Autocatalytic sets of proteins

This article investigates the possibility that the emergence of reflexively autocatalytic sets of peptides and polypeptides may be an essentially inevitable collective property of any sufficiently complex set of polypeptides. The central idea is based on the connectivity properties of random directed graphs. In the set of amino acid monomer and polymer species up to some maximum length, M, the number of possible polypeptides is large, but, for specifiable "legitimate" end condensation, cleavage and transpeptidation exchange reactions, the number of potential reactions by which the possible polypeptides can interconvert is very much larger. A directed graph in which arrows from smaller fragments to larger condensation products depict potential synthesis reactions, while arrows from the larger peptide to the smaller fragments depict the reverse cleavage reactions, comprises the reaction graph for such a system. Polypeptide protoenzymes are able to catalyze such reactions. The distribution of catalytic capacities in peptide space is a fundamental problem in its own right, and in its bearing on the existence of autocatalytic sets of proteins. Using an initial idealized hypothesis that an arbitrary polypeptide has a fixed a priori probability of catalyzing any arbitrary legitimate reaction to assign to each polypeptide those reactions, if any, which it catalyzes, the probability that the set of polypeptides up to length M contains a reflexively autocatalytic subset can be calculated and is a percolation problem on such reaction graphs. Because, as M increases, the ratio of reactions among the possible polypeptides to polypeptides rises rapidly, the existence of such autocatalytic subsets is assured for any fixed probability of catalysis. The main conclusions of this analysis appear independent of the idealizations of the initial model, introduce a novel kind of parallel selection for peptides catalyzing connected sequences of reactions, depend upon a new kind of minimal critical complexity whose properties are definable, and suggest that the emergence of self replicating systems may be a self organizing collective property of critically complex protein systems in prebiotic evolution. Similar principles may apply to the emergence of a primitive connected metabolism. Recombinant DNA procedures, cloning random DNA coding sequences into expression vectors, afford a direct avenue to test the distribution of catalytic capacities in peptide space, may provide a new means to select or screen for peptides with useful properties, and may ultimately lead toward the actual construction of autocatalytic peptide sets.     

Autocatalytic conversion of recombinant prion proteins displays a species barrier

The most unorthodox feature of the prion disease is the existence of an abnormal infectious isoform of the prion protein, PrP(Sc). According to the "protein-only" hypothesis, PrP(Sc) propagates its abnormal conformation in an autocatalytic manner using the normal isoform, PrP(C), as a substrate. Because autocatalytic conversion is considered a key element of prion replication, in this study I tested whether in vitro conversion of recombinant PrP into abnormal isoform displays specific features of an autocatalytic process. I found that recombinant human PrP formed two distinct beta-sheet rich isoforms, the beta-oligomer and the amyloid fibrils. The kinetics of the fibrils formation measured at different pH values were consistent with a model in which the beta-oligomer was not on the kinetic pathway to the fibrillar form. As judged by electron microscopy, an acidic pH favored to the long fibrils, whereas short fibrils morphologically similar to "prion rods" were formed at neutral pH. At neutral pH the conversion to the fibrils can be seeded with small aliquots of preformed fibrils. As small as 0.001% aliquot displayed seeding activity. The conversion of human PrP was seeded with high efficacy only with the preformed fibrils of human but not mouse PrP and vice versa. These studies illustrate that in vitro conversion of recombinant PrP displays specific features of an autocatalytic process and mimics the transmission barrier of prion propagation observed in vivo. I speculate that this model can be used as a rapid assay for assessing the intrinsic propensities of prion transmission between different species.     

Autocatalytic activation of a thermostable glutamyl endopeptidase capable of hydrolyzing proteins at high temperatures

