Motor reactions and vestibular reflexes in cats and monkey in weightlessness

Close morpho-functional relationships of the cerebellum and vestibular system at all stages of phylogenesis of vertebrates suggest that cerebellum can be regarded as an important center of gravireceptive function. Direct examination of electrical activity of the labyrinth in cats during transient (1-2 sec) state of weightlessness produced by free fall has shown that there was an almost two fold increase in both the rate and amplitude of electrical activity in the vestibular ganglion. It is commonly accepted at present time that the conditions of orbital flight around Earth closely connect with weightlessness that usually manifests itself as undesirable factor of flight. It is known, that vestibular, proprioceptive, visual and other sensory modalities are converted on the cerebellum, which would indicate that this information is used for motor coordination and spatial orientation. Undoubtedly, origin of many vestibulo-motor disturbances during flight and in postflight period to a considerable degree depends on weightlessness. On the whole the visual illusions, motor discoordination, and space sickness, including vomiting are referred to the "space adaptation syndrome." But nature of these disturbances still is not well understood. This investigation was dedicated to study of vestibular and motor reactions of cats and monkey in short-term microgravity.     

Phenomenology of spatial illusory reactions under conditions of weightlessness

Sensory interaction and sensory adaptation in short- and long-lasting space flights (SF) and the dynamics of stability of adaptive shifts were studied by the phenomenology of spontaneous and visually induced illusory reactions. It was shown that perceptive impairment developed during the initial adaptation to microgravity should be considered regular reactions of sensory systems under given environmental conditions rather than special features of the individuals examined. The classification of spontaneous illusory reactions (SIR) under conditions of microgravity and the results of investigation of the vertical vection (vection is a visual illusion evoked by the optokinetic stimulation) are presented. The following previously unknown phenomena were registered for the first time: inversion of the vertical vection illusion (VVI) evoked by vertical and sinusoidal optokinetic stimulation, impairment of perception of the body schema during VVI, change in the character of VVI, and development of VVI asymmetry. During long-lasting existence under conditions of weightlessness the anomalous perceptive reactions continued to be registered episodically (the period of adaptation was replaced by that of deadaptation). A hypothesis was suggested for the possible mechanisms of the phenomena found. [Translated from Fiziologiya Cheloveka, vol. 21, no. 4, p. 50-62, July-August, 1995]     

The vestibulo-ocular reflex of hypergravity rats

The vertebrate vestibular system detects linear (otolith organs) and angular (semicircular canals) acceleration. The function of the otolith system is twofold, 1: perception of linear acceleration of the head, and 2: assessment of the spatial orientation of the head relative to the vector of gravity. Because of the latter function, a change of gravity will affect the vestibular input which, in turn, may have a wide range of serious physiological effects, for instance on ocular reflexes. The function of the vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) is to stabilize the visual image on the retina. Measurement of this VOR provides a method to investigate the (processing within the) vestibular system. Discrimination between gravity and linear acceleration, caused by movement of the head, is not possible. Therefore, information from the otolith system must be constantly compared with additional information from other sensory systems in order to solve the inherent ambiguity between tilt and translation. In this processing, cues from the semicircular canals also play a role. During parabolic flight, experiments can be performed at altered gravity levels for brief periods of time. On earth, the only effective possibility to manipulate gravity for longer periods of time is a centrifuge. Together with experiments in weightlessness during orbital flight, these methods form useful tools to investigate the influence of gravity on physiology. In our laboratory, rats have been kept inside a centrifuge at 2.5 g during their entire life-span (i.e. including gestation).     

