Kinetics of appearance and disappearance of light-induced EPR signals of P700 and iron-sulfur protein(s) at low temperature

Light-induced changes of EPR signals in Photosystem-I subchloroplast particles at temperatures between 225 and 13 °K showed that the rates of onset of photooxidation of P700 and photoreduction of iron-sulfur protein(s) are identical and instantaneous within the limits of resolution of our instruments. The fraction of the P700⁺ EPR signal that appears reversibly decreased with decreasing temperature down to 13 °K when the photoreaction was completely irreversible. At temperatures below 225 °K, the reversible fraction consists of two approximately equal portions with decay halftimes of approx. 3 and 75 s, respectively. Light-induced absorption changes due to P700 photooxidation at low temperatures monitored at 700 nm showed a similar kinetic pattern.

Since the reduced iron-sulfur protein signals can only be detected at very low temperature, their decay kinetics cannot be continuously monitored at higher temperatures. Therefore, exposure at appropriate temperatures and reaction times were selected according to the decay kinetics of P700⁺, after which decay was stopped by lowering the temperature to 13 °K and the P700⁺ and reduced iron-sulfur protein signals were recorded and compared. In the temperature range (225-13 °K) studied, the decay of P700⁺ and reduced iron-sulfur protein signals appears identical, suggesting that the two oppositely charged species recombine in the dark. These experiments support the view that iron-sulfur protein(s) is the reaction partner of P700 in the primary photochemical act of Photosystem I.     

Quantitative EPR studies of the primary reaction of Photosystem I in chloroplasts

Quantitative electron paramagnetic resonance studies of the primary event associated with Photosystem I in chloroplasts have been carried out at 25 °K. After illumination of either whole chloroplasts or Photosystem I subchloroplast fragments (D-144) with 715-nm actinic light at 25 °K, equal spin concentrations of oxidized P700 and reduced bound iron-sulfur protein (bound ferredoxin) have been measured. Quantitative determination of the concentration of these two carriers by EPR spectroscopy after illumination at low temperature indicates that Photosystem I fragments are enriched in P700 and the bound iron-sulfur protein as compared with unfractionated chloroplasts. These results indicate that P700 and the bound iron-sulfur protein function as the donor-acceptor complex of chloroplast Photosystem I.     

Evidence for the role of a bound ferredoxin as the primary electron acceptor of Photosystem I in spinach chloroplasts

The presence of a bound electron transport component in spinach chloroplasts with an EPR spectrum characteristic of a ferredoxin has been confirmed. The ferredoxin is photoreduced at 77 °K or at room temperature, it is not reduced in the dark by Na₂S₂O₄. The distribution of the ferredoxin in subchloroplast particles has been investigated. The ferredoxin is enriched in Photosystem I particles and it is proposed that it functions as primary electron acceptor for Photosystem I.

The EPR spectra indicate the presence of two components which are photoreduced sequentially. It is proposed that they may represent two active centres of a single protein.     

Photosystem I photochemistry at low temperature. Heterogeneity in pathways for electron transfer to the secondary acceptors and for recombination processes

Electron transport has been studied by flash absorption and EPR spectroscopies at 10–30 K in Photosystem I particles prepared with digitonin under different redox conditions. In the presence of ascorbate, an irreversible charge separation is progressively induced at 10 K between P-700 and iron-sulfur center A by successive laser flashes, up to a maximum which corresponds to about two-thirds of the reaction centers. In these centers, heterogeneity of the rate for center A reduction is also shown. In the other third of reaction centers, the charge separation is reversible and relaxes with a t_1/2 ≈ 120 μs. When the iron-sulfur centers A and B are prereduced, the 120 μs relaxation becomes the dominant process (70–80% of the reaction centers), while a slow component (t_1/2 = 50–400 ms) reflecting the recombination between P-700⁺ and center X⁻ occurs in a minority of reaction centers (10–15%). Flash absorption and EPR experiments show that the partner of P-700⁺ in the 120 μs recombination is neither X nor a chlorophyll but more probably the acceptor A⁻₁ as defined by Bonnerjea and Evans (Bonnerjea, J. and Evans, M.C.W. (1982) FEBS Lett. 148, 313–316). The role of center X in low-temperature electron flow is also discussed.     

