Structural research on surface layers: a focus on stability, surface layer homology domains, and surface layer-cell wall interactions

Surface layers (S-layers) from Bacteria and Archaea are built from protein molecules arrayed in a two-dimensional lattice, forming the outermost cell wall layer in many prokaryotes. In almost half a century of S-layer research a wealth of structural, biochemical, and genetic data have accumulated, but it has not been possible to correlate sequence data with the tertiary structure of S-layer proteins to date. In this paper, some highlights of structural aspects of archaeal and bacterial S-layers that allow us to draw some conclusions on molecular properties are reviewed. We focus on the structural requirements for the extraordinary stability of many S-layer proteins, the structural and functional aspects of the S-layer homology domain found in S-layers, extracellular enzymes and related functional proteins, and outer membrane proteins, and the molecular interactions of S-layer proteins with other cell wall components. Finally, the perspectives and requirements for structural research on S-layers, which indicate that the investigation of isolated protein domains will be a prerequisite for solving S-layer structures at atomic resolution, are discussed.     

Bacterial and Archaeal S-Layers as a Subject of Nanobiotechnology

Many bacteria and archaea have a crystalline surface layer (S-layer), which overlies the cell envelope. S-layers each consist of one protein or glycoprotein species. Protein subunits of the S-layer noncovalently interact with each other and with the underlying cell-envelope component. On average, the S-layer lattice has pores of 2–6 nm and is 5–10 nm high. Isolated S-layer proteins recrystallize to form two-dimensional crystalline structures in solution, on a solid support, and on planar lipid membranes. Owing to this unique property, S-layers have a broad range of applications. This review focuses on the structural features and applications of S-layers and their proteins, with special emphasis on their use in nanobiotechnology.     

Bacterial and archaeal S-layers as object of bionanotechnology

Many species of Bacteria and Archaea posses a regularly structured surface layers (S-layers) as outermost cell envelope component. S-layers composed of a single protein or glycoprotein species. The individual subunits of S-layers interact with each other and with the supporting bacterial envelope component through non-covalent forces. Pores in the crystalline protein network are with mean diameter of 2-6 nm, the thickness of S-layer is 5-10 nm. The isolated S-layer subunits reassemble into two-dimensional crystalline arrays in solution, on solid supports, on planar lipid films. These unique features of S-layers have led to a broad spectrum applications. This review focuses on the structural properties S-layers and S-proteins and their applications with accent to using this structures in nanobiotechnology.     

S-layers as a tool kit for nanobiotechnological applications

Crystalline bacterial cell surface layers (S-layers) have been identified in a great number of different species of bacteria and represent an almost universal feature of archaea. Isolated native S-layer proteins and S-layer fusion proteins incorporating functional sequences self-assemble into monomolecular crystalline arrays in suspension, on a great variety of solid substrates and on various lipid structures including planar membranes and liposomes. S-layers have proven to be particularly suited as building blocks and patterning elements in a biomolecular construction kit involving all major classes of biological molecules (proteins, lipids, glycans, nucleic acids and combinations of them) enabling innovative approaches for the controlled 'bottom-up' assembly of functional supramolecular structures and devices. Here, we review the basic principles of S-layer proteins and the application potential of S-layers in nanobiotechnology and biomimetics including life and nonlife sciences.     

Host cell invasion and intracellular residence by Aeromonas salmonicida: role of the S-layer

Virulent strains of the fish pathogen Aeromonas salmonicida, which have surface S-layers (S+), efficiently adhere to, enter, and survive within macrophages. Here we report that S+ bacteria were 10- to 20-fold more adherent to non-phagocytic fish cell lines than S-layer-negative (S-) mutants. When reconstituted with exogenous S-layers, these S- mutants regained adherence. As well, latex beads coated with purified S-layers were more adherent to fish cell lines than uncoated beads, or beads coated with disorganized S-layers, suggesting that purified S-layers were sufficient to mediate high levels of adherence, and that this process relied on S-layer structure. Gentamicin protection assays and electron microscopy indicated that both S+ and S- A. salmonicida invaded non-phagocytic fish cells. In addition, these fish cells were unable to internalize S-layer-coated beads, clearly suggesting that the S-layer is not an invasion factor. Lipopolysaccharide (which is partially exposed in S+ bacteria) appeared to mediate invasion. Surprisingly, A. salmonicida did not show net growth inside fish cells cultured in the presence of gentamicin, as determined by viable bacterial cell counts. On the contrary, bacterial viability sharply decreased after cell infection. We thus concluded that the S-layer is an adhesin that promotes but does not mediate invasion of non-phagocytic fish cell lines. These cell lines should prove useful in studies aimed at characterizing the invasion mechanisms of A. salmonicida, but of limited value in studying the intracellular residence and replication of this invasive bacterium in vitro.     

