Developmental origins and evolution of jaws: new interpretation of "maxillary" and "mandibular"

Cartilage of the vertebrate jaw is derived from cranial neural crest cells that migrate to the first pharyngeal arch and form a dorsal "maxillary" and a ventral "mandibular" condensation. It has been assumed that the former gives rise to palatoquadrate and the latter to Meckel's (mandibular) cartilage. In anamniotes, these condensations were thought to form the framework for the bones of the adult jaw and, in amniotes, appear to prefigure the maxillary and mandibular facial prominences. Here, we directly test the contributions of these neural crest condensations in axolotl and chick embryos, as representatives of anamniote and amniote vertebrate groups, using molecular and morphological markers in combination with vital dye labeling of late-migrating cranial neural crest cells. Surprisingly, we find that both palatoquadrate and Meckel's cartilage derive solely from the ventral "mandibular" condensation. In contrast, the dorsal "maxillary" condensation contributes to trabecular cartilage of the neurocranium and forms part of the frontonasal process but does not contribute to jaw joints as previously assumed. These studies reveal the morphogenetic processes by which cranial neural crest cells within the first arch build the primordia for jaw cartilages and anterior cranium.     

Development of the mandibular skeleton in the embryonic chick as evaluated using the DNA-inhibiting agent 5-fluoro-2'-deoxyuridine

Mandibular development was examined in embryonic chicks following administration of 5-fluoro-2'-deoxyuridine (FUDR, 0.001-1.0 microgram/egg), an inhibitor of both DNA synthesis and of cell division. FUDR was injected in ovo at one of three developmental stages corresponding to 1) the migration of mandible-destined, midbrain-level neural crest cells (Hamburger and Hamilton [H.H.] stage 10); 2) midway through the epithelial-mesenchymal interaction required to initiate mandibular osteogenesis (H.H. stage 22), which is also after the epithelial-neural crest cell interaction required for the initiation of chondrogenesis in Meckel's cartilage; and 3) when prechondroblasts of Meckel's cartilage are beginning to differentiate (H.H. stage 25). Micromelia was induced following the administration of FUDR at either H.H. stages 22 or 25 but not when FUDR was given at H.H. stage 10. Although the micromelic mandibles were shorter than normal, Meckel's cartilage and the mandibular membrane bones both differentiated and grew along the full proximodistal length of the shortened mandibles. In contrast to the situation previously described by Ferguson for alligator embryos exposed to FUDR, the migration of neural crest cells in the embryonic chick was not inhibited by FUDR. In contrast to the situation previously described for rat embryos exposed to FUDR, differentiation of Meckel's cartilage was not inhibited in embryonic chicks exposed to FUDR. Differentiation of the membrane bones was also normal following either in ovo administration of FUDR or when mandibular processes were maintained in FUDR in vitro. Therefore, FUDR does not produce micromelia in the embryonic chick by interfering with the epithelial-mesenchymal/neural crest cell interactions, which are prerequisites or differentiation of cartilage or bone, nor by inhibiting the differentiation of chondrogenic or osteogenic mesenchymal cells after completion of these tissue interactions. Neither did the growth-inhibiting action of FUDR result from an inhibition of growth of Meckel's cartilage during the several days following initial chondrogenic differentiation. Rather, subsequent growth of the entire mandibular process was delayed. This mechanism of action differs from that in the alligator embryo, in which FUDR inhibits mandibular growth by removing mandible-destined, migrating neural crest cells, and in the rat, in which FUDR inhibits the differentiation of Meckel's cartilage but catch-up growth restores growth of the mandible to normal.     

