Structural Refinement of a Key Tryptophan Residue in the BLUF Photoreceptor AppA by Ultraviolet Resonance Raman Spectroscopy

The flavin-adenine-dinucleotide-binding BLUF domain constitutes a new class of blue-light receptors, and the N-terminal domain of AppA is a representative of this family. The BLUF domain is of special interest because it uses a rigid flavin rather than an isomerizable chromophore, such as a rhodopsin or phytochrome, for its light-activation process. Crystal and solution structures of several BLUF domains were recently obtained, and their overall structures are consistent. However, there is a key ambiguity regarding the position of a conserved tryptophan (Trp-104 in AppA), in that this residue was found either close to flavin (Trp_in conformation) or exposed to the solvent (Trp_out conformation). The location of Trp-104 is a crucial factor in understanding the photocycle mechanism of BLUF domains, because this residue has been shown to play an essential role in the activation of AppA. In this study, we demonstrated a Trp_in conformation for the BLUF domain of AppA through direct observation of the vibrational spectrum of Trp-104 by ultraviolet resonance Raman spectroscopy, and also observed light-induced conformational and environmental changes in Trp-104. This study provides a structural basis for future investigations of the photocycle mechanism of BLUF proteins.     

On the signaling mechanism and the absence of photoreversibility in the AppA BLUF domain

The flavoprotein AppA from Rhodobacter sphaeroides contains an N-terminal, FAD-binding BLUF photoreceptor domain. Upon illumination, the AppA BLUF domain forms a signaling state that is characterized by red-shifted absorbance by 10 nm, a state known as AppA_RED. We have applied ultrafast spectroscopy on the photoaccumulated AppA_RED state to investigate the photoreversible properties of the AppA BLUF domain. On light absorption by AppA_RED, the FAD singlet excited state decays monoexponentially in 7 ps to form the neutral semiquinone radical FADH^•, which subsequently decays to the original AppA_RED molecular ground state in 60 ps. Thus, is deactivated rapidly via electron and proton transfer, probably from the conserved tyrosine Tyr-21 to FAD, followed by radical-pair recombination. We conclude that, in contrast to many other photoreceptors, the AppA BLUF domain is not photoreversible and does not enter alternative reaction pathways upon absorption of a second photon. To explain these properties, we propose that a molecular configuration is formed upon excitation of AppA_RED that corresponds to a forward reaction intermediate previously identified for the dark-state BLUF photoreaction. Upon excitation of AppA_RED, the BLUF domain therefore enters its forward reaction coordinate, readily re-forming the AppA_RED ground state and suppressing reverse or side reactions. The monoexponential decay of FAD* indicates that the FAD-binding pocket in AppA_RED is significantly more rigid than in dark-state AppA. Steady-state fluorescence experiments on wild-type, W104F, and W64F mutant BLUF domains show tryptophan fluorescence maxima that correspond with a buried conformation of Trp-104 in dark and light states. We conclude that Trp-104 does not become exposed to solvent during the BLUF photocycle.     

Structure of a novel photoreceptor, the BLUF domain of AppA from Rhodobacter sphaeroides

The flavin-binding BLUF domain of AppA represents a new class of blue light photoreceptors that are present in a number of bacterial and algal species. The dark state X-ray structure of this domain was determined at 2.3 A resolution. The domain demonstrates a new function for the common ferredoxin-like fold; two long alpha-helices flank the flavin, which is bound with its isoalloxazine ring perpendicular to a five-stranded beta-sheet. The hydrogen bond network and the overall protein topology of the BLUF domain (but not its sequence) bear some resemblance to LOV domains, a subset of PAS domains widely involved in signaling. Nearly all residues conserved in BLUF domains surround the flavin chromophore, many of which are involved in an intricate hydrogen bond network. Photoactivation may induce a rearrangement in this network via reorientation of the Gln63 side chain to form a new hydrogen bond to the flavin O4 position. This shift would also break a hydrogen bond to the Trp104 side chain, which may be critical in induction of global structural change in AppA.     

