Structural requirements for the specific recognition of an m7G mRNA cap

7-Methylguanosine (m(7)G), also known as the mRNA "cap", is used as a molecular tag in eukaryotic cells to mark the 5' end of messenger RNAs. The mRNA cap is required for several key events in gene expression in which the m(7)G moiety is specifically recognized by cellular proteins. The configurations of the m(7)G-binding pockets of a cellular (eIF4E) and a viral (VP39) cap-binding protein have been determined by X-ray crystallography. The binding energy has been hypothesized to result from a pi-pi stacking interaction between aromatic residues sandwiching the m(7)G base in addition to hydrogen bonds between the base and acidic protein side chains. To further understand the structural requirements for the specific recognition of an m(7)G mRNA cap, we determined the effects of amino acid substitutions in eIF4E and VP39 cap-binding sites on their affinity for m(7)GDP. The requirements for residues suggested to pi-pi stack and hydrogen bond with the m(7)G base were examined in each protein by measuring their affinities for m(7)GDP by fluorimetry. The results suggest that both eIF4E and VP39 require a complicated pattern of both orientation and identity of the stacking aromatic residues to permit the selective binding of m(7)GDP.     

Biophysical studies of eIF4E cap-binding protein: recognition of mRNA 5' cap structure and synthetic fragments of eIF4G and 4E-BP1 proteins

mRNA 5'-cap recognition by the eukaryotic translation initiation factor eIF4E has been exhaustively characterized with the aid of a novel fluorometric, time-synchronized titration method, and X-ray crystallography. The association constant values of recombinant eIF4E for 20 different cap analogues cover six orders of magnitude; with the highest affinity observed for m(7)GTP (approximately 1.1 x 10(8) M(-1)). The affinity of the cap analogues for eIF4E correlates with their ability to inhibit in vitro translation. The association constants yield contributions of non-covalent interactions involving single structural elements of the cap to the free energy of binding, giving a reliable starting point to rational drug design. The free energy of 7-methylguanine stacking and hydrogen bonding (-4.9 kcal/mol) is separate from the energies of phosphate chain interactions (-3.0, -1.9, -0.9 kcal/mol for alpha, beta, gamma phosphates, respectively), supporting two-step mechanism of the binding. The negatively charged phosphate groups of the cap act as a molecular anchor, enabling further formation of the intermolecular contacts within the cap-binding slot. Stabilization of the stacked Trp102/m(7)G/Trp56 configuration is a precondition to form three hydrogen bonds with Glu103 and Trp102. Electrostatically steered eIF4E-cap association is accompanied by additional hydration of the complex by approximately 65 water molecules, and by ionic equilibria shift. Temperature dependence reveals the enthalpy-driven and entropy-opposed character of the m(7)GTP-eIF4E binding, which results from dominant charge-related interactions (DeltaH degrees =-17.8 kcal/mol, DeltaS degrees= -23.6 cal/mol K). For recruitment of synthetic eIF4GI, eIF4GII, and 4E-BP1 peptides to eIF4E, all the association constants were approximately 10(7) M(-1), in decreasing order: eIF4GI>4E-BP1>eIF4GII approximately 4E-BP1(P-Ser65) approximately 4E-BP1(P-Ser65/Thr70). Phosphorylation of 4E-BP1 at Ser65 and Thr70 is insufficient to prevent binding to eIF4E. Enhancement of the eIF4E affinity for cap occurs after binding to eIF4G peptides.     

Binding of protein synthesis initiation factor 4E to oligoribonucleotides: effects of cap accessibility and secondary structure.

The binding of rabbit globin mRNA to the 25-kDa cap binding protein eIF-4E from human erythrocytes was found to be 5.3-fold stronger than the binding of the cap analogue m7GpppG to eIF-4E [Gross et al. (1990) Biochemistry 29, 5008-5012]. In order to investigate whether this effect is due to the longer sequence of nucleotides in globin mRNA or to other features such as cap accessibility or secondary structure, oligoribonucleotide analogues of rabbit alpha-globin mRNA were synthesized by T7 RNA polymerase from a synthetic oligodeoxynucleotide template in the presence of m7GpppG; these oligoribonucleotide analogues possess varying degrees of cap accessibility and secondary structure. Equilibrium association constants for the interaction of these oligoribonucleotides and purified human erythrocyte eIF-4E were obtained from direct fluorescence titration experiments. The data indicate that while the presence of the m7G cap is required for efficient recognition by eIF-4E, the cap need not be completely sterically accessible, since other structural features within the mRNA also influence binding.     

