Fate and function of anti-CD3/CD28-activated T cells following adoptive transfer: IL-2 promotes development of anti-tumor memory T cells in vivo

BACKGROUND: Adoptive immunotherapy with T cells activated through CD3 alone requires exogenous IL-2 for T-cell function and survival after transfer, but the in vivo cytokine requirement of T cells activated through CD3 and CD28 is unknown. We hypothesized that CD3/CD28-activated T cells, unlike those activated through CD3 alone, might develop into long-lived memory T cells, either with or without systemic IL-2. METHODS: We used MHC class I-restricted TCR transgenic T cells from the OT-1 mouse, specific for the surrogate tumor Ag ovalbumin (OVA), to assess the trafficking kinetics, antigenic responsiveness and anti-tumor efficacy of dual-activated T cells in vivo as a function of IL-2 administration. At days 7, 14, and 28 after transfer, lymph node cells and splenocytes were examined for donor cell persistence and antigenic responsiveness by FACS and ELISA, respectively. RESULTS: In IL-2-treated mice, donor CD8+ T cells persisted and developed a memory phenotype, based on CD44 and Ly6c expression at day 28, while mice given no IL-2 had fewer donor cells at all time points. OVA-specific release of IFN-gamma was higher from lymphocytes of IL-2-treated mice compared with no-IL-2 mice (P<0.02 at all time points). In mice challenged with an OVA-bearing subline of the AML leukemia model C1498, IL-2 did not confer added protection from tumor challenge at 1 or 2 weeks after adoptive transfer, but gave improved survival at 4 weeks post-transfer. DISCUSSION: We conclude that exogenous IL-2 is not required for anti-tumor activity of CD3/CD28-activated CD8+ cells early after adoptive transfer, but promotes T-cell persistence that confers disease protection at more remote times.     

Unique ability of activated CD4+ T cells but not rested effectors to migrate to non-lymphoid sites in the absence of inflammation

Recent studies suggest that effector T cells generated by immune responses migrate to multiple non-lymphoid sites, even those without apparent expression of antigen or inflammation. To investigate the ability of distinct CD4(+) T lymphocyte subsets to enter and persist in non-lymphoid, noninflamed compartments, we examined the migration and persistence of na?ve, effector, and rested effector CD4(+) T cells generated in vitro following transfer to nonimmunized adoptive hosts. Th1 and Th2 effectors migrated to both lymphoid and non-lymphoid organs (peritoneum, fat pads, and lung). In contrast, rested effectors and na?ve cells migrated only to lymphoid areas. Adhesion molecule expression, but not chemokine receptor expression, correlated with the ability to enter non-lymphoid sites. Donor cells persisted longer in lymphoid than in non-lymphoid sites. When hosts with na?ve and memory donor cells were challenged with antigen, effectors developed in situ, which also migrated to non-lymphoid sites. Memory cells showed an accelerated shift to non-lymphoid migration, in keeping with memory effector formation. These results suggest that only recently activated effector T cells can disperse to non-lymphoid sites in the absence of antigen and inflammation, and as effectors return to rest, they lose this ability. These data also argue that memory cells in lymphoid sites are longer lived and not in equilibrium with those in non-lymphoid sites.     

Divergent generation of heterogeneous memory CD4 T cells

Mechanisms for the generation of memory CD4 T cells and their delineation into diverse subsets remain largely unknown. In this study, we demonstrate in two Ag systems, divergent generation of heterogeneous memory CD4 T cells from activated precursors in distinct differentiation stages. Specifically, we show that influenza hemagglutinin- and OVA-specific CD4 T cells activated for 1, 2, and 3 days, respectively, exhibit gradations of differentiation by cell surface phenotype, IFN-gamma production, and proliferation, yet all serve as direct precursors for functional memory CD4 T cells when transferred in vivo into Ag-free mouse hosts. Using a conversion assay to track the immediate fate of activated precursors in vivo, we show that day 1- to 3-activated cells all rapidly convert from an activated phenotype (CD25(high)IL-7R(low)CD44(high)) to a resting memory phenotype (IL-7R(high)CD25(low)CD44(high)) 1 day after antigenic withdrawal. Paradoxically, stable memory subset delineation from undifferentiated (day 1- to 2-activated) precursors was predominantly an effector memory (CD62L(low)) profile, with an increased proportion of central memory (CD62L(high)) T cells arising from more differentiated (day 3-activated) precursors. Our findings support a divergent model for generation of memory CD4 T cells directly from activated precursors in multiple differentiation states, with subset heterogeneity maximized by increased activation and differentiation during priming.     

