Functional anatomy of the photoreceptor and second-order cell mosaics in the retina of Xenopus laevis

Mosaics of photoreceptors, and horizontal and bipolar cells of the Xenopus laevis retina were studied in whole-mount preparations applying lectin-cytochemical, immunocytochemical and intracellular labeling techniques. The combined density of all photoreceptor types was about 13700/mm2, of which rods represented 53%. Of the cones, the large long-wavelength-sensitive (86% of all cones) and the miniature ultraviolet-wavelength-sensitive (4%) ones could be labeled with peanut agglutinin, whereas the large short-wavelength-sensitive (10%) cones remained unlabeled. There were no significant regional differences in photoreceptor distribution. Bipolar cells were selectively labeled with antibodies against calretinin. Their density was between 4000 and 6000 cells/cm2, with slightly elevated numbers in the superior nasal quadrant. Two types of horizontal cell were injected intracellularly. The luminosity-type cells were more frequent (approximately 1000 cells/mm2) than the chromaticity cells (approximately 450 cells/mm2). The dendritic field size of the latter cell type was threefold bigger than that of the luminosity cells. The coverage factors were estimated to be 3.3 for the luminosity cells and 5.2 for the chromaticity cells. The luminosity cells contacted all photoreceptor types, whereas chromatic horizontal cells received their inputs from the short-wavelength-sensitive cones and from some, but not all, rods. Luminosity cells encounter about 50-60 potential synaptic partners within their dendritic fields, whereas chromatic horizontal cells only about 20. Chromatic horizontal cells form multiple synaptic contacts with the short-wavelength-sensitive cones. The results indicate that the overall photoreceptor to bipolar and bipolar to ganglion cell convergence in Xenopus retina is similar to that in the central retinal specialized regions of mammals, predicting comparable spatial resolutions.     

Apoptosis of Retinal Photoreceptors During Development In Vitro: Protective Effect of Docosahexaenoic Acid

Abstract: When rat retinal cells are cultured in a serum-free medium, the photoreceptor cells start dying after 7 days. The addition of docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) to the cultures prevents the selective death of photoreceptors. Here it is shown that, unlike other retinal neurons, photoreceptors die through an apoptotic pathway. Hallmarks of apoptosis, such as nuclear fragmentation and condensation and DNA cleavage forming a ladder pattern on an agarose gel, were observed. The timing and high selectivity of the triggering of photoreceptor cell apoptosis suggest the existence of a programmed cell death. Compared with other fatty acids, DHA not only was the most effective in promoting photoreceptor survival, but also the only one to decrease the number of apoptotic nuclei. The results suggest that DHA is important among the factors preventing apoptosis of photoreceptors in the developing retina. A limitation in the availability of this fatty acid might trigger apoptosis as a result of the failure to develop functional photoreceptor outer segments.     

Intra- and interspecific changes in retinal morphology among mesopelagic and demersal teleosts from the slope waters of New Zealand

Synopsis Retinae from mesopelagic teleosts with adult ranges in the shallow, mid and deep mesopelagic zones, respectively, were examined by light microscopy. Retinal characteristics were described, and photoreceptor densities, outer segment dimensions, and convergence ratios measured from transverse sections. Juveniles of all species had lower photoreceptor densities, outer segment lengths and convergence ratios than adults. In species with multiple banks of photoreceptors, additional banks were added as the retina increased in size. A positive correlation was found between the degree of retinal specialisation for vision in dim light, and the depth of occurrence. The retina of each specimen was given a rank based on log unit changes in photoreceptor density and convergence ratio, the length of photoreceptor outer segments and the presence or absence of multiple banks of photoreceptors. Higher ranks (indicating greater retinal specialisation) were found among species occurring at greater depths. Among species showing a change in depth preference with growth, there was a corresponding increase in retinal rank. It is suggested that the proposed system of ranks has application in predicting the depth of occurrence of a species with a given pattern of retinal morphology.     

