Quantitative analysis of the 51Cr release cytotoxicity assay for cytotoxic lymphocytes

Using ⁵¹Cr-labelled P-815 mastocytoma cells as target cells and CS7BL/6 spleen cells sensitized against DBA/2 antigens as effector cells, it is shown that the variation in the observed specific ⁵¹Cr release over a broad range of experimental conditions can be explained on the basis of a simple physical model of the interaction process. The model assumes that a target cell can be destroyed only after contact with an effector cell, contact takes place on a random basis, one contact is sufficient, and that one effector cell can kill several targets with unchanged efficiency. The fraction of target cells destroyed (f) depends only on the incubation time (t), the number of effector cells (n) and a constant interaction probability (δ). Thus f = 1 ? e^?nδt. However, the experimental measurement, the fraction of ⁵¹Cr specifically released into the supernatant during the assay, may not be the same as the fraction of target cells destroyed because it takes considerable time for the releasable ⁵¹Cr to be released from a damaged target cell. This can be overcome experimentally by following the standard 37 °C incubation with a further incubation at 45 °C during which there are no new lytic events but all previously damaged target cells release the remainder of their releasable ⁵¹Cr. The model enables one to obtain accurate measurements of relative effector cell frequency over a broad range of experimental conditions.     

Spontaneous51Cr release by isolated rat hepatocytes: An indicator of membrane damage

Summary Radiochromium uptake and release by isolated rat hepatocytes in suspension was monitored under continuous-labeling conditions. Cell protein remained unchanged during the absorption phase, whereas the release of⁵¹Cr correlated well with the loss of cell viability and release of cytoplasmic protein. The results suggest that under equilibrium conditions,⁵¹Cr release represents an efflux of label from damaged or dying preparations and not an elution of radioisotope from intact cells.     

Effects of Ca2+ and other cations on the action of Clostridium perfringens enterotoxin

We investigated the role of extracellular Ca²⁺ in the Clostridium perfringens enterotoxin-induced alteration of the permeability of the plasma membrane. Enterotoxin released ⁸⁶Rb and ⁵¹Cr from the Vero cells preloaded with the isotope. In the presence of EGTA, however, it released ⁸⁶Rb but not ⁵¹Cr. The binding of enterotoxin to the cells was not influenced by Ca²⁺ or Mg²⁺. The effects of various cations on the enterotoxin-induced ⁵¹Cr release was also studied. The release depended on extracellular Ca²⁺ but not on Mg²⁺; it was inhibited by each of Zn²⁺, La³⁺ and Co²⁺. Zn²⁺ and Co²⁺ also inhibited ⁵¹Cr release caused by the enterotoxin previously bound to the cell membrane. In contrast, antibody against enterotoxin did not neutralize the toxin once it was bound to the Vero cells. When the cells were treated with enterotoxin, ⁴⁵Ca influx occurred and reached the plateau in a few minutes, as did ⁸⁶Rb release.     

Contrasting effects of alloantiserum and xenoantiserum on cell-mediated lysis of tumor cells

The effect of anti-EL-4 serum on antibody-dependent cytotoxicity (ADCC) and cell-mediated cytotoxicity (CMC) was studied in allogeneic and xenogeneic systems. Inbred strains of BALB/c mice and Lewis rats were immunized with EL-4 tumor cells. Using microcytotoxic assays of ⁵¹Cr release from labeled EL-4 cells, complement-dependent cytolysis, ADCC, and CMC were determined. Complement-dependent cytolysis was observed in both systems. Although ADCC was demonstrated in both systems, the kinetics of cytolysis were different. Xenoantisera and alloantisera had opposite effects on CMC. Incubation of EL-4 target cells with BALB/c anti-EL-4 serum resulted in inhibition of CMC by immune BALB/c spleen cells. In contrast, treatment of EL-4 target cells with Lewis anti-EL-4 serum potentiated the CMC of immune Lewis spleen cells. It is thought that differences in the strength of response, antibody characteristics, and effector cells may determine the degree of inhibition or potentiation observed in these systems.     

