A comparison between freezing methods for the cryopreservation of stallion spermatozoa

The effects of sperm freezing concentration (40 × 10⁶ mL⁻¹ vs. 400 × 10⁶ mL⁻¹), straw size (0.25 mL vs. 0.5 mL) and freezing method (liquid nitrogen vapour in a Styrofoam^® box vs. programmable freezing machine) were evaluated in a 2 × 2 × 2 factorial experimental design using 3 split ejaculates from each of 4 stallions. Immediately after thawing, the total motility and forward progressive motility of spermatozoa frozen at a concentration of 40 × 10⁶ mL⁻¹ was higher than for spermatozoa frozen at 400 × 10⁶ mL⁻¹. No significant differences were observed in the semen parameters assessed after cryopreservation in either 0.25 or 0.5 mL straws. However, the programmable freezer provided a more consistent and reliable freezing rate than liquid nitrogen vapour. We conclude that an effective protocol for the cryopreservation of stallion spermatozoa at low concentrations would include concentrations of 40 × 10⁶ mL⁻¹ in 0.25 mL straws using a programmable freezer. This freezing protocol would be suitable for emerging sperm technologies such as sex-preselection of stallion spermatozoa as the sorting process yields only low numbers of spermatozoa in a small volume available for either immediate insemination or cryopreservation.     

Morphological and functional changes of stallion spermatozoa after cryopreservation during breeding and non-breeding season

The study compared quality and freezability of stallion semen during breeding and non-breeding seasons. Ejaculates were collected twice per week from four stallions during May (n = 24) and December (n = 24). The semen was mixed with skim milk extender, centrifuged and resuspended in fresh extender. Aliquots of this sperm suspension were separated from extender and diluted in TALP medium for sperm evaluation or with cryoextender (type "Gent" or a combination of Triladyl and skim milk). Samples of 0.5ml were cryopreserved in straws using a programmed freezer. Parameters of sperm quality were evaluated before and after freezing/thawing. These included percentages of motile spermatozoa and of morphological intact sperm. Typical injuries were demonstrated by scanning electron microscopy (S.E.M.). The acrosomal status was visualised using FITC-conjugated peanut agglutinin, and the acrosome reaction was induced by calcium ionophore A 23187. The chromatin stability was estimated by acridine orange test.In winter, the average percentages of motile and morphologically normal sperm (67 and 74.3%, respectively) were higher than during the breeding season in May (59 and 65.9%; P < 0.05). After freezing/thawing the proportions of vital and intact sperm decreased significantly. The number of motile sperm declined to 15 and 18% in May and December (range 5-40%), and of morphologically intact sperm to 51% in both seasons. Results of S.E.M. showed typical membrane ruptures in the acrosomal region and some sperm with abnormal necks. The proportion of frozen sperm with spontaneous acrosome reaction was higher during winter (86.5 versus 77.0%), suggesting a higher degree of membrane reactivity. Percentages of spermatozoa with denaturated chromatin were minimal and showed minimal differences between fresh and frozen state, stallions or seasons. An additional decondensation treatment with papain and DTE revealed a slightly enhanced number of spermatozoa with denaturable DNA after cryopreservation, especially in December (5.4 +/- 1.3%). The influence of cryoextenders was not significant for most sperm parameters, but there was a high variability between the stallions. Altogether, the influence of factors on the quality of spermatozoa has the following rank order: cryopreservation > stallion > season. Different cellular structures seem to have different susceptibilities to physicochemical stress. The cryopreservation of sperm during December results in survival rates similar to those measured during the breeding season, even more important for successful preservation is the selection of suitable semen donors.     