Metamorphosis and fish vision

Many species of fish exhibit metamorphosis in which dramatic external transformations occur as a consequence of coordinated changes in gene expression within an organism. Because postembryonic development and change appears to be the rule rather than the exception in teleost fish species, we view metamorphosis as one of many developmental strategies in fish which have continued plasticity as a common theme. Metamorphic changes are manifested in the visual system by modification of photoreceptor peak sensitivity rod photoreceptor cell addition, and retinal reorganization. These changes correspond to significant changes in the natural habitat of the animal and in its visual capabilities as demonstrated behaviorally. Thyroxine is the main metamorphic hormone as has also been found in amphibia. The sequence of metamorphic events occur in all teleosts, but they are compressed in time in direct developing animals suggesting that such animals might prove useful for understanding the evolution of metamorphosis in fish. It seems likely that rod photoreceptors may have evolved in conjunction with the change from larval to juvenile stage through metamorphosis in indirect developing fishes. During evolution, the contraction and/or loss of the larval stage has resulted in earlier appearance of rod photoreceptors during development although they always arise later than cone photoreceptors. This ontogenetic developmental sequence supports Walls's (1942) proposal that cones are phylogenetically older than rods and suggests that rods may have evolved several times.     

Reactive oxygen species as mediators of photoreceptor apoptosis in vitro

Retinitis pigmentosa is a heterogeneous group of retinal degenerations characterized by a progressive loss of photoreceptors through the process of apoptosis. The apoptotic cell death of photoreceptors appears to represent a final common pathway in the pathology of retinitis pigmentosa. Previous studies have reported the ability of antioxidants to ameliorate light-induced retinal degeneration, suggesting a role for oxidative stress in photoreceptor cell death. This study demonstrates an early and sustained increase in intracellular reactive oxygen species accompanied by a rapid depletion of intracellular glutathione in an in vitro model of photoreceptor apoptosis. These early changes in the cellular redox state precede disruption of mitochondrial transmembrane potential, nuclear condensation, DNA nicking, and cell shrinkage, all of which are well-characterized events of apoptotic cell death. The ability of zinc chloride and pyrrolidine dithiocarbamate, two established antioxidants, to inhibit photoreceptor apoptosis through the scavenging of intracellular reactive oxygen species establishes a role for reactive oxygen species as possible mediators of in vitro photoreceptor apoptosis. This study provides a molecular basis for the inhibition of photoreceptor apoptosis by antioxidants.     

Metamorphosis and fish vision

Many species of fish exhibit metamorphosis in which dramatic external transformations occur as a consequence of coordinated changes in gene expression within an organism. Because postembryonic development and change appears to be the rule rather than the exception in teleost fish species, we view metamorphosis as one of many developmental strategies in fish which have continued plasticity as a common theme. Metamorphic changes are manifested in the visual system by modification of photoreceptor peak sensitivity, rod photoreceptor cell addition, and retinal reorganization. These changes correspond to significant changes in the natural habitat of the animal and in its visual capabilities as demonstrated behaviorally. Thyroxine is the main metamorphic hormone as has also been found in amphibia. The sequence of metamorphic events occur in all teleosts, but they are compressed in time in direct developing animals suggesting that such animals might prove useful for understanding the evolution of metamorphosis in fish. It seems likely that rod photoreceptors may have evolved in conjunction with the change from larval to juvenile stage through metamorphosis in indirect developing fishes. During evolution, the contraction and/or loss of the larval stage has resulted in earlier appearance of rod photoreceptors during development although they always arise later than cone photoreceptors. This ontogenetic developmental sequence supports Walls's (1942) proposal that cones are phylogenetically older than rods and suggests that rods may have evolved several times.     

Hyperoxia causes decreased expression of vascular endothelial growth factor and endothelial cell apoptosis in adult retina

Mice or humans with photoreceptor degenerations experience permeability and dropout of retinal capillaries. Loss of photoreceptors results in decreased oxygen usage and thinning of the retina with increased oxygen delivery to the inner retina. To investigate the possibility that increased tissue oxygen plays a role in the vascular damage, we exposed adult mice to hyperoxia, which also increases oxygen in the retina. After 1, 2, or 3 weeks of hyperoxia, there was a statistically significant decrease in retinal vascular density that was not reversible, and endothelial cell apoptosis was demonstrated by TUNEL staining. Mice exposed to hyperoxia and mice with photoreceptor degeneration both showed decreased expression of VEGF in the retina. After complete or near-complete degeneration of photoreceptors, there was increased expression of VEGF in RPE cells, which may explain the association of photoreceptor degeneration and neovascularization in or around the RPE. Increased expression of VEGF in photoreceptors of transgenic mice failed to prevent hyperoxia-induced retinal capillary dropout. These data suggest that increased oxygen in the retina, either by increased inspired oxygen or by photoreceptor degeneration, results in endothelial cell death and dropout of capillaries. Decreased expression of VEGF may be a contributing factor, but the situation may be more complicated for mature retinal vessels than it is for immature vessels, because VEGF replacement does not rescue mature retinal vessels, suggesting that other factors may also be involved.     