Flash-induced charge separation and dark recombination in a Photosystem-II subchloroplast particle

The decay time of flash-induced absorption changes in a Photosystem-II subchloroplast fragment is very temperature sensitive down to 210 K, below which it remains constant at 1.25 ± 0.05 ms. The difference spectrum from the near-infra-red to the ultraviolet regions indicates that the monophasic decay represents charge recombination between P-680⁺ and the reduced primary acceptor. The charge recombination proceeds by electron tunneling. The P-680 concentration in the TSF-IIa fragment was estimated to be one in 30 ± 5 total chlorophyll molecules.     

Photochemical properties of a Photosystem II subchloroplast fragment

1. The Photosystem II fraction (D-10) obtained by incubation of spinach chloroplasts with digitonin was further purified by incubation with Triton X-100. The resulting Photosystem II subchloroplast fragment (DT-10) contained 1 mole of cytochrome b-559 per 170 moles of chlorophyll. It lacked cytochrome f and cytochrome b₆ and its content of P700 was low.

2. The DT-10 fragment showed only traces of photochemical activity with water as electron donor, but it was active in a Photosystem II reaction with 2,6-dichlorophenolindophenol as electron acceptor and diphenyl carbazide as donor. Photoreduction of NADP⁺ with diphenyl carbazide as donor was negligible. There was some photoreduction of NADP⁺ with ascorbate plus 2,6 dichlorophenolindophenol as donor but this activity could be accounted for by contamination with Photosystem I. These results are consistent with the Z-scheme of photosynthesis with Photosystems I and II operating in series for the reduction of NADP⁺ from water. DT-10 subchloroplast fragments showed a light-induced rise in fluorescence yield at 20 °C in the presence of diphenyl carbazide. A light-induced fluorescence increase also was observed at 77 °K.

3. During the preparation of the DT-10 fragment, the high potential form of cytochrome b-559 was largely converted to a form of lower potential and C-550 was converted to the reduced state. A photoreduction of C-550 was observed at liquidnitrogen temperature, provided the C-550 was oxidised with ferricyanide prior to cooling. Some photooxidation of cytochrome b-559 was obtained at 77 °K if the preparation was reduced prior to cooling, but the degree of photooxidation was variable with different preparations. C-550 does not appear to be identical with the primary fluorescence quencher, Q.

4. Photosystem I subchloroplast fragments (D-144) released by the action of digitonin were compared with Photosystem I fragments (DT-144) released from D-10 fragments by Triton X-100. There were no significant differences between D-144 and DT-144 fragments either in chlorophyll a/b ratio or in P700 content.     

Correlation of reaction-center chlorophyll (P-700) oxidation and bound iron-sulfur protein photoreduction in chloroplast Photosystem I at low temperatures

The extent of P-700 photooxidation at 18 °K has been followed in three different chloroplast preparations (unfractionated chloroplasts and two preparations enriched in Photosystem I). More than 90% of P-700⁺ formation in all preparations was eliminated by the addition of sodium dithionite at pH 10. Photoreduction of a bound chloroplast iron-sulfur protein was also decreased by at least 90% under similar conditions. Electron paramagnetic resonance spectra of the chloroplast preparations in the presence of dithionite showed chemical reduction of bound iron-sulfur protein under conditions where primary photochemistry is eliminated. These results indicate that P-700 photooxidation is concomitant with photoreduction of a bound iron-sulfur protein and that this iron-sulfur protein functions as the primary electron acceptor of Photosystem I.     

