Crystal structure of the parasite protease inhibitor chagasin in complex with a host target cysteine protease

Chagasin is a protein produced by Trypanosoma cruzi, the parasite that causes Chagas' disease. This small protein belongs to a recently defined family of cysteine protease inhibitors. Although resembling well-known inhibitors like the cystatins in size (110 amino acid residues) and function (they all inhibit papain-like (C1 family) proteases), it has a unique amino acid sequence and structure. We have crystallized and solved the structure of chagasin in complex with the host cysteine protease, cathepsin L, at 1.75 A resolution. An inhibitory wedge composed of three loops (L2, L4, and L6) forms a number of contacts responsible for high-affinity binding (K(i), 39 pM) to the enzyme. All three loops interact with the catalytic groove, with the central loop L2 inserted directly into the catalytic center. Loops L4 and L6 embrace the enzyme molecule from both sides and exhibit distinctly different patterns of protein-protein recognition. Comparison with a 1.7 A structure of uncomplexed chagasin, also determined in this study, demonstrates that a conformational change of the first binding loop (L4) allows extended binding to the non-primed substrate pockets of the enzyme active site cleft, thereby providing a substantial part of the inhibitory surface. The mode of chagasin binding is generally similar, albeit distinctly different in detail, when compared to those displayed by cystatins and the cysteine protease inhibitory p41 fragment of the invariant chain. The chagasin-cathepsin L complex structure provides details of how the parasite protein inhibits a host enzyme of possible importance in host defense. The high level of structural and functional similarity between cathepsin L and the T. cruzi enzyme cruzipain gives clues to how the cysteine protease activity of the parasite can be targeted. This information will aid in the development of synthetic inhibitors for use as potential drugs for the treatment of Chagas disease.     

Crystal structure of chagasin, the endogenous cysteine-protease inhibitor from Trypanosoma cruzi

Trypanosoma cruzi chagasin belongs to a recently discovered family of cysteine protease inhibitors found in lower eukaryotes and prokaryotes but not in mammals. Chagasin binds tightly to cruzain, the major lysosomal T. cruzi cysteine protease, involved with infectivity and survival of the parasite in mammalian host cells. In the scope of a project to characterize proteins diferentially expressed during T. cruzi metacyclogenesis, we have determined the crystal structure of chagasin, which is now the first X-ray structure of a chagasin-like cysteine protease inhibitor to be reported. The structure was solved by the SIRAS method and refined at 1.7A resolution and a comparison with the two NMR structures available revealed some differences in the loops involved in binding to cysteine proteases. The highly flexible loop 4 could be entirely modeled and residues 29-33 from loop 2 form a 3(10)-helix structure that may be important to stabilize the loop conformation. Chagasin crystal structure was docked to the highest resolution structure available of cruzain and a model of chagasin-cruzain interaction was analyzed. The knowledge of the chagasin crystal structure may contribute to the elucidation of the molecular mechanism involved in the inhibition of cruzain and other T. cruzi cysteine proteases.     

The contribution of N-terminal region residues of cystatin A (stefin A) to the affinity and kinetics of inhibition of papain, cathepsin B, and cathepsin L.

The affinity and kinetics of binding of three N-terminally truncated variants of the cysteine proteinase inhibitor cystatin A to cysteine proteinases were characterized. Deletion of Met-1 only minimally altered the inhibitory properties of the protein. However, deletion also of Ile-2 resulted in reduced affinities of 900-, >/=3-, and 200-fold for papain and cathepsins L and B, respectively. Further truncation of Pro-3 substantially increased the inhibition constants to approximately 0.5 microM for papain and cathepsin L and to 60 microM for cathepsin B, reflecting additionally 2 x 10(3)-, 2 x 10(4)-, and 400-fold decreased affinities, respectively. The reductions in affinity shown by the latter mutant indicate that the N-terminal region contributes about 40% of the total free energy of binding of cystatin A to cysteine proteinases. Moreover, Pro-3 and to a lesser extent Ile-2 are the residues responsible for this binding energy. The reduced affinities for papain and cathepsin L were due only to higher dissociation rate constants, whereas both lower association and higher dissociation rate constants contributed to the decreased affinity for cathepsin B. These differential effects indicate that the N-terminal portion of cystatin A primarily functions by stabilizing the complexes with enzymes having easily accessible active-site clefts, e.g., papain and cathepsin L. In contrast, the N-terminal region is required also for an initial binding of cystatin A to cathepsin B, presumably by promoting the displacement of the occluding loop and allowing facile interaction of the rest of the inhibiting wedge with the active-site cleft of the enzyme.     

