Pulmonary perfusion in supine and prone positions: an electron-beam computed tomography study.

Acute respiratory distress syndrome is characterized by alterations in the ventilation-perfusion ratio. Present techniques for studying regional pulmonary perfusion are difficult to apply in the critically ill. Electron-beam computed tomography was used to study the effects of prone positioning on regional pulmonary perfusion in six healthy subjects. Contrast-enhanced sections were obtained sequentially in the supine, prone, and (original) supine positions at full inspiration. Regions of interest were placed along the nondependent to dependent axis and relative perfusion calculated. When corrected for the redistribution of lung parenchyma, a gravitational gradient of pulmonary perfusion existed in both supine and prone positions. The distribution of perfusion between the supine or prone positions did not differ, but data analysis using smaller regions of interest demonstrated marked heterogeneity of perfusion between anatomically adjacent regions of lung. The distribution of lung parenchyma was more uniform in the prone position. Gravity was estimated to be responsible for 22-34% of perfusion heterogeneity in the supine and 27-41% in the prone positions. These data support the hypothesis that factors other than gravity may be at least as important in determining the distribution of pulmonary perfusion in humans. The influence of nongravitational factors may not be detectable if techniques that sample large tissue volumes are employed.     

Pulmonary perfusion is more uniform in the prone than in the supine position: scintigraphy in healthy humans.

The main purpose of this study was to find out whether the dominant dorsal lung perfusion while supine changes to a dominant ventral lung perfusion while prone. Regional distribution of pulmonary blood flow was determined in 10 healthy volunteers. The subjects were studied in both prone and supine positions with and without lung distension caused by 10 cmH2O of continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP). Radiolabeled macroaggregates of albumin, rapidly trapped by pulmonary capillaries in proportion to blood flow, were injected intravenously. Tomographic gamma camera examinations (single-photon-emission computed tomography) were performed after injections in the different positions. All data acquisitions were made with the subject in the supine position. CPAP enhanced perfusion differences along the gravitational axis, which was more pronounced in the supine than prone position. Diaphragmatic sections of the lung had a more uniform pulmonary blood flow distribution in the prone than supine position during both normal and CPAP breathing. It was concluded that the dominant dorsal lung perfusion observed when the subjects were supine was not changed into a dominant ventral lung perfusion when the subjects were prone. Lung perfusion was more uniformly distributed in the prone compared with in the supine position, a difference that was more marked during total lung distension (CPAP) than during normal breathing.     

Effect of tidal volume and PEEP in ethchlorvynol-induced asymmetric lung injury.

We examined the effects of positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) and tidal volume on the distribution of ventilation and perfusion in a canine model of asymmetric lung injury. Unilateral right lung edema was established in 10 animals by use of a selective infusion of ethchlorvynol. Five animals were tested in the supine position (horizontal asymmetry) and five in the right decubitus position (vertical asymmetry). Raising PEEP from 5 to 12 cmH2O improved oxygenation despite a redistribution of blood flow toward the damage lung and a consistent decrease in total respiratory system compliance. This improvement paralleled a redistribution of tidal ventilation to the injured lung. This was effected primarily by a fall in the compliance of the noninjured lung due to hyperinflation. The effects of higher tidal volume were additive to those of PEEP. We propose that the major effect of PEEP in inhomogeneous lung injury is to restore tidal ventilation to a population of alveoli recruitable only at high airway pressures.     

Gravity is a minor determinant of pulmonary blood flow distribution

Regional pulmonary blood flow in dogs under zone 3 conditions was measured in supine and prone postures to evaluate the linear gravitational model of perfusion distribution. Flow to regions of lung that were 1.9 cm3 in volume was determined by injection of radiolabeled microspheres in both postures. There was marked perfusion heterogeneity within isogravitational planes (coefficient of variation = 42.5%) as well as within gravitational planes (coefficient of variation = 44.2 and 39.2% in supine and prone postures, respectively; P = 0.02). On average, vertical height explained only 5.8 and 2.4% of the flow variability in the supine and prone postures, respectively. Whereas the gravitational model predicts that regional flows should be negatively correlated when measured in supine and prone postures, flows in the two postures were positively correlated, with an r2 of 0.708 +/- 0.050. Regional perfusion as a function of distance from the center of a lung explained 13.4 and 10.8% of the flow variability in the supine and prone postures, respectively. A linear combination of vertical height and radial distance from the centers of each lung provided a better-fitting model but still explained only 20.0 and 12.0% of the flow variability in the supine and prone postures, respectively. The entire lung was searched for a region of contiguous lung pieces (22.8 cm3) with high flow. Such a region was found in the dorsal area of the lower lobes in six of seven animals, and flow to this region was independent of posture. Under zone 3 conditions, neither gravity nor radial location is the principal determinant of regional perfusion distribution in supine and prone dogs.     

