Molecular Phylogenetic Position of Hoplonympha natator (Trichonymphea,Parabasalia): Horizontal Symbiont Transfer or Differential Loss?

Hoplonympha natator is an obligate symbiont of Paraneotermes simplicicornis (Kalotermitidae), from southwestern North America. Another Hoplonympha species inhabits Hodotermopsis sjostedti (Archotermopsidae), from montane Southeast Asia. The large phylogenetic and geographical distance between the hosts makes the distribution of Hoplonympha puzzling. Here, we report the phylogenetic position of H. natator from P. simplicicornis through maximum likelihood and Bayesian analysis of 18S rRNA genes. The two Hoplonympha species form a clade with a deep node, making a recent symbiont transfer unlikely. The distribution of Hoplonympha may be due to an ancient transfer or strict vertical inheritance with differential loss from other hosts.     

Molecular Identity of Holomastigotes (Spirotrichonymphea,Parabasalia) with Descriptions of Holomastigotes flavipes n. sp. and Holomastigotes tibialis n. sp.

Holomastigotes is a protist genus (Parabasalia: Spirotrichonymphea) that resides in the hindguts of “lower” termites. It can be distinguished from other parabasalids by spiral flagellar bands that run along the entire length of the cell, an anterior nucleus, a reduced or absent axostyle, the presence of spherical vesicles inside the cells, and the absence of ingested wood particles. Eight species have been described based on their morphology so far, although no molecular data were available prior to this study. We determined the 18S rRNA gene sequences of Holomastigotes from the hindguts of Hodotermopsis sjostedti, Reticulitermes flavipes, Reticulitermes lucifugus, and Reticulitermes tibialis. Phylogenetic analyses placed all sequences in an exclusive and well‐supported clade with the type species, Holomastigotes elongatum from R. lucifugus. However, the phylogenetic position of Holomastigotes within the Spirotrichonymphea was not resolved. We describe two new species, Holomastigotes flavipes n. sp. and Holomastigotes tibialis n. sp., inhabiting the hindguts of R. flavipes and R. tibialis, respectively.     

COMPARATIVE ULTRASTRUCTURE OF ZOOSPORES WITH PARALLEL BASAL BODIES FROM THE GREEN ALGAE DICTYOCHLORIS FRAGRANS AND BRACTEACOCCUS SP.

The chlorococcalean algae Dictyochloris fragrans and Bracteacoccus sp. produce naked zoospores with two unequal flagella and parallel basal bodies. Ultrastructural features of the flagellar apparatus of these zoospores are basically identical and include a banded distal fiber, two proximal fibers, and four cruciately arranged microtubular rootlets with only one microtubule in each dexter rootlet. In D. fragrans, each proximal fiber is composed of two subfibers, one striated and one nonstriated, and each sinister rootlet is composed of five microtubules (4/1), decreasing to four away from the basal bodies. In Bracteacoccus sp., each proximal fiber is a single unit, the sinister rootlets are four (3/1) or rarely five (4/1) microtubules, and each basal body is associated with an unusual curved structure. The basic features of the flagellar apparatus of the zoospores of these two algae resemble those of Heterochlamydomonas rather than most other chlorococcalean algae that have equal length flagella, basal bodies in the V-shape arrangement, and clockwise absolute orientation. It is proposed that these algae with unequal flagella and parallel basal bodies have a shared common ancestry within the green algae.     

Comparative cytological study of four species in the genera Holomastigotes and Uteronympha n. comb. (Holomastigotidae, Parabasalia), symbiotic flagellates of termites

Cytological features observed using light, immunofluorescence, and electron microscopy of the type species Holomastigotes elongatum were compared with Holomastigotes lanceolata and to Holomastigotes flexuosum n. sp. The comparison was extended to Spirotrichonymphella pudibunda and to Uteronympha africana n. gen. n. sp., in order to present the common features of the Holomastigotidae (Spirotrichonymphida). All these species have anterior basal bodies bearing microfibrillar or striated rootlets that are reduced or absent posterior to the nucleus. An axostylar trunk is present in Holomastigotes elongatum and Holomastigotes lanceolata, whereas the axostylar microtubules do not extend posterior to the nucleus in Holomastigotes flexuosum, Spirotrichonymphella, and Uteronympha. Uteronympha africana has specific features, such as a transverse plaque inside the columella from which arise microtubules capping the nucleus, and as in Spirotrichonympha the striated lamina is present all along the flagellar lines. Uteronympha africana has ability to endocytose wood particles in addition to the osmotrophic feeding that occurs in all the Holomastigotidae.     