Sequence conservation in the chagasin family suggests a common trend in cysteine proteinase binding by unrelated protein inhibitors

The recently described inhibitor of cysteine proteinases from Trypanosoma cruzi, chagasin, was found to have close homologs in several eukaryotes, bacteria and archaea, the first protein inhibitors of cysteine proteases in prokaryotes. These previously uncharacterized 110-130 residue-long proteins share a well-conserved sequence motif that corresponds to two adjacent beta-strands and the short loop connecting them. Chagasin-like proteins also have other conserved, mostly aromatic, residues, and share the same predicted secondary structure. These proteins adopt an all-beta fold with eight predicted beta-strands of the immunoglobulin type. The phylogenetic distribution of the chagasins generally correlates with the presence of papain-like cysteine proteases. Previous studies have uncovered similar trends in cysteine proteinase binding by two unrelated inhibitors, stefin and p41, that belong to the cystatin and thyroglobulin families, respectively. A hypothetical model of chagasin-cruzipain interaction suggests that chagasin may dock to the cruzipain active site in a similar manner with the conserved NPTTG motif of chagasin forming a loop that is similar to the wedge structures formed at the active sites of papain and cathepsin L by stefin and p41.     

Solution structure and backbone dynamics of the Trypanosoma cruzi cysteine protease inhibitor chagasin

A Trypanosoma cruzi cysteine protease inhibitor, termed chagasin, is the first characterized member of a new family of tight-binding cysteine protease inhibitors identified in several lower eukaryotes and prokaryotes but not present in mammals. In the protozoan parasite T.cruzi, chagasin plays a role in parasite differentiation and in mammalian host cell invasion, due to its ability to modulate the endogenous activity of cruzipain, a lysosomal-like cysteine protease. In the present work, we determined the solution structure of chagasin and studied its backbone dynamics by NMR techniques. Structured as a single immunoglobulin-like domain in solution, chagasin exerts its inhibitory activity on cruzipain through conserved residues placed in three loops in the same side of the structure. One of these three loops, L4, predicted to be of variable length among chagasin homologues, is flexible in solution as determined by measurements of (15)N relaxation. The biological implications of structural homology between chagasin and other members of the immunoglobulin super-family are discussed.     

pH Dependence of inhibitors targeting the occluding loop of cathepsin B

Potent and selective cathepsin B inhibitors have previously been synthesized based upon the natural product cysteine protease inhibitor E-64. X-ray crystal data indicates that these compounds interact through their free carboxylate with the positively charged histidine residues located on the prime-side of the active site within the occluding loop of cathepsin B. Herein, we examine the pH dependence of two prime-side-binding compounds. In each case there is a dramatic decrease in k(inact)/K(I) as the pH is raised from 4 to 7.8 corresponding to a single ionization of pK(a) 4.4. These results suggest that targeting of the occluding loop of cathepsin B may be a poor inhibitor design strategy if the enzyme environment has a pH greater than 5.5. However, this type of inhibitor may be a useful tool to help elucidate the role and the environment of cathepsin B in invading tumors.     

Crystal Structures of TbCatB and Rhodesain,Potential Chemotherapeutic Targets and Major Cysteine Proteases of Trypanosoma brucei

Background

Trypanosoma brucei is the etiological agent of Human African Trypanosomiasis, an endemic parasitic disease of sub-Saharan Africa. TbCatB and rhodesain are the sole Clan CA papain-like cysteine proteases produced by the parasite during infection of the mammalian host and are implicated in the progression of disease. Of considerable interest is the exploration of these two enzymes as targets for cysteine protease inhibitors that are effective against T. brucei.

Methods and Findings

We have determined, by X-ray crystallography, the first reported structure of TbCatB in complex with the cathepsin B selective inhibitor CA074. In addition we report the structure of rhodesain in complex with the vinyl-sulfone K11002.