Molecular models predict light-induced glutamine tautomerization in BLUF photoreceptors

The recently discovered photoreceptor proteins containing BLUF (sensor of blue light using FAD) domains mediate physiological responses to blue light in bacteria and euglena. In BLUF domains, blue light activates the flavin chromophore yielding a signaling state characterized by a ∼10 nm red-shifted absorption. We developed molecular models for the dark and light states of the BLUF domain of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides AppA protein, which are based on the crystal structures and quantum-mechanical simulations. According to these models, photon absorption by the flavin results in a tautomerization and 180° rotation of the Gln side chain that interacts with the flavin cofactor. This chemical modification of the Gln residue induces alterations in the hydrogen bond network in the core of the photoreceptor domain, which were observed in numerous spectroscopic experiments. The calculated electronic transition energies and vibrational frequencies of the proposed dark and light states are consistent with the optical and IR spectral changes observed during the photocycle. Light-induced isomerization of an amino acid residue instead of a chromophore represents a feature that has not been described previously in photoreceptors.     

The critical role of a hydrogen bond between Gln63 and Trp104 in the blue-light sensing BLUF domain that controls AppA activity

AppA is a novel blue-light receptor that controls photosynthetic gene expression in the purple bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides. The photocycle reaction of the light-sensing domain, BLUF, is unique in the sense that a few hydrogen bond rearrangements are accompanied by only slight structural changes of the bound chromophore. However, the exact features of the hydrogen bond network around the active site are still the subject of some controversy. Here we present biochemical and genetic evidence showing that either Gln63 or Trp104 in the active site of the BLUF domain is crucial for light sensing, which in turn controls the antirepressor activity of AppA. Specifically, the Q63L and W104A mutants of AppA are insensitive to blue light in vivo and in vitro, and their activity is similar to that of the light-adapted wild-type AppA. Based on spectroscopic and structural information described previously, we conclude that light-dependent formation and breakage of the hydrogen bond between Gln63 and Trp104 are critical for the light-sensing mechanism of AppA.     

Tryptophan at position 104 is involved in transforming light signal into changes of beta-sheet structure for the signaling state in the BLUF domain of AppA

AppA is a member of an FAD-based new class blue-light sensory protein known as sensor of blue light using FAD (BLUF) protein. The spectroscopic properties of an AppA BLUF domain (AppA126), in which the tryptophan residue at position 104 had been replaced with alanine (W104A), were characterized. The W104A mutant AppA126 showed a nearly normal absorption red shift in the FAD UV-visible absorption upon illumination; however, the light state relaxed to the dark state at a rate approximately 150 times faster than that of wild-type AppA126. Light-induced structural changes of FAD and apoprotein in the wild-type and mutant AppA126 were studied by means of light-induced Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) difference spectroscopy using AppA126, in which the apoprotein had been selectively labeled with 13C. The light-induced FTIR spectrum of the W104A mutant AppA126 revealed bands corresponding to a C4 = O stretch of the FAD isoalloxazine ring and structural changes of apoprotein, but with some alterations in the bands' features. Notably, however, prominent protein bands at 1,632(+)/1,619(-) cm(-1) caused by changes in the beta-sheet structure were eliminated by the mutation, indicating that Trp104 is responsible for transforming the light signal into a specific beta-sheet structure change in the apoprotein of the AppA BLUF domain in the signaling state.     

Structural requirements for key residues and auxiliary portions of a BLUF domain

BlrB in Rhodobacter sphaeroides is a single domain, flavin-based blue light sensor protein in the BLUF family of photoreceptors. Consistent with other members of this family, blue light excitation induces a putative signaling state characterized by a 10 nm red shift in the UV-visible absorbance spectrum. Structural and spectroscopic characterization of truncated BlrB constructs establishes that the C-terminal 50 amino acids of this protein are essential to its structural integrity despite not being part of the canonical BLUF domain architecture. Mutagenesis studies support the critical roles of Tyr9, Asn33, and Gln51 for flavin binding and the integrity of the BLUF domain fold. Comparison of solution NMR spectra of BlrB acquired under dark and light conditions indicates very limited light-dependent conformational changes except for a few interesting residues: Trp92, Met94, and Ile127. Notably, the Ile127 side chain experiences significant chemical shift changes despite the fact that it is far ( approximately 15 A) from the flavin chromophore in the C-terminal extension. These data suggest that the light-induced signal is propagated from the flavin through the beta sheet to the last two alpha helices in the C-terminal extension, potentially providing a mechanism to transmit this change to initiate a cellular response to blue light.     

