Integration of environmental stimuli in the migratory orientation of the savannah sparrow (Passerculus sandwichensis)

Two ‘cue-conflict’ experiments were designed to evaluate the role of (1) solar cues at sunset and stars, and (2) solar cues at sunset and geomagnetic stimuli, in the migratory orientation of the savannah sparrow (Passerculus sandwichensis). A sunset and stars experiment exposed birds in the experimental group to a mirror-reflected sunset followed by an unmanipulated view of stars. Experimental birds shifted their migratory activity in accordance with the setting sun despite exposure to a normal night sky. The sunset and geomagnetism experiment exposed birds in the experimental group to a simultaneous shift in both the position of sunset and the earth's magnetic field. Again experimentals shifted their activity in accordance with the setting sun rather than the artificially shifted magnetic field. Savannah sparrows probaly use stars as celestial landmarks to maintain a preferred direction and do not reorient their activity when exposed to an alternative cue once a direction is established. Moreover, savannah sparrows with experience of migration do not require geomagnetic information in order to use the solar cues available at sunset to select a migratory direction.     

Shifted magnetic fields lead to deflected and axial orientation of migrating robins,Erithacus rubecula,at sunset

The migratory orientation of the robin was tested in shifted magnetic fields during the twilight period after sunset, under clear skies and under simulated total overcast. The horizontal direction of the geomagnetic field was shifted 90° to the right or left in relation to the local magnetic field, without changing either the intensity of the field or its angle of inclination. Experiments were conducted during both spring and autumn, with robins captured as passage migrants at the Falsterbo and Ottenby bird observatories in southern Sweden as test subjects. Generally, the orientation of robins was affected by magnetic shifts compared to controls tested in the natural geomagnetic field. Autumn birds from the two capture sites differed in their responses, probably because of different migratory dispositions and body conditions. The robins most often changed their orientation to maintain their typical axis of migration relative to the shifted magnetic fields. However, preferred directions in relation to the shifted magnetic fields were frequently reverse from normal, or axial rather than unimodal. These results disagree with suggested mechanisms for orientation by visual sunset cues and with the proposed basis of magnetic orientation. They do, however, demonstrate that the geomagnetic field is involved in the sunset orientation of robins, probably in combination with additional visual or non-visual cues that contribute to establish magnetic polarity.     

Orientation in pied flycatchers: the relative importance of magnetic and visual information at dusk

We investigated the orientation of juvenile pied flycatchers, Ficedula hypoleuca, during autumn migration in south Sweden using orientation cage experiments, to study the relative importance of visual and magnetic information at sunset. We performed cage tests under 12 experimental conditions that manipulated the geomagnetic and visual sunset cues available for orientation: natural clear skies in the local or a vertical magnetic field; simulated total overcast in the local or a vertical magnetic field; natural pattern of skylight polarization and directional information from stars screened off, with the sun's position as normal or shifted 120 degrees anticlockwise with mirrors; reduced polarization in the local or a vertical magnetic field; directions of polarization (e-vector) NE/SW and NW/SE, respectively, in the local or a vertical magnetic field. The pied flycatchers were significantly oriented towards slightly south of west when they could use a combination of skylight and geomagnetic cues. The mean orientation was significantly shifted along with the deflection of the sunset position by mirrors. Reduced polarization had no significant effect on orientation either in the local, or in a vertical, magnetic field. The birds tended to orient parallel with the axis of polarization, but only when the artificial e-vector was aligned NW/SE. The mean orientation under simulated total overcast in a vertical, and in the local, magnetic field was not significantly different from random. It is difficult to rank either cue as dominant over the other and we conclude that both visual and magnetic cues seem to be important for the birds' orientation when caught and tested during active migration. Copyright 1999 The Association for the Study of Animal Behaviour.     

Sunset and the orientation of European robins (Erithacus rubecula)

The migratory orientation of European robins (Erithacus rubecula) in autumn was tested immediately after sunset and also after the beginning of astronomical darkness. In twilight tests under clear skies, the birds selected an appropriate migratory direction. During the course of autumn, along with the shift of sunset azimuth, the orientation of birds also shifted, always in a counter-clockwise direction. Although this shift of orientation was not statistically significant, the difference between the mean direction and the sunset was the same for each autumn period. This suggests that the migratory direction was selected on the basis of menotactic orientation re the setting sun. Random directions were observed under solid overcast skies as well as during tests under starry skies, begun after all trace of the sunset position had disappeared.     

Avian orientation at steep angles of inclination: experiments with migratory white-crowned sparrows at the magnetic North Pole

The Earth's magnetic field and celestial cues provide animals with compass information during migration. Inherited magnetic compass courses are selected based on the angle of inclination, making it difficult to orient in the near vertical fields found at high geomagnetic latitudes. Orientation cage experiments were performed at different sites in high Arctic Canada with adult and young white-crowned sparrows (Zonotrichia leucophrys gambelii) in order to investigate birds' ability to use the Earth's magnetic field and celestial cues for orientation in naturally very steep magnetic fields at and close to the magnetic North Pole. Experiments were performed during the natural period of migration at night in the local geomagnetic field under natural clear skies and under simulated total overcast conditions. The experimental birds failed to select a meaningful magnetic compass course under overcast conditions at the magnetic North Pole, but could do so in geomagnetic fields deviating less than 3 degrees from the vertical. Migratory orientation was successful at all sites when celestial cues were available.     