Conclusions

The mature domain of our TbCat•CA074 structure contains unique features for a cathepsin B-like enzyme including an elongated N-terminus extending 16 residues past the predicted maturation cleavage site. N-terminal Edman sequencing reveals an even longer extension than is observed amongst the ordered portions of the crystal structure. The TbCat•CA074 structure confirms that the occluding loop, which is an essential part of the substrate-binding site, creates a larger prime side pocket in the active site cleft than is found in mammalian cathepsin B-small molecule structures. Our data further highlight enhanced flexibility in the occluding loop main chain and structural deviations from mammalian cathepsin B enzymes that may affect activity and inhibitor design. Comparisons with the rhodesain•K11002 structure highlight key differences that may impact the design of cysteine protease inhibitors as anti-trypanosomal drugs.     

The Occluding Loop of Cathepsin B Prevents Its Effective Inhibition by Human Kininogens

Kininogens, the major plasma cystatin-like inhibitors of cysteine cathepsins, are degraded at sites of inflammation, and cathepsin B has been identified as a prominent mediator of this process. Cathepsin B, in contrast to cathepsins L and S, is poorly inhibited by kininogens. This led us to delineate the molecular interactions between this protease and kininogens (high molecular weight kininogen and low molecular weight kininogen) and to elucidate the dual role of the occluding loop in this weak inhibition. Cathepsin B cleaves high molecular weight kininogen within the N-terminal region of the D2 and D3 cystatin-like domains and close to the consensus QVVAG inhibitory pentapeptide of the D3 domain. The His110Ala mutant, unlike His111Ala cathepsin B, fails to hydrolyze kininogens, but rather forms a tight-binding complex as observed by gel-filtration analysis. K_i values (picomolar range) as well as association rate constants for the His110Ala cathepsin B variant compare to those reported for cathepsin L for both kininogens. Homology modeling of isolated inhibitory (D2 and D3) domains and molecular dynamics simulations of the D2 domain complexed with wild-type cathepsin B and its mutants indicate that additional weak interactions, due to the lack of the salt bridge (Asp22-His110) and the subsequent open position of the occluding loop, increase the inhibitory potential of kininogens on His110Ala cathepsin B.     

A double-headed cathepsin B inhibitor devoid of warhead

Most synthetic inhibitors of peptidases have been targeted to the active site for inhibiting catalysis through reversible competition with the substrate or by covalent modification of catalytic groups. Cathepsin B is unique among the cysteine peptidase for the presence of a flexible segment, known as the occluding loop, which can block the primed subsites of the substrate binding cleft. With the occluding loop in the open conformation cathepsin B acts as an endopeptidase, and it acts as an exopeptidase when the loop is closed. We have targeted the occluding loop of human cathepsin B at its surface, outside the catalytic center, using a high-throughput docking procedure. The aim was to identify inhibitors that would interact with the occluding loop thereby modulating enzyme activity without the help of chemical warheads against catalytic residues. From a large library of compounds, the in silico approach identified [2-[2-(2,4-dioxo-1,3-thiazolidin-3-yl)ethylamino]-2-oxoethyl] 2-(furan-2-carbonylamino) acetate, which fulfills the working hypothesis. This molecule possesses two distinct binding moieties and behaves as a reversible, double-headed competitive inhibitor of cathepsin B by excluding synthetic and protein substrates from the active center. The kinetic mechanism of inhibition suggests that the occluding loop is stabilized in its closed conformation, mainly by hydrogen bonds with the inhibitor, thus decreasing endoproteolytic activity of the enzyme. Furthermore, the dioxothiazolidine head of the compound sterically hinders binding of the C-terminal residue of substrates resulting in inhibition of the exopeptidase activity of cathepsin B in a physiopathologically relevant pH range.     

The role of the second binding loop of the cysteine protease inhibitor, cystatin A (stefin A), in stabilizing complexes with target proteases is exerted predominantly by Leu73.

