Inverse Rap1 and phospho-ERK expression discriminate the maintenance phase of tolerance and priming of antigen-specific CD4+ T cells in vitro and in vivo

T cell recognition of Ag can result in priming or tolerance depending on the context in which Ag is recognized. Previously, we have reported that these distinct functional outcomes are associated with marked differences in the amplitude, kinetics, and cellular localization of activated, pERK signals at the level of individual Ag-specific T cells in vitro. Here, we show that the GTPase Rap1, which can antagonize the generation of such pERK signals and has been reported to accumulate in tolerant cells, exhibits an inverse pattern of expression to pERK in individual Ag-specific primed and tolerized T cells. Although pERK is expressed by more primed than tolerized T cells when rechallenged with Ag in vitro, Rap1 is expressed by higher percentages of tolerant compared with primed Ag-specific T cells. Moreover, whereas pERK localizes to the TCR and lipid rafts in primed cells, but exhibits a diffuse cellular distribution in tolerized cells, Rap1 colocalizes with the TCR and lipid raft structures under conditions of tolerance, but not priming, in vitro. This inverse relationship between Rap1 and pERK expression is physiologically relevant, given that we observed the same patterns in Ag-specific T cells in situ, following induction of priming and tolerance in vivo. Together, these data suggest that the maintenance of tolerance of individual Ag-specific T cells may reflect the recruitment of up-regulated Rap1 to the immune synapse, potentially resulting in sequestration of Raf-1 and uncoupling of the TCR from the Ras-ERK-MAPK cascade.     

Functional and biochemical characterization of a calcium-ionophore-induced state of unresponsiveness in a cytolytic T cell clone.

To characterize the requirements for the induction of an anergic state in immunocompetent cells we examined the effect of an increase in intracellular calcium concentration on the subsequent responsiveness of cytolytic T cells to antigenic stimulation in vitro. Pretreatment of a murine cytolytic T cell clone with the calcium-ionophore A23187 resulted in the induction of an anergic state characterized by a decrease in cytolytic activity and granule exocytosis upon Ag-specific stimulation. Furthermore, IFN-gamma synthesis declined whereas de novo synthesis of a yet unidentified protein with a molecular mass of 33 kDa as well as proliferative response of cells in response to exogenous IL-2 were unaffected. This state of partial unresponsiveness 1) could be prevented by concomitant pretreatment of cells with cyclosporin A or protein synthesis inhibitors and 2) was reversible within 48 h. Biochemical analysis of TCR-induced intracellular activation revealed a block in signal transduction before the activation of protein kinase C because cellular unresponsiveness could be bypassed by the phorbol ester PMA plus the calcium-ionophore A23187. However, phosphatidylinositol turnover was markedly inhibited in unresponsive cells that also did not show a calcium influx on stimulation with concanavalin A. We conclude that a rise in intracellular calcium in cytolytic T cells might not only be necessary for cellular activation but may also trigger the induction of a partial unresponsiveness to antigenic stimulation due to an inhibition in the early phase of signal transduction.     

Stimulation by soluble CD70 promotes strong primary and secondary CD8+ cytotoxic T cell responses in vivo

Identification of the signals required for optimal differentiation of naive CD8(+) T cells into effector and memory cells is critical for the design of effective vaccines. In this study we demonstrate that CD27 stimulation by soluble CD70 considerably enhances the magnitude and quality of the CD8(+) T cell response. Stimulation with soluble CD70 in the presence of Ag significantly enhanced the proliferation of CD8(+) T cells and their ability to produce IL-2 and IFN-gamma in vitro. Administration of Ag and soluble CD70 resulted in a massive (>300-fold) expansion of Ag-specific CD8(+) T cells in vivo, which was due to the enhanced proliferation and survival of activated T cells. In mice that received Ag and soluble CD70, CD8(+) T cells developed into effectors with direct ex vivo cytotoxicity. Furthermore, unlike peptide immunization, which resulted in a diminished response after rechallenge, CD27 stimulation during the primary challenge evoked a strong secondary response upon rechallenge with the antigenic peptide. Thus, in addition to increasing the frequency of primed Ag-specific T cells, CD27 signaling during the primary response instills a program of differentiation that allows CD8(+) T cells to overcome a state of unresponsiveness. Taken together these results demonstrate that soluble CD70 has potent in vivo adjuvant effects for CD8(+) T cell responses.     