FTIR study on the hydrogen bond structure of a key tyrosine residue in the flavin-binding blue light sensor TePixD from Thermosynechococcus elongatus

The BLUF (sensor of blue light using FAD) domain is a blue light receptor possessing a flavin molecule as an active cofactor. A conserved Tyr residue located adjacent to flavin has been proposed to be a key amino acid in the mechanism of the photoreaction of the BLUF domain. We have studied the structure of this key Tyr residue and the relevance to the photoreaction in the BLUF protein of the cyanobacterium Thermosynechococcus elongatus, TePixD, by means of Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) difference spectroscopy and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Light-induced FTIR difference spectra of unlabeled and [4-13C]Tyr-labeled TePixD in H2O and D2O revealed that the nuCO/deltaCOH vibrations of a photosensitive Tyr side chain are located at 1265/1242 cm-1 in the dark-adapted state and at 1273/1235 cm-1 in the light-induced signaling state. These signals were assigned to the vibrations of Tyr8 near flavin from the absence of the effect of [4-13C]Tyr labeling in the Tyr8Phe mutant. DFT calculations of H-bonded complexes of p-cresol with amides as models of the Tyr8-Gln50 interactions showed that Tyr8 acts as a H-bond donor to the Gln50 in both of the dark and light states. Further DFT analysis suggested that this H-bond is strengthened upon photoconversion to the light state accompanied with a change in the H-bond angle. The change in the H-bond structure of Tyr8 is coupled to the flavin photoreaction probably through the Tyr8-Gln50-flavin H-bond network, suggesting a significant role of Tyr8 in the photoreaction mechanism of TePixD.     

Adenosine diphosphate moiety does not participate in structural changes for the signaling state in the sensor of blue-light using FAD domain of AppA

A sensor of blue light using FAD (BLUF) protein is a flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) based new class blue-light sensory flavoprotein. The BLUF domain of AppA was reconstituted in vitro from apoprotein and flavin adenine dinucleotide, flavin adenine mononucleotide or riboflavin. The light-induced FTIR spectra of the domain reconstituted from various flavins and the 13C-labeled apoprotein showed that identical light-induced structural changes occur in both the flavin chromophore and protein for the signaling state in all of the reconstituted holoproteins. The results showed that an adenosine 5'-dinucleotide moiety is not required for signaling-state formation in a BLUF domain.     

Fate determination of the flavin photoreceptions in the cyanobacterial blue light receptor TePixD (Tll0078)

PixD (Tll0078, Slr1694) is a BLUF (sensor of blue light using FAD)-type blue light receptor protein of the thermophilic cyanobacterium Thermosynechococcus elongatus BP-1 and the mesophilic cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803. BLUF protein is known to show light-induced approximately 10 nm red shift of flavin absorption that is coupled with strengthening of the hydrogen bond between the O(4) of the isoalloxazine ring and a certain amino acid residue. According to the 3D structure of TePixD we determined, O(4) of the ring is linked to Gln50 and Asn32. A survey of flavin-interacting residues by site-directed mutagenesis showed that Gln50 but not Asn32 is essential for the normal red-shifting photoreaction. Here, we further studied the role of Gln50 and its close neighbor Tyr8. All the mutated proteins of Gln50 and Tyr8 (Q50A, Q50N, Y8A and Y8F) lost the normal red-shifting photoreaction. Y8A, Y8F and Q50N, instead, showed a light-induced flavin triplet state and a low yield of subsequent flavin reduction that is analogous to the photocycle of the LOV (light-oxygen-voltage-sensing) domain of phototropins, while Q50A did not. Fourier-transform infrared (FT-IR) analysis of N32A showed that O(4) of the ring is hydrogen-bonded to Asn32 both in the light and dark. These results, together with the 3D structure, indicate that the hydrogen bond network of Tyr8-Gln50-O(4)/N(5) (flavin) is critical for the light reaction of the BLUF domain. Based on the structural and functional similarities of the BLUF and the LOV domain of phototropins, we propose that the interaction between apoprotein and N(5) of flavin determines the photoreaction of the flavin-binding sensors.     

