Latitudinal countergradient variation in the common frog (Rana temporaria) development rates--evidence for local adaptation

Adaptive genetic differentiation along a climatic gradient as a response to natural selection is not necessarily expressed at phenotypic level if environmental effects on population mean phenotypes oppose the genotypic effects. This form of cryptic evolution--called countergradient variation--has seldom been explicitly demonstrated for terrestrial vertebrates. We investigated the patterns of phenotypic and genotypic differentiation in developmental rates of common frogs (Rana temporaria) along a ca. 1600 km latitudinal gradient across Scandinavia. Developmental rates in the field were not latitudinally ordered, but displayed large variation even among different ponds within a given latitudinal area. In contrast, development rates assessed in the laboratory increased strongly and linearly with increasing latitude, suggesting a genetic capacity for faster development in the northern than the southern larvae. Experiments further revealed that environmental effects (temperature and food) could easily override the genetic effects on developmental rates, providing a possible mechanistic explanation as to why the genetic differentiation was not seen in the samples collected from the wild. Our results suggest that the higher developmental rates of the northern larvae are likely to be related to selection stemming from seasonal time constrains, rather than from selection dictated by low ambient temperatures per se. All in all, the results provide a demonstration of environmental effects concealing substantial latitudinally ordered genetic differentiation understandable in terms of adaptation to clinal variation in time constrains.     

Carry-over effects of embryonic acid conditions on development and growth of Rana temporaria tadpoles

1. Conditions experienced during the early stages of development may have carry‐over effects on performance during later life. The egg laying period and embryonic development of temperate and boreal zone amphibians often coincides with peak acidity resulting from spring snow‐melt, but the effects of acid conditions during embryonic stage on subsequent performance are unknown. 2. We investigated the potential carry‐over effects of acidity during the embryonic stage on performance up to metamorphosis in the common frog (Rana temporaria) tadpoles. There were four combinations of acid (4.5) and neutral (7.5) pH treatments applied to the egg and larval stages in a factorial laboratory experiment. In addition, we studied the difference in embryonic and larval tolerance of acidity between two populations originating from circumneutral (pH 6.6) and acidic conditions (pH 4.8). 3. The effects of acid conditions during the embryonic stage were sublethal, as indicated by delayed development and reduced size. Under acid conditions, tadpoles that had been raised in neutral water as embryos at first grew more slowly than tadpoles raised under acid conditions as embryos. At metamorphosis, no effects of embryonic acidity were detectable indicating that tadpoles were able to compensate fully for the initial reduction in growth. 4. Acid conditions during the larval period had a strongly negative effect on survival, size and age at metamorphosis. The amount of food consumed was lower under acid conditions, suggesting that reduced food consumption was at least partly responsible for the negative effects. 5. Although the two populations differed in the length of larval period, there was no indication of a differential response to the treatments in any of the metamorphic traits studied. 6. These results suggest that, although moderate acid conditions during embryonic development affect growth and development negatively, this influence does not persist after conditions have returned to normal. However, even moderately acid conditions during the larval period may have a strong negative influence on survival and performance of the tadpoles.     

Utilization of yolk platelets during early embryonic development of Rana temporaria and Bufo bufo

Utilization of yolk platelets in cleaving embryos of Rana temporaria and Bufo bufo was studied by different methods. Morphological observations of yolk platelets of R. temporaria embryos at tail bud stage by transmission electron microscopy indicated four initial phases of platelet degradation. The pattern of these events is similar to that found in embryos of B. bufo. The morphological observations were confirmed by energy-dispersive X-ray microanalysis of the elemental content of platelets and by selected-area electron diffraction of platelet cores. Covalently bound sulphur content decreased during cleavage and the content of different inorganic ions changed, whereas the structure of crystalline core remained constant. Morphological changes found in the amorphous cortex of yolk platelets were due to their utilization. Stereological measurements indicated that utilization during cleavage increased, but only the initial phases of yolk platelet degradation were seen. The volume of the cortex did not decrease and the crystalline core did not fragment.     

