3D tumour models: novel in vitro approaches to cancer studies

3D in vitro models have been used in cancer research as a compromise between 2-dimensional cultures of isolated cancer cells and the manufactured complexity of xenografts of human cancers in immunocompromised animal hosts. 3D models can be tailored to be biomimetic and accurately recapitulate the native in vivo scenario in which they are found. These 3D in vitro models provide an important alternative to both complex in vivo whole organism approaches, and 2D culture with its spatial limitations. Approaches to create more biomimetic 3D models of cancer include, but are not limited to, (i) providing the appropriate matrix components in a 3D configuration found in vivo, (ii) co-culturing cancer cells, endothelial cells and other associated cells in a spatially relevant manner, (iii) monitoring and controlling hypoxia- to mimic levels found in native tumours and (iv) monitoring the release of angiogenic factors by cancer cells in response to hypoxia. This article aims to overview current 3D in vitro models of cancer and review strategies employed by researchers to tackle these aspects with special reference to recent promising developments, as well as the current limitations of 2D cultures and in vivo models. 3D in vitro models provide an important alternative to both complex in vivo whole organism approaches, and 2D culture with its spatial limitations. Here we review current strategies in the field of modelling cancer, with special reference to advances in complex 3D in vitro models.     

Intestinal tissue and cell cultures

The culture of animal cells and tissues is a widely used technique in the field of cellular and molecular biology; one of the most interesting aspect being linked to the study of the mechanisms of cell differentiation. In the specific case of intestinal epithelial cells, various tissue culture technologies have proved to be important tools for the study of precise facets related to intestinal function, pathology and differentiation. Concerning this latter aspect, organ culture experiments have brought about interesting data on the hormonal or nutritional control of intestinal maturation. Nevertheless, the study of the precise mechanisms underlying epithelial proliferation and/or differentiation at the cellular level needs more adequate cell culture model systems. One of them has been described for two cell lines derived from human colonic adenocarcinomas, in which the cells can be induced to achieve enterocytic-like differentiation. Up to date, none of the continuous cell lines starting from normal undifferentiated cells have allowed generation of morphological or functional enterocytic polarity. In contrast, primary cell cultures which allow maintenance of a more physiological environment for the epithelial cells like contacts with their in vivo counterparts, mesenchymal cells or extracellular matrix molecules, have proved to be promising approaches.     

How to model the events in cutaneous fibrosis?

Skin fibrosis is classically seen as the consequence of chronic inflammation and altered healing response that is characterized by the differentiation of fibroblasts into secretory myofibroblasts and accumulation of connective tissue. Although fibrosis severely affects organ function and causes esthetic defects, no effective therapy is currently available to attenuate the fibrogenic process probably because the fibrogenic process is more complex than previously thought. Indeed, it might involve several interacting and mutually dependent cell types (fibroblasts, keratinocytes, endothelial cells, inflammatory cells), numerous paracrine factors, bio-active molecules and micro-environmental stimuli (growth factors, vasoactive peptides, balance between pro- and anti-inflammatory cytokines, coagulation system, reactive oxygen species, extracellular matrix...). In this perspective, the traditional approach that model individual cell response in simple cell culture system is probably inadequate and too simplistic. This article reviews the new models used to study skin fibrosis in vitro, in organotypic culture systems and in vivo and examines how these different models might be used to identify new molecular pathways involved in fibrogenesis. The monolayer cultures allow the study of fibrogenic signals induced by a single factor on a single cell type. Isolation of cells from fibrotic tissue allows to define the fibrogenic differentiation acquired in vivo. The organotypic models allow cell to cell and cell to matrix interaction and the experimental models in pigs and mice allowed studies in integrated physiological systems. These various and complementary models would also provide new tools to develop and test new drugs and treatments.     

Confocal microscopy of cells implanted into tissue blocks: Cell migration in long-term histocultures

Summary In three-dimensional tissues in vivo, cells find themselves in a unique, heterogeneous microenvironment among various cellular and noncellular elements. Cells are greatly affected by and contribute to their physical and chemical microenvironments. However, live cells are currently studied predominantly in homogeneous monolayer cultures where newly established contacts might be fundamentally different from contacts in vivo. Several systems have been suggested to simulate the three-dimensional environment of real tissue. In this report, we describe a new system for studying cell behavior inside real tissues in vitro. By fluorescently labeling mouse tumor cells, then implanting them into cultured tissue blocks (histocultures), we have observed cellular location and followed their locomotion, within tissues in vitro for days. We discuss the potential of the described system for studying different aspects of cell behavior in a nativelike microenvironment.     

