Protein refolding by reversed micelles utilizing solid-liquid extraction technique

This article reports that a reversed micellar solution is useful for refolding proteins directly from a solid source. The solubilization of denatured RNase A, which had been prepared by reprecipitation from the denaturant protein solution, into reversed micelles formulated with sodium di-2-ethylhexyl sulfosuccinate (AOT) has been investigated by a solid-liquid extraction system. This method is an alternative to the ordinary protein extraction in reversed micelles based on the liquid-liquid extraction. The solid-liquid extraction method was found to facilitate the solubilization of denatured proteins more efficiently in the reversed micellar media than the ordinary phase transfer method of liquid extraction. The refolding of denatured RNase A entrapped in reversed micelles was attained by adding a redox reagent (reduced and oxidized glutathion). Enzymatic activity of RNase A was gradually recovered with time in the reversed micelles. The denatured RNase A was completely refolded within 30 h. In addition, the efficiency of protein refolding was enhanced when reversed micelles were applied to denatured RNase A containing a higher protein concentration that, in the case of aqueous media, would lead to protein aggregation. The solid-liquid extraction technique using reversed micelles affords better scale-up advantages in the direct refolding process of insoluble protein aggregates.     

Important parameters affecting efficiency of protein refolding by reversed micelles

Refolding of denatured RNase A as a model of inclusion bodies was performed by reversed micelles formulated with sodium di-2-ethylhexyl sulfosuccinate (AOT) in isooctane. In the novel refolding process, a solid-liquid extraction was utilized as an alternative to the ordinary protein extraction by reversed micelles based on a liquid-liquid extraction. First, the effects of operational parameters such as concentration of AOT, W(o) (= [H(2)O]/[AOT]), and pH were examined on the solubilization of solid denatured proteins into a reversed micellar solution. The solubilization was facilitated by a high AOT concentration, a high W(o) value, and a high pH in water pools. These conditions are favorable for the dispersion of the solid protein aggregates in an organic solvent. Second, the renaturation of the denatured RNase A solubilized into the reversed micellar solution was conducted by addition of glutathione as a redox reagent. A complete renaturation of RNase A was accomplished by adjusting the composition of the redox reagent even at a high protein concentration in which protein aggregation would usually occur in aqueous media. In addition, the renaturation rates were improved by optimizing water content (W(o)) and the pH of water pools in reversed micelles. Finally, the recovery of renatured RNase A from the reversed micellar solution was performed by adding a polar organic solvent such as acetone into the reversed micellar solution. This precipitation method was effective for recovering proteins from reversed micellar media without any significant reduction in enzymatic activity.     

Protein refolding in reversed micelles

A novel process has been developed which uses reversed micelles to isolate denatured protein molecules from each other and allows them to refold individually. These reversed micelles are aqueous phase droplets stabilized by the surfactant AOT and suspended in isooctane. By adjusting conditions such that only one protein molecule is present per reversed micelle, it was possible to achieve independent folding without encountering the problem of aggregation due to interactions with neighboring molecules. The feasibility of this process was demonstrated using bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A as a model system. It was shown that denatured and reduced ribonuclease can be transferred from a buffered solution containing guanidine hydrochloride into reversed micelles to a greater extent than native enzyme under the same conditions. The denaturant concentration can then be significantly reduced in the reversed micellar phase, while retaining most of the protein, by means of extractive contacting stages with a denaturant-free aqueous solution. Denatured and reduced ribonuclease will subsequently recover full activity inside reversed micelles within 24 h upon addition of a mixture of reduced and oxidized glutathione to reoxidize disulfide bonds. Extraction of this refolded enzyme from reversed micelles back into aqueous solution can be accomplished by contacting the reversed micelle phase with a high ionic strength (1.0M KCl) aqueous solution containing ethyl acetate.     