IL-21 can supplement suboptimal Lck-independent MAPK activation in a STAT-3-dependent manner in human CD8(+) T cells

Although both MHC class II/CD8α double-knockout and CD8β null mice show a defect in the development of MHC class I-restricted CD8(+) T cells in the thymus, they possess low numbers of high-avidity peripheral CTL with limited clonality and are able to contain acute and chronic infections. These in vivo data suggest that the CD8 coreceptor is not absolutely necessary for the generation of Ag-specific CTL. Lack of CD8 association causes partial TCR signaling because of the absence of CD8/Lck recruitment to the proximity of the MHC/TCR complex, resulting in suboptimal MAPK activation. Therefore, there should exist a signaling mechanism that can supplement partial TCR activation caused by the lack of CD8 association. In this human study, we have shown that CD8-independent stimulation of Ag-specific CTL previously primed in the presence of CD8 coligation, either in vivo or in vitro, induced severely impaired in vitro proliferation. When naive CD8(+) T cells were primed in the absence of CD8 binding and subsequently restimulated in the presence of CD8 coligation, the proliferation of Ag-specific CTL was also severely hampered. However, when CD8-independent T cell priming and restimulation were supplemented with IL-21, Ag-specific CD8(+) CTL expanded in two of six individuals tested. We found that IL-21 rescued partial MAPK activation in a STAT3- but not STAT1-dependent manner. These results suggest that CD8 coligation is critical for the expansion of postthymic peripheral Ag-specific CTL in humans. However, STAT3-mediated IL-21 signaling can supplement partial TCR signaling caused by the lack of CD8 association.     

Reciprocal NFAT1 and NFAT2 nuclear localization in CD8+ anergic T cells is regulated by suboptimal calcium signaling

Anergy is an important mechanism of maintaining peripheral immune tolerance. T cells rendered anergic are refractory to further stimulation and are characterized by defective proliferation and IL-2 production. We used a model of in vivo anergy induction in murine CD8+ T cells to analyze the initial signaling events in anergic T cells. Tolerant T cells displayed reduced phospholipase Cgamma activation and calcium mobilization, indicating a defect in calcium signaling. This correlated with a block in nuclear localization of NFAT1 in anergic cells. However, we found that stimulation of anergic, but not naive T cells induced nuclear translocation of NFAT2. This suggested that NFAT2 is activated preferentially by reduced calcium signaling, and we confirmed this hypothesis by stimulating naive T cells under conditions of calcium limitation or partial calcineurin inhibition. Thus, our work provides new insight into how T cell stimulation conditions might dictate specific NFAT isoform activation and implicates NFAT2 involvement in the expression of anergy-related genes.     

Ectopic B-Raf expression enhances extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK) signaling in T cells and prevents antigen-presenting cell-induced anergy

T cells that receive stimulation through the T cell receptor (TCR) in the absence of costimulation become anergic and are refractory to subsequent costimulation. This unresponsiveness is associated with the constitutive activation of the small G protein, Rap1, and the lack of Ras-dependent activation of ERK. Recent studies suggest that Rap1 can activate the MAP kinase kinase kinase B-Raf that is either endogenously or ectopically expressed. Peripheral T cells generally do not express B-Raf; therefore, to test the hypothesis that ectopic expression of B-Raf could permit Rap1 to activate ERK signaling, we generated transgenic mice expressing B-Raf within peripheral T cells. This converted Rap1 into an activator of ERK, to enhance ERK activation and proliferation following TCR engagement in the absence of costimulation. When T cells were incubated with engineered APCs presenting antigen on I-Ek and expressing low levels of B7, they became anergic, displayed constitutive activation of Rap1, and were deficient in Ras and ERK activation. However, when incubated with the same APCs, T cells expressing the B-Raf transgene proliferated upon restimulation and displayed elevated ERK activation. Thus B-Raf expression and enhanced ERK activation is sufficient to prevent anergy in a model of APC-induced T cell anergy. However, studies using anti-TCR antibody-induced anergy showed that the ability of ERKs to reverse T cell anergy is dependent on the anergic model utilized.     

