A pedestrian guide to membrane protein crystallization

Membrane protein structural biology is a frontier area of modern biomedical research. Twenty to thirty-five percent of the proteins encoded by an organism's genome are integral membrane proteins. Integral membrane proteins, such as channels, transporters, and receptors, are critical components of many fundamental biological processes. Also, many integral membrane proteins are important in biomedical and biotechnological applications; the majority of drug targets are integral membrane proteins. The sharp increase in the number of membrane protein structures over the last several years gives some indication that this field is poised for rather explosive growth as more and more investigators take on membrane protein projects. The purpose of this brief practical review was to take a snapshot of a field at the onset of its likely exponential growth phase, and to lay out the methods that have worked to date for obtaining membrane protein crystals suitable for structure determination by X-ray crystallography. Many of the successful experimental methods are identical to those used for soluble proteins. The major difference, and a non-trivial difference, is the necessity for inclusion of detergents above the critical micelle concentration in the purified membrane protein solution.     

Rampant Exchange of the Structure and Function of Extramembrane Domains between Membrane and Water Soluble Proteins

Of the membrane proteins of known structure, we found that a remarkable 67% of the water soluble domains are structurally similar to water soluble proteins of known structure. Moreover, 41% of known water soluble protein structures share a domain with an already known membrane protein structure. We also found that functional residues are frequently conserved between extramembrane domains of membrane and soluble proteins that share structural similarity. These results suggest membrane and soluble proteins readily exchange domains and their attendant functionalities. The exchanges between membrane and soluble proteins are particularly frequent in eukaryotes, indicating that this is an important mechanism for increasing functional complexity. The high level of structural overlap between the two classes of proteins provides an opportunity to employ the extensive information on soluble proteins to illuminate membrane protein structure and function, for which much less is known. To this end, we employed structure guided sequence alignment to elucidate the functions of membrane proteins in the human genome. Our results bridge the gap of fold space between membrane and water soluble proteins and provide a resource for the prediction of membrane protein function. A database of predicted structural and functional relationships for proteins in the human genome is provided at sbi.postech.ac.kr/emdmp.     

On the analysis of membrane protein circular dichroism spectra

Analysis of circular dichroism spectra of proteins provides information about protein secondary structure. Analytical methods developed for such an analysis use structures and spectra of a set of reference proteins. The reference protein sets currently in use include soluble proteins with a wide range of secondary structures, and perform quite well in analyzing CD spectra of soluble proteins. The utility of soluble protein reference sets in analyzing membrane protein CD spectra, however, has been questioned in a recent study that found current reference protein sets to be inadequate for analyzing membrane proteins. We have examined the performance of reference protein sets available in the CDPro software package for analyzing CD spectra of 13 membrane proteins with available crystal structures. Our results indicate that the reference protein sets currently available for CD analysis perform reasonably well in analyzing membrane protein CD spectra, with performance indices comparable to those for soluble proteins. Soluble + membrane protein reference sets, which were constructed by combining membrane proteins with soluble protein reference sets, gave improved performance in both soluble and membrane protein CD analysis.     

The use of soluble protein structures in modeling helical proteins in a layered membrane

Major advances have been made in the prediction of soluble protein structures, led by the knowledge-based modeling methods that extract useful structural trends from known protein structures and incorporate them into scoring functions. The same cannot be reported for the class of transmembrane proteins, primarily due to the lack of high-resolution structural data for transmembrane proteins, which render many of the knowledge-based method unreliable or invalid. We have developed a method that harnesses the vast structural knowledge available in soluble protein data for use in the modeling of transmembrane proteins. At the core of the method, a set of transmembrane protein decoy sets that allow us to filter and train features recognized from soluble proteins for transmembrane protein modeling into a set of scoring functions. We have demonstrated that structures of soluble proteins can provide significant insight into transmembrane protein structures. A complementary novel two-stage modeling/selection process that mimics the two-stage helical membrane protein folding was developed. Combined with the scoring function, the method was successfully applied to model 5 transmembrane proteins. The root mean square deviations of the predicted models ranged from 5.0 to 8.8?Å to the native structures.     

