Cooperativity in the inhibition of P-glycoprotein-mediated daunorubicin transport: evidence for half-of-the-sites reactivity

P-Glycoprotein (Pgp) is an important transport enzyme composed of two homologous domains and transports a wide range of structurally diverse xenobiotics from the cell. Recent studies have indicated that allosteric interactions occur between the nucleotide binding domains and between the substrate binding domains of the two halves, but the extent of this interaction as well as the means by which the enzyme can transport such a wide variety of substrates has not been elucidated. Herein, the Pgp-mediated transport of a marker substrate, daunorubicin (DNR), out of viable cells was examined in the presence of a variety of other known substrates of Pgp. For most of the typical Pgp substrates examined, the relationship between inhibition of DNR efflux and competing substrate concentration was sigmoidal and therefore not a simple mutually exclusive competitive inhibition of transport. The Hill coefficient ranged from about 3 to 5 for the inhibition of transport of DNR. This negative cooperativity in combination with recent evidence, including several examples of noncompetitive inhibition between the homologous halves of Pgp, indicates a "half-of-the-sites" reactivity. Our data support the mechanistic proposal that substrate binding at one putative transport binding site precludes activity at another unequal site; many of the substrates examined exert a negative allosteric effect on the other transport site (and vice versa). A half-of-the-sites reactivity model would account for many of these observations and may be critical to the efficiency of Pgp substrate transport of a broad spectrum of compounds.     

Human glutathione transferase A1-1 demonstrates both half-of-the-sites and all-of-the-sites reactivity

A study of the kinetics of a heterodimeric variant of glutathione transferase (GST) A1-1 has led to the conclusion that, although the wild-type enzyme displays all-of-the-sites reactivity in nucleophilic aromatic substitution reactions, it demonstrates half-of-the-sites reactivity in addition reactions. The heterodimer, designed to be essentially catalytically inactive in one subunit due to a single point mutation (D101K), and the two parental homodimers were analyzed with seven different substrates, exemplifying three types of reactions catalyzed by glutathione transferases (nucleophilic aromatic substitution, addition, and double-bond isomerization reactions). Stopped-flow kinetic results suggested that the wild-type GST A1-1 behaved with half-of-the-sites reactivity in a nucleophilic aromatic substitution reaction, but steady-state kinetic analyses of the GST A1-D101K heterodimer revealed that this was presumably due to changes to the extinction coefficient of the enzyme-bound product. In contrast, steady-state kinetic analysis of the heterodimer with three different substrates of addition reactions provided evidence that the wild-type enzyme displayed half-of-the-sites reactivity in association with these reactions. The half-of-the-sites reactivity was shown not to be dependent on substrate size, the level of saturation of the enzyme with glutathione, or relative catalytic rate.     

Synthesis and reactivity studies of model complexes for molybdopterin-dependent enzymes

The molybdenum cofactor (Moco)-containing enzymes are divided into three classes that are named after prototypical members of each family, viz. sulfite oxidase, DMSO reductase and xanthine oxidase. Functional or structural models have been prepared for these three prototypical enzymes: (i) The complex [MoO2(mnt)2]2- (mnt2- = 1,2-dicyanoethylenedithiolate) has been found to be able to oxidize hydrogen sulfite to HSO4- and is thus a functional model of sulfite oxidase. Kinetic and computational studies indicate that the reaction proceeds via attack of the substrate at one of the oxo ligands of the complex, rather than at the metal. (ii) The coordination geometries of the mono-oxo [Mo(VI)(O-Ser)(S2)2] entity (S2 = dithiolene moiety of molybdopterin) found in the crystal structure of R. sphaeroides DMSO reductase and the corresponding des-oxo Mo(IV) unit have been reproduced in the complexes [M(VI)O(OSiR3)(bdt)2] and [M(VI)O(OSiR3)(bdt)2] (M = Mo,W; bdt = benzene dithiolate). (iii) A facile route has been developed for the preparation of complexes containing a cis-Mo(VI)OS molybdenum oxo, sulfido moiety similar to that detected in the oxidized form of xanthine oxidase.     