Changes in quality of stallion spermatozoa during cryopreservation: Plasma membrane integrity and motion characteristics

Better procedures for freezing and thawing equine sperm are needed since variable fertility is obtained when cryopreserved sperm are used. To evaluate current methods of freezing equine sperm, we examined spermatozoal quality by means of two new techniques. These measured the integrity of plasma-acrosomal membranes by immunofluorescent analyses of binding of an antibody specific to the acrosome and evaluated eight parameters of spermatozoal motion using a fully automated computerized system. Five ejaculates from each of eight stallions were processed for freezing in egg yolk-lactose extender with 4% glycerol. Spermatozoal quality was assessed at four different points: at less than 15 min after collecting and before processing (Step 1); after centrifugation and just before freezing (Step 2); immediately after thawing less than 3 h after freezing (Step 3); and immediately after thawing 10 to 20 d after freezing (Step 4). Acrosome-specific monoclonal antibody detected differences (P <0.05) among steps and ejaculates within stallions. All parameters of spermatozoal motion, including the percentage of motile sperm, percentage of progressively motile sperm, curvilinear velocity, straight line velocity, linearity, amplitude of lateral head displacement, and radius of the average path for circularly swimming sperm, differed (P <0.05) among steps, and most of these parameters differed among ejaculates within a stallion and among stallions. For Steps 2 and 3, 62 and 37% of the sperm were motile, and 56 and 23% of all motile sperm had a curvilinear velocity of >100 mum/sec. Most damage to sperm occurred as a result of freezing-thawing, whereas centrifugation of sperm caused only minor damage.     

Morphological characteristics of stallion spermatozoa

A study of the morphological characteristics of stallion spermatozoa was conducted at the semen laboratory of the Department of Animal Production during four breeding seasons. A total of 590 ejaculates collected from 216 stallions aged from 2 to 26 years and including 13 breeds or colour types was examined. Overall means for the spermatozoal characteristics of these stallions and the classes of head and tail abnormalities are presented and compared with results of other works. Scanning electron micrographs are included to illustrate recognised abnormalities.     

Nuclear status of immature and mature stallion spermatozoa

'The highly packed chromatin of mature spermatozoa results from replacement of somatic-like histones by highly basic arginine- and cysteine-rich protamines during spermatogenesis, with additional conformational changes in chromatin structure during epididymal transit. The objective of the present study was to compare the nuclear characteristics of immature and mature epididymal stallion spermatozoa, using a variety of experimental approaches. Resistance to in vitro decondensation of chromatin, following exposure to SDS-DTT and alkaline thioglycolate, increased significantly in mature spermatozoa. Evaluation of the thiol-disulfide status (monobromobimane labeling) demonstrated that immature cells obtained from ductulli efferentes contained mostly thiol groups, whereas these groups were oxidized in mature cells collected from the cauda epididymidis. Based on atomic absorption spectrophotometry, maturation of stallion spermatozoa was accompanied by a 60% reduction in the Zn(2+) content of sperm cells, concomitant with increased concentrations of this ion in epididymal fluid. Furthermore, the degree of disulfide bonding was inversely correlated with susceptibility of chromatin to acid denaturation (SCSA). Collectively, these data were consistent with the hypothesis that maturation of stallion spermatozoa involves oxidation of sulphydryl groups to form intra- and intermolecular disulfide links between adjacent protamines, with loss of zinc as an integral feature. These changes endow mechanical and chemical resistance to the nucleus, ensuring efficient transmission of the paternal genome at fertilization.     

Challenges facing sex preselection of stallion spermatozoa

Since the production of the first live offspring from sex-sorted spermatozoa in 1989, there have been many developments in the fluorescence-activated cell separation (FACS) procedures to preselect X- and Y-chromosome bearing spermatozoa prior to insemination. During this time, FACS technology has been applied to a range of species and has resulted in offspring from rabbits, cattle, sheep, elk and horses. In horses, satisfactory fertility rates have been achieved after hysteroscopic insemination of 20 x 10(6) fresh or stored, sex-sorted spermatozoa. However, many of the sperm processing protocols are still based on the original protocol and components of these procedures may not necessarily be suitable for the stallion. This review examines the details of FACS protocols that have resulted in the production of live offspring and makes comparisons with the published stallion protocols in an attempt to determine how best to improve the fertility of sorted, frozen-thawed stallion spermatozoa.     

