Tape transfer sectioning of tissue microarrays introduces nonspecific immunohistochemical staining artifacts

Abstract

Tissue microarrays place tens to hundreds of formalin fixed, paraffin embedded tissue cores into a paraffin block in a systematic grid pattern that permits their simultaneous evaluation in a single section. The fragmented nature of the tissue cores often makes sectioning of tissue microarrays difficult so that the resulting disks of tissue lose their shape, fracture or fall out of the paraffin section altogether. We have evaluated an alternative sectioning protocol for stabilizing the tissue microarray surface by placing an adhesive tape “window” over the face of the paraffin block prior to sectioning. Once sectioned, the tape/sections are transferred directly onto coated microscope slides, thereby avoiding routine floating of sections on a water bath. After sectioning with either the tape transfer or standard protocols, slides were stained either using hematoxylin and eosin or immunohistochemistry using antibodies to S-100 protein and the tissue specific antigens, keratin (AE1/3) and the leukocyte common antigen CD45. We found that the tape method produced thicker sections that were darker and more densely packed with loss of tissue definition compared to sections prepared using water bath flotation. Quantitative image analysis of immunohistochemical staining demonstrated that the tape method produced a higher incidence of nonspecific staining, which raised the potential for false positive staining.     

Reliable LC3 and p62 Autophagy Marker Detection in Formalin Fixed Paraffin Embedded Human Tissue by Immunohistochemistry

Autophagy assures cellular homeostasis, and gains increasing importance in cancer, where it impacts on carcinogenesis, propagation of the malignant phenotype and development of resistance. To date, its tissue-based analysis by immunohistochemistry remains poorly standardized. Here we show the feasibility of specifically and reliably assessing the autophagy markers LC3B and p62 (SQSTM1) in formalin fixed and paraffin embedded human tissue by immunohistochemistry. Preceding functional experiments consisted of depleting LC3B and p62 in H1299 lung cancer cells with subsequent induction of autophagy. Western blot and immunofluorescence validated antibody specificity, knockdown efficiency and autophagy induction prior to fixation in formalin and embedding in paraffin. LC3B and p62 antibodies were validated on formalin fixed and paraffin embedded cell pellets of treated and control cells and finally applied on a tissue microarray with 80 human malignant and nonneoplastic lung and stomach formalin fixed and paraffin embedded tissue samples. Dot-like staining of various degrees was observed in cell pellets and 18/40 (LC3B) and 22/40 (p62) tumors, respectively. Seventeen tumors were double positive for LC3B and p62. P62 displayed additional significant cytoplasmic and nuclear staining of unknown significance. Interobserver-agreement for grading of staining intensities and patterns was substantial to excellent (kappa values 0.60-0.83). In summary, we present a specific and reliable IHC staining of LC3B and p62 on formalin fixed and paraffin embedded human tissue. Our presented protocol is designed to aid reliable investigation of dysregulated autophagy in solid tumors and may be used on large tissue collectives.Key words: Immunohistochemistry, immunofluorescence, formalin fixed paraffin embedded tissue, LC3B, p62, cancer     

Immunohistochemical Double Staining of Microwave Enhanced and Nonenhanced Nuclear and Cytoplasmic Antigens

Many of the antigens commonly investigated in histopathology can be enhanced by microwave pretreatment (MWPT) of formalin fixed, paraffin embedded tissue sections. We developed a double labeling method using microwave heating to detect otherwise undetectable nuclear antigens combined.with immunohisto-chemistry (IHC) of cytoplasmic or membranous antigens that do not benefit from MWPT. We used the same primary antibody solutions used in single antibody IHC. The staining technique is based on the alkaline phosphatase anti-alkaline phosphatase (APAAP) and the labeled avidin-biotin (LSAB) methods. Four different protocols were tested, each modifying the sequence of MWPT, APAAP and LSAB staining. In this study Ki67, estrogen receptor, progesterone receptor, c-neu, CD68 and desmin primary antibodies were used in routinely formalin fixed, paraffin embedded tissues of 50 tumor specimens. MWPT followed by LSAB for microwave enhanced antigens and APAAP for antigens that cannot be enhanced by MWPT gave the best double staining results. This method improves characterization of tumor cell features from paraffin embedded tissue and should aid analysis of tumor differentiation, receptor status and nuclear proteins in the single cells in archival tissues.     