Photic regulation of pineal function. Analogies between retinal and pineal photoreception

Light absorbed by a photopigment in a photoreceptor cell causes a photochemical reaction converting the 11-cis retinal chromophore into the all-trans configuration. These changes lead to a series of events that causes cGMP hydrolysis, a following decrease of cGMP in the cytoplasm of the photoreceptor outer segment and a closure of cGMP-gated cationic channels. As a consequence of these processes the membrane hyperpolarizes. In pineal photoreceptor cells of lower vertebrates these processes are only partly investigated. Molecules involved in the phototransduction process and the desensitization, like opsin, vitamin A, α-transducin and arrestin, have been immunocytochemically localized in pineal photoreceptors and also electrophysiological studies have shown that phototransduction mechanisms in pineal photoreceptors might be very similar to those found in retinal photoreceptors. This review will summarize some of the current knowledge on pineal photoreception and compare it with retinal processes.     

Neuronal and synaptic organization of the outer plexiform layer of the pigeon retina

The organization of the outer plexiform layer (OPL) of the pigeon retina is described by electron microscopy and Golgi impregnation. Six types of photoreceptor, four types of horizontal cell, eight types of bipolar cell, and an interplexiform cell type were found by Golgi impregnation. The OPL was tri-stratified due to the endings of the photoreceptors at three different levels. This stratification was reflected in the laminar arrangement of the dendrites of the horizontal and bipolar cells. Electron microscopy showed that the synaptic endings of the photoreceptors made ribbon synapses, both triads and dyads, and basal junctions with the process of second-order neurons. Horizontal cells formed conventional chemical synapses, while horizontal cell axon terminals were extensively linked by gap junctions.     

Midkine-a Protein Localization in the Developing and Adult Retina of the Zebrafish and Its Function During Photoreceptor Regeneration

Midkine is a heparin binding growth factor with important functions in neuronal development and survival, but little is known about its function in the retina. Previous studies show that in the developing zebrafish, Midkine-a (Mdka) regulates cell cycle kinetics in retinal progenitors, and following injury to the adult zebrafish retina, mdka is strongly upregulated in Müller glia and the injury-induced photoreceptor progenitors. Here we provide the first data describing Mdka protein localization during different stages of retinal development and during the regeneration of photoreceptors in adults. We also experimentally test the role of Mdka during photoreceptor regeneration. The immuno-localization of Mdka reflects the complex spatiotemporal pattern of gene expression and also reveals the apparent secretion and extracellular trafficking of this protein. During embryonic retinal development the Mdka antibodies label all mitotically active cells, but at the onset of neuronal differentiation, immunostaining is also localized to the nascent inner plexiform layer. Starting at five days post fertilization through the juvenile stage, Mdka immunostaining labels the cytoplasm of horizontal cells and the overlying somata of rod photoreceptors. Double immunolabeling shows that in adult horizontal cells, Mdka co-localizes with markers of the Golgi complex. Together, these data are interpreted to show that Mdka is synthesized in horizontal cells and secreted into the outer nuclear layer. In adults, Mdka is also present in the end feet of Müller glia. Similar to mdka gene expression, Mdka in horizontal cells is regulated by circadian rhythms. After the light-induced death of photoreceptors, Mdka immuonolabeling is localized to Müller glia, the intrinsic stem cells of the zebrafish retina, and proliferating photoreceptor progenitors. Knockdown of Mdka during photoreceptor regeneration results in less proliferation and diminished regeneration of rod photoreceptors. These data suggest that during photoreceptor regeneration Mdka regulates aspects of injury-induced cell proliferation.     