Kinetic evidence for half-of-the-sites reactivity in tRNATrp aminoacylation by tryptophanyl-tRNA synthetase from beef pancreas

The aminoacylation reaction catalyzed by the dimeric tryptophanyl-tRNA synthetase from beef pancreas was studied under pre-steady-state conditions by the quenched-flow method. The transfer of tryptophan to tRNATrp was monitored by using preformed enzyme-bis(tryptophanyl adenylate) complex. Combinations of either unlabeled or L-[14C]tryptophan-labeled tryptophanyl adenylate and of aminoacylation incubation mixtures containing either unlabeled tryptophan or L-[14C]tryptophan were used. We measured either the formation of a single labeled aminoacyl-tRNATrp per enzyme subunit or the turnover of labeled aminoacyl-tRNATrp synthesis. Four models were proposed to analyze the experimental data: (A) two independent and nonequivalent subunits; (B) a single active subunit (subunits presenting absolute "half-of-the-sites reactivity"); (C) alternate functioning of the subunits (flip-flop mechanism); (D) random functioning of the subunits with half-of-the-sites reactivity. The equations corresponding to the formation of labeled tryptophanyl-tRNATrp under each labeling condition were derived for each model. By use of least-squares criteria, the experimental curves were fitted with the four models, and it was possible to disregard models B and C as likely mechanisms. Complementary experiments, in which there was no significant excess of ATP-Mg over the enzyme-adenylate complex, emphasized an activator effect of free L-tryptophan on the rate of aminoacylation. This result disfavored model A. Model D was in agreement with all data. The analyses showed that the transfer step was not the major limiting reaction in the overall aminoacylation process.     

The half-of-the-sites reactivity of horse liver alcohol dehydrogenase in the presence of alcohol substrates

We investigated by stopped-flow techniques the oxidation of benzyl alcohol catalyzed by horse liver alcohol dehydrogenase varying the concentration of the reagents, pH and temperature. The course of the reaction under enzymelimiting conditions is biphasic and the measured amplitude of the initial step corresponds under saturation conditions to half of the total enzyme concentration (half-burst). The fast initial step (with a maximum rate of 20 s^?1 at pH 7.0) shows an isotope effect of approximately 2, which indicates that this rate contains a contribution from a hydrogen transfer. It is also shown that this rate differs by at least one order of magnitude with respect to that of the hydrogen transfer during benzaldehyde reduction. The half-of-the-sites reactivity of alcohol dehydrogenase in the initial transient process is obtained independent of reagent concentration, pH and/or temperature. It is obtained also when coenzyme analogues are substituted for NAD, and when different alcohols are substituted for benzyl alcohol. These data are taken to demonstrate unequivocally that the half-of-the-sites reactivity of alcohol dehydrogenase cannot be due to an interplay of rate constants (as proposed by various authors) and must rather be ascribed to a kinetic non-equivalence of the two subunits when active ternary complexes are being formed. When oxidation of benzyl alcohol is carried out in the presence of 0.1 m-isobutyramide (which makes a very tight complex with NADH at the enzyme active site), reaction stops after formation of an amount of NADH product that is equivalent to one half of the enzyme active site concentration.This is considered in the light of the pyrazole experiment designed by McFarland &; Bernhard (1972), in which reduction of benzaldehyde is carried out in the presence of pyrazole (which forms a very tight ternary complex with NAD at the enzyme active site). In this case, reaction stops after formation of an amount of NAD-product which is equivalent to the total enzyme active site concentration. It is shown that accommodation of these two seemingly contradictory sets of data poses severe restrictions on the alcohol dehydrogenase mechanism. In particular, it is shown that the only mechanism that adheres to such requirements is one in which the two subunits have distinct and alternating functions in each enzyme cycle. These two functions are the triggering of the chemical transformation and the chemical transformation itself. It is also shown that binding of NAD-substrate to one subunit triggers chemical reactivity in the other NAD-alcohol-containing subunit, whereas on aldehyde reduction, the triggering event is desorption of alcohol product from the first reacted subunit.     