Development and evolution of chordate cartilage

Deuterostomes are a monophyletic group of animals containing vertebrates, lancelets, tunicates, hemichordates, echinoderms, and xenoturbellids. Four out of these six extant groups-vertebrates, lancelets, tunicates, and hemichordates-have pharyngeal gill slits. All groups of deuterostome animals that have pharyngeal gill slits also have a pharyngeal skeleton supporting the pharyngeal openings, except tunicates. We previously found that pharyngeal cartilage in hemichordates and cephalochordates contains a fibrillar collagen protein similar to vertebrate type II collagen, but unlike vertebrate cartilage, the invertebrate deuterostome cartilages are acellular. We found SoxE and fibrillar collagen expression in the pharyngeal endodermal cells adjacent to where the cartilages form. These same endodermal epithelial cells also express Pax1/9, a marker of pharyngeal endoderm in vertebrates, lancelets, tunicates, and hemichordates. In situ experiments with a cephalochordate fibrillar collagen also showed expression in pharyngeal endoderm, as well as the ectoderm and the mesodermal coelomic pouches lining the gill bars. These results indicate that the pharyngeal endodermal cells are responsible for secretion of the cartilage in hemichordates, whereas in lancelets, all the pharyngeal cells surrounding the gill bars, ectodermal, endodermal, and mesodermal may be responsible for cartilage formation. We propose that endoderm secretion was primarily the ancestral mode of making pharyngeal cartilages in deuterostomes. Later the evolutionary origin of neural crest allowed co-option of the gene network for the secretion of pharyngeal cartilage matrix in the new migratory neural crest cell populations found in vertebrates.     

Lack of either chondrocyte hypertrophy or osteogenesis in Meckel's cartilage of the embryonic chick exposed to epithelia and to thyroxine in vitro

Osteogenesis was not initiated when Meckel's cartilages from embryonic chicks of Hamburger and Hamilton (H. H.) stages 38 and 39 were recombined with mandibular epithelia obtained from embryos of H. H. stage 22 (a stage when an epithelial-mesenchymal interaction elicits osteogenesis from mandibular mesenchyme) and grafted to the chorioallantoic membranes of host embryos for 7 to 21 days. Failure of osteogenesis was not because the cartilage inhibited or blocked the osteogenesis-initiating capabilities of mandibular epithelium for mandibular epithelia could still elicit osteogenesis when removed from Meckel's cartilages and recombined with mandibular mesenchyme. Chondrocyte hypertrophy is associated with osteogenesis in other cartilages, including Meckel's cartilage from rodent embryos. However, Meckel's cartilages from chick embryos of H. H. stages 34, 38, and 39 failed to hypertrophy when cultured in the presence of 7.5 nM thyroxine (3,3',5-triiodo-L-thyroxine), although H. H. stage 28 tibial chondrocytes cocultured with Meckel's cartilage did hypertrophy. Therefore, avian Meckelian chondrocytes fail to hypertrophy or to produce osteoprogenitor cells in response to stimuli known to evoke these events in other skeletal cells.     

Homeotic transformation of branchial arch identity after Hoxa2 overexpression

Overexpression of Hoxa2 in the chick first branchial arch leads to a transformation of first arch cartilages, such as Meckel's and the quadrate, into second arch elements, such as the tongue skeleton. These duplicated elements are fused to the original in a similar manner to that seen in the Hoxa2 knockout, where the reverse transformation of second to first arch morphology is observed. This confirms the role of Hoxa2 as a selector gene specifying second arch fate. When first arch neural crest alone is targeted, first arch elements are lost, but the Hoxa2-expressing crest is unable to develop into second arch elements. This is not due to Hoxa2 preventing differentiation of cartilages. Upregulation of a second arch marker in the first arch, and homeotic transformation of cartilage elements is only produced after global Hoxa2 overexpression in the crest and the surrounding tissue. Thus, although the neural crest appears to contain some patterning information, it needs to read cues from the environment to form a coordinated pattern. Hoxa2 appears to exert its effect during differentiation of the cartilage elements in the branchial arches, rather than during crest migration, implying that pattern is determined quite late in development.     

Specification and formation of the neural crest: Perspectives on lineage segregation

The neural crest is a fascinating embryonic population unique to vertebrates that is endowed with remarkable differentiation capacity. Thought to originate from ectodermal tissue, neural crest cells generate neurons and glia of the peripheral nervous system, and melanocytes throughout the body. However, the neural crest also generates many ectomesenchymal derivatives in the cranial region, including cell types considered to be of mesodermal origin such as cartilage, bone, and adipose tissue. These ectomesenchymal derivatives play a critical role in the formation of the vertebrate head, and are thought to be a key attribute at the center of vertebrate evolution and diversity. Further, aberrant neural crest cell development and differentiation is the root cause of many human pathologies, including cancers, rare syndromes, and birth malformations. In this review, we discuss the current findings of neural crest cell ontogeny, and consider tissue, cell, and molecular contributions toward neural crest formation. We further provide current perspectives into the molecular network involved during the segregation of the neural crest lineage.     