Organotypical tissue cultures from adult murine colon as an in vitro model of intestinal mucosa

Together with animal experiments, organotypical cell cultures are important models for analyzing cellular interactions of the mucosal epithelium and pathogenic mechanisms in the gastrointestinal tract. Here, we introduce a three-dimensional culture model from the adult mouse colon for cell biological investigations in an in vivo-like environment. These explant cultures were cultured for up to 2 weeks and maintained typical characteristics of the intestinal mucosa, including a high-prismatic epithelium with specific epithelial cell-to-cell connections, a basal lamina and various connective tissue cell types, as analyzed with immunohistological and electron microscopic methods. The function of the epithelium was tested by treating the cultures with dexamethasone, which resulted in a strong upregulation of the serum- and glucocorticoid-inducible kinase 1 similar to that found in vivo. The culture system was investigated in infection experiments with the fungal pathogen Candida albicans. Wildtype but not Deltacph1/Deltaefg1-knockout Candida adhered to, penetrated and infiltrated the epithelial barrier. The results demonstrate the potential usefulness of this intestinal in vitro model for studying epithelial cell-cell interactions, cellular signaling and microbiological infections in a three-dimensional cell arrangement.     

Modeling tissue morphogenesis and cancer in 3D

Three-dimensional (3D) in vitro models span the gap between two-dimensional cell cultures and whole-animal systems. By mimicking features of the in vivo environment and taking advantage of the same tools used to study cells in traditional cell culture, 3D models provide unique perspectives on the behavior of stem cells, developing tissues and organs, and tumors. These models may help to accelerate translational research in cancer biology and tissue engineering.     

Three-dimensional organotypic models of human colonic epithelium to study the early stages of enteric salmonellosis

In vitro cell culture models used to study how Salmonella initiates disease at the intestinal epithelium would benefit from the recognition that organs and tissues function in a three-dimensional (3-D) environment and that this spatial context is necessary for development of cultures that more realistically resemble in vivo tissues/organs. Our aim was to establish and characterize biologically meaningful 3-D models of human colonic epithelium and apply them to study the early stages of enteric salmonellosis. The human colonic cell line HT-29 was cultured in 3-D and characterized by immunohistochemistry, histology, and scanning electron microscopy. Wild-type Salmonella typhimurium and an isogenic SPI-1 type three secretion system (TTSS) mutant derivative (invA) were used to compare the interactions with 3-D cells and monolayers in adherence/invasion, tissue pathology, and cytokine expression studies. The results showed that 3-D culture enhanced many characteristics normally associated with fully differentiated, functional intestinal epithelia in vivo, including better organization of junctional, extracellular matrix, and brush-border proteins, and highly localized mucin production. Wild-type Salmonella demonstrated increased adherence, but significantly lower invasion for 3-D cells. Interestingly, the SPI-I TTSS mutant showed wild-type ability to invade into the 3-D cells but did not cause significant structural changes to these cells. Moreover, 3-D cells produced less interleukin-8 before and after Salmonella infection. These results suggest that 3-D cultures of human colonic epithelium provide valuable alternative models to study human enteric salmonellosis with potential for novel insight into Salmonella pathogenesis.     

Live imaging of wound inflammation in Drosophila embryos reveals key roles for small GTPases during in vivo cell migration

Aa robust inflammatory response to tissue damage and infection is conserved across almost all animal phyla. Neutrophils and macrophages, or their equivalents, are drawn to the wound site where they engulf cell and matrix debris and release signals that direct components of the repair process. This orchestrated cell migration is clinically important, and yet, to date, leukocyte chemotaxis has largely been studied in vitro. Here, we describe a genetically tractable in vivo wound model of inflammation in the Drosophila melanogaster embryo that is amenable to cinemicroscopy. For the first time, we are able to examine the roles of Rho-family small GTPases during inflammation in vivo and show that Rac-mediated lamellae are essential for hemocyte motility and Rho signaling is necessary for cells to retract from sites of matrix- and cell-cell contacts. Cdc42 is necessary for maintaining cellular polarity and yet, despite in vitro evidence, is dispensable for sensing and crawling toward wound cues.     

In vitro and in vivo responses of saccular and caudal nucleus neurons in the grassfrog (Rana temporaria).

