. Evidence for two distinct antigen systems

AKR/Gross leukemia virus-induced tumor reactive cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones were derived from C57BL/6 spleen cells. Analysis of their specificity pattern was performed by using a panel of target cells such as E male G2 and AKR.H-2bSL1 (susceptible tumors to polyclonal anti-AKR/Gross virus CTL), and cl. 18-5 and cl. 18-12 (insusceptible variant sublines derived from AKR.H-2bSL1). Several of these CTL clones were selected for further study. Lysis of Gross cell surface antigen-positive tumor cells by these clones was restricted by the H-2Kb molecule. The cell surface phenotype of these clones was Thy-1.2+, Lyt-2.2+, L3T4-, a phenotype consistent with that of polyclonal anti-AKR/Gross CTL, suggesting that they were of conventional CTL origin. According to their fine specificity pattern, the CTL clones were divided into two major groups (A and B) which were further subdivided into five and three subgroups, respectively. The specificity of group A clones was essentially the same as that of the standard polyclonal CTL population except for a variable level of natural killer-like activity by some of the CTL clones. That is, group A clones did not efficiently lyse the insusceptible variant tumors nor any of Friend-Moloney-Rauscher-positive tumors tested, but they showed strong lytic activity to susceptible tumors and iododeoxyuridine-treated insusceptible variants. Thus, their CTL activity appeared to be strictly directed to Gross cell surface antigen-positive tumors that are susceptible to polyclonal anti-AKR/Gross virus CTL. In contrast, group B clones could lyse both susceptible and insusceptible variant tumors and also a Friend virus-induced tumor (FBL3). Therefore, as defined by these CTL clones, at least two distinct antigenic systems (A and B), each with several antigenic determinants, appeared to be present. Because recent findings suggested that most of the polyclonal anti-AKR/Gross virus CTL activity appeared to be directed to N-ecotropic proviral determinants, we further investigated the nature of these two antigenic systems by use of additional target cells including lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-stimulated spleen cell blasts from AKXL recombinant inbred strains and retrovirus-infected fibroblasts. Group A clones could lyse all LPS blasts derived from AKXL recombinant inbred strains containing the AKV-1 proviral genome, but lysed only very insufficiently or did not lyse AKV-1-negative blasts containing the AKV-3 and/or AKV-4 provirus.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Biology of cloned cytotoxic T lymphocytes specific for lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus. I. Generation and recognition of virus strains and H-2b mutants

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) were induced in C57BL/6 and (C57BL/6 X DBA/2)F1 mice after immunization with the Armstrong strain of lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV-Arm) and were cloned by limiting dilution in vitro. The cytotoxic activity of these clones was LCMV specific and H-2 restricted. All clones induced in C57BL/6 (H-2b) mice with LCMV-Arm lysed target cells infected with each of five distinct strains of LCMV (Arm, Traub , WE, Pasteur, and UBC ), suggesting recognition of common regions of viral proteins in association with H-2b molecules. In contrast, one clone obtained from (B6 X D2)F1 mice and restricted to the H-2d haplotype only lysed cells infected with one of three strains of virus (Arm, Traub , WE) but not two others (Pasteur, UBC ), suggesting recognition of variable regions of viral proteins in the context of H-2d molecules. To assess the fine specificity for H-2 molecules, we tested H-2Kb-restricted CTL clones for their ability to kill LCMV-infected target cells bearing mutations in their H-2Kb, and we tested clones presumed to be restricted to the H-2Db region for their ability to all LCMV targets cells bearing a mutation in the H-2Db region. Several different patterns of killing of the mutant targets were observed, indicating that a number of different epitopes on the H-2b molecules were used as restricting determinants for LCMV antigen recognition by CTL. Thus, cross-reactive viral determinants were recognized in the context of several different restricting determinants. Mutations in the N or C1 domains of the H-2 molecule affected recognition by a single LCMV specific CTL clone. One implication of this result is that CTL recognize a conformational determinant on the H-2 molecule formed by the association of virus antigen(s) with H-2. An alternate explanation is that one site on the H-2 molecule is involved in the interaction of viral antigens with H-2, whereas another may serve as a binding site for the CTL receptor.     

Induction of I region-restricted hapten-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes.

