Migration of neural crest-derived enteric nervous system precursor cells to and within the gastrointestinal tract

The enteric nervous system, the intrinsic innervation of the gastrointestinal tract, consists of large numbers of phenotypically diverse neurons and glial cells, arranged in complex interconnecting plexuses situated between the smooth muscle layers of the gut wall. Recently, the enteric nervous system has attracted much attention from developmental biologists whose efforts have focused on analysing the cellular origins of enteric nervous system precursor cells, how these cells migrate to and within the gut and the identification of signalling mechanisms which cause migrating cells to differentiate into the appropriate phenotypes in the appropriate locations. This review summarises the state of knowledge concerning the early stages of enteric nervous system development and concentrates on: (i) the embryological origins of the neural crest cells which colonise the gastrointestinal tract, (ii) their spatiotemporal migration within the gut, (iii) the possible pre-specification of neural crest cells as enteric nervous system precursors and (iv) factors influencing their directional migration within the gut.     

Sacral neural crest cells colonise aganglionic hindgut in vivo but fail to compensate for lack of enteric ganglia

The vagal neural crest is the origin of majority of neurons and glia that constitute the enteric nervous system, the intrinsic innervation of the gut. We have recently confirmed that a second region of the neuraxis, the sacral neural crest, also contributes to the enteric neuronal and glial populations of both the myenteric and the submucosal plexuses in the chick, caudal to the level of the umbilicus. Results from this previous study showed that sacral neural crest-derived precursors colonised the gut in significant numbers only 4 days after vagal-derived cells had completed their migration along the entire length of the gut. This observation suggested that in order to migrate into the hindgut and differentiate into enteric neurons and glia, sacral neural crest cells may require an interaction with vagal-derived cells or with factors or signalling molecules released by them or their progeny. This interdependence may also explain the inability of sacral neural crest cells to compensate for the lack of ganglia in the terminal hindgut of Hirschsprung's disease in humans or aganglionic megacolon in animals. To investigate the possible interrelationship between sacral and vagal-derived neural crest cells within the hindgut, we mapped the contribution of various vagal neural crest regions to the gut and then ablated appropriate sections of chick vagal neural crest to interrupt the migration of enteric nervous system precursor cells and thus create an aganglionic hindgut model in vivo. In these same ablated animals, the sacral level neural axis was removed and replaced with the equivalent tissue from quail embryos, thus enabling us to document, using cell-specific antibodies, the migration and differentiation of sacral crest-derived cells. Results showed that the vagal neural crest contributed precursors to the enteric nervous system in a regionalised manner. When quail-chick grafts of the neural tube adjacent to somites 1-2 were performed, neural crest cells were found in enteric ganglia throughout the preumbilical gut. These cells were most numerous in the esophagus, sparse in the preumbilical intestine, and absent in the postumbilical gut. When similar grafts adjacent to somites 3-5 or 3-6 were carried out, crest cells were found within enteric ganglia along the entire gut, from the proximal esophagus to the distal colon. Vagal neural crest grafts adjacent to somites 6-7 showed that crest cells from this region were distributed along a caudal-rostral gradient, being most numerous in the hindgut, less so in the intestine, and absent in the proximal foregut. In order to generate aneural hindgut in vivo, it was necessary to ablate the vagal neural crest adjacent to somites 3-6, prior to the 13-somite stage of development. When such ablations were performed, the hindgut, and in some cases also the cecal region, lacked enteric ganglionated plexuses. Sacral neural crest grafting in these vagal neural crest ablated chicks showed that sacral cells migrated along normal, previously described hindgut pathways and formed isolated ganglia containing neurons and glia at the levels of the presumptive myenteric and submucosal plexuses. Comparison between vagal neural crest-ablated and nonablated control animals demonstrated that sacral-derived cells migrated into the gut and differentiated into neurons in higher numbers in the ablated animals than in controls. However, the increase in numbers of sacral neural crest-derived neurons within the hindgut did not appear to be sufficiently high to compensate for the lack of vagal-derived enteric plexuses, as ganglia containing sacral neural crest-derived neurons and glia were small and infrequent. Our findings suggest that the neuronal fate of a relatively fixed subpopulation of sacral neural crest cells may be predetermined as these cells neither require the presence of vagal-derived enteric precursors in order to colonise the hindgut, nor are capable of dramatically altering their proliferation or d     

