A current 10-year retrospective survey of 199 surgically treated orbital floor fractures in a nonurban tertiary care center.

This study characterizes the surgically treated patient population suffering from orbital floor fractures by use of current data from a large series consisting of 199 cases taken from a nonurban setting. Data were gathered through a retrospective chart review of patients surgically treated for orbital floor fractures at the University of Michigan Health System, collected over a 10-year period. Data regarding patient demographics, signs and symptoms of presentation, cause of injury, nature of injury, associated facial fractures, ocular injury, and associated nonfacial skeleton trauma were collected. In total, there were 199 cases of orbital floor fractures among 189 patients. Male patients outnumbered female patients by a 2:1 ratio and were found to engage in a wider range of behaviors that resulted in orbital floor fractures. Motor vehicle accidents were the leading cause of orbital floor fractures, followed by physical assault and sports-related mechanisms. The ratio of impure to pure orbital floor fracture was 3:1. The most common signs and symptoms associated with orbital floor fractures, in descending order, were periorbital ecchymosis, diplopia, subconjunctival hemorrhage, and enophthalmos. Associated facial fractures were found in 77.2 percent of patients, the most prevalent of which was the zygoma-malar fracture. Serious ocular injury occurred in 19.6 percent of patients, with globe rupture being the most prevalent, accounting for 40.5 percent of those injuries. There was a 38.1 percent occurrence of associated nonfacial skeletal trauma; skull fracture and intracranial injury were the most prevalent manifestations. Associated cervical-spine fractures were rare (0.5 percent). Statistical examination, using odds ratios and chi-squared analysis, demonstrated significant associations that have not previously been reported. Impure and pure orbital floor fractures revealed striking differences in several demographic aspects, including mechanism of injury, signs and symptoms of presentation, spectrum of associated trauma, and the severity of concomitant trauma.     

Pure orbital blowout fracture: new concepts and importance of medial orbital blowout fracture.

Pure orbital blowout fracture first occurs at the weakest point of the orbital wall. Although the medial orbital wall theoretically should be involved more frequently than the orbital floor, the orbital floor has been reported as the most common site of pure orbital blowout fractures. A total of 82 orbits in 76 patients with pure orbital blowout fracture were evaluated with computed tomographic scans taken on all patients with any suspicious clinical evidence, including nasal fracture. Isolated medial wall fracture was most common (55 percent), followed by medial and inferior wall fracture (27 percent). The most common facial fracture associated with medial wall fracture was nasal fracture (51 percent), not inferior wall fracture (33 percent). This finding suggests that the force causing nasal fracture is an important causative factor of pure medial wall fracture as the buckling force from the medial orbital rim. Of patients with medial wall fractures, 25 percent had diplopia and 40 percent had enophthalmos. On plain radiographs, diagnostic signs were found in 79 percent of medial wall fractures and in 95 percent of inferior wall fractures. On computed tomographic scans, late enophthalmos was expected in 76 percent of medial wall fractures. Therefore, the medial orbital blowout fracture may be an important cause of late enophthalmos, because it has a high incidence of occurrence, a low diagnostic rate, and a high severity of defect. Among the causes of limitation of ocular motility, muscle traction of the connective septa and direct muscle injury were found frequently, but true incarceration of the muscle was extremely rare in all fractures. The medial and inferior orbital walls are clearly demarcated by the bony buttress, which is an important structure supporting these orbital walls. Its buttress was closely correlated with the fracture of these orbital walls. Most orbital blowout fractures without collapse of the bony buttress had a trapdoor fracture with or without small fragments of punched-out fracture.     

Orbital roof fractures in the pediatric population

Twenty-three patients aged 3.3 +/- 1.6 years (mean +/- SD) presented between January of 1984 and September of 1987 with fronto-orbital trauma resulting in fractures of one (N = 20) or both (N = 3) orbital roofs. All patients had computed tomography (CT) with axial and coronal sections that revealed three fracture patterns of the orbital roof (nondisplaced, superiorly displaced, and inferiorly displaced fractures). Orbital dystopia was exhibited in 35 percent (N = 8) of the patients. Exophthalmos was noted in 61 percent (N = 14) of the patients. Only 30 percent of the patients (N = 7) sustained associated maxillofacial fractures. Eight percent of fractures exhibited orbital encephaloceles. All patients lacked frontal sinus pneumatization. The majority of children with orbital roof fractures do not exhibit concomitant facial fractures. CT utilizing both axial and coronal sections is valuable in defining the extent and pattern of the fracture as well as in identifying associated neurologic injuries. Large, displaced orbital roof fractures, which occurred in 3 of 13 patients with displaced fractures in our series, should undergo early reduction to avoid late development of encephalocele.     