Murine cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) reactive to TNP-conjugated syngeneic target cells do lyse to a moderate but significant extent TNP-conjugated, I region compatible but H-2K or H-2D region incompatible target cells. Antibody inhibition experiments and "cold inhibition" experiments indicate that some CTL clones recognize TNP-conjugated targets in association with syngeneic I region determinants independently of H-2K or H-2D gene products. The data suggest that besides TNP-conjugated H-2K or H-2D gene products, in principle, also TNP-conjugated I region determinants do stimulate TNP-specific CTL precursor cells and act as target antigens of TNP-specific CTL.     

Specificity repertoire of splenic Lyt-2+/F23+ cytotoxic lymphocyte precursors from B6 mice

As revealed by flow cytometric analysis, about 30% of nylon wool nonadherent Lyt-2+ B6 spleen cells were F23+, i.e., were stained with the monoclonal antibody F23.1 directed against an allotypic T-cell receptor determinant. The specificity repertoire of splenic Lyt-2+/F23+ cytotoxic lymphocyte precursors (CLP) from B6 mice was investigated in a limiting dilution (LD) system designed to support clonal expansion in vitro of a representative fraction of this T-cell subset: in highly purified Lyt-2+ responder cells cocultured with mitomycin-treated F23 hybridoma cells in the presence of (recombinant) interleukin 2 under LD conditions, one out of three Lyt-2+/F23+ CLP gave rise to a functional cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clone. The split-well analysis of individual CTL populations demonstrated a clear-cut segregation of the lytic reactivities toward different allogeneic Con A blast targets. A large fraction of B6-derived CTL clones (3-10%) specifically lysed fully H-2 allogeneic (H-2k, H-2d), or H-2K mutant (bm1) targets. Self-reactive and allorestricted lytic patterns were not found.     

Mapping of HLA epitopes recognized by H-2-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes specific for HLA using recombinant genes and synthetic peptides

Immunization of DBA/2 (H-2d) mice with syngeneic P815 tumor cell transfectants that express HLA class I genes elicits CTL that recognize HLA in the context of H-2Kd molecules. Anti-HLA-CW3 CTL cross-react to a variable extent on the related alleles A3 and A24. Using a panel of target cells expressing native or recombinant HLA genes, we could map the epitope recognized by a CTL clone specific for CW3 to the second external (alpha 2) domain of CW3. Moreover, the epitope recognized by this clone could be mimicked by incubating P815 (HLA negative) target cells with a synthetic peptide corresponding to the C-terminal 12 amino acids of the CW3 alpha 2 domain (residues 171 to 182). Other independent anti-CW3 CTL clones with different fine specificities recognized the same CW3 peptide. In contrast, CTL clones specific for HLA-A24 or HLA-A3 that did not lyse P815-CW3 transfectants did not recognize this peptide. The CW3 peptide could be recognized on other tumor cell targets that were also of H-2d origin, but not on those of H-2b or H-2k origin. The requirement for the expression of H-2Kd by the target cells was directly demonstrated using L cell Kd transfectants. Our results suggest that the CTL response of DBA/2 mice immunized with P815-CW3 transfectants is predominantly Kd restricted and focused on epitopes contained within the 12 C-terminal amino acids of the alpha 2 domain.     

Primary in vitro cytotoxic response of F1 T lymphocytes against parental antigens.

Spleen cells from adult female (AKR/J x BALB/(c)F1 mice can respond to mitomycin C-treated spleen from AKR/J mice and can generate effector CTL in a 5-day primary in vitro culture. The response is comparable in magnitude to the response to allogeneic H-2K or H-2D antigens. The response is T cell mediated and is directed to antigen(s) present only on the parental cells. The target cell must be homozygous at H-2Kk to be lysed and H-2Dk antigens do not serve as a target in this response. Spleen cells from (B10.BR x B10.D2) hybrids that have been stimulated with AKR/J lyse B10.Br as well as AKR/J target cells. Similar H-2k/d hybrid F1 anti-H-2k parent responses are seen in certain other strain combinations. A number of possible interpretations of these responses are discussed.     

Predominant T cell receptor gene elements in TNP-specific cytotoxic T cells.