FLAGELLAR MOTION AND FINE STRUCTURE OF THE FLAGELLAR APPARATUS IN CHLAMYDOMONAS

The biflagellate alga Chlamydomonas reinhardi was studied with the light and electron microscopes to determine the behavior of flagella in the living cell and the structure of the basal apparatus of the flagella. During normal forward swimming the flagella beat synchronously in the same plane, as in the human swimmer's breast stroke. The form of beat is like that of cilia. Occasionally cells swim backward with the flagella undulating and trailing the cell. Thus the same flagellar apparatus produces two types of motion. The central pair of fibers of both flagella appear to lie in the same plane, which coincides with the plane of beat. The two basal bodies lie in a V configuration and are joined at the top by a striated fiber and at the bottom by two smaller fibers. From the area between the basal bodies four bands of microtubules, each containing four tubules, radiate in an X-shaped pattern, diverge, and pass under the cell membrane. Details of the complex arrangement of tubules near the basal bodies are described. It seems probable that the connecting fibers and the microtubules play structural roles and thereby maintain the alignment of the flagellar apparatus. The relation of striated fibers and microtubules to cilia and flagella is reviewed, particularly in phytoflagellates and protozoa. Structures observed in the transitional region between the basal body and flagellar shaft are described and their occurrence is reviewed. Details of structure of the flagellar shaft and flagellar tip are described, and the latter is reviewed in detail.     

ULTRASTRUCTURE OF THE BIFLAGELLATE MOTILE CELLS OF ULVARIA OXYSPERMA (KÜTZ.) BLIDING AND PHYLOGENETIC RELATIONSHIPS AMONG ULVAPHYCEAN ALGAE

The detailed fine structure of the biflagellate motile cells of Ulvaria oxysperma (Kiitz.) Bliding is described. These cells demonstrate most of the features presently used to characterize the ulvaphycean motile cell, i.e., the capping plate, terminal cap, alternating two- and four-membered rootlets, rhizoplasts that extend posteriorly into the cell, the striated microtubule-associated component (SMAC) near the two-membered rootlets, microtubule septations in the basal bodies and flagella, and scales covering the external surface of the cell. In addition, the anterior end components have 180° rotational symmetry. The rootlets insert into the basal body complex in the anterior region just beneath the capping plate, and the rhizoplasts insert into triangularshaped proximal fibers that connect the basal bodies. The features of many other ulvaphycean algae are summarized and compared with Ulvaria oxysperma. Based on comparative ultrastructure, it is suggested that the Ulvaphyceae diverged from the Chlorophyceae after the separation of these two classes from the Charophyceae.     

Proteins related to green algal striated fiber assemblin are present in stramenopiles and alveolates

In green algae, striated fiber assemblin (SFA) is the major protein of the striated microtubule-associated fibers that are structural elements in the flagellar basal apparatus. Using Basic Local Alignment Search Tool (BLAST) searches of recently established databases, SFA-like sequences were detected in the genomes not only of green algal species but also of a range of other protists. These included species in two alveolate subgroups, the ciliates (Tetrahymena thermophila, Paramecium tetraurelia) and the dinoflagellates (Perkinsus marinus), and two stramenopile subgroups, the oomycetes (Phytophthora sojae, Phytophthora ramorum, Phytophthora infestans) and the diatoms (Thalassiosira pseudonana, Phaeodactylum tricornutum). Together with earlier identification of SFA-like sequences in the apicomplexans, these results indicate that homologs of SFA are present across the alveolates and stramenopiles. Antibodies raised against SFA from the green alga, Spermatozopsis similis, react in immunofluorescence assays with the two basal bodies and an anteriorly directed striated fiber in the flagellar apparatus of biflagellate Phytophthora zoospores.     

