Testing for defensive synergy in Caribbean sponges: Bad taste or glass spicules?

Chemical and physical defenses of sessile organisms against consumers are well described for both terrestrial and marine systems. However, previous studies have focused on chemical or physical defenses in isolation, and have not considered their interaction. Marine sponges provide a model system for testing this interaction. Some sponge species produce secondary metabolites that deter predation; they may also contain siliceous spicules, but previous studies have provided little evidence that spicules in isolation offer any defense against generalist fish predators. To determine whether the two components have an additive, antagonistic, or synergistic interaction, crude organic extracts and spicules from individuals of 8 Caribbean sponge species were isolated and tested in laboratory feeding assays. These included one chemically defended reef sponge (Agelas clathrodes) and seven known to be intermediately deterrent: six from reef habitats (Cinachyrella alloclada, Clathria virgultosa, Cribrochalina infundibulum, Niphates digitalis, Svenzea zeai, and Xestospongia muta) and one from mangrove habitats (Tedania ignis). Extracts and spicules were assayed at various concentrations, both individually and in combination, in laboratory feeding assays with the bluehead wrasse, Thalassoma bifasciatum. A SAS based GENMOD procedure based on an isobolographic analysis model was used for statistical comparisons. Four sponges (A. clathrodes, C. alloclada, C. virgultosa, and one of three individuals of X. muta) showed evidence of synergisms. Of these, synergy in C. alloclada, C. virgultosa, and X. muta was caused by approximately natural concentrations of extracts and spicules. The extract of A. clathrodes was deterrent, but combination assays required nearly a 3-fold reduction in extract concentration and an 8-fold increase in spicule concentration to show the synergistic effect. Contrary to previous findings, spicules from C. infundibulum and two of three individuals of X. muta were deterrent at natural concentrations. Sponge spicules may be defensive in isolation, or may enhance chemical defenses against consumers, but the lack of synergisms for individuals in 4 of 7 species with intermediate levels of chemical defense suggests that defensive synergy is not the general rule and, when present, may be an example of an exaptation.     

Chemical and physical defenses against predators in Cystodytes (Ascidiacea)

Ascidians utilize both physical (spicules, tunic toughness) and chemical defenses (secondary metabolites, acidity) and suffer relatively little predation by generalist predators. The genus Cystodytes (Polycitoridae) is distributed widely in both tropical and temperate waters. Secondary metabolite composition, calcareous spicules and tunic acidity (pH < 1) may act as redundant defense mechanisms against predation in this genus. To assess the relative importance of chemical and physical defenses against predation in ascidians, we studied purple and blue morphs of Cystodytes from the western Mediterranean (formerly assigned to Cystodytes dellechiajei, but recently shown to belong to two different species), and a purple morph from Guam (USA), identified as Cystodytes violatinctus. Crude extracts, spicules, ascididemin (the major alkaloid of the blue morph) and acidity were used in feeding trials to evaluate chemical and physical defense mechanisms in Cystodytes spp. We performed feeding experiments in the field with a guild of generalist fish (mostly damselfish), and in the laboratory with a sea urchin and a puffer fish. Our results showed that all crude extracts and ascididemin significantly deterred fish predation, but not sea urchin predation. However, neither acidity alone nor spicules at natural concentrations deterred feeding. These results and other studies on sponges and gorgonians suggest that secondary metabolites are the primary means of defense against fish predators. Spicules and tunic acidity may perform other ecological roles and/or target certain specialist predators.     

The role of the proteinase inhibitor ovorubin in apple snail eggs resembles plant embryo defense against predation

Background

Fieldwork has thoroughly established that most eggs are intensely predated. Among the few exceptions are the aerial egg clutches from the aquatic snail Pomacea canaliculata which have virtually no predators. Its defenses are advertised by the pigmented ovorubin perivitellin providing a conspicuous reddish coloration. The nature of the defense however, was not clear, except for a screening for defenses that identified a neurotoxic perivitellin with lethal effect on rodents.Ovorubin is a proteinase inhibitor (PI) whose role to protect against pathogens was taken for granted, according to the prevailing assumption. Through biochemical, biophysical and feeding experiments we studied the proteinase inhibitor function of ovorubin in egg defenses.

