A new cryomacroscope device (Type III) for visualization of physical events in cryopreservation with applications to vitrification and synthetic ice modulators

The objective of the current study is to develop a new cryomacroscope prototype for the study of vitrification in large-size specimens. The unique contribution in the current study is in developing a cryomacroscope setup as an add-on device to a commercial controlled-rate cooler and in demonstration of physical events in cryoprotective cocktails containing synthetic ice modulators (SIM)—compounds which hinder ice crystal growth. Cryopreservation by vitrification is a highly complex application, where the likelihood of crystallization, fracture formation, degradation of the biomaterial quality, and other physical events are dependent not only upon the instantaneous cryogenic conditions, but more significantly upon the evolution of conditions along the cryogenic protocol. Nevertheless, cryopreservation success is most frequently assessed by evaluating the cryopreserved product at its end states—either at the cryogenic storage temperature or room temperature. The cryomacroscope is the only available device for visualization of large-size specimens along the thermal protocol, in an effort to correlate the quality of the cryopreserved product with physical events. Compared with earlier cryomacroscope prototypes, the new Cryomacroscope-III evaluated here benefits from a higher resolution color camera, improved illumination, digital recording capabilities, and high repeatability in tested thermal conditions via a commercial controlled-rate cooler. A specialized software package was developed in the current study, having two modes of operation: (a) experimentation mode to control the operation of the camera, record camera frames sequentially, log thermal data from sensors, and save case-specific information; and (b) post-processing mode to generate a compact file integrating images, elapsed time, and thermal data for each experiment. The benefits of the Cryomacroscope-III are demonstrated using various tested mixtures of SIMs with the cryoprotective cocktail DP6, which were found effective in preventing ice growth, even at significantly subcritical cooling rates with reference to the pure DP6.     

Thermal expansion of vitrified blood vessels permeated with DP6 and synthetic ice modulators

This study provides thermal expansion data for blood vessels permeated with the cryoprotective cocktail DP6, when combined with selected synthetic ice modulators (SIMs): 12% polyethylene glycol 400, 6% 1,3-cyclohexanediol, and 6% 2,3-butanediol. The general classification of SIMs includes molecules that modulate ice nucleation and growth, or possess properties of stabilizing the amorphous state, by virtue of their chemical structure and at concentrations that are not explained on a purely colligative basis. The current study is part of an ongoing effort to characterize thermo-mechanical effects on structural integrity of cryopreserved materials, where thermal expansion is the driving mechanism to thermo-mechanical stress. This study focuses on the lower part of the cryogenic temperature range, where the cryoprotective agent (CPA) behaves as a solid for all practical applications. By combining results obtained in the current study with literature data on the thermal expansion in the upper part of the cryogenic temperature range, unified thermal expansion curves are presented.     

Thermal expansion of the cryoprotectant cocktail DP6 combined with synthetic ice modulators in presence and absence of biological tissues

This study explores physical effects associated with the application of cryopreservation via vitrification using a class of compounds which are defined here as synthetic ice modulators (SIMs). The general classification of SIMs includes molecules that modulate ice nucleation and growth, or possess properties of stabilizing the amorphous state, by virtue of their chemical structure and at concentrations that are not explained on a purely colligative basis. A sub-category of SIMs, referred to in the literature as synthetic ice blockers (SIBs), are compounds that interact directly with ice nuclei or crystals to modify their structure and/or rate of growth. The current study is part of an ongoing effort to characterize thermo-mechanical effects during vitrification, with emphasis on measuring the physical property of thermal expansion-the driving mechanism to thermo-mechanical stress. Materials under investigation are the cryoprotective agent (CPA) cocktail DP6 in combination with one of the following SIMs: 12% polyethylene glycol 400, 6% 1,3 cyclohexanediol, and 6% 2,3 butanediol. Results are presented for the CPA-SIM cocktail in the absence and presence of bovine muscle and goat artery specimens. This study focuses on the upper part of the cryogenic temperature range, where the CPA behaves as a fluid for all practical applications. Results of this study indicate that the addition of SIMs to DP6 allows lower cooling rates to ensure vitrification and extends the range of measurements. It is demonstrated that the combination of SIM with DP6 increases the thermal expansion of the cocktail, with implications for the likelihood of fracture formation-the most dramatic outcome of thermo-mechanical stress.     