S-layer-supported lipid membranes

Many prokaryotic organisms (archaea and bacteria) are covered by a regularly ordered surface layer (S-layer) as the outermost cell wall component. S-layers are built up of a single protein or glycoprotein species and represent the simplest biological membrane developed during evolution. Pores in S-layers are of regular size and morphology, and functional groups on the protein lattice are aligned in well-defined positions and orientations. Due to the high degree of structural regularity S-layers represent unique systems for studying the structure, morphogenesis, and function of layered supramolecular assemblies. Isolated S-layer subunits of numerous organisms are able to assemble into monomolecular arrays either in suspension, at air/water interfaces, on planar mono- and bilayer lipid films, on liposomes and on solid supports (e.g. silicon wafers). Detailed studies on composite S-layer/lipid structures have been performed with Langmuir films, freestanding bilayer lipid membranes, solid supported lipid membranes, and liposomes. Lipid molecules in planar films and liposomes interact via their head groups with defined domains on the S-layer lattice. Electrostatic interactions are the most prevalent forces. The hydrophobic chains of the lipid monolayers are almost unaffected by the attachment of the S-layer and no impact on the hydrophobic thickness of the membranes has been observed. Upon crystallization of a coherent S-layer lattice on planar and vesicular lipid membranes, an increase in molecular order is observed, which is reflected in a decrease of the membrane tension and an enhanced mobility of probe molecules within an S-layer-supported bilayer. Thus, the terminology 'semifluid membrane' has been introduced for describing S-layer-supported lipid membranes. The most important feature of composite S-layer/lipid membranes is an enhanced stability in comparison to unsupported membranes.     

Primary structure of selected archaeal mesophilic and extremely thermophilic outer surface layer proteins

The archaea are recognized as a separate third domain of life together with the bacteria and eucarya. The archaea include the methanogens, extreme halophiles, thermoplasmas, sulfate reducers and sulfur metabolizing thermophiles, which thrive in different habitats such as anaerobic niches, salt lakes, and marine hydrothermals systems and continental solfataras. Many of these habitats represent extreme environments in respect to temperature, osmotic pressure and pH-values and remind on the conditions of the early earth. The cell envelope structures were one of the first biochemical characteristics of archaea studied in detail. The most common archaeal cell envelope is composed of a single crystalline protein or glycoprotein surface layer (S-layer), which is associated with the outside of the cytoplasmic membrane. The S-layers are directly exposed to the extreme environment and can not be stabilized by cellular components. Therefore, from comparative studies of mesophilic and extremely thermophilic S-layer proteins hints can be obtained about the molecular mechanisms of protein stabilization at high temperatures. First crystallization experiments of surface layer proteins under microgravity conditions were successful. Here, we report on the biochemical features of selected mesophilic and extremely archaeal S-layer (glyco-) proteins.     

Are S-layers exoskeletons? The basic function of protein surface layers revisited

Surface protein or glycoprotein layers (S-layers) are common structures of the prokaryotic cell envelope. They are either associated with the peptidoglycan or outer membrane of bacteria, and constitute the only cell wall component of many archaea. Despite their occurrence in most of the phylogenetic branches of microorganisms, the functional significance of S-layers is assumed to be specific for genera or groups of organisms in the same environment rather than common to all prokaryotes. Functional aspects have usually been investigated with isolated S-layer sheets or proteins, which disregards the interactions between S-layers and the underlying cell envelope components. This study discusses the synergistic effects in cell envelope assemblies, the hypothetical role of S-layers for cell shape formation, and the existence of a common function in view of new insights.     