Pre-steady-state analysis of the nucleoside hydrolase of Trypanosoma vivax. Evidence for half-of-the-sites reactivity and rate-limiting product release

The nucleoside hydrolase (NH) of the Trypanosoma vivax parasite catalyzes the hydrolysis of the N-glycosidic bond in ribonucleosides according to the following reaction: beta-purine (or pyrimidine) nucleoside + H(2)O --> purine (pyrimidine) base + ribose. The reaction follows a highly dissociative nucleophilic displacement reaction mechanism with a ribosyl oxocarbenium-like transition state. This paper describes the first pre-steady-state analysis of the conversion of a number of purine nucleosides. The NH exhibits burst kinetics and behaves with half-of-the-sites reactivity. The analysis suggests that the NH of T. vivax follows a complex multistep mechanism in which a common slow step different from the chemical hydrolysis is rate limiting. Stopped-flow fluorescence binding experiments with ribose indicate that a tightly bound enzyme-ribose complex accumulates during the enzymatic hydrolysis of the common purine nucleosides. This is caused by a slow isomerization between a tight and a loose enzyme-ribose complex forming the rate-limiting step on the reaction coordinate.     

Inhibitory effect of polyelectrolytes on oligomeric enzymes

The effect of polyelectrolytes on the stability and catalytic characteristics of oligomeric enzymes--pig muscle lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) and bovine liver glutamate dehydrogenase (GDH)--was studied by fluorescent spectroscopic and steady state kinetic methods. It was shown that the binding of negatively charged polyelectrolytes--polystyrene sulfonate, polymethacrylate, and polyphosphate--destroys the tertiary and partially the secondary structure of LDH and GDH, resulting in their complete inactivation at pH < 7. The concentrations of polyelectrolytes needed for inhibition of the enzymes were in this case by two or more orders of magnitude lower than the corresponding concentrations for monomers--toluene sulfonate, methacrylate, and phosphate. The affinity of the substrate (pyruvate) for LDH did not vary in the presence of the polyelectrolytes, but the inhibition was removed by excess of substrate. We propose that the oligomeric state of enzymes causes polyelectrolytes to act on them in a special manner, this special effect differing significantly from the effect of polyelectrolytes on monomeric enzymes. The effect consists in that polyelectrolytes cleave the oligomeric structure of the enzymes, this "cleaving" effect being higher the greater the hydrophobicity of the polyelectrolyte chain.     

Advances in high-resolution cryo-EM of oligomeric enzymes

1. Download : Download high-res image (492KB)
2. Download : Download full-size image

     

Rabbit muscle D-glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase: half-of-the-sites reactivity of the enzyme modified at arginine residues.

Modification of a single arginine residue per subunit of rabbit muscle apo-D-Glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase does not affect the rate of hydrolysis of p-nitrophenyl acetate catalyzed by the enzyme, but locks the tetramer in a conformation wherein only two active sites are functioning. The modified enzyme also exhibits half-of-the sites reactivity towards iodoacetate and iodoacetamide. On the other hand, its NAD(+)-binding characteristics remain unchanged. Evidence is presented supporting the view that mechanisms of half-of-the-sites reactivity and negative cooperativity in coenzyme binding are different. The results are consistent with a built-in asymmetry of the tetramer and suggest that the arginine residue (probably Arg-231) controls the conformational transition between the asymmetric and symmetric states of the tetramer.     

Threonine deaminase from a nonsense mutant of Escherichia coli requiring isoleucine or pyridoxine: evidence for half-of-the-sites reactivity.