Persistence, immune specificity, and functional ability of murine mutant ras epitope-specific CD4(+) and CD8(+) T lymphocytes following in vivo adoptive transfer.

Adoptive T-cell transfer has been shown to be a potentially effective strategy for cellular immunotherapy in some murine models of disease. However, several issues remain unresolved regarding some of the basic features involved in effective adoptive transfer, such as the influence of specific peptide antigen (Ag) boost after T-cell transfer, the addition of IL-2 post-T-cell transfer, the trafficking of transferred T cells to lymphoid and nonlymphoid tissues, and the functional stability of recoverable CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells. We investigated several of these parameters, particularly as they relate to the persistence and maintenance of effector functions of murine CD4(+) and/or CD8(+) T lymphocytes after adoptive cellular transfer into partially gamma-irradiated syngeneic hosts. Our laboratory previously identified murine (H-2(d)) immunogenic CD4(+) and CD8(+) T-cell peptide epitopes reflecting codon 12 ras mutations as tumor-specific Ag. Therefore, the model system chosen here employed epitope-specific MHC class II-restricted CD4(+) T cells and MHC class I-restricted CD8(+) T cells produced from previously immunized BALB/c mice. Between 2 and 7 days after T-cell transfer, recipient mice received various combinations of peptide boosts and/or IL-2 treatments. At different times after the T-cell transfer, spleen and lung tissues were analyzed phenotypically to monitor the persistence of the immune T cells and functionally (via proliferation or cytotoxicity assays) to assess the maintenance of peptide specificity. The results showed that immune donor T lymphocytes (uncultured immune T cells or cloned T cells) were recoverable from the spleens and lungs of recipient mice after transfer. The recovery of Ag-specific T-cell responses was greatest from recipient mice that received peptide boosts and IL-2 treatment. However, mice that received a peptide boost without IL-2 treatment responded nearly as well, which suggested that including a peptide boost after T-cell transfer was more obligatory than exogenous IL-2 treatment to sustain adoptively transferred T cells in vivo. Ag-specific T-cell responses were weak in mice that either received IL-2 alone or did not receive the cognate peptide boost after T-cell transfer. The T-cell clones were also monitored by flow cytometry or RT-PCR based on expression of the T-cell receptor Vbeta-chain, which was previously characterized. Ag-specific T cells were recovered from both spleens and lungs of recipient mice, demonstrating that the T-cell clones could localize to both lymphoid and nonlymphoid tissues. This study demonstrates that both uncultured and in vitro-cloned T lymphocytes can migrate to lymphoid tissues and nonlymphoid (e.g., lung) tissues in recipient hosts and that their functional activities can be maintained at these sites after transfer, if they are exposed to peptide Ag in vivo.     

Helper T cells, dendritic cells and CTL Immunity

In this review, we examine the emerging view that all CTL responses depend on CD4 T-cell help for the generation of efficient memory. We further review the evidence that CD4 and CD8 T cells must recognize antigen on the same dendritic cell, and examine why this corecognition is required. Earlier studies have suggested that CD4 T cells must activate the dendritic cell via CD40 to license it for the capacity to prime CTL immunity. More recently, however, CD40 signalling of the CTL has been reported. Here, we argue that the main reason for corecognition of antigen on the dendritic cell may be related to the time taken to activate and release CD4 and CD8 T cells from their priming dendritic cell. CD4 T cells may only be capable of activating one dendritic cell during the period that CD8 T cells are primed. In this case, corecognition of this same dendritic cell would be essential.     

