Low diversity and biased substitution patterns in the mitochondrial DNA control region of sperm whales: implications for estimates of time since common ancestry

The mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) control region was sequenced in 37 sperm whales from a large part of the global range of the species. Nucleotide diversity was several-fold lower than that reported for control regions of abundant and outbred mammals, but similar to that for populations known to have experienced bottlenecks. Relative neck tests did not suggest that the low diversity is due to a lower substitution rate in sperm whale mtDNA. Rather, it is more likely that demographic factors have reduced diversity. The pattern of nucleotide substitutions was examined by cladistic methods, facilitated by the apparent monophyly of lineages from the Southern Hemisphere, as defined by a single base pair deletion. Substitutions were nonrandom in nature, confined to a few "hot spots," and parallel substitutions constituted a majority of the inferred changes. The substitution pattern fitted a negative binomial distribution better than a Poisson distribution, and the bias in number of substitutions among sites was considerably higher than previously reported for the mtDNA control region of any species. A novel method of estimating time since common ancestry was developed, which utilizes the transition/transversion ratio R and the number of substitutions inferred from a parsimony analysis. Using this method, we estimated the age of sperm whale mtDNA diversity to be about 6,000-25,000 years, and when the uncertainty of R was accounted for, a range of about 1,000- 100,000 years was obtained.      

Nonneutral Mitochondrial DNA Variation in Humans and Chimpanzees

We sequenced the NADH dehydrogenase subunit 3 (ND3) gene from a sample of 61 humans, five common chimpanzees, and one gorilla to test whether patterns of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) variation are consistent with a neutral model of molecular evolution. Within humans and within chimpanzees, the ratio of replacement to silent nucleotide substitutions was higher than observed in comparisons between species, contrary to neutral expectations. To test the generality of this result, we reanalyzed published human RFLP data from the entire mitochondrial genome. Gains of restriction sites relative to a known human mtDNA sequence were used to infer unambiguous nucleotide substitutions. We also compared the complete mtDNA sequences of three humans. Both the RFLP data and the sequence data reveal a higher ratio of replacement to silent nucleotide substitutions within humans than is seen between species. This pattern is observed at most or all human mitochondrial genes and is inconsistent with a strictly neutral model. These data suggest that many mitochondrial protein polymorphisms are slightly deleterious, consistent with studies of human mitochondrial diseases.     

Human Mitochondrial DNA Variation and Evolution: Analysis of Nucleotide Sequences from Seven Individuals

We have analyzed nucleotide sequence variation in an approximately 900-base pair region of the human mitochondrial DNA molecule encompassing the heavy strand origin of replication and the D-loop. Our analysis has focused on nucleotide sequences available from seven humans. Average nucleotide diversity among the sequences is 1.7%, several-fold higher than estimates from restriction endonuclease site variation in mtDNA from these individuals and previously reported for other humans. This disparity is consistent with the rapidly evolving nature of this noncoding region. However, several instances of convergent or parallel gain and loss of restriction sites due to multiple substitutions were observed. In addition, other results suggest that restriction site (as well as pairwise sequence) comparisons may underestimate the total number of substitutions that have occurred since the divergence of two mtDNA sequences from a common ancestral sequence, even at low levels of divergence. This emphasizes the importance of recognizing the large standard errors associated with estimates of sequence variability, particularly when constructing phylogenies among closely related sequences. Analysis of the observed number and direction of substitutions revealed several significant biases, most notably a strand dependence of substitution type and a 32-fold bias favoring transitions over transversions. The results also revealed a significantly nonrandom distribution of nucleotide substitutions and sequence length variation. Significantly more multiple substitutions were observed than expected for these closely related sequences under the assumption of uniform rates of substitution. The bias for transitions has resulted in predominantly convergent or parallel changes among the observed multiple substitutions. There is no convincing evidence that recombination has contributed to the mtDNA sequence diversity we have observed.     