An mRNA m7G cap binding-like motif within human Ago2 represses translation

microRNAs (miRNAs) bind to Argonaute (Ago) proteins and inhibit translation or promote degradation of mRNA targets. Human let-7 miRNA inhibits translation initiation of mRNA targets in an m(7)G cap-dependent manner and also appears to block protein production, but the molecular mechanism(s) involved is unknown and the role of Ago proteins in translational regulation remains elusive. Here we identify a motif (MC) within the Mid domain of Ago proteins, which bears significant similarity to the m(7)G cap-binding domain of eIF4E, an essential translation initiation factor. We identify conserved aromatic residues within the MC motif of human Ago2 that are required for binding to the m(7)G cap and for translational repression but do not affect the assembly of Ago2 with miRNA or its catalytic activity. We propose that Ago2 represses the initiation of mRNA translation by binding to the m(7)G cap of mRNA targets, thus likely precluding the recruitment of eIF4E.     

The "cap-binding slot" of an mRNA cap-binding protein: quantitative effects of aromatic side chain choice in the double-stacking sandwich with cap

The N7-methylguanine portion of the mRNA cap structure interacts with cap-binding proteins via an unusual double-stacking arrangement in which the positively charged cap is sandwiched between two parallel-oriented aromatic protein side chains. Three-dimensional costructures of cap with two mRNA cap-binding proteins, namely, translational initiation factor eIF4E and VP39 (the vaccinia virus-encoded mRNA cap-specific 2'-O-methyltransferase), have heretofore been reported. Despite striking similarities between the two proteins in the double stack with the cap, the stack differs most notably in the species of stacked side chain donated by the protein. Whereas eIF4E employs two tryptophans, VP39 uses a tyrosine and a phenylalanine. Here, we have generated tryptophan substitutions in VP39. Tryptophan substitution was shown, crystallographically, not to disrupt the maintenance of a bona fide parallel stack. However, the single-tryptophan and double-tryptophan substitutions were associated with increased affinity for cap nucleoside by factors of 10 and 50, respectively. VP39 interacted more strongly with a true substrate (containing portions of RNA downstream of the cap in addition to the cap itself) than with isolated cap nucleoside, by several orders of magnitude. VP39 mutants with tryptophan substitution at position 180 exhibited apparent defects in substrate catalytic rate during the first turnover cycle, indicating the possibility of an exquisite sensitivity of the catalytic center to subtle changes in substrate position brought about by alterations in the cap-binding slot. The X-ray structure of VP39 with a genuine nucleobase analogue of N7-methylguanosine, namely, N7,9-dimethylguanine, indicated that the N7-methylguanosine rotational orientation within the stack is a property of the cap nucleobase itself.     

Functional characterization of a 48 kDa Trypanosoma brucei cap 2 RNA methyltransferase

Kinetoplastid mRNAs possess a unique hypermethylated cap 4 structure derived from the standard m⁷GpppN cap structure, with 2′-O methylations on the first four ribose sugars and additional base methylations on the first adenine and the fourth uracil. While the enzymes responsible for m⁷GpppN cap 0 formations has been characterized in Trypanosoma brucei, the mechanism of cap 4 methylation and the role of the hypermethylated structure remain unclear. Here, we describe the characterization of a 48 kDa T.brucei 2′-O nucleoside methyltransferase (TbCom1). Recombinant TbCom1 transfers the methyl group from S-adenosylmethionine (AdoMet) to the 2′-OH of the second nucleoside of m⁷GpppNpNp-RNA to form m⁷GpppNpNmp-RNA. TbCom1 is also capable of converting cap 1 RNA to cap 2 RNA. The methyl transfer reaction is dependent on the m⁷GpppN cap, as the enzyme does not form a stable interaction with GpppN-terminated RNA. Mutational analysis establishes that the TbCom1 and vaccinia virus VP39 methyltransferases share mechanistic similarities in AdoMet- and cap-recognition. Two aromatic residues, Tyr18 and Tyr187, may participate in base-stacking interactions with the guanine ring of the cap, as the removal of each of these aromatic side-chains abolishes cap-specific RNA-binding.     