Identification of Sox8 as a modifier gene in a mouse model of Hirschsprung disease reveals underlying molecular defect

Mice carrying heterozygous mutations in the Sox10 gene display aganglionosis of the colon and represent a model for human Hirschsprung disease. Here, we show that the closely related Sox8 functions as a modifier gene for Sox10-dependent enteric nervous system defects as it increases both penetrance and severity of the defect in Sox10 heterozygous mice despite having no detectable influence on enteric nervous system development on its own. Sox8 exhibits an expression pattern very similar to Sox10 with occurrence in vagal and enteric neural crest cells and later confinement to enteric glia. Loss of Sox8 alleles in Sox10 heterozygous mice impaired colonization of the gut by enteric neural crest cells already at early times. Whereas proliferation, apoptosis, and neuronal differentiation were normal for enteric neural crest cells in the gut of mutant mice, apoptosis was dramatically increased in vagal neural crest cells outside the gut. The defects in enteric nervous system development of mice with Sox10 and Sox8 mutations are therefore likely caused by a reduction of the pool of undifferentiated vagal neural crest cells. Our study suggests that Sox8 and Sox10 are jointly required for the maintenance of these vagal neural crest stem cells.     

Dual embryonic origin of the mammalian enteric nervous system

The enteric nervous system is thought to originate solely from the neural crest. Transgenic lineage tracing revealed a novel population of clonal pancreatic duodenal homeobox-1 (Pdx1)-Cre lineage progenitor cells in the tunica muscularis of the gut that produced pancreatic descendants as well as neurons upon differentiation in vitro. Additionally, an in vivo subpopulation of endoderm lineage enteric neurons, but not glial cells, was seen especially in the proximal gut. Analysis of early transgenic embryos revealed Pdx1-Cre progeny (as well as Sox-17-Cre and Foxa2-Cre progeny) migrating from the developing pancreas and duodenum at E11.5 and contributing to the enteric nervous system. These results show that the mammalian enteric nervous system arises from both the neural crest and the endoderm. Moreover, in adult mice there are separate Wnt1-Cre neural crest stem cells and Pdx1-Cre pancreatic progenitors within the muscle layer of the gut.     

Characterization of HNK-1 antigens during the formation of the avian enteric nervous system.

During vertebrate embryogenesis, interaction between neural crest cells and the enteric mesenchyme gives rise to the development of the enteric nervous system. In birds, monoclonal antibody HNK-1 is a marker for neural crest cells from the entire rostrocaudal axis. In this study, we aimed to characterize the HNK-1 carrying cells and antigen(s) during the formation of the enteric nervous system in the hindgut. Immunohistological findings showed that HNK-1-positive mesenchymal cells are present in the gut prior to neural crest cell colonization. After neural crest cell colonization this cell type cannot be visualized anymore with the HNK-1 antibody. We characterized the HNK-1 antigens that are present before and after neural crest cell colonization of the hindgut. Immunoblot analysis of plasma membranes from embryonic hindgut revealed a wide array of HNK-1-carrying glycoproteins. We found that two HNK-1 antigens are present in E4 hindgut prior to neural crest cell colonization and that the expression of these antigens disappears after neural crest colonization. These two membrane glycoproteins, G-42 and G-44, have relative molecular masses of 42,000 and 44,000, respectively, and they both have isoelectric points of 5.5 under reducing conditions. We suggest that these HNK-1 antigens and the HNK-1-positive mesenchymal cells have some role in the formation of the enteric nervous system.     

The migratory behavior of immature enteric neurons

While they are migrating caudally along the developing gut, around 10%-20% of enteric neural crest-derived cells start to express pan-neuronal markers and tyrosine hydroxylase (TH). We used explants of gut from embryonic TH-green fluorescence protein (GFP) mice and time-lapse microscopy to examine whether these immature enteric neurons migrate and their mode of migration. In the gut of E10.5 and E11.5 TH-GFP mice, around 50% of immature enteric neurons (GFP(+) cells) migrated, with an average speed of around 15 mum/h. This is slower than the speed at which the population of enteric neural crest-derived cells advances along the developing gut, and hence neuronal differentiation seems to slow, but not necessarily halt, the caudal migration of enteric neural crest cells. Most migrating immature enteric neurons migrated caudally by extending a long-leading process followed by translocation of the cell body. This mode of migration is different from that of non-neuronal enteric neural crest-derived cells and neural crest cells in other locations, but resembles that of migrating neurons in many regions of the developing central nervous system (CNS). In migrating immature enteric neurons, a swelling often preceded the movement of the nucleus in the direction of the leading process. However, the centrosomal marker, pericentrin, was not localized to either the leading process or swelling. This seems to be the first detailed report of neuronal migration in the developing mammalian peripheral nervous system.     