Cytological and functional analysis of inflammatory infiltrates in human malignant tumors: III. Further functional investigations using cultured autochthonous tumor cell lines and freeze-thawed infiltrating inflammatory cells

Short-term monolayer cultures, dominated by cells with malignant characteristics, were established from human tumors displaying an unusually strong host-inflammatory response. Upon repeated testings in the ⁵¹Cr release cytotoxicity assay, blood leukocytes were frequently cytotoxic (a) to autologous and allogeneic tumor cells, without any apparent restriction as to tumor origin or HLA type, and (b) to the so-called natural killer (NK) target cells. The anti-tumor cytotoxicity disappeared with time. The in situ inflammatory cells, freshly isolated or recovered from the deep freeze, did not display any type of cytotoxic activity. Nor were they notably suppressive to either type of blood leukocyte cytotoxic activity in the ⁵¹Cr release assay. Cytological analysis demonstrated that the “large granular lymphocytes” (LGL), known to be largely responsible for the NK activity in man, were prominent in the blood but not in the inflammatory infiltrate. These preliminary observations suggest that lack of cytotoxic activity in situ correlates with the absence of effector cells in the inflammatory infiltrate.     

Differing time courses of spleen leukocyte MIF synthesis and cytotoxicity during rejection of a murine lymphoma allograft

In vitro spleen leukocyte MIF synthesis and direct cytotoxicity were studied during growth and rejection of the EL-4 murine lymphoma in allogeneic tumor-bearing BALB/c mice to compare the time courses of these events. Rejection of EL-4 tumors occurred between 6 and 8 flays after intraperitoneal inoculation. Spleen leukocyte cytotoxicity measured by isotope release from chromium-51 labeled EL-4 target cells was first detected on day 6 and was maximal between days 11 and 18. In contrast, spleen leukocyte MIF synthesis stimulated by intact EL-4 cells was sometimes observed on day 11 and was maximal between 18 and 25 days after tumor challenge. These results show that maximal spleen cytotoxicity and MIF synthesis occur after completion of, rather than during ip tumor rejection and, in addition, that these two in vitro lymphocyte responses follow independent, significantly different time courses (P < 0.05). This asynchrony of MIF synthesis and cytotoxicity suggests that these in vitro correlates are mediated by distinct lymphocyte subpopulations.     

The combined effect of lymphokine activated killer cell and radiation therapy on rat brain tumorin vitro

Thein vitro effect of a combined treatment with lymphokine activated killer (LAK) cell and radiation therapy on rat brain tumor was examined using⁵¹Cr release assay. The tumor cell-line used in this experiment was 9L rat brain tumor derived from a Fischer 344 rat. LAK cells were obtained by culturing rat lymphocytes with recombinant human interleukin 2 for at least 3 days. The cytotoxic activity of the LAK cells was examined by⁵¹Cr release assay. Irradiation was done by exposing the microtiter plate in which the¹⁵Cr labeled 9L cells and LAK cells were cultured to a¹³⁷Cs gamma cell unit. Without irradiation, there was 18% cytotoxicity in the 1:100 tumor-to-LAK cell ratio specimen after 24 hrs cocultivation. However, if 5 Gy of irradiation was given, followed by 12 hrs incubation, the cytotoxicity was enhanced significantly at the same cell ratio (30%). This enhancement effect was the most prominent when the cell ratio was 1:100 and the irradiation dose was 5 Gy. To generate the enhancement effect, an incubation time of over 8 hrs both before and after irradiation was required. The supernatant of the LAK cells showed 19.8% and 11.4% cytotoxicity with and without irradiation, respectively. This result indicates the participation of a cytotoxic factor released from LAK cells.This work is supported in part by grant from Univeristy of Tsukuba Project Research.     