Interaction of Escherichia coli purine nucleoside phosphorylase (PNP) with the cationic and zwitterionic forms of the fluorescent substrate N(7)-methylguanosine

Steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy, and enzyme kinetics, were applied to study the reaction of purine nucleoside phosphorylase (PNP) from Escherichia coli with its substrate N(7)-methylguanosine (m7Guo), which consists of an equilibrium mixture of cationic and zwitterionic forms (pK(a)=7.0), each with characteristic absorption and fluorescence spectra, over the pH range 6-9, where absorption and intrinsic fluorescence of the enzyme are virtually unchanged. The pH-dependence of kinetic constants for phosphorolysis of m7Guo were studied under condition where the population of the zwitterion varied from 10% to 100%. This demonstrated that, whereas the zwitterion is a 3- to 6-fold poorer substrate, if at all, than the cation for the mammalian enzymes, both ionic species are almost equally good substrates for E. coli PNP. The imidazole-ring-opened form of m7Guo is neither a substrate nor an inhibitor of phosphorolysis. Enzyme fluorescence quenching, and concomitant changes in absorption and fluorescence spectra of the two ionic species of m7Guo on binding, showed that both forms are bound by the enzyme, the affinity of the zwitterion being 3-fold lower than that of the cation. Binding of m7Guo is bimodal, i.e., an increase in ligand concentration leads to a decrease in the association constant of the enzyme-ligand complex, typical for negative cooperativity of enzyme-ligand binding, with a Hill constant <1. This is in striking contrast to interaction of the enzyme with the parent Guo, for which the association constant is independent of concentration. The weakly fluorescent N(7)-methylguanine (m7Gua), the product of phosphorolysis of m7Guo, is a competitive non-substrate inhibitor of phosphorolysis (K(i)=8+/-2 microM) and exhibits negative cooperativity on binding to the enzyme at pH 6.9. Quenching of enzyme emission by the ligands is a static process, inasmuch as the mean excited-state lifetime, =2.7 ns, is unchanged in the presence of the ligands, and the constants K(SV) may therefore be considered as the association constants for the enzyme-ligand complexes. In the pH range 9.5-11 there is an instantaneous reversible decrease in PNP emission of approximately 15%, corresponding to one of the six tyrosine residues per subunit readily accessible to solvent, and OH- ions. Relevance of the overall results to the mechanism of phosphorolysis, and binding of substrates/inhibitors is discussed.     

Structural basis of mRNA cap recognition by proteins

Crystal structures have recently become available for two proteins (VP39 and eIF4E) complexed with their cognate ligand - the mRNA cap. Despite their total structural dissimilarity, both proteins bind N7-methylguanine between two parallel aromatic sidechains. The resulting stacked arrangement governs their high specificity for the alkylated form of the nucleobase.     

West Nile virus methyltransferase catalyzes two methylations of the viral RNA cap through a substrate-repositioning mechanism

Flaviviruses encode a single methyltransferase domain that sequentially catalyzes two methylations of the viral RNA cap, GpppA-RNA-->m(7)GpppA-RNA-->m(7)GpppAm-RNA, by using S-adenosyl-l-methionine (SAM) as a methyl donor. Crystal structures of flavivirus methyltransferases exhibit distinct binding sites for SAM, GTP, and RNA molecules. Biochemical analysis of West Nile virus methyltransferase shows that the single SAM-binding site donates methyl groups to both N7 and 2'-O positions of the viral RNA cap, the GTP-binding pocket functions only during the 2'-O methylation, and two distinct sets of amino acids in the RNA-binding site are required for the N7 and 2'-O methylations. These results demonstrate that flavivirus methyltransferase catalyzes two cap methylations through a substrate-repositioning mechanism. In this mechanism, guanine N7 of substrate GpppA-RNA is first positioned to SAM to generate m(7)GpppA-RNA, after which the m(7)G moiety is repositioned to the GTP-binding pocket to register the 2'-OH of the adenosine with SAM, generating m(7)GpppAm-RNA. Because N7 cap methylation is essential for viral replication, inhibitors designed to block the pocket identified for the N7 cap methylation could be developed for flavivirus therapy.     