Redox Modulation of Flavin and Tyrosine Determines Photoinduced Proton-coupled Electron Transfer and Photoactivation of BLUF Photoreceptors

Photoinduced electron transfer in biological systems, especially in proteins, is a highly intriguing matter. Its mechanistic details cannot be addressed by structural data obtained by crystallography alone because this provides only static information on a given redox system. In combination with transient spectroscopy and site-directed manipulation of the protein, however, a dynamic molecular picture of the ET process may be obtained. In BLUF (blue light sensors using FAD) photoreceptors, proton-coupled electron transfer between a tyrosine and the flavin cofactor is the key reaction to switch from a dark-adapted to a light-adapted state, which corresponds to the biological signaling state. Particularly puzzling is the fact that, although the various naturally occurring BLUF domains show little difference in the amino acid composition of the flavin binding pocket, the reaction rates of the forward reaction differ quite largely from a few ps up to several hundred ps. In this study, we modified the redox potential of the flavin/tyrosine redox pair by site-directed mutagenesis close to the flavin C2 carbonyl and fluorination of the tyrosine, respectively. We provide information on how changes in the redox potential of either reaction partner significantly influence photoinduced proton-coupled electron transfer. The altered redox potentials allowed us furthermore to experimentally describe an excited state charge transfer intermediately prior to electron transfer in the BLUF photocycle. Additionally, we show that the electron transfer rate directly correlates with the quantum yield of signaling state formation.     

Crystal structures of the AppA BLUF domain photoreceptor provide insights into blue light-mediated signal transduction

Proteins containing a sensor of blue light using FAD (BLUF) domain control diverse cellular processes, such as gene expression, nucleotide metabolism and motility, by relaying blue light signals to distinct output units. Despite its crucial and widespread functions, the mechanism of BLUF signal transduction has remained elusive. We determined crystal structures of the dark-adapted state and of a photo-excited, red-shifted photocycle intermediate of the BLUF unit of AppA, a purple bacterial photoreceptor involved in the light-dependent regulation of photosynthesis gene expression. In contrast to a recently published crystal structure of the AppA BLUF domain determined in the presence of detergent molecules, our structural model of the dark state corresponds well to those reported for the BLUF domains of Tll0078 and BlrB. This establishes that a highly conserved methionine (Met106 in AppA) is next to the active site glutamine (Gln63 in AppA), which is of relevance for the latter's orientation in the dark state and for the mechanism of the photoreaction. The comparison of the dark-adapted and photointermediate state structures shows light-induced conformational alterations, which suggest a path for signal propagation. In particular, we observe a significant movement of the Met106 side-chain. Met106 thereby changes its mode of interaction with Gln63, which supports a light-dependent rotation of the latter. In view of other BLUF structures available, our data further suggest that the hydrogen bond between Asn45 and the backbone carbonyl of His105 breaks upon illumination. The ensuing extensive structural rearrangement of beta-strand 5 is predicted to involve a flip of Met106 out of the flavin-binding pocket and Trp104 moving in to fill the void. We propose that the blue light signal is transmitted towards the surface of the BLUF domain via His44, which serves as a reporter of active site changes.     