Methodology/Principal Findings

Mass spectrometry sequencing indicated ovorubin belongs to the Kunitz-type serine proteinase inhibitor family. It specifically binds trypsin as determined by small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and cross-linking studies but, in contrast to the classical assumption, it does not prevent bacterial growth. Ovorubin was found extremely resistant to in vitro gastrointestinal proteolysis. Moreover feeding studies showed that ovorubin ingestion diminishes growth rate in rats indicating that this highly stable PI is capable of surviving passage through the gastrointestinal tract in a biologically active form.

Conclusions

To our knowledge, this is the first direct evidence of the interaction of an egg PI with a digestive protease of potential predators, limiting predator''s ability to digest egg nutrients. This role has not been reported in the animal kingdom but it is similar to plant defenses against herbivory. Further, this would be the only defense model with no trade-offs between conspicuousness and noxiousness by encoding into the same molecule both the aposematic warning signal and an antinutritive/antidigestive defense. These defenses, combined with a neurotoxin and probably unpalatable factors would explain the near absence of predators, opening new perspectives in the study of the evolution and ecology of egg defensive strategies.     

Chemical defense of the eastern newt (Notophthalmus viridescens): variation in efficiency against different consumers and in different habitats

Amphibian secondary metabolites are well known chemically, but their ecological functions are poorly understood--even for well-studied species. For example, the eastern newt (Notophthalmus viridescens) is a well known secretor of tetrodotoxin (TTX), with this compound hypothesized to facilitate this salamander's coexistence with a variety of aquatic consumers across the eastern United States. However, this assumption of chemical defense is primarily based on observational data with low replication against only a few predator types. Therefore, we tested the hypothesis that N. viridescens is chemically defended against co-occurring fishes, invertebrates, and amphibian generalist predators and that this defense confers high survivorship when newts are transplanted into both fish-containing and fishless habitats. We found that adult eastern newts were unpalatable to predatory fishes (Micropterus salmoides, Lepomis macrochirus) and a crayfish (Procambarus clarkii), but were readily consumed by bullfrogs (Lithobates catesbeianus). The eggs and neonate larvae were also unpalatable to fish (L. macrochirus). Bioassay-guided fractionation confirmed that deterrence is chemical and that ecologically relevant concentrations of TTX would deter feeding. Despite predatory fishes rejecting eastern newts in laboratory assays, field experiments demonstrated that tethered newts suffered high rates of predation in fish-containing ponds. We suggest that this may be due to predation by amphibians (frogs) and reptiles (turtles) that co-occur with fishes rather than from fishes directly. Fishes suppress invertebrate consumers that prey on bullfrog larvae, leading to higher bullfrog densities in fish containing ponds and thus considerable consumption of newts due to bullfrog tolerance of newt chemical defenses. Amphibian chemical defenses, and consumer responses to them, may be more complex and indirect than previously appreciated.     

Ultrastructural Variation of Cuticular Layers in Cephalobinae (Nemata: Rhabditida)

The ultrastructure of the body wall cuticle in Acrobeles complexus, Cervidellus alutus, and Zeldia punctata was studied as a step toward understanding biological diversity within Cephalobinae, and to discover new characters for phylogeny-based classification of the suborder. In each species the cuticle consists of cortical, median, and basal layers. The cortical layer includes an external trilaminate and internal granular zone; the basal layer is striated. In Z. punctata the median layer is electron-lucent, vacuolar, and penetrates the cortical layer; it also includes periodically dense columns that apparently correspond to punctuations visible with light microscopy. In contrast, the median layer of the body wall cuticle in A. complexus and C. alutus is bisected by a zone that undulates parallel to the nematode surface and with periodicity corresponding to annuli. Phylogenetic analysis, using derived cuticle patterns of Cephalobinae, requires an understanding of ecological pressures that could result in convergent evolution of cuticle characters.     