Inhibition of the mitochondrial permeability transition pore reduces “apoptosis like” changes during cryopreservation of stallion spermatozoa

In order to evaluate to what extent the changes that occur during cryopreservation involve the mitochondrial permeability transition pore (PT-pore), a specific inhibitor was used during the cryopreservation process of stallion spermatozoa. Four ejaculates from each of 7 stallions were frozen using a standard protocol. Before freezing, each ejaculate was split into three subsamples. The first was supplemented with 2.5 μM bongkrekic acid (BA) and the second with 5 μM BA. The third subsample served as control. The BA significantly reduced the percentage of spermatozoa depicting active caspases after thawing, reduced the percentage of spermatozoa with increased membrane permeability, and increased the mitochondrial membrane potential of thawed sperm. Sperm motility was reduced as a result of the treatment. It is concluded that the mitochondrial pathway of apoptosis seems to be an important factor involved in the sublethal damage that equine spermatozoa experience after freezing and thawing, and that sperm motility in the equine species is largely dependent on mitochondrial ATP produced by oxidative phosphorylation.     

Alpha-mannosidase activity in stallion epididymal fluid and spermatozoa

The expression of α-D-mannosidase activity was fluorometrically and electrophoretically assessed in spermatozoa, epididymal fluid and homogenates of stallion epididymal tissue. Enzyme activity had regional differences; it was higher (P < 0.05) in samples from the cauda epididymal region than in samples from the proximal caput region (largely composed of efferent ducts). Based on enzyme activity, as a function of pH of the assay substrate, electrophoretic analysis in native and native/SDS-PAGE conditions, and the effect of inhibitors or activators, we inferred the presence of at least two catalytically active forms of α-D-mannosidase. The neutral form of the enzyme (α-mannosidase II) was activated by Co²⁺, whereas the acid form (optimum pH 3.5 to 4.0) was sensitive to swainsonine (an inhibitor of α-mannosidase I), stabilized or stimulated by Zn²⁺, and not activated by Co²⁺ (activator of the neutral form). The activity of the acid form of the enzyme was highest in the epididymal fluid, where it seemed to be mainly in a secretory form. This form of the enzyme may have a role in plasma membrane remodeling associated with sperm maturation. In contrast, the activity of α-mannosidase II was higher in mature spermatozoa. It has been postulated that α-mannosidase II may act as a receptor in the recognition and binding of the complementary carbohydrate moieties present on the zona pellucida. With non-denaturing electrophoresis, α-D-mannosidase had an electrophoretic mobility of 0.35 and 0.24. When resolved by 1D and 2D SDS-PAGE (under denaturing conditions) the enzyme had a major protein band of molecular weight 154 kDa in spermatozoa and epididymal samples. Based on its properties under native conditions, we inferred that this enzyme might interact with other proteins and form transitory aggregates.     

Field fertility of sex-sorted and non-sorted frozen-thawed stallion spermatozoa

In the 2004/2005 breeding season, the fertility of sex-sorted (SS) and non-sorted (NS) frozen stallion spermatozoa from two Hannovarian stallions was compared. A hysteroscopic insemination technique [Morris, L.H., Tiplady, C., Allen, W.R., 2003a. Pregnancy rates in mares after a single fixed time hysteroscopic insemination of low numbers of frozen–thawed spermatozoa onto the uterotubal junction. Equine Vet. J. 35, 197–201] was used to deposit low doses (6, 13 or 25 × 10⁶ frozen–thawed SS or NS spermatozoa) onto the utero-tubal junction at 32 or 38 h after the administration of Chorulon (2500 IU, Intervet). Fertility was low, with one pregnancy (13 × 10⁶ spermatozoa, 500 μL) obtained after artificial insemination with frozen SS spermatozoa (n = 29 cycles) which resulted in the birth of a filly. Two pregnancies were obtained in mares inseminated with 6 × 10⁶ NS spermatozoa in 250 μL (n = 31 cycles). Mares failing to conceive on two experimental cycles were allocated to the conventional insemination group. Insemination with >500 × 10⁶ motile NS frozen–thawed spermatozoa, yielded satisfactory per cycle conception rates (35.5%, 22/62) for both stallions combined and was within the values of their normal fertility as quoted by the stud's records. This suggests that the quality of the frozen semen was acceptable and that the freezing processes yielded viable spermatozoa capable of fertilisation. The poor fertility after hysteroscopic insemination with low doses of sex-sorted or non-sorted spermatozoa from the same stallions may be directly attributable to the low dose insemination conditions with frozen–thawed rather than sex-sorted spermatozoa.     