The specificity of interphase FISH translocation probes in formalin fixed paraffin embedded tissue sections is readily assessed using automated staining and scoring of tissue microarrays constructed from murine xenografts

Implementation of interphase fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) assays in the clinical laboratory requires validation against established methods. Validation tools in common use include exchange of consecutive sections with another institution that has already established the FISH assay, comparison with conventional banded metaphase cytogenetics, confirmation of specificity using probed normal metaphases, consecutive paraffin sections of a validation set tested by a reference laboratory, and specificity assessment against well characterized cell lines. We have investigated the feasibility of using tissue microarrays (TMA) constructed from murine xenografts as a preliminary specificity-screening tool for validation of interphase FISH assays. Cell lines currently in use for FISH controls are used to generate xenografts in SCID mice which are fixed in formalin and paraffin embedded. A TMA is constructed using duplicate donor cores from the xenograft blocks. Xenografts used represent a wide range of translocations used routinely for formalin fixed paraffin embedded sections evaluated by FISH. Probe cocktails (Abbott-Vysis), for several non-random translocations associated with hematologic neoplasms and soft tissue sarcomas have been used in this manner. On-line deparaffinization, cell conditioning, and prehybridization steps are automated using a staining workstation (Ventana Discovery XT); hybridization and stringency washes are performed manually offline. FISH-probed TMAs are tracked using a Metasystems image scanner and analyzed using classifiers specifically developed for each molecular abnormality. FISH results for each xenograft in the TMA correspond exactly to the genotype previously established for the parent cell line from which the xenograft was prepared. Moderate complexity tissue microarrays constructed from murine xenografts are excellent validation tools for initial assessment of interphase FISH probe specificity.     

Collagenase predigestion on paraffin sections enhances collagen immunohistochemical detection without distorting tissue morphology

Reliable immunohistochemical detection of collagen in formalin fixed, paraffin embedded tissues requires protease digestion. While these pan-proteases (pepsin, trypsin, protease K, etc.) enhance collagen detection, they also digest many other tissue proteins and produce poor cellular morphology and unrecognizable cellular structures. Balancing the conditions (protease type, concentration, incubation time and temperature) to digest some, but not all, proteins in a tissue section while optimizing collagen detection requires one to compromise improved collagen immunolabeling with adequate cellular morphology. Furthermore, optimal conditions for digesting tissue proteins to enhance collagen detection vary among tissue types and their fixation. Although brain is not typically subject to these deleterious consequences, structures such as epithelium, spermatids, stroma etc. and other tissues with complicated histology are profoundly affected. To resolve this technical dilemma, we discovered a novel use for collagenase to enhance collagen immunodetection without affecting the noncollagen proteins, thereby preserving tissue morphology. Collagenase, which is typically used in vitro for disassociation of cells, has never been used reliably on formalin fixed, paraffin embedded tissue sections. This new use of collagenase for immunohistochemistry promotes increased collagen immunolabeling, is easy to use, is versatile, and allows preservation of tissue structure that provides maximal and accurate histological information.     

Collagenase predigestion on paraffin sections enhances collagen immunohistochemical detection without distorting tissue morphology