Vestibular function and space motion sickness

The vestibular system plays an important role in intersensory interactions and gravitation is a natural stimulus for its receptors. Weightlessness alters the input signals of the otoliths and their effect on the pattern and dynamics of changes in the vestibular function (VF), which is accompanied by development of space adaptation syndrome (SAS) and space motion sickness (SMS). These changes occur both during the spaceflight (SF) and after returning to Earth, but the mechanisms of their development are still poorly understood and require special studies. In total, 47 Russian cosmonauts (crewmembers of long-term International Space Station (ISS) missions) have participated in the studies into VF before and after SF and nine of them, in onboard studies during SF (129–215 days) as a part of the Virtual space experiment (stage 1). Electro- and video-oculography are used to record spontaneous eye movements (SpEM), static vestibular–ocular responses during head tilts to the right or left shoulder (static otolith–cervical–ocular reflex, OCOR), and dynamic vestibular-ocular response during the head rotation around the longitudinal axis of the body. The examination is accompanied by personal and questionnaire survey on subjective responses and complaints of cosmonauts about SAS and SMS. Significant changes in SpEM (drifts of eyes, spontaneous and gaze-evoked nystagmus, and arbitrary saccades) and a decrease in OCOR (statistically significant decrease in the amplitude of ocular counter-rolling in response to head tilts up to its absence or inversion, an atypical OCOR) are observed during SF. An atypical OCOR is observed at the beginning of adaptation to weightlessness in seven of the nine cosmonauts (the first one to two weeks of SF) and repeatedly throughout the flight in all cosmonauts regardless of whether it is their first flight or not. Atypical vestibular responses after SF, similar to the responses during SF, are observed in several cosmonauts by day 9 after flight. It has been shown that atypical OCOR variants are more frequently observed in the subjects lacking any previous space experience, as well as a more pronounced decrease in this response with a concurrent increase in the response of the semicircular canals. It is also demonstrated that repeated SFs lead to a considerable shortening in the after-flight readaptation to terrestrial conditions and a considerable decrease in the degree of vestibular disorders. In the initial period of SF, the changes in VF are correlated with the complaints and manifestations of SAS and SMS; however, the complaints and the corresponding symptoms are unobservable during the further flight despite significant changes in the VF state. The patterns of the VF disorders associated with the impact of weightlessness and observed during and after SF are very similar, allowing these disorders to be regarded as SAS and SMS of different severities (intensities).     

Behavioural and functional vestibular disorders after space flight: 2. Fish,amphibians and birds

The review presents data on functional changes in fish, amphibians and birds associated with otolith organ activity after exposure to weightlessness during spaceflight. These data are of importance both for solving some fundamental problems of vestibulology and for practice. In the latter case, lower vertebrates are considered as a convenient and, most importantly, adequate model to unravel the mechanisms of vestibular disorders in humans. Analysis of the experimental results shows that weightlessness exerts no substantial effect on the formation and functional state of the otolith system in embryos of fish, amphibians and birds developing during spaceflight. Moreover, they even promote faster embryonic development of fish and amphibians as shown for mammalian fetuses. The experiments show that both in lower and higher vertebrates weightlessness brings about similar functional and behavioral changes. For example, in fish hatchlings and amphibian tadpoles (without lordosis) the vestibulo-ocular reflex was more pronounced immediately after orbital spaceflight than in control. An analogous alteration in the otolith reflex was observed in most cosmonauts after short-time space missions. In adult terrestrial vertebrates, as well as in humans, immediately after landing there was found a drop in the level of activity and deterioration of the equilibrium function and motor coordination. Another interesting finding was an unusual looping behavior when fish and tadpoles swam in loops post landing. Presumably, unusual motor activity of animals, as well as illusions arising in cosmonauts and astronauts during the transition from 1 to 0 g, have the same background being associated with changes in the stimulation pattern of the otolith organs. Considering the similarity of vestibular responses, the use of animal models seems very promising as allowing different invasive techniques.     