Neural crest development in the Xenopus laevis embryo, studied by interspecific transplantation and scanning electron microscopy

The Xenopus borealis quinacrine marker and scanning electron microscopy have been used to study the appearance, migration, and homing of neural crest cells in the embryo of Xenopus. The analysis shows that the primordium of the neural crest develops from the nervous layer of the ectoderm and consists of three segments at early neurula stages. This primordium is located in the lateral halves of the neural folds behind the prospective eye vesicles. The histological and experimental evidence shows that the neural crest cells also originate from the medial portion of the neural folds. The neural crest segments in the cephalic region start to migrate just before the closure of the neural tube. Isotopic and isochronic unilateral grafts of X. borealis neural crest into X. laevis embryos were performed in order to map the fate of the cranial crest segments and the vagal-truncal neural crest. The analysis of the X. laevis host embryos shows that the mandibular crest segment contributes to the lower jaw (Meckel's cartilage), quadrate, and ethmoid-trabecular cartilages, as well as to the ganglionic and Schwann cells of the trigeminus nerve, the connective tissues, the mesenchymal and choroid layers of the eye, and the cornea. The hyoid crest segment is located in the ceratohyal cartilage and in ganglia VII and VIII. The branchial crest segment migrates from the caudal part of the otic vesicle and divides into two portions which contribute to the cartilages of the gills. The vagal-truncal neural crest starts to migrate later at stage 25. It migrates by means of the vagus complex in a ventral direction and penetrates into the splanchnic layer of the digestive tract. The trunk neural crest cells disperse into three different pathways which differ from those of the avian embryo at this level.     

A celebration of the new head and an evaluation of the new mouth

Twenty years ago now, Carl Gans and Glen Northcutt proposed that the main invention of vertebrates was a new head, with its full array of sensory organs involved in an active predatory lifestyle. Tracing back the embryological origin of these structures, they showed how all are primarily derived from the neural crest and the placodes, two transient ectodermal cell populations in the embryo. These cell types were then used for further innovations, such as a new mouth in jawed vertebrates. The interplay between patterning and plasticity of the neural crest is largely responsible for the endless variation of vertebrate craniofacial features in evolution.     

Insights from amphioxus into the evolution of vertebrate cartilage

Central to the story of vertebrate evolution is the origin of the vertebrate head, a problem difficult to approach using paleontology and comparative morphology due to a lack of unambiguous intermediate forms. Embryologically, much of the vertebrate head is derived from two ectodermal tissues, the neural crest and cranial placodes. Recent work in protochordates suggests the first chordates possessed migratory neural tube cells with some features of neural crest cells. However, it is unclear how and when these cells acquired the ability to form cellular cartilage, a cell type unique to vertebrates. It has been variously proposed that the neural crest acquired chondrogenic ability by recruiting proto-chondrogenic gene programs deployed in the neural tube, pharynx, and notochord. To test these hypotheses we examined the expression of 11 amphioxus orthologs of genes involved in neural crest chondrogenesis. Consistent with cellular cartilage as a vertebrate novelty, we find that no single amphioxus tissue co-expresses all or most of these genes. However, most are variously co-expressed in mesodermal derivatives. Our results suggest that neural crest-derived cartilage evolved by serial cooption of genes which functioned primitively in mesoderm.     

Segmentation of the vertebrate skull: neural-crest derivation of adult cartilages in the clawed frog, Xenopus laevis

We utilize a novel, transgenic cell-labeling system to assess the embryonic derivation of cartilages in the post-metamorphic skull of anuran amphibians. Many of these cartilages form de novo at metamorphosis and have no obvious precursors within the larval skeleton. Most adult cartilages are derived from mandibular- or hyoid-stream neural crest, either individually or in combination; branchial-stream neural crest makes a modest contribution. Each stream also contributes to at least one cartilage in the middle ear or external ear. Four cartilages are composite elements; each is derived from at least two distinct cell populations. Many boundaries between adjacent neural-crest territories are cryptic insofar as they do not coincide with anatomical boundaries. The system of adult cranial segmentation revealed by these fate-mapping results differs in important respects from both the segmentation of the ontogenetically earlier larval skull and the cranial segmentation in amniotes. Most striking is the rostral "inversion" of neural-crest-derived cartilages in Xenopus, such that mandibular stream-derived elements are deployed caudal to those derived from the hyoid stream, which predominate anteriorly. This novel pattern of rostral segmentation may be a consequence of the complex, biphasic life history that is characteristic of most species of living amphibians, and especially anurans, in which cranial architecture is significantly reconfigured at metamorphosis. Neural-crest derivation of the vertebrate skull is not invariant; instead, embryonic derivation of individual components of the cranial skeleton may vary widely among species.     