Density-dependent differentiation in nontransformed human retinal progenitor cells in response to basic fibroblast growth factor- and transforming growth factor-alpha

Multipotential retinal precursors give rise to all cell types seen in multilayered retina. The generation of differentiation and diversity of neuronal cell types is determined by both extrinsic regulatory signals and endogenous genetic programs. We have previously reported that cell commitment in human retinal precursor cells (SV-40T) can be modified in response to exogenous growth factors, basic fibroblast growth factor, and transforming growth factor alpha (bFGF and TGFalpha). We report in this study that nontransformed human retinal precursors differentiate into photoreceptors by a cell density-dependent mechanism, and the effects were potentiated by bFGF and TGFalpha alone or in combination. A larger proportion of multipotential precursors plated at a density of 1 x 10(4) cells/cm(2) differentiated into neurons (photoreceptors) compared to cells plated at 3-5 x 10(4)/cm(2) and 1 x 10(5) cells/cm(2) under serum-free conditions and the effects were amplified seven- to eightfold in response to growth factors. Basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) and TGFalpha can induce 90% of the cells to assume a photoreceptor phenotype at a lower cell density, compared to only 30 and 25% of the cells acquiring a photoreceptor phenotype at intermediate and higher cell densities. Furthermore, at a lower cell density, 60-70% of the cells incorporate Bromodeoxyuridine (Brdu), suggesting that cells in a cell cycle may make a commitment to a specific fate in response to neurotrophins. Neurons with a photoreceptor phenotype were positive for three different sets of antibodies for rods/cones. Cells also exhibited upregulation of other proteins such as a D4 receptor protein expressed in photoreceptors, protein kinase Calpha (PKCalpha) expressed in rod bipolars and blue cones, and some other neuronal cell types. This was also confirmed by Western blot analysis. Newly derived photoreceptors survive for a few days before significant cell death ensues under serum-free conditions. To summarize, differentiation in precursors is density dependent, and growth factors amplify the effects.     

A diffusible factor from normal retinal cells promotes rod photoreceptor survival in an in vitro model of retinitis pigmentosa

Transgenic mice expressing a dominant mutation in the gene for the phototransduction molecule rhodopsin undergo retinal degeneration similar to that experienced by patients with the retinal degenerative disease, retinitis pigmentosa (RP). Although the mutation is thought to cause photoreceptor degeneration in a cell‐autonomous manner, the fact that rod photoreceptor degeneration is slowed in chimeric wild‐type/mutant mice suggests that cellular interactions are also important for maintaining photoreceptor survival. To more fully characterize the nature of the cellular interactions important for rod degeneration in the RP mutant mice, we have used an in vitro approach. We found that when the retinas of the transgenic mice were isolated from the pigmented epithelium and cultured as explants, the rod photoreceptors underwent selective degeneration with a similar time course to that observed in vivo. This selective rod degeneration also occurred when the cells were dissociated and cultured as monolayers. These data indicate that the mutant rod photoreceptors degenerate when removed from their normal cellular relationships and without contact with the pigmented epithelium, thus confirming the relative cell autonomy of the mutant phenotype. We next tested whether normal retinal cells could rescue the mutant photoreceptors in a coculture paradigm. Coculture of transgenic mouse with wild‐type mouse or rat retinal cells significantly enhanced transgenic rod photoreceptor survival; this survival‐promoting activity was diffusible through a filter, was heat labile, and not present in transgenic retinal cells. Several peptide growth factors known to be present in the retina were tested as the potential survival‐promoting molecule responsible for the effects of the conditioned medium; however, none of them promoted survival of the photoreceptors expressing the Pro23His mutant rhodopsin. Nevertheless, we were able to demonstrate that the mutant photoreceptors could be rescued by an antagonist to a retinoic acid receptor, suggesting that the endogeneous survival‐promoting activity may function through this pathway. These data thus confirm and extend the findings of previous work that local trophic interactions are important in regulating rod photoreceptor degeneration in retinitis pigmentosa. A diffusible factor found in normal but not transgenic retinal cells has a protective effect on the survival of rod photoreceptors from Pro23His mutant rhodopsin mice. © 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Neurobiol 39: 475–490, 1999     