Electron paramagnetic resonance saturation studies of P-700 reaction center chlorophyll in plant photosynthesis

Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) power saturation and saturation recovery methods have been used to determine the spin lattice, T₁, and spin-spin, T₂, relaxation times of P-700⁺ reaction-center chlorophyll in Photosystem I of plant chloroplasts for 10 K T 100 K. T₁ was 200 μs at 100 K and increased to 900 μs at 10 K. T₂ was 40 ns at 40 K and increased to 100 ns at 10 K. T₁ for 40 K T 100 K is inversely proportional to temperature, which is evidence of a direct-lattice relaxation process. At T = 20 K, T₁ deviates from the 1/T dependence, indicating a cross relaxation process with an unidentified paramagnetic species. The individual effects of ascorbate and ferricyanide on T₁ of P-700⁺ were examined: T₁ of P-700⁺ was not affected by adding 10 mM ascorbate to digitonin-treated chloroplast fragments (D144 fragments). The P-700⁺ relaxation time in broken chloroplasts treated with 10 mM ferricyanide was 4-times shorter than in the untreated control at 40 K. Ferricyanide appears to be relaxing the P-700⁺ indirectly to the lattice by a cross-relaxation process. The possibility of dipolar-spin broadening of P-700⁺ due to either the iron-sulfur center A or plastocyanin was examined by determining the spin-packet linewidth for P-700⁺ when center A and plastocyanin were in either the reduced or oxidized states. Neither reduced center A nor oxidized plastocyanin was capable of broadening the spin-packet linewidth of the P-700⁺ signal. The absence of diplolar broadening indicates that both center A and plastocyanin are located at a distance at least 3.0 nm from the P-700⁺ reaction center chlorophyll. This evidence supports previous hypotheses that the electron donor and acceptor to P-700 are situated on opposite sides of the chloroplast membrane. It is also shown that the ratio of photo-oxidized P-700 to photoreduced centers A and B at low temperature is 2 : 1 if P-700 is monitored at a nonsaturating microwave power.     

Flash-induced absorption changes in Photosystem I,Radical pair or triplet state formation?

Absorption changes induced in chlorophyll protein (CP 1) particles by short laser flashes have been analyzed in order to decide whether a state lasting for a few microseconds at 21°C or 800 μs at 10 K corresponds to the biradical P-700⁺ ... A⁻₁ (A₁ being a chlorophyll a) or to a triplet state produced in a submicrosecond recombination of the preceding state. At 21°C the spectrum of the flash-induced ΔA (720–870 nm) presents a flat-topped band from 740 to 820 nm, clearly different from that of P-700⁺. A saturation curve (ΔA vs. laser energy), obtained with a 2 or 10 ns laser pulse, indicates that ΔA saturates at a value 2- or 3-times smaller than that expected on the basis of the chemical oxidation of P-700. At 21°C the size of flash-induced ΔA is slightly decreased (5–15%) when the sample is subjected to a 400 G magnetic field. The kinetics of decay are not affected; they are not affected either by the oxygen concentration. At 10 K the spectrum of the flash-induced ΔA has been measured between 650 and 1700 nm. Between 650 and 720 nm, the spectrum presents only one major negative peak at 702 nm; it is quite different from that due to the chemical oxidation of P-700 (which has additional peaks at 688 and 677 nm). Between 720 and 870 nm, the spectrum is identical to that obtained at 21°C. Above 870 nm, the spectrum includes a broad band around 1250 nm, which is absent in P-700⁺. A saturation curve leads to a maximum ΔA greater than that at 21°C and which is also greater with a 1 μs dye laser flash than with a 10 ns ruby laser flash. An analysis of the spectral data indicates that these do not fit correctly with the hypothesis of a contribution of P-700⁺ and of a chlorophyll a anion radical. They fit more closely with the hypothesis of a triplet state of P-700, a hypothesis which is discussed in relation to other experimental data.     

One-way electron discharge subsequent to the photochemical charge separation in Photosystem I

Subsequent to the photochemical charge separation in Photosystem I, three fates are possible: (a) recombination of the photooxidized P700⁺ and photoreduced P430⁻; (b) a cyclic electron flow involving P700⁺, P430⁻ and another electron carrier present in its oxidized and reduced forms; and (c) a non-cyclic electron flow involving one electron donor reacting with P700⁺ and another electron acceptor reacting with P430⁻. This note deals with a fourth fate which is brought about only when an autooxidizable secondary electron acceptor is present but the secondary electron donor is either absent or blocked. In this case, only P430⁻ reverts to the uncharged state in the dark by discharging its electron; P700⁺ remains oxidized and reverts to the uncharged state only extremely slowly.     

