A comparison of the second harmonic generation from light-adapted, dark-adapted, blue, and acid purple membrane.

The second order nonlinear polarizability and dipole moment changes upon light excitation of light-adapted bacteriorhodopsin (BR), dark-adapted BR, blue membrane, and acid purple membrane have been measured by second harmonic generation. Our results indicate that the dipole moment changes of the retinal chromophore, delta mu, are very sensitive to both the chromophore structure and protein/chromophore interactions. Delta mu of light-adapted BR is larger than that of dark-adapted BR. The acid-induced formation of the blue membrane results in an increase in the delta mu value, and formation of acid purple membrane, resulting from further reduction of pH to 0, returns the delta mu to that of light-adapted BR. The implications of these findings are discussed.     

Guanidinium restores the chromophore but not rapid proton release in bacteriorhodopsin mutant R82Q.

Replacement of the Arg residue at position 82 in bacteriorhodopsin by Gln or Ala was previously shown to slow the rate of proton release and raise the pK of Asp 85, indicating that R82 is involved both in the proton release reaction and in stabilizing the purple form of the chromophore. We now find that guanidinium chloride lowers the pK of D85, as monitored by the shift of the 587-nm absorbance maximum to 570 nm (blue to purple transition) and increased yield of photointermediate M. The absorbance shift follows a simple binding curve, with an apparent dissociation constant of 20 mM. When membrane surface charge is taken into account, an intrinsic dissociation constant of 0.3 M fits the data over a range of 0.2-1.0 M cation concentration (Na+ plus guanidinium) and pH 5.4-6.7. A chloride counterion is not involved in the observed spectral changes, as chloride up to 0.2 M has little effect on the R82Q chromophore at pH 6, whereas guanidinium sulfate has a similar effect to guanidinium chloride. Furthermore, guanidinium does not affect the chromophore of the double mutant R82Q/D85N. Taken together, these observations suggest that guanidinium binds to a specific site near D85 and restores the purple chromophore. Surprisingly, guanidinium does not restore rapid proton release in the photocycle of R82Q. This result suggests either that guanidinium dissociates during the pump cycle or that it binds with a different hydrogen-bonding geometry than the Arg side chain of the wild type.     

Light- and dark-adapted bacteriorhodopsin, a time-resolved neutron diffraction study

Recently, neutron diffraction experiments have revealed well-resolved and reversible changes in the protein conformation of bacteriorhodopsin (BR) between the light-adapted ground state and the M-intermediate of the proton pumping photocycle (Dencher, Dresselhaus, Zaccai and Büldt (1989) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 86, 7876-7879). These changes are triggered by the light-induced isomerization of the chromophore retinal from the all-trans to the 13-cis configuration. Dark-adapted purple membranes contain a mixture of two pigment species with either the all-trans- or 13-cis-retinal isomer as chromophore. Employing a time-resolved neutron diffraction technique, no changes in protein conformation in the resolution regime of up to 7 A are observed during the transition between the two ground-state species 13-cis-BR and all-trans-BR. This is in line with the fact that the conversion of all-trans BR to 13-cis-BR involves an additional isomerization about the C15 = N Schiff's base bond, which in contrast to M formation minimizes retinal displacement and keeps the Schiff's base in the original protein environment. Furthermore, there is no indication for large-scale redistribution of water molecules in the purple membrane during light-dark adaptation.     

Control of bacteriorhodopsin color by chloride at low pH. Significance for the proton pump mechanism