Comparative study on the cell wall structure of protein-producing Bacillus brevis

Abstract Among eight strains of protein-producing Bacillus brevis , three morphological groups have been identified according to the structure of the cell walls.

• (I)

  Cell wall consisting of a peptidoglycanlayer
• (II)

  Two-layered cell wall consisting of a peptidoglycan-layer and an S-layer
• (III)

  Three-layered cell wall consisting of a peptidoglycan-layer and two S-layers

Group I and group II cell walls have not been described yet for protein-producing bacteria. The S-layers observed in this study all had hexagonal symmetry and lattice constants of approximately 18 nm. The immunological relation between the S-layer proteins of the newly isolated B. brevis strains and those of B. brevis 47 has been examined using antisera against both S-layer-proteins of B. brevis 47. S-layers from protein-producing B. brevis strains, which were adjacent to the peptidoglycan-layer, were similar to each other, whether they were the outermost cell wall layer (group II) or not (group III). However, no similarity was found between these layers and the outermost S-layer of B. brevis 47 (group III).     

Classification of hyper-variable Corynebacterium glutamicum surface-layer proteins by sequence analyses and atomic force microscopy

The structural S-layer proteins of 28 different Corynebacterium glutamicum isolates have been analyzed systematically. Treatment of whole C. glutamicum cells with detergents resulted in the isolation of S-layer proteins with different apparent molecular masses, ranging in size from 55 to 66 kDa. The S-layer genes analyzed were characterized by coding regions ranging from 1,473 to 1,533 nucleotides coding for S-layer proteins with a size of 490-510 amino acids. Using PCR techniques, the corresponding S-layer genes of the 28 C. glutamicum isolates were all cloned and sequenced. The deduced amino acid sequences of the S-layer proteins showed identities between 69 and 98% and could be grouped into five phylogenetic classes. Furthermore, sequence analyses indicated that the S-layer proteins of the analyzed C. glutamicum isolates exhibit a mosaic structure of highly conserved and highly variable regions. Several conserved regions were assumed to play a key role in the formation of the C. glutamicum S-layers. Especially the N-terminal signal peptides and the C-terminal anchor sequences of the S-layer proteins showed a nearly perfect amino acid sequence conservation. Analyses by atomic force microscopy revealed a committed hexagonal structure. Morphological diversity of the C. glutamicum S-layers was observed in a class-specific unit cell dimension (ranging from 15.2 to 17.4 nm), which correlates with the sequence similarity-based classification. It could be demonstrated that differences in the primary structure of the S-layer proteins were reflected by the S-layer morphology.     

Heterogeneity of S-layer proteins of Lactobacillus acidophilus strains.

An S-layer (surface regular array) was found in the cell wall from six out of ten strains of Lactobacillus acidophilus examined by electron microscopic observations. All of the six strains which were shown to carry the S-layers belonged to the deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) homology group A, but not to B, which had been classified by Johnson et al (Int. J. Syst. Bacteriol. 30: 53-68, 1980). On the other hand, the other four strains which possessed no S-layers were in the homology group B. The apparent molecular weights of the S-layer proteins ranged from 41 to 49 kDa as estimated by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Of the S-layer proteins from the six strains, three were susceptible to chemical cleavage with N-chlorosuccinimide, giving different peptide maps. All of the six S-layer proteins were fragmented by limited proteolysis with Staphylococcus aureus V8 protease, and gave markedly different peptide patterns by the subsequent peptide mapping analysis, except that the peptide maps of the S-layer proteins from the two strains which were in the same subgroup were identical.     

