Models for the complexes formed between cytochrome b5 and the subunits of methemoglobin

Computer graphics-generated models for the electron transfer complexes formed between cytochrome b5 and the subunits of methemoglobin are proposed. For both complexes, the orientation allowing optimal hydrogen bonding involves interaction between negatively charged residues on cytochrome b5 and positively charged residues on methemoglobin. In each complex, the heme groups of the interacting species are coplanar with the edges of the heme groups separated by 7-8 A and with the iron atoms 16 A apart. For the alpha-chain X cytochrome b5 complex, alpha-chain residues 56 (Lys), 60 (Lys), and 90 (Lys) interact with cytochrome b5 residues 44 (Glu), 43 (Glu), and 60 (Asp) respectively. A fourth hydrogen bond involves alpha-61 (Lys) bridging between a heme propionate from cytochrome b5 and a heme propionate from the alpha-chain. The contacts present in the beta-chain X cytochrome b5 complex involve hydrogen-bonding between beta-chain lysyl residues 59, 61, 65, and 95, and cytochrome b5 residues 48 (Glu), 44 (Glu), 43 (Glu), and 60 (Asp) respectively. An additional hydrogen bond can be formed by bridging of the epsilon-amino group of beta-66 (Lys) between a heme propionate from cytochrome b5 and a beta-chain heme propionate. In each complex, two nonionic interactions, one on each side of the heme groups, are also suggested. These interactions appear to effectively exclude external water molecules from the center of the protein-protein interaction domain. Comparison of the proposed binding loci for cytochrome b5 on the methemoglobin subunits with those proposed on cytochrome c reveals considerable structural homology between the cytochrome b5 binding sites.     

Covalent cross-linking of the active sites of vesicle-bound cytochrome b5 and NADH-cytochrome b5 reductase

A water-soluble carbodiimide has been used to promote the formation of amide bonds between carboxyl residues on cytochrome b5 and lysyl residues on cytochrome b5 reductase. The visible and UV absorption spectrum of the purified cross-linked complex was identical with the sum of the spectra of the individual enzymes, and the average apparent molecular weight of the complex, determined by sodium dodecyl sulfate-gel electrophoresis, was within 12% of the sum of the apparent molecular weights of the two monomeric enzymes, indicating that the cross-linked derivative was a dimer containing one molecule each of cytochrome b5 and cytochrome b5 reductase. When reconstituted into phospholipid vesicles, the amphipathic derivative showed substantially reduced Vmax values with the soluble electron acceptors potassium ferricyanide, cytochrome b5 heme peptide and cytochrome c, and with the membrane-bound acceptors amphipathic cytochrome b5 and stearyl-CoA desaturase. The soluble catalytic fragment of the derivative, produced by limited digestion with subtilisin Carlsberg, showed similar decreases in Vmax values with the above soluble acceptors. In contrast, intradimer electron transfer in the soluble fragment, measured by stopped flow spectrophotometry at 2 degrees C was very efficient. Ninety per cent of the cytochrome b5 in the derivative was reduced with a first order rate constant of 51 s-1 upon the addition of NADH; the transfer of electrons from NADH to the reductase FAD prosthetic group, which is known to be the rate-limiting step in the reductase reaction mechanism, proceeded with an apparent rate constant of 57 s-1 under these conditions. These kinetic data show that the enzymes in the complex are cross-linked together at the surfaces involved in protein-protein contacts during electron transfer in an orientation similar to that assumed during electron transfer between the free proteins.     

Mapping the electron transfer interface between cytochrome b5 and cytochrome c

To characterize the cytochrome b(5) (Cyt b(5))-cytochrome c (Cyt c) interactions during electron transfer, variants of Cyt b(5) have been employed to assess the contributions of electrostatic interactions (substitution of surface charged residues Glu44, Glu48, Glu56, and Asp60 and heme propionate), hydrophobic interactions, and the thermodynamic driving forces (substitutions for hydrophobic residues in heme pocket residues Phe35, Pro40, Val45, Phe58, and Val61). The electrostatic interactions play an important role in maintaining the stability and specificity of the Cyt b(5)-Cyt c complex that is formed. There is no essential effect on the intraprotein complex electron transfer even if most of the involved negatively charged residues on the surface of Cyt b(5) have been removed. The results support a dynamic docking paradigm for Cyt b(5)-Cyt c interactions. The orientation that is optimal for binding may not be optimal form for electron transfer. Substitution of hydrophobic residues does not have a significant effect on the binding between Cyt b(5) and Cyt c; rather, it regulates the electron transfer rates via changes in the driving force. Combining the electron transfer studies of the Cyt b(5)-Cyt c system and the Cyt b(5)-Zn-Cyt c system, we obtain the reorganization energy (0.6 eV) at an ionic strength of 150 mM.     