Cryomacroscopy of vitrification, Part II: Experimental observations and analysis of fracture formation in vitrified VS55 and DP6

A new imaging device, termed a "cryomacroscope", was used to observe macrofractures in the cryoprotectant cocktails DP6 and VS55. Details of the design and construction of the cryomacroscope were presented in Part I of this report, which focused on describing the apparatus and observations of crystallization. Part I and the current paper (Part II) describe events that occur as 1 m? of cryoprotectant contained in a glass vial is cooled from room temperature down to cryogenic temperatures (～ -135°C). The presence of cracking, as well as patterns in their position and orientation, are found to be dependent on the cooling rate and on the specific cryoprotectant cocktail. Cracks, if present, disappear upon rewarming, although they appear to be sites for later preferential crystallization. Computations which predict temperatures and mechanical stresses are used to explain observations of cracking. In conjunction with these reports, additional photos of cryomacroscopy of vitrification, crystallization, and fracture formation are available at http://www.me.cmu.edu/faculty1/rabin/CryomacroscopyImages01.htm.     

Large Thermal Conductivity Differences between the Crystalline and Vitrified States of DMSO with Applications to Cryopreservation

Thermal conductivity of dimethyl-sulfoxide (DMSO) solution is measured in this study using a transient hot wire technique, where DMSO is a key ingredient in many cryoprotective agent (CPA) cocktails. Characterization of thermal properties of cryoprotective agents is essential to the analysis of cryopreservation processes, either when evaluating experimental data or for the design of new protocols. Also presented are reference measurements of thermal conductivity for pure water ice and glycerol. The thermal conductivity measurement setup is integrated into the experimentation stage of a scanning cryomacroscope apparatus, which facilitates the correlation of measured data with visualization of physical events. Thermal conductivity measurements were conducted for a DMSO concentration range of 2M and 10M, in a temperature range of -180°C and 25°C. Vitrified samples showed decreased thermal conductivity with decreasing temperature, while crystalline samples showed increased thermal conductivity with decreasing temperature. These different behaviors result in up to a tenfold difference in thermal conductivity at -180°C. Such dramatic differences can drastically impact heat transfer during cryopreservation and their quantification is therefore critical to cryobiology.     

Thermal analysis of marginal conditions to facilitate cryopreservation by vitrification using a semi-empirical approach

This study aims at the thermal analysis of marginal conditions leading to cryopreservation by vitrification, which appears to be the only alternative for indefinite preservation of large-size tissues and organs. The term “marginal conditions” here refers to cooling rates in close range with the so-called critical cooling rate, above which crystallization is avoided. The analysis of thermal effects associated with partial crystallization during vitrification is associated with the coupled phenomena of heat transfer and kinetics of crystallization. This study takes a practical, semi-empirical approach, where heat transfer is analyzed based on its underlying theoretical principles, while the thermal effects associated with partial crystallization are taken into account by means of empirical correlations. This study presents a computation framework to solve the coupled problem, while presenting a proof-of-concept for DP6 as a representative cryoprotective agent. The thermal effects associated with crystallization at various relevant cooling rates are measured in this study by means of differential scanning calorimetry. Results of this study demonstrate that, due to the thermal effects associated with partial crystallization, the cooling rate at the center of a large organ may lag behind the cooling rate in its surroundings under some scenarios, but may also exceed the surroundings cooling rate in other scenarios, leading to counter-intuitive effects associated with partial crystallization.     

