Never too many? How legumes control nodule numbers

Restricted availability of nitrogen compounds in soils is often a major limiting factor for plant growth and productivity. Legumes circumvent this problem by establishing a symbiosis with soil-borne bacteria, called rhizobia that fix nitrogen for the plant. Nitrogen fixation and nutrient exchange take place in specialized root organs, the nodules, which are formed by a coordinated and controlled process that combines bacterial infection and organ formation. Because nodule formation and nitrogen fixation are energy-consuming processes, legumes develop the minimal number of nodules required to ensure optimal growth. To this end, several mechanisms have evolved that adapt nodule formation and nitrogen fixation to the plant's needs and environmental conditions, such as nitrate availability in the soil. In this review, we give an updated view on the mechanisms that control nodulation.     

Immunity of a leguminous plant infected by nodular bacteria <Emphasis Type="Italic">Rhizobium</Emphasis> spp. F.: Review

Recent studies of the immune system of leguminous plants infected with nodular bacteria (rhizobia) are summarized. The possibility of blocking the invasion of rhizobia into plant organs not affected by the primary infection is discussed. The concept of local and systemic resistance of the leguminous plant to rhizobial infection is introduced. The Nod factors of rhizobia are considered, as well as the plant receptors that interact with these factors upon the formation of symbiosis of the plant and bacteria. The role of bacterial surface exopolysaccharides in the suppression of the protective system of the plants is discussed. The innate immunity of leguminous plant cells is assumed to affect the formation and functioning of the symbiosis of the plant and the bacteria.     

Contribution of NFP LysM domains to the recognition of Nod factors during the Medicago truncatula/Sinorhizobium meliloti symbiosis

The root nodule nitrogen fixing symbiosis between legume plants and soil bacteria called rhizobia is of great agronomical and ecological interest since it provides the plant with fixed atmospheric nitrogen. The establishment of this symbiosis is mediated by the recognition by the host plant of lipo-chitooligosaccharides called Nod Factors (NFs), produced by the rhizobia. This recognition is highly specific, as precise NF structures are required depending on the host plant. Here, we study the importance of different LysM domains of a LysM-Receptor Like Kinase (LysM-RLK) from Medicago truncatula called Nod factor perception (NFP) in the recognition of different substitutions of NFs produced by its symbiont Sinorhizobium meliloti. These substitutions are a sulphate group at the reducing end, which is essential for host specificity, and a specific acyl chain at the non-reducing end, that is critical for the infection process. The NFP extracellular domain (ECD) contains 3 LysM domains that are predicted to bind NFs. By swapping the whole ECD or individual LysM domains of NFP for those of its orthologous gene from pea, SYM10 (a legume plant that interacts with another strain of rhizobium producing NFs with different substitutions), we showed that NFP is not directly responsible for specific recognition of the sulphate substitution of S. meliloti NFs, but probably interacts with the acyl substitution. Moreover, we have demonstrated the importance of the NFP LysM2 domain for rhizobial infection and we have pinpointed the importance of a single leucine residue of LysM2 in that step of the symbiosis. Together, our data put into new perspective the recognition of NFs in the different steps of symbiosis in M. truncatula, emphasising the probable existence of a missing component for early NF recognition and reinforcing the important role of NFP for NF recognition during rhizobial infection.     

Bacterial Endocytic Systems in Plants and Animals: Ca2+ as a Common Theme?

Intracellular interactions between bacteria and host cells are widespread in nature. In this review, the similarity between the infection processes of bacteria in plant and animal cells will be addressed. As paradigms, we selected the symbiosis between rhizobia and leguminous plants, and the survival of intracellular pathogenic bacteria in animal cells. The rhizobial symbiosis with leguminous plants is a model system for the study of plant-bacterium interactions. Through this interaction, the bacteria are released in a vacuole-like structure, called the symbiosome. The molecular processes, which lead to a functional symbiosome, are far from known. However, membrane fusion processes, and therefore also Ca²⁺, are crucial to establish this highly specialized organelle-like structure. A homologous system is the infection by certain bacterial pathogens of animal cells. These bacteria enter their host via phagocytosis and avoid the fusion with lysosomes, resulting in a membrane-bound vacuole in which the pathogens survive. The origin and maturation of this phagosome depends on Ca²⁺-signaling processes in the host cell and on proteins that regulate membrane fusion processes, such as SNAREs, Rab proteins, synaptotagmins and calmodulin. The aim of this review is to compare the endosymbiosis in leguminous plants with the surviving pathogens in animal host cells with a focus on Ca²⁺-signaling and membrane fusion-related processes. For both systems, the interaction starts with a bacterial entry of the host cell. It will be demonstrated that in both cases Ca²⁺ is a crucial second messenger. However, more emphasis will be put on the comparison of the later stages of infection, i.e., the formation of specialized bacteria-containing vacuoles. From structural, functional, and proteomic data, it is clear that phagosomes and symbiosomes are more related to each other than originally assumed. Proteins such as V-ATPases, calreticulin, phosphatidylinositol-3-kinase, Rab proteins, and SNAREs are present in both the phagosome and the symbiosome membrane, indicating that common cellular processes are used for building these intracellular organelles.     