The aim of this work was to elucidate the roles of individual residues within the flexible second binding loop of human cystatin A in the inhibition of cysteine proteases. Four recombinant variants of the inhibitor, each with a single mutation, L73G, P74G, Q76G or N77G, in the most exposed part of this loop were generated by PCR-based site-directed mutagenesis. The binding of these variants to papain, cathepsin L, and cathepsin B was characterized by equilibrium and kinetic methods. Mutation of Leu73 decreased the affinity for papain, cathepsin L and cathepsin B by approximately 300-fold, >10-fold and approximately 4000-fold, respectively. Mutation of Pro74 decreased the affinity for cathepsin B by approximately 10-fold but minimally affected the affinity for the other two enzymes. Mutation of Gln76 and Asn77 did not alter the affinity of cystatin A for any of the proteases studied. The decreased affinities were caused exclusively by increased dissociation rate constants. These results show that the second binding loop of cystatin A plays a major role in stabilizing the complexes with proteases by retarding their dissociation. In contrast with cystatin B, only one amino-acid residue of the loop, Leu73, is of principal importance for this effect, Pro74 assisting to a minor extent only in the case of cathepsin B binding. The contribution of the second binding loop of cystatin A to protease binding varies with the protease, being largest, approximately 45% of the total binding energy, for inhibition of cathepsin B.     

The role of conserved residues of chagasin in the inhibition of cysteine peptidases

We have evaluated the roles of key amino acids to the action of the natural inhibitor chagasin of papain-family cysteine peptidases. A W93A substitution decreased inhibitor affinity for human cathepsin L 100-fold, while substitutions of T31 resulted in 10-100-fold increases in the K(i) for cruzipain of Trypanosoma cruzi. A T31A/T32A double mutant had increased affinity for cathepsin L but not for cruzipain, while the T31-T32 deletion drastically affected inhibition of both human and parasite peptidases. These differential effects reflect the occurrence of direct interactions between chagasin and helix 8 of cathepsin L, interactions that do not occur with cruzipain.     

The refined 2.15 A X-ray crystal structure of human liver cathepsin B: the structural basis for its specificity.

From the lysosomal cysteine proteinase cathepsin B, isolated from human liver in its two-chain form, monoclinic crystals were obtained which contain two molecules per asymmetric unit. The molecular structure was solved by a combination of Patterson search and heavy atom replacement methods (simultaneously with rat cathepsin B) and refined to a crystallographic R value of 0.164 using X-ray data to 2.15 A resolution. The overall folding pattern of cathepsin B and the arrangement of the active site residues are similar to the related cysteine proteinases papain, actinidin and calotropin DI. 166 alpha-carbon atoms out of 248 defined cathepsin B residues are topologically equivalent (with an r.m.s. deviation of 1.04 A) with alpha-carbon atoms of papain. However, several large insertion loops are accommodated on the molecular surface and modify its properties. The disulphide connectivities recently determined for bovine cathepsin B by chemical means were shown to be correct. Some of the primed subsites are occluded by a novel insertion loop, which seems to favour binding of peptide substrates with two residues carboxy-terminal to the scissile peptide bond; two histidine residues (His110 and His111) in this "occluding loop' provide positively charged anchors for the C-terminal carboxylate group of such polypeptide substrates. These structural features explain the well-known dipeptidyl carboxypeptidase activity of cathepsin B. The other subsites adjacent to the reactive site Cys29 are relatively similar to papain; Glu245 in the S2 subsite favours basic P2-side chains. The above mentioned histidine residues, but also the buried Glu171 might represent the group with a pKa of approximately 5.5 near the active site, which governs endo- and exopeptidase activity. The "occluding loop' does not allow cystatin-like protein inhibitors to bind to cathepsin B as they do to papain, consistent with the reduced affinity of these protein inhibitors for cathepsin B compared with the related plant enzymes.     

Grafting of features of cystatins C or B into the N-terminal region or second binding loop of cystatin A (stefin A) substantially enhances inhibition of cysteine proteinases

Replacement of the three N-terminal residues preceding the conserved Gly of cystatin A by the corresponding 10-residue long segment of cystatin C increased the affinity of the inhibitor for the major lysosomal cysteine proteinase, cathepsin B, by approximately 15-fold. This tighter binding was predominantly due to a higher overall association rate constant. Characterization of the interaction with an inactive Cys29 to Ala variant of cathepsin B indicated that the higher rate constant was a result of an increased ability of the N-terminal region of the chimeric inhibitor to promote displacement of the cathepsin B occluding loop in the second binding step. The low dissociation rate constant for the binding of cystatin A to cathepsin B was retained by the chimeric inhibitor, which therefore had a higher affinity for this enzyme than any natural cystatin identified so far. In contrast, the N-terminal substitution negligibly affected the ability of cystatin A to inhibit papain. However, substitutions of Gly75 in the second binding loop of cystatin A by Trp or His, making the loop similar to those of cystatins C or B, respectively, increased the affinity for papain by approximately 10-fold. This enhanced affinity was due to both a higher association rate constant and a lower dissociation rate constant. Modeling of complexes between the two variants and papain indicated the possibility of favorable interactions being established between the substituting residues and the enzyme. The second-loop substitutions negligibly affected or moderately reduced the affinity for cathepsin B. Together, these results show that the inhibitory ability of cystatins can be substantially improved by protein engineering.     