Behavioral lateralization and otolith asymmetry

Lateralized behavior is widespread among vertebrate animals and is determined primarily by structural-functional brain asymmetry as well as by the presence of somatic and visceral asymmetry. Some kinds of asymmetric reactions are suggested to be due to the presence of asymmetry at the level of sense organs, in particular, of otolith organs. This review presents data on values and characters of otolith asymmetry (OA) in animals of various species and classes and on the effect of weightlessness and hypergravity on OA; the issue of the effect of OA on vestibular and auditory functions also is considered. In symmetric vertebrates, OA was shown to be fluctuating, and its coefficient χ ranges from ?0.2 to +0.2; in the overwhelming majority of individuals, |χ| < 0.06. The low OA level enables the paired otolith organs to work in coordination; this is why the OA level is equally low regardless of the individual taxonomic and ecological position, size, age, and otolith growth rate. Individuals with the abnormally high OA level can experience difficulties in analyzing auditory and vestibular stimuli; therefore, most of such individuals are eliminated by natural selection. Unlike symmetric vertebrates, labyrinths of many Pleuronectiformes have pronounced OA-otoliths in the lower labyrinth, on average, are significantly heavier than those in the upper labyrinth. The organs of flatfish represent the only example when OA, being directional, seem to play an essential role in lateralized behavior and are suggested to be used in the spatial localization of the source of sound. The short-term weightlessness and relatively weak hypergravity (≤ 2g) do not affect OA. However, it cannot be ruled out that the long-term weightlessness and hypergravity ≥ 3g as well as some diseases and age-related changes can enhance OA and cause some functional disturbances.     

Bilateral otolith contribution to spatial coding in the vestibular system

Recent work on the coding of spatial information in central otolith neurons has significantly advanced our knowledge of signal transformation from head-fixed otolith coordinates to space-centered coordinates during motion. In this review, emphasis is placed on the neural mechanisms by which signals generated at the bilateral labyrinths are recognized as gravity-dependent spatial information and in turn as substrate for otolithic reflexes. We first focus on the spatiotemporal neuronal response patterns (i.e. one- and two-dimensional neurons) to pure otolith stimulation, as assessed by single unit recording from the vestibular nucleus in labyrinth-intact animals. These spatiotemporal features are also analyzed in association with other electrophysiological properties to evaluate their role in the central construction of a spatial frame of reference in the otolith system. Data derived from animals with elimination of inputs from one labyrinth then provide evidence that during vestibular stimulation signals arising from a single utricle are operative at the level of both the ipsilateral and contralateral vestibular nuclei. Hemilabyrinthectomy also revealed neural asymmetries in spontaneous activity, response dynamics and spatial coding behavior between neuronal subpopulations on the two sides and as a result suggested a segregation of otolith signals reaching the ipsilateral and contralateral vestibular nuclei. Recent studies have confirmed and extended previous observations that the recovery of resting activity within the vestibular nuclear complex during vestibular compensation is related to changes in both intrinsic membrane properties and capacities to respond to extracellular factors. The bilateral imbalance provides the basis for deranged spatial coding and motor deficits accompanying hemilabyrinthectomy. Taken together, these experimental findings indicate that in the normal state converging inputs from bilateral vestibular labyrinths are essential to spatiotemporal signal transformation at the central otolith neurons during low-frequency head movements.     

Functional asymmetry estimated by measurements of otolith in fish.

It is widely accepted that the incidence of space adaptation syndrome (SAS) is due to a mismatch of sensory information from various receptors to the central nervous system. We investigated the functional asymmetry of vestibular organ, which may caused sensory conflict in space, by measuring the weight difference of otolith between left and right side in goldfish and carp. In the goldfish utricular otolith, the maximum difference was 0.8 mg and the mean difference was 0.091 mg. The percentage of weight difference to the heavier otolith was calculated. The maximum difference was 20.57% and the mean was 3.035%. A difference exceeding 10% was found in only 2 goldfish. In the carp utricular otolith, the maximum percentage difference of weight was 24.8% and the mean was 3.491%. A difference exceeding 10% was found in only 3 carp. The maximum difference of saccular otolith was 11.8% with the mean of 6.92%, and that of lagenar otolith was 32% with the mean of 5.6% in goldfish. The close relationship of utricular otolith weight between both sides suggested that the otolith asymmetry might not be the main factor inducing SAS at least in goldfish and carp.     

The Vestibular-Evoked Postural Response of Adolescents with Idiopathic Scoliosis Is Altered

Adolescent idiopathic scoliosis is a multifactorial disorder including neurological factors. A dysfunction of the sensorimotor networks processing vestibular information could be related to spine deformation. This study investigates whether feed-forward vestibulomotor control or sensory reweighting mechanisms are impaired in adolescent scoliosis patients. Vestibular evoked postural responses were obtained using galvanic vestibular stimulation while participants stood with their eyes closed and head facing forward. Lateral forces under each foot and lateral displacement of the upper body of adolescents with mild (n = 20) or severe (n = 16) spine deformation were compared to those of healthy control adolescents (n = 16). Adolescent idiopathic scoliosis patients demonstrated greater lateral displacement and net lateral forces than controls both during and immediately after vestibular stimulation. Altered sensory reweighting of vestibular and proprioceptive information changed balance control of AIS patients during and after vestibular stimulation. Therefore, scoliosis onset could be related to abnormal sensory reweighting, leading to altered sensorimotor processes.     