The biological interactions ofRhizobium to its host legume

Conclusion The intensive study of the symbiosis ofRhizobium and its legume host-plant has emphasised how delicate is the equilibrium upon which a satisfactory association depends. The effectiveness of the bacterial strain for a particular host plant, the genetic stability of this strain and its ability to compete with other strains in the soil may all influence the growth of the crop. The plant begins to exert its influence on the bacteria by root secretions before they infect the roots and both the degree of infection and the activity of the nodules that are formed, will be influenced by genes in the plant as well as by environmental conditions that affect its physiology. It is the separation of these complex factors, that is at once the main difficulty and the chief fascination in the study of this symbiosis.     

Evolution of symbiotic bacteria within the extra- and intra-cellular plant compartments: experimental evidence and mathematical simulation (Mini-review)

Using the example of nodular legume-rhizobia symbiosis (LRS), we discuss the evolution in plant micro-symbionts of mutualistic traits that are apparently host-beneficial and therefore the products of inter-species evolution. These traits include: in planta activation of N₂ fixation machinery; exporting the products of nitrogenase reaction into the plant cells/tissues; and the terminal differentiation of bacteria into non-reproductive N₂-fixing bacteroids. It seems probable that such adaptive traits evolved by natural selection within the populations of endosymbiotic bacteria that colonize the extra- and intra-cellular compartments provided by the hosts (i.e., infection threads and symbiosomes). This evolution would occur under the impacts of group (inter-deme, kin) selection pressures induced by the partners’ metabolic and regulatory feedbacks that ensure the high activity of symbiotic N₂ fixation. These important feedbacks include: progressive allocation of C compounds into N₂-fixing nodules; maintenance of micro-aerobic intracellular environments that are indispensable for intensive N₂ fixation; and stringent control by the host over bacterial reproduction in planta. A computational simulation of the associated co-evolutionary processes reveals the trade-off between inter-species and individual species components of progressive and adaptive LRS evolution. This is expressed as a correlated increase of ecological efficiency, functional integrity and genotypic specificity of mutualistic symbiosis. Thus, the evolution of rhizobia in symbiosis may be represented by a progressive multi-level scenario based on increasing the dependency of bacteria on the host-provided nutrients accompanied by increasing complexity of the bacterial genomes and of the symbiosis-encoding gene networks.     

Bacterial genes induced within the nodule during the Rhizobium–legume symbiosis

During the symbiosis between the bacterium Rhizobium meliloti and plants such as alfalfa, the bacteria elicit the formation of nodules on the roots of host plants. The bacteria infect the nodule, enter the cytoplasm of plant cells and differentiate into a distinct cell type called a bacteroid, which is capable of fixing atmospheric nitrogen. To discover bacterial genes involved in the infection and differentiation stages of symbiosis, we obtained genes expressed at the appropriate time and place in the nodule by identifying promoters that are able to direct expression of the bacA gene, which is required for bacteroid differentiation. We identified 230 fusions that are expressed predominantly in the nodule. Analysis of 23 sequences indicated that only three encode proteins known to be involved in the Rhizobium-legume symbiosis, six encode proteins with homology to proteins not previously associated with symbiosis, and 14 have no significant similarity to proteins of known function. Disruption of a locus that encodes a protein with homology to a cell adhesion molecule led to a defect in the formation of nitrogen-fixing nodules, resulting in an increased number of nitrogen-starved plants. Our isolation of a large number of nodule-expressed genes will help to open the intermediate stages of nodulation to molecular analysis.     