Analyses of circular dichroism spectra of membrane proteins

Circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy is a valuable technique for the determination of protein secondary structures. Many linear and nonlinear algorithms have been developed for the empirical analysis of CD data, using reference databases derived from proteins of known structures. To date, the reference databases used by the various algorithms have all been derived from the spectra of soluble proteins. When applied to the analysis of soluble protein spectra, these methods generally produce calculated secondary structures that correspond well with crystallographic structures. In this study, however, it was shown that when applied to membrane protein spectra, the resulting calculations produce considerably poorer results. One source of this discrepancy may be the altered spectral peak positions (wavelength shifts) of membrane proteins due to the different dielectric of the membrane environment relative to that of water. These results have important consequences for studies that seek to use the existing soluble protein reference databases for the analyses of membrane proteins.     

Strategies for crystallizing membrane proteins

Crystallizing membrane proteins remains a challenging endeavor despite the increasing number of membrane protein structures solved by X-ray crystallography. The critical factors in determining the success of the crystallization experiments are the purification and preparation of membrane protein samples. Moreover, there is the added complication that the crystallization conditions must be optimized for use in the presence of detergents although the methods used to crystallize most membrane proteins are, in essence, straightforward applications of standard methodologies for soluble protein crystallization. The roles that detergents play in the stability and aggregation of membrane proteins as well as the colloidal properties of the protein-detergent complexes need to be appreciated and controlledbefore and during the crystallization trials. All X-ray quality crystals of membrane proteins were grown from preparations of detergent-solubilized protein, where the heterogeneous natural lipids from the membrane have been replaced by ahomogeneous detergent environment. It is the preparation of such monodisperse, isotropic solutions of membrane proteins that has allowed the successful application of the standard crystallization methods routinely used on soluble proteins. In this review, the issues of protein purification and sample preparation are addressed as well as the new refinements in crystallization methodologies for membrane proteins. How the physical behavior of the detergent, in the form of micelles or protein-detergent aggregates, affects crystallization and the adaptation of published protocols to new membrane protein systems are also addressed. The general conclusion is that many integral membrane proteins could be crystallized if pure and monodisperse preparations in a suitable detergent system can be prepared.In memory of Glenn D. Garavito.     

Forces and factors that contribute to the structural stability of membrane proteins

While a considerable amount of literature deals with the structural energetics of water-soluble proteins, relatively little is known about the forces that determine the stability of membrane proteins. Similarly, only a few membrane protein structures are known at atomic resolution, although new structures have recently been described. In this article, we review the current knowledge about the structural features of membrane proteins. We then proceed to summarize the existing literature regarding the thermal stability of bacteriorhodopsin, cytochrome-c oxidase, the band 3 protein, Photosystem II and porins. We conclude that a fundamental difference between soluble and membrane proteins is the high thermal stability of intrabilayer secondary structure elements in membrane proteins. This property manifests itself as incomplete unfolding, and is reflected in the observed low enthalpies of denaturation of most membrane proteins. By contrast, the extramembranous parts of membrane proteins may behave much like soluble proteins. A brief general account of thermodynamics factors that contribute to the stability of water soluble and membrane proteins is presented.     

Tricks of the trade used to accelerate high-resolution structure determination of membrane proteins

The rate at which X-ray structures of membrane proteins are solved is on a par with that of soluble proteins in the late 1970s. There are still many obstacles facing the membrane protein structural community. Recently, there have been several technical achievements in the field that have started to dramatically accelerate structural studies. Here, we summarize these so-called ‘tricks-of-the-trade’ and include case studies of several mammalian transporters.     

Eukaryotic membrane protein overproduction in Lactococcus lactis

Eukaryotic membrane proteins play many vital roles in the cell and are important drug targets. Approximately 25% of all genes identified in the genome are known to encode membrane proteins, but the vast majority have no assigned function. Although the generation of structures of soluble proteins has entered the high-throughput stage, for eukaryotic membrane proteins only a dozen high-resolution structures have been obtained so far. One major bottleneck for the functional and structural characterisation of membrane proteins is the overproduction of biologically active material. Recent advances in the development of the Lactococcus lactis expression system have opened the way for the high-throughput functional expression of eukaryotic membrane proteins.     