Peculiarities of state diagrams of aqueous solutions of cryoprotective agents

The phase transitions in aqueous solutions of glycerol and PEO-1500 within the temperature range of +30 to −150 °C have been studied using the methods of thermoplastic analysis and volumetric scanning tensodilatometry. We present the revealed phenomenon of cluster cyrystallization of these solutions as well as principles of describing this phenomenon using state diagrams, containing the intervals of concentration corresponding to the existence of amorphous and cryocolloid fractions. We note that for the cryocolloid fraction, a low temperature association of molecules of cryoprotective agents leads the formation of ice nanocrystals either close to or directly inside the aggregations. These fractions exist in cooled cryoprotective solutions near the vitrification temperatures of the liquid phase and may contribute to the initiation of damaging events in cryopreserved biological systems. Our data may be helpful in explaining the peculiarities observed during crystallization of cryoprotective solutions and may further contribute to a broader understanding of the principles of protection and protocol optimization of biological materials at temperatures approaching vitrification.     

Thermal expansion of blood vessels in low cryogenic temperatures Part I: A new experimental device

As part of the ongoing effort to study the mechanical behavior of biological material during cryopreservation processes, the current study focuses on thermal expansion of blood vessels at low cryogenic temperatures. The current paper (Part I) describes a new experimental device for thermal expansion measurements of blood vessels in typical conditions of vitrification, which are associated with rapid cooling rates. For validation purposes, the thermal strain of frozen arteries in the absence of cryoprotectants was measured, and found to be about 10% larger than that of polycrystalline water; this observation agrees with literature data. The companion paper (Part II) reports on experimental results of cryoprotectants permeated with VS55, DP6, and 7.05 M DMSO at high cooling rates applicable to vitrification.     

Comparison of cryosurvival and spermatogenesis efficiency of cryopreserved neonatal mouse testicular tissue between three vitrification protocols and controlled-rate freezing

Grafting of cryopreserved testicular tissue is a promising tool for fertility and testicular function preservation in endangered species, mutant animals, or cancer patients for future use. In this study, we aimed to improve the whole neonatal mouse testicular tissue cryopreservation protocols by comparing cryosurvival, spermatogenesis, and androgen production of grafted testicular tissue after cryopreservation with three different vitrification protocols and an automated computed controlled-rate freezing. Whole neonatal mouse testes were vitrified with various vitrification solutions (V1) 40% EG + 18% Ficoll + 0.35 M Sucrose, (V2) DAP 213 (2 M DMSO + 1 M Acetamid + 3 M PG), or (V3) 15% EG + 15% PG + 0.5 M Sucrose (total solute concentration V1:74.34%, V2:44.0%, and V3:49.22% wt/vol). Alternatively, neonatal testicular tissue was also frozen in 0.7 M DMSO +5% fetal bovine serum using controlled-rate freezing and compared to fresh grafted testicular tissue, sham grafted controls, and the vitrification protocol groups. Fresh (n = 4) and frozen-thawed (n = 4) testes tissues were grafted onto the flank of castrated male NCr Nude recipient mouse. The grafts were harvested after three months. Fresh or frozen-thawed grafts with controlled-rate freezing had the highest rate of tissue survival compared to other vitrified protocols after harvesting (p < 0.05). Both controlled-rate freezing and V1 protocol groups displayed the most advanced stages of spermatogenesis with elongated spermatids and spermatozoa in 17.6 ± 1.3% and 16.3 ± 1.9% of seminiferous tubules based on histopathological evaluation, respectively. Hosts of the testicular graft from controlled-rate freezing had higher levels of serum testosterone compared to all other vitrified-thawed graft groups (p < 0.05). This study shows that completed spermatogenesis from whole neonatal mouse testes were obtained when frozen with controlled-rate freezing and V1 vitrification solution and that testicular cryopreservation efficacy vary with the protocol and vitrification technique.     