Simian immunodeficiency virus infection in neonatal macaques

Children with human immunodeficiency virus infection often have higher viral loads and progress to AIDS more rapidly than adults. Since the intestinal tract is a major site of early viral replication and CD4(+) T-cell depletion in adults, we examined the effects of simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) on both peripheral and intestinal lymphocytes from 13 neonatal macaques infected with SIVmac239. Normal neonates had more CD4(+) T cells and fewer CD8(+) T cells in all tissues than adults. Surprisingly, neonates had substantial percentages of CD4(+) T cells with an activated, memory phenotype (effector CD4(+) T cells) in the lamina propria of the intestine compared to peripheral lymphoid tissues, even when examined on the day of birth. Moreover, profound and selective depletion of jejunum lamina propria CD4(+) T cells occurred in neonatal macaques within 21 days of infection, which was preceded by large numbers of SIV-infected cells in this compartment. Furthermore, neonates with less CD4(+) T-cell depletion in tissues tended to have higher viral loads. The persistence of intestinal lamina propria CD4(+) T cells in some neonates with high viral loads suggests that increased turnover and/or resistance to CD4(+) T-cell loss may contribute to the higher viral loads and increased severity of disease in neonatal hosts.     

Failure of CD4 T-cells to respond to liver-derived antigen and to provide help to CD8 T-cells

CD4 T-cell help is required for the induction of efficient CD8 T-cells responses and the generation of memory cells. Lack of CD4 T-cell help may contribute to an exhausted CD8 phenotype and viral persistence. Little is known about priming of CD4 T-cells by liver-derived antigen. We used TF-OVA mice expressing ovalbumin in hepatocytes to investigate CD4 T-cell priming by liver-derived antigen and the impact of CD4 T-cell help on CD8 T-cell function. Naïve and effector CD4 T-cells specific for ovalbumin were transferred into TF-OVA mice alone or together with naïve ovalbumin-specific CD8 T-cells. T-cell activation and function were analyzed. CD4 T-cells ignored antigen presented by liver antigen-presenting cells (APCs) in vitro and in vivo but were primed in the liver-draining lymph node and the spleen. No priming occurred in the absence of bone-marrow derived APCs capable of presenting ovalbumin in vivo. CD4 T-cells primed in TF-OVA mice displayed defective Th1-effector function and caused no liver damage. CD4 T-cells were not required for the induction of hepatitis by CD8 T-cells. Th1-effector but not naïve CD4 T-cells augmented the severity of liver injury caused by CD8 T-cells. Our data demonstrate that CD4 T-cells fail to respond to liver-derived antigen presented by liver APCs and develop defective effector function after priming in lymph nodes and spleen. The lack of CD4 T-cell help may be responsible for insufficient CD8 T-cell function against hepatic antigens.     

Bone marrow precursor cells from aged mice generate CD4 T cells that function well in primary and memory responses

Understanding how aging impacts the function of memory CD4 T cells is critical for designing effective vaccines. Our studies show that immunological memory generated during youth functions well into old age, whereas that generated later in life functions poorly. This is the result of declines in the function of naive CD4 T cells from aged individuals and contributes to reduced efficacy of vaccines in the elderly. To begin to identify the cause of this defect, we examined the function of memory T cells generated from bone marrow precursor cells (BMPC) from young or aged mice in young hosts. In two different models, memory cells derived from young and aged BMPC exhibit good ex vivo and in vivo function. Importantly, memory CD4 T cells generated from aged BMPC exhibit potent cognate helper function for humoral responses, which are critical for effective immunization. These results indicate that there are no apparent age-related intrinsic defects in BMPC with regards to generation of functional memory T cells.     

Effector CD4 T cells are biochemically distinct from the memory subset: evidence for long-term persistence of effectors in vivo.

Memory T cell responses are believed to be mediated by long-lived memory T cells that arise directly from a subset of short-lived, activated effector T cells that have reverted to the resting state. Although widely accepted, definitive proof that memory T cells arise from effectors is lacking because of the inability to reliably distinguish these subsets based on known phenotypic or functional parameters. We have used a biochemical approach to distinguish effector and memory CD4 T cell subsets and follow the differentiative fate of effector cells in vivo. When examined biochemically, effector and memory CD4 T cells are strikingly distinct and exhibit qualitative and quantitative differences in tyrosine phosphorylation. These effector-specific patterns were identical in effectors derived either from naive CD4 T cells (primary effectors) or memory CD4 T cells (memory effectors). To monitor the fate of effector cells in vivo, Ag-activated CD4+ TCR-transgenic T cells were transferred into irradiated BALB/c mice. These TCR-transgenic CD4 T cells persisted in adoptive hosts for several months, gave a recall response to Ag, yet exhibited effector-specific biochemical profiles. These results suggest that a subset of effector CD4 T cells can persist in vivo and contribute to long-term immunity by mediating secondary immune responses.     