Glutamyl endopeptidases (GSEs) specifically hydrolyze peptide bonds formed by α-carboxyl groups of Glu and Asp residues. We cloned the gene for a thermophilic GSE (designated TS-GSE) from Thermoactinomyces sp. CDF. A proform of TS-GSE that contained a 61-amino acid N-terminal propeptide and a 218-amino acid mature domain was produced in Escherichia coli. We found that the proform possessed two processing sites and was capable of autocatalytic activation via multiple pathways. The N-terminal propeptide could be autoprocessed at the Glu^?1-Ser¹ bond to directly generate the mature enzyme. It could also be autoprocessed at the Glu^?12-Lys^?11 bond to yield an intermediate, which was then converted into the mature form after removal of the remaining part of the propeptide. The segment surrounding the two processing sites was flexible, which allowed the proform and the intermediate form to be trans-processed into the mature form by either active TS-GSE or heterogeneous proteases. Deletion analysis revealed that the N-terminal propeptide is important for the correct folding and maturation of TS-GSE. The propeptide, even its last 11-amino acid peptide segment, could inhibit the activity of its cognate mature domain. The mature TS-GSE displayed a temperature optimum of 85 °C and retained approximately 90 % of its original activity after incubation at 70 °C for 6 h, representing the most thermostable GSE reported to date. Mutational analysis suggested that the disulfide bonds Cys³²-Cys⁴⁸ and Cys¹⁸⁰-Cys¹⁸³ cumulatively contributed to the thermostability of TS-GSE.     

Autocatalytic processing of gamma-glutamyltranspeptidase

gamma-Glutamyltranspeptidase is the key enzyme in glutathione metabolism, and we previously presented evidence suggesting that it belongs to the N-terminal nucleophile hydrolase superfamily. Enzymatically active gamma-glutamyltranspeptidase, which consists of one large subunit and one small subunit, is generated from an inactive common precursor through post-translational proteolytic processing. The processing mechanism for gamma-glutamyltranspeptidase of Escherichia coli K-12 has been analyzed by means of in vitro studies using purified precursors. Here we show that the processing of a precursor of gamma-glutamyltranspeptidase is an intramolecular autocatalytic event and that the catalytic nucleophile for the processing reaction is the oxygen atom of the side chain of Thr-391 (N-terminal residue of the small (beta) subunit), which is also the nucleophile for the enzymatic reaction.     

Autocatalytic activation of acetyl-CoA synthase

Acetyl-CoA synthase (ACS ACS/CODH CODH/ACS) from Moorella thermoacetica catalyzes the synthesis of acetyl-CoA from CO, CoA, and a methyl group of a corrinoid-iron-sulfur protein (CoFeSP). A time lag prior to the onset of acetyl-CoA production, varying from 4 to 20 min, was observed in assay solutions lacking the low-potential electron-transfer agent methyl viologen (MV). No lag was observed when MV was included in the assay. The length of the lag depended on the concentrations of CO and ACS, with shorter lags found for higher [ACS] and sub-saturating [CO]. Lag length also depended on CoFeSP. Rate profiles of acetyl-CoA synthesis, including the lag phase, were numerically simulated assuming an autocatalytic mechanism. A similar reaction profile was monitored by UV-vis spectrophotometry, allowing the redox status of the CoFeSP to be evaluated during this process. At early stages in the lag phase, Co²⁺FeSP reduced to Co⁺FeSP, and this was rapidly methylated to afford CH₃-Co³⁺FeSP. During steady-state synthesis of acetyl-CoA, CoFeSP was predominately in the CH₃-Co³⁺FeSP state. As the synthesis rate declined and eventually ceased, the Co⁺FeSP state predominated. Three activation reductive reactions may be involved, including reduction of the A- and C-clusters within ACS and the reduction of the cobamide of CoFeSP. The B-, C-, and D-clusters in the subunit appear to be electronically isolated from the A-cluster in the connected subunit, consistent with the ~70 Å distance separating these clusters, suggesting the need for an in vivo reductant that activates ACS and/or CoFeSP.Abbreviations ACS acetyl-CoA synthase, also known as CODH (carbon monoxide dehydrogenase) or CODH/ACS or ACS/CODH - CH₃-Co³⁺FeSP, Co²⁺FeSP, and Co⁺FeSP corrinoid-iron-sulfur protein with the cobalamin in the methylated 3+, unmethylated 2+, and unmethylated 1+ states - CoA coenzyme A - DTT dithiothreitol - H-THF or THF tetrahydrofolic acid or tetrahydrofolate - MT methyl transferase - MV methyl viologen     