Dual origins of the prechordal cranium in the chicken embryo

The prechordal cranium, or the anterior half of the neurocranial base, is a key structure for understanding the development and evolution of the vertebrate cranium, but its embryonic configuration is not well understood. It arises initially as a pair of cartilaginous rods, the trabeculae, which have been thought to fuse later into a single central stem called the trabecula communis (TC). Involvement of another element, the intertrabecula, has also been suggested to occur rostral to the trabecular rods and form the medial region of the prechordal cranium. Here, we examined the origin of the avian prechordal cranium, especially the TC, by observing the craniogenic and precraniogenic stages of chicken embryos using molecular markers, and by focal labeling of the ectomesenchyme forming the prechordal cranium. Subsequent to formation of the paired trabeculae, a cartilaginous mass appeared at the midline to connect their anterior ends. During this midline cartilage formation, we did not observe any progressive medial expansion of the trabeculae. The cartilages consisted of premandibular ectomesenchyme derived from the cranial neural crest. This was further divided anteroposteriorly into two portions, derived from two neural crest cell streams rostral and caudal to the optic vesicle, called preoptic and postoptic neural crest cells, respectively. Fate-mapping analysis elucidated that the postoptic neural crest cells were distributed exclusively in the lateroposterior part of the prechordal cranium corresponding to the trabeculae, whereas the preoptic stream of cells occupied the middle anterior part, differentiating into a cartilage mass corresponding to the intertrabecula. These results suggest that the central stem of the prechordal cranium of gnathostomes is composed of two kinds of distinct cartilaginous modules: a pair of trabeculae and a median intertrabecula, each derived from neural crest cells populating distinct places of the craniofacial primordia through specific migratory pathways.     

Modulated Expression of Type X Collagen in the Meckel's Cartilage with Different Developmental Fates

Mammalian Meckel's cartilage undergoes regionally diverse histodifferentiation: the caudal end of Meckel's cartilage extends to the developing ear and gives rise to malleus and incus through endochondral ossification while its major distal region differentiates into sphenomandibular ligament and the anterior ligament of the malleus tympanic plate through fibrous transformation. Since the entire Meckel's cartilage develops up to chondrocyte hypertrophy, the regional extracellular matrix components in the hypertrophic Meckel's cartilage may differ in association with the diverse developmental fates. In this project, the expressions of cartilage collagens were investigated in developing rat Meckel's cartilage and particular interest was given to type X collagen. A cDNA, HP114, encoding the NC1 domain of rat α1(X) collagen was cloned, and a synthetic peptide based on the sequence deduced from HP114 was used to generate a monospecific antibody. In situ hybridization of newborn rat condylar and angular cartilages undergoing endochondral ossification showed restricted labeling with the α1(X) collagen probe in the hypertrophic chondrocyte layer. In contrast, the α1(X) collagen probe totally failed to label the major distal portion of Meckel's cartilage even in the hypertrophic cartilage zone. Immunohistochemistry using the anti-type X collagen monospecific antibody consistently failed to recognize the epitope in the corresponding portion of Meckel's cartilage throughout the experimental periods of gestational Day 17, newborn, and Postnatal Day 7, while the strictly localized positive staining was found in the posterior part of Meckel's cartilage which gave rise to malleus and incus. Since major cartilage collagens type II and type IX were found to be present throughout Meckel's cartilage, we postulate that the regulatory molecular mechanism of type X collagen expression may be closely associated with the developmental fates of fibrous transformation and endochondral ossification in mammalian Meckel's cartilage.     

Generating,growing and transforming skeletal shape: insights from amphibian pharyngeal arch cartilages

Amphibians that undergo a metamorphosis provide an unparalleled opportunity to investigate how skeletal shape is generated, preserved, and transformed in development. Their pharyngeal arch (PA) cartilages, which support breathing and feeding behaviors, form embryonically from cranial neural crest cells, grow isometrically at larval stages, and abruptly change shape during metamorphosis. Further, the shape changes occur in three different ways: some adult cartilages form de novo, others emerge from within resorbing larval cartilages and some larval cartilages reshape themselves at the cellular level. Isometric growth followed by abrupt shape change is unique to amphibian PA cartilages, which suggests that the origin and evolution of amphibian metamorphosis has been influenced by the tissue properties of cartilage. This essay reviews the functional role of the PA skeleton in frogs and salamanders and presents a mechanistic framework for understanding how its shape is generated, preserved, and transformed at the levels of cell behavior and specification mechanisms.     