Cooperative stacking and hydrogen bond pairing interactions of fragment peptide in cap binding protein with mRNA cap structure

The stacking and hydrogen bonding abilities of Trp-(Gly)n-Glu (n = 0 approximately 3) for the interaction with 7-methylguanine (m7G) base were examined by fluorescence and 1H-NMR methods, and it was shown that they correlate with the distance between the Trp and Glu residues, and become most significant when both residues are separated from each other by two Gly residues (n = 2). Based on this insight, the sequence conserved between the human and yeast cap binding proteins (CBPs) was surveyed, and the sequence of Trp-Glu-Asp-Glu (No. 102-105 in human CBP) was selected as a probable site for the binding with mRNA cap structure. Thus, the stacking and hydrogen bonding abilities of Trp-Glu-Asp-Glu with m7G cap structure were examined by comparative experiments using its analogous peptides. The results showed that the fourth Glu residue is important not only for the construction of hydrogen bond pairing with m7G base but also for strengthening the stacking interaction between the Trp indole ring and m7G base. Taking account of the recognition analysis using the mutant CBP proteins by site-directed mutagenesis (Ueda, H., Iyo, H., Doi, M., Inoue, M., Ishida, T., Morioka, H., Tanaka, T., Nishikawa, S. and Uesugi, S. (1991) FEBS Lett. 280, 207-210), this cooperative interaction could be important for the recognition of mRNA cap structure.     

Stopped-flow kinetic analysis of eIF4E and phosphorylated eIF4E binding to cap analogs and capped oligoribonucleotides: evidence for a one-step binding mechanism

Recruitment of eukaryotic mRNA to the 48 S initiation complex is rate-limiting for protein synthesis under normal conditions. Binding of the 5' -terminal cap structure of mRNA to eIF4E is a critical event during this process. Mammalian eIF4E is phosphorylated at Ser-209 by Mnk1 and Mnk2 kinases. We investigated the interaction of both eIF4E and phosphorylated eIF4E (eIF4E(P)) with cap analogs and capped oligoribonucleotides by stopped-flow kinetics. For m(7)GpppG, the rate constant of association, k(on), was dependent on ionic strength, decreasing progressively up to 350 mm KCl, but the rate constant of dissociation, k(off), was independent of ionic strength. Phosphorylation of eIF4E decreased k(on) by 2.1-2.3-fold at 50-100 mm KCl but had progressively less effect at higher ionic strengths, being negligible at 350 mm. Contrary to published evidence, eIF4E phosphorylation had no effect on k(off). Several observations supported a simple one-step binding mechanism, in contrast to published reports of a two-step mechanism. The kinetic function that best fit the data changed from single- to double-exponential as the eIF4E concentration was increased. However, measuring k(off) for dissociation of a pre-formed eIF4E.m(7)GpppG complex suggested that the double-exponential kinetics were caused by dissociation of eIF4E dimers, not a two-step mechanism. Addition of a 12-nucleotide chain to the cap structure increased affinity at high ionic strength for both eIF4E (24-fold) and eIF4E(P) (7-fold), primarily due to a decrease in k(off). This suggests that additional stabilizing interactions between capped oligoribonucleotides and eIF4E, which do not occur with cap analogs alone, act to slow dissociation.     

Characterization of the interaction of wheat germ protein synthesis initiation factor eIF-3 with mRNA oligonucleotide and cap analogues.