Distribution of regional lung aeration and perfusion during conventional and noisy pressure support ventilation in experimental lung injury

In acute lung injury (ALI), pressure support ventilation (PSV) may improve oxygenation compared with pressure-controlled ventilation (PCV), and benefit from random variation of pressure support (noisy PSV). We investigated the effects of PCV, PSV, and noisy PSV on gas exchange as well as the distribution of lung aeration and perfusion in 12 pigs with ALI induced by saline lung lavage in supine position. After injury, animals were mechanically ventilated with PCV, PSV, and noisy PSV for 1 h/mode in random sequence. The driving pressure was set to a mean tidal volume of 6 ml/kg and positive end-expiratory pressure to 8 cmH?O in all modes. Functional variables were measured, and the distribution of lung aeration was determined by static and dynamic computed tomography (CT), whereas the distribution of pulmonary blood flow (PBF) was determined by intravenously administered fluorescent microspheres. PSV and noisy PSV improved oxygenation and reduced venous admixture compared with PCV. Mechanical ventilation with PSV and noisy PSV did not decrease nonaerated areas but led to a redistribution of PBF from dorsal to ventral lung regions and reduced tidal reaeration and hyperinflation compared with PCV. Noisy PSV further improved oxygenation and redistributed PBF from caudal to cranial lung regions compared with conventional PSV. We conclude that assisted ventilation with PSV and noisy PSV improves oxygenation compared with PCV through redistribution of PBF from dependent to nondependent zones without lung recruitment. Random variation of pressure support further redistributes PBF and improves oxygenation compared with conventional PSV.     

Eicosanoid balance and perfusion redistribution of oleic acid-induced acute lung injury.

We have proposed that endogenous prostacyclin opposes the vasoconstriction responsible for redistribution of regional pulmonary blood flow (rPBF) away from areas of increased regional lung water concentration (rLWC) in canine oleic acid- (OA) induced acute lung injury (D. P. Schuster and J. Haller. J. Appl. Physiol. 69: 353-361, 1990). To test this hypothesis, we related regional lung tissue concentrations of 6-ketoprostaglandin (PG) F1 alpha and thromboxane (Tx) B2 in tissue samples obtained 2.5 h after administration of OA (0.08 ml/kg iv) to rPBF and rLWC measured by positron emission tomography. After OA only (n = 16), rLWC increased in dependent lung regions. Some animals responded to increased rLWC by redistribution of rPBF away from the most edematous regions (OA-R, n = 6), whereas others did not (OA-NR, n = 10). In another six animals, meclofenamate was administered after OA (OA-meclo). After OA, tissue concentrations of 6-keto-PGF1 alpha were greater than TxB2 in all groups, but concentrations of 6-keto-PGF1 alpha were not different between OA-R and OA-NR animals. TxB2 was increased in the dependent regions of animals in both OA-R and OA-NR groups compared with controls (no OA, n = 4, P < 0.05). The tissue TxB2/6-keto-PGF1 alpha ratio was smaller in controls and OA-NR in which no perfusion redistribution occurred than in OA-R and OA-meclo in which it did occur. This TxB2/6-keto-PGF1 alpha ratio correlated significantly with the magnitude of perfusion redistribution.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Effect of position, nitric oxide, and almitrine on lung perfusion in a porcine model of acute lung injury.