Towards complete sets of farnesylated and geranylgeranylated proteins

Three different prenyltransferases attach isoprenyl anchors to C-terminal motifs in substrate proteins. These lipid anchors serve for membrane attachment or protein-protein interactions in many pathways. Although well-tolerated selective prenyltransferase inhibitors are clinically available, their mode of action remains unclear since the known substrate sets of the various prenyltransferases are incomplete. The Prenylation Prediction Suite (PrePS) has been applied for large-scale predictions of prenylated proteins. To prioritize targets for experimental verification, we rank the predictions by their functional importance estimated by evolutionary conservation of the prenylation motifs within protein families. The ranked lists of predictions are accessible as PRENbase (http://mendel.imp.univie.ac.at/sat/PrePS/PRENbase) and can be queried for verification status, type of modifying enzymes (anchor type), and taxonomic distribution. Our results highlight a large group of plant metal-binding chaperones as well as several newly predicted proteins involved in ubiquitin-mediated protein degradation, enriching the known functional repertoire of prenylated proteins. Furthermore, we identify two possibly prenylated proteins in Mimivirus. The section HumanPRENbase provides complete lists of predicted prenylated human proteins-for example, the list of farnesyltransferase targets that cannot become substrates of geranylgeranyltransferase 1 and, therefore, are especially affected by farnesyltransferase inhibitors (FTIs) used in cancer and anti-parasite therapy. We report direct experimental evidence verifying the prediction of the human proteins Prickle1, Prickle2, the BRO1 domain-containing FLJ32421 (termed BROFTI), and Rab28 (short isoform) as exclusive farnesyltransferase targets. We introduce PRENbase, a database of large-scale predictions of protein prenylation substrates ranked by evolutionary conservation of the motif. Experimental evidence is presented for the selective farnesylation of targets with an evolutionary conserved modification site.     

Autocatalytic networks with translation

We consider the kinetics of an autocatalytic reaction network in which replication and catalytic actions are separated by a translation step. We find that the behaviour of such a system is closely related to second-order replicator equations, which describe the kinetics of autocatalytic reaction networks in which the replicators act also as catalysts. In fact, the qualitative dynamics seems to be described almost entirely be the second-order reaction rates of the replication step. For two species we recover the qualitative dynamics of the replicator equations. Larger networks show some deviations, however. A hypercyclic system consisting of three interacting species can converge toward a stable limit cycle in contrast to the replicator equation case. A singular perturbation analysis shows that the replication-translation system reduces to a second-order replicator equation if translation is fast. The influence of mutations on replication-translation networks is also very similar to the behavior of selection-mutation equations.     

Autocatalytic activation of influenza hemagglutinin

Enveloped viruses contain surface proteins that mediate fusion between the viral and target cell membranes following an activating stimulus. Acidic pH induces the influenza virus fusion protein hemagglutinin (HA) via irreversible refolding of a trimeric conformational state leading to exposure of hydrophobic fusion peptides on each trimer subunit. Herein, we show that cells expressing fowl plague virus HA demonstrate discrete switching behavior with respect to the HA conformational change. Partially activated states do not exist at the scale of the cell, activation of HA leads to aggregation of cell surface trimers, and newly synthesized HA refold spontaneously in the presence of previously activated HA. These observations imply a feedback mechanism involving self-catalyzed refolding of HA and thus suggest a mechanism similar to the autocatalytic refolding and aggregation of prions.     

Autocatalytic membrane conductance and memory

A basic characteristic of biological memory is that it has a graded duration, which, even for socalled short-term memory, can vary from minutes to days (i.e. over about three orders of magnitude), depending on the training protocol, which one can think of as determining the “strength” of the memory. Furthermore, the molecular analysis of simple learning in invertebrates has revealed many examples where “learning” is produced by adecrease in an appropriate membrane conductance. This paper provides a quantitative analysis of a simple kinetic scheme where by a conductance decrease can be produced by repetitive nerve impulses, with a duration that varies with stimulus frequency. The simplest model considered is based on the actual kinetics of the naturally-occurring ionophore Monazomycin. This model yields durations ranging only over a factor of about 10, for reasonable parameter values. However, a simple modification of the model yields memory durations ranging over three or more orders of magnitude. We also show that Monazomycin-like kinetics can appear as the result of a combination of simple uni- and bi-molecular reactions, thus making more plausible the possibility that the effects described here may operate in actual biological systems.     