Display of membrane proteins on the heterologous caveolae carved by caveolin-1 in the Escherichia coli cytoplasm

Caveolae are membrane-budding structures that exist in many vertebrate cells. One of the important functions of caveolae is to form membrane curvature and endocytic vesicles. Recently, it was shown that caveolae-like structures were formed in Escherichia coli through the expression of caveolin-1. This interesting structure seems to be versatile for a variety of biotechnological applications. Targeting of heterologous proteins in the caveolae-like structure should be the first question to be addressed for this purpose. Here we show that membrane proteins co-expressed with caveolin-1 are embedded into the heterologous caveolae (h-caveolae), the cavaolae-like structures formed inside the cell. Two transmembrane SNARE (soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor attachment protein receptor) proteins, Syntaxin 1a and vesicle-associated membrane protein 2 (VAMP2), were displayed on the h-caveolae surface. The size of the h-caveolae harboring the transmembrane proteins was ∼100 nm in diameter. The proteins were functional and faced outward on the h-caveolae. Multi-spanning transmembrane proteins FtsH and FeoB could be included in the h-caveolae, too. Furthermore, the recombinant E. coli cells were shown to endocytose substrate supplemented in the medium. These results provide a basis for exploiting the h-caveolae formed inside E. coli cells for future biotechnological applications.     

Glycines: role in α-helical membrane protein structures and a potential indicator of native conformation

Among the growing number of membrane protein structures in the Protein Data Bank, there are many transmembrane domains that appear to be native-like; at the same time, there are others that appear to have less than complete native-like character. Hence, there is an increasing need for validation tools that distinguish native-like from non-native-like structures. Membrane mimetics used in protein structural characterizations differ in numerous physicochemical properties from native membranes and provide many opportunities for introducing non-native-like features into membrane protein structures. One possible approach for validating membrane protein structures is based on the use of glycine residues in transmembrane domains. Here, we have reviewed the membrane protein structure database and identified a set of benchmark proteins that appear to be native-like. In these structures, conserved glycine residues rarely face the lipid interstices, and many of them participate in close helix-helix packing. Glycine-based validation allowed the identification of non-native-like features in several membrane proteins and also shows the potential for verifying the native-like character for numerous other membrane protein structures.     

Collection of soluble variants of membrane proteins for transcriptomics and proteomics

The existence of a soluble splice variant for a gene encoding a transmembrane protein suggests that this gene plays a role in intercellular signalling, particularly in immunological processes. Also, the absence of a splice variant of a reported soluble variant suggests exclusive control of the solubilisation by proteolytic cleavage. Soluble splice variants of membrane proteins may also be interesting targets for crystallisation as their structure may be expected to preserve, at least partially, their function as integral membrane proteins, whose structures are most difficult to determine. This paper presents a dataset derived from the literature in an attempt to collect all reported soluble variants of membrane proteins, be they splice variants or shedded. A list of soluble variants is derived in silico from Ensembl. These are checked on their presence in multiple organisms and their number of membranespanning regions is inspected. The findings then are confirmed by a comparison with identified proteins of a recent global proteomics study of human blood plasma. Finally, a tool to determine novel soluble variants by proteomics is provided.     

Formation of an unfolding intermediate state of soluble chloride intracellular channel protein CLIC1 at acidic pH

CLIC proteins function as anion channels when their structures convert from a soluble form to an integral membrane form. While very little is known about the mechanism of the conversion process, channel formation and activity are highly pH-dependent. In this study, the structural properties and conformational stability of CLIC1 were determined as a function of pH in the absence of membranes to improve our understanding of how its conformation changes when the protein encounters the acidic environment at the surface of a membrane. Although the global conformation and size of CLIC1 are not significantly altered by pH in the range of 5.5-8.2, equilibrium unfolding studies reveal that the protein molecule becomes destabilized at low pH, resulting in the formation of a highly populated intermediate with a solvent-exposed hydrophobic surface. Unlike the intermediates formed by many soluble pore-forming proteins for their insertion into membranes, the CLIC1 intermediate is not a molten globule. Acid-induced destabilization and partial unfolding of CLIC1 involve helix alpha1 which is the major structural element of the transmembrane region. We propose that the acidic environment encountered by CLICs at the surface of membranes primes the transmembrane region in the N-domain, thereby lowering the energy barrier for the conversion of soluble CLICs to their membrane-inserted forms.     