Reliable immunohistochemical detection of collagen in formalin fixed, paraffin embedded tissues requires protease digestion. While these pan-proteases (pepsin, trypsin, protease K, etc.) enhance collagen detection, they also digest many other tissue proteins and produce poor cellular morphology and unrecognizable cellular structures. Balancing the conditions (protease type, concentration, incubation time and temperature) to digest some, but not all, proteins in a tissue section while optimizing collagen detection requires one to compromise improved collagen immunolabeling with adequate cellular morphology. Furthermore, optimal conditions for digesting tissue proteins to enhance collagen detection vary among tissue types and their fixation. Although brain is not typically subject to these deleterious consequences, structures such as epithelium, spermatids, stroma etc. and other tissues with complicated histology are profoundly affected. To resolve this technical dilemma, we discovered a novel use for collagenase to enhance collagen immunodetection without affecting the noncollagen proteins, thereby preserving tissue morphology. Collagenase, which is typically used in vitro for disassociation of cells, has never been used reliably on formalin fixed, paraffin embedded tissue sections. This new use of collagenase for immunohistochemistry promotes increased collagen immunolabeling, is easy to use, is versatile, and allows preservation of tissue structure that provides maximal and accurate histological information.     

Detergent addition to tryptic digests and ion mobility separation prior to MS/MS improves peptide yield and protein identification for in situ proteomic investigation of frozen and formalin‐fixed paraffin‐embedded adenocarcinoma tissue sections

The identification of proteins involved in tumour progression or which permit enhanced or novel therapeutic targeting is essential for cancer research. Direct MALDI analysis of tissue sections is rapidly demonstrating its potential for protein imaging and profiling in the investigation of a range of disease states including cancer. MALDI‐mass spectrometry imaging (MALDI‐MSI) has been used here for direct visualisation and in situ characterisation of proteins in breast tumour tissue section samples. Frozen MCF7 breast tumour xenograft and human formalin‐fixed paraffin‐embedded breast cancer tissue sections were used. An improved protocol for on‐tissue trypsin digestion is described incorporating the use of a detergent, which increases the yield of tryptic peptides for both fresh frozen and formalin‐fixed paraffin‐embedded tumour tissue sections. A novel approach combining MALDI‐MSI and ion mobility separation MALDI‐tandem mass spectrometry imaging for improving the detection of low‐abundance proteins that are difficult to detect by direct MALDI‐MSI analysis is described. In situ protein identification was carried out directly from the tissue section by MALDI‐MSI. Numerous protein signals were detected and some proteins including histone H3, H4 and Grp75 that were abundant in the tumour region were identified.     

PAXgene fixation enables comprehensive metabolomic and proteomic analyses of tissue specimens by MALDI MSI

An alcohol-based non-crosslinking tissue fixative, PAXgene Tissue System, has been proposed as alternative fixation method to formalin, providing superior and morphological preservation. To date, metabolites have not been assessed in PAXgene-fixed tissues. The study focuses on a comparison between PAXgene and standard formalin fixation for metabolomic analysis by MALDI mass spectrometry imaging. Therefore, fifty-six samples from seven mice organs were fixed with PAXgene (PFPE) or formalin (FFPE), embedded in paraffin, and processed to a tissue microarray. PAXgene was able to spatially preserve metabolites in organs achieving an overlap of common metabolites ranging from 34 to 78% with FFPE. Highly similar signal intensities and visualization of molecules demonstrated negligible differences for metabolite imaging on PFPE compared to FFPE tissues. In addition, we performed proteomic analysis of intact proteins and peptides derived from enzymatic digestion. An overlap of 33 to 58% was found between FFPE and PFPE tissue samples in peptide analysis with a higher number of PFPE-specific peaks. Analysis of intact proteins achieved an overlap in the range of 0 to 28% owing to the poor detectability of cross-linked proteins in formalin-fixed tissues. Furthermore, metabolite and peptide profiles obtained from PFPE tissues were able to correctly classify organs independent of the fixation method, whereas a distinction of organs by protein profiles was only achieved by PAXgene fixation. Finally, we applied MALDI MSI to human biopsies by sequentially analyzing metabolites and peptides within the same tissue section. Concerning prospective studies, PAXgene can be used as an alternative fixative for multi-omic tissue analysis.     