Regulation of the maintenance of peripheral T-cell anergy by TAB1-mediated p38 alpha activation

In anergic T cells, T-cell receptor (TCR)-mediated responses are functionally inactivated by negative regulatory signals whose mechanisms are poorly understood. Here, we show that CD4(+) T cells anergized in vivo by superantigen Mls-1(a) express a scaffolding protein, transforming growth factor beta-activated protein kinase 1-binding protein 1 (TAB1), that negatively regulates TCR signaling through the activation of mitogen-activated protein kinase p38 alpha. TAB1 was not expressed in naive and activated CD4(+) T cells. Inhibition of p38 activity in anergic T cells by a chemical inhibitor resulted in the recovery of interleukin 2 (IL-2) and the inhibition of IL-10 secretion. T-cell hybridoma 2B4 cells transduced with TAB1-containing retrovirus (TAB1-2B4 cells) showed activated p38 alpha, inhibited extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK) activity, culminating in reduced IL-2 levels and increased IL-10 production. The use of a p38 inhibitor or cotransfection of a dominant-negative form of p38 in TAB1-2B4 cells resulted in the recovery of ERK activity and IL-2 production. These results imply that TAB1-mediated activation of p38 alpha in anergic T cells regulates the maintenance of T-cell unresponsiveness both by inhibiting IL-2 production and by promoting IL-10 production.     

Absence of CTLA-4 lowers the activation threshold of primed CD8+ TCR-transgenic T cells: lack of correlation with Src homology domain 2-containing protein tyrosine phosphatase

To examine the role of CTLA-4 in controlling Ag-specific CD8(+) T cell activation, TCR-transgenic/CTLA-4 wild-type or -deficient mice were generated in a recombination-activating gene 2-deficient background. Naive T cells from these mice responded comparably whether or not CTLA-4 was expressed. In contrast, primed T cells responded more vigorously if they lacked CTLA-4 expression. We took advantage of the difference between naive and primed T cell responses to approach the mechanism of CTLA-4 function. Single-cell analyses demonstrated that a greater fraction of CTLA-4-deficient cells responded to a fixed dose of Ag compared with CTLA-4-expressing cells, whereas the magnitude of response per cell was comparable. A shift in the dose-response curve to APCs was also observed such that fewer APCs were required to activate CTLA-4-deficient T cells to produce intracellular IFN-gamma and to proliferate. These results suggest that CTLA-4 controls the threshold of productive TCR signaling. Biochemical analysis comparing stimulated naive and primed TCR-transgenic cells revealed no obvious differences in expression of total CTLA-4, tyrosine-phosphorylated CTLA-4, and associated Src homology domain 2-containing protein tyrosine phosphatase. Thus, the biochemical mechanism explaining the differential inhibitory effect of CTLA-4 on naive and primed CD8(+) T cells remains unclear.     

Hierarchical signaling thresholds determine the fates of naíve T cells: partial priming leads nai;ve T cells to unresponsiveness

Differing conditions of antigen priming varying either the concentration or affinity of T cell receptor (TCR) ligands greatly alter T cell responses. Here, we demonstrate that antigen-specific CD4(+) nai;ve T cells primed with either altered peptide ligands (APLs) or a minimal concentration of antigen peptide become anergic without observable cell divisions. Transforming growth factor-beta1 (TGF-beta1) expression was induced 24h following in these stimulation conditions producing anergic cells. Productively stimulated nai;ve T cells expressed IL-2 to differentiate into T helper 1 (Th1) cells, secreting interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) upon secondary antigen stimulation; T cells primed with an APL did not secrete either interleukin-4 (IL-4) or IFN-gamma, but expressed TGF-beta1 and Tob, a member of the anti-proliferative gene family. Therefore, T cell responses are regulated by TCR signaling depending on the extent of TCR engagement. These results suggest that partial antigen stimulation in the periphery can induce nai;ve CD4(+)T cell unresponsiveness.     

B lymphocytes as antigen-presenting cells for CD4+ T cell priming in vivo

The contribution of B lymphocytes as APCs for CD4+ T cell priming remains controversial, based on findings that B cells cannot provide the requisite ligating and costimulatory signals for naive T cells to be activated. In the current study, we have examined Ag-specific T:B cell collaboration under circumstances in which B cells take up Ag through Ig receptors in vivo. This results in their activation and an ability to effectively stimulate naive CD4+ T cells both in vitro and in vivo. The aim of this work was to establish some of the key molecular interactions, as well as kinetics, between Ag-specific T and B cells that enable this priming to take place. Our approach was to amplify the starting pools of both Ag-specific T and B cell populations in vivo to track directly the events during initial T:B cell collaborations. We show that the induction of optimal levels of T cell priming to a protein Ag requires the involvement of Ag-specific B cells. The interaction that results between Ag-specific T and B cells prevents the down-modulation of B7 costimulatory molecules usually observed in the absence of appropriate T cells. Moreover, this prevention in down-modulation is independent of CD40:CD40 ligand contact. Finally, we present data suggesting that once Ag-specific T and B cells interact, there is a rapid (1-2-h) down-regulation of antigenic complexes on the surface of the B lymphocytes, possibly to prevent them from engaging other T cells in the vicinity and therefore focus the initial interaction.     