Spectroscopic properties of horse liver alcohol dehydrogenase in reversed micellar solutions

Catalytic and spectroscopic properties of alcohol dehydrogenase from horse liver, incorporated in reversed micellar media, have been studied. Two different reversed micellar systems have been used, one containing an anionic [sodium bis(2-ethylhexyl)sulfosuccinate, AOT], the other containing a cationic (cetyltrimethylammonium bromide, CTAB) surfactant. With 1-hexanol as substrate the turnover number of the enzyme in AOT-reversed micelles is strongly dependent on the water content of the system. At low wo ([H2O]/[surfactant]) (wo less than 20) no enzymatic activity can be detected whereas at high wo (wo = 40) the turnover is only slightly lower than in aqueous solution. In CTAB-reversed micelles the dependence of the turnover number on wo is much less. The enzymatic activity is in this case significantly lower than in aqueous solution and increases only slightly with an increasing water content of the reversed micelles. Possible interactions of the protein with the surfactant interfaces in the reversed micellar media were studied via circular dichroism and fluorescence measurements. From the circular dichroism of the protein backbone it is observed that the protein secondary structure is not significantly affected upon incorporation in the reversed micelles since the far-ultraviolet spectrum is not altered. Results from time-resolved fluorescence anisotropy experiments indicate that, especially in AOT-reversed micelles, interactions between the protein and the surfactant interface are largely electrostatic in nature, as evident from the dependence on the pH of the buffer used. In CTAB-reversed micellar solutions such interactions appear to be much less pronounced than in AOT.     

Mechanism of extraction of chymotrypsin into isooctane at very low concentrations of aerosol OT in the absence of reversed micelles

Chymotrypsin is easily extracted from an aqueous solution into isooctane containing the anionic surfactant aerosol OT (AOT). The concentration of AOT needed to efficiently extract 0.5 mg/mL CMT is as low as 1 mM and as low as 0.2 mM AOT was sufficient to extract the protein into isooctane. The extraction process was unaffected by 10% (v/v) ethyl acetate in the isooctane phase. Moreover, spectroscopic analysis by electron paramagnetic resonance indicated that CMT did not exist inside a discreet water pool of a reversed micelle. Calculations of the number of AOT molecules associated per extracted CMT molecule indicate that only ca. 30 surfactant molecules interact with the protein, a value too low for reversed micellar incorporation of the protein in isooctane. These studies suggested that reversed micelles do not need to be involved in the actual transfer of the protein from the aqueous to the organic phase and protein solubilization in the organic phase is possible in the absence of reversed micelles. Based on these findings, a new mechanism has been proposed herein for protein extraction via the phase transfer method involving ionic surfactants. The central theme of this mechanism is the formation of an electrostatic complex between CMT and AOT at the aqueous/organic interface between AOT and CMT, thereby leading to the formation of a hydrophobic species that partitions into the organic phase. Consistent with this mechanism, the efficiency of extraction is dependent on the interfacial mass transfer, the concentrations of CMT and AOT in the aqueous and organic phases, respectively; the ionic strength of the aqueous phase; and the presence of various cosolvents. (c) 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Time-resolved fluorescence and circular dichroism of porphyrin cytochrome c and Zn-porphyrin cytochrome c incorporated in reversed micelles

Interactions between fluorescent horse heart cytochrome c derivatives (e. g. porphyrin cytochrome c and Zn-porphyrin cytochrome c) with surfactant interfaces in reversed micellar solutions have been studied, using different spectroscopic techniques. Anionic [sodium bis(2-ethylhexyl)sulfosuccinate, AOT] and cationic (cetyltrime-thylammonium bromide, CTAB) surfactant solutions have been used in order to investigate the effects of charge interactions between proteins and interfaces. Circular dichroism reveals that much of the protein secondary structure is lost in AOT-reversed micelles, especially when the molar water/surfactant ratio, wo, is high (wo = 40), whereas in CTAB-reversed micelles secondary structure seems to be preserved. Time-resolved fluorescence measurements of the porphyrin in the cytochrome c molecule yields information about the changes in structure and the dynamics of the protein upon interaction with surfactant assemblies both in aqueous and in hydrocarbon solutions. With AOT as surfactant a strong interaction between protein and interface can be observed. The effects found in aqueous AOT solution are of the same kind as in hydrocarbon solution. In the CTAB systems the interactions between protein and surfactant are much less pronounced. The measured effects on the fluorescence properties of the proteins are different in aqueous and hydrocarbon solutions. In general, the observations can be explained by an electrostatic attraction between the overall positively charged protein molecules and the anionic AOT interface. Electrostatic attraction can also occur between the cytochrome c derivatives and CTAB because there is a negatively charged zone on the surface of the proteins. From the fluorescence anisotropy decays it can be concluded that in the CTAB-reversed micellar system these interactions are not important, whereas in an aqueous CTAB solution the proteins interact with surfactant molecules.     