Cryomacroscopy of vitrification, Part I: A prototype and experimental observations on the cocktails VS55 and DP6

A new imaging device, termed a "cryomacroscope", is presented in this report. This device is designed to assist in exploring thermal and mechanical effects associated with large-scale vitrification and crystallization, with the current setup aimed at the range of 50 μm to 2 cm. The cryomacroscope is not intended as a substitute for the cryomicroscope, but as a complementary tool for the cryobiologist. A combination of cryomacroscopy and cryomicroscopy is suggested as a basis for multi-scale cryobiology studies. This report presents initial results on vitrification, crystallization, and fracture formation in the cryoprotectant cocktails DP6 and VS55. These results show some inconsistency in the tendency to form crystals, based on critical cooling and rewarming rates measured by means of a differential scanning calorimetric device (DSC) in parallel studies. This research is in its early stages, and comparative studies on biological materials are currently underway. Part II of this report (the companion paper) presents results for fracture formation in the cryoprotectant and discusses the mechanical stresses which promote these fractures. In conjunction with these reports, additional photos of cryomacroscopy of vitrification, crystallization, and fracture formation are available at http://www.me.cmu.edu/faculty1/rabin/CryomacroscopyImages01.htm.     

Thermal expansion of blood vessels in low cryogenic temperatures, Part II: Vitrification with VS55, DP6, and 7.05 M DMSO

As part of the ongoing effort to study the mechanical behavior of biological materials in cryopreservation processes, the current study focuses on thermal expansion during vitrification (vitreous in Latin means glassy). A new device is utilized in this study, which has been described in detail in the companion paper (Part I). The current study (Part II) focuses on measurements of vitrified blood vessels permeated with the cryoprotectants VS55, DP6, and DMSO. Data analysis in this study includes polynomial approximation of experimental results in the lower part of the cryogenic temperature range, where the material behaves as solid over a practical time scale. The study further includes a unified thermal expansion analysis throughout the entire cryogenic temperature range by compiling the current results with previously reported data. Finally, analysis of the glass transition temperature, based on thermal strain data is presented.     

Thermal expansion measurements of cryoprotective agents. Part II: measurements of DP6 and VS55, and comparison with DMSO

As part of an ongoing effort to characterize the mechanical behavior of biological tissues in the cryogenic temperature range, the current study focuses on thermal expansion measurements of cryoprotective agents. Utilizing the experimental apparatus described in the previous report (Part I), the current report (Part II) includes thermal expansion measurements of the cryoprotectant mixtures DP6 and VS55, and comparison with available data from the literature on DMSO. In the temperature range in which the cryoprotectant mixture behaves like low viscosity liquid, results of this study show that the thermal expansion coefficient of VS55 and DP6 is 22% and 40% lower than that of 3M DMSO, respectively, where 3M DMSO is only one component of each cryoprotectant mixture. This significant difference is attributed to the presence of 3M formamide in VS55.     

Continuum mechanics analysis of fracture progression in the vitrified cryoprotective agent DP6

As part of an ongoing effort to study the continuum mechanics effects associated with cryopreservation, the current report focuses on the prediction of fracture formation in cryoprotective agents. Fractures had been previously observed in 1 ml samples of the cryoprotective agent cocktail DP6, contained in a standard 15 ml glass vial, and subjected to various cooling rates. These experimental observations were obtained by means of a cryomacroscope, which has been recently presented by the current research team. High and low cooling rates were found to produce very distinct patterns of cracking. The current study seeks to explain the observed patterns on the basis of stresses predicted from finite element analysis, which relies on a simple viscoelastic constitutive model and on estimates of the critical stress for cracking. The current study demonstrates that the stress, which results in instantaneous fracture at low cooling rates, is consistent with the stress to initiate fracture at high cooling rate. This consistency supports the credibility of the proposed constitutive model and analysis, and the unified criterion for fracturing, that is, a critical stress threshold.     