Thyroid hormone-responsive genes mediate otolith growth and development during flatfish metamorphosis

Flatfish begin life as up-right swimming, bilaterally symmetrical larvae that metamorphose into asymmetrically shaped juveniles that swim with a highly lateralized posture. We have previously shown that TH induces abrupt growth and mineralization of one component of the vestibular system, the otoliths, during early larval development and metamorphosis. Here we report that four of five vestibular-specific genes that we tested (alpha-tectorin, otogelin, otolith matrix protein, and otopetrins 1 and 2 that are known to be associated with otolith development in other vertebrates are up-regulated 1.5- to 7-fold in larval flatfish during spontaneous metamorphosis and/or following 72 h of TH treatment. These findings suggest that otolith growth and development are mediated by diverse TH-responsive genes during flatfish metamorphosis.     

Velocity of head movements and sensory-motor adaptation during and after short spaceflight

To investigate to time course of sensory-motor adaptation to microgravity, we tested spatially-directed voluntary head movements before, during and after short spaceflight. We also tested the re-adaptation of postural responses to sensory stimulation after space flight. The cosmonaut performed in microgravity six cycles of voluntary head rotation in pitch, roll and yaw directions. During the first days of weightlessness the angular velocity of head movements increased. Over the next days of microgravity the velocity of head movements gradually decreased. On landing day a significant decrease of head rotation velocity was observed compared to the head movement velocity before spaceflight. Re-adaptation to Earth condition measured by body sway on soft support showed similar time course, but re-adaptation measured by postural responses to vestibular galvanic stimulation was prolonged. These results showed that the angular velocity of aimed head movements of cosmonauts is a good indicator of sensory-motor adaptation in altered gravity conditions.     

The development of vestibular connections in rat embryos in microgravity

Existing experimental embryological data suggests that the vestibular system initially develops in a very rigid and genetically controlled manner. Nevertheless, gravity appears to be a critical factor in the normal development of the vestibular system that monitors position with respect to gravity (saccule and utricle). In fact several studies have shown that prenatal exposure to microgravity causes temporary deficits in gravity-dependent righting behaviors, and prolonged exposure to hypergravity from conception to weaning causes permanent deficits in gravity-dependent righting behaviors. Data on hypergravity and microgravity exposure suggest some changes in the otolith formation during development, in particular the size although these changes may actually vary with the species involved. In adults exposed to microgravity there is a change in the synaptic density in the optic sensory epithelia suggesting that some adaptation may occur there. However, effects have also been reported in the brainstem. Several studies have shown synaptic changes in the lateral vestibular nucleus and in the nodulus of the cerebellum after neonatal exposure to hypergravity. We report here that synaptogenesis in the medial vestibular nucleus is retarded in developing rat embryos that were exposed to microgravity from gestation days 9 to 19.     

Effect before Cause: Supramodal Recalibration of Sensorimotor Timing

Background

Our motor actions normally generate sensory events, but how do we know which events were self generated and which have external causes? Here we use temporal adaptation to investigate the processing stage and generality of our sensorimotor timing estimates.

Methodology/Principal Findings

Adaptation to artificially-induced delays between action and event can produce a startling percept—upon removal of the delay it feels as if the sensory event precedes its causative action. This temporal recalibration of action and event occurs in a quantitatively similar manner across the sensory modalities. Critically, it is robust to the replacement of one sense during the adaptation phase with another sense during the test judgment.

Conclusions/Significance

Our findings suggest a high-level, supramodal recalibration mechanism. The effects are well described by a simple model which attempts to preserve the expected synchrony between action and event, but only when causality indicates it is reasonable to do so. We further demonstrate that this model successfully characterises related adaptation data from outside the sensorimotor domain.     