Infraorbital nerve injury associated with zygoma fractures: documentation with neurosensory testing

Persistent sensibility abnormalities after correction of zygoma fractures indicate injury to the infraorbital nerve and may produce pain. To investigate this, a retrospective study of 25 patients who had undergone surgical correction of a zygoma fracture was performed. Bilateral neurosensory measurements were obtained with the Pressure-Specified Sensory Device (Sensory Management Services, Baltimore, Md.). Seven of the 25 patients had required orbital floor reconstruction. Each patient had undergone fracture correction at least 6 months earlier and was interviewed, at the time of sensibility testing, regarding symptoms related to the fracture. The data were evaluated by a blinded examiner, from a separate clinical facility, who attempted to predict the side of the fracture and the degree of zygoma displacement on the basis of measurements of sensibility of the paranasal, upper lip, and zygomaticotemporal areas. Seventy-six percent of patients demonstrated abnormal sensibility on the side of the zygoma fracture, compared with the contralateral side. Sensibility was abnormal for 100 percent of the patients who required orbital floor reconstruction. Seventy-four percent of patients with abnormal sensibility reported symptoms related to the fracture. Eighty percent of the zygoma fractures were correctly identified, with respect to the side of the fracture, by the blinded examiner on the basis of the neurosensory measurements alone (p < 0.005). Predictions proved correct for 91 percent of the patients with widely displaced fractures and none of the patients with nondisplaced fractures. The results of this study suggest that neurosensory testing is an important clinical adjunct for the evaluation of patients with facial pain or dysesthesia after facial fracture reconstruction. The results suggest the need to develop algorithms for the diagnosis and treatment of trigeminal nerve injuries after craniofacial trauma. This approach could also be applicable to dysesthesia or pain after aesthetic facial surgical procedures.     

Reconstruction of internal orbital fractures with Vitallium mesh

Trauma to the face frequently results in internal orbital fractures that may produce large orbital defects involving multiple walls. Accurate anatomic reconstruction of the bony orbit is essential to maintain normal appearance and function of the eye following such injuries. Autogenous bone grafts do not always produce predictable long-term support of the globe. Displacement and varying amounts of bone-graft resorption can lead to enophthalmos. This study examines the use of Vitallium mesh in the acute reconstruction of internal orbital defects. Fifty-four patients with 66 orbits underwent reconstruction of internal orbital defects with Vitallium mesh. Associated fractures were anatomically reduced and rigidly fixed. Forty-six patients and 57 orbits had adequate follow-up for analysis of results. The average follow-up was 9 months, with 85 percent of the patients followed 6 months or longer. There were no postoperative orbital infections, and none of the Vitallium mesh required removal. Large internal orbital defects can be reconstructed using Vitallium mesh with good results and little risk of infection. Vitallium mesh appears to be well tolerated in spite of free communication with the sinuses. Stable reconstruction of the internal orbit can be achieved and predictable eye position maintained without donor-site morbidity.     

Management of the medial canthal tendon in nasoethmoid orbital fractures: the importance of the central fragment in classification and treatment

The medial canthal tendon and the fragment of bone on which it inserts ("central" fragment) are the critical factors in the diagnosis and treatment of nasoethmoid orbital fractures. The status of the tendon, the tendon-bearing bone segment, and the fracture pattern define a clinically useful classification system. Three patterns of fracture are appreciated: type I--single-segment central fragment; type II--comminuted central fragment with fractures remaining external to the medial canthal tendon insertion; and type III--comminuted central fragment with fractures extending into bone bearing the canthal insertion. Injuries are further classified as unilateral and bilateral and by their extension into other anatomic areas. The fracture pattern determines exposure and fixation. Inferior approaches alone are advised for unilateral single-segment injuries that are nondisplaced superiorly. Superior and inferior approaches are required for displaced unilateral single-segment injuries, for bilateral single-segment injuries, and for all comminuted fractures. Complete interfragment wiring of all segments is stabilized by junctional rigid fixation. All comminuted fractures require transnasal wiring of the bones of the medial orbital rim (medial canthal tendon-bearing or "central" bone fragment). If the fracture does not extend through the canthal insertion, the canthus should not be detached to accomplish the reduction.     