Characterization of chemical defenses in ranid tadpoles against a fish predator

Tadpoles of some ranid species appear to possess chemical defenses against fish predators, but the chemicals have not been characterized. Here, we evaluated the vulnerability of three Japanese anuran tadpole species (Glandirana rugosa, Pelophylax nigromaculatus, and Hyla japonica) to a fish (Gnathopogon elongatus elongatus) and analyzed the defensive chemicals extracted from the unpalatable tadpoles. Additionally, we examined the defensive behavior of unpalatable tadpoles in response to fish chemical cues. The fish rejected both G. rugosa (83%) and P. nigromaculatus (48%), but not H. japonica (0%). Many of the rejected tadpoles survived (60–80%). Possible defensive chemicals were extracted by methanol from the skin of G. rugosa, but were not identifiable by gas chromatography–mass spectrometry because of small quantities. The chemicals have high polarity and non-volatility. When exposed to fish chemical cues, P. nigromaculatus decreased activity presumably as a defensive behavior, but G. rugosa did not. We demonstrated the presence of chemical defenses in at least two of these species and revealed that G. rugosa releases more effective or greater amounts of defense chemicals than P. nigromaculatus with respect to this fish predator. The increased efficacy of chemical defenses may correlate with decreasing defensive behavior.     

In situ tests on inducible defenses in Dictyota kunthii and Macrocystis integrifolia (Phaeophyceae) from the Chilean coast

Numerous experimental studies have reported inducible defenses in macroalgae, but most of them have been conducted in laboratory environments where algae were maintained detached from the substratum and in artificial flow regimes. The results of those experiments might not reflect the natural situation, which can only be studied in situ. We examined whether the brown macroalgae Dictyota kunthii (C. Agardh) Greville and Macrocystis integrifolia (Bory) show inducible defenses following exposure to different grazing levels (direct, water-borne cues from nearby grazed conspecifics, presence of a non-grazing herbivore and natural grazing) in field experiments, striving to maintain natural conditions as much as possible. We measured palatability of algae after exposure to different grazing levels by using live algae and agar-based food containing non-polar extracts. M. integrifolia showed no induction of defenses (at least not of non-polar compounds), suggesting constitutive defenses, absence of defenses (tolerance) or use of another strategy to avoid herbivory. These results are similar to those from previous laboratory experiments. In D. kunthii, defense was induced after two weeks of direct grazing by amphipods under field conditions. Water-borne cues from nearby grazed conspecifics, presence of a non-grazing herbivore and natural grazing did not induce defenses. Induction of defense in response to direct grazing agrees with results from a previous laboratory study, but while indirect cues induced defenses in the laboratory, there was no measurable induced defense in the field. Probably chemical cues from grazers are diluted quickly in the field, not reaching concentrations that cause induction of defenses. This might be the reason why in some algae induction by direct grazing is a more important defensive strategy than induction by water-borne cues. The results from our study also suggest that laboratory experiments showing induced defenses in response to grazed neighbours or mere grazer presence need to be interpreted with caution.     

Phylogenetic Relationships of a Distinct Species of Globodera from Portugal and Two Punctodera Species

Evolutionary relationships based on ribosomal DNA (rDNA) sequence data for a previously unknown species of Globodera from Portugal, Punctodera chalcoensis from Mexico, and P. punctata from Estonia, plus previously published sequences, support the following relationships: (((Cactodera weissi, G. artemisiae, C. milleri), ((G. sp. Bouro, G. sp. Canha, G. sp. Ladoeiro), ((G. pallida, G. rostochiensis), (P. chalcoensis, P. punctata)))), Heterodera avenae). Globodera sp. from Portugal, which can be confused with potato cyst nematodes by phytosanitary services when the identification is based only on morphological characters, is clearly different based on our molecular data. In addition, the rDNA data show the Globodera sp. to be only distantly related to other European Globodera species that parasitize Asteraceae. Punctodera chalcoensis and P. punctata form a sister clade to the G. pallida + G. rostochiensis clade.     

UV radiation affects antipredatory defense traits in Daphnia pulex

In aquatic environments, prey perceive predator threats by chemical cues called kairomones, which can induce changes in their morphology, life histories, and behavior. Predator‐induced defenses have allowed for prey, such as Daphnia pulex, to avert capture by common invertebrate predators, such as Chaoborus sp. larvae. However, the influence of additional stressors, such as ultraviolet radiation (UVR), on the Daphnia–Chaoborus interaction is not settled as UVR may for instance deactivate the kairomone. In laboratory experiments, we investigated the combined effect of kairomones and UVR at ecologically relevant levels on induced morphological defenses of two D. pulex clones. We found that kairomones were not deactivated by UVR exposure. Instead, UVR exposure suppressed induced morphological defense traits of D. pulex juveniles under predation threat by generally decreasing the number of neckteeth and especially by decreasing the size of the pedestal beneath the neckteeth. UVR exposure also decreased the body length, body width, and tail spine length of juveniles, likely additionally increasing the vulnerability to Chaoborus predation. Our results suggest potential detrimental effects on fitness and survival of D. pulex subject to UVR stress, with consequences on community composition and food web structure in clear and shallow water bodies.     