Informationsaustausch in der Ektomykorrhiza

To see the wood for the trees: Communication in ectomycorrhizal symbiosis The mutual symbiosis of ectomycorrhiza has been established in a co‐evolution that depends on a specific communication between the woody plant and the fungus. The exchange of inorganic nutrients and water (delivered by the fungus) for sugar (supplied by the host tree) provides the basis for the symbiosis. The interaction is initiated with signals that can be associated with root exudates and volatiles in the soil matrix. After recognition, the fungus is able to modulate plant response functions that usually suppress pathogens by excretion of effector molecules, which allows entry into the root. Within the root, specific cell wall proteins of the fungus like hydrophobins are important for host specificity. Signals in the mycorrhizal root like the auxin indole‐acetic acid modify the morphology of both partners resulting in the intimate interactions of fully established mycorrhiza. The soil hyphae of the fungus, at the same time, respond to other bacteria and fungi in the mycorrhizosphere.     

Bacterial leaf symbiosis in angiosperms: host specificity without co-speciation

Bacterial leaf symbiosis is a unique and intimate interaction between bacteria and flowering plants, in which endosymbionts are organized in specialized leaf structures. Previously, bacterial leaf symbiosis has been described as a cyclic and obligate interaction in which the endosymbionts are vertically transmitted between plant generations and lack autonomous growth. Theoretically this allows for co-speciation between leaf nodulated plants and their endosymbionts. We sequenced the nodulated Burkholderia endosymbionts of 54 plant species from known leaf nodulated angiosperm genera, i.e. Ardisia, Pavetta, Psychotria and Sericanthe. Phylogenetic reconstruction of bacterial leaf symbionts and closely related free-living bacteria indicates the occurrence of multiple horizontal transfers of bacteria from the environment to leaf nodulated plant species. This rejects the hypothesis of a long co-speciation process between the bacterial endosymbionts and their host plants. Our results indicate a recent evolutionary process towards a stable and host specific interaction confirming the proposed maternal transmission mode of the endosymbionts through the seeds. Divergence estimates provide evidence for a relatively recent origin of bacterial leaf symbiosis, dating back to the Miocene (5-23 Mya). This geological epoch was characterized by cool and arid conditions, which may have triggered the origin of bacterial leaf symbiosis.     

Phosphoproteomic Analysis in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Phaseolus vulgaris</Emphasis> Roots Treated with <Emphasis Type="Italic">Rhizobium etli</Emphasis> Nodulation Factors

Legumes are unique in their ability to establish symbiotic interactions with rhizobacteria, providing a source of assimilable nitrogen; this symbiosis is regulated by complex signaling process between the plant and the bacteria. The participation of specific protein kinases during the initial steps of the nodulation process has been established. However, their substrates or the signaling networks implicated are not fully understood. Herein, a phosphoproteomic analysis of Phaseolus vulgaris roots treated for 24 h with specific Nod factors was performed using an immobilized metal ion affinity chromatography enrichment and two-dimensional gel electrophoresis approach with mass spectrometry identification. A total of 33 protein spots showing more than 1.5-fold shift were identified (17 protein spots in which the relative abundance increased and 16 that decreased). The majority of the identified root phosphoproteins displaying an increased relative abundance are presumed to have functions related to the biosynthesis and folding of proteins, energy metabolism, or cytoskeleton rearrangements, which reflect the metabolic status of the roots as being part of the developmental processes leading to nodule initiation and the importance of cytoskeleton rearrangement in the P. vulgaris–rhizobia symbiosis. The proteins in which relative abundance decreased are associated with defense and oxido-reduction processes, which could indicate a suppression of plant defense responses during the establishment of the rhizobia–legume interaction and an increase of reactive oxygen species production.     