Behavioral and functional vestibular disorders after space flight: I. Mammals

The review presents data on functional disorders in mammals caused by changes in the vestibular system after space flight. These data show that the mammalian vestibular system responds to weightlessness dissimilarly at different ontogenetic stages. During the embryonic period, orbital space flight conditions have a little effect on the developing vestibular system and even promote normal fetal development. During the early postnatal period, when optimal sensorymotor tactics arise, long-term exposure to space flight conditions leads to the development of novel, “extraterrestrial”, sensory-motor programs that may fixate in CNS for life. In adult individuals, substantial vestibular changes and disorders may occur immediately after landing depending on the weightlessness duration. An adult organism has to solve two concurrent and mutually conflicting problems: to adapt to weightlessness and not to adapt to it in order to facilitate readaptation after return. Thus, individuals have to counteract weightlessness to retain a maximum of their pre-flight health status. The means of such a counteraction have to be adjusted according to the weightlessness duration. It is noteworthy, however, that not all functional changes occurring in adult individuals under weightlessness can be adequately accounted for. Some of them can assume a chronic or even pathological character. The review raises for the first time the question of necessity to include into the scope of studies the effect of weightlessness on a senile (senescent) organism and its vestibular system. We believe that development of space gerontology as a special branch of space biology and medicine is undoubtedly of interest and may become practically important in the future in view of the ever-growing age of space explorers.     

High transmittance of X-rays in the utricular otolith of upside-down swimming catfish, Synodontis nigriventris.

The upside-down swimming catfish (Synodontis nigriventris) has unique behavior, i.e., it frequently shows a stable upside-down posture during swimming and resting. To examine whether the unique postural control in S. nigriventris results from the characteristics of the vestibular organ, we observed the morphological aspects of the otolith and the orientation of sensory hair cells in the utricle. Soft X-ray densitometry analysis showed that the transmittance of soft X-rays in the otolith of S. nigriventris was higher than that in a closely related species (Synodontis multipunctatus) belonging to Synodontis family, goldfish (Carassius auratus) or miniature catfish (Corydoras paleatus) which shows upside-up swimming. The higher transmittance of soft X-rays suggests that the density of the otolith in S. nigriventris is lower than that in S. multipunctatus, C. auratus or C. paleatus. It is possible that the low density of the otolith may have a relation to the control of the unique upside-down posture of S. nigriventris. The hair cells in S. nigriventris were present at the ventral to ventro-lateral site of the utricular epithelium, forming a single hair cell layer as in the other 3 species of fish. The orientation of the sensory hair cells does not appear to cause the unique postural control.     

Cross-Modal Calibration of Vestibular Afference for Human Balance

To determine how the vestibular sense controls balance, we used instantaneous head angular velocity to drive a galvanic vestibular stimulus so that afference would signal that head movement was faster or slower than actual. In effect, this changed vestibular afferent gain. This increased sway 4-fold when subjects (N = 8) stood without vision. However, after a 240 s conditioning period with stable balance achieved through reliable visual or somatosensory cues, sway returned to normal. An equivalent galvanic stimulus unrelated to sway (not driven by head motion) was equally destabilising but in this situation the conditioning period of stable balance did not reduce sway. Reflex muscle responses evoked by an independent, higher bandwidth vestibular stimulus were initially reduced in amplitude by the galvanic stimulus but returned to normal levels after the conditioning period, contrary to predictions that they would decrease after adaptation to increased sensory gain and increase after adaptation to decreased sensory gain. We conclude that an erroneous vestibular signal of head motion during standing has profound effects on balance control. If it is unrelated to current head motion, the CNS has no immediate mechanism of ignoring the vestibular signal to reduce its influence on destabilising balance. This result is inconsistent with sensory reweighting based on disturbances. The increase in sway with increased sensory gain is also inconsistent with a simple feedback model of vestibular reflex action. Thus, we propose that recalibration of a forward sensory model best explains the reinterpretation of an altered reafferent signal of head motion during stable balance.     