The effect of temperature on the primary reaction of chloroplast Photosystem II Evidence for a temperature-dependent back reaction

The primary reaction of Photosystem II has been studied over the temperature range from −196 to −20 °C. The photooxidation of the reaction-center chlorophyll (P680) was followed by the free-radical electron paramagnetic resonance signal of P680⁺, and the photoreduction of the Photosystem II primary electron acceptor was monitored by the C-550 absorbance change.

At temperatures below −100 °C, the primary reaction of Photosystem II is irreversible. However, at temperatures between −100 and −20 °C a back reaction that is insensitive to 3-(3′,4′-dichlorophenyl)-1,1′-dimethylurea (DCMU) occurs between P680⁺ and the reduced acceptor.

The amount of reduced acceptor and P680⁺ present under steady-state illumination at temperatures between −100 and −20 °C is small unless high light intensity is used to overcome the competing back reaction. The amount of reduced acceptor present at low light intensity can be increased by adjusting the oxidation-reduction potential so that P680⁺ is reduced by a secondary electron donor (cytochrome b₅₅₉) before P680⁺ can reoxidize the reduced primary acceptor. The photooxidation of cytochrome b₅₅₉ and the accompanying photoreduction of C-550 are inhibited by DCMU. The inhibition of C-550 photoreduction by DCMU, the dependence of P680 photooxidation and C-550 photoreduction on light intensity, and the effect of the availability of reduced cytochrome b₅₅₉ on C-550 photoreduction are unique to the temperature range where the Photosystem II primary reaction is reversible and are not observed at lower temperatures.     

Characteristics of thermoluminescence bands of intact leaves and isolated chloroplasts in relation to the watersplitting activity in photosynthesis

Plant materials (intact leaves, chloroplasts or subchloroplast particles) preilluminated at a low temperature (e.g. −60°C) were rapidly cooled to −196°C and then the luminescence emitted from the sample on raising the temperature was measured as a function of temperature, by means of a sensitive photo-electron counting technique. Mature spinach leaves showed five luminescence bands at different temperatures which were denoted as Z_v, A, B₁, B₂ and C bands. The A, B₁, B₂ and C bands appeared at constant temperatures, −10, +25, +40 and +55°C, respectively, being independent of the illumination temperature, but the Z_v band appeared at a variable temperature slightly higher than the illumination temperature. The B₁ and B₂ bands were absent in the thermoluminescence profiles of samples devoid of the oxygenevolving activity, such as heat-treated spinach leaves, wheat leaves greened under intermittent illumination and photosystem-II particles prepared with Triton X-100. It was deduced that these luminescence bands arise from the energy stored by the electron flow in photosystem II to evolve oxygen, and other bands were ascribed to charge-separation in some other sites not related to the oxygen evolving system.     

Electrochemical and spectro-kinetic evidence for an intermediate electron acceptor in Photosystem I

Absorption changes accompanying light-induced P-700⁺ formation and its decay in the dark at 15 K in Photosystem-I particles poised at various redox potentials have been examined. In unpoised samples, the light-induced absorption change is practically irreversible. At increasingly negative potentials, an increasing fraction of the absorption change, proportional to the fraction of bound iron-sulfur protein chemically reduced, becomes reversible, and the titration curve has a midpoint potential of −530 mV (vs. normal hydrogen electrode). At −666 mV, the P-700 absorption change is 97% reversible. The total P-700-signal amplitude decreases over the same potential span and levels off at about 43% (to slightly over 50% at a substantially higher excitation intensity). These results provide additional support to previous suggestions of an existence of an intermediate electron acceptor located between the primary donor, P-700, and the more stable primary electron acceptor (P-430 or bound iron-sulfur protein).     