The role of individual lysine residues in the basic patch on turnip cytochrome f for electrostatic interactions with plastocyanin in vitro.

The role of electrostatic interactions in determining the rate of electron transfer between cytochrome f and plastocyanin has been examined in vitro with mutants of turnip cytochrome f and mutants of pea and spinach plastocyanins. Mutation of lysine residues Lys58, Lys65 and Lys187 of cytochrome f to neutral or acidic residues resulted in decreased binding constants and decreased rates of electron transfer to wild-type pea plastocyanin. Interaction of the cytochrome f mutant K187E with the pea plastocyanin mutant D51K gave a further decrease in electron transfer rate, indicating that a complementary charge pair at these positions could not compensate for the decreased overall charge on the proteins. Similar results were obtained with the interaction of the cytochrome f mutant K187E with single, double and triple mutants of residues in the acidic patches of spinach plastocyanin. These results suggest that the lysine residues of the basic patch on cytochrome f are predominantly involved in long-range electrostatic interactions with plastocyanin. However, analysis of the data using thermodynamic cycles provided evidence for the interaction of Lys187 of cytochrome f with Asp51, Asp42 and Glu43 of plastocyanin in the complex, in agreement with a structural model of a cytochrome f-plastocyanin complex determined by NMR.     

Characterization of lysyl residues of NADH-cytochrome b5 reductase implicated in charge-pairing with active-site carboxyl residues of cytochrome b5 by site-directed mutagenesis of an expression vector for the flavoprotein.

An expression vector for bovine NADH-cytochrome b5 reductase was constructed from two DNA fragments that were derived from beef liver poly(A+) RNA using the polymerase chain reaction. Site-directed mutagenesis of the 3 lysine residues of the reductase, previously implicated in the formation of active-site charge pairs with carboxylate residues of cytochrome b5, was then used to obtain the purified catalytic domains of flavoproteins modified at each of these sites. The observed marked decreases in catalytic efficiencies of substitutions of a negative charge at the normally positively charged residues with the catalytic domain of cytochrome b5 are consistent with their participation in the formation of charge pairs with carboxylate groups of the hemeprotein to optimize rapid electron transfer from the reductase flavin to the heme of the cytochrome.     

Association of cytochrome b5 and cytochrome P-450 reductase with cytochrome P-450 in the membrane of reconstituted vesicles

A protein-protein association of cytochrome P-450 LM2 with NADPH-cytochrome P-450 reductase, with cytochrome b5, and with both proteins was demonstrated in reconstituted phospholipid vesicles by magnetic circular dichroism difference spectra. A 23% decrease in the absolute intensity of the Soret band of the magnetic CD spectrum of cytochrome P-450 was observed when it was reconstituted with reductase. A difference spectrum corresponding to a 7% decrease in absolute intensity was obtained when cytochrome b5 was incorporated into vesicles that already contained cytochrome P-450 and cytochrome P-450 reductase compared to a decrease of 13% in absolute intensity when cytochrome b5 was incorporated into vesicles that contained only cytochrome P-450. The use of the magnetic circular dichroism confirmed that protein-protein associations that have been detected by absorption spectroscopy between purified and detergent-solubilized proteins also exist in membranes. High ionic strength was shown to interrupt direct electron flow from cytochrome P-450 reductase to cytochrome P-450 but not the electron flow from reductase through cytochrome b5 to cytochrome P-450. Upon incorporation of cytochrome b5 into cytochrome P-450- and cytochrome P-450 reductase-containing vesicles, an increase of benzphetamine N-demethylation activity was observed. The magnitude of this increase was numerically identical to the residual activity of the reconstituted vesicles measured in the presence of 0.3 M KCl. It is concluded that there is a requirement for at least one charge pairing for electron transfer from reductase to cytochrome P-450. These observations are combined in a proposed mechanism of coupled reversible association reactions in the membrane.     