The origin and evolution of the neural crest

Many of the features that distinguish the vertebrates from other chordates are derived from the neural crest, and it has long been argued that the emergence of this multipotent embryonic population was a key innovation underpinning vertebrate evolution. More recently, however, a number of studies have suggested that the evolution of the neural crest was less sudden than previously believed. This has exposed the fact that neural crest, as evidenced by its repertoire of derivative cell types, has evolved through vertebrate evolution. In this light, attempts to derive a typological definition of neural crest, in terms of molecular signatures or networks, are unfounded. We propose a less restrictive, embryological definition of this cell type that facilitates, rather than precludes, investigating the evolution of neural crest. While the evolutionary origin of neural crest has attracted much attention, its subsequent evolution has received almost no attention and yet it is more readily open to experimental investigation and has greater relevance to understanding vertebrate evolution. Finally, we provide a brief outline of how the evolutionary emergence of neural crest potentiality may have proceeded, and how it may be investigated.     

Zebrafish arl6ip1 is required for neural crest development during embryogenesis

Background

Although the embryonic expression pattern of ADP ribosylation factor-like 6 interacting protein 1 (Arl6ip1) has been reported, its function in neural crest development is unclear.

Methods/Principal Findings

We found that knockdown of Arl6ip1 caused defective embryonic neural crest derivatives that were particularly severe in craniofacial cartilages. Expressions of the ectodermal patterning factors msxb, dlx3b, and pax3 were normal, but the expressions of the neural crest specifier genes foxd3, snai1b, and sox10 were greatly reduced. These findings suggest that arl6ip1 is essential for specification of neural crest derivatives, but not neural crest induction. Furthermore, we revealed that the streams of crestin- and sox10-expressing neural crest cells, which migrate ventrally from neural tube into trunk, were disrupted in arl6ip1 morphants. This migration defect was not only in the trunk neural crest, but also in the enteric tract where the vagal-derived neural crest cells failed to populate the enteric nervous system. We found that this migration defect was induced by dampened Shh signaling, which may have resulted from defective cilia. These data further suggested that arl6ip1 is required for neural crest migration. Finally, by double-staining of TUNEL and crestin, we confirmed that the loss of neural crest cells could not be attributed to apoptosis.

Conclusions/Significance

Therefore, we concluded that arl6ip1 is required for neural crest migration and sublineage specification.     

Evidence that the protein tyrosine phosphatase (PC12,Br7,Sl) gamma (-) isoform modulates chondrogenic patterning and growth

One of the earliest events in bone morphogenesis is the condensation of embryonic mesenchymal cells into chondroblasts and their subsequent proliferation and differentiation into chondrocytes. During this time, certain signaling cascades operate to establish proper patterning and differentiation of the cartilaginous skeleton. Characterization of the signaling pathways involved in these processes remains to be accomplished. We have identified a novel murine cytosolic tyrosine phosphatase termed PTPPBS gamma (+/-) which is a member of the PTP PC12,Br7,Sl (PTPPBS) family. Spatio-temporal expression analysis of the members of this tyrosine phosphatase family demonstrates significant expression of the gamma (-) splice variant in the cartilaginous skeleton. Using an embryonic mandibular explant culture system to serve as a model for cartilage formation, we examined the potential roles of the PTPPBS gamma phosphatase by loss-of-function studies achieved with antisense oligodeoxynucleotides. These studies demonstrated that loss of expression of the PTPPBS gamma (-) isoform resulted in abnormal patterning of Meckel's cartilage and an increase in the size of the chondrogenic regions. In gamma antisense-treated explants, bromodeoxyuridine-pulse labeling studies revealed increased proliferation of chondroblasts bordering along precartilaginous condensations and bordering populations of maturing chondrocytes. These studies provide evidence that in early skeletal development, PTPPBS gamma may regulate the rate of chondroblast proliferation in the cartilaginous skeleton.