Reconstruction of orbital floor fracture using solvent-preserved bone graft

The orbital floor is one of the most frequently damaged parts of the maxillofacial skeleton during facial trauma. Unfavorable aesthetic and functional outcomes are frequent when it is treated inadequately. The treatment consists of spanning the floor defect with a material that can provide structural support and restore the orbital volume. This material should also be biocompatible with the surrounding tissues and easily reshaped to fit the orbital floor. Although various autografts or synthetic materials have been used, there is still no consensus on the ideal reconstruction method of orbital floor defects. This study evaluated the applicability of solvent-preserved cadaveric cranial bone graft and its preliminary results in the reconstruction of the orbital floor fractures. Twenty-five orbital floor fractures of 21 patients who underwent surgical repair with cadaveric bone graft during a 2-year period were included in this study. Pure blowout fractures were determined in nine patients, whereas 12 patients had other accompanying maxillofacial fractures. Of the 21 patients, 14 had clinically evident diplopia (66.7 percent), 12 of them had enophthalmos (57.1 percent), and two of them had gaze restriction preoperatively. Reconstruction of the floor of the orbit was performed following either the subciliary or the transconjunctival approach. A cranial allograft was placed over the defect after sufficient exposure. The mean follow-up period was 9 months. Postoperative diplopia, enophthalmos, eye motility, cosmetic appearance, and complications were documented. None of the patients had any evidence of diplopia, limited eye movement, inflammatory reactions in soft tissues, infection, or graft extrusion in the postoperative period. Providing sufficient orbital volume, no graft resorption was detected in computed tomography scan controls. None of the implants required removal for any reason. Enophthalmos was seen in one patient, and temporary scleral show lasting up to 3 to 6 weeks was detected in another three patients. Satisfactory cosmetic results were obtained in all patients. This study showed that solvent-preserved bone, which is a nonsynthetic, human-originated, processed bioimplant, can be safely used in orbital floor repair and can be considered as another reliable treatment alternative.     

Volkmann's contracture of the extraocular muscles following blowout fracture

In the past decade there has been considerable controversy over the surgical indications for treatment of blowout fractures of the orbit. It has been well recognized that some fracture patients develop an ischemic contracture of the inferior rectus muscle. We have found that a Volkmann's type of contracture of the inferior rectus muscle does exist and is similar to that found in the distal extremities. A specific group of fracture patients is at greater risk for development of a contracture. Elderly patients, hypotensive patients, patients with small fractures, and those with high inferior rectus compartment pressures are more prone to developing a contracted extraocular muscle. We have measured compartment pressures in 18 patients who were surgical candidates following orbital fracture. Our conclusions indicate that surgical intervention following blowout fractures in these high-risk patients may be more prudent than medical management. Patients with persistent diplopia due to a contracted inferior rectus are extremely difficult to treat many months after fracture. We still believe it prudent to surgically repair orbital fractures in patients with diplopia, enophthalmos, and a risk for muscle contracture. The documentation of this additional sequela of unrepaired fractures lends more strength to this belief. There is no evidence to indicate that a Volkmann's contracture would be possible after early repair of a blowout fracture.     