A focus on fixation

Three fixation issues related to immunostaining are discussed here: 1) Generally, a tissue block is fixed, then embedded and sectioned (pre-fixation). The type of fixative applied, crosslinking or coagulating, has an impact on selecting an epitope retrieval method. Individual antigens have a fixation-retrieval characteristic. 2) A long fixation time, especially with crosslinking fixatives, may compromise the result of immunostaining. This negative effect varies among different antigens and can be partially restored by applying a more sensitive/efficient detection system such as tyramide amplification. 3) Sections cut from a fresh frozen tissue block usually are acetone fixed (post-fixation). This was accepted as the “gold standard” for a long time. Post-fixation, however, may have serious consequences for preservation of small peptides leaking from the cut open cells, whereas this is not the case with pre-fixed intact cells. Consequently, the concept of an acetone post-fixed cryostat tissue section as “gold standard” no longer exists and a more appropriate use of the terms immunohistochemistry and immunocytochemistry therefore seems justified. For many antibodies, it is not known whether a formalin fixed, paraffin embedded tissue specimen is appropriate. Suggestions are made for creating a positive control cell block for testing such antibodies.     

Automatic quantification of immunohistochemically stained cell nuclei based on standard reference cells.

A fully automatic method for quantification of images of immunohistochemically stained cell nuclei by computing area proportions, is presented. Agarose embedded cultured fibroblasts were fixed, paraffin embedded and sectioned at 4 microm. They were then stained together with 4 microm sections of the test specimen obtained from bladder cancer material. A colour based classifier is automatically computed from the control cells. The method was tested on formalin fixed paraffin embedded tissue section material, stained with monoclonal antibodies against the Ki67 antigen and cyclin A protein. Ki67 staining results in a detailed nuclear texture with pronounced nucleoli and cyclin A staining is obtained in a more homogeneously distributed pattern. However, different staining patterns did not seem to influence labelling index quantification, and the sensitivity to variations in light conditions and choice of areas within the control population was low. Thus, the technique represents a robust and reproducible quantification method. In tests measuring proportions of stained area an average standard deviation of about 1.5% for the same field was achieved when classified with classifiers created from different control samples.     

Application of cryo-compatible antibodies to human placenta paraffin sections

The hepes-glutamic acid buffer-mediated organic solvent protection effect (HOPE) -fixation and paraffin embedding technique has been described to expand possibilities for immuno-labellings due to low denaturation of proteins. In this study, the issue was addressed as to whether the HOPE technique could be a useful tool in placenta tissue-based studies when only cryo-compatible antibodies are available. Such antibodies can be used on cryostat sections only, giving results of considerably inferior morphological detail as compared to routinely fixed paraffin embedded tissue sections. Commercially available, only cryo-compatible, monoclonal antibodies against a conformational epitope of HLA-G (clone MEM-G/9) and leukocyte differentiation antigens CD56, CD163 and CD34 III were selected and applied to frozen sections, routinely formalin-fixed and HOPE-fixed paraffin sections. All tested antibodies immunolocalized their antigen on cryo sections and on HOPE-fixed but not formalin-fixed paraffin sections. The HOPE technique provides an excellent preservation of protein antigenicity together with well presented morphological details in paraffin embedded placenta tissues. The detection of native or conformation-dependent epitopes in paraffin sections expands the immunolocalization possibilities in placenta research and reproductive immunology.     

Isolation of high quality protein samples from punches of formalin fixed and paraffin embedded tissue blocks

In general, it is believed that the extraction of proteins from formalin-fixed paraffin embedded samples is not feasible. However, recently a new technique was developed, presenting the extraction of non-degraded, full length proteins from formalin fixed tissues, usable for western blotting and protein arrays. In the study presented here, we applied this technique to punch biopsies of formalin fixed tissues embedded in paraffin to reduce heterogeneity of the tissue represented in sections, and to ensure analysing mainly defined cellular material. Successful extraction was achieved even from very small samples (0.7 mm(3)). Additionally, we were able to detect highly glycosylated proteins and protein modification, such as phosphorylation. Interestingly, with this technique it is feasible to extract high quality proteins from 14 year old samples. In summary, the new technique makes a great pool of material now usable for molecular analysis with high throughput tools.     