The mutant IP7 of Escherichia coli B requires isoleucine or pyridoxine for growth as a consequence of a mutation in the gene coding for biosynthetic threonine deaminase. The mutation of IP7 was shown to be of the nonsense type by the following data: (1) reversion to isoleucine prototrophy involves the formation of external suppression at a high frequency, as shown by transduction experiments; and (ii) the isoleucine requirement is suppressed by lysogenization with a phage carrying the amber suppressor su-3. Cell extracts of the mutant strain contain a low activity of threonine deaminase. The possibility that this activity is biodegradative was ruled out by kinetic experiments. The mutant threonine deaminase was purified to homogeneity by conventional procedures. The enzyme is a dimer of identical subunits of an approximate molecular weight of 43,000 (Grimminger and Feldner, 1974), whereas the wild-type enzyme is a tetramer of 50,000-dalton subunits (Calhoun et al., 1973; Grimminger et al., 1973). The mutant enzyme is not inhibited by isoleucine and does not bind isoleucine, as shown by equilibrium dialysis experiments. Pyridoxal phosphate enhances the maximum catalytic activity of the mutant enzyme by a factor of five, whereas the wild-type enzyme is not affected. In wild-type and mutant threonine deaminase the ratio of protein subunits and bound pyridoxal phosphate is 2:1. The activation of threonine deaminase from strain IP7 is due to a second coenzyme binding site, as shown by (i) spectrophotometric titration of the enzyme with pyridoxal phosphate and by (ii) measurement the pyridoxal phosphate content of the enzyme after sodium borohydride reduction of the protein. The observation of one pyridoxal phosphate binding site per peptide dimer in the wild-type enzyme and of two binding sites per dimer in the mutant strongly suggests that one of the potential sites in the wild-type enzyme is masked by allosteric effects. The factors responsible for the half-of-the-sites reactivity of the coenzyme sites appear to be nonoperative in the mutant protein.     

Kinetic model of the action of oligomeric enzymes using phosphofructokinase as an example. II. General formulation of the hierarchical model

A general approach is suggested to describe the steady-state kinetics of the oligomeric enzymes on the base of the generalized statistical Ising model. Detailed analysis is given for the case of a oligomeric enzyme with a hierarchical supramolecular organization. A protomer of this enzyme composed of several equivalent subunits represents the quarternary level of structure. In their turn the finite or infinite number of protomers is associated into a oligomer thus creating a new "quinternary" level of the enzyme organization. The model accounts for the ligand-induced homotrophic cooperative interactions: firstly, between the neighbouring protomers and secondly, between the subunits of the same protomer. The influence of protomer conformation on the subunit state and the cooperativity induction caused by two-ligand binding are also taken into consideration. Monod-Wyman-Changeux's and Koshland's models are shown to be special limit cases of the suggested general theory.     

A fully nonequilibrium concerted model for enzymes

The concerted model of Monod, Wyman, and Changeux is generalized so that all effects of interactions for an enzyme operating at a nonequilibrium stationary state are considered. In contrast to the original model, which is based on an analogy to equilibrium ligand binding, the generalization may show both “positive” and “negative cooperativity” in both catalytic binding and conformational processes. Furthermore, in contrast to any equilibrium binding model, the Hill coefficients may be greater than the number of sites n. For catalysis, the maximum value is 2n, and for conformational changes, n + 1. These points are illustrated by two cases that yield simpler analytic expressions. The first obtains when catalysis occurs on a much faster time scale than the conformational changes, and the second, when this situation is reversed.     

Direct kinetic evidence for half-of-the-sites reactivity in the E1 component of the human pyruvate dehydrogenase multienzyme complex through alternating sites cofactor activation