Organoid technology for retinal repair

A major cause for vision impairment and blindness in industrialized countries is the loss of the light-sensing retinal tissue in the eye. Photoreceptor damage is one of the main characteristics found in retinal degeneration diseases, such as Retinitis Pigmentosa or age-related macular degeneration. The lack of effective therapies to stop photoreceptor loss together with the absence of significant intrinsic regeneration in the human retina converts such degenerative diseases into permanent conditions that are currently irreversible. Cell replacement by means of photoreceptor transplantation has been proposed as a potential approach to tackle cell loss in the retina. Since the first attempt of photoreceptor transplantation in humans, about twenty years ago, several research groups have focused in the development and improvement of technologies necessary to bring cell transplantation for retinal degeneration diseases to reality. Progress in recent years in the generation of human tissue derived from pluripotent stem cells (PSCs) has significantly improved our tools to study human development and disease in the dish. Particularly the availability of 3D culture systems for the generation of PSC-derived organoids, including the human retina, has dramatically increased access to human material for basic and medical research. In this review, we focus on important milestones towards the generation of transplantable photoreceptor precursors from PSC-derived retinal organoids and discuss recent pre-clinical transplantation studies using organoid-derived photoreceptors in context to related in vivo work using primary photoreceptors as donor material. Additionally, we summarize remaining challenges for developing photoreceptor transplantation towards clinical application.     

Light exposure during embryonic and yolk-sac alevin development of Chinook salmon Oncorhynchus tshawytscha does not alter the spectral phenotype of photoreceptors

Colour vision is mediated by the expression of different visual pigments in photoreceptors of the vertebrate retina. Each visual pigment is a complex of a protein (opsin) and a vitamin A chromophore; alterations to either component affects visual pigment absorbance and, potentially, the visual capabilities of an animal. Many species of fish undergo changes in opsin expression during retinal development. In the case of salmonid fishes the single cone photoreceptors undergo a switch in opsin expression from SWS1 (ultraviolet sensitive) to SWS2 (blue-light sensitive) starting at the yolk-sac alevin stage, around the time when they first experience light. Whether light may initiate this event or produce a plastic response in the various photoreceptors is unknown. In this study, Chinook salmon Oncorhynchus tshawytscha were exposed to light from the embryonic (5 days prior to hatching) into the yolk sac alevin (25 days post hatching) stage and the spectral phenotype of photoreceptors assessed with respect to that of unexposed controls by in situ hybridization with opsin riboprobes. Light exposure did not change the spectral phenotype of photoreceptors, their overall morphology or spatial arrangement. These results concur with those from a variety of fish species and suggest that plasticity in photoreceptor spectral phenotype via changes in opsin expression may not be a widespread occurrence among teleosts.     

Retinal Development and Ommin Pigment in the Cranchiid Squid Teuthowenia pellucida (Cephalopoda: Oegopsida)

The cranchiid Teuthowenia pellucida, like many deep-sea squid species, possesses large eyes that maximise light sensitivity in a nearly aphotic environment. To assess ontogenetic changes in the visual system, we conducted morphometric and histological analyses of the eyes using specimens from New Zealand collections. While the ratio between eye diameter and mantle length maintained a linear relationship throughout development, histological sections of the retina revealed that the outer photoreceptor layer became proportionally longer as the animal aged, coincident with a habitat shift into deeper, darker ocean strata. Other retinal layers maintained the same absolute thickness as was observed in paralarvae. Granules of the pigment ommin, normally located in the screening layer positioned at the base of the photoreceptors, were also observed at the outer end of the photoreceptor segments throughout the retina in young and mid-sized specimens. Early developmental stages of this species, dwelling in shallow waters, may therefore rely on migratory ommin to help shield photoreceptors from excess light and prevent over-stimulation. The oldest, deeper-dwelling specimens of T. pellucida examined had longer photoreceptors, and little or no migrated ommin was observed; we suggest therefore that short-term adaptive mechanisms for bright light conditions may be used primarily during epipelagic, early life stages in this species.     