A focus on fixation

Three fixation issues related to immunostaining are discussed here: 1) Generally, a tissue block is fixed, then embedded and sectioned (pre-fixation). The type of fixative applied, crosslinking or coagulating, has an impact on selecting an epitope retrieval method. Individual antigens have a fixation–retrieval characteristic. 2) A long fixation time, especially with crosslinking fixatives, may compromise the result of immunostaining. This negative effect varies among different antigens and can be partially restored by applying a more sensitive/efficient detection system such as tyramide amplification. 3) Sections cut from a fresh frozen tissue block usually are acetone fixed (post-fixation). This was accepted as the “gold standard” for a long time. Post-fixation, however, may have serious consequences for preservation of small peptides leaking from the cut open cells, whereas this is not the case with pre-fixed intact cells. Consequently, the concept of an acetone post-fixed cryostat tissue section as “gold standard” no longer exists and a more appropriate use of the terms immunohistochemistry and immunocytochemistry therefore seems justified. For many antibodies, it is not known whether a formalin fixed, paraffin embedded tissue specimen is appropriate. Suggestions are made for creating a positive control cell block for testing such antibodies.     

Generation of high‐quality protein extracts from formalin‐fixed,paraffin‐embedded tissues

A wealth of information on proteins involved in many aspects of disease is encased within formalin‐fixed paraffin‐embedded (FFPE) tissue repositories stored in hospitals worldwide. Recently, access to this “hidden treasure” is being actively pursued by the application of two main extraction strategies: digestion of the entangled protein matrix with generation of tryptic peptides, or decrosslinking and extraction of full‐length proteins. Here, we describe an optimised method for extraction of full‐length proteins from FFPE tissues. This method builds on the classical “antigen retrieval” technique used for immunohistochemistry, and allows generation of protein extracts with elevated and reproducible yields. In model animal tissues, average yields of 16.3 μg and 86.8 μg of proteins were obtained per 80 mm² tissue slice of formalin‐fixed paraffin‐embedded skeletal muscle and liver, respectively. Protein extracts generated with this method can be used for the reproducible investigation of the proteome with a wide array of techniques. The results obtained by SDS‐PAGE, western immunoblotting, protein arrays, ELISA, and, most importantly, nanoHPLC‐nanoESI‐Q‐TOF MS of FFPE proteins resolved by SDS‐PAGE, are presented and discussed. An evaluation of the extent of modifications introduced on proteins by formalin fixation and crosslink reversal, and their impact on quality of MS results, is also reported.     

Molecular mechanisms of antigen retrieval: antigen retrieval reverses steric interference caused by formalin-induced cross-links

Abstract

The overwhelming majority of antibodies useful for formalin fixed, paraffin embedded (FFPE) tissues require antigen retrieval to reverse the effect of formalin fixation and re-establish immunoreactivity. How this reversal happens is poorly understood. We developed a new experimental model for studying the mechanism of formalin fixation and antigen retrieval. Epitope mapping studies on nine antibodies useful for FFPE tissues revealed that each consisted of a contiguous stretch of amino acids in the native protein (linear epitope). Small peptides representing the epitopes of antibodies to human epidermal growth factor receptor type (HER2), estrogen, and progesterone receptors were attached covalently to glass microscope slides in a peptide array. Most peptides retained immunoreactivity after formalin fixation. Immunoreactivity was completely abrogated for all peptides, however, if an irrelevant large protein was present during formalin-induced cross-linking. We hypothesize that cross-linking the irrelevant protein to the peptide epitopes sterically blocked antibodies from binding. Antigen retrieval dissociates irrelevant proteins and restores immunoreactivity. Because the epitopes for clinical antibodies require only primary protein structure, the fact that antigen retrieval probably denatures the secondary and tertiary structure of the protein is irrelevant. The same mechanism may occur in tissue samples subjected to formalin fixation and antigen retrieval.     