Direct fluorescence titration experiments of wheat germ protein synthesis initiation factor eIF-3 with mRNA cap and oligoribonucleotide analogues were performed in order to determine the equilibrium association constants (Keq) for the eIF-3.mRNA interaction as a function of pH and temperature. These data suggest that (i) the eIF-3.mRNA interaction is not cap-specific (i.e., m7G-specific), (ii) ATP hydrolysis is not involved in the interaction, and (iii) the interaction is primarily ionic in nature. Competition experiments between a rabbit alpha-globin mRNA oligoribonucleotide analogue and either mRNA cap analogues or nucleoside triphosphates (NTPs) are also reported; these experiments indicate that NTPs act as both activators and competitive inhibitors of the mRNA.eIF-3 association. The results are consistent with a partially uncompetitive binding mechanism, whereby at low NTP concentrations (less than or equal to 10 microM) the bound NTP enhances subsequent mRNA binding to eIF-3, perhaps by inducing a conformational change, and at higher NTP concentrations, the NTP acts as a competitive inhibitor for the mRNA binding site on eIF-3.     

Weak binding affinity of human 4EHP for mRNA cap analogs

Ribosome recruitment to the majority of eukaryotic mRNAs is facilitated by the interaction of the cap binding protein, eIF4E, with the mRNA 5' cap structure. eIF4E stimulates translation through its interaction with a scaffolding protein, eIF4G, which helps to recruit the ribosome. Metazoans also contain a homolog of eIF4E, termed 4EHP, which binds the cap structure, but not eIF4G, and thus cannot stimulate translation, but it instead inhibits the translation of only one known, and possibly subset mRNAs. To understand why 4EHP does not inhibit general translation, we studied the binding affinity of 4EHP for cap analogs using two methods: fluorescence titration and stopped-flow measurements. We show that 4EHP binds cap analogs m(7)GpppG and m(7)GTP with 30 and 100 lower affinity than eIF4E. Thus, 4EHP cannot compete with eIF4E for binding to the cap structure of most mRNAs.     

Stacking efficiency and flexibility analysis of aromatic amino acids in cap-binding proteins

Recognition of the ribonucleic acid 5' termini (RNA 5' cap) by a wide class of cap-binding proteins is largely accomplished by cation-pi stacking that involves the positively charged 7-methylguanine ring and aromatic amino acid side chains. Quantum calculations of the stacking energy were performed by means of MP2 perturbation method for binary and ternary associates composed of the 7-methylguanine moiety and tryptophan, tyrosine, or phenylalanine, in their spatial orientations known from the crystalline cap-protein complexes. The results clearly pointed to an enhancement of the stacking energy due to a net positive charge in the cap guanine moiety and allowed analysis of a role of various amino acids in stabilization of the complexes. Conformational flexibility of the aromatic amino acids taking part in binding ligands to a wide class of RNA-recognizing proteins, including the cap-binding proteins, was determined by regional order neural network (RONN) algorithm that provides results close to those of the crystallographic B-factors analysis. Interestingly, some of the tyrosines that are classified in general as "rigid" showed high flexibility when engaged in binding the cap to nuclear cap-binding protein complex CBC and to viral methyltransferase VP39. Parallel analyses of the binding energy and flexibility of the protein fragments engaged in the binding leads to understanding differences in molecular mechanisms of the cap recognition by various proteins, CBC compared with the eukaryotic initiation factor eIF4E, and enzymes vs. other protein factors.     

General RNA binding proteins render translation cap dependent.

Translation in rabbit reticulocyte lysate is relatively independent of the presence of the mRNA m7G cap structure and the cap binding protein, eIF-4E. In addition, initiation occurs frequently at spurious internal sites. Here we show that a critical parameter which contributes to cap-dependent translation is the amount of general RNA binding proteins in the extract. Addition of several general RNA binding proteins, such as hnRNP A1, La autoantigen, pyrimidine tract binding protein (hnRNP I/PTB) and the major core protein of cytoplasmic mRNP (p50), rendered translation in a rabbit reticulocyte lysate cap dependent. These proteins drastically inhibited the translation of an uncapped mRNA, but had no effect on translation of a capped mRNA. Based on these and other results, we suggest that one function of general mRNA binding proteins in the cytoplasm is to promote ribosome binding by a 5' end, cap-mediated mechanism, and prevent spurious initiations at aberrant translation start sites.