H-2b class I-restricted, TNP-specific CTL clones were obtained by limiting dilution cloning of either short term polyclonal CTL lines or spleen cells of TNP-immunized mice directly ex vivo. Sequence analyses of mRNA coding for TCR alpha- and beta-chains of 11 clones derived from CTL lines from individual C57BL/6 mice revealed that all of them expressed unique but clearly nonrandom receptor structures. Five alpha-chains (45%) employed V alpha 10 gene elements, and four of those (36%) were associated with J beta 2.6-expressing beta-chains. The alpha-chains from these four TCR, moreover, contained an acidic amino acid in position 93 of their N or J region-determined sequences. Clones isolated directly from spleen cells carried these types of receptors at lower frequency, 27% V alpha 10 and 19% J beta 2.6, indicating that bulk in vitro cultivation on Ag leads to selection for these particular receptors. However, even in TNP-specific CTL cloned directly ex vivo, V alpha 10 usage was increased about fivefold over that in Ag-independently activated T cells in H-2b mice (4 to 5%). The selection for V alpha 10/J beta 2.6-expressing cells was obtained repeatedly in other TNP-specific CTL lines from C57BL/6 mice but not in FITC-specific CTL from the same strain or in TNP-specific CTL lines from B10.BR (H-2k) or B10.D2 (H-2d) mice. We conclude from this (a) that the selection for V alpha 10/J beta 2.6+ T cells is driven by the complementarity of these receptors to a combination of TNP and MHC epitopes and (b) that predominant receptor structures reflect the existence of a surprisingly limited number of "T cell-relevant" hapten determinants on the surface of covalently TNP-modified cells.     

Anti-Thy-1 plus complement-treated, cultured bone marrow cells resemble fetal thymocytes in killer cell function and marker expression

Anti-Thy-1.2 plus complement treated bone marrow cells were tested after short-term culture for their ability to lyse allogeneic target cells. Significant lytic activity was generated after 9 days, and required both CAS and splenic or PEC feeders as culture supplements. Allogeneic as well as syngeneic-specific cytotoxic cells were generated polyclonally under such conditions, and could be separated by using limiting dilution protocols. When 65 clones were tested for lytic activity toward three targets bearing H-2k, H-2d, and H-2b haplotypes, respectively, only two clones lysed all three targets; 53 clones showed specificity toward one target only. Targets low in class I H-2 expression were lysed only minimally compared with high H-2 expressors. Allogeneic-kill by C57BL/6 bone marrow cells grown on AKR feeder cells was destroyed by treating effectors with anti-Thy-1.2, but not anti-Thy-1.1, antibody plus complement, suggesting 1) a de novo generation of surface Thy-1 during culture and 2) that effectors were derived from bone marrow, but not feeder, populations. Partial inhibition of kill occurred by treatment of effectors with anti-asialo-GM1 (approximately 80%), anti-Lyt-2 (approximately 60%), or anti-Ly-5.1 (approximately 30%) antibodies plus complement; treatment of effectors with anti-L3T4 or anti-NK-1.1 antibodies plus complement had no effect. When precursor populations were treated with either anti-Thy-1.2 alone or a combination of anti-Thy-1.2 and anti-Lyt-2 antibodies plus complement, killers were easily demonstrated. However, the addition of an anti-asialo-GM1 antibody plus complement treatment before culture abolished function. The characteristics of these effectors showed a resemblance to those described previously for day 14 to 17 fetal thymocytes, designated pCTL.     

Specificities of killing by T lymphocytes generated against syngeneic SV40 transformants: studies employing recombinants within the H-2 complex.

T lymphocyte effectors to syngeneic SV40-transformed cells, generated by secondary in vitro sensitization of immune spleen cells, lyse SV40 transformed targets that are syngeneic at the H-2 locus. In this study we have employed recombinants within the H-2 region to examine in detail this H-2 specificity. H-2b effectors were found to lyse SV40-transformed targets from recombinants bearing either H-2Kb or H-2Db.H-2k effectors recognized only SV40-transformed H-2Kk, and not H-2Dk target cells. By using the same protocol for sensitization, no effector cells could be detected in H-2d mice. Effectors generated in H-2 recombinant mice showed that the response capacity resides with K and D. For example, HTG, which is H-2d except at the D locus (H-2Db), produced effector cells specific for SV40-transformed H-2Db targets. Thus, the secondary in vitro response to SV40 transformants was found to depend only on the K and D alleles and not to be modified by the I region to any measurable extent.     