Requirement of signalling by receptor tyrosine kinase RET for the directed migration of enteric nervous system progenitor cells during mammalian embryogenesis

The majority of neurones and glia of the enteric nervous system (ENS) are derived from the vagal neural crest. Shortly after emigration from the neural tube, ENS progenitors invade the anterior foregut and, migrating in a rostrocaudal direction, colonise in an orderly fashion the rest of the foregut, the midgut and the hindgut. We provide evidence that activation of the receptor tyrosine kinase RET by glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) is required for the directional migration of ENS progenitors towards and within the gut wall. We find that neural crest-derived cells present within foetal small intestine explants migrate towards an exogenous source of GDNF in a RET-dependent fashion. Consistent with an in vivo role of GDNF in the migration of ENS progenitors, we demonstrate that Gdnf is expressed at high levels in the gut of mouse embryos in a spatially and temporally regulated manner. Thus, during invasion of the foregut by vagal-derived neural crest cells, expression of Gdnf was restricted to the mesenchyme of the stomach, ahead of the invading NC cells. Twenty-four hours later and as the ENS progenitors were colonising the midgut, Gdnf expression was upregulated in a more posterior region - the caecum anlage. In further support of a role of endogenous GDNF in enteric neural crest cell migration, we find that in explant cultures GDNF produced by caecum is sufficient to attract NC cells residing in more anterior gut segments. In addition, two independently generated loss-of-function alleles of murine Ret, Ret.k- and miRet51, result in characteristic defects of neural crest cell migration within the developing gut. Finally, we identify phosphatidylinositol-3 kinase and the mitogen-activated protein kinase signalling pathways as playing crucial roles in the migratory response of enteric neural crest cells to GDNF.     

Vital dye labelling demonstrates a sacral neural crest contribution to the enteric nervous system of chick and mouse embryos

We have used the vital dye, DiI, to analyze the contribution of sacral neural crest cells to the enteric nervous system in chick and mouse embryos. In order to label premigratory sacral neural crest cells selectively, DiI was injected into the lumen of the neural tube at the level of the hindlimb. In chick embryos, DiI injections made prior to stage 19 resulted in labelled cells in the gut, which had emerged from the neural tube adjacent to somites 29-37. In mouse embryos, neural crest cells emigrated from the sacral neural tube between E9 and E9.5. In both chick and mouse embryos, DiI-labelled cells were observed in the rostral half of the somitic sclerotome, around the dorsal aorta, in the mesentery surrounding the gut, as well as within the epithelium of the gut. Mouse embryos, however, contained consistently fewer labelled cells than chick embryos. DiI-labelled cells first were observed in the rostral and dorsal portion of the gut. Paralleling the maturation of the embryo, there was a rostral-to-caudal sequence in which neural crest cells populated the gut at the sacral level. In addition, neural crest cells appeared within the gut in a dorsal-to-ventral sequence, suggesting that the cells entered the gut dorsally and moved progressively ventrally. The present results resolve a long-standing discrepancy in the literature by demonstrating that sacral neural crest cells in both the chick and mouse contribute to the enteric nervous system in the postumbilical gut.     

Development of the mammalian enteric nervous system.

The mammalian enteric nervous system is derived from neural crest cells which invade the foregut and hindgut mesenchyme. It has been established that signalling molecules produced by the mesenchyme of the gut wall play a critical role in the development of the mammalian enteric nervous system. Recent studies have characterised further the role of such molecules and have identified novel extracellular and intracellular signals that are critical for enteric ganglia formation.     