炭疽杆菌S层的研究进展

S层是广泛存在于古细菌和真细菌细胞壁最外层的结构独特、功能特殊的成分,对它的研究具有重要的意义。炭疽杆菌是引起人畜炭疽病的病原体,对其S层的研究将为深入认识该菌的生理特性及致病机制等提供坚实的基础。就近年来对炭疽杆菌S层的结构、功能特点及应用前景等方面的研究进展做一简要的综述。     

Charting and unzipping the surface layer of Corynebacterium glutamicum with the atomic force microscope

Bacterial surface layers (S-layers) are extracellular protein networks that act as molecular sieves and protect a large variety of archaea and bacteria from hostile environments. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) was used to asses the S-layer of Coryne-bacterium glutamicum formed of PS2 proteins that assemble into hexameric complexes within a hexagonal lattice. Native and trypsin-treated S-layers were studied. Using the AFM stylus as a nanodissector, native arrays that adsorbed to mica as double layers were separated. All surfaces of native and protease-digested S-layers were imaged at better than 1 nm lateral resolution. Difference maps of the topographies of native and proteolysed samples revealed the location of the cleaved C-terminal fragment and the sidedness of the S-layer. Because the corrugation depths determined from images of both sides span the total thickness of the S-layer, a three-dimensional reconstruction of the S-layer could be calculated. Lattice defects visualized at 1 nm resolution revealed the molecular boundaries of PS2 proteins. The combination of AFM imaging and single molecule force spectroscopy allowed the mechanical properties of the Corynebacterium glutamicum S-layer to be examined. The results provide a basis for understanding the amazing stability of this protective bacterial surface coat.     

Structural and chemical characterization of S-layers of selected strains ofBacillus stearothermophilus andDesulfotomaculum nigrificans

The structures, amino acid- and neutral sugar compositions of the crystalline surface layers (S-layers) of four selected strains each ofBacillus stearothermophilus andDesulfotomaculum nigrificans were compared. Among the four strains of each species a remarkable diversity in the molecular weights of the S-layer subunits and in the geometry and constants of the S-layer lattices was apparent. The crystalline arrays included hexagonal (p6), square (p4) and oblique (p2) lattices. In vitro self-assembly of isolated S-layer subunits (or S-layer fragments) led to the formation of flat sheets or open-ended cylindrical assembly products. The amino acid composition of the S-layers exhibited great similarities and was predominantly acidic. With the exception of the S-layers of two strains ofB. stearothermophilus (where only traces of neutral sugars could be detected), all other S-layer proteins seemed to be glycosylated. Among these strains significant differences in the amount and composition of the glycan portions were found. Based on this diversity interesting questions may be asked about the biological significance of the carbohydrate units of glycoproteins in prokaryotic organisms.     

S-layer fusion proteins--construction principles and applications

Crystalline bacterial cell surface layers (S-layers) are the outermost cell envelope component of many bacteria and archaea. S-layers are monomolecular arrays composed of a single protein or glycoprotein species and represent the simplest biological membrane developed during evolution. The wealth of information available on the structure, chemistry, genetics and assembly of S-layers revealed a broad spectrum of applications in nanobiotechnology and biomimetics. By genetic engineering techniques, specific functional domains can be incorporated in S-layer proteins while maintaining the self-assembly capability. These techniques have led to new types of affinity structures, microcarriers, enzyme membranes, diagnostic devices, biosensors, vaccines, as well as targeting, delivery and encapsulation systems.     

Structural analysis and evidence for dynamic emergence of Bacillus anthracis S-layer networks

Surface layers (S-layers), which form the outermost layers of many Bacteria and Archaea, consist of protein molecules arranged in two-dimensional crystalline arrays. Bacillus anthracis, a gram-positive, spore-forming bacterium, responsible for anthrax, synthesizes two abundant surface proteins: Sap and EA1. Regulatory studies showed that EA1 and Sap appear sequentially at the surface of the parental strain. Sap and EA1 can form arrays. The structural parameters of S-layers from mutant strains (EA1(-) and Sap(-)) were determined by computer image processing of electron micrographs of negatively stained regular S-layer fragments or deflated whole bacteria. Sap and EA1 projection maps were calculated on a p1 symmetry basis. The unit cell parameters of EA1 were a = 69 A, b = 83 A, and gamma = 106 degrees, while those of Sap were a = 184 A, b = 81 A, and gamma = 84 degrees. Freeze-etching experiments and the analysis of the peripheral regions of the cell suggested that the two S-layers have different settings. We characterized the settings of each network at different growth phases. Our data indicated that the scattered emergence of EA1 destabilizes the Sap S-layer.     