Human cytotoxic lymphocytes. V. Frequency and specificity of gamma delta+ cytotoxic lymphocyte precursors activated by allogeneic or autologous stimulator cells

We have investigated the frequency and specificity of gamma delta+ cytotoxic lymphocyte precursors (CLP) under limiting dilution culture conditions. E rosette separated total T cells and CD3+CD4-CD8-TCR alpha beta- double-negative (DN) T cells were cocultured with allogeneic or autologous PBMC stimulator cells, and frequencies of alloreactive and autoreactive CLP were determined after 12 to 14 days against Con A blast target cells. Freshly isolated DN cells consisting of 82.3 +/- 8.2% gamma delta+ T cells did not exert cytolytic activity against K562 or anti-TCR gamma delta mAb-producing hybridoma cells. In striking contrast to E+ cells, the vast majority of alloantigen-stimulated clonally developing DN CLP did not show specificity for stimulator-derived target cells. Thus, frequencies of alloreactive and autoreactive CLP after alloantigenic stimulation were in the range of 1/100 to 1/4800 and 1/450 to 1/5000, respectively. After coculture with autologous stimulator cells, frequencies of autoreactive and alloreactive DN CLP were 1/700 to 1/2700 and 1/1360 to 1/4500, respectively. Split culture analysis revealed that most proliferating DN colonies selected for high probability of clonality simultaneously killed both autologous and HLA-mismatched allogeneic targets. The majority of the DN cells expressed the CD3+/TCR gamma delta+ phenotype after culture, and thus were not CD2+CD3- NK cells. Taken together, our results show that 1) freshly isolated peripheral blood gamma delta+ T cells lack cytotoxic activity, and 2) most cytotoxic gamma delta+ T cells activated by autologous or allogeneic stimulator cells under limiting dilution conditions do not discriminate between autologous and allogeneic targets.     

Functional heterogeneity in allospecific cytotoxic T lymphocyte clones. II. Development of syngeneic cytotoxicity in the absence of specific antigenic stimulation

Two out of four long-term murine allospecific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones tested could develop high levels of cytotoxicity against syngeneic target cells when cultured under appropriate conditions. All CTL clones maintained strict allospecificity so long as they were cultured with both appropriate allogeneic stimulator cells and growth factor (supernatant from secondary mixed lymphocyte cultures). In two of the clones, syngeneic reactivity rapidly developed when the allogeneic stimulator cells were replaced with syngeneic or third party stimulator cells, and when the supernatant from EL4 thymoma cells stimulated with phorbol ester was used as growth factor. In addition to killing the appropriate allogeneic target, clones with syngeneic reactivity could kill both syngeneic C57BL/6 targets and H-2-congenic BALB.B targets but not third party unrelated targets, suggesting that the self structure recognized was coded for within the major histocompatibility complex. Such clones did not kill the natural killer (NK) target YAC. The results obtained from cold target inhibition and from subcloning at limiting dilution of clones with syngeneic reactivity suggested that both allogeneic and syngeneic reactivity could be expressed by the same individual cell in the CTL clone. The specificity for syngeneic H-2 as opposed to third party H-2 and NK-sensitive target cells, and the observation that both allospecific and syngeneic killing could be partially blocked by anti-Lyt-2 antibody treatment of the CTL, strongly suggested that different recognition structures are involved in CTL-mediated syngeneic cytotoxicity and NK cytotoxicity.     

Frequency and cross-reactivity od cytolytic T lymphocyte precursors reacting against male alloantigens

It is well established that cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) specific for the male minor histocompatibility antigen (H-Y) are generated by restimulation in vitro of in vivo primed spleen cells from C57BL/6 (H-2b) female mice with syngeneic male spleen cells. When tested on target cells from H-2 different strains, the male-specific C57BL/6 CTL populations exhibited significant lysis of DBA/2 (H-2d), A (H-2a), but not C3H (H-2k), male and female target cells. In an attempt to document this cross-reactivity further at the clonal level, a sensitive technique of limiting dilution analysis was used to determine the specificity of C57BL/6 individual CTL precursors (CTL-P) reactive against the male antigen. The mean frequency of anti-H-Y CTL-P in spleens of primed female mice was about 1/3500. Between one-third to one-tenth of these CTL-P produced a progeny that cross-reacted with H-2d (allogeneic) female target cells. These findings were confirmed by the analysis of the reactivity pattern exhibited by male-specific CTL clones derived by limiting dilution. Of 99 clones tested, 13 were found to cross-react with female DBA/2 target cells. These results thus indicate that a relatively large proportion (greater than 10%) of H-2b CTL-P directed against the H-Y antigen cross-react with target cells expressing H-2d alloantigens in the absence of H-Y antigen.     