Spectroscopic analysis of the dark relaxation process of a photocycle in a sensor of blue light using FAD (BLUF) protein Slr1694 of the cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp. PCC6803

Slr1694 is a BLUF (sensor of blue light using flavin adenine dinucleotide) protein and a putative photoreceptor in the cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp. PCC6803. Illumination of Slr1694 induced a signaling light state concurrent with a red shift in the UV-visible absorption of flavin, and formation of the bands from flavin and apo-protein in the light-minus-dark Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) difference spectrum. Replacement of Tyr8 with phenylalanine abolished these changes. The light state relaxed to the ground dark state, during which the FTIR bands decayed monophasically. These bands were classifiable into three groups according to their decay rates. The C4=O stretching bands of a flavin isoalloxazine ring had the highest decay rate, which corresponded to that of the absorption red shift. The result indicated that the hydrogen bonding at C4=O is responsible for the UV-visible red shift, consistent with the results of density functional calculation. All FTIR bands and the red shift decayed at the same slower rate in deuterated Slr1694. These results indicated that the dark relaxation from the light state is limited by proton transfer. In contrast, a constrained light state formed under dehydrated conditions decayed much more slowly with no deuteration effects. A photocycle mechanism involving the proton transfer was proposed.     

Crucial role in light signal transduction for the conserved Met93 of the BLUF protein PixD/Slr1694

PixD/Slr1694 from the cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp. PCC6803 is a member of a new class of flavin-containing blue-light sensory proteins containing a BLUF (blue light using flavin) domain. The photocycle reaction mechanism of BLUF is unique because only small structural changes of a bound chromophore are accompanied by a few hydrogen bond rearrangements in the chromophore-binding site. Here, we show that in PixD, Met93, the residue conserved in all BLUF domains, is crucial for light-dependent signal transduction. Specifically, the light-insensitive M93A mutant of PixD revealed biochemical and physiological activities compatible with those of the light-adapted wild-type PixD. However, the W91A mutant of PixD retained light sensitivity and biological function, although the corresponding mutant of another BLUF protein, AppA, has been reported to be locked in the light signaling state. These observations suggest that the pathway through which the light signal is transformed into apoprotein structural changes has been modified in BLUF proteins for their respective functions.     

A LOV story: the signaling state of the phot1 LOV2 photocycle involves chromophore-triggered protein structure relaxation, as probed by far-UV time-resolved optical rotatory dispersion spectroscopy

Light-, oxygen-, or voltage-regulated (LOV1 and LOV2) domains bind flavin mononucleotide (FMN) and activate the phototropism photoreceptors phototropin 1 (phot1) and phototropin 2 (phot2) by using energy from absorbed blue light. Upon absorption of blue light, chromophore and protein conformational changes trigger the kinase domain for subsequent autophosphorylation and presumed downstream signal transduction. To date, the light-induced photocycle of the phot1 LOV2 protein is known to involve formation of a triplet flavin mononucleotide (FMN) chromophore followed by the appearance of a FMN adduct within 4 micros [Swartz, T. E., Corchnoy, S. B., Christie, J. M., Lewis, J. W., Szundi, I., Briggs, W. R., and Bogomolni, R. A. (2001) J. Biol. Chem. 276, 36493-36500] before thermal decay back to the dark state. To probe the mechanism by which the blue light information is relayed from the chromophore to the protein, nanosecond time-resolved optical rotatory dispersion (TRORD) spectroscopy, which is a direct probe of global secondary structure, was used to study the phot1 LOV2 protein in the far-UV region. These TRORD experiments reveal a previously unobserved intermediate species (tau approximately 90 micros) that is characterized by a FMN adduct chromophore and partially unfolded secondary structure (LOV390(S2)). This intermediate appears shortly after the formation of the FMN adduct. For LOV2, formation of a long-lived species that is ready to interact with a receptor domain for downstream signaling is much faster by comparison with formation of a similar species in other light-sensing proteins.     