Autocatalytic Sets and Biological Specificity

A universal feature of the biochemistry of any living system is that all the molecules and catalysts that are required for reactions of the system can be built up from an available food source by repeated application of reactions from within that system. RAF (reflexively autocatalytic and food-generated) theory provides a formal way to study such processes. Beginning with Kauffman’s notion of “collectively autocatalytic sets,” this theory has been further developed over the last decade with the discovery of efficient algorithms and new mathematical analysis. In this paper, we study how the behaviour of a simple binary polymer model can be extended to models where the pattern of catalysis more precisely reflects the ligation and cleavage reactions involved. We find that certain properties of these models are similar to, and can be accurately predicted from, the simple binary polymer model; however, other properties lead to slightly different estimates. We also establish a number of new results concerning the structure of RAFs in these systems.     

Autocatalytic polysialylation of polysialyltransferase-1.

Polysialic acid (PSA) is a specific and highly regulated post-translational modification of the neural cell adhesion molecule NCAM. Synthesis of PSA depends on the activity of a single enzyme, the polysialyltransferase-1 (PST-1), recently cloned from three mammalian species. The present study was carried out to investigate the catalytic mechanism of PST-1. Using a newly developed in vitro assay system, we demonstrate autopolysialylation for PST-1. The synthesis of PSA chains, which involved N-glycosylation sites, occurred immediately after contact with the activated sugar donor CMP-Neu5Ac. In contrast to the polysialylation of NCAM, where terminal sialylation in either the alpha2,3 or alpha2,6 position is required, the autopolysialylation could be started in the asialo-PST-1 isolated from CHO cells of the Lec2 complementation group. Pre-formed PSA chains were not transferred to NCAM. Nevertheless, the autocatalytic step is likely to be a prerequisite for enzymatic activity, since agalacto-PST-1 isolated from Lec8 cells was functionally inactive. Our data describe a novel route of autocatalytic maturation of a glycosyltransferase and thereby provide a new basis for studies aimed at elucidating and influencing the catalytic functions of PST-1.     

Autocatalytic replication of a recombinant RNA

We demonstrate that a heterologous RNA sequence can be copied in vitro by Q beta replicase when it is inserted into a naturally occurring Q beta replicase template. A recombinant RNA was constructed by inserting decaadenylic acid between nucleotides 63 and 64 of MDV-1 (+) RNA, using phage T4 RNA ligase. The insert was located away from regions of the template known to be required for the binding of the replicase and for the initiation of product strand synthesis. To minimize the disruption of template structure, we inserted the heterologous sequence into a hairpin loop on the exterior of the molecule. Q beta replicase copied this recombinant RNA in vitro, and the complementary product strands served as templates for the synthesis of additional copies of the original recombinant RNA. The reaction was therefore autocatalytic and the amount of recombinant RNA increased exponentially. A 300-fold amplification of the recombinant RNA occurred within nine minutes. Insertion of biologically significant RNAs into the MDV-1 RNA sequence should allow them to be replicated autocatalytically.     

Autocatalytic peroxidation of ferrocytochrome c

1. Ferricytochrome c acts as a catalyst in the peroxidation of ferrocytochrome c thereby giving rise to an autocatalytic reaction.

2. The rate of the peroxidation reaction is proportional to the concentration of H₂O₂ and ferricytochrome c but is independent of the concentration of ferrocytochrome c in the concentration ranges studied.

3. Integration of the rate equation, d[c³⁺]/dt = k[c³⁺][H₂O₂], gives a theoretical expression which fits the experimental time courses for the ferrocytochrome c peroxidation reaction.

4. No direct spectral evidence was found for the formation of a catalytically active ferricytochrome c-H₂O₂ derivative. Kinetic evidence is presented, however, which indicates the existence of such an intermediate.

5. Ferricytochrome c was more susceptible than ferrocytochrome c to an apparent degradation reaction caused by excess H₂O₂, thus supporting the idea that the cytochrome c heme iron is more accessible in the oxidized form.     

Consistency matrices: quantified structure alignments for sets of related proteins

Comparing two remotely similar structures is a difficult problem: more often than not, resulting structure alignments will show ambiguities and a unique answer usually does not even exist. In addition, alignments in general have a limited information content because every aligned residue is considered equally important. To solve these issues to a certain extent, one can take the perspective of a whole group of similar structures and then evaluate common structural features. Here, we describe a consistency approach that, although not actually performing a multiple structure alignment, does produce the information that one would conceivably want from such an experiment: the key structural features of the group, e.g., a fold, which in this case are projected onto either a pair of proteins or a single protein. Both representations are useful for a number of applications, ranging from the detection of (partially) wrong structure alignments to protein structure classification and fold recognition. To demonstrate some of these applications, the procedure was applied to 195 SCOP folds containing a total of 1802 domains sharing very low sequence similarity.     

