Rhizobitoxine modulates plant-microbe interactions by ethylene inhibition

Bradyrhizobium elkanii produces rhizobitoxine, an enol-ether amino acid, which has been regarded as a phytotoxin because it causes chlorosis in soybeans. However, recent studies have revealed that rhizobitoxine plays a positive role in establishing symbiosis between B. elkanii and host legumes: rhizobitoxine enhances the nodulation process by inhibiting ACC (1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate) synthase in the ethylene biosynthesis of host roots. B. elkanii rtxA and rtxC genes are required for rhizobitoxine production. In particular, rtxC gene is involved in the desaturation of dihydrorhizobitoxine into rhizobitoxine. A legume with a mutated ethylene receptor gene produced markedly higher numbers of rhizobial infection threads and nodule primordia. Thus, endogenous ethylene in legume roots negatively regulates the formation of nodule primordia, which is overcome by rhiozbitoxine. Although a plant pathogen Burkholderia andropogonis has been known to produce rhizobitoxine, the genome sequence of Xanthomonas oryzae showed the existence of a putative rhizobitoxine transposon in the genome. The cumulative evidence suggests that rhizobitoxine-producing bacteria modulate plant-microbe interactions via ethylene in the rhizosphere and phyllosphere environments. In addition, rhizobitoxine-producing capability might be utilized as tools in agriculture and biotechnology.     

Isolation and characterization of rhizobitoxine mutants of Bradyrhizobium japonicum.

To explore the role of rhizobitoxine in Bradyrhizobium-legume symbiosis, 11 rhizobitoxine mutants of B. japonicum USDA61 were isolated on the basis of their inability to synthesize the toxin in culture. Each mutant is prototrophic and symbiotically effective on soybean, cowpea, siratro, and Glycine soja. The rhizobitoxine mutants differ in their chlorosis phenotypes and rhizobitoxine production in planta. As expected, one group of mutant fail to make toxin in planta, resulting in the absence of chlorosis. Another group of mutants causes severe chlorosis on all cultivars of soybean tested. Surprisingly, this group of mutants makes more rhizobitoxine in soybean nodules than the wild-type strain does. This phenotype is only observed on soybean and not on other hosts such as cowpea, siratro, or G. soja. The remaining mutants all produce rhizobitoxine in planta but vary in the amount of toxin they produce and the severity of chlorosis they induce in soybean plants. Biochemical analysis of mutants demonstrates that one mutant is unable to synthesize serinol, a molecule hypothesized to be an intermediate in rhizobitoxine biosynthesis. By using these mutants, it was found that rhizobitoxine plays no apparent role in the nodulation of rj1 soybeans. Recently, it was found that inhibition of ethylene biosynthesis allows Rhizobium meliloti to overcome nitrate inhibition of nodule formation on alfalfa. Because rhizobitoxine also inhibits ethylene biosynthesis, we tested the ability of mutants which accumulate high levels of toxin in planta to overcome nitrate inhibition of nodule formation on soybean plants and found that the nodule formation induced by the wild type and that induced by mutant strains were equally suppressed in the presence of nitrate.     

New Assay for Rhizobitoxine Based on Inhibition of 1-Aminocyclopropane-1-Carboxylate Synthase

Rhizobitoxine is synthesized by the legume symbiont Bradyrhizobium elkanii and the plant pathogen Burkholderia andropogonis. Rhizobitoxine competitively inhibited 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate (ACC) synthase bLE-ACS2 from the tomato, a key enzyme in the pathway of ethylene biosynthesis. Based on this inhibition of ACC synthase, we have developed a new assay for rhizobitoxine.     

Inhibition of ethylene production by rhizobitoxine

Rhizobitoxine, an inhibitor of methionine biosynthesis in Salmonella typhimurium, inhibited ethylene production about 75% in light-grown sorghum seedlings and in senescent apple tissue. Ethylene production stimulated by indoleacetic acid and kinetin in sorghum was similarly inhibited. With both apple and sorghum, the inhibition could only be partially relieved by additions of methionine. A methionine analogue, α-keto-γ-methylthiobutyric acid, which has been suggested as an intermediate between methionine and ethylene, had no effect on the inhibition.     