Neural and glial phenotypic expression by neural crest cells in culture: effects of control and presumptive aganglionic bowel from ls/ls mice

The enteric nervous system is formed by cells that migrate to the bowel from the neural crest. Previous experiments have established that avian crest cells in vitro will colonize explants of murine bowel and there give rise to neurons. It has been proposed that phenotypic expression by the crest-derived precursors of enteric neurons and glia is critically influenced by the microenvironment these cells encounter within the gut. To test this hypothesis, quail crest cells were cocultured with explants of control or presumptive aganglionic bowel from the ls/ls mutant mouse, and the effects of the enteric tissue on five phenotypic markers of crest cell development were followed. Aganglionosis develops in the terminal region of the colon of the ls/ls mouse because viable crest-derived neural and glial precursors fail to colonize this tissue. Expression of the phenotypic markers in the cocultures was compared with that in cultures of crest alone, crest plus neural tube, and gut grown alone. The markers examined were melanogenesis and immunostaining with antisera to 5-hydroxytryptamine (5-HT) and tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) and the monoclonal antibodies, NC-1 and GlN1. Explants of control, but not presumptive aganglionic ls/ls gut were found to increase the incidence of the expression of 5-HT and NC-1 immunoreactivities; moreover, especially near the gut, the assumption of a neuronal morphology by 5-HT-, NC-1-, and GlN1-immunoreactive cells was also increased. Coincidence of expression of 5-HT with NC-1 and GlN1 immunoreactivities was observed. The effect of the bowel was selective in that the expression of TH immunoreactivity, which is not a marker of mature enteric neurons, was reduced rather than enhanced. The effect of enteric explants on crest cell development was specific in that it was not mimicked by explants of metanephros, which inhibited expression of 5-HT immunoreactivity and the acquisition of a neuritic form by NC-1-immunoreactive cells. It is concluded that the enteric microenvironment affects the phenotypic expression of subsets of crest cells and that this action of the bowel is manifested in vitro. The inability of presumptive aganglionic gut from ls/ls mice to influence neural phenotypic expression may be due to the failure of this tissue to produce putative factor(s) required for the effect or to the inability of the crest-derived precursor cells to migrate into the abnormal enteric tissue.     

Notch signaling is required for the maintenance of enteric neural crest progenitors

Notch signaling is involved in neurogenesis, including that of the peripheral nervous system as derived from neural crest cells (NCCs). However, it remains unclear which step is regulated by this signaling. To address this question, we took advantage of the Cre-loxP system to specifically eliminate the protein O-fucosyltransferase 1 (Pofut1) gene, which is a core component of Notch signaling, in NCCs. NCC-specific Pofut1-knockout mice died within 1 day of birth, accompanied by a defect of enteric nervous system (ENS) development. These embryos showed a reduction in enteric neural crest cells (ENCCs) resulting from premature neurogenesis. We found that Sox10 expression, which is normally maintained in ENCC progenitors, was decreased in Pofut1-null ENCCs. By contrast, the number of ENCCs that expressed Mash1, a potent repressor of Sox10, was increased in the Pofut1-null mouse. Given that Mash1 is suppressed via the Notch signaling pathway, we propose a model in which ENCCs have a cell-autonomous differentiating program for neurons as reflected in the expression of Mash1, and in which Notch signaling is required for the maintenance of ENS progenitors by attenuating this cell-autonomous program via the suppression of Mash1.     

Non-cell-autonomous effects of Ret deletion in early enteric neurogenesis

Neural crest cells (NCCs) form at the dorsal margin of the neural tube and migrate along distinct pathways throughout the vertebrate embryo to generate multiple cell types. A subpopulation of vagal NCCs invades the foregut and colonises the entire gastrointestinal tract to form the enteric nervous system (ENS). The colonisation of embryonic gut by NCCs has been studied extensively in chick embryos, and genetic studies in mice have identified genes crucial for ENS development, including Ret. Here, we have combined mouse embryo and organotypic gut culture to monitor and experimentally manipulate the progenitors of the ENS. Using this system, we demonstrate that lineally marked intestinal ENS progenitors from E11.5 mouse embryos grafted into the early vagal NCC pathway of E8.5 embryos colonise the entire length of the gastrointestinal tract. By contrast, similar progenitors transplanted into Ret-deficient host embryos are restricted to the proximal foregut. Our findings establish an experimental system that can be used to explore the interactions of NCCs with their cellular environment and reveal a previously unrecognised non-cell-autonomous effect of Ret deletion on ENS development.     