On the estimation of the rate of nucleotide substitution for the control region of human mitochondrial DNA

To apply molecular clock for studying human evolution, the pattern of nucleotide substitution for the control region of human mtDNA was analyzed in detail. It is well known that the rate of nucleotide substitution for the control region is much higher than that for any other part of mtDNA. In this study, the higher substitution rate was attributed to the higher rate of transition-type substitution between pyrimidines within the D-loop part, whereas the rates of other types of substitution were essentially the same over the entire mtDNA molecule. Even within the control region, the rate and pattern of nucleotide substitution were different between the D-loop part and the rest. The rate and pattern for the non-D-loop part were very similar to those for fourfold-degenerate sites in the protein-coding region. In contrast, the D-loop and non-D-loop parts showed similarities in the base composition, whereas the base composition of fourfold-degenerate sites slightly different from that of the both parts of the control region. It is concluded, therefore, that the nucleotide frequencies of the control region should be used to estimate the number of substitutions (d) between the control region sequences. However, a method to verify the accuracy of the estimation of d by means of the transition/transversion (s/v) ratio was theoretically studied. It was suggested that the s/v ratio becomes constant over a wide range of d values only when the estimation of d is unbiased. On the basis of this result, the estimates of d previously obtained between human sequences were evaluated.     

Man's place in hominoidea revealed by mitochondrial DNA genealogy

Summary Molecular biology has resurrected C. Darwin and T.H. Huxley's question about the origin of humans, but the precise branching pattern and dating remain controversial. To settle this issue, a large amount of sequence information is required. We determined mitochondrial (mt) DNA sequences for five hominoids; pygmy and common chimpanzees, gorilla, orangutan, and siamang. The common region compared with the known human sequence is 4759 by long, encompassing genes for 11 transfer RNAs and 6 proteins. Because of the high substitution rates in mammalian mtDNA and an unprecedentedly large region compared, the sequence differences clearly indicate that the closest relatives to human are chimpanzees rather than gorilla. For dating the divergences of human, chimpanzee, and gorilla, we used only unsaturated parts of sequence differences in which the mtDNA genealogy is not obscured by multiple substitutions. The result suggests that gorilla branched off 7.7 ± 0.7 million years (Myr) ago and human 4.7 ± 0.5 Myr ago; the time difference between these divergences being as long as 3 Myr.Offprint requests to: S. Horai     

Tempo and mode of synonymous substitutions in mitochondrial DNA of primates

Nucleotide substitutions of the four-fold degenerate sites and the total third codon positions of mitochondrial DNA from human, common chimpanzee, bonobo, gorilla, and orangutan were examined in detail by three alternative Markov models; (1) Hasegawa, Kishino, and Yano's (1985) model, (2) Tamura and Nei's (1993) model, and (3) the general reversible Markov model. These sites are expected to be relatively free from constraint, and therefore their tempo and mode in evolution should reflect those of mutation. It turned out that, among the alternative models, the general reversible Markov model best approximates the nucleotide substitutions of the four-fold degenerate sites and the total third codon positions, while the maximum likelihood estimates of the numbers of nucleotide substitutions along each branch do not differ significantly among the three models. It was further shown that the transition rate of these sites during evolution, and therefore transitional mutation rate of mtDNA, are higher in humans than in chimpanzees and gorillas probably by about two times. However, transversional mutation rate and amino acid substitution rate do not differ significantly between humans and the African apes. These and additional observations suggest heterogeneity of the mutation rate as well as of the constraint operating on the mtDNA-encoded proteins among different lineages of Hominoidea.      

Gene diversity patterns at 10 X-chromosomal loci in humans and chimpanzees

We have investigated the pattern and extent of nucleotide diversityin 10 X-chromosomal genes where mutations are known to causemental retardation in humans. For each gene, we sequenced theentire coding region from cDNA in humans, chimpanzees, and orangutans,as well as about 3 kb of genomic DNA in 20 humans sampled worldwideand in 10 chimpanzees representing two "subspecies." Overallnucleotide diversity in these genes is about twofold lower inhumans than in chimpanzees, and nucleotide diversity withinand between species is low, suggesting that a high level offunctional constraint acts on these genes. Strikingly, we findthat a summary of the allele frequency spectrum is significantlycorrelated in humans and chimpanzees, perhaps reflecting verysimilar levels of constraint at these genes in the two species.A possible exception is FMR2, which shows a higher number ofnonsynonymous than synonymous substitutions on the human lineage,suggesting the action of positive selection.     