Antigen-experienced T cells undergo a transient phase of unresponsiveness following optimal stimulation

Interaction of the Ag-specific receptor of T lymphocytes with its Ag/MHC ligand can lead either to cell activation or to a state of unresponsiveness often referred to as anergy. It has been generally assumed that anergy develops as a consequence of inadequate stimulation, such as in response to altered peptide ligands or to agonists presented by costimulatory-deficient accessory cells. The present study uncovers an alternative way of inducing an unresponsive state in T cells. Indeed, we demonstrate herein that Ag-stimulation of murine CD4+ Th clones induces cellular activation, characterized by cytokine production and cell proliferation, followed by a state of transient (lasting up to 6 days) unresponsiveness to further antigenic stimulation. This state of activation-induced unresponsiveness 1) is not a consequence of inadequate costimulation, as it occurs when cells are stimulated in the presence of dendritic cells or anti-CD28 Abs; 2) develops after an optimal response to Ag; 3) is not due to cell death/apoptosis or CTLA-4 engagement; 4) down-regulates the proliferation and cytokine production of both Th1- and Th2-like clones; and 5) does not affect the early steps of signal transduction. Finally, naive T cells are not sensitive to this novel form of unresponsiveness, but become gradually susceptible to activation-induced unresponsiveness upon Ag stimulation. Collectively, these data suggest that activation-induced T cell unresponsiveness may represent a regulatory mechanism limiting the clonal expansion and effector cell function of Ag-experienced T cells, thus contributing to the homeostasis of an immune response.     

Induction of rapid T cell activation, division, and recirculation by intratracheal injection of dendritic cells in a TCR transgenic model

Dendritic cells (DCs) are thought to be responsible for sensitization to inhaled Ag and induction of adaptive immunity in the lung. The characteristics of T cell activation in the lung were studied after transfer of Ag-pulsed bone marrow-derived DCs into the airways of naive mice. Cell division of Ag-specific T cells in vivo was followed in a carboxyfluorescein diacetate succinimidyl ester-labeled cohort of naive moth cytochrome c-reactive TCR transgenic T cells. Our adoptive transfer system was such that transferred DCs were the only cells expressing the MHC molecule required for presentation of cytochrome c to transgenic T cells. Ag-specific T cell activation and proliferation occurred rapidly in the draining lymph nodes of the lung, but not in nondraining lymph nodes or spleen. No bystander activation of non-Ag-specific T cells was induced. Division of Ag-specific T cells was accompanied by transient expression of CD69, while up-regulation of CD44 increased with each cell division. Divided cells had recirculated to nondraining lymph nodes and spleen by day 4 of the response. In vitro restimulation with specific Ag revealed that T cells were primed to proliferate more strongly and to produce higher amounts of cytokines per cell. These data are consistent with the notion that DCs in the lung are extremely efficient in selecting Ag-reactive T cells from a diverse repertoire. The response is initially localized in the mediastinal lymph nodes, but subsequently spreads systemically. This system should allow us to study the early events leading to sensitization to inhaled Ag.     

Establishment of unresponsiveness in primed B lymphocytes in vivo

As an approach to examine the influence of the state of cellular activation on the ability to tolerize B cells, the induction of unresponsiveness in human gamma-globulin-(HGG) primed B lymphocytes was studied in an adoptive transfer system. In contrast to transferred normal spleen cells, spleen cells from HGG-primed mice are not readily rendered unresponsive when exposed to the tolerogen, deaggregated HGG (DHGG), in irradiated recipients. A kinetic study showed that unfractionated primed spleen cells do not respond to an antigenic challenge given between 6 and 10 days after cell transfer and injection of DHGG, indicating that they are transiently depressed. In contrast, isolated primed B cells are tolerized when transferred to recipients and treated with DHGG in the absence of T cells. Furthermore, primed B cells exposed to tolerogen in the recipients do not recover the ability to respond to HGG either after a secondary challenge with AHGG given up to 14 days after transfer, or after 2 consecutive challenges given on days 14 and 24 after transfer. The presence of primed T cells at the time of tolerization interferes with the induction of unresponsiveness in these primed B cells. These studies suggest that the presence of primed T cells is responsible for the inability to tolerize unfractionated primed spleen cells populations and that primed B cells themselves are not intrinsically resistant to the induction of unresponsiveness.     