Evidence of binary complex formations between cytochrome P-450, cytochrome b5, and NADPH-cytochrome P-450 reductase of hepatic microsomes

Water-soluble carbodiimide-catalyzed cross-linking of purified cytochrome P-450 LM2, cytochrome b5, and NADPH-cytochrome P-450 reductase was used to identify stable complexes formed between these proteins. High yields of P-450-b5 and P-450 reductase-b5 dimers, and lower yields of P-450 reductase-LM2 dimers were obtained. Substitution of native b5 and P-450 reductase with fully amidinated derivatives showed that LM2 and b5 were cross-linked exclusively through their respective amino and carboxyl groups. However, there appeared to be two complexation sites on the reductase which cross-link to b5 through amino groups and to LM2 through carboxyl groups respectively. A heterotrimer could not be identified following incubation of all three proteins together with EDC.     

Interaction between cytochrome c and cytochrome b5.

The reduction of cytochrome c by cytochrome b5 was studied over a wide range of ionic strengths in four different buffer systems. The reaction rate decreased linearly as the I1/2 was increased, suggesting that electrostatic interactions are important in the interaction. The ionic strength dependence of the reaction rate was in quantitative agreement with the theory of Wherland & Gray [Wherland, S., & Gray, H.B. (1976) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci U.S.A. 73, 2950] only if the effective radius of the interaction was 2 A. This indicates that the interaction between the two proteins is best described as the sum of n complementary charge interactions, each involving a specific lysine on cytochrome c and a specific carboxyl group on cytochrome b5. The number of complementary charge interactions, n, was calculated to be five to seven, in agreement with the results of our specific modification studies. Ultracentrifugation and gel permeation techniques were used to demonstrate that cytochrome b5 and cytochrome c formed a stable complex at low ionic strength.     

Biodiversity of the P450 catalytic cycle: yeast cytochrome b5/NADH cytochrome b5 reductase complex efficiently drives the entire sterol 14-demethylation (CYP51) reaction

The widely accepted catalytic cycle of cytochromes P450 (CYP) involves the electron transfer from NADPH cytochrome P450 reductase (CPR), with a potential for second electron donation from the microsomal cytochrome b5/NADH cytochrome b5 reductase system. The latter system only supported CYP reactions inefficiently. Using purified proteins including Candida albicans CYP51 and yeast NADPH cytochrome P450 reductase, cytochrome b5 and NADH cytochrome b5 reductase, we show here that fungal CYP51 mediated sterol 14alpha-demethylation can be wholly and efficiently supported by the cytochrome b5/NADH cytochrome b5 reductase electron transport system. This alternative catalytic cycle, where both the first and second electrons were donated via the NADH cytochrome b5 electron transport system, can account for the continued ergosterol production seen in yeast strains containing a disruption of the gene encoding CPR.     

Location of a cytochrome c binding site on the surface of flavocytochrome b 2

Saccharomyces cerevisiae flavocytochrome b ₂ couples the oxidation of L-lactate to the reduction of cytochrome c. The second-order rate constant for cytochrome c reduction by flavocytochrome b ₂ depends on the rate of complex formation and is sensitive to ionic strength. Mutations in the heme domain of flavocytochrome b ₂ (Glu63→Lys, Asp72→Lys and the double mutation Glu63→Lys:Asp72→Lys) have significant effects on the reaction with cytochrome c, implicating these residues in complex formation. This kinetic information has been used to guide molecular modelling studies, which are consistent with there being no one single best-configuration. Rather, there is a set of possible complexes in which the docking-face of cytochrome c can approach flavocytochrome b ₂ in a variety of orientations. Four cytochromes c can be accommodated on the flavocytochrome b ₂ tetramer, with each cytochrome c forming interactions with only one flavocytochrome b ₂ subunit. All the models involve residues 72 and 63 on flavocytochrome b ₂ but in addition predict that Glu237 may also be important for complex formation. These acidic residues interact with the basic residues 13, 27 and 79 on cytochrome c. Through this triangle of interactions runs a possible σ-tunnelling pathway for electron transfer. This pathway starts with the imidazole ring of His66 (a ligand to the heme-iron of flavocytochrome b ₂) and ends with the ring of Pro68, which is in van der Waals contact with the cytochrome c heme. In total, the edge-to-edge "through space" distance from the imidazole ring of His66 to the C3C pyrrole ring of cytochrome c is 13.1?Å.     