Characteristics of the killing mechanism of human natural killer cells against hepatocellular carcinoma cell lines HepG2 and Hep3B

Purpose Unlike normal hepatocytes, most hepatocellular carcinomas (HCCs) are quite resistant to death receptor-mediated apoptosis when the cell surface death receptor is cross linked with either agonistic antibodies or soluble death ligand proteins in vitro. The resistance might play an essential role in the escape from the host immune surveillance; however, it has not been directly demonstrated that HCCs are actually resistant to natural killer (NK) cell-mediated death. Therefore, this study investigated the molecular mechanism of NK cell-mediated cytotoxicity against the HCCs, HepG2, and Hep3B, using two distinct cytotoxic assays: a 4-h ⁵¹Cr-release assay and a 2-h [³H] thymidine release assay which selectively measures the extent of necrotic and apoptotic target cell death, respectively.Methods Most of the target cells exhibited marked morphologic changes when they were co-incubated with the NK cells, and the NK cytotoxicity against these HCCs was comparable to that against K562, a NK-sensitive leukemia cell line, when the cytotoxicity was assessed by a 4-h ⁵¹Cr release assay.Results The NK cells also induced significant apoptotic cell death in the Hep3B targets, but not in the HepG2 targets, when the cytotoxicity was assessed by a 2-h [³H]-thymidine release assay. In agreement with these results, procaspase-3 was activated in the Hep3B targets, but not in the HepG2 targets. Interestingly, mildly fixed NK cells had no detectable activity in the 4-h ⁵¹Cr release assay against both HepG2 and Hep3B targets, while they were similarly effective as the untreated NK cells in the 2-h [³H]-thymidine release assay, suggesting that the level of apoptotic cell death of the Hep3B targets is granule independent and might be primarily mediated by the death ligands of the NK cells.Conclusion This study found that a tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-related apoptosis-inducing ligand (TRAIL)/TRAIL receptor interaction is involved in the NK cell-mediated apoptotic death of the Hep3B targets, but a Fas/Fas ligand (FasL) interaction is not.     

Comparison between 125IUdR and 51Cr as cell labels in investigations of tumor cell migration

YAC-1 tumor cells double-labeled with Na₂[⁵¹Cr]O₄ [⁵¹Cr] and [¹²⁵I]iododeoxyuridine [¹²⁵IUdR] were injected intravenously into Balb/c mice in order to investigate their migration and fate 0–4 h after the injection. Whereas the clearance of tumor cells from the lung tissue was similar as judged with both labels, the kinetics of isotope uptake in the liver were strikingly different. Thus, retention of ⁵¹Cr in the liver was very high compared to a much lower and only transient retention of ¹²⁵I. A higher retention of non-tumor cell-associated ⁵¹Cr was also observed in most other organs, resulting in overestimation of the number of viable tumor cells in these organs. Moreover, a marked spontaneous release (> 10% after 12 h) makes ⁵¹Cr less suitable as a cell label than ¹²⁵IUdR. On the other hand, we found that the release of ¹²⁵I from dead cells in vivo depends at least partially on host factors such as macrophages. Consequently, caution must be exerted when tumor cell migration is investigated in animals treated with drugs that might affect the reticuloendothelial system. We conclude that ¹²⁵IUdR is superior to ⁵¹Cr as a cell label for investigation of tumor cell migration in vivo, even though some doubt about the reliability of the number of tumor cells in liver and carcass, predicted by this radiolabel, still remains.     

Cytotoxicity of lymphoid cells induced by Maclura pomifera (MP) lectin.

The cytotoxic activity of lymphoid cells stimulated with Maclura pomifera (MP) lectin was investigated. Spleen cells of Lewis (LEW) or Brown Norway (BN) rats induced a cell-dependent release of ⁵¹Cr from syngeneic, allogeneic, and xenogeneic erythrocytes when incubated with MP for 4–16 hr. The activity of MP differed from that of concanavalin A (Con A). MP exhibited a greater activity with spleen cells while Con A was more active when bone marrow cells were tested. Activity induced by MP required the presence of the lectin for at least 4 hr and was inhibited by melibiose, an inhibitor of MP binding. MP also stimulated phagocytosis by peritoneal macrophages of LEW rats, but phagocytosis was not responsible for the cytotoxic effect measured by ⁵¹Cr release. The ability of aggressor cells to bind MP did not correlate with their cytotoxic activity. The cytotoxic activity of spleen cells from athymic nude mice was equivalent to that of cells from euthymic littermates when stimulated with MP.     