Trapdoor fracture of the orbit in a pediatric population

Orbital-floor blowout fractures of the trapdoor variety, first described by Soll and Poley, have also appeared in the French and Japanese literature. The trapdoor fracture is described as a pure orbital-floor fracture, linear in form and hinged medially, which allows herniation of orbital contents through the fracture and then entraps these herniated contents. A review of the orbital-floor fracture literature reveals a high incidence of persistent diplopia associated with ocular-muscle entrapment, which may later necessitate corrective surgery of extraocular muscles. Recent publications in the ophthalmologic literature have stressed the importance of early surgical intervention. This article reports a retrospective series of 19 pediatric patients (age range, 5 to 16 years) who presented to two institutions. All patients had radiographic confirmation of a trapdoor fracture. Physical examination demonstrated a high association between these fractures and restricted ocular motility (17 of the 19 patients). In the cases with trapdoor fracture and restricted ocular movement, early intervention was associated with better postoperative function. It is thus recommended that the symptomatic trapdoor orbit fracture be considered an urgent indication for surgical intervention. Practitioners therefore must have a high index of suspicion for these injuries. Prompt diagnosis is critical to maximize clinical outcome.     

Facial fractures from dog bite injuries

Dog bites are commonly associated with soft-tissue injury to the face but rarely result in facial fractures. This article reports six new cases of facial fractures associated with dog bites and reviews additional cases reported in the literature. The demographics of the patients attacked, the location of facial fractures, and the characteristics of associated soft-tissue injuries or complications developing from the dog bite are described. With six new cases and 10 from the literature, this article reviewed a total of 16 cases involving 27 facial fractures. Eighty-seven percent of the cases involved children less than 16 years of age. The periorbital or nasal bones were involved in 69 percent of the cases. Lacerations were the most frequently associated soft-tissue injury. Additional injuries included facial nerve damage, lacrimal duct damage requiring stenting and reconstruction, ptosis from levator transection, and blood loss requiring transfusion. Although facial fractures are not commonly considered to be associated with dog bite injuries, the index of suspicion for a fracture should be raised when the injury occurs in a child, particularly when injury occurs near the orbit, nose, and cheek.     

Mechanisms of extraocular muscle injury in orbital fractures

The gross and microscopic events that occur after orbital blowout fractures were evaluated to assess the mechanisms of diplopia and muscle injury. Intramuscular and intraorbital pressures were evaluated in experimental animals, in cadavers, and at the time of orbital fracture explorations for repair of orbital fractures in humans. Histologic and circulatory changes, muscle pressure recordings, and operative observations were evaluated. Creation of a compartment syndrome was evaluated to include a histologic evaluation of the orbital fibrous sheath network for the extraocular muscles and the intramuscular vasculature. These experiments and observations do not support the role of a compartment syndrome in ocular motility disturbances because (1) intramuscular pressures were subcritical in both humans and animals; (2) no limiting fascial compartment could be demonstrated; and (3) microangiograms and histologic evaluations did not confirm areas of compartmental ischemic necrosis. Muscle contusion, scarring within and around the orbital fibrous sheath network, nerve contusion, and incarceration within fractures remain the probable causes of diplopia, with the most likely explanations being muscle contusion and fibrosis or incarceration involving the muscular fascial network.     

Transcaruncular orbital decompression for management of compressive optic neuropathy in thyroid-related orbitopathy

This study was conducted to assess the outcome of transcaruncular orbital decompression to treat compressive optic neuropathy in thyroid-related orbitopathy. It involved a retrospective, noncomparative case series of 18 eyes of 10 consecutive patients with documented vision loss secondary to thyroid-related orbitopathy. Bony decompression of the orbital apex was performed via a transcaruncular approach. Main outcome measures were visual acuity, color vision, presence of diplopia, and reduction of exophthalmos. Of 18 eyes, 16 (89 percent) had improved visual acuity after the operation. One eye had no improvement and one had worsening of vision in the setting of diabetic retinopathy. Color vision was improved in 12 eyes (67 percent). Five of the patients did not have diplopia before the operation; none of these patients developed double vision after intervention. Exophthalmos was decreased by an average of 2.6 mm. The authors conclude that transcaruncular orbital decompression for compressive optic neuropathy in thyroid-related orbitopathy is successful in restoring visual function. Compared with other approaches used for decompression surgery, the transcaruncular approach offers direct access to the medial wall and orbital apex without a cutaneous incision or disruption of the medial canthus. In addition, this approach allows a controlled, graded removal of the ethmoidal air cells and reduced recovery time.     