Isolation of an ozone-sensitive and jasmonate-semi-insensitive Arabidopsis mutant (oji1)

A novel ozone-sensitive mutant was isolated from Arabidopsis T-DNA tagging lines. This mutant revealed severe foliar injury and higher ethylene emission than the wild type under ozone exposure. The ozone-induced injury and ethylene emission were suppressed by pretreatment with aminoethoxyvinyl glycine, an inhibitor of ethylene biosynthesis, both in this mutant and wild-type plants. Pretreatment with methyl-jasmonate (MeJA) at 10 micro M, however, suppressed the ozone-induced ethylene emission and foliar injury only in the wild-type plants. This mutant was less sensitive to jasmonate than the wild type, estimated by the MeJA-induced inhibition of root elongation and ozone-induced expression of AtVSP1, a jasmonate-inducible gene. Thus, this mutant was named oji1 (ozone-sensitive and jasmonate-insensitive 1). These results suggest that the ozone sensitivity of oji1 is caused by the increase in ozone-induced emission of ethylene as a result of low sensitivity to jasmonate, which plays defensive roles under stress conditions.     

Ethylene biosynthesis in a chilling-sensitive<Emphasis Type="Italic">Arabidopsis</Emphasis> mutant,<Emphasis Type="Italic">chs4-2</Emphasis>

We investigated chilling-induced changes in ethylene levels in Arabidopsis to find plants with distinct patterns of ethylene production in the cold-related biosynthetic pathway. The sensitive mutants identified here includedchs1-2,chs4-2, andchs6-2. Among these, plants of thechs4-2 mutant produced more ethylene than did the wild type after both were transferred from 4°C or 10°C to 22°C. This mutant also showed less freezing tolerance and more electrolyte leakage than the wild-type plants. Our results suggest a relationship between ethylene biosynthesis and chilling sensitivity in the mutant To determine which of the enzymes involved in ethylene biosynthesis were induced by chilling, we tested the activities of ACC synthase and ACC oxidase in both mutant and wild-type plants, and found greater activity by ACC synthase as well as a higher ACC content in the mutants after all the plants were transferred from 10°C to 22°C. However, ACC oxidase activity did not differ between mutant and wild-type plants in response to chilling treatment Therefore, we conclude thatchs4-2 mutants produce more ethylene than do other mutants or the wild type during their recovery from chilling conditions. Furthermore, we believe that ACC synthase is the key enzyme involved in this response.     

Circadian Ethylene Synthesis in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Sorghum bicolor</Emphasis>: Expression and Control of the System at the Whole Plant Level

Ethylene production by sorghum is rhythmic and the amplitude of the rhythm is increased both by dim, far-red enriched light and in mutant plants deficient in phytochrome B. The mechanisms involved in controlling ethylene production were examined in detail by measuring the rate of ethylene production among organs and tissues, examining the organ-specific levels of ACC (1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid, the ethylene precursor) and investigating the contribution of the roots to shoot ethylene production. The results demonstrate that the expanding leaves were the major source of ethylene under dim, far-red enriched light and in the phytochrome B mutant. Enhanced ethylene production by the expanding leaf appeared to be the result of targeted delivery of ACC to this tissue. Root ACC levels were much higher than those in the shoot but roots converted much less of this endogenous ACC to ethylene. Applying ACC to the roots had only a marginal effect on their ethylene production, but greatly increased that of the shoots. Decapitated shoots continued to produce ethylene in a rhythmic pattern but the amplitude decreased with time compared to intact plants. The results collectively suggest that some, but not all, of the shoot ethylene rhythm depends on the transport of ACC from the roots to the shoots.     