In a porcine model of oleic acid-induced lung injury, the effects of inhaled nitric oxide (iNO) and intravenous almitrine bismesylate (ivALM), which enhances the hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction on the distribution of regional pulmonary blood flow (PBF), were assessed. After injection of 0.12 ml/kg oleic acid, 20 anesthetized and mechanically ventilated piglets [weight of 25 +/- 2.6 (SD) kg] were randomly divided into four groups: supine position, prone position, and 10 ppm iNO for 40 min followed by 4 microg x kg(-1) x min(-1) ivALM for 40 min in supine position and in prone position. PBF was measured with positron emission tomography and H(2)15O. The redistribution of PBF was studied on a pixel-by-pixel basis. Positron emission tomography scans were performed before and then 120, 160, and 200 min after injury. With prone position alone, although PBF remained prevalent in the dorsal regions it was significantly redistributed toward the ventral regions (P < 0.001). A ventral redistribution of PBF was also obtained with iNO regardless of the position (P = 0.043). Adjunction of ivALM had no further effect on PBF redistribution. PP and iNO have an additive effect on ventral redistribution of PBF.     

Marked differences between prone and supine sheep in effect of PEEP on perfusion distribution in zone II lung.

The classic four-zone model of lung blood flow distribution has been questioned. We asked whether the effect of positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) is different between the prone and supine position for lung tissue in the same zonal condition. Anesthetized and mechanically ventilated prone (n = 6) and supine (n = 5) sheep were studied at 0, 10, and 20 cm H2O PEEP. Perfusion was measured with intravenous infusion of radiolabeled 15-microm microspheres. The right lung was dried at total lung capacity and diced into pieces (approximately 1.5 cm3), keeping track of the spatial location of each piece. Radioactivity per unit weight was determined and normalized to the mean value for each condition and animal. In the supine posture, perfusion to nondependent lung regions decreased with little relative perfusion in nondependent horizontal lung planes at 10 and 20 cm H2O PEEP. In the prone position, the effect of PEEP was markedly different with substantial perfusion remaining in nondependent lung regions and even increasing in these regions with 20 cm H2O PEEP. Vertical blood flow gradients in zone II lung were large in supine, but surprisingly absent in prone, animals. Isogravitational perfusion heterogeneity was smaller in prone than in supine animals at all PEEP levels. Redistribution of pulmonary perfusion by PEEP ventilation in supine was largely as predicted by the zonal model in marked contrast to the findings in prone. The differences between postures in blood flow distribution within zone II strongly indicate that factors in addition to pulmonary arterial, venous, and alveolar pressure play important roles in determining perfusion distribution in the in situ lung. We suggest that regional variation in lung volume through the effect on vascular resistance is one such factor and that chest wall conformation and thoracic contents determine regional lung volume.     

Paradoxical redistribution of pulmonary blood flow in prone and supine humans exposed to hypergravity.

We hypothesized that exposure to hypergravity in the supine and prone postures causes a redistribution of pulmonary blood flow to dependent lung regions. Four normal subjects were exposed to hypergravity by use of a human centrifuge. Regional lung perfusion was estimated by single-photon-emission computed tomography (SPECT) after administration of (99m)Tc-labeled albumin macroaggregates during normal and three times normal gravity conditions in the supine and prone postures. All images were obtained during normal gravity. Exposure to hypergravity caused a redistribution of blood flow from dependent to nondependent lung regions in all subjects in both postures. We speculate that this unexpected and paradoxical redistribution is a consequence of airway closure in dependent lung regions causing alveolar hypoxia and hypoxic vasoconstriction. Alternatively, increased vascular resistance in dependent lung regions is caused by distortion of lung parenchyma. The redistribution of blood flow is likely to attenuate rather than contribute to the arterial desaturation caused by hypergravity.     

Effect of body posture on spatial distribution of pulmonary blood flow

Single-photon emission-computed tomography (SPECT) on intact dogs and humans suggests that one aspect of regional blood flow in the lung (Qr) is independent of gravity, e.g., the gradient in Qr between the core and the periphery. To further evaluate these findings, six anesthetized healthy dogs (approximately 30 kg), two in the supine posture, two in the prone posture, and two suspended in the upright posture, breathing spontaneously, were injected (iv) at end expiration with 20 mCi99mTc-labeled albumin macroaggregates. The animals were killed, their chests were opened, their lungs were removed and dissected free of other tissue, and the blood was drained. The lungs were dried by blowing warm air (50 degrees C) while they were inflated to full capacity for about 18 h. The fully inflated and dry lungs were placed in the supine position and SPECT was performed to determine the three-dimensional distribution of activity. One hundred and twenty projections of the activity in the entire lungs were obtained at 3 degrees steps with a rotating gamma camera and stored in computer memory. Once SPECT was completed, either a coronal slice or a sagittal slice (1 cm thick) was cut and imaged directly by placing it against the gamma camera collimator for 6 min. The tomographic-reconstructed slices revealed that at isogravity, in all body postures, Qr in the central region of the lungs was up to 10 times that in the periphery. Furthermore, the central-peripheral gradient was discernible within the individual lobes. The direct images of slices also confirmed these findings. Although flow inequalities independent of gravity were present, the central region with the highest flow often was closer to the dependent regions of the lungs, suggesting that gravity had some influence on the final distribution. The results suggest that factors other than gravity also play an important role in the distribution of pulmonary blood flow. These factors may be related to the conductance of the vascular pathways that lead to different regions in the lungs.     