Naive, effector, and memory CD8 T cells in protection against pulmonary influenza virus infection: homing properties rather than initial frequencies are crucial.

The goal of adoptive immunotherapy is to target a high number of persisting effector cells to the site of a virus infection or tumor. In this study, we compared the protective value of hemagglutinin peptide-specific CD8 T cells generated from the clone-4 TCR-transgenic mice, defined by different stages of their differentiation, against lethal pulmonary influenza infection. We show that the adoptive transfer of high numbers of Ag-specific unprimed, naive CD8 T cells failed to clear the pulmonary virus titer and to promote host survival. The same numbers of in vitro generated primary Ag-specific Tc1 effector cells, producing high amounts of IFN-gamma, or resting Tc1 memory cells, generated from these effectors, were protective. Highly activated CD62Llow Tc1 effectors accumulated in the lung with rapid kinetics and most efficiently reduced the pulmonary viral titer early during infection. The resting CD62Lhigh naive and memory populations first increased in cell numbers in the draining lymph nodes. Subsequently, memory cells accumulated more rapidly and to a greater extent in the lung lavage as compared with naive cells. Thus, effector cells are most effective against a localized virus infection, which correlates with their ability to rapidly distribute at the infected tissue site. The finding that similar numbers of naive Ag-specific CD8 T cells are not protective supports the view that qualitative differences between the two resting populations, the naive and the memory population, may play a major role in their protective value against disease.     

Activated mouse T cells downregulate, process and present their surface TCR to cognate anti-idiotypic CD4+ T cells

The ability of activated T cells to present foreign antigens through the MHC class II pathway has been shown in the case of human, rat and mouse T cells. In the present study, the ability of activated T cells to present their endogenous TCR in association with MHC class II molecules to CD4+ T cells was shown. Upon activation mouse T cells downregulate their surface TCR, which are degraded into peptides in endosomal/lysosomal compartments. The idiopeptides (peptides derived from the variable region of the TCR) are presented to cognate anti-idiotypic CD4+ T cells, resulting in activation and proliferation of these cells. Interaction of idiotypic and anti-idiotypic T cells brought about by presentation of TCR idiopeptide may have important implications for T-cell vaccination and perpetuation of T-cell memory not requiring persisting antigen or long-lived memory cells.     

Overnight Resting of PBMC Changes Functional Signatures of Antigen Specific T- Cell Responses: Impact for Immune Monitoring within Clinical Trials

Polyfunctional CD4 or CD8 T cells are proposed to represent a correlate of immune control for persistent viruses as well as for vaccine mediated protection against infection. A well-suited methodology to study complex functional phenotypes of antiviral T cells is the combined staining of intracellular cytokines and phenotypic marker expression using polychromatic flow cytometry. In this study we analyzed the effect of an overnight resting period at 37°C on the quantity and functionality of HIV-1, EBV, CMV, HBV and HCV specific CD4 and CD8 T-cell responses in a cohort of 21 individuals. We quantified total antigen specific T cells by multimer staining and used 10-color intracellular cytokine staining (ICS) to determine IFNγ, TNFα, IL2 and MIP1β production. After an overnight resting significantly higher numbers of functionally active T cells were detectable by ICS for all tested antigen specificities, whereas the total number of antigen specific T cells determined by multimer staining remained unchanged. Overnight resting shifted the quality of T-cell responses towards polyfunctionality and increased antigen sensitivity of T cells. Our data suggest that the observed effect is mediated by T cells rather than by antigen presenting cells. We conclude that overnight resting of PBMC prior to ex vivo analysis of antiviral T-cell responses represents an efficient method to increase sensitivity of ICS-based methods and has a prominent impact on the functional phenotype of T cells.     