Effects of Exogenous 1,3-Diaminopropane and Spermidine on Senescence of Oat Leaves : II. Inhibition of Ethylene Biosynthesis and Possible Mode of Action

The effects of the polyamines spermidine and 1,3-diaminopropane on ethylene biosynthesis and chlorophyll (Chl) loss were studied in peeled leaves of oat (Avena sativa L., var. Victory) incubated in the dark. Peeling off the epidermal cells induces an increase in 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate (ACC) synthase activity, resulting in an enhanced ACC and ethylene formation. Both polyamines inhibit ethylene biosynthesis from methionine by inhibiting ACC synthase activity and, more effectively, the conversion of ACC to ethylene. They also inhibit Chl loss occurring between 24 and 48 h of dark incubation; but, as shown by inhibitor experiments, inhibition of Chl loss does not result from inhibition of ethylene formation. Ethylene production and Chl loss, both associated with senescence, require membrane integrity; thus, treatments which promote deterioration of membranes inhibit both processes. Ca²⁺ in the incubation medium competitively reduces the polyamine-mediated inhibition of ACC conversion and Chl loss. The data suggest that polyamines initially attach to membranes, thereby inducing changes which, in turn, lead to inhibition of ethylene biosynthesis and retardation of senescence.     

Biosynthesis of stress ethylene in soybean seedlings: Similarities to endogenous ethylene biosynthesis

The similarity of stress ethylene biosynthesis in whole plants to endogenous ethylene biosynthesis was investigated using two inhibitors of ethylene biosynthesis, aminoethoxyvinylglycine (AVG) and cobalt chloride (Co²⁺); and the intermediates, methionine, S -adenosylmethionine (SAM), and 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC), of basal ethylene biosynthesis. Stress ethylene production induced by ozone, cadmium, or 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid was inhibited in hydroponically-grown soybean seedlings in a concentration-dependent manner by both AVG and CO²⁺. The ethylene intermediates evoked responses in intact seedlings similar to that described for endogenous ethylene production in isolated vegetative tissue. The addition of SAM to the hydroponic system relieved AVG inhibition of stress ethylene production. Feeding ACC to the seedlings resulted in increased ethylene production independent of stress application or prior AVG inhibition. Cobalt inhibition of stress ethylene production was relieved by increasing concentrations of ACC. A short lag period of 12–18 min was observed in stress ethylene production following a 30-min ozone exposure. Addition of cycloheximide partially inhibited ozone-induced ethylene production.
These results suggest a common pathway in whole plants for stress ethylene production and endogenous ethylene biosynthesis.     

The mechanism of rhythmic ethylene production in sorghum. The role of phytochrome B and simulated shading

Mutant sorghum (Sorghum bicolor [L.] Moench) deficient in functional phytochrome B exhibits reduced photoperiodic sensitivity and constitutively expresses a shade-avoidance phenotype. Under relatively bright, high red:far-red light, ethylene production by seedlings of wild-type and phytochrome B-mutant cultivars progresses through cycles in a circadian rhythm; however, the phytochrome B mutant produces ethylene peaks with approximately 10 times the amplitude of the wild type. Time-course northern blots show that the mutant's abundance of the 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) oxidase mRNA SbACO2 is cyclic and is commensurate with ethylene production, and that ACC oxidase activity follows the same pattern. Both SbACO2 abundance and ACC oxidase activity in the wild-type plant are very low under this regimen. ACC levels in the two cultivars did not demonstrate fluctuations coincident with the ethylene produced. Simulated shading caused the wild-type plant to mimic the phenotype of the mutant and to produce high amplitude rhythms of ethylene evolution. The circadian feature of the ethylene cycle is conditionally present in the mutant and absent in the wild-type plant under simulated shading. SbACO2 abundance in both cultivars demonstrates a high-amplitude diurnal cycle under these conditions; however, ACC oxidase activity, although elevated, does not exhibit a clear rhythm correlated with ethylene production. ACC levels in both cultivars show fluctuations corresponding to the ethylene rhythm previously observed. It appears that at least two separate mechanisms may be involved in generating high-amplitude ethylene rhythms in sorghum, one in response to the loss of phytochrome B function and another in response to shading.     