The occluding loop in cathepsin B defines the pH dependence of inhibition by its propeptide

Papain-like proenzymes are prone to autoprocess under acidic pH conditions. Similarly, peptides derived from the proregion of cathepsin B are potent pH-dependent inhibitors of that enzyme; i.e., at pH 6.0 the inhibition of human cathepsin B by its propeptide is defined by slow binding kinetics with a Ki of 3.7 nM and at pH 4.0 by classical kinetics with a Ki of 82 nM. This pH dependency is essentially eliminated either by the removal of a portion of the enzyme's occluding loop through deletion mutagenesis or by the mutation of either residue Asp22 or His110 to alanine; e.g., the mutant enzyme His110Ala is inhibited by its propeptide with Ki's of 2.0 +/- 0.3 nM at pH 4.0 and 1.1 +/- 0.2 nM at pH 6.0. For the His110Ala mutant the inhibition also displays slow binding kinetics at both pH 4.0 and pH 6.0. As shown by the crystal structure of mature cathepsin B [Musil, D., et al. (1991) EMBO J. 10, 2321-2330] Asp22 and His110 form a salt bridge in the mature enzyme, and it has been shown that this bridge stabilizes the occluding loop in its closed position [N?gler, D. K., et al. (1997) Biochemistry 36, 12608-12615]. Thus the pH dependency of propeptide binding can be explained on the basis of a competitive binding between the occluding loop and the propeptide. At low pH, when the Asp22-His110 pair forms a salt bridge stabilizing the occluding loop in its closed conformation, the loop more effectively competes with the propeptide than at higher pH where deprotonation of His110 and the concomitant destruction of the Asp22-His110 salt bridge results in a destabilization of the closed form of the loop. The rate of autocatalytic processing of procathepsin B to cathepsin B correlates with the affinity of the enzyme for its propeptide rather than with its catalytic activity, thus suggesting a possible influence of occluding loop stability on the rate of processing.     

Evidence that serpin architecture intrinsically supports papain-like cysteine protease inhibition: engineering alpha(1)-antitrypsin to inhibit cathepsin proteases

The closely related serpins squamous cell carcinoma antigen-1 and -2 (SCCA-1 and -2, respectively) are capable of inhibiting cysteine proteases of the papain superfamily. To ascertain whether the ability to inhibit cysteine proteases is an intrinsic property of serpins in general, the reactive center loop (RCL) of the archetypal serine protease inhibitor alpha(1)-antitrypsin was replaced with that of SCCA-1. It was found that this simple substitution could convert alpha(1)-antitrypsin into a cysteine protease inhibitor, albeit an inefficient one. The RCL of SCCA-1 is three residues longer than that of alpha(1)-antitrypsin, and therefore, the effect of loop length on the cysteine protease inhibitory activity was investigated. Mutants in which the RCL was shortened by one, two, or three residues were effective inhibitors with second-order rate constants of 10(5)-10(7) M(-)(1) s(-)(1). In addition to loop length, the identity of the cysteine protease was of considerable importance, since the chimeric molecules inhibited cathepsins L, V, and K efficiently, but not papain or cathepsin B. By testing complexes between an RCL-mimicking peptide and the mutants, it was found that the formation of a stable serpin-cysteine protease complex and the inhibition of a cysteine protease were both critically dependent on RCL insertion. The results strongly indicate that the serpin body is intrinsically capable of supporting cysteine protease inhibition, and that the complex with a papain-like cysteine protease would be expected to be analogous to that seen with serine proteases.     