Direct refolding of inclusion bodies using reversed micelles

The protein refolding of inclusion bodies was investigated using reversed micelles formed by aerosol OT (AOT). Ribonuclease A (RNase A) was overexpressed in Escherichia coli and used as native inclusion bodies. The enzymatic activity of RNase A was completely regained from the inclusion bodies within 14 h by solubilization in reversed micelles. To further enhance the refolding rate, a molecular chaperone, GroEL, was incorporated into the refolding system. The resultant refolding system including GroEL showed better performance under optimized conditions for the refolding of RNase A inclusion bodies. The refolding rate was considerably improved by the addition of the molecular chaperone, and the refolding step was completed in 1 h. The protein refolding in the GroEL-containing refolding system was strongly dependent on the coexistence of ATP and Mg2+, suggesting that the GroEL hosted in the reversed micelles was biologically active and assisted in the renaturation of the inclusion bodies. The addition of cold acetone to the reversed micellar solution allowed over 90% recovery of the renatured RNase A.     

Renaturation and interaction of ribonuclease A with AOT surfactant in reverse micelles

This study extended works on effects of solute on the percolation of reverse micelles to the effects of interactions between protein and surfactants on protein refolding by reverse micelles. The changes in percolation behavior were identified and attributed to the position of solutes in the core aqueous phase and the interaction between the solute and the surfactants. The percolation behavior of reverse micelles with solutes was related to protein renaturation and the reverse micelle. This study aims to highlight the involvement of the interface and the interaction of the protein with the surfactant during protein refolding. Ribonuclease A and AOT reverse micelles together constitute a model system considered here. The systemic parameters of the reverse micelle, water content (W(o)) and pH value, were applied to modify the interaction between the denatured protein molecules and the surfactant interface. The interactions and the locations of the protein molecules were determined from changes in percolation temperature measured by conductivity. The percolation and protein activity show that a stronger interaction of the protein molecules with surfactant corresponds to superior recovery of protein activity. The investigation concludes that the refolding of protein by reverse micelles is not only facilitated by the isolation of reverse micelles but also by the interaction due to the interface of the reverse micelle.     

Refolding of chemically denatured alpha-amylase in dilution additive mode

Cyclodextrins (CDs) possess hydrophobic surfaces, which probably shield the hydrophobic surfaces of denatured proteins and prevent the direct interactions between the surfaces which are believed to be responsible for protein aggregation during refolding process. This probability was evaluated by studying the refolding process of denatured alpha-amylase in the presence and absence of alpha-CD, as a dilution additive agent. Our data indicate that in the presence of 100 mM alpha-CD in the refolding buffer, the extent of aggregation reduces by almost 90%. Spectrofluorometric analysis of the refolding intermediate(s) also indicates that the tertiary structure of the refolded alpha-amylase, in the presence of alpha-CD, is very similar to the tertiary structure of the native protein. However, this similarity was distorted upon addition of exogenous hydrophobic (aliphatic or aromatic) amino acids to the refolding buffer, meaning that the hydrophobic interactions between alpha-CD and the denatured protein play significant role in preventing aggregate formation. In addition, by weakening the extent of these hydrophobic interactions by adding polarity-reducing agent (e.g. ethylene glycol) to the refolding buffer, more aggregates were formed. In contrast, strengthening these interactions by enhancing the ionic strength of the refolding buffer made these hydrophobic interactions very strong. Therefore, alpha-CD could not depart from the protein/alpha-CD complex, as it usually does during the process of refolding. As a result, more aggregates were formed in the presence of alpha-CD compared to the corresponding control samples.     