Adaptive immune responses during Shigella dysenteriae type 1 infection: an in vitro stimulation with 57 kDa major antigenic OMP in the presence of anti-CD3 antibody

An effort was made to understand the role of the 57 kDa major antigenic fraction of Shigella outer membrane protein (OMP) in the presence of T-cell antigen receptor in activation of adaptive immune responses of the cell mediated immune (CMI) restored patients. The expression of HLA-DR/CD4 out of CD3⁺ T-cells was significantly dominant over the HLA-DR/CD8 and comparable to unstimulated cells of infected or healthy controls. CD4⁺ T-cell activation together with HLA-DR is associated with the expression of CD25⁺ (IL2Rα) for IL-2 growth factors with decreased IL-4 levels, required for maintaining the homeostasis of CD4⁺ T cell. Furthermore, the positive expression of the CD45 antigen is possibly required for acquiring the memory for CD4⁺ cells signals and facilitates the interaction with CD54 antigen. As a result, antigen-specific secondary signal is generated for B-cell activation to produce IgG2a and IgG2b. This suggests that antibody mediated-adaptive immune responses are generated due to anti-CD3 induced helper T-cell activity. The above mentioned findings reflect that the antigen alone might not exacerbate the selective T-cell responses. But these antigens in the presence of anti-CD3 antibody might help to elicit adaptive immune response via T-cell receptor (TCR) activation.     

Modeling HIV Infection of CD4 T-cell Subpopulations

We develop and analyze a set of models for the interaction of HIV with CD4⁺ T cells. We consider three major subpopulations of T cells: virgin, activated and memory. In our first model we assume that HIV can infect activated cells but not resting cells. We then generalize the model to take into account recent reports that HIV can enter resting cells but that such entry does not lead to the production of completely reverse transcribed copies of the vital genome or integration of the DNA copy into the host cell's genome unless cell activation occurs. Our models show that T-cell memory is greatly reduced by HIV infection and that T-cell depletion may be due to the direct killing of peripheral T cells and T-cell precursors in the thymus.     

Qualitative changes accompany memory T cell generation: faster, more effective responses at lower doses of antigen

The generation of memory T cells is critically important for rapid clearance and neutralization of pathogens encountered previously by the immune system. We have studied the kinetics of response and Ag dose requirements for proliferation and cytokine secretion of CD4+ memory T cells to examine whether there are qualitative changes which might lead to improved immunity. TCR Tg CD4+ T cells were primed in vitro and transferred into T cell-deficient hosts. After 6 or more weeks, the persisting T cells were exclusively small resting cells with a memory phenotype: CD44high CD62L+/- CD25-. Memory CD4 T cells showed a similar pattern of response as naive cells to peptide analogues with similar Ag dose requirements for IL-2 secretion. However, memory cells (derived from both Th2 and Th1 effectors) displayed faster kinetics of cytokine secretion, cell division, and proliferation, enhanced proliferation in response to low doses of Ag or peptide analogues, and production of IL-4, IL-5, and IFN-gamma. These results suggest there is a much more efficient response of CD4 memory T cells to Ag re-exposure and that the expanded functional capacity of memory cells will promote a rapid development of effector functions, providing more rapid and effective immunity.     

Persistent antigen presentation after acute vesicular stomatitis virus infection

Long-term antigen expression is believed to play an important role in modulation of T-cell responses to chronic virus infections. However, recent studies suggest that immune responses may occur late after apparently acute infections. We have now analyzed the CD8 T-cell response to vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), which is thought to cause to an infection characterized by rapid virus clearance by innate and adaptive immune system components. Unexpectedly, virus-encoded antigen was detectable more than 6 weeks after intranasal VSV infection in both draining and nondraining lymph nodes by adoptively transferred CD8 T cells. Infection with Listeria monocytogenes expressing the same antigen did not result in prolonged antigen presentation. Weeks after VSV infection, discrete T-cell clustering with dendritic cells within the lymph node was observed after transfer of antigen-specific CD8 T cells. Moreover, memory CD8 T cells as defined by phenotype and function were generated from na?ve CD8 T cells entering the response late after infection. These findings suggested that protracted antigen presentation after an apparently acute virus infection may contribute to an ongoing antiviral immune response.     