Influence of bacteria and gentamicin on cooled-stored stallion spermatozoa

This study investigated effects of bacteria from the genital tract of horses and the effect of gentamicin in semen extender on spermatozoal function in cooled-stored stallion semen. Semen was collected from healthy stallions and processed with a milk-based extender with or without gentamicin (1g/l). Pseudomonas (Ps.) aeruginosa, Staphylococcus (St.) aureus, Streptococcus (Sc.) equi subsp. equi (Sc. equi), Sc. equi subsp. zooepidemicus (Sc. zooepidemicus), Sc. dysgalactiae subsp. equisimilis (Sc. equisimilis) or culture medium alone (control) were added. Immediately after addition of bacteria and after storage at 5 degrees C for 24, 48 and 72h, motility, velocity and membrane integrity of diluted semen were determined with a CASA system. After 24h, semen with Ps. aeruginosa and Sc. equisimilis showed significantly lower motility and velocity compared to all other groups; after 72h these differences still existed for Ps. aeruginosa (p<0.05). The percentage of membrane-intact spermatozoa was significantly lower after 24h of storage in spermatozoa incubated with Sc. equisimilis and after 72h with Sc. equisimilis and Ps. aeruginosa. Addition of gentamicin to extender resulted in decreased motility and velocity in semen without addition of bacteria and did not improve motility parameters in semen with bacteria added. In conclusion, certain bacteria may have detrimental effects on semen quality during cooled-storage. These effects are not reduced by addition of gentamicin. Gentamicin can negatively affect spermatozoal function in extended semen during cooled-storage and therefore, optimal concentrations have to be tested for the respective extender medium.     

Evaluation of in vitro capacitation of stallion spermatozoa

The primary aim of this study was to establish a flow cytometric technique for determining the capacitation status of stallion spermatozoa. To this end, a flow cytometric technique that demonstrates changes in plasma membrane fluidity; namely, merocyanine 540 staining, was compared with the more conventional Ca(2+)-dependent fluorescence microscopic technique, chlortetracycline (CTC) staining, for assessing capacitation status. In addition, the effect of bicarbonate/CO(2) on the progress of capacitation and the acrosome reaction (AR) and on temporal changes in sperm motility, with particular regard to hyperactivation, was analyzed. For the study, fresh semen was washed and then incubated for 5 h in bicarbonate-containing or bicarbonate-free medium, with or without Ca(2+) ionophore to induce the AR, and at intervals during incubation aliquots were taken and analyzed for capacitation and acrosome status. The AR was assessed using both the CTC and fluorescein isothiocyanate-peanut agglutinin (FITC-PNA) staining techniques with similar results. In brief, it was found that merocyanine 540 detects capacitation-related changes much earlier than CTC does (0.5 h versus approximately 3 h), and that flow cytometry for evaluation of capacitation and AR was a quicker (10 sec per sample) and more accurate (10,000 cells counted) technique than fluorescence microscopy. Furthermore, it was observed that Ca(2+) ionophore could not induce the AR in the absence of bicarbonate, but that the ionophore synergized the bicarbonate-mediated induction of the AR as detected by CTC (although it was not significant when evaluated using FITC-PNA). The percentage of hyperactive sperm in each sample was not affected by time of incubation under the experimental conditions studied. In conclusion, merocyanine 540 staining is a better method than CTC staining for evaluating the early events of capacitation for stallion spermatozoa incubated in vitro. Furthermore, bicarbonate sperm activation clearly plays a vital role in the induction of the AR in stallion spermatozoa.     