Adaptation of the Human Body to Simulated Weightlessness: Clinical Studies

Problems of adaptation of functional systems of the human body to conditions of continuous weightlessness are considered (prolonged stay under conditions of antiorthostatic hypokinesia and in an immersion medium). It was revealed that, during adaptation to these conditions, polymorphic clinicofunctional disorders develop, transforming into clinicophysiological syndromes, the most frequently observed being autonomic vascular malfunction, asthenoneurotic syndrome, detraining of the blood circulatory system, trophic and neuromuscular disorders, statokinetic syndrome, pain syndrome, and metabolic and hormonal disorders. The severity of the specified disorders and the duration of the recovery period depend on the duration of hypokinesia and the intensity and regularity of application of preventive measures during hypokinesia. The most probable pathophysiological mechanisms of adverse effects of continuous hypokinesia (maladaptation) on functional systems of the human body are described.     

Effects of long-term space flights on organization of horizontal gaze fixation reaction

Results of Russian-Austrian space experiment "Monimir" which was a part of international space program "Austromir" are presented in this paper. Characteristics of horizontal gaze fixation reaction (hGFR) to visual targets were analyzed. Seven crewmembers of "Mir" space station expeditions took part in the experiment. Experiments were carried out 4 times before space flight, 5 times in flight and 3-4 times after landing. There were revealed significant alterations in characteristics of gaze fixation reaction during flight and after its accomplishing, namely: an increase of the time of gaze fixation to the target, changes of eye and head movements' velocity and increase of the gain of vestibular-ocular reflex, that pointed out to the disturbances of the control mechanisms of vestibular-ocular reflex in weightlessness caused by changes of vestibular input's activity. There was discovered also the difference in the strategies of adaptation to microgravity conditions among the cosmonauts of flight and non-flight occupation: in the first group exposure to weightlessness was accompanied by gaze hypermetry and inhibition of head movements; in the second one--on the contrary--by increase of head movement velocity and decrease of saccades' velocity.     

Early and Phasic Cortical Metabolic Changes in Vestibular Neuritis Onset

Functional brain activation studies described the presence of separate cortical areas responsible for central processing of peripheral vestibular information and reported their activation and interactions with other sensory modalities and the changes of this network associated to strategic peripheral or central vestibular lesions. It is already known that cortical changes induced by acute unilateral vestibular failure (UVF) are various and undergo variations over time, revealing different cortical involved areas at the onset and recovery from symptoms. The present study aimed at reporting the earliest change in cortical metabolic activity during a paradigmatic form of UVF such as vestibular neuritis (VN), that is, a purely peripheral lesion of the vestibular system, that offers the opportunity to study the cortical response to altered vestibular processing. This research reports [¹⁸F]fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography brain scan data concerning the early cortical metabolic activity associated to symptoms onset in a group of eight patients suffering from VN. VN patients’ cortical metabolic activity during the first two days from symptoms onset was compared to that recorded one month later and to a control healthy group. Beside the known cortical response in the sensorimotor network associated to vestibular deafferentation, we show for the first time the involvement of Entorhinal (BAs 28, 34) and Temporal (BA 38) cortices in early phases of symptomatology onset. We interpret these findings as the cortical counterparts of the attempt to reorient oneself in space counteracting the vertigo symptom (Bas 28, 34) and of the emotional response to the new pathologic condition (BA 38) respectively. These interpretations were further supported by changes in patients’ subjective ratings in balance, anxiety, and depersonalization/derealization scores when tested at illness onset and one month later. The present findings contribute in expanding knowledge about early, fast-changing, and complex cortical responses to pathological vestibular unbalanced processing.     

Compensatory processes during unilateral loss of vestibular function]

Changes in the compensation of the sequences of the unilateral loss of the labyrinthine function were studied in rabbits. Destruction of the labyrinth was accompanied by ocular nystagmus, increase of frequency of respiration and heart contractions, and EEG-activation. Investigations carried out showed these reactions to be extinguished at different time. At the late periods of labyrinthectomy a considerable asymmetry of nystagmus reaction to the angular accelerations equal in intensity, but opposite in direction was revealed. Stimulation of an intact otolith labyrinth was accompanied by the appearance of positional nystagmus. The results obtained indicated imperfection of the compensatory mechanisms during complete unilateral loss of the vestibular function.