Foliar chlorosis in legumes induced by cowpea rhizobia

Summary While screening cowpea rhizobia from West Africa for ability to nodulate various host species, foliar chlorosis was observed in young mung bean and soybean plants inoculated with certain strains. The chlorosis occurred in the first and sometimes the second trifoliate, but not on subsequent leaves. There was no correlation of symptoms with the presence of nodules. Where extreme chlorosis was induced in soybeans, there was stunting of the primary root. Disease symptoms were obtained with culture-broth supernatants free of rhizobia, indicating an extracellular toxin. In common with rhizobitoxine-producing strains ofR. japonicum, chlorosis-inducing cowpea strains were able to nodulate ‘non-nodulating’ soybeans of the rj₁rj₁ genotype.     

Rhizobitoxine production and symbiotic compatibility of Bradyrhizobium from Asian and North American lineages of amphicarpaea.

Reciprocal inoculations with Bradyrhizobium sp. isolates from the North American legume Amphicarpaea bracteata (L.) Fern. (Phaseoleae-Glycininae) and from a Japanese population of its close relative Amphicarpaea edgeworthii (Benth.) var. japonica were performed to analyze relative symbiotic compatibility. Amphicarpaea edgeworthii plants formed few or no nodules with any North American bradyrhizobial strains isolated from A. bracteata, but all A. bracteata lineages formed effective nitrogen-fixing nodules with Japanese Bradyrhizobium isolates from A. edgeworthii. However, one group of A. bracteata plants (lineage Ia) when inoculated with Japanese bradyrhizobia developed a striking leaf chlorosis similar to that known to be caused by rhizobitoxine. The beta-cystathionase inhibition assay demonstrated that significant amounts of rhizobitoxine were present in nodules formed by these Japanese bradyrhizobia. No North American bradyrhizobial isolate from A. bracteata induced chlorosis on any plants, and the beta-cystathionase assay failed to detect rhizobitoxine in nodules formed by these isolates. The role of rhizobitoxine in A. edgeworthii nodulation development was tested by inoculating plants with a Bradyrhizobium elkanii rhizobitoxine-producing strain, USDA 61, and two mutant derivatives, RX17E and RX18E, which are unable to synthesize rhizobitoxine. Amphicarpaea edgeworthii inoculated with wild-type USDA 61 developed >150 nodules per plant, while plants inoculated with RX17E and RX18E developed fewer than 10 nodules per plant. Thus, efficient nodule development in A. edgeworthii appears to be highly dependent on rhizobitoxine production by Bradyrhizobium strains.     

Identification of ethylene-mediated protein changes during nodulation in Medicago truncatula using proteome analysis

Ethylene has been hypothesised to be a regulator of root nodule development in legumes, but its molecular mechanisms of action remain unclear. The skl mutant is an ethylene-insensitive legume mutant showing a hypernodulation phenotype when inoculated with its symbiont Sinorhizobium meliloti. We used the skl mutant to study the ethylene-mediated protein changes during nodule development in Medicago truncatula. We compared the root proteome of the skl mutant to its wild-type in response to the ethylene precursor aminocyclopropane carboxylic acid (ACC) to study ethylene-mediated protein expression in root tissues. We then compared the proteome of skl roots to its wild-type after Sinorhizobium inoculation to identify differentially displayed proteins during nodule development at 1 and 3 days post inoculation (dpi). Six proteins (pprg-2, Kunitz proteinase inhibitor, and ACC oxidase isoforms) were down-regulated in skl roots, while three protein spots were up-regulated (trypsin inhibitor, albumin 2, and CPRD49). ACC induced stress-related proteins in wild-type roots, such as pprg-2, ACC oxidase, proteinase inhibitor, ascorbate peroxidase, and heat-shock proteins. However, the expression of stress-related proteins such as pprg-2, Kunitz proteinase inhibitor, and ACC oxidase, was down-regulated in inoculated skl roots. We hypothesize that during early nodule development, the plant induces ethylene-mediated stress responses to limit nodule numbers. When a mutant defective in ethylene signaling, such as skl, is inoculated with rhizobia, the plant stress response is reduced, resulting in increased nodule numbers.     