Autocatalytic degradation of proteins in extracts of a brewing strain of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The role of endoproteinases and exopeptidases

Summary Cells of a brewing strain of Saccharomyces cerevisiae NCYC 1109 were harvested after the end of fermentation, but before decline in viability had commenced, and extracted by passage through an Eaton press. Immediately after preparation the proteolytic enzymes PrA and CpY, but not PrB, could be detected in the extracts. After 24 h incubation at 25°C all three enzymes were found. PrA activity was unaffected by incubation whereas CpY activity increased up to threefold. Measurement of the release of acid-soluble material in the extracts themselves over an 18-h period at 25°C and a range of pH values using the Lowry and trinitrobenzoyl sulphonic acid methods, suggested that the endoprotease, PrB, was a major contributor to autocatalysis. Further studies using pepstatin, phenylmethylsulphonyl fluoride (PMSF), HgCl₂, EDTA, bestatin and ZnCl₂ confirmed the importance of PrB but also indicated that about 30% of the initial proteolytic degradation was due to another enzyme. This enzyme was inhibited by Zn²⁺ and Hg²⁺ but not by PMSF or pepstatin, and could be the recently characterised enzyme, PrE. Correspondence to: J. C. Slaughter     

Autocatalytic Processing of m-AAA Protease Subunits in Mitochondria

m-AAA proteases are ATP-dependent proteolytic machines in the inner membrane of mitochondria which are crucial for the maintenance of mitochondrial activities. Conserved nuclear-encoded subunits, termed paraplegin, Afg3l1, and Afg3l2, form various isoenzymes differing in their subunit composition in mammalian mitochondria. Mutations in different m-AAA protease subunits are associated with distinct neuronal disorders in human. However, the biogenesis of m-AAA protease complexes or of individual subunits is only poorly understood. Here, we have examined the processing of nuclear-encoded m-AAA protease subunits upon import into mitochondria and demonstrate autocatalytic processing of Afg3l1 and Afg3l2. The mitochondrial processing peptidase MPP generates an intermediate form of Afg3l2 that is matured autocatalytically. Afg3l1 or Afg3l2 are also required for maturation of newly imported paraplegin subunits after their cleavage by MPP. Our results establish that mammalian m-AAA proteases can act as processing enzymes in vivo and reveal overlapping activities of Afg3l1 and Afg3l2. These findings might be of relevance for the pathogenesis of neurodegenerative disorders associated with mutations in different m-AAA protease subunits.     

Autocatalytic enzyme system for amplification of light signals

High-sensitivity systems are considered in which a low trypsin (EC 3.4.21.4) concentration can be increased by several factors by means of an autoactivation reaction. This amplification of a catalyst makes it possible to reveal weak effects resulting in trypsin generation. For this purpose, the pH-dependent and light-sensitive systems inducing active trypsin have been studied in the presence of trypsinogen. The application of such systems to detect superweak light signals has been shown to be practicable.     

Autocatalytic nature of "slow virus infections"

A concept that considers the causative nature of the so-called "slow virus infections", causing syndromes of spongiform encephalopathies in man and animals as a chain autocatalytic process is put forward. According to this concept, PrP(27-30) protein, isolated recently from the brains of scrapie-infected animals, is a C-terminal domain of the normal protein component of brain tissue which is a latent zimogen. Certain clinical and experimental data are discussed within the framework of this concept. Exogenous proteinases are presumed to be capable of triggering such a chain autocatalytic process in the brains of susceptible animals. Indeed, in one of our experiments, a subtoxic dose of pronase injected into mouse brain induced the development of a syndrome indistinguishable from spongiform encephalopathy in its clinical and pathomorphological manifestations. The probable role of neuron-specific proteins of intermediate filaments in such pathological processes is discussed. It seems possible that spongiform encephalopathies are particular cases of pathological processes that have catalytic nature. Presumably, the Alzheimer disease has such a catalytic causative nature.