Lung albumin accumulation is spatially heterogeneous but not correlated with regional pulmonary perfusion.

The contribution of pulmonary perfusion heterogeneity to the development of regional differences in lung injury and edema is unknown. To test whether regional differences in pulmonary perfusion are associated with regional differences in microvascular function during lung injury, pigs were mechanically ventilated in the prone position and infused with endotoxin (Escherichia coli 055:B5, 0.15 microg. kg(-1). h(-1); n = 8) or saline (n = 4) for 4 h. Extravascular albumin accumulation and perfusion were measured in multiple approximately 0.7-ml lung regions by injecting pigs with radiolabeled albumin and radioactive microspheres, respectively. Extravascular albumin accumulation was spatially heterogeneous but not correlated with regional perfusion. Extravascular albumin accumulation was greater in dorsal than ventral regions, and regions with similar albumin accumulation were spatially clustered. This spatial organization was less evident in endotoxemic than control pigs. We conclude that there are regional differences in lung albumin accumulation that are spatially organized but not mediated by regional differences in pulmonary perfusion. We speculate that regional differences in microvascular pressure or endothelial function may account for the observed distribution of extravascular albumin accumulation.     

Regional VA, Q, and VA/Q during PLV: effects of nitroprusside and inhaled nitric oxide.

Partial liquid ventilation (PLV) with high-specific-weight perfluorocarbon liquids has been shown to improve oxygenation in acute lung injury, possibly by redistributing perfusion from dependent, injured regions to nondependent, less injured regions of the lung. Our hypothesis was that during PLV in normal lungs, a shift in perfusion away from dependent lung zones might, in part, be due to vasoconstriction that could be reversed by infusing sodium nitroprusside (NTP). In addition, delivering inhaled NO during PLV should improve gas exchange by further redistributing blood flow to well-ventilated lung regions. To examine this, we used a single transverse-slice positron emission tomography camera to image regional ventilation and perfusion at the level of the heart apex in six supine mechanically ventilated sheep during five conditions: control, PLV, PLV + NTP, and PLV + NO at 10 and 80 ppm. We found that PLV shifted perfusion from dependent to middle regions, and the dependent region demonstrated marked hypoventilation. The vertical distribution of perfusion changed little when high-dose intravenous NTP was added during PLV, and inhaled NO tended to shift perfusion toward better ventilated middle regions. We conclude that PLV shifts perfusion to the middle regions of the lung because of the high specific weight of perflubron rather than vasoconstriction.     

Local gas transport in eucapnic ventilation: effects of gravity and breathing frequency

The effects of body position and respiratory frequency (f) on regional gas transport during eucapnic conventional ventilation (CV) and high-frequency ventilation (HFV) were assessed from the washout of nitrogen 13 (13NN) using positron-emission tomography. In one protocol, six dogs were ventilated with CV or HFV at f = 6 Hz and tidal volume (VT) selected supine for eucapnia. A coronal cross section of the lung base was studied in the supine, prone, and right and left lateral decubitus positions. In a second protocol, six dogs were studied prone: apical and basal cross sections were studied in CV and in HFV with f = 3 and 9 Hz at eucapnic VT. Regional alveolar ventilation per unit of lung volume (spVr) was calculated for selected regions and analyzed for gravity-dependent cephalocaudal and right-to-left gradients. In both CV and HFV, nonuniformity in spVr was highest supine and lowest prone. In CV there were vertical gradients of spVr in all body positions: nondependent less ventilated than dependent regions, particularly in the supine position. In HFV there was a moderate vertical gradient in spVr in addition to a preferentially ventilated central region in all body positions. Overall lung spV was unaffected by body position in CV but in HFV was highest supine and lowest prone. Nonuniformity in eucapnic prone HFV was unaffected by f and always higher than in CV.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Regional ventilation-perfusion distribution is more uniform in the prone position.