Dynamic Functional Modulation of CD4+ T Cell Recall Responses Is Dependent on the Inflammatory Environment of the Secondary Stimulus

The parameters that modulate the functional capacity of secondary Th1 effector cells are poorly understood. In this study, we employ a serial adoptive transfer model system to show that the functional differentiation and secondary memory potential of secondary CD4⁺ effector T cells are dependent on the inflammatory environment of the secondary challenge. Adoptive transfer of TCR transgenic lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) Glycoprotein-specific SMARTA memory cells into LCMV-immune hosts, followed by secondary challenge with Listeria monocytogenes recombinantly expressing a portion of the LCMV Glycoprotein (Lm-gp61), resulted in the rapid emergence of SMARTA secondary effector cells with heightened functional avidity (as measured by their ability to make IFNγ in response to ex vivo restimulation with decreasing concentrations of peptide), limited contraction after pathogen clearance and stable maintenance secondary memory T cell populations. In contrast, transfer of SMARTA memory cells into naïve hosts prior to secondary Lm-gp61 challenge, which resulted in a more extended infectious period, resulted in poor functional avidity, increased death during the contraction phase and poor maintenance of secondary memory T cell populations. The modulation of functional avidity during the secondary Th1 response was independent of differences in antigen load or persistence. Instead, the inflammatory environment strongly influenced the function of the secondary Th1 response, as inhibition of IL-12 or IFN-I activity respectively reduced or increased the functional avidity of secondary SMARTA effector cells following rechallenge in a naïve secondary hosts. Our findings demonstrate that secondary effector T cells exhibit inflammation-dependent differences in functional avidity and memory potential, and have direct bearing on the design of strategies aimed at boosting memory T cell responses.     

Dys-regulation of effector CD4+ T cell function by the V3 domain of the HIV-1 gp120 during antigen presentation.

It was recently demonstrated that the semiconserved domain of the V3 region of the HIV-1 surface glycoprotein gp120 can induce an activation-apoptosis phenomenon to memory CD4+ cells from healthy individuals. Studying the effects of V3 on the interaction of antigen presentation between monocyte-derived macrophages and resting memory CD4+ T cells, we observed that V3 affects both cell populations. Macrophages exposed to composite liposomes containing V3 on the surface and tetanus toxoid (TT) as the recall antigen entrapped in the aqueous phase (lipoV3/TT liposomes) were able to activate CD4+ T cells during primary stimulation, but not after restimulation nine days later. Unstimulated macrophages or macrophages exposed to soluble TT responded to second stimuli, lipoV3/TT liposomes, and soluble TT in activating CD4+ T cells. Soluble TT-activated CD4+ T cells could be restimulated by soluble TT but not by lipoV3/TT liposomes, whereas lipoV3/TT liposome-activated CD4+ T cells became unresponsive to a second stimulus. These results show that resting memory CD4+ cells activated by macrophages presenting the recall antigen together with V3 become unresponsive to restimulation.     

Withdrawal of stimulation may initiate the transition of effector to memory CD4 cells.

The initial steps that determine development of memory in CD4 cells are unknown. To distinguish an intrinsic capacity of effectors to become memory cells from contributions of as yet undefined survival factors, we analyzed the effects of withdrawal of signals via TCR, costimulation, and cytokines from Th1 or Th2 primary effectors induced in vitro from TCR-transgenic CD4 cells. Withdrawal of stimulation caused the transition of effectors to resting populations with a memory phenotype that did not undergo division following transfer to normal syngeneic recipients. The return of effectors to rest was accompanied by acquisition of the capacity to function as memory cells in vivo as defined by extended persistence and a more rapid response to Ag in vivo than naive cells in adoptive hosts. Upon challenge with Ag, these in vitro-rested Th1 and Th2 cells were similar to long-term in vivo-rested memory cells, but distinct from in vitro-generated primary effectors and in vivo-restimulated memory effectors by their ability to resist apoptosis. Cessation of stimulation may occur when activated CD4 cells exit lymphoid tissues after priming and transition to memory may be initiated if effectors either fail to gain access to Ag in peripheral tissues where restimulation can lead to activation-induced cell death or do not receive sufficient stimuli to continue a response. Our results suggest that the first stage leading to stable CD4 memory could occur stochastically and independently of instructional processes and as such, the development of memory may be a default pathway when signals that direct responses are not received.