The roles of cytochrome b5 in cytochrome P450 reactions

Cytochrome b(5), a 17-kDa hemeprotein associated primarily with the endoplasmic reticulum of eukaryotic cells, has long been known to augment some cytochrome P450 monooxygenase reactions, but the mechanism of stimulation has remained controversial. Studies in recent years have clarified this issue by delineating three pathways by which cytochrome b(5) augments P450 reactions: direct electron transfer of both required electrons from NADH-cytochrome b(5) reductase to P450, in a pathway separate and independent of NADPH-cytochrome P450 reductase; transfer of the second electron to oxyferrous P450 from either cytochrome b(5) reductase or cytochrome P450 reductase; and allosteric stimulation of P450 without electron transfer. Evidence now indicates that each of these pathways is likely to operate in vivo.     

Transfer of cytochrome b 5 and NADPH cytochrome c reductase between membranes

NADPH-cytochrome c reductase also reduces cytochrome b 5. The reduction is very slow when the proteins are in solution or bound to different membranes. Only when both proteins share a common membrane, is cytochrome b 5 reduced rapidly by NADPH. The difference in reaction rates indicates recombination on a common membrane of cytochrome b 5 and NADPH reductase originally bound to different vesicles. The recombination of the two proteins occurs with a variety of biological membranes (previously enriched with either reductase or cytochrome b 5) as well as with liposomes. We explain this process as protein transfer rather than vesicle fusion for several reasons: 1. The vesicles do not alter shape or size during incubation. 2. The rate of this process corresponds to the rate of incorporation of the single proteins into liposomes carrying the 'complementary' protein. 3. The exchange of proteins between biological membranes and liposomes occupied by protein does not change the density of either membrane. Protein transfer between membranes appears to be limited to those proteins which had spontaneously recombined with a preformed membrane. In contrast, proteins incorporated into liposomes by means of a detergent were not transferred, nor were endogenous cytochrome b 5 and NADPH-cytochrome c reductase transferred from microsomes to Golgi membranes or lipid vesicles. We conclude that the endogenous proteins and proteins incorporated in the presence of a detergent are linked to the membrane in another manner than the same proteins which had been inserted into a preformed membrane.     

Effects of charged amino-acid mutation on the solution structure of cytochrome b5 and binding between cytochrome b5 and cytochrome c

The solution structure of oxidized bovine microsomal cytochrome b(5) mutant (E48, E56/A, D60/A) has been determined through 1524 meaningful nuclear Overhauser effect constraints together with 190 pseudocontact shift constraints. The final family of 35 conformers has rmsd values with respect to the mean structure of 0.045+/-0.009 nm and 0.088+/-0.011 nm for backbone and heavy atoms, respectively. A characteristic of this mutant is that of having no significant changes in the whole folding and secondary structure compared with the X-ray and solution structures of wild-type cytochrome b(5). The binding of different surface mutants of cytochrome b(5) with cytochrome c shows that electrostatic interactions play an important role in maintaining the stability and specificity of the protein complex formed. The differences in association constants demonstrate the electrostatic contributions of cytochrome b(5) surface negatively charged residues, which were suggested to be involved in complex formation in the Northrup and Salemme models, have cumulative effect on the stability of cyt c-cyt b(5) complex, and the contribution of Glu48 is a little higher than that of Glu44. Moreover, our result suggests that the docking geometry proposed by Northrup, which is involved in the participation of Glu48, Glu56, Asp60, and heme propionate of cytochrome b(5), do occur in the association between cytochrome b(5) and cytochrome c.     

Expression of outer mitochondrial membrane cytochrome b 5 in Escherichia coli. Purification of the recombinant protein and studies of its interaction with electron-transfer partners

In the present work, we report expression in Escherichia coli, purification, and characterization of recombinant full-length cytochrome b(5) from outer mitochondrial membrane. Optimization of expression conditions for cytochrome b(5) from outer mitochondrial membrane allowed reaching expression level up to 10(4) nmol of the hemeprotein per liter of culture. Recombinant cytochrome b(5) from outer mitochondrial membrane was purified from cell lysate by using metal-affinity chromatography. It has physicochemical, spectral, and immunochemical properties similar to those of cytochrome b(5) from rat liver outer mitochondrial membrane. Immobilized recombinant mitochondrial cytochrome b(5) was used as affinity ligand to study its interaction with electron transfer proteins. By using this approach, it is shown that in interaction of NADPH:cytochrome P450 reductase with both forms of cytochrome b(5) an important role is played by hydrophobic interactions between proteins, although the contribution of these interactions in complex formation with NADPH:cytochrome P450 reductase is different for isoforms of cytochrome b(5).     