The effects of the herbicide quinclorac on shoot growth in tomato is alleviated by inhibitors of ethylene biosynthesis and by the presence of an antisense construct to the 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) synthase gene in transgenic plants

Reduction of shoot growth, leaf epinasty and chlorosis in young tomato plants (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill. cv. Hellfrucht/Frühstamm) treated hydroponically with 10^-7 M of the herbicide quinclorac were partially compensated when the plants were simultaneously sprayed with salicyclic acid or the oxime ether derivative PACME. Since salicyclic acid and PACME are known inhibitors of ethylene biosynthesis, it is suggested that this pathway is implicated in quinclorac action. Further support for this hypothesis was obtained in experiments with transgenic tomato plants containing an antisense gene to 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) synthase in ethylene biosynthesis. When quinclorac was applied via the root antisense plants showed reduced phenotypical alterations compared to those of wild-type plants.     

Promotion ofin vitro shoot formation from excised roots of silktree (Albizzia julibrissin) by an oxime ether derivative and other ethylene inhibitors

Summary This report describes the regeneration response of excised seedling roots of silktree (Albizzia julibrissin) to added ethylene precursors/generators (1-amino-cyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid [ACC], 2-chloroethylphosphonic acid [CEPA]), biosynthesis inhibitors (aminoethoxyvinylglycine [AVG], an oxime ether derivative [OED={[(ispropylidene)-amino]oxy}-acetic acid-2-(methoxy)-2-oxoethyl ester], CoCl² [Co⁺⁺]), and an ethylene action inhibitor (AgNO₃ [Ag⁺]). When placed on B5 medium, about 50% of the control explants formed shoot buds within 15 days. Addition of ACC or CEPA (1–10 µM) to the culture medium decreased both the percentage of cultures forming shoots and the number of shoots formed per culture. In contrast, AVG and OED (1–10 µM) increased shoot formation to almost 100% and increased the number of shoots formed per culture. Likewise, both Co⁺⁺ and Ag⁺ (1–10 µM) increased shoot regeneration, but the number of shoots produced after 30 days was less than with AVG or OED. The inhibitors of ethylene biosynthesis were partially effective in counteracting the inhibitory effect of ACC on shoot formation. These results suggest that modulation of ethylene biosynthesis and/or action can strongly influence the formation of adventitious shoots from excised roots of silktree.Abbreviations ACC 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid - AVG aminoethoxyvinylglycine - CEPA 2-chloroethylphosphonic acid - OED oxime ether derivative     

Biosynthesis of ethylene from methionine in aminoethoxyvinylglycine-resistant avocado tissue

This study was conducted to determine if aminoethoxyvinylglycine (AVG) insensitivity in avocado (Persea americana Mill., Lula, Haas, and Bacon) tissue was due to an alternate pathway of ethylene biosynthesis from methionine. AVG, at 0.1 millimolar, had little or no inhibitory effect on either total ethylene production or [(14)C] ethylene production from [(14)C]methionine in avocado tissue at various stages of ripening. However, aminoxyacetic acid (AOA), which inhibits 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) synthase (the AVG-sensitive enzyme of ethylene biosynthesis), inhibited ethylene production in avocado tissue. Total ethylene production was stimulated, and [(14)C]ethylene production from [(14)C]methionine was lowered by treating avocado tissue with 1 millimolar ACC. An inhibitor of methionine adenosyltransferase (EC 2.5.1.6), l-2-amino-4-hexynoic acid (AHA), at 1.5 millimolar, effectively inhibited [(14)C]ethylene production from [(14)C]methionine in avocado tissue but had no effect on total ethylene production during a 2-hour incubation. Rates of [(14)C]AVG uptake by avocado and apple (Malus domestica Borkh., Golden Delicious) tissues were similar, and [(14)C]AVG was the only radioactive compound in alcohol-soluble fractions of the tissues. Hence, AVG-insensitivity in avocado tissue does not appear to be due to lack of uptake or to metabolism of AVG by avocado tissue. ACC synthase activity in extracts of avocado tissue was strongly inhibited (about 60%) by 10 micromolar AVG. Insensitivity of ethylene production in avocado tissue to AVG may be due to inaccessibility of ACC synthase to AVG. AVG-resistance in the avocado system is, therefore, different from that of early climacteric apple tissue, in which AVG-insensitivity of total ethylene production appears to be due to a high level of endogenous ACC relative to its rate of conversion to ethylene. However, the sensitivity of the avocado system to AOA and AHA, dilution of labeled ethylene production by ACC, and stimulation of total ethylene production by ACC provide evidence for the methionine --> SAM --> ACC --> ethylene pathway in avocado and do not suggest the operation of an alternate pathway.     