On the role of aromatic side chains in the photoactivation of BLUF domains

BLUF (blue-light sensing using FAD) domain proteins are a novel group of blue-light sensing receptors found in many microorganisms. The role of the aromatic side chains Y21 and W104, which are in close vicinity to the FAD cofactor in the AppA BLUF domain from Rhodobacter sphaeroides, is investigated through the introduction of several amino acid substitutions at these positions. NMR spectroscopy indicated that in the W104F mutant, the local structure of the FAD binding pocket was not significantly perturbed as compared to that of the wild type. Time-resolved fluorescence and absorption spectroscopy was applied to explore the role of Y21 and W104 in AppA BLUF photochemistry. In the Y21 mutants, FADH*-W* radical pairs are transiently formed on a ps time scale and recombine to the ground state on a ns time scale. The W104F mutant shows a spectral evolution similar to that of wild type AppA but with an increased yield of signaling state formation. In the Y21F/W104F double mutant, all light-driven electron-transfer processes are abolished, and the FAD singlet excited-state evolves by intersystem crossing to the triplet state. Our results indicate that two competing light-driven electron-transfer pathways are available in BLUF domains: one productive pathway that involves electron transfer from the tyrosine, which leads to signaling state formation, and one nonproductive electron-transfer pathway from the tryptophan, which leads to deactivation and the effective lowering of the quantum yield of the signaling state formation. Our results are consistent with a photoactivation mechanism for BLUF domains where signaling state formation proceeds via light-driven electron and proton transfer from the conserved tyrosine to FAD, followed by a hydrogen-bond rearrangement and radical-pair recombination.     

The anomalous pKa of Tyr-9 in glutathione S-transferase A1-1 catalyzes product release

The pKa of the catalytic Tyr-9 in glutathione S-transferase (GST) A1-1 is lowered from 10.3 to approximately 8.1 in the apoenzyme and approximately 9.0 with a GSH conjugate bound at the active site. However, a clear functional role for the unusual Tyr-9 pKa has not been elucidated. GSTA1-1 also includes a dynamic C terminus that undergoes a ligand-dependent disorder-to-order transition. Previous studies suggest a functional link between Tyr-9 ionization and C-terminal dynamics. Here we directly probe the role of Tyr-9 ionization in ligand binding and C-terminal conformation. An engineered mutant of rGSTA1-1, W21F/F222W, which contains a single Trp at the C terminus, was used as a fluorescent reporter of pH-dependent C-terminal dynamics. This mutant exhibited a pH-dependent change in Trp-222 emission properties consistent with changes in C-terminal solvation or conformation. The apparent pKa values for the conformational transition were 7.9 +/- 0.1 and 9.3 +/- 0.1 for the apoenzyme and ligand-bound enzyme, respectively, in excellent agreement with the pKa for Tyr-9 in these states. The Y9F/W21F/F222W mutant, however, exhibited no such pH-dependent changes. Time-resolved fluorescence anisotropy studies revealed a ligand-dependent, Tyr-9-dependent, change in the order parameter of Trp-222. However, no pH dependence was observed. In equilibrium and pre-steady-state ligand binding studies, product conjugate had a decreased equilibrium binding affinity (KD), concomitant with increased binding and dissociation rates, at higher pH values. Furthermore, the recovered pKa values for the pH-dependent microscopic rate constants ranged from 7.7 to 8.4, also in agreement with the pKa of Tyr-9. In contrast, the Y9F/W21F/F222W mutant had no pH-dependent transition in KD or rate constants for ligand binding or dissociation. The combined results indicate that the macroscopic populations of "open" and "closed" states of the C terminus are not determined solely by the ionization state of Tyr-9. However, the rates of transition between these states are faster for the ionized Tyr-9. The ionized Tyr-9 states provide a parallel pathway for product dissociation, which is kinetically and thermodynamically favored. In silico kinetic models further support the functional role for the parallel dissociation pathway provided by ionized Tyr-9.     

On the use of advanced modelling techniques to investigate the conformational discrepancy between two X-ray structures of the AppA BLUF domain

The conformation of the blue light utilising flavin domain of the signalling protein AppA in the dark state is a matter of intensive research, both experimental and theoretical, and has not yet unambiguously been determined. Two contradicting X-ray structures of the dark state have been published previously. We aim at resolving this seeming contradiction by exploring conformational pathways between the two X-ray structures using advanced modelling techniques, such as local-elevation searching and sampling, soft-core non-bonded interactions and protocols of successively biasing the sampling of sets of torsional angles which adopt different values in the two alternative X-ray structures. The results suggest a high energetic barrier for a change in the Trp104 side chain from a ‘Trp-in’ to a ‘Trp-out’ conformation or vice versa, and illustrate the complexity to model conformational transitions involving a large number of degrees of freedom.