The arterial blood PO(2) is increased in the prone position in animals and humans because of an improvement in ventilation (VA) and perfusion (Q) matching. However, the mechanism of improved VA/Q is unknown. This experiment measured regional VA/Q heterogeneity and the correlation between VA and Q in supine and prone positions in pigs. Eight ketamine-diazepam-anesthetized, mechanically ventilated pigs were studied in supine and prone positions in random order. Regional VA and Q were measured using fluorescent-labeled aerosols and radioactive-labeled microspheres, respectively. The lungs were dried at total lung capacity and cubed into 603-967 small ( approximately 1.7-cm(3)) pieces. In the prone position the homogeneity of the ventilation distribution increased (P = 0.030) and the correlation between VA and Q increased (correlation coefficient = 0.72 +/- 0.08 and 0.82 +/- 0.06 in supine and prone positions, respectively, P = 0.03). The homogeneity of the VA/Q distribution increased in the prone position (P = 0.028). We conclude that the improvement in VA/Q matching in the prone position is secondary to increased homogeneity of the VA distribution and increased correlation of regional VA and Q.     

Distributions of lung ventilation and perfusion in prone and supine humans exposed to hypergravity.

When normal subjects are exposed to hypergravity [5 times normal gravity (5 G)] there is an impaired arterial oxygenation that is less severe in the prone compared with supine posture. We hypothesized that under these conditions the heterogeneities of ventilation and/or perfusion distributions would be less prominent when subjects were prone compared with supine. Expirograms from a combined rebreathing-single breath washout maneuver (Rohdin M, Sundblad P, and Linnarsson D. J Appl Physiol 96: 1470-1477, 2004) were analyzed for vital capacity (VC), phase III slope, and phase IV amplitude, to analyze heterogeneities in ventilation (Ar) and perfusion [CO(2)-to-Ar ratio (CO(2)/Ar)] distribution, respectively. During hypergravity, VC decreased more in the supine than in the prone position (ANOVA, P = 0.02). Phase III slope was more positive for Ar (P = 0.003) and more negative for CO(2)/Ar (P = 0.007) in the supine compared with prone posture at 5 G, in agreement with the notion of a more severe hypergravity-induced ventilation-perfusion mismatch in supine posture. Phase IV amplitude became lower in the supine than in the prone posture for both Ar (P = 0.02) and CO(2)/Ar (P = 0.004) during hypergravity as a result of the more reduced VC in the supine posture. We speculate that results of VC and phase IV amplitude are due to the differences in heart-lung interaction and diaphragm position between postures: a stable position of the heart and diaphragm in prone hypergravity, in contrast to supine in which the weight of the heart and a cephalad shift of the diaphragm compress lung tissue.     

Gas exchange and intrapulmonary distribution of ventilation during continuous-flow ventilation

In 12 anesthetized paralyzed dogs, pulmonary gas exchange and intrapulmonary inspired gas distribution were compared between continuous-flow ventilation (CFV) and conventional mechanical ventilation (CMV). Nine dogs were studied while they were lying supine, and three dogs were studied while they were lying prone. A single-lumen catheter for tracheal insufflation and a double-lumen catheter for bilateral endobronchial insufflation [inspired O2 fraction = 0.4; inspired minute ventilation = 1.7 +/- 0.3 (SD) 1.kg-1.min-1] were evaluated. Intrapulmonary gas distribution was assessed from regional 133Xe clearances. In dogs lying supine, CO2 elimination was more efficient with endobronchial insufflation than with tracheal insufflation, but the alveolar-arterial O2 partial pressure difference was larger during CFV than during CMV, regardless of the type of insufflation. By contrast, endobronchial insufflation maintained both arterial PCO2 and alveolar-arterial O2 partial pressure difference at significantly lower levels in dogs lying prone than in dogs lying supine. In dogs lying supine, the dependent lung was preferentially ventilated during CMV but not during CFV. In dogs lying prone, gas distribution was uniform with both modes of ventilation. The alveolar-arterial O2 partial pressure difference during CFV in dogs lying supine was negatively correlated with the reduced ventilation of the dependent lung, which suggests that increased ventilation-perfusion mismatching was responsible for the increase in alveolar-arterial O2 partial pressure difference. The more efficient oxygenation during CFV in dogs lying prone suggests a more efficient matching of ventilation to perfusion, presumably because the distribution of blood flow is also nearly uniform.     