Fracture formation in vitrified thin films of cryoprotectants

As a part of an ongoing effort to study the continuum mechanics effects associated with cryopreservation, the current report focuses on fracture formation in vitrified thin films of cryoprotective agents. The current study combines experimental observations with continuum mechanics analysis. Experimental results have been developed using a new imaging device, termed a "cryomacroscope", which has been recently presented by the current research team. A newly developed liquid nitrogen-based cooling stage is presented in this paper. The samples under investigation are 0.5 ml droplets of cryoprotective agents, having a characteristic diameter of 20 mm and a characteristic thickness of 1.5 mm. Tested samples included dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) in a concentration range from 6 to 8.4M, and the cryoprotectant cocktails VS55 and DP6. Some samples contained small bovine muscle segments, having a characteristic dimension of 1mm, in order to study stress concentration effects. Experimental results show that the onset of fracturing in vitrified films of cryoprotectants is very consistent, occurring over a small temperature range. Fracture pattern, however, was affected by the cooling rate. The presence of tissue segments did not affect the onset temperature of fracture, but affected the fracture pattern. The continuum mechanics analysis solidified the hypothesis that fracture is driven by thermal stress, not by temperature per se, and allowed fracture strain to be inferred from observed fracture temperature. In conjunction with the current report, additional photos of fracture formation in thin films are available at .     

Isochoric vitrification: An experimental study to establish proof of concept

Ice-free vitreous cryopreservation (vitrification) is regarded as the principal method for avoiding ice crystallization damage in cryopreserved tissues and organs. We previously established the fundamental thermodynamics of isochoric (constant volume) systems for cryopreservation, and now extend this novel approach to vitrification in an isochoric system. This was achieved by measuring pressure changes in a 2 ml isochoric chamber containing a variety of aqueous solutions of the ubiquitous cryoprotective additives (CPA), dimethyl sulfoxide (Me₂SO) and Propane-diol. The CPAs, ranging in concentrations from 0 to 49%(w/v), were prepared in a proprietary preservation solution (Unisol^®) in anticipation of future applications to tissue and organ banking. Pressures developed in the system were monitored as a function of CPA concentration and cooling rate when the isochoric chamber was cooled to cryogenic temperature (−160 °C). This study corroborated our previous findings that pressure increases in accordance with the thermodynamics of partially frozen systems of low concentrations of CPAs. A key finding of this study was that in an isochoric system of higher concentrations of CPA, which vitrifies, there is no increase in pressure. In fact, an increase in pressure is a measure of failure to vitrify and a measure of devitrification. Comparison with results from the literature show that the concentration of CPAs needed for vitrification in an isochoric chamber is substantially lower than that needed for vitrification in isobaric systems at 1 atm and hyperbaric systems at 1000 atm. In addition, isochoric chambers are much more effective in promoting vitrification than hyperbaric pressure chambers, and are less expensive, easier to design, and implement.     

Strong Isotope Effects on Melting Dynamics and Ice Crystallisation Processes in Cryo Vitrification Solutions

The nucleation and growth of crystalline ice during cooling, and further crystallization processes during re-warming are considered to be key processes determining the success of low temperature storage of biological objects, as used in medical, agricultural and nature conservation applications. To avoid these problems a method, termed vitrification, is being developed to inhibit ice formation by use of high concentration of cryoprotectants and ultra-rapid cooling, but this is only successful across a limited number of biological objects and in small volume applications. This study explores physical processes of ice crystal formation in a model cryoprotective solution used previously in trials on vitrification of complex biological systems, to improve our understanding of the process and identify limiting biophysical factors. Here we present results of neutron scattering experiments which show that even if ice crystal formation has been suppressed during quench cooling, the water molecules, mobilised during warming, can crystallise as detectable ice. The crystallisation happens right after melting of the glass phase formed during quench cooling, whilst the sample is still transiting deep cryogenic temperatures. We also observe strong water isotope effects on ice crystallisation processes in the cryoprotectant mixture. In the neutron scattering experiment with a fully protiated water component, we observe ready crystallisation occurring just after the glass melting transition. On the contrary with a fully deuteriated water component, the process of crystallisation is either completely or substantially supressed. This behaviour might be explained by nuclear quantum effects in water. The strong isotope effect, observed here, may play an important role in development of new cryopreservation strategies.     