Chemical defense of an exotic coral as invasion strategy

The invasion success of exotic species has been frequently correlated to abiotic and biotic features of the receptor region and to the biological aspects of the invasive organism. There is, however, no information about defensive chemicals found in invasive species as strategy that could promote or facilitate an invasion in a marine environment. We conducted experimental field assays to verify the potential of secondary metabolites of an Indo-Pacific exotic soft coral, Stereonephthya aff. curvata, as a defensive chemical against generalist fish and as an allelopathic agent against the potential local competitor-the gorgonian Phyllogorgia dilatata-in Arraial do Cabo, on the southeastern coast of Brazil. As a result of our experiments, it was confirmed as an efficient chemical defense against fishes by crude coral hexanic extract. In addition to its role as defense against consumers, the field experimental assay also verified that chemicals from this exotic coral had an allelopatic effect causing large necrosis on tissues of the Brazilian endemic gorgonian P. dilatata. Both defensive strategies observed may facilitate the perpetuation and/or expansion and characterize an expressive, invasive facilitator for S. aff. curvata. The obtained results indicate that this exotic coral species may be a real threat to the biological integrity of the Arraial do Cabo Harvest Reserve, Rio de Janeiro. In addition, the study reveals that defensive chemicals can be used to predict the potential invasiveness of introduced species.     

Behavioral plasticity of the soft-shell clam, Mya arenaria (L.), in the presence of predators increases survival in the field

Soft-shell clams, Mya arenaria, are sessile, suspension-feeding bivalves that are preyed upon by the exotic green crab, Carcinus maenas. Clams evade crab consumers by burrowing deeper into the sediment after perceiving a threat from a nearby predator. The purpose of this study was to determine the types of signals that M. arenaria use to detect predators and the types of behaviors clams use to avoid being eaten. In a field study, clams increased their burial depth in the presence of green crab predators consuming conspecifics that were caged nearby, and also increased burial depth after artificial tactile stimulation in the laboratory assay. These results indicate that clams can use chemical and mechanical cues to detect potential predatory threats. We performed a field study to examine the difference in survivability of clams that had burrowed deeper into the sediment in response to predators vs. control clams that were burrowed less deeply. Significantly higher survival rates were observed in clams that had initially burrowed more deeply, suggesting that increasing burial depth is a valid predator avoidance strategy. Some bivalves also alter their pumping rates in the presence of predators, making them less apparent and providing more structural defense by covering soft tissue, and we measured pumping time of soft-shell clams in the presence and absence of predators, when burrowing was not an option for escape. Soft-shell clams did not alter their pumping time in the presence of green crab predators, possibly because they employ a burrowing method called “hydraulic” or “jet-propelled” burrowing, where it is necessary for the clam to pump in order to burrow. Chemical signals and tactile cues instigated behavioral changes in M. arenaria, and this change in behavior (increasing burial depth) increased clam survival in the field.     

Why are intertidal snails rare in the subtidal? Predation, growth and the vertical distribution of Littorina littorea (L.) in the Gulf of Maine

The North Atlantic gastropod Littorina littorea exhibits a characteristic “intertidal” distribution: the snail is abundant in the littoral zone but scarce in the shallow subtidal and the relatively few subtidal individuals are larger (in shell size) on average than those in the intertidal zone. For highly mobile species like L. littorea, this vertical distribution is primarily determined by directional movement. Biotic and abiotic factors vary across tidal heights, and natural selection for movement to shore levels where fitness is maximized provides the ultimate (evolutionary) explanation for vertical distribution patterns. In this study, we asked whether variation in growth rate and/or predation pressure among tidal heights provide an ultimate explanation for vertical gradients in L. littorea size and abundance. We used a cage experiment to compare juvenile growth rate among tidal heights and a series of field and laboratory experiments to examine variation in predation pressure among tidal heights and snail size classes. Juvenile growth rates were highest in the low intertidal zone, declining at both higher and lower levels. Predation risk for tethered L. littorea increased with both decreasing tidal height and decreasing body size (shell height). Almost all tethered prey were consumed by shell- breaking predators and a census revealed that the two most abundant such predators were the crabs Carcinus maenas and Cancer borealis. Laboratory feeding experiments were used to compare size-dependent prey vulnerability and prey-size preferences for these two key predators. We found that L. littorea vulnerability decreased with increasing snail size and increased with increasing size of both predator species. However, whereas C. borealis were capable of consuming even the largest L. littorea, most Carcinus were unable to feed on individuals larger than 10 mm in shell height. Additionally, C. borealis preferred larger sizes of L. littorea than did Carcinus. Thus, Carcinus, which co-occurs with L. littorea in the intertidal, is a much less effective predator than C. borealis, which is found primarily in the subtidal. We conclude that predation on L. littorea by C. borealis and other subtidal consumers has resulted in the scarcity of this ecologically important grazer in the subtidal. This effect has been produced both through direct predation and by imposing strong selection for movement of L. littorea to higher tidal zones.     