Endotoxemia increases relative perfusion to dorsal-caudal lung regions.

Changes in the spatial distribution of perfusion during acute lung injury and their impact on gas exchange are poorly understood. We tested whether endotoxemia caused topographical differences in perfusion and whether these differences caused meaningful changes in regional ventilation-to-perfusion ratios and gas exchange. Regional ventilation and perfusion were measured in anesthetized, mechanically ventilated pigs in the prone position before and during endotoxemia with the use of aerosolized and intravenous fluorescent microspheres. On average, relative perfusion halved in ventral and cranial lung regions, doubled in caudal lung regions, and increased 1.5-fold in dorsal lung regions during endotoxemia. In contrast, there were no topographical differences in perfusion before endotoxemia and no topographical differences in ventilation at any time point. Consequently, endotoxemia increased regional ventilation-to-perfusion ratios in the caudal-to-cranial and dorsal-to-ventral directions, resulting in end-capillary PO2 values that were significantly lower in dorsal-caudal than ventral-cranial regions. We conclude that there are topographical differences in the pulmonary vascular response to endotoxin that may have important consequences for gas exchange in acute lung injury.     

Strength of pulmonary vascular response to regional alveolar hypoxia.

Regional alveolar hypoxia in the lung induces regional pulmonary vasoconstriction which diverts blood flow from the hypoxic area. However, the predominant determinant of the distribution of perfusion in the normal erect lung is gravity so that more perfusion occurs at the base than at the apex. To determine the strength of the regional alveolar hypoxic response in diverting flow with or against the gravity gradient a divided tracheal cannula was placed in anesthetized dogs and unilateral alveolar hypoxia created by venilating one lung with nitrogen while ventilating the other lung with oxygen to preserve normal systemic oxygentation. Scintigrams of the distribution of perfusion obtained with intravenous 13-N and the MGH positron camera revealed a 34 and 32 per cent decrease in perfusion to the hypoxic lung in the supine and erect positions and a 26 per cent decrease in the decubitus position with the hypoxic lung dependent (P equal to 0.94 from supine shift), indicating nearly equal vasoconstriction with shift of perfusion away from the hypoxic lung in all positions. Analysis of regional shifts in perfusion revealed an equal vasoconstrictor response from apex to base in the supine position but a greater response in the lower lung zones in the erect position where perfusion was also greatest.     

Effect of mechanical ventilation in the prone position on clinical outcomes in patients with acute hypoxemic respiratory failure: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Background

Mechanical ventilation in the prone position is used to improve oxygenation in patients with acute hypoxemic respiratory failure. We sought to determine the effect of mechanical ventilation in the prone position on mortality, oxygenation, duration of ventilation and adverse events in patients with acute hypoxemic respiratory failure.

Methods

In this systematic review we searched MEDLINE, EMBASE, the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials and Science Citation Index Expanded for articles published from database inception to February 2008. We also conducted extensive manual searches and contacted experts. We extracted physiologic data and clinically relevant outcomes.

Results

Thirteen trials that enrolled a total of 1559 patients met our inclusion criteria. Overall methodologic quality was good. In 10 of the trials (n = 1486) reporting this outcome, we found that prone positioning did not reduce mortality among hypoxemic patients (risk ratio [RR] 0.96, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.84–1.09; p = 0.52). The lack of effect of ventilation in the prone position on mortality was similar in trials of prolonged prone positioning and in patients with acute lung injury. In 8 of the trials (n = 633), the ratio of partial pressure of oxygen to inspired fraction of oxygen on day 1 was 34% higher among patients in the prone position than among those who remained supine (p < 0.001); these results were similar in 4 trials on day 2 and in 5 trials on day 3. In 9 trials (n = 1206), the ratio in patients assigned to the prone group remained 6% higher the morning after they returned to the supine position compared with patients assigned to the supine group (p = 0.07). Results were quantitatively similar but statistically significant in 7 trials on day 2 and in 6 trials on day 3 (p = 0.001). In 5 trials (n = 1004), prone positioning was associated with a reduced risk of ventilator-associated pneumonia (RR 0.81, 95% CI 0.66–0.99; p = 0.04) but not with a reduced duration of ventilation. In 6 trials (n = 504), prone positioning was associated with an increased risk of pressure ulcers (RR 1.36, 95% CI 1.07–1.71; p = 0.01). Most analyses found no to moderate between-trial heterogeneity.