Comparative proteome analysis of subcellular fractions from Borrelia burgdorferi by NEPHGE and IPG

Borrelia burgdorferi, the cause of Lyme disease, produces excessive amounts of membrane lipoproteins such as outer surface protein A (OspA) when grown in vitro, and consequently many low or moderately abundant proteins are underrepresented when cell lysates are examined by 2-DE. We analyzed the B. burgdorferi B31 proteome computationally and by IPG or modified NEPHGE after subcellular fractionation into membrane-associated and soluble proteins. The B. burgdorferi B31 theoretical proteome is comprised of 1623 proteins and has a mean pI of 8.36 and a median pI of 9.03 with 68% of the proteome possessing a pI >/=7.5. Separation of soluble proteins by IPG resulted in 205 individual spots and identification of 78 protein spots by MALDI-TOF MS. Separation by modified NEPHGE routinely resulted in approximately 185 soluble and 160 membrane protein spots with the identification of 88 individual protein spots combined by MALDI-TOF MS. Homologues to GroEL and aminopeptidase I were present in greater amounts in the membrane faction, with enolase at nearly equivalent amounts in the soluble and membrane fractions. Identification of proteins isolated and separated by such methods will enable future determination of proteome changes in membrane and soluble protein fractions as spirochetes adapt to their changing environments.     

Consequences of membrane protein overexpression in Escherichia coli

Overexpression of membrane proteins is often essential for structural and functional studies, but yields are frequently too low. An understanding of the physiological response to overexpression is needed to improve such yields. Therefore, we analyzed the consequences of overexpression of three different membrane proteins (YidC, YedZ, and LepI) fused to green fluorescent protein (GFP) in the bacterium Escherichia coli and compared this with overexpression of a soluble protein, GST-GFP. Proteomes of total lysates, purified aggregates, and cytoplasmic membranes were analyzed by one- and two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and mass spectrometry complemented with flow cytometry, microscopy, Western blotting, and pulse labeling experiments. Composition and accumulation levels of protein complexes in the cytoplasmic membrane were analyzed with improved two-dimensional blue native PAGE. Overexpression of the three membrane proteins, but not soluble GST-GFP, resulted in accumulation of cytoplasmic aggregates containing the overexpressed proteins, chaperones (DnaK/J and GroEL/S), and soluble proteases (HslUV and ClpXP) as well as many precursors of periplasmic and outer membrane proteins. This was consistent with lowered accumulation levels of secreted proteins in the three membrane protein overexpressors and is likely to be a direct consequence of saturation of the cytoplasmic membrane protein translocation machinery. Importantly accumulation levels of respiratory chain complexes in the cytoplasmic membrane were strongly reduced. Induction of the acetate-phosphotransacetylase pathway for ATP production and a down-regulated tricarboxylic acid cycle indicated the activation of the Arc two-component system, which mediates adaptive responses to changing respiratory states. This study provides a basis for designing rational strategies to improve yields of membrane protein overexpression in E. coli.     

Structure refinement of membrane proteins via molecular dynamics simulations

A refinement protocol based on physics‐based techniques established for water soluble proteins is tested for membrane protein structures. Initial structures were generated by homology modeling and sampled via molecular dynamics simulations in explicit lipid bilayer and aqueous solvent systems. Snapshots from the simulations were selected based on scoring with either knowledge‐based or implicit membrane‐based scoring functions and averaged to obtain refined models. The protocol resulted in consistent and significant refinement of the membrane protein structures similar to the performance of refinement methods for soluble proteins. Refinement success was similar between sampling in the presence of lipid bilayers and aqueous solvent but the presence of lipid bilayers may benefit the improvement of lipid‐facing residues. Scoring with knowledge‐based functions (DFIRE and RWplus) was found to be as good as scoring using implicit membrane‐based scoring functions suggesting that differences in internal packing is more important than orientations relative to the membrane during the refinement of membrane protein homology models.     