Blowout Fractures of the Floor of the Orbit

Blowout fractures of the orbit, a frequent complication of midfacial trauma, result from an increased intraorbital pressure which “blows out” the weakest area—the floor. Intraorbital fat and muscles herniated into the maxillary sinus, muscles incarcerated in the fracture, and the displaced orbital contents produce diplopia. After incarceration, elevation of the affected eye is impossible.Diagnosis is frequently difficult because initial intraorbital hemorrhage may limit mobility. Tomograms in the Waters'' projection may show the fracture but frequently reveal only a cloudy antrum. The muscle traction test described herein is most helpful.The surgical correction aims at bridging the defect with Teflon or stainless-steel mesh or endogenous bone graft placed beneath the periosteum. Entry is gained through the lower lid. If repaired early, there is no functional loss and the repair is cosmetically excellent.     

Primary and secondary orbit surgery: the transconjunctival approach

The transconjunctival approach to the orbit is underutilized because of concern regarding inadequate exposure and higher postoperative rates of lower eyelid shortening and ectropion. All patients who had a transconjunctival incision performed for orbital surgery over the last 6 years (1990 to 1996) were studied. Patients who had a transconjunctival blepharoplasty were excluded. A total of 35 patients, average age 32 years, had 45 transconjunctival incisions performed. Lateral canthotomy or cantholysis was not done. Operations fell into three categories: fracture plating alone, 10 (22 percent); split-calvarial bone graft placement with or without plating, 26 (58 percent); and orbital decompression, 9 (20 percent). The overall incidence of ectropion was 6.7 percent (3 of 45). One patient (2 percent) had transient ectropion, and two patients (4 percent) had persistent ectropion, which required surgical correction. Ectropion occurred only in those lower eyelids that had a previous transcutaneous incision (3 of 18 = 17 percent). None occurred in those eyelids that had no prior incision or only a previous transconjunctival incision. The transconjunctival approach without a lateral canthotomy provides safe access to the orbit in eyelids that have not had a previous transconjunctival incision.     

Paget's disease with orbital involvement: a review and case report

Paget's disease (osteitis deformans) is characterized by localized deformation of bone leading to structural abnormalities with secondary pain, fractures and nerve compression. A Paget's patient with exophthalmos, a displaced globe, restricted muscle fields, diplopia and superior oblique entrapment secondary to deformation of the frontal bone is presented. The clinical features, ocular complications and treatment of Paget's disease is discussed.     

Endoscopic endonasal reconstruction of blowout fractures of the medial orbital walls

High-resolution endoscopes and the advent of endoscopic instruments for sinus surgery currently provide surgeons with excellent endonasal visualization and access to the medial orbital walls. The purpose of this study was to demonstrate the reduction of medial orbital wall fractures through an endonasal endoscopic approach that allows the repair of the medial orbital wall fractures without an external incision. This study was a retrospective analysis of 16 patients who underwent surgical repair of medial orbital wall fractures from March of 1997 to May of 1998. The 11 male and five female patients ranged in age from 16 to 54 years (mean, 30.5 years). These patients had undergone primary reduction of medial orbital wall fractures and were observed for at least 12 months after surgery. There were no intraoperative or postoperative complications. Fifteen of 16 patients showed a complete improvement of their symptoms. One patient showed persistent diplopia, which was well managed by prisms. Endoscopic reduction of medial orbital wall fracture using an endonasal approach seems to produce good results and definite cosmetic advantages.     

A computational study of the passive mechanisms of eye restraint during head impact trauma

A finite element model of the eye and the orbit was used to examine the hypothesis that the orbital fat provides an important mechanism of eye stability during head trauma. The model includes the globe, the orbital fat, the extra-ocular muscles, and the optic nerve. MRI images of an adult human orbit were used to generate an idealized geometry of the orbital space. The globe was approximated as a sphere 12 mm in radius. The optic nerve and the sclera were represented as thin shells, whereas the vitreous and the orbital fat were represented as nearly incompressible solids of low stiffness. The orbital bone was modelled as a rigid shell. Frontal head impact resulting from a fall onto a hard floor was simulated by prescribing to the orbital bone a triangular acceleration pulse of 200 g (1962 m/s(2)) peak for a duration of 4.5 ms. The results show that the fat provides the crucial passive mechanism of eye restraint. The mechanism is a consequence of the fact that the fat is incompressible and that its motion is restricted by the rigidity of the orbital walls. Thus, the acceleration loads of short duration cannot generate significant distortion of the fat. In contrast, the passive muscles provide little support to the globe. When the connection between the orbital fat and the eye is absent the eye is held mainly by the optic nerve. We discuss the possible role that this loss of contact may have in some cases of the evulsion of the eye and the optic nerve.     