Cthulhu Macrofasciculumque n. g., n. sp. and Cthylla Microfasciculumque n. g., n. sp., a Newly Identified Lineage of Parabasalian Termite Symbionts

The parabasalian symbionts of lower termite hindgut communities are well-known for their large size and structural complexity. The most complex forms evolved multiple times independently from smaller and simpler flagellates, but we know little of the diversity of these small flagellates or their phylogenetic relationships to more complex lineages. To understand the true diversity of Parabasalia and how their unique cellular complexity arose, more data from smaller and simpler flagellates are needed. Here, we describe two new genera of small-to-intermediate size and complexity, represented by the type species Cthulhu macrofasciculumque and Cthylla microfasciculumque from Prorhinotermes simplex and Reticulitermes virginicus, respectively (both hosts confirmed by DNA barcoding). Both genera have a single anterior nucleus embeded in a robust protruding axostyle, and an anterior bundle flagella (and likely a single posterior flagellum) that emerge slightly subanteriorly and have a distinctive beat pattern. Cthulhu is relatively large and has a distinctive bundle of over 20 flagella whereas Cthylla is smaller, has only 5 anterior flagella and closely resembles several other parababsalian genera. Molecular phylogenies based on small subunit ribosomal RNA (SSU rRNA) show both genera are related to previously unidentified environmental sequences from other termites (possibly from members of the Tricercomitidae), which all branch as sisters to the Hexamastigitae. Altogether, Cthulhu likely represents another independent origin of relatively high cellular complexity within parabasalia, and points to the need for molecular characterization of other key taxa, such as Tricercomitus.     

ULTRASTRUCTURE OF THE FLAGELLAR APPARATUS OF PYROBOTRYS (CHLOROPHYCEAE)1

The flagellar apparatus of Pyrobotrys has a number of features that are typical of the Chlorophyceae, but others that are unusual for this class. The two flagella are inserted at the apex, but they extend to the side of the cell toward the outside of the colony, here designated as the ventral side. Four basal bodies are present, two of which extend into flagella. Four microtubular rootlets alternate between the functional and accessory basal bodies. In each cell, the two ventral rootlets are nearly parallel, but the dorsal rootlets are more widely divergent. The rootlets alternate between two and four microtubules each. A striated distal fiber connects the two functional basal bodies in the plane of the flagella. Two additional, apparently nonstriated, fibers connect the basal bodies proximal to the distal fiber. Another striated fiber is associated with each four-membered rootlet near its insertion into the flagellar apparatus. A fine periodic component is associated with each two-membered rootlet. A rhizoplast-like structure extends into the cell from each of the functional basal bodies. The arrangement of these components does not reflect the 180° rotational symmetry that is usually present in the Chlorophyceae, but appears to be derived from a more symmetrical ancestor. It is suggested that the form of the flagellar apparatus is associated with the unusual colony structure of Pyrobotrys.     

Phylogenetic Position and In Situ Identification of Ectosymbiotic Spirochetes on Protists in the Termite Gut

Phylogenetic relationships, diversity, and in situ identification of spirochetes in the gut of the termite Neotermes koshunensis were examined without cultivation, with an emphasis on ectosymbionts attached to flagellated protists. Spirochetes in the gut microbial community investigated so far are related to the genus Treponema and divided into two phylogenetic clusters. In situ hybridizations with a 16S rRNA-targeting consensus oligonucleotide probe for one cluster (known as termite Treponema cluster I) detected both the ectosymbiotic spirochetes on gut protists and the free-swimming spirochetes in the gut fluid of N. koshunensis. The probe for the other cluster (cluster II), which has been identified as ectosymbionts on gut protists of two other termite species, Reticulitermes speratus and Hodotermopsis sjoestedti, failed to detect any spirochete population. The absence of cluster II spirochetes in N. koshunensis was confirmed by intensive 16S ribosomal DNA (rDNA) clone analysis, in which remarkably diverse spirochetes of 45 phylotypes were identified, almost all belonging to cluster I. Ectosymbiotic spirochetes of the three gut protist species Devescovina sp., Stephanonympha sp., and Oxymonas sp. in N. koshunensis were identified by their 16S rDNA and by in situ hybridizations using specific probes. The probes specific for these ectosymbionts did not receive a signal from the free-swimming spirochetes. The ectosymbionts were dispersed in cluster I of the phylogeny, and they formed distinct phylogenetic lineages, suggesting multiple origins of the spirochete attachment. Each single protist cell harbored multiple spirochete species, and some of the spirochetes were common among protist species. The results indicate complex relationships of the ectosymbiotic spirochetes with the gut protists.     