Factors determining tadpole vulnerability to predators: can prior experience compensate for a suboptimal shape?

We investigated the role of constitutive morphology and previous experience in predator avoidance in two anuran species associated with different larval habitats. In Rana temporaria, deeper tails and larger body size conferred selective advantage against dragonfly predation. Previous experience with predators had a positive influence on the survival of R. temporaria tadpoles equivalent to predator selection. By contrast, survival in Bufo bufo seems unrelated to tail shape or experience. This suggests that B. bufo lacks constitutive morphological defenses against insect predators, and that morphological and behavioral defenses could result more effective than chemical deterrents for these insect predators. A key novelty of this study is the observation that Rana tadpoles having prior experience with predators have an enhanced success in further encounters, and this occurs before the morphological induced defense has been established. This induced modification for R. temporaria, and its lack of for B. bufo, may be an important determinant of larval survival.     

The role of amphibian antimicrobial peptides in protection of amphibians from pathogens linked to global amphibian declines

Amphibian species have experienced population declines and extinctions worldwide that are unprecedented in recent history. Many of these recent declines have been linked to a pathogenic skin fungus, Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis, or to iridoviruses of the genus Ranavirus. One of the first lines of defense against pathogens that enter by way of the skin are antimicrobial peptides synthesized and stored in dermal granular glands and secreted into the mucus following alarm or injury. Here, I review what is known about the capacity of amphibian antimicrobial peptides from diverse amphibians to inhibit B. dendrobatidis or ranavirus infections. When multiple species were compared for the effectiveness of their in vitro antimicrobial peptides defenses against B. dendrobatidis, non-declining species of rainforest amphibians had more effective antimicrobial peptides than species in the same habitat that had recently experienced population declines. Further, there was a significant correlation between the effectiveness of the antimicrobial peptides and resistance of the species to experimental infection. These studies support the hypothesis that antimicrobial peptides are an important component of innate defenses against B. dendrobatidis. Some amphibian antimicrobial peptides inhibit ranavirus infections and infection of human T lymphocytes by the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). An effective antimicrobial peptide defense against skin pathogens appears to depend on a diverse array of genes expressing antimicrobial peptides. The production of antimicrobial peptides may be regulated by signals from the pathogens. However, this defense must also accommodate potentially beneficial microbes on the skin that compete or inhibit growth of the pathogens. How this delicate balancing act is accomplished is an important area of future research.     

Inducible Defenses with a "Twist": Daphnia barbata Abandons Bilateral Symmetry in Response to an Ancient Predator

Predation is one of the most important drivers of natural selection. In consequence a huge variety of anti-predator defenses have evolved in prey species. Under unpredictable and temporally variable predation pressure, the evolution of phenotypically plastic defensive traits is favored. These “inducible defenses”, range from changes in behavior, life history, physiology to morphology and can be found in almost all taxa from bacteria to vertebrates. An important group of model organisms in ecological, evolutionary and environmental research, water fleas of the genus Daphnia (Crustacea: Cladocera), are well known for their ability to respond to predators with an enormous variety of inducible morphological defenses. Here we report on the “twist”, a body torsion, as a so far unrecognized inducible morphological defense in Daphnia, expressed by Daphnia barbata exposed to the predatory tadpole shrimp Triops cancriformis. This defense is realized by a twisted carapace with the helmet and the tail spine deviating from the body axis into opposing directions, resulting in a complete abolishment of bilateral symmetry. The twisted morphotype should considerably interfere with the feeding apparatus of the predator, contributing to the effectiveness of the array of defensive traits in D. barbata. As such this study does not only describe a completely novel inducible defense in the genus Daphnia but also presents the first report of a free living Bilateria to flexibly respond to predation risk by abandoning bilateral symmetry.     