Endoscopic endonasal reduction for blowout fracture of the medial orbital wall

Endoscopic endonasal reductions have been addressed in 63 patients with blowout fracture of the medial orbital wall since 1992. The operations were carried out under general anesthesia with a magnified operative space projected on a television monitor by a charge coupled device video camera attached to the endoscope. The middle nasal turbinate was fractured toward the nasal septum, the uncinate process was cut off, and the bulla was opened. The ethmoidal bony partition and the mucous membrane were removed; however, the fractured bone chips of the medial orbital wall were preserved. The herniated orbital contents were pressed back into the orbital cavity, and the medial wall was set with 2-mm-thick bent silicone plates placed in the ethmoidal sinus. The plates were removed in the outpatient clinic 2 months after the operation. The surgical results of 21 patients treated with endoscopic reduction were compared with those of four patients treated with transfacial reduction with an iliac bone graft. All of the patients had isolated medial wall fracture and became aware of diplopia within 15 degrees in any direction from the primary position (straight gaze) before the operation; the follow-up period covered 6 months. The patients were classified into two categories according to postoperative double vision: "good," indicating no double vision or diplopia of more than 45 degrees, and "poor," diplopia of less than 45 degrees. Improvement of diplopia was observed in all patients without any complication. Of the 21 patients who underwent endoscopic reductions, 17 were classified as "good" and four as "poor." On the other hand, of the four patients who underwent transfacial reductions, three were classified as "good" and one as "poor." Significant differences were not observed between the surgical results of our two methods. Endoscopic endonasal reduction showed greater aesthetic advantages and, moreover, required no grafting. This technique is suggested as one of the most reasonable treatments of medial orbital wall fractures.     

Orbital floor fractures--should they be explored early?

One hundred consecutive cases of orbital floor fractures from varying causes are reviewed, and the admission symptoms and signs are compared to the late results. We considered the early findings of diplopia, infraorbital rim step-off, and hypesthesia (with an associated clinical diagnosis of malar bone involvement) an indication for exploration of the orbital floor and possible placement of silicone sheeting. When this was done, minimal complications resulted.     

Subunit principles in midface fractures: the importance of sagittal buttresses, soft-tissue reductions, and sequencing treatment of segmental fractures

The patterns of midface fractures were related to postoperative computed tomography scans and clinical results to assess the value of ordering fracture assembly in success of treatment methods. A total of 550 midface fractures were studied for their midface components and the presence of fractures in the adjacent frontal bone or mandible. Preoperative and postoperative computed tomography scans were analyzed to generate recommendations regarding exposure and postoperative stability related to fracture pattern and treatment sequence, both within the midface alone and when combined with frontal bone and mandibular fractures. Large segment (Le Fort I, II, and III) fractures were seen in 68 patients (12 percent); more comminuted midface fracture combinations were seen in 93 patients (17 percent). Midface and mandibular fractures were seen in 166 patients (30 percent). Midface, mandible, and nasoethmoid fractures were seen in 38 patients (7 percent). Frontal bone and midface fractures were seen in 131 patients (24 percent). Split-palate fractures accompanied 8 percent of midface fractures. Frontal bone, midface, and mandibular fractures were seen in 54 patients (10 percent). The midface, because of weak bone structure and comminuted fracture pattern, must therefore be considered a dependent, less stable structure. Its injuries more commonly occur with fractures of the frontal bone or mandible (two-thirds of cases) and, more often than not (>60 percent), are comminuted. Comminuted and pan-facial (multiple area) fractures deserve individualized consideration regarding the length of intermaxillary immobilization. Examples of common errors are described from this patient experience.