Recent kinetic and structural studies on various thiamin-dependent enzymes, including the bacterial E1 component of the pyruvate dehydrogenase complex (PDHc), suggested an active center communication between the cofactors in these multimeric enzymes. This regulatory mode has been inferred from the dissymmetry of active sites in proteolytic patterns and X-ray structures and from a complex macroscopic kinetic behavior not being consistent with independently working active sites. Here, direct microscopic kinetic evidence for this hypothesis is presented for the alpha2beta2-type E1 component of the human pyruvate dehydrogenase complex. Only one of the two thiamin molecules bound to the two active sites is in a chemically activated state exhibiting an apparent C2 ionization rate constant of approximately 50 s(-1) at pH 7.6 and 30 degrees C, whereas the thiamin in the "inactive site" ionizes with a rate that is at least 3 orders of magnitude smaller. The chemical nonequivalence is also exhibited in the ability to bind the substrate analogue methyl acetylphosphonate and in the catalytic turnover of the substrate pyruvate in the E1-only reaction. In the activated active site, pyruvate is rapidly bound and decarboxylated with apparent forward rate constants of covalent pyruvate binding of 2 s(-1) and decarboxylation of the formed 2-lactyl-thiamin intermediate of 5 s(-1). In the dormant site, these steps are as slow as 0.03 s(-1). Under the conditions that were used, only the heterotetramer can be detected by analytical ultracentrifugation, thus ruling out the possibility that multiple oligomeric species with different reactivities cause the observed kinetic effects. The results are consistent with the recently suggested model of an active site synchronization in PDHc-E1 via a proton wire that keeps the two active sites in an alternating activation state [Frank, R. A., et al. (2004) Science 306, 872]. Kinetic studies on the related thiamin enzymes transketolase, pyruvate oxidase, and bacterial pyruvate decarboxylase are not consistent with a chemical and/or functional nonequivalence of the active sites as observed in the E1 component of hsPDHc. We hypothesize that the alternating sites reaction in PDHc-E1 aids in the synchronized acyl transfer to the E2 component in the highly organized multienzyme complex.     

Investigation of the symmetry of oligomeric enzymes with bifunctional reagents.

The symmetry of proteins composed of identical polypeptide chains has been investigated by means of cross-linking with bifunctional reagents and subsequent sodium dodecylsulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The majority of the investigations were performed with diimidates of different chain lengths (C3-C12), which react exclusively with amino groups. Aldolase, catalase, fumarase, pyruvate kinase, tetrameric proteins with identical polypeptide chains, reveal a D2 symmetry, i.e. they appear to be composed of two pairs of polypeptide chains. The validity of this conclusion is demonstrated with lactate dehydrogenase. This enzyme, shown by X-ray analysis to have a D2 symmetry, yields after cross-linking and subsequent polyacrylamide electrophoresis the band pattern expected for a protein with this quaternary structure and similar to the pattern obtained with the above enzymes. 2. The influence of the experimental conditions on the cross-linking reaction has been investigated. The selectivity of the bifunctional reagent for the different contact domains within the quaternary structure of a protein depends on the reaction time, the chain length and on the concentration of the reagent. In general the D2 symmetry becomes more obvious with increasing chain length and with increasing concentration of the diimidate. Diethylpyrocarbonate showed very little selectivity.     

A mechanical model for the human intervertebral disc

Stress relaxation experiments were performed on specimens from a human intervertebral disc. Specimens were made from the nucleus pulposus and from the external lamellae of the anulus fibrosus in two different orientations. Tests were run with varying moisture content so as to develop a relaxation master curve. A model was developed based on the experimental data. It was found that the short term master curve for the lamellae of the anulus and nucleus are similar, whereas the long term rubbery plateau is different between the lamellae and the nucleus. It was also established that the master curves for different lamellae and the nucleus were shifted relative to each other in the time domain due to changes in water content. The average relaxation modulus of the whole disc was obtained by averaging the properties between the anulus and nucleus. This model was then used for studies of Schmorl's nodes, of degenerated discs and for circumstances in which hydration is considered to be important.     

A model for the allosteric regulation of pH-sensitive enzymes.

1. In an enzyme that has two independent binding sites for a ligand, any inhibitor that binds solely to the free enzyme will give rise to positive co-operativity. 2. A model is considered for the allosteric control of enzymes by effectors in which their effects are mediated by ligand-induced perturbations of the ionization constants of a group or groups involved in the binding of substrate to the active site. 3. The model described offers a plausible explanation for the observation that the sigmoidal initial-rate curves reported for some regulatory enzymes are not expressed at all pH values where the enzyme is catalytically active.