Genome size variation in the common frog Rana temporaria

Genome size variation in the common frog (Rana temporaria) was investigated with flow cytometry in three latitudinally separated populations in Sweden to see whether it could provide a useful tool for sex-identification in this species. Depending on the sex and population, per cell DNA content (2C value) varied from 8.823 to 11.266 pg with a mean (+/- SE) 2C value of 9.961+/-0.083 pg. Analysis of variance revealed significant differences in genome size among populations and between sexes. Females had ca 3% larger genomes (x=10.133+/-0.068 pg) than males (x=9.832+/-0.068 pg) in all of the populations (sex x population interaction: P>0.10). Individuals from the southern-most population had significantly (x=9.330+/-0.081 pg) smaller genomes than those from the more northern populations (x=10.032+/-0.085 and x=10.584+/-0.085 pg, respectively). These results are in line with the interpretation that males in the common frog are the heterogametic sex, and that there exists large (up to 12%) geographic variation in genome size in this species. However, the sex differences in the genome size are too small to be useful in individual sex identification.     

Effects of aluminium and low pH on growth and development in Rana temporaria tadpoles

Summary Rana temporaria tadpoles were raised to metamorphosis at 6 levels of pH (pH 3.6–6.5) and 2 levels of aluminium (800 and 1,600 g l^-1) at pH 4.4. Treatments involved both chronic and acute exposure to depressed pH. Decreasing pH reduced maximum body size and delayed metamorphosis. Growth was depressed and metamorphosis delayed by 800 g l^-1 Al, and several tadpoles died at foreleg emergence. At 1,600 g l^-1 Al, small tadpoles suffered arrested growth and development and eventually died, while larger tadpoles metamorphosed without delay, though at a very small size. There was no mortality among controls. The levels of pH and inorganic monomeric aluminium measured in the experiments were similar to field levels at a site in Scotland, and it is concluded that individual tadpoles will, in certain types of water body, be adversely affected by both acidity and aluminium. The impact of these factors on populations remains to be determined.     

Proximate causes of adaptive growth rates: growth efficiency variation among latitudinal populations of Rana temporaria

In ectothermic organisms, declining season length and lower temperature towards higher latitudes often select for latitudinal variation in growth and development. However, the energetic mechanisms underlying this adaptive variation are largely unknown. We investigated growth, food intake and growth efficiency of Rana temporaria tadpoles from eight populations along a 1500 km latitudinal gradient across Sweden. To gain an insight into the mechanisms of adaptation at organ level, we also examined variation in tadpole gut length. The tadpoles were raised at two temperatures (16 and 20 degrees C) in a laboratory common garden experiment. We found increased growth rate towards higher latitudes, regardless of temperature treatment. This increase in growth was not because of a higher food intake rate, but populations from higher latitudes had higher growth efficiency, i.e. they were more efficient at converting ingested food into body mass. Low temperature reduced growth efficiency most strongly in southern populations. Relative gut length increased with latitude, and tadpoles at low temperature tended to have longer guts. However, variation in gut length was not the sole adaptive explanation for increased growth efficiency as latitude and body length still explained significant amounts of variation in growth efficiency. Hence, additional energetic adaptations are probably involved in growth efficiency variation along the latitudinal gradient.     

Effects of prochloraz and ethinylestradiol on sexual development in Rana temporaria

A wide range of environmental xenobiotics that mimic hormones (endocrine-disrupting chemicals) may cause alterations in sexual development or reproductive function in aquatic organisms such as amphibians when exposed during early sensitive stages. We exposed tadpoles of the Common frog, Rana temporaria, from hatch to metamorphosis, to two different endocrine disruptors, the synthetic estrogen 17 alpha-ethinylestradiol and the fungicide prochloraz. The object of the study was to assess the effects of these two compounds on the sexual development of the tadpoles by investigating sex ratio, gonadal development, sex steroid concentrations and vitellogenin induction. Histology revealed that a large percentage of all groups were juvenile hermaphrodites at metamorphosis. Tadpoles exposed to 115 and 251 microg/L prochloraz showed a significant increased proportion of males. However, the testosterone concentrations were depressed in those groups. Ethinylestradiol in concentrations of 77 and 159 ng/L EE(2) increased whole-body calcium levels in a dose-dependent manner indicating induction of the egg yolk protein vitellogenin, verified also by gel electrophoresis. The study shows that ethinylestradiol may induce vitellogenesis and prochloraz may affect the sexual development in Common frogs.     