Reactive oxygen and nitrogen species and glutathione: key players in the legume-Rhizobium symbiosis

Several reactive oxygen and nitrogen species (ROS/RNS) are continuously produced in plants as by-products of aerobic metabolism or in response to stresses. Depending on the nature of the ROS and RNS, some of them are highly toxic and rapidly detoxified by various cellular enzymatic and non-enzymatic mechanisms. Whereas plants have many mechanisms with which to combat increased ROS/RNS levels produced during stress conditions, under other circumstances plants appear to generate ROS/RNS as signalling molecules to control various processes encompassing the whole lifespan of the plant such as normal growth and development stages. This review aims to summarize recent studies highlighting the involvement of ROS/RNS, as well as the low molecular weight thiols, glutathione and homoglutathione, during the symbiosis between rhizobia and leguminous plants. This compatible interaction initiated by a molecular dialogue between the plant and bacterial partners, leads to the formation of a novel root organ capable of fixing atmospheric nitrogen under nitrogen-limiting conditions. On the one hand, ROS/RNS detection during the symbiotic process highlights the similarity of the early response to infection by pathogenic and symbiotic bacteria, addressing the question as to which mechanism rhizobia use to counteract the plant defence response. Moreover, there is increasing evidence that ROS are needed to establish the symbiosis fully. On the other hand, GSH synthesis appears to be essential for proper development of the root nodules during the symbiotic interaction. Elucidating the mechanisms that control ROS/RNS signalling during symbiosis could therefore contribute in defining a powerful strategy to enhance the efficiency of the symbiotic interaction.     

Insights into the history of the legume‐betaproteobacterial symbiosis

The interaction between legumes and rhizobia has been well studied in the context of a mutualistic, nitrogen‐fixing symbiosis. The fitness of legumes, including important agricultural crops, is enhanced by the plants’ ability to develop symbiotic associations with certain soil bacteria that fix atmospheric nitrogen into a utilizable form, namely, ammonia, via a chemical reaction that only bacteria and archaea can perform. Of the bacteria, members of the alpha subclass of the protebacteria are the best‐known nitrogen‐fixing symbionts of legumes. Recently, members of the beta subclass of the proteobacteria that induce nitrogen‐fixing nodules on legume roots in a species‐specific manner have been identified. In this issue, Bontemps et al. reveal that not only are these newly identified rhizobia novel in shifting the paradigm of our understanding of legume symbiosis, but also, based on symbiotic gene phylogenies, have a history that is both ancient and stable. Expanding our understanding of novel plant growth promoting rhizobia will be a valuable resource for incorporating alternative strategies of nitrogen fixation for enhancing plant growth.     

Rhizobitoxine modulates plant-microbe interactions by ethylene inhibition

Bradyrhizobium elkanii produces rhizobitoxine, an enol-ether amino acid, which has been regarded as a phytotoxin because it causes chlorosis in soybeans. However, recent studies have revealed that rhizobitoxine plays a positive role in establishing symbiosis between B. elkanii and host legumes: rhizobitoxine enhances the nodulation process by inhibiting ACC (1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate) synthase in the ethylene biosynthesis of host roots. B. elkanii rtxA and rtxC genes are required for rhizobitoxine production. In particular, rtxC gene is involved in the desaturation of dihydrorhizobitoxine into rhizobitoxine. A legume with a mutated ethylene receptor gene produced markedly higher numbers of rhizobial infection threads and nodule primordia. Thus, endogenous ethylene in legume roots negatively regulates the formation of nodule primordia, which is overcome by rhiozbitoxine. Although a plant pathogen Burkholderia andropogonis has been known to produce rhizobitoxine, the genome sequence of Xanthomonas oryzae showed the existence of a putative rhizobitoxine transposon in the genome. The cumulative evidence suggests that rhizobitoxine-producing bacteria modulate plant-microbe interactions via ethylene in the rhizosphere and phyllosphere environments. In addition, rhizobitoxine-producing capability might be utilized as tools in agriculture and biotechnology.     

Symbiosis specificity in the legume: rhizobial mutualism

Legume plants are able to engage in root nodule symbiosis with nitrogen-fixing soil bacteria, collectively called rhizobia. This mutualistic association is highly specific, such that each rhizobial species/strain interacts with only a specific group of legumes, and vice versa. Symbiosis specificity can occur at multiple phases of the interaction, ranging from initial bacterial attachment and infection to late nodule development associated with nitrogen fixation. Genetic control of symbiosis specificity is complex, involving fine-tuned signal communication between the symbiotic partners. Here we review our current understanding of the mechanisms used by the host and bacteria to choose their symbiotic partners, with a special focus on the role that the host immunity plays in controlling the specificity of the legume - rhizobial symbiosis.     