Hyperproliferative response of a monoclonal memory CD8 T cell population is characterized by an increased frequency of clonogenic precursors

Strong memory T cell responses result partly from the selection of Ag-specific clones during immunization. In this study, we show that a monoclonal CD8 T cell population expressing a unique TCR is heterogeneous in terms of clonogenic potential following activation under optimal conditions. More importantly, the frequency of clonogenic cells is strongly increased among Ag-experienced cells, indicating that these cells were either generated or selected during the in vivo primary response. Moreover, strong proliferative responses of primed cells result from this enhanced frequency, as proliferating naive and primed cells display the same cycling parameters, i.e., lag time and intermitotic interval. Hence, these results suggest that the clonogenic potential of individual cells is imprinted before Ag encounter and that clonogenic precursors are selected or generated following in vivo activation.     

Dendritic cell programming by cytomegalovirus stunts naive T cell responses via the PD-L1/PD-1 pathway

Early during infection, CMV targets dendritic cells (DC) and alters their functions. Herein we show that CMV-infected DC maintain the ability to present both virus-derived and exogenous Ags, but that they actively induce tolerance or anergy in Ag-specific T cells. CMV accomplishes this by selectively maintaining high-level expression of the negative costimulatory molecule programmed death ligand-1 (PD-L1), while commensurately down-regulating positive costimulatory molecules and MHC on the DC surface. Consequently, CD4 and CD8 T cells activated by these infected DC have a stunted phenotype, characterized by poor proliferation, effector function. and recall responses. Blocking PD-L1, but not PD-L2, during direct priming of naive T cells by infected DC significantly restores Ag-specific T cell functions. Using systems where direct and cross-priming of T cells can be distinguished revealed that PD-L1/PD-1 signaling contributes only when naive T cells are primed directly by infected DC, and not upon cross-presentation of viral Ags by uninfected DC. These data suggest that murine CMV programs infected DC during acute infection to inhibit early host adaptive antiviral responses by tipping the balance between negative and positive cosignals.     

TGF-beta inhibits IL-2 production and promotes cell cycle arrest in TCR-activated effector/memory T cells in the presence of sustained TCR signal transduction

TGF-beta signaling is critical for controlling naive T cell homeostasis and differentiation; however, the biological and biochemical changes induced by TGF-beta in effector/memory T cells are poorly defined. We show that although TGF-beta inhibits effector/memory peripheral blood T lymphoblast proliferation and IL-2 production, the intensity and kinetics for TCR-induced global tyrosine phosphorylation are markedly increased compared with that in untreated cells or naive T cells. After TCR ligation, tyrosine phosphorylation of proximal tyrosine kinases and docking proteins like linker for activation of T cells is maintained for >30 min in TGF-beta-primed cells compared with untreated cells where phosphorylation of these targets returned to basal levels by 10 min. Extended phosphorylation of linker for activation of T cells in treated peripheral blood T selectively prolongs ERK 1/2 signaling and phospholipase C-gamma1 activation leading to increased Ca(2+) flux. A kinase/phosphatase imbalance could not account for extended phosphorylation as CD45R, SHP-1, and SHP-2 expression remains unaltered. The contradiction between prolonged signal transduction and inhibition of proliferation is partially explained by the observation that TGF-beta priming results in ERK 1/2-independent p21 induction and decreased cyclin D1 expression leading to accumulation of T cells in G(0)/G(1) phases of the cell cycle and cell cycle arrest. Despite inhibition of T cell function by TGF-beta priming, TCR and cytokine signaling pathways are intact and selectively extended, suggesting that suppression in the effector/memory T cell is mediated by reprogramming signal transduction, rather than its inhibition as in the naive T cell.     

Anergic Th1 cells express altered levels of the protein tyrosine kinases p56lck and p59fyn.

Tolerance in T lymphocytes can result from clonal anergy, or paralysis, of Ag-specific T cells. To investigate the molecular mechanisms responsible for anergy, a system in which tolerance can be induced in vitro was employed. Anergy, as defined by long-lived nonresponsiveness to normal antigenic stimulation for IL-2 production, was produced in cloned murine CD4+ Th1 cells. Here we report that such anergic Th1 cells express constitutively reduced amounts of the protein tyrosine kinase p56lck and constitutively elevated levels of the protein tyrosine kinase p59fyn. Because protein tyrosine phosphorylation is known to be important for the normal induction of IL-2 synthesis, these results suggest that T cell anergy may be maintained, at least in part, by alterations in tyrosine phosphorylation signaling events.