The chromophore of bacteriorhodopsin undergoes a transition from purple (570 nm absorbance maximum) to blue (605 nm absorbance maximum) at low pH or when the membrane is deionized. The blue form was stable down to pH 0 in sulfuric acid, while 1 M NaCl at pH 0 completely converted the pigment to a purple form absorbing maximally at 565 Other acids were not as effective as sulfuric in maintaining the blue form, and chloride was the best anion for converting blue membrane to purple membrane at low pH. The apparent dissociation constant for Cl- was 35 mM at pH 0, 0.7 M at pH 1 and 1.5 M at pH 2. The pH dependence of apparent Cl- binding could be modeled by assuming two different types of chromophore-linked Cl- binding site, one pH-dependent. Chemical modification of bacteriorhodopsin carboxyl groups (probably Asp-96, -102 and/or -104) by 1-ethyl-3-dimethlyaminopropyl carbodiimide, Lys-41 by dansyl chloride, or surface arginines by cyclohexanedione had no effect on the conversion of blue to purple membrane at pH 1. Fourier transform infrared difference spectroscopy of chloride purple membrane minus acid blue membrane showed the protonation of a carboxyl group (trough at 1392 cm -1 and peak at 1731 cm -1). The latter peak shifted to 1723 cm -1 in D2O. Ultraviolet difference spectroscopy of chloride purple membrane minus acid blue membrane showed ionization of a phenolic group (peak at 243 nm and evidence for a 295 nm peak superimposed on a tryptophan perturbation trough). This suggests the possibility of chloride-induced proton transfer from a tyrosine phenolic group to a carboxylate side-chain. We propose a mechanism for the purple to acid blue to chloride purple transition based on these results and the proton pump model of Braiman et al. (Biochemistry 27 (1988) 8516-8520).     

The quantum efficiency of proton pumping by the purple membrane of Halobacterium halobium.

The quantum yield of H+ release in purple membrane (PM) sheets, and H+ uptake in phospholipid (egg phosphatidylcholine, PC) vesicles containing PM, was measured in single turnover light flashes using a pH-sensitive dye, p-nitrophenol, with rhodopsin as an actinometer. We have also calculated the ratio of H+ released per M412 formed (an unprotonated Shiff-base intermediate formed during the photocycle). In PM sheets, the quantum yield of H+ release depends on the medium. The quantum yield of M412 is independent of salt concentration. The ratio H+/M412 is approximately 1.8 M KC; and approximately 0.64 in 10 mM KCl. Direct measurements of the quantum yield of H+ give approximately 0.7 when the PM is suspended in 0.5 M KC; and 0.25 in 10 mM KCl. Using a quantum yield for M412 formation of 0.3 (Becher and Ebrey, 1977 Biophys J. 17:185.), these measurements also give a H+/M412 approximately 2 at high salt. In PM/PC vesicles, the H+/M412 is approximately 2 at all salt concentrations. The M412 decay is biphasic and the dye absorption change is monophasic. The dissipation of the proton gradient is very slow, taking on the order of seconds. Addition of nigericin (H+/K+ antiporter) drastically reduces the pH changes observed in PM/PC vesicles. This and the observation that the proton relaxation time is much longer than the photochemical cycling time suggest that the protons are pumped across the membrane and there is no contribution as a result of reversible binding and release of protons on just one side of the membrane.     

菌紫质研究的新进展

菌紫质(BR)是嗜盐菌紫膜中的唯一蛋白质,野生型的BR分子含有248个氨基酸残基,其中一个视黄醛通过希夫碱基连结在第216位赖氨酸上,它具有质子泵的功能．光照下,BR进行光循环,光循环又与质子泵过程相关联．菌紫质的结构和功能方面的研究已有很大进展,但其光循环途径和质子泵的机理还不太清楚．文章概述了近年来对菌紫质结构,光循环和质子泵机理研究的进展,尤其对争论较大的菌紫质光循环途径的四类模型作了较详细的介绍．     

Anaerobic reaction of ascorbate oxidase with ascorbate

Ascorbate oxidase is fully reduced by 4 mol of ascorbate in the absence of air, as monitored by optical and electron paramagnetic resonance spectra. At less than stoichiometric ascorbate concentration there is a slow equilibration between the 605-and 330-nm absorption bands: The 605-nm chromophore is first reduced, then its color reappears while the 330-nm absorption band decreases. Upon reoxidation with air the process takes place in the opposite direction. Intramolecular rather than intermolecular electron exchange appears to be responsible for this process. The reduced protein is about twice as fluorescent as the oxidized protein. The fluorescence quenching in the oxidized protein is related to the 330-nm absorption band rather than to the 605-nm band as previously reported for laccase.     

Photoelectric response of polarization sensitive bacteriorhodopsin films

Polarization sensitivity is introduced into oriented bacteriorhodopsin (BR) films through a photochemical bleaching process, which chemically modifies the structure of the purple membrane by breaking the intrinsic symmetry of the membrane-bound BR trimers. The resulting photovoltage generated in an indium-tin oxide (ITO)/BR/ITO detector is found to be anisotropic with respect to cross-polarized probe beams. A model, based on the polarization dependent photoselection of the BR molecules qualitatively explains the photochemical bleaching process and the observed anisotropic response. The effect reported here can be used to construct a polarization sensitive BR-based bio-photoreceiver.     