Cell-mediated immune responses in vitro. II. Simultaneous generation of cytotoxic lymphocyte responses to two sets of alloantigens of limited cross-reactivity.

The conditions for generation of simultaneous and independent cytotoxic lymphocyte (CL) responses to each of two sets of alloantigens of limited cross-reactivity by mouse spleen cells in vitro have been investigated. Responder spleen cells were incubated with mitomycin C-treated C57BL/6 (H-2b) or DBA/2 (H-2d) stimulator spleen cells and day 5 CL responses were assayed with 51Cr-labeled EL-4 leukemia (H-2b) and P815 mastocytoma (H-2d) as target cells. Spleen cells from mice of the various H-2 haplotypes tested differed greatly in their ability to develop specific CL responses against alloantigens on the stimulator spleen cells and in the degree of cross-reactive cytotoxic activity against target cells bearing alloantigens not present on the stimulator spleen cells. In contrast to the other strains examined, DBA/1 (H-2q) spleen cells developed specific CL responses to either H-2b or H-2d alloantigens without exhibiting significant cross-reactive activity on the inappropriate target cell. The CL responses to H-2b and H-2d alloantigens by DBA/1 spleen cells were comparable in magnitude and had similar stimulator cell-dose requirements. Further, DBA/1 spleen cells developed CL responses of normal magnitude simultaneously against both target cells when incubated with both mitomycin C-treated C57BL/6 and DBA/2 stimulator cells.     

Characterization of dual-reactive H-2Kb-restricted anti-vesicular stomatitus virus and alloreactive cytotoxic T cells

Cross-reactive recognition of alloantigen by "self + X"-reactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) has been documented in a variety of systems. It has been shown previously that the H-2Kb-restricted CTL response of C57BL/6 (B6) mice to vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) infection is partially cross-reactive on uninfected target cells expressing the H-2Kbm8 mutation. In this report, we describe the isolation and detailed characterization of such dual-reactive CTL. By employing EL4 tumor lines transfected with genes encoding various VSV proteins, we demonstrated that the majority of dual-reactive CTL recognize the internal N protein of VSV and are also reactive against uninfected bm8 targets. Although the response of normal B6 mice to bm8 stimulators shows no measurable cross-reactivity on VSV-infected targets, the response of VSV-primed B6 mice to bm8 stimulation is almost entirely cross-reactive, lysing VSV-B6 targets and uninfected bm8 targets roughly equally. Furthermore, about 70% of CTL clones isolated from such mice by bm8 stimulation are dual-reactive with respect to effector function. Analysis at the population and clonal levels with cold target competition and antibody blocking suggests that the bulk of dual-reactive CTL have a higher avidity for VSV-B6 targets than for bm8 targets. The extreme case of this is illustrated by a fraction of CTL clones, isolated and maintained on bm8 stimulators, which lyse VSV-B6 targets but do not lyse bm8 targets. One such CTL clone is shown to be specific for the bm8 antigen in proliferation assays. These results demonstrate that: the specificity of an alloreactive CTL response may be dramatically altered by previous antigenic encounters; and dual-reactive CTL display a significant difference in affinity of the CTL receptor-determinant interaction, depending on the target which is recognized.     

Studies on the induction and expression of T cell-mediated immunity. IV. Non-overlapping populations of alloimmune cytotoxic lymphocytes with specificity for tumor-associated antigens and transplantation antigens.