反胶束萃取血红蛋白的研究

研究了ＣＴＡＢ－正辛醇－正庚烷交束溶液萃取牛血红蛋白（ｐＨｂ）时、ｐＨ值、表面活性剂浓度、助表面活性剂浓度、离子种类和离子强度、溶剂比以及蛋白质浓度等因素对萃取效果的影响,并以蛋白质分子与表面活性剂分子间的相互作用以及反胶束大空间阻碍作用上进行了解释。研究表明,水相ＰＨ值在１０．５￣１２．５之间,ＫＣ１浓度为０．１ｍｏｌ／ｌ,反胶束溶液中表面活性剂浓度为０．０２ｍｏｌ／ｌ,正辛醇与正庚烷之比为０．     

Triplet-state kinetics of Zn-porphyrin cytochrome c in micellar media. Measurement of intermicellar exchange rates

The interactions of protein molecules with surfactant assemblies in aqueous and hydrocarbon media have been studied via the triplet-state kinetics of Zn-porphyrin cytochrome c in solutions containing an anionic [sodium bis(2-ethylhexyl)sulfosuccinate, AOT] or a cationic (cetyltrimethylammonium bromide, CTAB) surfactant. In aqueous solution, the observed triplet state decay is single exponential with a lifetime of 8 ms. In aqueous solutions of AOT and in AOT-reversed micellar solutions, biexponential triplet state decays were observed, indicating that interactions between the surfactant and the protein occur, resulting in a change in protein conformation near the porphyrin ring. In CTAB-reversed micellar solutions, quenching of the Zn-porphyrin cytochrome c triplet state by ferricyanide and methyl viologen was studied. Because the quenching is exchange-limited under the conditions used, the exchange rate constants for the water pools can be obtained from these experiments. The observed exchange rate constants are in the range (1-5) x 10(7) M-1 S-1, depending on the water content of the reversed micelles and on the type of quencher used. These values are three orders of magnitude lower than the calculated collision rate of the reversed micelles.     

Design of surfactants suitable for protein extraction by reversed micelles

New surfactants have been synthesized for potential use in reversed micellar protein extraction operations. Preferential solubility of the surfactant in an aliphatic solvent such as hexane, heptane, or isooctane and the formation of reversed micelles accompanied with solubilization of significant quantities of water can be achieved by using strongly hydrophobic, twin alkyl chains as the hydrophobic moiety. Different surfactants having identical water-solubilizing capacities can have significantly different behavior in protein extractions, where extraction efficiency appears to be governed by the nature of the interfacial complex that forms between surfactants and proteins. Bulky surfactant chains provide a steric hindrance to the adsorption of the surfactant to the protein surface, thus inhibiting solvation of the protein/surfactant complex, and hence protein extraction. Under these conditions, a precipitate forms either in the bulk aqueous phase or at the interface. Surfactants that can form a close-packed complex with the protein are excellent protein-solubilizing agents. Dioleyl phosphoric acid (DOLPA) appears to be the best surfactant currently available for protein extraction. (c) 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Biotechnol Bioeng 54: 26-32, 1997.     

Protein extraction using the sodium bis(2-ethylhexyl) phosphate (NaDEHP) reverse micellar system

The reverse micellar system of sodium bis(2-ethylhexyl) phosphate (NaDEHP)/isooctane/brine was used for liquid-liquid extraction of proteins. We investigated the solubilization of cytochrome-c and alpha-chymotrypsin into the NaDEHP reverse micellar phase by varying the pH and NaCl concentration in the aqueous phase. At neutral pH and relatively low ionic strength, the proteins are extracted into the micellar phase with high yield. By contacting the micellar phase with a divalent cation (e.g., Ca(2+)) aqueous solution, the reverse micelles are destabilized and release the protein molecules back into an aqueous solution for recovery. This method separates the proteins from the surfactant with very high overall efficiencies. (c) 1996 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Affinity extraction of proteins with a reversed micellar system composed of Cibacron Blue-modified lecithin