Trichomes as dangerous lollipops: Do lizards also use caterpillar body and frass odor to optimize their foraging?

When attacked by herbivores, plants produce toxic secondary metabolites that function as direct defenses, as well as indirect defenses that attract and reward predators of the offending herbivores. These indirect defenses include both nutritive rewards such as extra floral nectar, as well as informational rewards, such as the production and release of volatile compounds that betray the location of feeding herbivores to predators. Herbivory of Nicotiana attenuata by the tobacco hornworm (Manduca larvae) alters the volatile profiles of both the plant and larval headspace. Herbivory-elicited specific changes in the volatile profiles are detected by arthropod predators of Manduca larvae. The known predators that perceive volatile cues induced by Manduca herbivory of N. attenuata are insects that target Manduca at early developmental stages, when the larvae are still small; large, late-instar larvae may have outgrown these predation risks. However, here we offer evidence that branched chain aliphatic acids derived from the digestion of plant O-acyl sugars from trichomes may betray Manduca larvae to lizard predators during late developmental stages as well.     

Patterns of chemical defense among Caribbean gorgonian corals: a preliminary survey

Ship-board assays employing the common Caribbean wrasse Thalassoma bifasdatum (Bloch) were undertaken to determine the palatability of food pellets coated with freshly-extracted, lipid-soluble metabolites of 37 types of Caribbean gorgonian corals representing at least 19 species from 11 genera. Extracts of 19 types (51%) were highly unpalatable (zero or one of five pellets eaten), four types (11%) were moderately unpalatable (two or three of five pellets eaten) and 14 (38%) were palatable (four or five of five pellets eaten) to fish in feeding assays. Gorgonians of the genera Pterogorgia (three types) and Eunicea (nine types) were consistently highly unpalatable, those of the genus Plexaurella (four types) were palatable and those of the genus Plexaura were most frequently palatable (six of eight types). Further assays of serial dilutions of extracts from seven representative, unpalatable types revealed that extracts inhibited fish feeding at pellet concentrations near or below the concentrations that metabolites occur in the gorgonian soft tissue. Extracts of Erythropodium caribaeorum (Duchassaing and Michelotti) and Pseudopterogorgia rigida (Bielschowsky) deterred fish feeding at pellet concentrations less than an order of magnitude lower than those found in the soft tissues of the corresponding gorgonians. Thin layer chromatographic analyses of extracts revealed the presence of lipid-soluble, secondary metabolites in a majority of the highly unpalatable extracts, although secondary metabolites were also present in a smaller percentage of palatable extracts. These data support the hypothesis that the soft tissues of many gorgonian corals contain lipid-soluble feeding deterrents which act as a defense against predation.     

Dietary nitrogen availability in macroalgae enhances growth of the sea hare Aplysia californica (Opisthobranchia: Anaspidea)

Evidence suggests that marine herbivores select for prey items with elevated nitrogen content. We tested this hypothesis with experimental growth studies of the herbivorous gastropod Aplysia californica offered diets of the rhodophyte Gracilaria ferox with varying nitrogen content. A. californica had a sevenfold feeding preference by weight for G. ferox with higher tissue % N and % protein, and lower % C, % carbohydrate and carbon-to-nitrogen ratio (C/N) as compared to treatments with lower nitrogen and protein content. A. californica provided treatment diets of varying nitrogen availability (high, medium and low) also had significantly different growth rates within 30 days. The high N diet supported a two-fold higher growth rate than that of the medium N diet and four-fold higher than the low N treatment, with mean weights over the experiment reaching 20.4, 9.8, and 5.6 g, respectively. The evolutionary value of this dietary preference may facilitate faster growth to reproductive size, outgrowth of predators and sequestration of organic compounds from nitrogen-enriched macroalgae to deter predators. Despite recent attention, the importance of diet-derived compounds as anti-predatory chemical defenses in Aplysiids remains equivocal. Nitrogen-enriched macroalgal diets, however, may provide “primary metabolites” that serve as alternative defenses for Aplysiids.