Properties of a water-soluble, yellow protein isolated from a halophilic phototrophic bacterium that has photochemical activity analogous to sensory rhodopsin

A water-soluble yellow protein, previously discovered in the purple photosynthetic bacterium Ectothiorhodospira halophila, contains a chromophore which has an absorbance maximum at 446 nm. The protein is now shown to be photoactive. A pulse of 445-nm laser light caused the 446-nm peak to be partially bleached and red-shifted in a time less than 1 microsecond. The intermediate thus formed was subsequently further bleached in the dark in a biphasic process occurring in approximately 20 ms. Finally, the absorbance of native protein was restored in a first-order process occurring over several seconds. These kinetic processes are remarkably similar to those of sensory rhodopsin from Halobacterium, and to a lesser extent bacteriorhodopsin and halorhodopsin; although these proteins are membrane-bound, they have absorbance maxima at about 570 nm, and they cycle more rapidly. In attempts to remove the chromophore for identification, it was found that a variety of methods of denaturation of the protein caused transient or permanent conversion to a form which has an absorbance maximum near 340 nm. Thus, by analogy to the rhodopsins, the absorption at 446 nm in the native protein appears to result from a 106-nm red shift of the chromophore induced by the protein. Acid denaturation followed by extraction with organic solvents established that the chromophore could be removed from the protein. It is not identical with all-trans-retinal and remains to be identified, although it could still be a related pigment. The E. halophila yellow protein has a circular dichroism spectrum which indicates little alpha-helical secondary structure (19%).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

The chromophore retinal hinders passive proton/hydroxide ion translocation through bacteriorhodopsin

Experiments have been performed to examine any influence of the chromophore retinal in bacteriorhodopsin (BR) on the passive proton/hydroxide ion flux through this integral membrane protein. BR was reconstituted into dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC)-phosphatidylserine or DMPC-dimyristoylphosphatidylglycerol unilamellar vesicles with molar lipid to protein ratios ranging from 30 to 150. The entrapped fluorescence dye pyranine served as a reliable indicator of the internal proton concentration. Transmembrane pH-gradients were quickly established across the vesicular membrane and the kinetics of the induced fluorescence changes were compared for vesicles with incorporated native BR, BR bleached to the chromophore-free protein bacterioopsin, and BR regenerated from bacterioopsin with all-trans-retinal, respectively. For aggregated protein molecules, the H+/OH- diffusion across bacterioopsin was always considerably faster than that through the protein containing covalently bound retinal. The decay rate of the imposed pH-gradient was 4.4-9.1 and 2.0-5.1 times slower for native and regenerated BR, respectively, as compared to bacterioopsin. Stepwise regeneration of bacterioopsin with all-trans-retinal revealed a linear dependence of the predominant delta pH-decay time on the degree of regeneration. Essentially the same observations were made with monomeric protein molecules in vesicular lipid membranes. The results demonstrate that the chromophore retinal itself blocks the H+/OH- conducting pathway across the transmembrane protein BR or indirectly controls this path by inducing conformational changes in the protein upon binding.     

Photochemical conversion of the O-intermediate to 9-cis-retinal-containing products in bacteriorhodopsin films.

The photochemical activity of the O-state was investigated in bacteriorhodopsin (BR) films containing wildtype BR at pH 6.5 in the presence of glycerol. The formation of a photoproduct of O with an absorption maximum at 490 nm and 9-cis-retinal configuration was found. This 490-nm product was named P and shows a slow thermal reaction into a compound with a maximal absorption at 380 nm which was named Q and contains free 9-cis-retinal in the proteins binding site. The photoproducts of O, i.e., P and Q, are very similar, or even identical, to those previously observed in blue membranes. Common to the O-state and blue membrane forms of bacteriorhodopsin is a protonated aspartic acid 85, and we suggest that it is the reduced negative charge around the Schiff base which is responsible for the 9-cis photoisomerization. The release of a proton from aspartic acid 85 is linked to the conversion of the O-state back to the initial state of BR. Therefore the conditions of low proton mobility in BR films containing glycerol favor the accumulation of the O-state. For optical and holographic applications such BR films are very attractive. It is possible to create photoproducts with red light which are thermally stable at room temperature and that can be photochemically erased. Dependent on the light composition both properties can be realized in the same sample material. This feature may bridge the gap between information processing and short-term and long-term storage of information with BR.     