Morphometry of stallion spermatozoa by computer-assisted image analysis

Metric measurements of stallion spermatozoal heads were determined for live, unfixed spermatozoa and for Feulgen-stained spermatozoa by videomicroscopy and computerized image analysis. Two ejaculates were collected from each of five stallions of normal fertility. Air-dried semen smears were Feulgen-stained, and live, unfixed spermatozoa were examined as wet-mount preparations. For Feulgen-stained spermatozoa, videoimages (x3850) were captured, and sperm heads were detected via image segmentation and particle analysis. For live, unfixed spermatozoa, phase contrast videoimages (x3850) were measured to determine width and length of the sperm head. For Feulgen-stained spermatozoa, there were significant effects (P < 0.001) of stallion and ejaculate on measured parameters of area, circumference, and the length and width of the sperm head. For live, unfixed spermatozoa, there were significant effects of stallion on length and width and of ejaculate on length of the sperm heads. There was a very poor correlation between length and width of sperm heads between Feulgen-stained and live, unfixed spermatozoa. Two indices of sperm shape (oval factor and aspect ratio) were also determined. Both aspect ratio and oval factor were significantly affected by stallion (P < 0.001); however, oval factor was not affected by ejaculate and therefore may represent a less variable determination of sperm head shape across stallions. Overall, length and width of stallion sperm heads were larger (P < 0.01) for live, unfixed spermatozoa than for Feulgen-stained spermatozoa (length: 6.3 +/- 0.4 vs 5.08 +/- 0.44; width: 3.08 +/- 0.34 vs 2.71 +/- 0.28 mum, respectively). Computerized image analysis may be useful as a means to objectively measure sperm head dimensions in the stallion and could be useful in future studies to determine associations with stallion fertility.     

Evaluation of alternative cryoprotectants for preserving stallion spermatozoa

Although use of cryopreserved stallion spermatozoa is currently accepted by many breed registries, utilization of this technique remains limited due to poor fertility for some stallions. One reason for these results is osmotic stress that spermatozoa experiences when the cryoprotectant (glycerol) is added to the cells prior to freezing and removal from the cells after thawing. In an effort to minimize osmotic damage, alternative cryoprotectants, having lower molecular weights and greater membrane permeability than glycerol, were evaluated to determine their effectiveness for cryopreserving stallion spermatozoa. In the first experiment, equal molar concentrations of several amides were compared to determine if they could preserve the motility of sperm as well as glycerol. At 0.55 M concentration, addition of glycerol to a skim milk-egg yolk (SMEY) diluent resulted in higher percentages of motile sperm (61%) than methyl formamide (40%) or dimethyl formamide (38%, P<0.05), while formamide, acetamide, and methyl acetamide resulted in recovery of less than 20% motile cells (P<0.05). When methyl formamide or dimethyl formamide were increased to 0.6 or 0.9 M they resulted in percentages of motile cells (48-54%) similar to that achieved with glycerol (52%). Similarly, 0.9 M ethylene glycol also resulted in similar percentages of motile cells (43%). Replacing the glucose and fructose in the SMEY diluent with either raffinose or trehalose did not result in higher percentages of motile sperm (65 and 66%, respectively) than the control SMEY (63%). Similarly, addition of methyl cellulose also did not increase the percentages of motile spermatozoa in the samples, after cryopreservation (P>0.05). In conclusion, both methyl formamide and dimethyl formamide protected stallion spermatozoa from cryodamage as effectively as glycerol. Since these compounds permeate the plasma membrane more effectively than glycerol, they should cause less osmotic damage to stallion spermatozoa than glycerol. Therefore, these compounds may prove very effective in the cryopreservation of stallion spermatozoa, and may be particularly useful for spermatozoa from stallions that produce spermatozoa that have poor post-thaw characteristics when glycerol is used as the cryoprotectant.     

Current methods for stallion semen cryopreservation: a survey

Various factors affect the success of AI with frozen-thawed semen in horses. Stallion variability is thought to be one of the major factors, but semen processing and evaluation techniques, thawing protocols, packaging systems and timing of insemination are far from standardized among laboratories. Our objective was to survey current methods for stallion semen cryopreservation used commercially around the world. From the answers to the questions in the survey, we attempted to provide an overview of procedures that are standard as well as those that are used by only few laboratories and to review critically the efficacy of these procedures. Twenty-five questionnaires were sent to individuals or laboratories in 14 countries that were i.v. involved in freezing stallion semen for commercial purposes. Questionnaires were returned from 10/14 countries with 21/25 (84%) of the addresses responding. From the responses, it became evident that most of prefreezing, freezing and thawing and post-thawing processing procedures were far from standardized. The great variety of procedures makes it difficult to accept any of them as reliable. In order to increase the credibility of AI technology in the horse, laboratories need to standardize processing methods as well as the record-keeping systems. In addition, it is evident that no group of research mares is large enough to provide meaningful fertility data. It is therefore imperative to have multicentered collaborative studies to record and disseminate information about methods and the corresponding fertility rate. to gain valuable information and be able to compare different protocols.