Effect of KCl on the interactions between NADPH:cytochrome P-450 reductase and either cytochrome c, cytochrome b5 or cytochrome P-450 in octyl glucoside micelles.

Significant dissociation of FMN from NADPH:cytochrome P-450 reductase resulted in loss of the activity for reduction of cytochrome b5 as well as cytochrome c and cytochrome P-450. However, the ability to reduce these electron acceptors was greatly restored upon incubation of FMN-depleted enzyme with added FMN. The reductions of cytochrome c and detergent-solubilized cytochrome b5 by NADPH:cytochrome P-450 reductase were greatly increased in the presence of high concentrations of KCl, although the stimulatory effect of the salt on cytochrome P-450 reduction was less significant. No apparent effect of superoxide dismutase could be seen on the rate or extent of cytochrome reduction in solutions containing high-salt concentrations. Complex formation of the flavoprotein with cytochrome c, which is known to be involved in the mechanism of non-physiological electron transfer, caused a perturbation in the absorption spectrum in the Soret-band region of cytochrome c, and its magnitude was enhanced by addition of KCl. Similarly, an appreciable increase in ellipticity in the Soret band of cytochrome c was observed upon binding with the flavoprotein. However, only small changes were found in absorption and circular dichroism spectra for the complex of NADPH:cytochrome P-450 reductase with either cytochrome b5 or cytochrome P-450. It is suggested that the high-salt concentration allows closer contact between the heme and flavin prosthetic groups through hydrophobic-hydrophobic interactions rather than electrostatic-charge pairing between the flavoprotein and the cytochrome which causes a faster rate of electron transfer. Neither alterations in the chemical shift nor in the line width of the bound FMN and FAD phosphate resonances were observed upon complex formation of NADPH:cytochrome P-450 reductase with the cytochrome.     

Structure of an electron transfer complex. I. Covalent cross-linking of cytochrome c peroxidase and cytochrome c

Cytochrome c peroxidase and cytochrome c form a noncovalent electron transfer complex in the course of the peroxidase-catalyzed reduction of H2O2. The two hemoproteins were cross-linked in 40% yield to a covalent 1:1 complex with the aid of 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)carbodiimide. The covalent complex was found to be a valid model of the noncovalent electron transfer complex for the following reasons. The covalent complex had only 5% residual peroxidase activity toward exogeneous ferrocytochrome c indicating that the cross-linked cytochrome c covers the electron-accepting site of cytochrome c peroxidase. The residual peroxidase activity was almost independent of ionic strength indicating that the electron-accepting site is much less accessible even when ionic bonds between the two cross-linked hemoproteins are severed. The rate of reduction of heme c by ascorbate is 15 times slower in the covalent complex than in free cytochrome c and is independent of ionic strength. Although the covalent complex may not have been entirely pure with respect to the number and location of the cross-links, two major cross-links could be localized to within a few residues. One is from Lys 13 of cytochrome c to an acidic residue in positions 32, 33, 34, 35, or 37 of cytochrome c peroxidase, the other from Lys 86 of cytochrome c to a carboxyl group in the same cluster of acidic residues. The result stresses the importance of a peculiar stretch of acidic residues of cytochrome c peroxidase and of Lys 13 and 86 of cytochrome c.     

The binding sites on human heme oxygenase-1 for cytochrome p450 reductase and biliverdin reductase