A transporter converted into a sensor, a phototaxis signaling mutant of bacteriorhodopsin at 3.0 Å

Bacteriorhodopsin (BR) and sensory rhodopsin II (SRII), homologous photoactive proteins in haloarchaea, have different molecular functions. BR is a light-driven proton pump, whereas SRII is a phototaxis receptor that transmits a light-induced conformational change to its transducer HtrII. Despite these distinctly different functions, a single residue substitution, Ala215 to Thr215 in the BR retinal-binding pocket, enables its photochemical reactions to transmit signals to HtrII and mediate phototaxis. We pursued a crystal structure of the signaling BR mutant (BR_A215T) to determine the structural changes caused by the A215T mutation and to assess what new photochemistry is likely to be introduced into the BR photoactive site. We crystallized BR_A215T from bicelles and solved its structure to 3.0 Å resolution to enable an atomic-level comparison. The analysis was complemented by molecular dynamics simulation of BR mutated in silico. Three main conclusions regarding the roles of photoactive site residues in signaling emerge from the comparison of BR_A215T, BR, and SRII structures: (i) the Thr215 residue in signaling BR is positioned nearly identically with respect to the retinal chromophore as in SRII, consistent with its role in producing a steric conflict with the retinal C₁₄ group during photoisomerization, proposed earlier to be essential for SRII signaling from vibrational spectroscopy and motility measurements; (ii) Tyr174–Thr204 hydrogen bonding, critical in SRII signaling and mimicked in signaling BR, is likely auxiliary, for example, to maintain Thr204 in the proper position for the steric trigger to occur; and (iii) the primary role of Arg72 in SRII is spectral tuning and not signaling.     

Dynamics of pH-induced spectral changes in bacteriorhodopsin.

The kinetics of the spectral shift induced in bacteriorhodopsin by low pH are investigated by using the rapid-mixing, stopped-flow technique. The generation of the acid form of the chromophore (A605) occurs in two distinct steps: a fast process (t1/2I = 21 +/- 4 ms) is followed by a much slower reaction (t1/2II = 6 +/- 2 s). The observations are interpreted in terms of neutralization of an acid group in the neighborhood of the retinyl chromophore, the double-staged kinetics being attributed to cooperative effects between chromophores. The method may serve as a tool for studying the kinetics of proton migration across the purple membrane.     

Specific binding sites for cations in bacteriorhodopsin.

The Asp-85 residue, located in the vicinity of the retinal chromophore, plays a key role in the function of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) as a light-driven proton pump. In the unphotolyzed pigment the protonation of Asp-85 is responsible for the transition from the purple form (lambda(max) = 570 nm) to the blue form (lambda(max) = 605 nm) of bR. This transition can also be induced by deionization (cation removal). It was previously proposed that the cations bind to the bR surface and raise the surface pH, or bind to a specific site in the protein, probably in the retinal vicinity. We have reexamined these possibilities by evaluating the interaction between Mn(2+) and a nitroxyl radical probe covalently bound to several mutants in which protein residues were substituted by cystein. We have found that Mn(2+), which binds to the highest-affinity binding site, significantly affects the EPR spectrum of a spin label attached to residue 74C. Therefore, it is concluded that the highest-affinity binding site is located in the extracellular side of the protein and its distance from the spin label at 74C is estimated to be approximately 9.8 +/- 0.7 A. At least part of the three to four low-affinity cation binding sites are located in the cytoplasmic side, because Mn(2+) bound to these binding sites affects spin labels attached to residues 103C and 163C located in the cytoplasmic side of the protein. The results indicate specific binding sites for the color-controlling cations, and suggest that the binding sites involve negatively charged lipids located on the exterior of the bR trimer structure.     