Rate of electron transfer between plastocyanin, cytochrome ƒ, related proteins and artificial redox reagents in solution

The rate of electron transfer between reduced cytochrome ƒ and plastocyanin (both purified from parsley) has been measured as k = 3.6 · 10⁷ M⁻¹ · s⁻¹, at 298 °K and pH 7.0, with activation parameters ΔH^‡ = 44 kJ · mole⁻¹ and ΔS^‡ = +46 J · mole⁻¹ · °K⁻¹. Replacement of cytochrome ƒ with red algal cytochrome c-553, Pseudomonas cytochrome c-551 and mammalian cytochrome c gave rates at least 30 times slower: k = 5 · 10⁵, 7.5 · 10⁵ and 1.0 · 10⁶ M⁻¹ · s⁻¹, respectively.

Similar measurements made with azurin instead of plastocyanin gave k = 6 · 10⁶ and approx. 2 · 10⁷ M⁻¹ · s⁻¹ for reaction of reduced azurin with cytochrome ƒ and algal cytochrome respectively.

Rate constants of 115 and 80 M⁻¹ · s⁻¹ were found for reduction of plastocyanin by ascorbate and hydroquinone at 298 °K and pH 7.0. The rate constants for the oxidation of plastocyanin, cytochrome ƒ, Pseudomonas cytochrome c-551 and red algal cytochrome c-553 by ferricyanide were found to be between 3 · 10⁴ and 8 · 10⁴ M⁻¹ · s⁻¹.

The results are discussed in relation to photosynthetic electron transport.     

Light-induced absorbance changes in chloroplasts mediated by Photosystem I and Photosystem II at low temperature

Stable light-induced absorbance changes in chloroplasts at −196 °C were measured across the visible spectrum from 370 to 730 nm in an effort to find previously undiscovered absorbance changes that could be related to the primary photochemical activity of Photosystem I or Photosystem II. A Photosystem I mediated absorbance increase of a band at 690 nm and a Photosystem II mediated absorbance increase of a band at 683 nm were found. The 690-nm change accompanied the oxidation of P₇₀₀ and the 683-nm increase accompanied the reduction of C-550. No Soret band was detected for P₇₀₀.

A specific effort was made to measure the difference spectrum for the photooxidation of P₆₈₀ under conditions (chloroplasts frozen to −196 °C in the presence of ferricyanide) where a stable, Photosystem II mediated EPR signal, attributed to P₆₈₀⁺ has been reported. The difference spectra, however, did not show that P₆₈₀⁺ was stable at −196 °C under any conditions tested. Absorbance measurements induced by saturating flashes at −196 °C (in the presence or absence of ferricyanide) indicated that all of the P₆₈₀⁺ formed by the flash was reduced in the dark either by a secondary electron donor or by a backreaction with the primary electron acceptor. We conclude that P₆₈₀⁺ is not stable in the dark at −196 °C: if the normal secondary donor at −196 °C is oxidized by ferricyanide prior to freezing, P₆₈₀⁺ will oxidize other substances.     

Electron donation in Photosystem II

The electron transfer resulting from illumination and dark storage of PS II has been studied using EPR signals from several electron carriers. The recombination of D⁺ (Signal II) and Q⁻_A formed by illumination occurred during dark storage at 77 K and was used to deplete reaction centres of D⁺. The donor D was then shown to be oxidized in the dark by the S₂ state of the oxygen-evolving complex. A slow change which occurred during dark storage of PS II samples was detected using the power saturation characteristics of D. We interpret this effect on D to be an indirect result of a rearrangement of the manganese complex during long-term dark adaptation. A role for D in the stability, protection and perhaps initial manganese binding of the oxygen-evolving complex is suggested.     