Single-molecule force spectroscopy reveals the individual mechanical unfolding pathways of a surface layer protein

Surface layers (S-layers) represent an almost universal feature of archaeal cell envelopes and are probably the most abundant bacterial cell proteins. S-layers are monomolecular crystalline structures of single protein or glycoprotein monomers that completely cover the cell surface during all stages of the cell growth cycle, thereby performing their intrinsic function under a constant intra- and intermolecular mechanical stress. In gram-positive bacteria, the individual S-layer proteins are anchored by a specific binding mechanism to polysaccharides (secondary cell wall polymers) that are linked to the underlying peptidoglycan layer. In this work, atomic force microscopy-based single-molecule force spectroscopy and a polyprotein approach are used to study the individual mechanical unfolding pathways of an S-layer protein. We uncover complex unfolding pathways involving the consecutive unfolding of structural intermediates, where a mechanical stability of 87 pN is revealed. Different initial extensibilities allow the hypothesis that S-layer proteins adapt highly stable, mechanically resilient conformations that are not extensible under the presence of a pulling force. Interestingly, a change of the unfolding pathway is observed when individual S-layer proteins interact with secondary cell wall polymers, which is a direct signature of a conformational change induced by the ligand. Moreover, the mechanical stability increases up to 110 pN. This work demonstrates that single-molecule force spectroscopy offers a powerful tool to detect subtle changes in the structure of an individual protein upon binding of a ligand and constitutes the first conformational study of surface layer proteins at the single-molecule level.     

Ultrastructure of the cell envelope of the archaebacteria Thermoproteus tenax and Thermoproteus neutrophilus.

The ultrastructures of the regular surface layers (S-layers) of the extremely thermophilic archaebacteria Thermoproteus tenax and Thermoproteus neutrophilus were examined by freeze-etching, freeze-drying, and negative staining methods combined with optical and digital image enhancement. In both strains, a monolayer of macromolecules arranged in hexagonal arrays with center-to-center spacings of approximately 30 nm was the only component of the cell wall. The gross morphologies of the S-layer lattices of the two organisms were similar and showed the same handedness in the arrangement of the protomers of the morphological units. Striking differences were found in the anionic charge distributions on the surfaces of the two S-layer proteins as determined by labeling with polycationic ferritin. Analysis of the lattice orientation, together with the number and distribution of lattice faults on intact cells, provided a strong indication that the S-layers of both organisms have a shape-determining function.     

Two-dimensional protein crystals (S-layers): Fundamentals and applications

Two-diminsional crystalline surface layers (S-layers) composed of prtein or glucoprotein subunits are one of the most commonly observed prokaryotic cell envelope structures. lsolated S-layer Subunits are endowed with the ability to assemble into monomolecular arrays in suspension, on surfaces or interface by an entropy-driven process. S-layer lattices are isoporous structures with functional groups located on the surface in an identical position and orientation. These characteristic featupes have alreadu led to applicatioinns of S-layers as (1) ultrafilration membranes with well-defiled mmlecular weight cut -ooffs and excellent antifouling characteristics, (2) immobilization matrices for functional molecules as required for affiviy and enzyme memberanes, affiniy micricarriers and biosensors, (3) conjugate vaaines, (4) carriers for Langmuir-Blodgett films and reconstituted biological memberanes, and (5) patterning elements in molecular nanotechnology.     

Lactobacillus surface layers and their applications

Surface (S-) layers are crystalline arrays of proteinaceous subunits present as the outermost component of cell wall in several species of the genus Lactobacillus, as well as in many other bacteria and Archaea. Despite the high similarity of the amino acid composition of all known S-layer proteins, the overall sequence similarity is, however, surprisingly small even between the Lactobacillus S-layer proteins. In addition, the typical characteristics of Lactobacillus S-layer proteins, distinguishing them from other S-layer proteins, are small size and high-predicted pI value. Several lactobacilli possess multiple S-layer protein genes, which can be differentially or simultaneously expressed. To date, the characterized functions of Lactobacillus S-layers are involved in mediating adhesion to different host tissues. A few applications for the S-layer proteins of lactobacilli already exist, including their use as antigen delivery vehicles.