Lysis of virus-infected target cells by antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity. I. General requirements of the reaction and temporal relationship between lethal hits and cytolysis.

The effect of various physical and chemical parameters on the cytotoxic reaction was studied in a ⁵¹Cr-release assay in order to analyze the mechanism by which human blood mononuclear cells (MC) damage antibody-sensitized target cells infected with herpes simplex virus. Centrifugation of the target cell-MC mixture consistently increased the velocity of the reaction. In addition, uncentrifuged target cell-MC cultures showed a sigmoidal kinetic curve of ⁵¹Cr release with an initial lag phase of at least 10 min, whereas ⁵¹Cr release in centrifuged cultures followed a linear pattern with time without an initial lag. These findings indicate that direct contact between target and effector cells is necessary for cytotoxicity to occur. The reaction as a whole was temperature dependent, proceeding well at 37 °C and not at all at 4 °C. Incubation of the MC at 46 °C for 10 min abolished their cytotoxic potential without affecting their viability; similar heating of the target cells did not affect their background isotope release or sensitivity to the lytic process. Heating target cell-MC mixtures at 46 °C for 10 min thus provided a tool by which the temporal relationship between the mounting of “lethal hits” and specific isotope release, or cell lysis, could be studied. Using this technique, we observed virtually simultaneous occurrence of lethal hits and cell lysis, measured at various intervals between 10 and 360 min postincubation. Likewise, we were unable to demonstrate a transient period of increased osmotic fragility in target cells after contact with MC but before actual cell lysis. Taken together, these findings imply either that cell lysis, as indicated by ⁵¹Cr release, results from a sudden nonosmotic injury to the target cell membrane or, alternatively, osmotic damage leading to ⁵¹Cr release occurs too rapidly to be detected by the methods employed in this study. These findings imply either a qualitative or a quantitative difference between antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) mediated by K cells and cytotoxicity mediated by sensitized T cells.The cytotoxic reaction was completely inhibited by 10 mM EDTA and did not occur in a Ca²⁺- and Mg²⁺-free medium. Neither Ca²⁺ nor Mg²⁺ alone produced as much cytotoxicity as the two cations in tandem; in addition, when added to the culture medium in suboptimal amounts, the two cations were either additive or synergistic. These observations suggest that both cations are necessary in ADCC and also that there may be separate Ca²⁺- and Mg²⁺-dependent events in the lytic pathway.     

Sizes of isotopically labeled molecules released during lysis of tumor cells labeled with 51Cr and [14C]nicotinamide.

Previous studies of mechanisms of immune lysis have utilized the release of isotopically labeled molecules from cells labeled with Na₂⁵¹Cr0₄ and [¹⁴C]nicotinamide, among others. The interpretation of specific isotope release from such cells was hampered by the lack of knowledge about the molecular sizes of the released radioactive molecules. In the present study, P815 tumor cells were labeled with the above two isotopic compounds. The cells were then lysed by freezing and thawing, antibody and complement, or immune T-lymphocyte-mediated killing. Soluble supernatants from the lysates were chromatographed in the cold on Sephadex G-10, G-25, and G-200 using several elution media. No differences were detected due to different kinds of lysis or different eluting media. Eighty-five percent of ¹⁴C-labeled molecules released from the cells were indistinguishable from nicotinamide and clearly distinct from nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide. The results suggest that [¹⁴C]nicotinamide taken up by the tumor cells during overnight culture is released unaltered during lysis. Ninety percent of ⁵¹Cr-labeled lysate molecules had an apparent molecular weight less than 4000. Most of this material was distinct from inorganic chromate, but its chemical form is not known.     