Photosystem I charge separation in the absence of centers A and B. II. ESR spectral characterization of center 'X' and correlation with optical signal 'A2'

The Photosystem I electron acceptor complex was characterized by optical flash photolysis and electron spin resonance (ESR) spectroscopy after treatment of a subchloroplast particle with lithium dodecyl sulfate (LDS). The following properties were observed after 60 s of incubation with 1% LDS followed by rapid freezing. (i) ESR centers A and B were not observed during or after illumination of the sample at 19 K, although the P-700+ radical at g = 2.0026 showed a large, reversible light-minus-dark difference signal. (ii) Center 'X', characterized by g factors of 2.08, 1.88 and 1.78, exhibited reversible photoreduction at 8 K in the absence of reduced centers A and B. (iii) The backreaction kinetics at 8 K between P-700, observed at g = 2.0026, and center X, observed at g = 1.78, was 0.30 s. (iv) The amplitudes of the reversible g = 2.0026 radical observed at 19 K and the 1.2 ms optical 698 nm transient observed at 298 K were diminished to the same extent when treated with 1% LDS at room temperature for periods of 1 and 45 min. We interpret the strict correlation between the properties and lifetimes of the optical P-700+ A2 reaction pair and the ESR P-700+ center X- reaction pair to indicate that signal A2 and center X represent the same iron-sulfur center in Photosystem I.     

A reversible NO complex of Fe(TIM): an S = 1/2FeNO nitrosyl

[Fe(TIM)(CH₃CN)₂](PF₆)₂ (1) (TIM = 2,3,9,10-tetramethyl-1,4,8,11-tetraazacyclodeca-1,3,8,10-tetraene) forms a complex with NO reversibly in CH₃CN (53±1% converted to the NO complex) or 60% CH₃OH/40% CH₃CN (81±1% conversion). Quantitative NO complexation occurs in H₂O or CH₃OH solvents. The EPR spectrum of [Fe(TIM)(solvent)NO]²⁺ in frozen 60/40 CH₃OH/CH₃CN at 77 K shows a three line feature at g=2.01, 1.99 and 1.97 of an S=1/2FeNO⁷ ground state. The middle line exhibits a three-line N-shf coupling of 24 G indicating a six-coordinate complex with either CH₃OH or CH₃CN as a ligand trans to NO. In H₂O [Fe(TIM)(H₂O)₂]²⁺ undergoes a slow decomposition, liberating 2,3-butanedione, as detected by ¹H NMR in D₂O, unless a π-acceptor axial ligand, L=CO, CH₃CN or NO is present. An equilibrium of 1 in water containing CH₃CN forms [Fe(TIM)(CH₃CN)(H₂O)]²⁺ which has a formation constant K_CH3CN=320 M⁻¹. In water K_NOK_CH3CN since NO completely displaces CH₃CN. [Fe(TIM)(CH₃CN)₂]²⁺ binds either CO or NO in CH₃CN with K_NO/K_CO=0.46, sigificantly lower than the ratio for [Fe^II(hemes)] of 1100 in various media. A steric influence due to bumping of β-CH₂ protons of the TIM macrocycle with a bent S=1/2 nitrosyl as opposed to much lessened steric factors for the linear Fe---CO unit is proposed to explain the lower K_NO/K_CO ratio for the [Fe(TIM)(CH₃CN)]²⁺ adducts of NO or CO. Estimates for formation constants with [Fe(TIM)]²⁺ in CH₃CN of K_NO=80.1 M⁻¹ and K_CO=173 M⁻ are much lower than to hemoglobin (where K_NO=2.5×10¹⁰ M⁻¹ and K_CO=2.3×10⁷) due to a reversal of steric factors and stronger π-backdonation from [Fe^II(heme)] than from [Fe^II(TIM)(CH₃CN)]²⁺.     

Primary reactions, plastoquinone and fluorescence yield in subchloroplast fragments prepared with deoxycholate

1. In subchloroplast fragments prepared with the detergent deoxycholate the primary reactions of Photosystem II could be studied at room temperature, because the secondary reactions were largely or completely inhibited.

2. The main quencher of chlorophyll fluorescence in these particles was the photosynthetically active pool of plastoquinone in its oxidized form. Its photoreduction in the presence of artificial electron donors was accompanied by a shift of a chlorophyll a absorption band. Its reoxidation in the dark was very slow, even in the presence of ferricyanide.