We present results from in vitro and in vivo studies of response properties of neurons in the saccular and caudal nuclei in the frog. In the in vitro studies the saccular nerve of the isolated brain was stimulated with electrical pulses. In the in vivo experiments, the neurons were stimulated by dorso-ventral vibrations of the intact animal. We identified six response types: (1) primary-like cells with short latencies and follow repetition rates up to 100 Hz; (2) phasic cells responding only to the first pulse in a train; (3) bursting cells firing several spikes in response to any stimulation; (4) late responders with very long latencies; (5) integrator cells showing facilitated responses, and (6) inhibitory cells inhibited by saccular nerve stimulation.The cells have comparable sensitivity and frequency characteristics to the primary fibres (BF 10-80 Hz, thresholds from 0.01 cm/s2) and enable a sophisticated analysis of vibrational stimuli.     

Spatial organization of extracellular matrix and fibroblast activity: effects of serum, transforming growth factor beta, and fibronectin

The goal of our research is to understand reciprocal relationships between cell function and tissue organization. We studied the regulation of fibroblast activity in an in vitro culture model that recapitulates in continuous fashion the cycle of events occurring during connective tissue repair. We present evidence that concomitant with spatial reorganization of the extracellular matrix, there was a dramatic decline in extracellular matrix synthesis and cell proliferation. Therefore, spatial reorganization was a crucial turning point for fibroblast activity. Factors that regulated the timing of spatial reorganization included serum, transforming growth factor beta, and fibronectin. By accelerating spatial reorganization of the cultures, transforming growth factor beta led to a relative decrease in cell proliferation and extracellular matrix synthesis. By retarding spatial reorganization of the cultures, fibronectin led to a relative increase in cell proliferation and extracellular matrix synthesis. The results indicate that spatial information in the three-dimensional cell-matrix interaction permits higher order, tissue-level regulation of fibroblast function.     

Collagen-based cell migration models in vitro and in vivo

Fibrillar collagen is the most abundant extracellular matrix (ECM) constituent which maintains the structure of most interstitial tissues and organs, including skin, gut, and breast. Density and spatial alignments of the three-dimensional (3D) collagen architecture define mechanical tissue properties, i.e. stiffness and porosity, which guide or oppose cell migration and positioning in different contexts, such as morphogenesis, regeneration, immune response, and cancer progression. To reproduce interstitial cell movement in vitro with high in vivo fidelity, 3D collagen lattices are being reconstituted from extracted collagen monomers, resulting in the re-assembly of a fibrillar meshwork of defined porosity and stiffness. With a focus on tumor invasion studies, we here evaluate different in vitro collagen-based cell invasion models, employing either pepsinized or non-pepsinized collagen extracts, and compare their structure to connective tissue in vivo, including mouse dermis and mammary gland, chick chorioallantoic membrane (CAM), and human dermis. Using confocal reflection and two-photon-excited second harmonic generation (SHG) microscopy, we here show that, depending on the collagen source, in vitro models yield homogeneous fibrillar texture with a quite narrow range of pore size variation, whereas all in vivo scaffolds comprise a range from low- to high-density fibrillar networks and heterogeneous pore sizes within the same tissue. Future in-depth comparison of structure and physical properties between 3D ECM-based models in vitro and in vivo are mandatory to better understand the mechanisms and limits of interstitial cell movements in distinct tissue environments.     

Apoptosis in a tissue-like culture model of human colorectal adenoma cells

Tissue-like cultures of LT97 human colonic adenoma cells were produced by plating on reconstructed connective tissue supports (CTR) containing colon-associated fibroblasts to form mucosal monolayers and polyp-like structures closely resembling the in vivo situation. Tight cell-cell contacts and a high density of desmosomes were observed in 93.8+/-3.5% of the section area for CTR cultures, but only in 17.8+/-10.0% of the area for cultures on collagen gels (CG) without fibroblasts. While LT97 cultures on plastic shed apoptotic bodies into the medium, they collected at the basal pole of the cell layer in the CTR cultures as is also observed in adenoma tissue. Only a small proportion was released into the medium as shown by the detection of apoptosis specific keratin fragments, which could be increased by 100microM of quercetin and resveratrol. In addition, tissue-like structures altered the relative effectivity of test compounds. As the tissue-like conditions closely resemble the situation in vivo tissue-like cultures are an important step towards the establishment of tissue reconstructs that can replace animal models in the analysis of basic mechanisms of growth control and the testing of tumor promoting and chemopreventive compounds and may even be superior in terms of predictivity as they use human cells.     