SOME PRYMNESIACEAE (HAPTOPHYTA,PRYMNESIOPHYCEAE) FROM THE MEDITERRANEAN SEA,WITH THE DESCRIPTION OF TWO NEW SPECIES: CHRYSOCHROMULINA LANCEOLATA SP. NOV. AND C. PSEUDOLANCEOLATA SP. NOV.1

Five species belonging to the family Prymnesiaceae (one Prymnesium and four Chrysochromulina) have been identified in cultures obtained from water collected in the Bay of Banyuls‐sur‐Mer (Mediterranean Sea, France) using LM, SEM, and TEM. Two are described as new species, Chrysochromulina lanceolata sp. nov. and C. pseudolanceolata sp. nov. Both species are large and lanceolate with an acute posterior and two anterior arms. They are easily detectable with LM but difficult to distinguish to species level with live cells, without experience. EM reveals two completely different scale patterns in the two species. Cells of C. lanceolata are 21–38 μm long, 7–12 μm wide, and 3–7 μm thick. They possess two subequal flagella (30–51 and 29–44 μm), and the haptonema is shorter than the flagella (23–37 μm). The cell body is covered by plate and spine scales. Cells of C. pseudolanceolata sp. nov. are slightly smaller (15–18 × 6–8 μm) with more rounded extremities, two subequal flagella (19–26 and 17–24 μm), and the haptonema is longer than the flagella (about 35 μm). Three types of plate scales are observed in this species. Other findings are C. alifera Parke et Manton and C. throndsenii Eikrem (a new record for the Mediterranean Sea). Prymnesium faveolatum Fresnel, a new toxic species recently described, is illustrated with both LM and SEM.     

The flagellar apparatus of the golden algaSynura uvella: Four absolute orientations

Summary Flagellated vegetative cells of the colonial golden algaSynura uvella Ehr, were examined using serial sections. The two flagella are nearly parallel as they emerge from a flagellar pit near the apex of the cell. The photoreceptor is restricted to swellings on the flagella in the region where they pass through the apical pore in the scale case and the swellings are not associated with the cell membrane or an eyespot. A unique ring-like structure surrounds the axonemes of both flagella at a level just above the transitional helix. The basal bodies are interconnected by three striated, fibrous bands. Four short (<100 nm) microtubules lie between the basal bodies at their proximal ends. Two rhizoplasts extend down from the basal bodies and separate into numerous fine striated bands which lie over the nucleus. Three- and four-membered microtubular roots arise from the rhizoplasts and extend apically together. As the roots reach the cell anterior, the three-membered root bends and curves clockwise to form a large loop around the flagella; the four-membered root bends anticlockwise and terminates under the distal end of the three-membered root as it completes the loop. There are four absolute orientations, termed Types 1–4, in which the flagellar apparatus can occur. With each orientation type the positions of the Golgi body, nucleus, rhizoplasts, chloroplasts and microtubular roots change with respect to the flagella, basal bodies and photoreceptor. Two new basal bodies appear in pre-division cells, and three short microtubules appear in a dense substance adjacent to each new basal body. Based upon the positions of new pre-division basal bodies, a hypothesis is proposed to explain why there are four orientations and how they are maintained through successive cell divisions.     

COMPARATIVE ANALYSES OF THE DINOFLAGELLATE FLAGELLAR APPARATUS. I. WOLOSZYNSKIA SP.1

The three-dimensional structure of the flagellar apparatus in Woloszynskia sp. was determined. This recently discovered dinoflagellate possesses two basal bodies that are offset from one another and lie at an angle of approximately 110°. The transverse basal body is associated with a striated fibrous root assemblage that consists of two differently staining fibrous portions with identical striation periodicity. Unlike the transverse striated fibrous roots reported in other dinoflagellates, this assemblage extends to the cell's right beyond the proximal end of the transverse basal body. The striated fibrous root complex is attached to the anterior end of the longitudinal microtubular root by a broad striated fibrous connective. The longitudinal basal body is also associated with the longitudinal microtubular root. The flagellar opening of each emerging axoneme is surrounded by a striated collar. The striated collars are linked to one another by a striated fibrous, striated collar connective. The variations and similarities of the flagellar apparatus and the ventral ridge/striated collar connective in Woloszynskia sp. are compared to similar components in other dinoflagellates.     