N-cadherin and β1-integrins cooperate during the development of the enteric nervous system

Cell adhesion controls various embryonic morphogenetic processes, including the development of the enteric nervous system (ENS). Ablation of β1-integrin (β1-/-) expression in enteric neural crest cells (ENCC) in mice leads to major alterations in the ENS structure caused by reduced migration and increased aggregation properties of ENCC during gut colonization, which gives rise to a Hirschsprung's disease-like phenotype. In the present study, we examined the role of N-cadherin in ENS development and the interplay with β1 integrins during this process. The Ht-PA-Cre mouse model was used to target gene disruption of N-cadherin and β1 integrin in migratory NCC and to produce single- and double-conditional mutants for these two types of adhesion receptors. Double mutation of N-cadherin and β1 integrin led to embryonic lethality with severe defects in ENS development. N-cadherin-null (Ncad-/-) ENCC exhibited a delayed colonization in the developing gut at E12.5, although this was to a lesser extent than in β1-/- mutants. This delay of Ncad-/- ENCC migration was recovered at later stages of development. The double Ncad-/-; β1-/- mutant ENCC failed to colonize the distal part of the gut and there was more severe aganglionosis in the proximal hindgut than in the single mutants for N-cadherin or β1-integrin. This was due to an altered speed of locomotion and directionality in the gut wall. The abnormal aggregation defect of ENCC and the disorganized ganglia network in the β1-/- mutant was not observed in the double mutant. This indicates that N-cadherin enhances the effect of the β1-integrin mutation and demonstrates cooperation between these two adhesion receptors during ENS ontogenesis. In conclusion, our data reveal that N-cadherin is not essential for ENS development but it does modulate the modes of ENCC migration and acts in concert with β1-integrin to control the proper development of the ENS.     

Dual function of Slit2 in repulsion and enhanced migration of trunk,but not vagal,neural crest cells

Neural crest precursors to the autonomic nervous system form different derivatives depending upon their axial level of origin; for example, vagal, but not trunk, neural crest cells form the enteric ganglia of the gut. Here, we show that Slit2 is expressed at the entrance of the gut, which is selectively invaded by vagal, but not trunk, neural crest. Accordingly, only trunk neural crest cells express Robo receptors. In vivo and in vitro experiments demonstrate that trunk, not vagal, crest cells avoid cells or cell membranes expressing Slit2, thereby contributing to the differential ability of neural crest populations to invade and innervate the gut. Conversely, exposure to soluble Slit2 significantly increases the distance traversed by trunk neural crest cells. These results suggest that Slit2 can act bifunctionally, both repulsing and stimulating the motility of trunk neural crest cells.     

Immunostaining to Visualize Murine Enteric Nervous System Development

The enteric nervous system is formed by neural crest cells that proliferate, migrate and colonize the gut. Following colonization, neural crest cells must then differentiate into neurons with markers specific for their neurotransmitter phenotype. Cholinergic neurons, a major neurotransmitter phenotype in the enteric nervous system, are identified by staining for choline acetyltransferase (ChAT), the synthesizing enzyme for acetylcholine. Historical efforts to visualize cholinergic neurons have been hampered by antibodies with differing specificities to central nervous system versus peripheral nervous system ChAT. We and others have overcome this limitation by using an antibody against placental ChAT, which recognizes both central and peripheral ChAT, to successfully visualize embryonic enteric cholinergic neurons. Additionally, we have compared this antibody to genetic reporters for ChAT and shown that the antibody is more reliable during embryogenesis. This protocol describes a technique for dissecting, fixing and immunostaining of the murine embryonic gastrointestinal tract to visualize enteric nervous system neurotransmitter expression.     

Development of the enteric nervous system in chick embryonic duodenum in terms of the distribution of tubulin

An immunohistochemical method that uses anti-tubulin was utilized to observe the development of the enteric nervous system in chick embryonic duodenum. Neural crest cells, and enteric neuroblasts, or enteric ganglia, which derive from neural crest cells were clearly shown as sharp immunoreactive regions of tubulin. The distributions of enteric neuroblasts and enteric ganglia in chick duodena were in agreement with results of previous reports in which different techniques were used. The initial stage at which cells of neural crest origin were present in the duodenal walls (4-day-old embryos) was earlier than the initial stage (about 6-day-old embryos) reported earlier. This was verified by transmission electron microscopy. Also, the tubulin that is a component of the enteric nervous system was shown to be stable at a low temperature. This tubulin-immunostaining method provides a useful histochemical technique with which to study the development of the enteric ganglion and the function of tubulin as a component of the enteric nervous system.