3. Of all the artificial electron donors tested MnCl₂ was by far the most efficient.

4. Measurements at room temperature of the C550 absorbance change confirmed its correlation with the primary electron acceptor. Its difference spectrum was broader and its extinction coefficient correspondingly lower than at liquid-N₂ temperature. In chloroplasts the C550 concentration was about 1:360 chlorophylls.

5. In the dark C550 was largely in the reduced state and its oxidation by plastoquinone took place in the presence of an artificial electron donor only, suggesting that the redox potential of C550 was increased by accumulated positive charges at the donor side of the reaction center.

6. The free radical 1,1′-diphenyl-2-picrylhydrazyl oxidized C550 directly in a 3-(3,4-dichlorophenyl)-1,1-dimethylurea (DCMU)-insensitive reaction. A DCMU-insensitive oxidation of C550 was observed at high ferricyanide concentrations as well, but probably in this case an endogenous electron donor was oxidized, which in turn oxidized C550 via the back reaction of the photochemical reaction.

7. The oxidized form of the primary electron donor, P680⁺, accumulated in the light in the presence of deoxycholate and a low ferricyanide concentration. In chloroplasts the P680 concentration was about 1:360 chlorophylls.

8. The P 680 absorption difference spectrum and electron spin resonance could be explained by the oxidation of a chlorophyll a dimer. Repeated deoxycholate treatments progressively changed the spectra to those of a monomer. The monomer was still photochemically active.

9. A new interpretation of the difference spectrum of P700 is proposed: it may be the same as that of the difference spectrum of P680 if the bleaching at 700 nm is attributed to a band shift.     

Electron spin polarization in photosynthesis and the mechanism of electron transfer in photosystem I. Experimental observations.

Transient electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) methods are used to examine the spin populations of the light-induced radicals produced in spinach chloroplasts, photosystem I particles, and Chlorella pyrenoidosa. We observe both emission and enhanced absorption within the hyperfine structure of the EPR spectrum of P700+, the photooxidized reaction-center chlorophyll radical (Signal I). By using flow gradients or magnetic fields to orient the chloroplasts in the Zeeman field, we are able to influence both the magnitude and sign of the spin polarization. Identification of the polarized radical and P700+ is consistent with the effects of inhibitors, excitation light intensity and wavelength, redox potential, and fractionation of the membranes. The EPR signal of the polarized P700+ radical displays a 30% narrower line width than P700+ after spin relaxation. This suggests a magnetic interaction between P700+ and its reduced (paramagnetic) acceptor, which leads to a collapse of the P700+ hyperfine structure. Narrowing of the spectrum is evident only in the spectrum of polarized P700+, because prompt electron transfer rapidly separates the radical pair. Evidence of cross-relaxation between the adjacent radicals suggests the existence of an exchange interaction. The results indicate that polarization is produced by a radical pair mechanism between P700+ and the reduced primary acceptor of photosystem I. The orientation dependence of the spin polarization of P700+ is due to the g-tensor anisotropy of the acceptor radical to which it is exchange-coupled. The EPR spectrum of P700+ is virtually isotropic once the adjacent acceptor radical has passed the photoionized electron to a later, more remote acceptor molecule. This interpretation implies that the acceptor radical has g-tensor anisotropy significantly greater than the width of the hyperfine field on P700+ and that the acceptor is oriented with its smallest g-tensor axis along the normal to the thylakoid membranes. Both the ferredoxin-like iron-sulfur centers and the X- species observed directly by EPR at low temperatures have g-tensor anisotropy large enough to produce the observed spin polarization; however, studies on oriented chloroplasts show that the bound ferredoxin centers do not have this orientation of their g tensors. In contrast, X- is aligned with its smallest g-tensor axis predominantly normal to the plane of the thylakoid membranes. This is the same orientation predicted for the acceptor radical based on analysis of the spin polarization of P700+, and indicates that the species responsible for the anisotropy of the polarized P700+ spectrum is probably X-. The dark EPR Signal II is shown to possess anisotropic hyperfine structure (and possibly g-tensor anisotropy), which serves as a good indicator of the extent of membrane alignment.