Time of the deepest root for polymorphism in human mitochondrial DNA

Summary A molecular clock analysis was carried out on the nucleotide sequences of parts of the major noncoding region of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) from the major geographic populations of humans. Dates of branchings in the mtDNA tree among humans were estimated with an improved maximum likelihood method. Two species of chimpanzees were used as an outgroup, and the mtDNA clock was calibrated by assuming that the chimpanzee/human split occurred 4 million years ago, following our earlier works. A model of homogeneous evolution among sites does not fit well with the data even within hypervariable segments, and hence an additional parameter that represents a proportion of variable sites was introduced. Taking account of this heterogeneity among sites, the date for the deepest root of the mtDNA tree among humans was estimated to be 280,000±50,000 years old (±1 SE), although there remains uncertainty about the constancy of the evolutionary rate among lineages. The evolutionary rate of the most rapidly evolving sites in mtDNA was estimated to be more than 100 times greater than that of a nuclear pseudogene.     

MtDNA substitution rate and segregation of heteroplasmy in coding and noncoding regions

The mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) substitution rate and segregation of heteroplasmy were studied for the non-coding control region (D-loop) and 500 bp of the coding region between nucleotide positions 5550 and 6050, by sequence analysis of blood samples from 194 individuals, representing 33 maternal lineages. No homoplasmic nucleotide substitutions were detected in a total of 292 transmissions. The estimated substitution rate per nucleotide per million years for the control region (micro>0.21, 95% CI 0-0.6) was not significantly different from that for the coding region (micro>0.54, 95% CI 0-1.0). Variation in the length of homopolymeric C streches was observed at three sites in the control region (positions 65, 309 and 16,189), all of which were in the heteroplasmic state. Segregation of heteroplasmic genotypes between generations was observed in several maternal pedigrees. At position 309, a longer poly C tract length was strongly associated with a higher probability for heteroplasmy and rapid segregation between generations. The length heteroplasmy at positions 65 and 16,189 was found at low frequency and was confined to a few families.     

Substitution rate variation among sites in mitochondrial hypervariable region I of humans and chimpanzees

Mitochondrial D-loop hypervariable region I (HVI) sequences are widely used in human molecular evolutionary studies, and therefore accurate assessment of rate heterogeneity among sites is essential. We used the maximum-likelihood method to estimate the gamma shape parameter alpha for variable substitution rates among sites for HVI from humans and chimpanzees to provide estimates for future studies. The complete data of 839 humans and 224 chimpanzees, as well as many subsets of these data, were analyzed to examine the effect of sequence sampling. The effects of the genealogical tree and the nucleotide substitution model were also examined. The transition/transversion rate ratio (kappa) is estimated to be about 25, although much larger and biased estimates were also obtained from small data sets at low divergences. Estimates of alpha were 0.28-0.39 for human data sets of different sizes and 0.20-0.39 for data sets including different chimpanzee subspecies. The combined data set of both species gave estimates of 0.42-0.45. While all those estimates suggest highly variable substitution rates among sites, smaller samples tend to give smaller estimates of alpha. Possible causes for this pattern were examined, such as biases in the estimation procedure and shifts in the rate distribution along certain lineages. Computer simulations suggest that the estimation procedure is quite reliable for large trees but can be biased for small samples at low divergences. Thus, an alpha of 0.4 appears suitable for both humans and chimpanzees. Estimates of alpha can be affected by the nucleotide sites included in the data, the overall tree length (the amount of sequence divergence), the number of rate classes used for the estimation, and to a lesser extent, the included sequences. The genealogical tree, the substitution model, and demographic processes such as population expansion do not have much effect.     

Nucleotide diversity in gorillas

Comparison of the levels of nucleotide diversity in humans and apes may provide valuable information for inferring the demographic history of these species, the effect of social structure on genetic diversity, patterns of past migration, and signatures of past selection events. Previous DNA sequence data from both the mitochondrial and the nuclear genomes suggested a much higher level of nucleotide diversity in the African apes than in humans. Noting that the nuclear DNA data from the apes were very limited, we previously conducted a DNA polymorphism study in humans and another in chimpanzees and bonobos, using 50 DNA segments randomly chosen from the noncoding, nonrepetitive parts of the human genome. The data revealed that the nucleotide diversity (pi) in bonobos (0.077%) is actually lower than that in humans (0.087%) and that pi in chimpanzees (0.134%) is only 50% higher than that in humans. In the present study we sequenced the same 50 segments in 15 western lowland gorillas and estimated pi to be 0.158%. This is the highest value among the African apes but is only about two times higher than that in humans. Interestingly, available mtDNA sequence data also suggest a twofold higher nucleotide diversity in gorillas than in humans, but suggest a threefold higher nucleotide diversity in chimpanzees than in humans. The higher mtDNA diversity in chimpanzees might be due to the unique pattern in the evolution of chimpanzee mtDNA. From the nuclear DNA pi values, we estimated that the long-term effective population sizes of humans, bonobos, chimpanzees, and gorillas are, respectively, 10,400, 12,300, 21,300, and 25,200.     