Laser‐ablation electrospray ionization mass spectrometry with ion mobility separation reveals metabolites in the symbiotic interactions of soybean roots and rhizobia

Technologies enabling in situ metabolic profiling of living plant systems are invaluable for understanding physiological processes and could be used for rapid phenotypic screening (e.g., to produce plants with superior biological nitrogen‐fixing ability). The symbiotic interaction between legumes and nitrogen‐fixing soil bacteria results in a specialized plant organ (i.e., root nodule) where the exchange of nutrients between host and endosymbiont occurs. Laser‐ablation electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (LAESI‐MS) is a method that can be performed under ambient conditions requiring minimal sample preparation. Here, we employed LAESI‐MS to explore the well characterized symbiosis between soybean (Glycine max L. Merr.) and its compatible symbiont, Bradyrhizobium japonicum. The utilization of ion mobility separation (IMS) improved the molecular coverage, selectivity, and identification of the detected biomolecules. Specifically, incorporation of IMS resulted in an increase of 153 differentially abundant spectral features in the nodule samples. The data presented demonstrate the advantages of using LAESI–IMS–MS for the rapid analysis of intact root nodules, uninfected root segments, and free‐living rhizobia. Untargeted pathway analysis revealed several metabolic processes within the nodule (e.g., zeatin, riboflavin, and purine synthesis). Compounds specific to the uninfected root and bacteria were also detected. Lastly, we performed depth profiling of intact nodules to reveal the location of metabolites to the cortex and inside the infected region, and lateral profiling of sectioned nodules confirmed these molecular distributions. Our results established the feasibility of LAESI–IMS–MS for the analysis and spatial mapping of plant tissues, with its specific demonstration to improve our understanding of the soybean‐rhizobial symbiosis.     

The eroded genome of a Psychotria leaf symbiont: hypotheses about lifestyle and interactions with its plant host

Several plant species of the genus Psychotria (Rubiaceae) harbour Burkholderia sp. bacteria within specialized leaf nodules. The bacteria are transmitted vertically between plant generations and have not yet been cultured outside of their host. This symbiosis is also generally described as obligatory because plants devoid of symbionts fail to develop into mature individuals. We sequenced for the first time the genome of the symbiont of Psychotria kirkii in order to shed some light on the nature of their symbiotic relationship. We found that the 4?Mb genome of Candidatus Burkholderia kirkii (B.?kirkii) is small for a Burkholderia species and displays features consistent with ongoing genome erosion such as large proportions of pseudogenes and transposable elements. Reductive genome evolution affected a wide array of functional categories that may hinder the ability of the symbiont to be free-living. The genome does not encode functions commonly found in plant symbionts such as nitrogen fixation or plant hormone metabolism. Instead, a collection of genes for secondary metabolites' synthesis is located on the 140?kb plasmid of B.?kirkii and suggests that leaf nodule symbiosis benefits the host by providing protection against herbivores or pathogens.     

Plant and fungal identity determines pathogen protection of plant roots by arbuscular mycorrhizas

1.  A major benefit of the mycorrhizal symbiosis is that it can protect plants from below-ground enemies, such as pathogens. Previous studies have indicated that plant identity (particularly plants that differ in root system architecture) or fungal identity (fungi from different families within the Glomeromycota) can determine the degree of protection from infection by pathogens. Here, we test the combined effects of plant and fungal identity to assess if there is a strong interaction between these two factors.
2.  We paired one of two plants ( Setaria glauca , a plant with a finely branched root system and Allium cepa , which has a simple root system) with one of six different fungal species from two families within the Glomeromycota. We assessed the degree to which plant identity, fungal identity and their interaction determined infection by Fusarium oxysporum , a common plant pathogen.
3.  Our results show that the interaction between plant and fungal identity can be an important determinant of root infection by the pathogen. Infection by Fusarium was less severe in Allium (simple root system) or when Setaria (complex root system) was associated with a fungus from the family Glomeraceae. We also detected significant plant growth responses to the treatments; the fine-rooted Setaria benefited more from associating with a member of the family Glomeraceae, while Allium benefited more from associating with a member of the family Gigasporaceae.
4.   Synthesis . This study supports previous claims that plants with complex root systems are more susceptible to infection by pathogens, and that the arbuscular mycorrhizal symbiosis can reduce infection in such plants – provided that the plant is colonized by a mycorrhizal fungus that can offer protection, such as the isolates of Glomus used here.