Measurement of CTL-induced cytotoxicity: The caspase 3 assay

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) are critical effector cells of the immune system. Measurement of target cell damage has historically been an important measure of CTL function. CTL kill their target cells predominantly by inducing programmed cell death, or apoptosis. The gold standard for CTL-mediated cytotoxicity has been the ⁵¹Cr release assay. However, measurement of target cell lysis by ⁵¹Cr release does not provide mechanistic information on the fate of target cells, especially at the single cell level. Given the recent advances in our understanding of programmed cell death, newer assays are required which evaluate the status of the apoptotic pathways in target cells. We have developed a flow cytometry-based assay for CTL-mediated cytotoxicity based on specific binding of antibody to activated caspase 3 in target cells. Our assay is convenient and more sensitive than the ⁵¹Cr release assay. The use of this assay should allow mechanistic studies of the intracellular events resulting from CTL attack.     

Announcements

Human peripheral blood monocytes were reproducibly shown to lyse a variety of tumor cells in a 3- to 4-hr ⁵¹Cr release assay. Ficoll-Hypaque-purified mononuclear cells were suspended in medium supplemented with either 10% autologous serum or fetal calf serum (PCS). With either serum, highly purified (97–99%) and viable (>99%) monocyte suspensions were obtained by EDTA-reversible adherence to plastic surfaces which had been precoated with autologous serum. When used as effectors in cytotoxicity assays, the monocytes recovered from mononuclear cells suspended in FCS-supplemented medium exhibited higher cytolytic activity and were therefore used for further studies. Using FCS for both coating the plates and supplementing the suspension medium resulted in monocytes with low cytolytic activity. Tumor cell lysis measured by ⁵¹Cr release was detected within 2 hr of incubation and increased gradually with time. The level of lysis was dependent on the effector/target ratio and the tumor target cell employed. The involvement of natural killer lymphocytes in the observed tumoricidal activity was excluded. Detection of cytotoxic activity in a short-term assay will be very helpful in further studies of the mechanism of tumor cell killing by human monocytes since potential complicating effects of long-term in vitro cultivation will be minimized.     

Cytopathic Action of Naegleria fowleri Amoebae on Rat Neuroblastoma Target Cells

The axenically cultured, weakly pathogenic Naegleria fowleri LEE and the highly pathogenic, mouse passaged N. fowleri LEEmp are cytopathic for B103 rat nerve cells in culture. Cytopathogenicity was measured by release of radiolabeled rubidium or radiolabeled chromium from B103 target cells. Cytopathogenicity was time-dependent for up to 18 h and dependent upon amoebae effector to nerve cell target ratios of less than 1:1. Release of⁵¹ Cr from B103 cells by either LEE or LEEmp amoebae was enhanced by addition of calcium or magnesium to medium free of these divalent cations but the ion-channel inhibitor, verapamil, or the ionophore A23187 and phorbol myristate acetate did not alter release of ⁵¹ Cr from B103 cells cocultured with the amoebae. Cycloheximide or actinomycin D impaired release of ⁵¹ Cr from B103 target cells injured by either LEE or LEEmp amoebae. Both strains of amoebae were fractionated by glass bead disruption and high speed centrifugation into membrane and soluble fractions. Each fraction was incubated with either ⁸⁶Rb or ⁵¹ Cr labeled nerve cells. The membrane fraction from LEEmp was more active than the soluble fraction in facilitating rubidium and chromium release. In contrast, the soluble fraction from LEE was more active than the membrane fraction in facilitating rubidium release from radiolabeled target cells. The sequential release of ⁸⁶Rb and ⁵¹ Cr from target cells rather than the simultaneous release of the two isotopes indicates that target cell death is due to the release of ions followed later by the release of large macromolecules. The results indicate that N. fowleri amoebae injure nerve cells by two alternate mechanisms, trogocytosis or contact-dependent lysis.     

Induction of cell-mediated cytotoxic immunity to sperm-specific lactate dehydrogenase-C4 in SJL/J female mice

SJL/J female mice were tested for a cell-mediated cytotoxic response to sperm-specific lactate dehydrogenase C4 (LDH-C4). We demonstrated this response with a 51chromium release assay. Mouse LDH-C4 was coupled to EL-4 tumor cells. These cells were then labeled with 51Cr and mixed with splenocytes from LDH-C4-immune and -nonimmune mice. Specific lysis of the tumor cells by splenocytes from LDH-C4-immune mice was detected at 7 days and 14 days following a single footpad immunization. Since LDH-C4 is present on the surface of sperm, these results support the suggestion that cytotoxic removal of sperm from the female reproductive tract is one of the mechanisms whereby fertility is reduced following immunization with this enzyme.     