Model of amino acid substitution in proteins encoded by mitochondrial DNA

Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) sequences are widely used for inferring the phylogenetic relationships among species. Clearly, the assumed model of nucleotide or amino acid substitution used should be as realistic as possible. Dependence among neighboring nucleotides in a codon complicates modeling of nucleotide substitutions in protein-encoding genes. It seems preferable to model amino acid substitution rather than nucleotide substitution. Therefore, we present a transition probability matrix of the general reversible Markov model of amino acid substitution for mtDNA-encoded proteins. The matrix is estimated by the maximum likelihood (ML) method from the complete sequence data of mtDNA from 20 vertebrate species. This matrix represents the substitution pattern of the mtDNA-encoded proteins and shows some differences from the matrix estimated from the nuclear-encoded proteins. The use of this matrix would be recommended in inferring trees from mtDNA-encoded protein sequences by the ML method. Received: 3 May 1995 / Accepted: 31 October 1995     

A Comparative Analysis of Regulatory Regions of the Transthyretin Gene in the Mouse, Human, and Chimpanzee Genomes

A full genome analysis of differences between the gene expression in the human and chimpanzee brains revealed that the gene for transthyretin, the carrier of thyroid hormones, is differently transcribed in the cerebella of these species. A 7-kbp DNA fragment of chimpanzee was sequenced to identify possible regulatory sequences responsible for the differences in expression. One hundred and thirteen substitutions were found in the chimpanzee sequence in comparison with the human sequence. About 40% of the substitutions were revealed within the repeating elements of the genome; their location and sizes did not differ from those in the corresponding fragments of the human genome, and the nucleotide sequences had a high degree of identity. A comparison of nucleotide sequences of the transthyretin region of human, chimpanzee, and mouse genes revealed substantial differences in the distribution of G + C content along the examined fragment in the human (chimpanzee) and mouse genes and allowed us to localize three sequence tracts with a higher degree of identity in the three species. One of these tracts was located in the promoter region of the gene, and the other two probably determine the specificity of transthyretin gene expression in the liver and brain. One of the conserved tracts of the chimpanzee genome was found to have a single and a triple nucleotide substitution. The triple substitution distinguishes chimpanzees from humans and mice, which have identical sequences of this site. It is likely that these substitutions are responsible for the differences in the expression levels of the transthyretin gene in the human and chimpanzee brains.     

Ancestral Population Sizes and Species Divergence Times in the Primate Lineage on the Basis of Intron and BAC End Sequences

The effective sizes of ancestral populations and species divergence times of six primate species (humans, chimpanzees, gorillas, orangutans, and representatives of Old World monkeys and New World monkeys) are estimated by applying the two-species maximum likelihood (ML) method to intron sequences of 20 different loci. Examination of rate heterogeneity of nucleotide substitutions and intragenic recombination identifies five outrageous loci (ODC1, GHR, HBE, INS, and HBG). The estimated ancestral polymorphism ranges from 0.21 to 0.96% at major divergences in primate evolution. One exceptionally low polymorphism occurs when African and Asian apes diverged. However, taking into consideration the possible short generation times in primate ancestors, it is concluded that the ancestral population size in the primate lineage was no smaller than that of extant humans. Furthermore, under the assumption of 6 million years (myr) divergence between humans and chimpanzees, the divergence time of humans from gorillas, orangutans, Old World monkeys, and New World monkeys is estimated as 7.2, 18, 34, and 65 myr ago, respectively, which are generally older than traditional estimates. Beside the intron sequences, three other data sets of orthologous sequences are used between the human and the chimpanzee comparison. The ML application to these data sets including 58,156 random BAC end sequences (BES) shows that the nucleotide substitution rate is as low as 0.6–0.8 × 10^–9 per site per year and the extent of ancestral polymorphism is 0.33–0.51%. With such a low substitution rate and short generation time, the relatively high extent of polymorphism suggests a fairly large effective population size in the ancestral lineage common to humans and chimpanzees.[Reviewing Editor: Dr. Magnus Nordborg]     