An experimental research on cryopreserving rabbit trachea by vitrification

Vitrification is a promising alternative to tissue preservation, in which the tissue is permeated with cryoprotective agents (CPAs) in order to circumvent the hazardous effects associated with ice formation. In this study, we evaluate the effect of vitreous cryopreservation of rabbit trachea, by comparing vitrification procedure with conventional computer-programmed slow freezing approaches. Harvested rabbit trachea were tailored and divided into groups and cryopreserved by vitrification and programmed freezing, respectively. The morphology and ultrastructure of the thawed tracheal fragments including HE dyes, terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated dUTP-digoxigenin nick end-labeling (TUNEL) staining, transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) were studied to assess the integrity of the tracheal fragments. Morphological studies demonstrated that both cryopreservation procedure retained the integrity of trachea, both epithelial cells, cilia and cartilage cells were in good shape. Compared with slow freezing methods, vitrification was less detrimental to cartilage cells and had a higher survival rate of chondrocytes and coverage of epithelium and cilia. Therefore, vitrification procedure can be a more satisfactory method to preserve trachea and the survival of chondrocytes in situ in cartilage tissue is adequate and respiratory epithelium is soundly present.     

Cryopreservation of cartilage cell and tissue for biobanking

Preservation of cell and tissue samples from endangered species is a part of biodiversity conservation strategy. Therefore, setting up proper cell and tissue cryopreservation methods is very important as these tissue samples and cells could be used to reintroduce the lost genes into the breeding pool by nuclear transfer. In this study, we investigated the effect of vitrification and slow freezing on cartilage cell and tissue viability for biobanking. Firstly, primary adult cartilage cells (ACCs) and fetal cartilage cells (FCC) were cryopreserved by vitrification and slow freezing. Cells were vitrified after a two-step equilibration in a solution composed of ethylene glycol (EG), Ficoll and sucrose. For slow freezing three different cooling rates (0.5, 1 and 2 °C/min) were tested in straws. Secondly, the tissues taken from articular cartilage were cryopreserved by vitrification and slow freezing (1 °C/min). The results revealed no significant difference between the viability ratios, proliferative activity and GAG synthesis of cartilage cells which were cryopreserved by using vitrification or slow freezing methods. Despite the significant decrease in the viability ratio of freeze–thawed cartilage tissues, cryopreservation did not prevent the establishment of primary cell cultures from cartilage tissues. The results revealed that the vitrification method could be recommended to cryopreserve cartilage tissue and cells from bovine to be used as alternative cell donor sources in nuclear transfer studies for biobanking as a part of biodiversity conservation strategy. Moreover, cartilage cell suspensions were successfully cryopreserved in straws by using a controlled-rate freezing machine in the present study.     

Vitrification tendency and stability of DP6-based vitrification solutions for complex tissue cryopreservation

Vitrification tendency and stability of the amorphous state were analyzed by means of differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) for the vitrification solution DP6, with and without additional solutes to enhance ice suppression. This study is a part of an ongoing research effort to characterize the thermophysical and mechanical properties of DP6 and its derivatives, and their qualities as cryoprotective solutions. DP6 was determined to have a critical cooling rate necessary to ensure vitrification of 2.7 °C/min. The following additional solutions were tested: DP6 + 6% (2R, 3R) 2,3-butanediol, DP6 + 6% 1,3-cyclohexanediol, DP6 + 6% (0.175M) sucrose, DP6 + 12% PEG 400, and DP6 + 17.1% (0.5 M) sucrose. The additives decreased the critical cooling rate of the DP6 solution to rates below 1 °C/min that were not quantifiable by the DSC techniques used. The following critical warming rates necessary to avoid devitrification were identified for DP6 and the modified solutions, respectively: 189 °C/min, 5 °C/min, ≈ 1 °C/min, 15 °C/min, <1 °C/min, and <1 °C/min. Glass transition temperatures and melting temperatures were also measured. Sucrose was the least effective additive on a per mass basis, with 1,3-cyclohexanediol appearing to be the most effective additive for suppressing ice formation in DP6.