FTIR spectroscopy of the M photointermediate in pharaonis rhoborhodopsin

pharaonis phoborhodopsin (ppR; also called pharaonis sensory rhodopsin II, psR-II) is a photoreceptor for negative phototaxis in Natronobacterium pharaonis. During the photocycle of ppR, the Schiff base of the retinal chromophore is deprotonated upon formation of the M intermediate (ppR(M)). The present FTIR spectroscopy of ppR(M) revealed that the Schiff base proton is transferred to Asp-75, which corresponds to Asp-85 in a light-driven proton-pump bacteriorhodopsin (BR). In addition, the C==O stretching vibrations of Asn-105 were assigned for ppR and ppR(M). The common hydrogen-bonding alterations in Asn-105 of ppR and Asp-115 of BR were found in the process from photoisomerization (K intermediate) to the primary proton transfer (M intermediate). These results implicate similar protein structural changes between ppR and BR. However, BR(M) decays to BR(N) accompanying a proton transfer from Asp-96 to the Schiff base and largely changed protein structure. In the D96N mutant protein of BR that lacks a proton donor to the Schiff base, the N-like protein structure was observed with the deprotonated Schiff base (called M(N)) at alkaline pH. In ppR, such an N-like (M(N)-like) structure was not observed at alkaline pH, suggesting that the protein structure of the M state activates its transducer protein.     

A defective proton pump, point-mutated bacteriorhodopsin Asp96----Asn is fully reactivated by azide.

Addition of azide fully restored the proton pump activity of defective bacteriorhodopsin (BR) mutant protein Asp96----Asn. The decay time of M of BR Asp96----Asn, the longest living intermediate, was decreased from 500 ms at pH 7.0 to approximately 1 ms under conditions of saturating azide concentrations. This decay was faster than the decay of M in the wild-type, where no such azide effect was detectable. Stationary photocurrents, measured with purple membranes immobilized and oriented in a polyacrylamide gel, increased upon addition of azide up to the level of the wild-type. Different small anions of weak acids restored the pump activity with decreasing affinity in the order: cyanate greater than azide greater than nitrite greater than formiate greater than acetate. The activation energy of the M decay in the mutant was higher in the presence (48 kJ/mol) than in the absence (27 kJ/mol) of 100 mM azide even though the absolute rate was dramatically increased by azide. This effect of azide is due to the substitution of a carboxamido group for a carboxylic group at position 96 which removes the internal proton donor and causes an increase in the entropy change of activation for proton transfer which is reversed by azide.     

Structural changes of pharaonis phoborhodopsin upon photoisomerization of the retinal chromophore: infrared spectral comparison with bacteriorhodopsin

Archaeal rhodopsins possess a retinal molecule as their chromophores, and their light energy and light signal conversions are triggered by all-trans to 13-cis isomerization of the retinal chromophore. Relaxation through structural changes of the protein then leads to functional processes, proton pump in bacteriorhodopsin and transducer activation in sensory rhodopsins. In the present paper, low-temperature Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy is applied to phoborhodopsin from Natronobacterium pharaonis (ppR), a photoreceptor for the negative phototaxis of the bacteria, and infrared spectral changes before and after photoisomerization are compared with those of bacteriorhodopsin (BR) at 77 K. Spectral comparison of the C--C stretching vibrations of the retinal chromophore shows that chromophore conformation of the polyene chain is similar between ppR and BR. This fact implies that the unique chromophore-protein interaction in ppR, such as the blue-shifted absorption spectrum with vibrational fine structure, originates from both ends, the beta-ionone ring and the Schiff base regions. In fact, less planer ring structure and stronger hydrogen bond of the Schiff base were suggested for ppR. Similar frequency changes upon photoisomerization are observed for the C==N stretch of the retinal Schiff base and the stretch of the neighboring threonine side chain (Thr79 in ppR and Thr89 in BR), suggesting that photoisomerization in ppR is driven by the motion of the Schiff base like BR. Nevertheless, the structure of the K state after photoisomerization is different between ppR and BR. In BR, chromophore distortion is localized in the Schiff base region, as shown in its hydrogen out-of-plane vibrations. In contrast, more extended structural changes take place in ppR in view of chromophore distortion and protein structural changes. Such structure of the K intermediate of ppR is probably correlated with its high thermal stability. In fact, almost identical infrared spectra are obtained between 77 and 170 K in ppR. Unique chromophore-protein interaction and photoisomerization processes in ppR are discussed on the basis of the present infrared spectral comparison with BR.     