Crude soybean lecithin was used as a novel surfactant to form reversed micelles in n-hexane. Cibacron Blue F-3GA (CB) was directly immobilized to the reversed micelles by a two-phase reaction. The reversed micellar system without CB showed low solubilizing capacity for low molecular weight proteins, lysozyme, and cytochrome c due to the weak electrostatic interactions. The introduction of CB significantly increased the solubilization of lysozyme because of its affinity binding to CB but showed no effect on the solubilization of cytochrome c since it did not bind to CB. Although bovine serum albumin had an affinity for CB, it was not extracted to the reversed micelles containing CB because its high molecular weight resulted in a significant steric hindrance effect. Thus the reversed micellar system had a high selectivity resulting from both biospecific and steric hindrance effects. The extraction yield of lysozyme decreased significantly with increasing ionic strength. Therefore, the back extraction of lysozyme was carried out using a stripping solution with an ionic strength of 0.865 mol/L. The overall recovery yield of lysozyme after back extraction could be increased to 87% by stripping for 2 h. The recovered lysozyme exhibited an activity equivalent to native lysozyme, and its secondary structure was also unchanged.     

Protein refolding mediated by reverse micelles of Cibacron Blue F-3GA modified nonionic surfactant

An affinity-based reverse micellar system formulated with nonionic surfactant was applied to the refolding of denatured-reduced lysozyme. The nonionic surfactant of sorbitan trioleate (Span 85) was modified with Cibacron Blue F-3GA (CB) as an affinity surfactant (CB-Span 85) to form affinity-based reverse micelles in n-hexane. The water content of 15 was found optimal for lysozyme refolding in the reverse micellar system of 62.7 mmol/L Span 85 with coupled CB of 0.3 and 0.5 mmol/L. In addition, the operating conditions such as pH and the concentrations of urea and redox reagents were optimized. Under the optimized conditions, complete renaturation of lysozyme at 3-3.5 mg/mL was achieved, whereas dilution refolding in the bulk aqueous phase under the same conditions gave much lower activity recovery. Moreover, the secondary structure of the refolded lysozyme was found to be the same as the native lysozyme. Over 95% of the refolded lysozyme was recovered from CB-Span 85 reverse micelles by a stripping solution of 0.5 mol/L MgCl(2). Thus, the present system is advantageous over the conventional reverse micellar system formed with ionic surfactants in the ease of protein recovery.     

Nonaggregating refolding of ribonuclease A using reverse micellar dialysis

A hydrophilic ultrafiltration membrane, regenerated cellulose, facilitates the size-selectable permeability of hydrophilic solutes in reverse micellar solution. By using an ultrafiltration membrane with a molecular weight cutoff of 3,500, we demonstrate a nonaggregating protein refolding technique based on the dialysis of reverse micellar solution. This realizes concurrent removal of denaturants, urea and 2-mercaptoethanol, and the supply of redox reagents, reduced and oxidized glutathione (GSH, GSSG), to promote renaturation of proteins. Two mg/ml ribonuclease A (RNase A) was refolded completely without any dilution and aggregation for 60 h. The refolding behavior of RNase A is strongly influenced by the ratio of GSH and GSSG. Moreover, we recovered 90% of the refolded RNase A from AOT reverse micellar solution with acetone precipitation and beta-cyclodextrin washing. These findings should facilitate the production of a continuous protein refolding membrane reactor.     

Downstream processing of soy hull peroxidase employing reverse micellar extraction

Phase transfer studies were conducted to evaluate the solubilization of soy hull peroxidase (SHP) in reverse micelles formed in isooctane/butanol/hexanol using the cationic surfactant cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB). The effect of various parameters such as pH, ionic strength, surfactant concentration of the initial aqueous phase for forward extraction and buffer pH, type and concentration of salt, concentration of isopropyl alcohol and volume ratio for back extraction was studied to improve the efficiency of reverse micellar extraction. The active SHP was recovered after a complete cycle of forward and back extraction. A forward extraction efficiency of 100%, back extraction efficiency of 36%, overall activity recovery of 90% and purification fold of 4.72 were obtained under optimised conditions. Anionic surfactant sodium bis (2-ethylhexyl) sulfosuccinate (AOT) did not yield good results under the conditions studied. The phase transfer of soy hull peroxidase was found to be controlled by electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions during forward and back extraction respectively.     