Development of an optimal antigen retrieval protocol for immunohistochemistry of retinoblastoma protein (pRB) in formalin fixed, paraffin sections based on comparison of different methods

A novel protocol for antigen retrieval (AR) for immunohistochemistry (IHC) of retinoblastoma protein (pRB) in formalin fixed, paraffin embedded (FFPE) tissue sections was developed using 0.05% citraconic anhydride as the AR solution for heat treatment based on comparison of different methods. This new protocol has advantages including superior morphological preservation, greater reproducibility, and more intense staining after retrieval. Our study demonstrates the importance of comparing various AR protocols to obtain maximal IHC for standardization and for quantitative IHC.     

Development of an optimal antigen retrieval protocol for immunohistochemistry of retinoblastoma protein (pRB) in formalin fixed,paraffin sections based on comparison of different methods

A novel protocol for antigen retrieval (AR) for immunohistochemistry (IHC) of retinoblastoma protein (pRB) in formalin fixed, paraffin embedded (FFPE) tissue sections was developed using 0.05% citraconic anhydride as the AR solution for heat treatment based on comparison of different methods. This new protocol has advantages including superior morphological preservation, greater reproducibility, and more intense staining after retrieval. Our study demonstrates the importance of comparing various AR protocols to obtain maximal IHC for standardization and for quantitative IHC.     

三种不同方法固定的石蜡切片中RNA的分析

研究在 10 %中性福尔马林、丙酮、甲醇 氯仿 冰醋酸 3种方法固定的石蜡切片中提取RNA的质量和数量 .取 2 5 0g体重的Wistar大鼠的肾脏 ,分别采用 10 %中性福尔马林、丙酮、甲醇 氯仿 冰醋酸 3种方法固定 ,石蜡包埋 ,H E染色 ;采用RNA裂解液、TRIZOL试剂 2种方法提取切片RNA ,逆转录为cDNA ,采用普通PCR和SYBRGREEN 1定量PCR分析RNA质量和数量 .结果表明 ,3种固定方法都可保持组织良好的结构和形态 ;采用 2种提取方法 ,均可经RT PCR扩增出 180bp大鼠磷酸甘油醛脱氢酶 (G3PDH)、5 6 5bpβ肌动蛋白 (β actin)、10 0bp纤溶酶系活化剂抑制物 1(PAI 1) ;但采用RNA裂解液时 ,比TRIZOL试剂可提取更多的RNA .     

Application of microwave irradiation to immunohistochemistry: preservation of antigens of the extracellular matrix

Microwave irradiation as a means of fixation was evaluated for the preservation of extracellular matrix antigens such as collagen III, IV, fibronectin and laminin in both lung and liver specimens. Small tissue samples were placed in normal saline or periodate-lysine-paraformaldehyde (PLP) and irradiated for 30 sec to bring them to a temperature of 50 C. The tissue was then processed rapidly in a tissue processor adjusted to a 2 hr cycle and embedded in paraffin. Sections were immunostained. For comparison, routine cryostat sections as well as sections of formalin fixed tissue were used. Microwave irradiation in saline gave excellent morphological detail, comparable to that in formalin fixed tissue. All four antigens evaluated were well preserved without the necessity of prior pepsin digestion. Microwave fixation is promising for preservation of antigenicity and morphological detail, and considerably reduces the time required for processing.     

Application of Microwave Irradiation to Immunohistochemistry: Preservation of Antigens of the Extracellular Matrix

Microwave irradiation as a means of fixation was evaluated for the preservation of extracellular matrix antigens such as collagen III, IV, fibronectin and laminin in both lung and liver specimens. Small tissue samples were placed in normal saline or periodatelysine-paraformaldehyde (PLP) and irradiated for 30 sec to bring them to a temperature of 50 C. The tissue was then processed rapidly in a tissue processor adjusted to a 2 hr cycle and embedded in paraffin. Sections were immunostained. For comparison, routine cryostat sections as well as sections of formalin fixed tissue were used. Microwave irradiation in saline gave excellent morphological detail, comparable to that in formalin fixed tissue. All four antigens evaluated were well preserved without the necessity of prior pepsin digestion. Microwave fixation is promising for preservation of antigenicity and morphological detail, and considerably reduces the time required for processing.