A comparative analysis of regulatory regions of the transthyretin gene in the mouse, human, and chimpanzee genomes

A full genome analysis of differences between the gene expression in the human and chimpanzee brains revealed that the gene for transthyretin, the carrier of thyroid hormones, is differently transcribed in the cerebella of these species. A 7-kbp DNA fragment of chimpanzee was sequenced to identify possible regulatory sequences responsible for the differences in expression. One hundred and thirteen substitutions were found in the chimpanzee sequence in comparison with the human sequence. About 40% of the substitutions were revealed within the repeating elements of the genome; their location and sizes did not differ from those in the corresponding fragments of the human genome, and the nucleotide sequences had a high degree of identity. A comparison of nucleotide sequences of the transthyretin region of human, chimpanzee, and mouse genes revealed substantial differences in the distribution of G + C content along the examined fragment in the human (chimpanzee) and mouse genes and allowed us to localize three sequence tracts with a higher degree of identity in the three species. One of these tracts is located in the promoter region of the gene, and the other two probably determine the specificity of transthyretin gene expression in the liver and brain. One of the conserved tracts of the chimpanzee genome was found to have a single and a triple nucleotide substitution. The triple substitution distinguishes chimpanzees from humans and mice, which have identical sequences of this site. It is likely that these substitutions are responsible for the differences in the expression levels of the transthyretin gene in the human and chimpanzee brains.     

Relative rates of evolution in the coding and control regions of African mtDNAs

Reduced median networks of African haplogroup L mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) sequences were analyzed to determine the pattern of substitutions in both the noncoding control and coding regions. In particular, we attempted to determine the causes of the previously reported (Howell et al. 2004) violation of the molecular clock during the evolution of these sequences. In the coding region, there was a significantly higher rate of substitution at synonymous sites than at nonsynonymous sites as well as in the tRNA and rRNA genes. This is further evidence for the operation of purifying selection during human mtDNA evolution. For most sites in the control region, the relative rate of substitution was similar to the rate of neutral evolution (assumed to be most closely approximated by the substitution rate at 4-fold degenerate sites). However, there are a number of mutational hot spots in the control region, approximately 3% of the total sites, that have a rate of substitution greater than the neutral rate, at some sites by more than an order of magnitude. It is possible either that these sites are evolving under conditions of positive selection or that the substitution rate at some sites in the control region is strongly dependent upon sequence context. Finally, we obtained preliminary evidence for "nonideal" evolution in the control region, including haplogroup-specific substitution patterns and a decoupling between relative rates of substitution in the control and coding regions.     

Complete mtDNA genome of Otus sunia (Aves,Strigidae) and the relaxation of selective constrains on Strigiformes mtDNA following evolution

Most of owls are nocturnal raptor and usually use their soft and fluffy feathers to flight silently to catch prey while other diurnal raptors prefer fierce attack and swift flight. For energy cost of these different hunting strategies can be greatly different, we speculate that mitochondrial gene of owls may undergo a different evolution pattern following raptors evolution. To test our hypothesis, we sequenced the mtDNA genome of Otus sunia and calculated the ratio of nonsynonymous to synonymous nucleotide substitutions (ω, Ka/Ks, dN/dS) of raptors. The mtDNA genome of O. sunia was 17,609 bp in length, containing 13 PCGs, 2 ribosomal RNAs, 22 transfer RNAs and a control region. Secondly structure of tRNAs and rRNAs were predicted and conserved sequence blocks (CSBs) on control region were identified. The Bayesian inference tree and maximum likelihood tree based on 13 PCGs and 2 rRNAs suggested the owls were related to other raptors. Finally, calculation of ω-values of each owls and other raptors mtDNA PCGs indicated that owls accumulated more nonsynonymous nucleotide substitutions relative to synonymous substitutions compared to other raptors. For mtDNA PCGs associated with energy metabolism, this finding may reveal the degeneration of flight abilities of owls.     