Maternal and genetic contributions to geographical variation in Rana temporaria larval life-history traits

The relative importance of genetic, environmental, and maternal effects as determinants of geographical variation in vertebrate life-histories has not often been explored. We examined the role of genetic and maternal effects as determinants of population divergence in survival and three important larval life-history traits (growth rate, age, and size at metamorphosis) using reciprocal crosses between two latitudinally separated populations of the common frog ( Rana temporaria Linnaeus). Genetic effects were important in all three traits as indicated by the significant effect of male origin, but there was also evidence for nonadditive genetic contributions on metamorphic size and growth rate. Likewise, maternal effect contributions to population divergence were large, partially environment dependent, and apparently acting primarily through egg size in two of three traits. These results suggest that both genetic and maternal effects are important determinants of geographical variation in amphibian life-histories, and that much of the differentiation resulting from maternal effects is mediated through variation in egg size. © 2002 The Linnean Society of London, Biological Journal of the Linnean Society , 2002, 76 , 61–70.     

Testing the role of phenotypic plasticity for local adaptation: growth and development in time-constrained Rana temporaria populations

Phenotypic plasticity can be important for local adaptation, because it enables individuals to survive in a novel environment until genetic changes have been accumulated by genetic accommodation. By analysing the relationship between development rate and growth rate, it can be determined whether plasticity in life-history traits is caused by changed physiology or behaviour. We extended this to examine whether plasticity had been aiding local adaptation, by investigating whether the plastic response had been fixed in locally adapted populations. Tadpoles from island populations of Rana temporaria, locally adapted to different pool-drying regimes, were monitored in a common garden. Individual differences in development rate were caused by different foraging efficiency. However, developmental plasticity was physiologically mediated by trading off growth against development rate. Surprisingly, plasticity has not aided local adaptation to time-stressed environments, because local adaptation was not caused by genetic assimilation but on selection on the standing genetic variation in development time.     

Temperature and immobility reaction in Rana temporaria

Experiments were conducted on two groups of Rana temporaria acclimatized to 7°C and to 14°C. Two hours prior to the experiments the animals were divided into six groups of 40 subjects each and placed in containers at temperatures of 5°, 10°, 15°, 20°, 25° and 30°C. Frogs remained immobile for a shorter time in temperatures which differed little from those of acclimatization. It was concluded that the body temperature interferes with the duration of the immobility reaction.     

Cerebellar afferents in the frogs,Rana esculenta and Rana temporaria

Summary Afferents to the cerebellum in frogs (Rana esculenta, Rana temporaria) were studied by use of retrograde transport of horseradish peroxidase. Following injections restricted to the molecular layer of the cerebellum cell labelling was found in the contralateral inferior olive and the ventral portion of the caudal medullary raphe. Injections involving the granular layer resulted in labelling in the ventral horn of the cervical spinal cord, the caudal spinal trigeminal nucleus, the nucleus caudalis and the medial portion of the nucleus ventralis of the vestibular nerve, the inferior reticular nucleus and the nucleus of the fasciculus longitudinalis medialis. Following larger injections, which may have spread significantly into the cerebellar, secondary gustatory, trigeminal or vestibular nuclei, labelled cell bodies were also found in the nucleus ruber, nucleus solitarius, the rostral spinal trigeminal nucleus and the rostral rhombencephalic reticular formation. It is unclear whether the fibers from these latter areas innervate the cerebellum of the frog, as they do in mammals, or only reach the underlying areas. This situation emphasizes a limitation of the HRP technique when applied to small structures as is often the case in lower vertebrates.Supported by Grant Gr 276 to U. G.-C. from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft.     

The effects of pH, aluminium concentration and temperature on the embryonic development of the European common frog, Rana temporaria

The individual and combined effects of pH, aluminium concentration and temperature, on the development of common frog ( Rana temporaria ) embryos from an upland area of northern England, were investigated in a controlled laboratory study. There was strong evidence to suggest that embryonic survival was lower at pH 4.5 compared with pH 6.0. At pH 4.5, embryonic survival was reduced at the highest aluminium concentrations. There was no strong evidence for a reduction in embryonic survival at lower aluminium concentrations.
Gastrulation and hatching appeared to be the most sensitive stages to both pH and aluminium concentration.
There was strong evidence to suggest that temperature-shocked embryos had reduced survival when compared with those kept at a constant temperature, particularly at pH 4.5.
There was substantial variation in the survival of embryos from different clutches in the same pond with respect to low pH, aluminium concentration and temperatures. Thus R. temporaria has a wide genetic base from which to tolerate environmental changes. It is suggested, however, that the lethal and sublethal effects of low pH, high aluminium concentration and low temperature, could lead to a decrease in recruitment to the adult populations of R. temporaria in upland, northern England.