A virtual high-throughput screening approach to the discovery of novel inhibitors of the bacterial leucine transporter,LeuT

Abstract

Membrane proteins are intrinsically involved in both human and pathogen physiology, and are the target of 60% of all marketed drugs. During the past decade, advances in the studies of membrane proteins using X-ray crystallography, electron microscopy and NMR-based techniques led to the elucidation of over 250 unique membrane protein crystal structures. The aim of the European Drug Initiative for Channels and Transporter (EDICT) project is to use the structures of clinically significant membrane proteins for the development of lead molecules. One of the approaches used to achieve this is a virtual high-throughput screening (vHTS) technique initially developed for soluble proteins. This paper describes application of this technique to the discovery of inhibitors of the leucine transporter (LeuT), a member of the neurotransmitter:sodium symporter (NSS) family.     

Helix-helix packing and interfacial pairwise interactions of residues in membrane proteins

Helix-helix packing plays a critical role in maintaining the tertiary structures of helical membrane proteins. By examining the overall distribution of voids and pockets in the transmembrane (TM) regions of helical membrane proteins, we found that bacteriorhodopsin and halorhodopsin are the most tightly packed, whereas mechanosensitive channel is the least tightly packed. Large residues F, W, and H have the highest propensity to be in a TM void or a pocket, whereas small residues such as S, G, A, and T are least likely to be found in a void or a pocket. The coordination number for non-bonded interactions for each of the residue types is found to correlate with the size of the residue. To assess specific interhelical interactions between residues, we have developed a new computational method to characterize nearest neighboring atoms that are in physical contact. Using an atom-based probabilistic model, we estimate the membrane helical interfacial pairwise (MHIP) propensity. We found that there are many residue pairs that have high propensity for interhelical interactions, but disulfide bonds are rarely found in the TM regions. The high propensity pairs include residue pairs between an aromatic residue and a basic residue (W-R, W-H, and Y-K). In addition, many residue pairs have high propensity to form interhelical polar-polar atomic contacts, for example, residue pairs between two ionizable residues, between one ionizable residue and one N or Q. Soluble proteins do not share this pattern of diverse polar-polar interhelical interaction. Exploratory analysis by clustering of the MHIP values suggests that residues similar in side-chain branchness, cyclic structures, and size tend to have correlated behavior in participating interhelical interactions. A chi-square test rejects the null hypothesis that membrane protein and soluble protein have the same distribution of interhelical pairwise propensity. This observation may help us to understand the folding mechanism of membrane proteins.     

Conversion of phospholamban into a soluble pentameric helical bundle

Although membrane proteins and soluble proteins may achieve their final folded states through different pathways, it has been suggested that the packing inside a membrane protein could maintain a similar fold if the lipid-exposed surface were redesigned for solubility in an aqueous environment. To test this idea, the surface of the transmembrane domain of phospholamban (PLB), a protein that forms a stable helical homopentamer within the sarcoplasmic reticulum membrane, has been redesigned by replacing its lipid-exposed hydrophobic residues with charged and polar residues. CD spectra indicate that the full-length soluble PLB is highly alpha-helical. Small-angle X-ray scattering and multiangle laser light scattering experiments reveal that this soluble variant of PLB associates as a pentamer, preserving the oligomeric state of the natural protein. Mutations that destabilize native PLB also disrupt the pentamer. However, NMR experiments suggest that the redesigned protein exhibits molten globule-like properties, possibly because the redesign of the surface of this membrane protein may have altered some native contacts at the core of the protein or possibly because the core is not rigidly packed in wild-type PLB. Nonetheless, our success in converting the membrane protein PLB into a specific soluble helical pentamer indicates that the interior of a membrane protein contains at least some of the determinants necessary to dictate folding in an aqueous environment. The design we successfully used was based on one of the two models in the literature; the alternative design did not give stable, soluble pentamers. This suggests that surface redesign can be employed in gaining insights into the structures of membrane proteins.