Organization of the flagellar apparatus and associate cytoplasmic microtubules in the quadriflagellate alga Polytomella agilis

The organization of microtubular systems in the quadriflagellate unicell Polytomella agilis has been reconstructed by electron microscopy of serial sections, and the overall arrangement confirmed by immunofluorescent staining using antiserum directed against chick brain tubulin. The basal bodies of the four flagella are shown to be linked in two pairs of short fibers. Light microscopy of swimming cells indicates that the flagella beat in two synchronous pairs, with each pair exhibiting a breast-stroke-like motion. Two structurally distinct flagellar rootlets, one consisting of four microtubules in a 3 over 1 pattern and the other of a striated fiber over two microtubules, terminate between adjacent basal bodies. These rootlets diverge from the basal body region and extend toward the cell posterior, passing just beneath the plasma membrane. Near the anterior part of the cell, all eight rootlets serve as attachment sites for large numbers of cytoplasmic microtubules which occur in a single row around the circumference of the cell and closely parallel the cell shape. It is suggested that the flagellar rootless may function in controlling the patterning and the direction of cytoplasmic microtubule assembly. The occurrence of similar rootlet structures in other flagellates is briefly reviewed.     

FINE STRUCTURE OF THE ZOOSPORE OF OEDOCLADIUM CAROLINIANUM (CHLOROPHYTA) WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO THE FLAGELLAR APPARATUS1, 2

Ultrastructure of the motile zoospore has been investigated in Oedocladium catolinianum & Hoffman. An unwalled zoospore is usually produced from the contents of a terminal vegetative cell and consists of two principal regions: a small anterior dome and a larger body region; a ring of flagella marks the juncture of these two areas. Chloroplast inclusions consist of thylakoids, mature and incipient pyrenoids, starch and striated microtubules; no eyespot has been observed. Zoospores appear to possess permanent contractile vacuoles with numerous accessory vacuoles, coated vesicles and occasionally coated tubules. The cytoplasm of the dome contains numerous mitochondria ER and golgi bodies, as well as two distinct types of vesicles. The first contains an electron-dense; granular core and is surrounded by a loose, sinuate membrane. The second vesicle is electron-opaque and is found at the apex of the dome: it contains mucopolysaccharides employed during zoospore adhesion. A complex flagellar apparatus encircles the lower region of the dome. It consists of ca. 30–65 flagella, a ring-shaped fibrous band, flagella roots and additional supporting material. The flagella and roots alternate with one another beneath the fibrous band. The compound flagellar roots consist of two superimposed components: an outer ribbon-like unit composed of three microtubular elements and a single striated inner component. A band of support material lies beneath the proximal end of the basal bodies. It is a continuous fibrous band, although it often appears as three distinct, repetitive units.     

New evolutionary lineages, unexpected diversity, and host specificity in the parabasalid genus Tetratrichomonas

We studied morphological and molecular polymorphism of 53 Tetratrichomonas isolates obtained from amphibian, reptilian, mammalian hosts, and from a slug with the aid of protargol staining and analyses of ITS1-5.8S rRNA-ITS2, SSU rRNA, and alpha-tubulin gene sequences. The phylogenetic tree based on the concatenate of all sequences showed the monophyly of the genus Tetratrichomonas with respect to the genus Trichomonas. Our data suggest that two parabasalid genera, Pentatrichomonoides and Trichomonoides, may belong to the genus Tetratrichomonas. Tetratrichomonas isolates were divided into 16 robust host-specific and monophyletic groups that probably represent separate, mostly new, species. As only five Tetratrichomonas species were described from the examined host taxa so far, our study uncovered considerable species diversity within the genus. The wide host range, high level of species-specific host specificity, and newly revealed biodiversity make the genus Tetratrichomonas a valuable model for studying evolution of parasites.     