Study of the immune responses to nucleated cells. I. In vitro functional evaluation of the immune effectors responsible for complement-dependent cellular cytotoxicity

A modification of the ⁵¹Cr cytotoxic test has made it possible to assess under the same conditions not only cytotoxic serum antibodies, and cell-mediated immunity, but also cells releasing cytotoxic antibody. The measurement of these antibody-releasing cells was carried out with nucleated target cells, both normal and leukemic, across θ or H-2 antigenic differences. This test was found to be specific. The release of ⁵¹Cr from the labeled target cells was proportional to the ratio of immune cells to target cells, and for a given ratio to the incubation time, 60 min usually being the optimum time at ratios of 50–100 to 1. The test was not affected by treatment of the effector cells with an anti-θ serum; however, pretreatment of these cells with an anti-IgM serum, even without complement, inhibited the test with cells taken during primary responses. Both cytotoxic IgM and IgG antibodies were detected by the assay directly without the addition of enhancing serum; discrimination between these two γ-globulins can be made by suppressing the cytotoxicity due to either Ig class consequent to the addition of the appropriate specific anti-globulin serum during the incubation.     

Stabilization and functional studies of high-molecular-weight murine lymphotoxins

High levels of lymphotoxin-like activity (LT) were found in supernatants from secondarily stimulated immune mouse splenocytes activated with concanavalin A (Con A) in vitro. Splenocytes obtained from C57Bl/6 mice immune to the P815 mastocytoma were restimulated in vitro with mitomycin C-treated P815 cells, and then stimulated with Con A. High levels of unstable LT activity are rapidly (2–4 hr) released by these lectin-stimulated splenocytes. The introduction of a crosslinking agent, glutaraldehyde, was found to stabilize this LT activity and allowed us to perform more defined biochemical studies and to examine the functional activities of the LT classes. The lytic activity in these supernatants resided in the high-molecular-weight classes, termed Complex (Cx > 200,000 daltons) and alpha-heavy (α_H 130,000–160,000 daltons). It was found that the Cx and α_H LT classes from the secondarily stimulated immune splenocytes cause lysis of allogeneic target cells, P815 and EL-4, in a 16-hr ⁷⁵Semethionine release assay, and in some cases, this lysis was specific for the sensitizing target cell.     

Regulatory mechanism of delayed-type hypersensitivity in mice. II. Effect of suppressor cells on the development of memory cells for delayed-type hypersensitivity

Murine lymph node cells (LNC), which we showed previously to noncompetitively inhibit antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) to an erythrocyte target, were tested for their ability to inhibit ADCC to a tumor target, EL-4. Both a 4-hr ⁵¹Cr-release cytotoxicity assay and an overnight ¹²⁵IUdR (iododeoxyuridine) postlabeling cytostasis assay were used. Normal autologous lymph node cells inhibited spleen cell-mediated ADCC in both assays. Inhibition by LNC was dose dependent, but comparable numbers of sheep erythrocytes did not inhibit, indicating that LNC-mediated inhibition was not simply a matter of crowding. Inhibitory activity was enriched in LNC after removal of Fc receptor-bearing cells on EA monolayers.     

Cytolytic T lymphocyte mediated chromium-51 release versus spontaneous release from blast and spleen cell targets at low temperatures

The rate of spontaneous ⁵¹Cr release from spleen cell and LPS blast target cells is strongly temperature dependent. Between 32 and 37 °C the rate of spontaneous release increases dramatically with temperature. Cytolytic T-lymphocyte-mediated lysis of these target cells is also temperature dependent, but lysis does not increase greatly above 32 °C. The ratio of specific ⁵¹Cr release to spontaneous release can be significantly improved by doing ⁵¹Cr-release assays at temperatures below 37 °C.