Morphological differentiation and changes in polypeptide synthesis pattern during regeneration of human epidermal tissue developed in vitro

By incubating multilayered primary cultures of human keratinocytes in low-calcium medium the suprabasal cell layers can be stripped off leaving a basal cell monolayer. When this monolayer is re-fed normal calcium medium a reproducible series of cell kinetic, morphological, and biochemical changes takes place resulting in the reestablishment of a multilayered tissue. Analysis of cell-cycle-specific proteins indicated that, during regeneration, a large cohort of cells became synchronized undergoing DNA replication after 3 days. Examination of culture morphology at the ultrastructural level confirmed the capacity of the basal cell monolayer to gradually reestablish a multilayered, differentiated epithelium. The ultrastructural appearance at 7 days poststripping was similar to that of unstripped cultures and was indicative of a tissue in steady state. Quantitation of cornified envelope formation at different times during regeneration showed that an increasing proportion of the cells were able to undergo terminal differentiation. In general, the pattern of keratin synthesis in the original epidermal explant labelled in vitro was similar to the pattern observed in human epidermis in vivo; however, in contrast to epidermis in vivo the explant also synthesized the hyperproliferative keratins 6 and 16. The in vitro differentiated keratinocytes showed underexpression of several proteins identified as differentiation markers, whereas several basal cell markers were overexpressed compared to the original explant. In addition, the in vitro differentiated keratinocytes synthesized some new proteins, notably keratins 7, 15 and 19. The basal layer remaining after stripping mainly expressed basal cell markers; however, during recovery, some of the differentiation-specific markers (e.g. keratin 10 and 15) were again expressed together with keratin no. 19, which is also expressed during wound healing in vivo. It is suggested that the present system of regenerating epidermal tissue cultures may serve as an experimental model to investigate certain aspects of the regulation of epidermal tissue homeostasis.     

Odontoblast cells immortalized by telomerase produce mineralized dentin-like tissue both in vitro and in vivo

The formation of dentin provides one well accepted paradigm for studying mineralized tissue formation. For the assembly of dentin, several cellular signaling pathways cooperate to provide neural crest-derived mesenchymal cells with positional information. Further, "cross-talk" between signaling pathways from the mesenchymal derived odontoblast cells and the epithelially derived ameloblasts during development is responsible for the formation of functional odontoblasts. These intercellular signals are tightly regulated, both temporally and spatially. When isolated from the developing tooth germ, odontoblasts quickly lose their potential to maintain the odontoblast-specific phenotype. Therefore, generation of an odontoblast cell line would be a valuable reproducible tool for studying the modulatory effects involved in odontoblast differentiation as well as the molecular events involved in mineralized dentin formation. In this study an immortalized odontoblast cell line, which has the required biochemical machinery to produce mineralized tissue in vitro, has been generated. These cells were implanted into animal models to determine their in vivo effects on dentin formation. After implantation, we observed a multistep, programmed cascade of gene expression in the exogenous odontoblasts as the dentin formed de novo. Some of the genes expressed include the dentin matrix proteins 1, 2, and 3, which are extracellular matrix molecules responsible for the ultimate formation of mineralized dentin. The biological response was also examined by histology and radiography and confirmed for mineral deposition by von Kossa staining. Thus, a transformed odontoblast cell line was created with high proliferative capacity that might ultimately be used for the regeneration and repair of dentin in vivo.     

Tissue-level cytoprotection

In vitro and ex vivo tissue models provide a useful level of biological organization for cytoprotection studies positioned between cultured cells and intact animals. We have used 2 such models, primary tissue cultures of winter flounder renal secretory epithelium and ex vivo preparations of rat intestinal tissues, the latter to access the microcirculation of exposed mesentery tissues. Herein we discuss studies indicating that differentiated functions are altered in thermotolerant or cytoprotected tissues. These functions include transepithelial transport in renal epithelium and attachment and transmigration of leukocytes across vascular endothelium in response to mediators of inflammation. Evidence pointing to inflammation as a major venue for the heat shock response in vertebrates continues to mount. One such venue is wound healing. Heat shock proteins are induced early in wound responses, and some are released into the extracellular wound fluid where they appear to function as proinflammatory cytokines. However, within responding cells in the wound, heat shock proteins contribute to the acquisition of a state of cytoprotection that protects cells from the hostile environment of the wound, an environment created to destroy pathogens and essentially sterilize the wound. We propose that the cytoprotected state is an anti-inflammatory state that contributes to limiting the inflammatory response; that is, it serves as a brake on inflammation.     

Clinical hurdles for the transplantation of cardiomyocytes derived from human embryonic stem cells: role of molecular imaging

Over the past few years, human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) have gained popularity as a potentially ideal cell candidate for tissue regeneration. In particular, hESCs are capable of cardiac lineage-specific differentiation and confer improvement of cardiac function following transplantation into animal models. Although such data are encouraging, there remain significant hurdles before safe and successful translation of hESC-based treatment into clinical therapy, including the ability to assess cells following transplant. To this end, molecular imaging has proven a reliable methodology for tracking the long-term fate of transplanted cells. Imaging reporter genes that are introduced into the cells before transplantation enable non-invasive and longitudinal studies of cell viability, location and behaviour in vivo. Therefore, molecular imaging is expected to play an increasing role in characterizing the biology and physiology of hESC-derived cardiac cells in living subjects.     