Regulation of Auxin-induced Ethylene Production in Mung Bean Hypocotyls: Role of 1-Aminocyclopropane-1-Carboxylic Acid

Ethylene production in mung bean hypocotyls was greatly increased by treatment with 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC), which was utilized as the ethylene precursor. Unlike auxin-stimulated ethylene production, ACC-dependent ethylene production was not inhibited by aminoethoxyvinylglycine, which is known to inhibit the conversion of S-adenosylmethionine to ACC. While the conversion of methionine to ethylene requires induction by auxin, the conversion of methionine to S-adenosylmethionine and the conversion of ACC to ethylene do not. It is proposed that the conversion of S-adenosylmethionine to ACC is the rate-limiting step in the biosynthesis of ethylene, and that auxin stimulates ethylene production by inducing the synthesis of the enzyme involved in this reaction.     

1-Aminocyclopropane-1-Carboxylate Oxidase Activity Limits Ethylene Biosynthesis in Rumex palustris during Submergence

Submergence strongly stimulates petiole elongation in Rumex palustris, and ethylene accumulation initiates and maintains this response in submerged tissues. cDNAs from R. palustris corresponding to a 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate (ACC) oxidase gene (RP-ACO1) were isolated from elongating petioles and used to study the expression of the corresponding gene. An increase in RP-ACO1 messenger was observed in the petioles and lamina of elongating leaves 2 h after the start of submergence. ACC oxidase enzyme activity was measured in homogenates of R. palustris shoots, and a relevant increase was observed within 12 h under water with a maximum after 24 h. We have shown previously that the ethylene production rate of submerged shoots does not increase significantly during the first 24 h of submergence (L.A.C.J. Voesenek, M. Banga, R. H. Thier, C.M. Mudde, F.M. Harren, G.W.M. Barendse, C.W.P.M. Blom [1993] Plant Physiol 103: 783-791), suggesting that under these conditions ACC oxidase activity is inhibited in vivo. We found evidence that this inhibition is caused by a reduction of oxygen levels. We hypothesize that an increased ACC oxidase enzyme concentration counterbalances the reduced enzyme activity caused by low oxygen concentration during submergence, thus sustaining ethylene production under these conditions. Therefore, ethylene biosynthesis seems to be limited at the level of ACC oxidase activity rather than by ACC synthase in R. palustris during submergence.     

Ethylene-mediated enhancement of apical hook formation in etiolated Arabidopsis thaliana seedlings is gibberellin dependent

Dark-grown Arabidopsis seedlings develop an apical hook by differential elongation and division of hypocotyl cells. This allows the curved hypocotyl to gently drag the apex, which is protected by the cotyledons, upwards through the soil. Several plant hormones are known to be involved in hook development, including ethylene, which causes exaggeration of the hook. We show that gibberellins (GAs) are also involved in this process. Inhibition of GA biosynthesis with paclobutrazol (PAC) prevented hook formation in wild-type (WT) seedlings and in constitutive ethylene response (ctr)1-1, a mutant that exhibits a constitutive ethylene response. In addition, a GA-deficient mutant (ga1-3) did not form an apical hook in the presence of the ethylene precursor 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate (ACC). Analysis of transgenic Arabidopsis seedlings expressing a green fluorescent protein (GFP)-repressor of ga1-3 (RGA) fusion protein suggested that ACC inhibits cell elongation in the apical hook by inhibition of GA signaling. A decreased feedback of GA possibly causes an induction of GA biosynthesis based upon the expression of genes encoding copalyl diphosphate synthase (CPS; GA1) and GA 2-oxidase (AtGA2ox1). Furthermore, expression of GASA1, a GA-response gene, suggests that differential cell elongation in the apical hook might be a result of differential GA-sensitivity.