Two non-overlapping populations of alloimmune cytotoxic T cells with specificity for tumor-associated antigens (TAA) and for histocompatibility antigens (H-2) were characterized by two independent methods. The heterogeneity of cytotoxic cells was demonstrated in spleen cells derived from BALB/c (H-2d) mice sensitized to EL-4 (H-2b) tumor and from C57BL/6 (H-2b) mice sensitized to G-35 (H-2d) tumor cells. Adsorption of immune lymphocytes on monolayers prepared with cells bearing the sensitizing H-2 antigens abrogated the in vitro cell-mediated cytotoxicity (CMC) directed against 51Cr-labeled normal target cells (spleen cells or ConA-activated spleen blasts), whereas significant cytolytic activity to the corresponding 51Cr-tumor cells was still retained. Likewise, in competitive inhibition assays, CMC to 51 Cr-tumor target cells was only partially inhibited by unlabeled normal cells, whereas CMC to 51Cr-normal target cells was completely abrogated. These results suggested that alloimmune cytotoxic lymphocytes are heterogeneous and can be subdivided into two independent populations of restricted specificity. Several experiments suggested that the effector cell population directed against TAA can no longer elicit a graft-vs-host (GVH) reaction in vivo. This was demonstrated by adoptive transfer into lethally-irradiated allogeneic recipients of cytotoxic or primed spleen cells fractionated on host target cell monolayers. Furthermore, these results demonstrated that both effector cells and memory cells possess high affinity binding receptors to corresponding H-2 antigens. The potential use of fractionated immune lymphocytes sensitized to tumor allografts in adoptive immunotherapy is discussed.     

Generation of cytotoxic T cells specific for minor histocompatibility antigens by cross challenge in vitro with H-2 disparate adherent cells

Although it is well known that an H-2-restricted cytotoxic T cell response to minor histocompatibility antigens (MIHA) can be primed in vivo with H-2 disparate spleen cells, it has not been previously possible to induce cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) precursors (CTLp) in vitro by this type of challenge. In this work, we demonstrate that the inability to cross challenge in vitro is due to the existence of inhibitory effects that can be obviated by cell fractionation, and to insufficient priming in vivo. BALB/c CTLp (H-2d) that have been repeatedly primed in vivo with B10.D2 can be challenged in vitro with C57BL10/J (H-2b) or B10.BR (H-2k)-adherent cells to generate CTL able to lyse B10.D2 (H-2d) target cells. The H-2 restriction properties of the cross-challenged CTL specific for MIHA were analyzed by using the technique of cold target competition. Within the limits of detection in bulk cultures, the entire response appeared to be H-2 unrestricted, whether the cross challenge was with intact C57BL10/J-adherent cells, or with membrane fragments of C57BL10/J presented by BALB/c adherent cells. The frequency of CTLp responsive to cross challenge was analyzed by limiting dilution, with cold target competition at each cell number to establish the restriction properties of the MIHA-specific CTL induced. We were able to detect two subsets of H-2-unrestricted CTLp responsive to intact C57BL10/J-adherent cells; one present at high frequency (1/250 T cells) and subject to suppressive effects at high cell number, and a second present at lower frequency (1/9800 T cells). There appeared to be a relatively infrequent subset of H-2-restricted CTLp as well (1/52,500 T cells). The frequency of CTLp responsive to cross challenge is of comparable magnitude to the frequency of H-2-restricted CTLp responsive to H-2-matched cells bearing MIHA. These observations are discussed in relationship to immunodominance and clonal dominance effects in the response to MIHA.     

Killing of mouse blastocyst stage embryos by cytotoxic T lymphocytes directed to major histocompatibility complex antigens

A new assay, mixed embryo leukocyte interaction assay, in which the ability of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) to kill preimplantation mouse embryos could be investigated, is described. CTL were generated both in vitro and in vivo to the H-2b and H-2d haplotypes. The specificity of the CTL was verified by using EL-4 (H-2b) and P815 (H-2d) target cells in a 51Cr-release assay. The cytolytic effect of the CTL on mouse blastocysts was measured by assessing blastocoel retention and inhibition of [3H]thymidine incorporation by the embryos. It was shown that CTL kill blastocyst stage embryos from C57BL/6J (H-2b) and B10.D2 (H-2d) mice with the zona pellucida removed, but not with the zona pellucida intact. These results demonstrate that the H-2 antigens present on mouse blastocysts can be recognized by CTL. It is suggested that one biologic role for the zona pellucida is the prevention of cell-mediated destruction of preimplantation embryos in utero.