Thermodynamics of proton transfer in carboxylic acid-retinal Schiff base hydrogen bonds with large proton polarizability

During the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin (BR) the chromophore, a retinal Schiff base, is deprotonated. Simultaneously an asp residue is protonated. These results suggest that this deprotonation occurs via a Schiff base - asp hydrogen bond. Therefore, we studied carboxylic acid - retinal Schiff base model systems in CCl4 using IR spectroscopy. The IR spectra show that double minimum proton potentials are present in the OH ... N in equilibrium with O- ... HN+ H-bonds formed and that the proton can easily be shifted in these bonds by local electrical fields. The thermodynamic data of H-bond formation and proton transfer within these H-bonds are determined. On the basis of these data a hypothesis is developed with regard to the molecular mechanism of the deprotonation of the Schiff base of BR.     

Binding of the nonprotein chromophore of neocarzinostatin to deoxyribonucleic acid

The methanol-extracted, nonprotein chromophore of neocarzinostatin (NCS), which has DNA-degrading activity comparable to that of the native antibiotic, was found to have a strong affinity for DNA. Binding of chromophore was shown by (1) quenching by DNA of the 440-nm fluorescence and shifting of the emission peak to 420 nm, (2) protection by DNA against spontaneous loss of activity in aqueous solution, and (3) inhibition by DNA of the spontaneous generation of 490-nm fluorescence. Good quantitative correlation was found between these three methods in measuring chromophore binding. There was nearly a 1:1 correspondence between loss of chromophore activity and generation of 490-nm fluorescence, suggesting spontaneous degradation of active chromophore to a highly fluorescent product. Chromophore showed a preference for DNA high in adenine + thymine content in both fluorescence quenching and protection studies. NCS apoprotein, which is known to bind and protect active chromophore, quenched the 440-nm fluorescence, shifted the emission peak to 420 nm, and inhibited the generation of 490-nm fluorescence. Chromophore had a higher affinity for apoprotein than for DNA. Pretreatment of chromophore with 2-mercaptoethanol increased the 440-nm fluorescence seven-fold and eliminated the tendency to generate 490-nm fluorescence. The 440-nm fluorescence of this inactive material was also quenched by DNA and shifted to 420 nm, indicating an affinity for DNA comparable to that of untreated chromophore. However, its affinity for apoprotein was much lower than that of untreated chromophore. Both 2-mercapto-ethanol-treated and untreated chromophore unwound supercoiled pMB9 DNA, suggesting intercalation by both molecules. Since no physical evidence for interaction of native neocarzinostatin with DNA has been found, it is likely that dissociation of the chromophore from the protein and association with DNA are important steps in degradation of DNA by neocarzinostatin.     

pH dependence of light-driven proton pumping by an archaerhodopsin from Tibet: comparison with bacteriorhodopsin

The pH-dependence of photocycle of archaerhodopsin 4 (AR4) was examined, and the underlying proton pumping mechanism investigated. AR4 is a retinal-containing membrane protein isolated from a strain of halobacteria from a Tibetan salt lake. It acts as a light-driven proton pump like bacteriorhodopsin (BR). However, AR4 exhibits an "abnormal" feature--the time sequence of proton release and uptake is reversed at neutral pH. We show here that the temporal sequence of AR4 reversed to "normal"--proton release preceding proton uptake--when the pH is increased above 8.6. We estimated the pK(a) of the proton release complex (PRC) in the M-intermediate to be approximately 8.4, much higher than 5.7 of wide-type BR. The pH-dependence of the rate constant of M-formation shows that the pK(a) of PRC in the initial state of AR4 is approximately 10.4, whereas it is 9.7 in BR. Thus in AR4, the chromophore photoisomerization and subsequent proton transport from the Schiff base to Asp-85 is coupled to a decrease in the pK(a) of PRC from 10.4 to 8.4, which is 2 pK units less than in BR (4 units). This weakened coupling accounts for the lack of early proton release at neutral pH and the reversed time sequence of proton release and uptake in AR4. Nevertheless the PRC in AR4 effectively facilitates deprotonation of primary proton acceptor and recovery of initial state at neutral pH. We found also that all pK(a)s of the key amino acid residues in AR4 were elevated compared to those of BR.