Role of Tau,a microtubule associated protein,in Drosophila photoreceptor morphogenesis

Cell polarity genes have important functions in photoreceptor morphogenesis. Based on recent discovery of stabilized microtubule cytoskeleton in developing photoreceptors and its role in photoreceptor cell polarity, microtubule associated proteins might have important roles in controlling cell polarity proteins' localizations in developing photoreceptors. Here, Tau, a microtubule associated protein, was analyzed to find its potential role in photoreceptor cell polarity. Tau colocalizes with acetylated/stabilized microtubules in developing pupal photoreceptors. Although it is known that tau mutant photoreceptor has no defects in early eye differentiation and development, it shows dramatic disruptions of cell polarity proteins, adherens junctions, and the stable microtubules in developing pupal photoreceptors. This role of Tau in cell polarity proteins' localization in photoreceptor cells during the photoreceptor morphogenesis was further supported by Tau's overexpression studies. Tau overexpression caused dramatic expansions of apical membrane domains where the polarity proteins localize in the developing pupal photoreceptors. It is also found that Tau's role in photoreceptor cell polarity depends on Par‐1 kinase. Furthermore, a strong genetic interaction between tau and crumbs was found. It is found that Tau has a crucial role in cell polarity protein localization during pupal photoreceptor morphogenesis stage, but not in early eye development including eye cell differentiation.     

Photoreceptor development in the pineal organ and the eye of Plecoglossus altivelis and Paralichthys olivaceus (Teleostei)

Summary The ontogenetic apperance of pineal photo-receptors was compared with that of retinal photoreceptors in the ayu Plecoglossus altivelis and the lefteye flounder Paralichthys olivaceus, which hatched 10 days and 3 days after fertilization, respectively. Despite the disparity in incubation time, the outer segments (containing membranous lamellae) of the pineal photoreceptors first appeared from 3 to 4 days after fertilization in both species. In contrast, the outer segments of the retinal photoreceptors first became visible 5 to 6 days after fertilization, although a characteristic retinal stratification and the optic tract leaving the ganglion cell layer were already found 4 days after fertilization in both species. The functional significance of these temporal disparities and/or similarities in photoreceptor development are discussed with special reference to the timing of daily rhythmic activities during the early developmental period of the teleosts.The results were presented at the Annual Meeting of the Japanese Society of Scientific Fisheries on April 2, 1990 (Tokyo)     

Intraocular gene transfer of ciliary neurotrophic factor rescues photoreceptor degeneration in RCS rats

Ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF) is known as an important factor in the regulation of retinal cell growth. We used both recombinant CNTF and an adenovirus carrying the CNTF gene to regulate retinal photoreceptor expression in a retinal degenerative animal, Royal College of Surgeons (RCS) rats. Cells in the outer nuclear layer of the retinae from recombinant-CNTF-treated, adenoviral-CNTF-treated, saline-operated, and contralateral untreated preparations were examined for those exhibiting CNTF photoreceptor protective effects. Cell apoptosis in the outer nuclear layer of the retinae was also detected. It was found that CNTF had a potent effect on delaying the photoreceptor degeneration process in RCS rats. Furthermore, adenovirus CNTF gene transfer was proven to be better at rescuing photoreceptors than that when using recombinant CNTF, since adenoviral CNTF prolonged the photoreceptor protection effect. The function of the photoreceptors was also examined by taking electroretinograms of different animals. Adenoviral-CNTF-treated eyes showed better retinal function than did the contralateral control eyes. This study indicates that adenoviral CNTF effectively rescues degenerating photoreceptors in RCS rats.S.-P.H. and P.-K.L. contributed equally to this work.     

Variations in cone photoreceptor abundance and the visual ecology of birds

The relative abundance and topographical distribution of retinal cone photoreceptors was measured in 19 bird species to identify possible correlations between photoreceptor complement and visual ecology. In contrast to previous studies, all five types of cone photoreceptor were distinguished, using bright field and epifluorescent light microscopy, in four retinal quadrants. Land birds tended to show either posterior dorsal to anterior ventral or anterior dorsal to posterior ventral gradients in cone photoreceptor distribution, fundus coloration and oil droplet pigmentation across the retina. Marine birds tended to show dorsal to ventral gradients instead. Statistical analyses showed that the proportions of the different cone types varied significantly across the retinae of all species investigated. Cluster analysis was performed on the data to identify groups or clusters of species on the basis of their oil droplet complement. Using the absolute percentages of each oil droplet type in each quadrant for the analysis produced clusters that tended to reflect phylogenetic relatedness between species rather than similarities in their visual ecology. Repeating the analysis after subtracting the mean percentage of a given oil droplet type across the whole retina (the 'eye mean') from the percentage of that oil droplet type in each quadrant, i.e. to give a measure of the variation about the mean, resulted in clusters that reflected diet, feeding behaviour and habitat to a greater extent than phylogeny.