Organ slices for the evaluation of human drug toxicity

Human organ slices, an in vitro model representing the multicellular and functional features of in vivo tissue, is a promising model for characterizing mechanisms of drug-induced organ injury and for identifying biomarkers of organ injury. Target organ injury is a significant clinical issue. In vitro models, which compare human and animal tissue to improve the extrapolation of animal in vivo studies for predicting human outcome, will contribute to improving drug candidate selection and to defining species susceptibilities in drug discovery and development programs. A critical aspect to the performance and outcome of human organ slice studies is the use of high quality tissue, and the use of culture conditions that support optimum organ slice survivability, in order to accurately reproduce mechanisms of organ injury in vitro. The attribute of organ slices possessing various cell types and interactions contributes to the overall biotransformation, inflammatory response and assessment of injury. Regional differences and changes in morphology can be readily evaluated by histology and special stains, similar to tissue obtained from in vivo studies. The liver is the major organ of which slice studies have been performed, however the utility of extra-hepatic derived slices, as well as co-cultures is increasing. Recent application of integrating gene expression, with human organ slice function and morphology demonstrate the increased potential of this model for defining the molecular and biochemical pathways leading to drug-induced tissue changes. By gaining a more detailed understanding of the mechanisms of drug-induced organ injury, and by correlating clinical measurements with drug-induced effects in the in vitro models, the vision of human in vitro models to identify more sensitive and discriminating markers of organ damage is attainable.     

Outgrowth in vitro of cervical epithelium separated from the uterovaginal anlage of newborn mice

Summary After gentle trypsinization, the pseudostratified columnar Müllerian epithelium that lines the uterine cervix of newborn mice could be separated from the enclosing stromal tissue. Pure epithelial tubes explanted in vitro and were allowed to grow in a standard medium for 3–4 days forming a confluent colony of rather closely-fitting cells. The cell sheet was studied by a preparatory technique that allows examination of a large number of cells with preserved intercellular spatial orientation. Attempts were made to identify cultured cells according to the morphology of cell types in the cervicovaginal epithelium in vivo.Electron micrographs revealed that, close to the explant, the cultured cell sheet exhibited several features similar to the Müllerian epithelium in vivo. Outside these central areas of the colony was a broad transitional zone consisting of thin platelike cells distinguished by an abundance of microfilaments. At the periphery of the colonies, bulky cells possessing microvilli and a vacuolated cytoplasm tended to overlap adjoining platelike cells. These bulky cells had a morphology resembling that of the superficial cells seen in the upper vagina and common cervical canal of immature and diestrous animals. The epithelial development in the cultures apparently simulated the transformation in vivo from a pseudostratified Müllerian epithelium in the newborn to a stratified epithelium resembling that of the uppermost vagina and common cervical canal of immature animals. Judged by morphological and cytochemical criteria, the Müllerian cells in the outgrowth obviously had many changed features. It thus seems questionable whether the cells grown in vitro are comparable with the corresponding cells in vivo when used for experiments requiring the controlled conditions of the culture environment.Supported by grants from the Norwegian Research Council for Science and the Humanities and from the Norwegian Cancer Society     

Fabrication techniques of biomimetic scaffolds in three‐dimensional cell culture: A review

In the last four decades, several researchers worldwide have routinely and meticulously exercised cell culture experiments in two‐dimensional (2D) platforms. Using traditionally existing 2D models, the therapeutic efficacy of drugs has been inappropriately validated due to the failure in generating the precise therapeutic response. Fortunately, a 3D model addresses the foregoing limitations by recapitulating the in vivo environment. In this context, one has to contemplate the design of an appropriate scaffold for favoring the organization of cell microenvironment. Instituting pertinent model on the platter will pave way for a precise mimicking of in vivo conditions. It is because animal cells in scaffolds oblige spontaneous formation of 3D colonies that molecularly, phenotypically, and histologically resemble the native environment. The 3D culture provides insight into the biochemical aspects of cell–cell communication, plasticity, cell division, cytoskeletal reorganization, signaling mechanisms, differentiation, and cell death. Focusing on these criteria, this paper discusses in detail, the diversification of polymeric scaffolds based on their available resources. The paper also reviews the well‐founded and latest techniques of scaffold fabrication, and their applications pertaining to tissue engineering, drug screening, and tumor model development.