A new approach to titrating active enzyme centers upon the use of surface-active micellar substances in organic solvents

Micellar solutions of surfactant in organic solvents with rubber additions are proposed for determination of active enzyme concentration. A kinetic theory of enzymatic reactions in reversed micellar systems is developed, suggesting the intermicellar transport of the substrate to be the limiting step in viscous medium. Under these conditions, it is shown that fraction of the product formed after quick transformation of the substrate located in the enzyme-containing micelles depends upon active enzyme concentration and aggregation number of surfactant molecules. The proposed approach is used for the active-site titration of trypsin and cellobiase and for the determination of the aggregation number of Aerosol OT (AOT) molecules in the ternary system AOT/water/cyclohexane.     

Extraction of lysozyme and ribonuclease-a using reverse micelles: Limits to protein solubilization

Experiments are reported here on the equilibrium partitioning of lysozyme and ribonuclease-a between aqueous and reversed micellar phases comprised of an anionic surfactant, sodium di-2-ethylhexyl sulfosuccinate (AOT), in isooctane. A distinct maximum, [P](rm,max) was found for the quantity of a given protein that can be solubilized in the reverse micelle phase by the phase-transfer method. This upper limit depended upon the size of the protein, the surfactant concentration, and the aqueous phase ionic strength, and was determined by complex formation between protein and surfactant molecules to form an insoluble interfacial precipitate at high values of [P](rm). In this work, it was found to be possible to dissociate the protein-surfactant complex and recover the precipitated protein. The kinetics of protein-surfactant complex formation depended upon the nature and concentration of the solubilized protein and on the surfactant concentration. Calculations of micellar occupancy and the relative surface areas of protein molecules and surfactant head-groups suggested that it was the exposure of the solubilized protein to the bulk organic solvent which promoted protein-surfactant complex formation as [P](rm) --> [P](rm,max). In the light of the experimental results and calculations described above, a mechanistic model is proposed to account for the observed phenomena. This is based upon the competing effects of increasing the solubilized protein concentration and the corresponding increase in the rate of protein-surfactant complex formation. The dynamic nature of the reverse micelles is inherent in the model, explaining the formation of the interfacial precipitate with time and its dependence on the internal phase volume of the micellar phase. Experiments on the co-partitioning of water and measurement ofthe AOT concentration in both phases verified the loss of protein, water, and surfactant from the organic phase at high values of [P](rm). (c) 1995 John Wiley & Sons Inc.     

The effect of surfactants on the aggregation state of amphotericin B

We have studied the effect of two surfactants, one non-ionic, lauryl sucrose (LS) and the other ionic, sodium deoxycholate (DOC), on the aggregation state of amphotericin B (AmB) and its selectivity towards ergosterol and cholesterol. It is shown that the addition of these surfactants has very similar effects on the AmB micelles. Below the critical micellar concentration of the surfactants, mixed micelles with AmB are first formed as a result of the penetration of the surfactant molecules into the AmB micelles. At higher concentrations of the surfactant molecules, the micellar structure is completely destroyed and AmB is found as monomers in solution. When the concentration of the surfactant is further increased, micelles of the surfactant molecules are built up, AmB remaining in monomeric form. However, the critical micellar concentration of LS is modified by the presence of AmB in solution, while that of DOC is not affected, thereby indicating that the interactions of AmB with LS are stronger than those of DOC with AmB. We also show that both surfactants enhance the selectivity of the AmB binding to sterols at exactly the concentrations of the surfactants which induce the monomerization of the antibiotic. It is observed that the maximal selectivity is found at a concentration of the surfactants corresponding to their particular CMC in presence of the antibiotic.