Interpretation

Mechanical ventilation in the prone position does not reduce mortality or duration of ventilation despite improved oxygenation and a decreased risk of pneumonia. Therefore, it should not be used routinely for acute hypoxemic respiratory failure. However, a sustained improvement in oxygenation may support the use of prone positioning in patients with very severe hypoxemia, who have not been well-studied to date.Patients with acute lung injury^1,2 and hypoxemic respiratory failure may require mechanical ventilation to maintain oxygenation. Persistent hypoxemia may entail additional treatments, such as inhaled nitric oxide³ or high-frequency oscillation,^4–6 but these treatments are not universally available. In contrast, ventilation in the prone position, first recommended in 1974,⁷ can be readily implemented in any intensive care unit (ICU), and clinicians should be familiar with its effects on patient outcomes.Improved ventilation-perfusion matching is the major physiologic effect of prone positioning for ventilation in patients with acute lung injury.⁸ In the supine position, the dependent dorsal lung regions (compared with nondependent regions) are atelectatic owing to decreased transpulmonary pressure and direct compression by the lungs, heart and abdominal contents (via pressure on a passive diaphragm). Gravity favours increased perfusion to these collapsed dorsal lung segments, which creates shunt conditions. In the prone position, lung compression is decreased, and chest-wall and lung mechanics create more uniform transpulmonary pressure. The previously atelectatic lung thus becomes aerated, and new atelectasis in the now dependent ventral regions is comparatively minor. In addition, lung perfusion in the prone position is more homogeneous. Shunt conditions are therefore reduced and ventilation is better matched to perfusion. Other clinical effects of prone positioning may include enhanced postural drainage of secretions,^9,10 decreasing the risk of ventilator-associated pneumonia. Effects may also include decreased alveolar overdistension, cyclic alveolar collapse and ventilator-induced lung injury.¹¹ For this reason, some investigators have recommended prone positioning for mechanical ventilation in the treatment of acute lung injury.^8,11 Although ventilation in the prone position offers physiologic advantages and does not require specialized tools, one survey found that in most ICUs, 3 personnel (range 2–6) were required to turn an adult patient.¹² These caregivers must handle major safety challenges in putting patients with life-threatening hypoxemia in the prone position, including disconnection or removal of endotracheal tubes or intravascular catheters, and kinking or secretion-induced plugging of endotracheal tubes.¹³ Despite prone positioning''s physiologic advantages, individual randomized controlled trials have not demonstrated its superior clinical outcomes compared with supine positioning. Consequently, we conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis to evaluate the effect of prone positioning on clinical outcomes, including mortality, oxygenation, ventilator-associated pneumonia, duration of ventilation and adverse events, in patients with acute hypoxemic respiratory failure.     

Pleural pressure as a function of body position in rabbits

Pleural pressure was measured at end expiration in spontaneously breathing anesthetized rabbits. A liquid-filled capsule was implanted into a rib to measure pleural liquid pressure with minimal distortion of the pleural space. Capsule position relative to lung height was measured from thoracic radiographs. Measurements were made when the rabbits were in the prone, supine, right lateral, and left lateral positions. Average lung heights in the prone and supine positions were 4.21 +/- 0.58 and 4.42 +/- 0.51 (SD) cm, respectively (n = 7). Pleural pressure was -2.60 +/- 1.87 (SD) cmH2O at 50.2 +/- 7.75% lung height in the prone position and -3.10 +/- 1.22 cmH2O at 51.4 +/- 6.75% lung height in the supine position. There was no difference between the values recorded in the prone and supine positions. Placement of the capsule into the right or left chest had no effect on the magnitude of the pleural pressure recorded in rabbits in right and left lateral recumbency (n = 12). Measurements over the nondependent lung were repeatable when rabbits were turned between the right and left lateral positions. Lung height in laterally recumbent rabbits averaged 4.55 +/- 0.52 (SD) cm.