Accelerated rate of gene gain and loss in primates

The molecular changes responsible for the evolution of modern humans have primarily been discussed in terms of individual nucleotide substitutions in regulatory or protein coding sequences. However, rates of nucleotide substitution are slowed in primates, and thus humans and chimpanzees are highly similar at the nucleotide level. We find that a third source of molecular evolution, gene gain and loss, is accelerated in primates relative to other mammals. Using a novel method that allows estimation of rate heterogeneity among lineages, we find that the rate of gene turnover in humans is more than 2.5 times faster than in other mammals and may be due to both mutational and selective forces. By reconciling the gene trees for all of the gene families included in the analysis, we are able to independently verify the numbers of inferred duplications. We also use two methods based on the genome assembly of rhesus macaque to further verify our results. Our analyses identify several gene families that have expanded or contracted more rapidly than is expected even after accounting for an overall rate acceleration in primates, including brain-related families that have more than doubled in size in humans. Many of the families showing large expansions also show evidence for positive selection on their nucleotide sequences, suggesting that selection has been important in shaping copy-number differences among mammals. These findings may help explain why humans and chimpanzees show high similarity between orthologous nucleotides yet great morphological and behavioral differences.     

A low rate of replacement substitutions in two major Ovis aries mitochondrial genomes

Two mitochondrial DNA molecules which represent major Ovis aries mtDNA haplogroups were cloned and comparatively sequenced to assess the degree of intraspecific variation. A total of 9623 bp that correspond to 58% of both mitochondrial genomes were determined. The control region, the Cyt b , ND2, ND3, ND4L, COIII and 12 tRNA genes, including the origin of L-strand replication, were completely characterized. Partial sequence information was obtained from the 12S and 16S rRNA and an additional six protein coding and six tRNA genes. The control regions of the two mtDNAs showed a nucleotide divergence of 4·34% while coding regions differed by 0·44%. The number of sheep coding region substitutions was similar to values observed in intraspecific comparisons of mitochondrial DNAs that represent remote points in genealogical trees of mice and humans. However, replacement substitutions were only observed at ∼30% of the rate in mice and ∼20% of the rate in humans. Nucleotide substitutions with a potential for phenotypic effects were found in the 12S and 16S rRNA and in the ND1 and COIII genes.     

Mitochondrial DNA mutations in diseases of energy metabolism

A variety of degenerative diseases involving deficiencies in mitochondrial bioenergetics have been associated with mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutations. Maternally inherited mtDNA nucleotide substitutions range from neutral polymorphisms to lethal mutations. Neutral polymorphisms are ancient, having accumulated along mtDNA lineages, and thus correlate with ethnic and geographic origin. Mildly deleterious base substitutions have also occurred along mtDNA lineages and have been associated with familial deafness and some cases of Alzheimer's Disease and Parkinson's Disease. Moderately deleterious nucleotide substitutions are more recent and cause maternally-inherited diseases such as Leber's Hereditary Optic Neuropathy (LHON) and Myoclonic Epilepsy and Ragged-Red Fiber Disease (MERRF). Severe nucleotide substitutions are generally new mutations that cause pediatric diseases such as Leigh's Syndrome and dystonia. MtDNA rearrangements also cause a variety of phenotypes. The milder rearrangements generally involve duplications and can cause maternally-inherited adult-onset diabetes and deafness. More severe rearrangements frequently involving detetions have been associated with adult-onset Chronic Progressive External Ophthalmoplegia (CPEO) and Kearns-Sayre Syndrome (KSS) or the lethal childhood disorder, Pearson's Marrow/Pancreas Syndrome. Defects in nuclear-cytoplasmic interaction have also been observed, and include an autosomal dominant mutation causing multiple muscle mtDNA deletions and a genetically complex disease resulting in the tissue depletion of mtDNAs. MtDNA nucleotide substitution and rearrangement mutations also accumulate with age in quiescent tissues. These somatic mutations appear to degrade cellular bioenergetic capacity, exacerbate inherited mitochondrial defects and contribute to tissue senescence. Thus, bioenergetic defects resulting from mtDNA mutations may be a common cause of human degenerative disease.