THE FINE STRUCTURE OF GIARDIA MURIS

Giardia is a noninvasive intestinal zooflagellate. This electron microscope study demonstrates the fine structure of the trophozoite of Giardia muris in the lumen of the duodenum of the mouse as it appears after combined glutaraldehyde and acrolein fixation and osmium tetroxide postfixation. Giardia muris is of teardrop shape, rounded anteriorly, with a convex dorsal surface and a concave ventral one. The anterior two-thirds of the ventral surface is modified to form an adhesive disc. The adhesive disc is divided into 2 lobes whose medial surfaces form the median groove. The marginal grooves are the spaces between the lateral crests of the adhesive disc and a protruding portion of the peripheral cytoplasm. The organism has 2 nuclei, 1 dorsal to each lobe of the adhesive disc. Between the anterior poles of the nuclei, basal bodies give rise to 8 paired flagella. The median body, unique to Giardia, is situated between the posterior poles of the nuclei. The cytoplasm contains 300-A granules that resemble particulate glycogen, 150- to 200-A granules that resemble ribosomes, and fusiform clefts. The dorsal portion of the cell periphery is occupied by a linear array of flattened vacuoles, some of which contain clusters of dense particles. The ventrolateral cytoplasm is composed of regularly packed coarse and fine filaments which extend as a striated flange around the adhesive disc. The adhesive disc is composed of a layer of microtubules which are joined to the cytoplasm by regularly spaced fibrous ribbons. The plasma membrane covers the ventral and lateral surfaces of the disc. The median body consists of an oval aggregate of curved microtubules. Microtubules extend ventrally from the median body to lie alongside the caudal flagella. The intracytoplasmic portions of the caudal, lateral, and anterior flagella course considerable distances, accompanied by hollow filaments adjacent to their outer doublets. The intracytoplasmic portions of the anterior flagella are accompanied also by finely granular rodlike bodies. No structures identifiable as mitochondria, smooth endoplasmic reticulum, the Golgi complex, lysosomes, or axostyles are recognized.     

Transformation and development of the flagellar apparatus ofCryptomonas ovata (Cryptophyceae) during cell division

Summary InCryptomonas ovata, long, dorsal flagella are produced which transform during the following cell division into short, ventral flagella. At division there is a reorientation in cell polarity, and the parental basal apparatus, which comprises the basal bodies and associated roots, is distributed to the daughter cells via a complex sequence of events. Flagellar apparatus development includes the transformation of a four-stranded microtubular root into a mature root of different structure and function. Each newly formed basal body nucleates new microtubular roots, but receives a striated fibrous root from a parental basal body. The striated roots are originally produced on the transforming basal body and are transferred to the new basal bodies at each successive division. The development of the asymmetric flagellar apparatus throughout the cell cycle is described.     

Malawimonas jakobiformis n. gen., n. sp. (Malawimonadidae n. fam.): A Jakoba-like Heterotrophic Nanoflagellate with Discoidal Mitochondrial Cristae

Malawimonas jakobiformis n. gen., n. sp., is established for a bacterivorous heterotrophic nanoflagellate isolated from the Malawi shore of Lake Nyasa (eastern Africa). Trophic stages observed were anteriorly biflagellate and naked. The posterior flagellum of a trophic cell resided in a conspicuous groove on the ventral surface, and bore a prominent vane. A Golgi stack and a mitochondrion with discoidal cristae were present anterior to the nucleus. The kinetid consisted of two short, slightly separated basal bodies, four microtubular roots, and associated fibers and bands. The three microtubular roots associated with the posterior basal body were associated with the ventral groove, while the single root associated with the anterior basal body gave rise to secondary cytoskeletal microtubules. Dividing cells became rounded, with persistent flagella. Cysts were uninucleate, and had thin organic walls without clearly differentiated apertures or ornamentation but with conspicuous attachment pads. Kinetid elements were present within cysts. On the basis of microscopical features, especially those of the kinetid, the nearest relatives of M. jakobiformis are the mitochondriate “jakobid” protists (families Histionidae and Jakobidae) and the amitochondriate retortamonads. Malawimonadidae n. fam. is established to accommodate this species.     

杉木人工混交林对土壤铝毒害的缓解作用

以四川盆周山地现有杉木人工林为研究对象,在划分林分类型并采用因子分析建立地上部分树种指标系统的基础上,经主成分分析,建立铝毒害指标综合评价函数,应用典范相关分析探讨树种与土壤铝毒害两组变量的相关关系。结果表明:杉木人工林分成6种林分类型,其中杉木纯林、杉木+柳杉和杉木+茶树林仍遭受铝毒害,杉木长势差,而以杉木+木荷为主,混栽如栎(栗)类、毛泡桐、桤木、檫木等阔叶树种的林分类型,由于提高了土壤pH值、Ca含量,降低了土壤Al含量,因此未遭受铝毒害,或者铝毒害已得到不同程度的缓解,杉木长势相对较好;缓解铝毒效果明显的树种有木荷、毛竹、桤木、檫木、黄绒润楠、香樟、连香和青冈;从缓解铝毒害的角度,茶树和柳杉等不宜与杉木混交。