Human heme oxygenase-1 (hHO-1) catalyzes the NADPH-cytochrome P450 reductase-dependent oxidation of heme to biliverdin, CO, and free iron. The biliverdin is subsequently reduced to bilirubin by biliverdin reductase. Earlier kinetic studies suggested that biliverdin reductase facilitates the release of biliverdin from hHO-1 (Liu, Y., and Ortiz de Montellano, P. R. (2000) J. Biol. Chem. 275, 5297-5307). We have investigated the binding of P450 reductase and biliverdin reductase to truncated, soluble hHO-1 by fluorescence resonance energy transfer and site-specific mutagenesis. P450 reductase and biliverdin reductase bind to truncated hHO-1 with Kd = 0.4 +/- 0.1 and 0.2 +/- 0.1 microm, respectively. FRET experiments indicate that biliverdin reductase and P450 reductase compete for binding to truncated hHO-1. Mutation of surface ionic residues shows that hHO-1 residues Lys18, Lys22, Lys179, Arg183, Arg198, Glu19, Glu127, and Glu190 contribute to the binding of cytochrome P450 reductase. The mutagenesis results and a computational analysis of the protein surfaces partially define the binding site for P450 reductase. An overlapping binding site including Lys18, Lys22, Lys179, Arg183, and Arg185 is similarly defined for biliverdin reductase. These results confirm the binding of biliverdin reductase to hHO-1 and define binding sites of the two reductases.     

Binding of cytochrome c2 to the isolated reaction center of Rhodospirillum rubrum involves the "backside" of cytochrome c2

Lys 109, Lys 112 and Glu 1 of cytochrome c2 from Rhodospirillum rubrum G-9 are about 4-fold less reactive towards acetic anhydride when cytochrome c2 is bound to the isolated photosynthetic reaction center from the same organism. The three shielded residues are clustered together on the "backside" of cytochrome c2. This contrasts with mitochondrial cytochrome c where "frontside" lysines are protected by different physiological electron transfer partners.     

Double mutant studies identify electrostatic interactions that are important for docking cytochrome c2 onto the bacterial reaction center

Cytochrome c2 (cyt) is the mobile electron donor to the reaction center (RC) in photosynthetic bacteria. The electrostatic interactions involved in the dynamics of docking of cyt onto the RC were examined by double mutant studies of the rates of electron transfer between six modified Rhodobacter sphaeroides RCs in which negatively charged acid residues were replaced with Lys and five modified Rhodobacter capsulatus Cyt c2 molecules in which positively charged Lys residues were replaced with Glu. We measured the second-order rate constant, k2, for electron transfer from the reduced cyt to the oxidized primary donor on the RC, which reflects the energy of the transition state for the formation of the active electron transfer complex. Strong interactions were found between Lys C99 and Asp M184/Glu M95, and between Lys C54 and Asp L261/Asp L257. The interacting residues were found to be located close to each other in the recently determined crystal structure of the cyt-RC complex [Axelrod, H., et al. (2002) J. Mol. Biol. (in press)]. The interaction energies were approximately inversely proportional to the distances between charges. These results support earlier suggestions [Tetreault, M., et al. (2001) Biochemistry 40, 8452-8462] that the structure of the transition state in solution resembles the structure of the cyt-RC complex in the cocrystal and indicate that specific electrostatic interactions facilitate docking of the cyt onto the RC in a configuration optimized for both binding and electron transfer. The specific interaction between Asp M184 and Lys C99 may help to nucleate short-range hydrophobic contacts.     

Reduction of cytochrome b5 by NADPH-cytochrome P450 reductase

The reduction of mammalian cytochrome b5 (b5) by NADPH-cytochrome P450 (P450) reductase is involved in a number of biological reactions. The kinetics of the process have received limited consideration previously, and a combination of pre-steady-state (stopped-flow) and steady-state approaches was used to investigate the mechanism of b5 reduction. In the absence of detergent or lipid, a reductase-b5 complex is formed and rearranges slowly to an active form. Electron transfer to b5 is rapid within this complex (>30 s(-1) at 23 degrees C), as fast as to cytochrome c. With excess b5 present, a burst of reduction is observed, consistent with rapid electron transfer to one or two b5 molecules per reductase, followed by a subsequent rate-limiting event. In detergent vesicles, the reductase and b5 interact rapidly but electron transfer is slower (approximately 3 s(-1) at 23 degrees C). Experiments with dimyristyl lecithin vesicles yielded results intermediate between the non-vesicle and detergent systems. These steady-state and pre-steady-state kinetics provide views of the different natures of the reduction of b5 by the reductase in the absence and presence of vesicles. Without vesicles, the encounter of the reductase and b5 is rapid, followed by a slow reorganization of the initial complex (approximately 0.07 s(-1)), very fast reduction, and dissociation. In vesicles, encounter is rapid and the slow step (approximately 3 s(-1)) is reduction within a complex less favorable for reduction than in the non-vesicle systems.