Role of the single cysteine residue, Cys 3, of human and bovine cystatin B (stefin B) in the inhibition of cysteine proteinases

Cystatin B is unique among cysteine proteinase inhibitors of the cystatin superfamily in having a free Cys in the N-terminal segment of the proteinase binding region. The importance of this residue for inhibition of target proteinases was assessed by studies of the affinity and kinetics of interaction of human and bovine wild-type cystatin B and the Cys 3-to-Ser mutants of the inhibitors with papain and cathepsins L, H, and B. The wild-type forms from the two species had about the same affinity for each proteinase, binding tightly to papain and cathepsin L and more weakly to cathepsins H and B. In general, these affinities were appreciably higher than those reported earlier, perhaps because of irreversible oxidation of Cys 3 in previous work. The Cys-to-Ser mutation resulted in weaker binding of cystatin B to all four proteinases examined, the effect varying with both the proteinase and the species variant of the inhibitor. The affinities of the human inhibitor for papain and cathepsin H were decreased by threefold to fourfold and that for cathepsin B by approximately 20-fold, whereas the reductions in the affinities of the bovine inhibitor for papain and cathepsins H and B were approximately 14-fold, approximately 10-fold and approximately 300-fold, respectively. The decreases in affinity for cathepsin L could not be properly quantified but were greater than threefold. Increased dissociation rate constants were responsible for the weaker binding of both mutants to papain. By contrast, the reduced affinities for cathepsins H and B were due to decreased association rate constants. Cys 3 of both human and bovine cystatin B is thus of appreciable importance for inhibition of cysteine proteinases, in particular cathepsin B.     

Solution structure of the inhibitor of cysteine proteases 1 from Entamoeba histolytica reveals a possible auto regulatory mechanism

The genome of Entamoeba histolytica encodes approximately 50 Cysteine Proteases (CPs) whose activity is regulated by two Inhibitors of Cysteine Proteases (ICPs), EhICP1 and EhICP2. The main difference between both EhICPs is the acquisition of a 17 N-terminal targeting signal in EhICP2 and three exposed cysteine residues in EhICP1. The three exposed cysteines in EhICP1 potentiate the formation of cross-linking species that drive heterogeneity. Here we solved the NMR structure of EhICP1 using a mutant protein without accessible cysteines. Our structural data shows that EhICP1 adopts an immunoglobulin fold composed of seven β-strands, and three solvent exposed loops that resemble the structures of EhICP2 and chagasin. EhICP1 and EhICP2 are able to inhibit the archetypical cysteine protease papain by intercalating their BC loops into the protease active site independently of the character of the residue (serine or threonine) responsible to interact with the active site of papain. EhICP1 and EhICP2 present signals of functional divergence as they clustered in different clades. Two of the three exposed cysteines in EhICP1 are located at the DE loop that intercalates into the CP substrate-binding cleft. We propose that the solvent exposed cysteines of EhICP1 play a role in regulating its inhibitory activity and that in oxidative conditions, the cysteines of EhICP1 react to form intra and intermolecular disulfide bonds that render an inactive inhibitor. EhICP2 is not subject to redox regulation, as this inhibitor does not contain a single cysteine residue. This proposed redox regulation may be related to the differential cellular localization between EhICP1 and EhICP2.     

Versatile Loops in Mycocypins Inhibit Three Protease Families

Mycocypins, clitocypins and macrocypins, are cysteine protease inhibitors isolated from the mushrooms Clitocybe nebularis and Macrolepiota procera. Lack of sequence homology to other families of protease inhibitors suggested that mycocypins inhibit their target cysteine protease by a unique mechanism and that a novel fold may be found. The crystal structures of the complex of clitocypin with the papain-like cysteine protease cathepsin V and of macrocypin and clitocypin alone have revealed yet another motif of binding to papain like-cysteine proteases, which in a yet unrevealed way occludes the catalytic residue. The binding is associated with a peptide-bond flip of glycine that occurs before or concurrently with the inhibitor docking. Mycocypins possess a β-trefoil fold, the hallmark of Kunitz-type inhibitors. It is a tree-like structure with two loops in the root region, a stem comprising a six-stranded β-barrel, and two layers of loops (6 + 3) in the crown region. The two loops that bind to cysteine cathepsins belong to the lower layer of the crown loops, whereas a single loop from the crown region can inhibit trypsin or asparaginyl endopeptidase, as demonstrated by site-directed mutagenesis. These loops present a versatile surface with the potential to bind to additional classes of proteases. When appropriately engineered, they could provide the basis for possible exploitation in crop protection.