Orientation of Dunnocks (Prunella modularis) at Sunset

To find out the relative importance of the geomagnetic and solar cues for the orientation at the time of sunset, dunnocks were tested outdoors during the spring migration periods of 1982 and 1983. Experimental magnetic fields were produced by Helmholtz coils. In the various magnetic conditions, the following results were obtained:

• 1 In the local geomagnetic field, the dunnocks oriented in a seasonally appropriate northerly direction.
• 2 In a magnetic field the north of which was shifted 120° clock-wise to ESE, the birds showed a corresponding shift in their orientation.
• 3 In a vertical magnetic field without meaningful directional information, birds previously tested in either the local geomagnetic field or the shifted magnetic field now displayed axially bimodal orientation, with the axes of the two groups differing.

These findings indicate that for migratory dunnocks, the magnetic field plays a dominant role in determining their orientation at the time of sunset, and that magnetic information may affect the dunnocks' response to other directional, presumably solar cues as well.     

Orientation Cage and Release Experiments with Migratory Wheatears (Oenanthe oenanthe) in Scandinavia and Greenland: The Importance of Visual Cues

Migratory orientation of Scandinavian and Greenland wheatears was recorded during the autumn migration periods of 1988 and 1989. Orientation cage tests were conducted under clear sunset skies, to investigate the importance of different visible sky sections on orientation performance. In addition, wheatears were released under clear starry skies and under total overcast to examine the orientation of free-flying birds. The following results were obtained:

• 1 Wheatears tested with a restricted visible sky section (90° centered around zenith) in orientation cages, showed a mean orientation towards geographic W/geomagnetic NW (Greenland) and towards geographic and magnetic WNW-NW (Sweden). These mean directions are clearly inconsistent with the expected autumn migration directions, SW-SSW in Scandinavia and SE in Greenland, as revealed by ringing recoveries for the two populations.
• 2 When the birds were allowed a much more extensive view of the sky, almost down to the horizon (above 10° elevation), Scandinavian wheatears chose headings in agreement with ringing data. Greenland birds were not significantly oriented.
• 3 Release experiments under clear starry skies resulted in mean vanishing directions in good agreement with ringing data from both sites. Greenland wheatears released under total overcast showed a similar orientation as under clear skies, indicating that a view of the stars may not be of crucial importance for selecting a seasonally accurate migratory direction.

The results suggest that an unobstructed view of the sky, including visual cues low over the horizon, is important, possibly in combination with geomagnetic cues, for the orientation of migratory naive wheatears. Furthermore, the birds showed remarkably similar orientation responses in Greenland and Scandinavia, respectively, indicating that they use basically the same orientation system, despite considerable differences in visual and geomagnetic orientation premises at the two different geographic and magnetic latitudes.     

Magnetic information calibrates celestial cues during migration

Migratory birds use celestial and geomagnetic directional information to orient on their way between breeding and wintering areas. Cue-conflict experiments involving these two orientation cue systems have shown that directional information can be transferred from one system to the other by calibration. We designed experiments with four species of North American songbirds to: (1) examine whether these species calibrate orientation information from one system to the other; and (2) determine whether there are species-specific differences in calibration. Migratory orientation was recorded with two different techniques, cage tests and free-flight release tests, during autumn migration. Cage tests at dusk in the local geomagnetic field revealed species-specific differences: red-eyed vireo, Vireo olivaceus, and northern waterthrush, Seiurus noveboracensis, selected seasonally appropriate southerly directions whereas indigo bunting, Passerina cyanea, and grey catbird, Dumetella carolinensis, oriented towards the sunset direction. When tested in deflected magnetic fields, vireos and waterthrushes responded by shifting their orientation according to the deflection of the magnetic field, but buntings and catbirds failed to show any response to the treatment. In release tests, all four species showed that they had recalibrated their star compass on the basis of the magnetic field they had just experienced in the cage tests. Since release tests were done in the local geomagnetic field it seems clear that once the migratory direction is determined, most likely during the twilight period, the birds use their recalibrated star compass for orientation at departure. Copyright 2000 The Association for the Study of Animal Behaviour.     

Mechanisms of dusk orientation in white-throated sparrows (Zonotrichia albicollis): Clock-shift experiments

Summary Several species of night migrating birds, especially North American emberizines, exhibit markedly different orientation behaviour when tested in circular cages under clear skies at dusk as compared with tests performed after complete darkness. During the period between sunset and the first appearance of stars, birds tend to show high levels of well-oriented hopping; birds deprived of exposure to clear skies at dusk hop less and their activity is usually not oriented. There is evidence that visual cues available during the dusk period, but not later, are responsible for this difference, but details of the orientation mechanisms involved are unclear. We performed 3-h fast and slow clock shifts on white-throated sparrows (Zonotrichia albicollis) to address two questions concerning migratory orientation at dusk: (1) Is the better orientation of sparrows tested at dusk a function of the visual cues available at that time, or does it result from circadian changes in motivation?; and (2) Is the dusk orientation based on a time-compensated sun compass?Sparrows subjected to a 3-h slow clock shift were tested with controls on clear, moonless nights beginning immediately after lights-off in the clock shift room and thus about 3.5 h after local sunset. Individuals of both groups performed poorly oriented hopping typical of tests performed after complete darkness. The pooled data from each group were not significantly oriented. These results show that the visual cues available shortly after sunset, not temporal changes in the motivation of the birds, are responsible for the qualitative differences in orientation.Birds exposed to a 3-h fast clock shift were tested with controls on clear evenings between sunset and the first appearance of stars. Both groups showed well-oriented hopping. The mean direction of the pooled tests of controls was 325°, a typical spring orientation direction for this species. The mean direction of the pooled tests of the clock shifted birds (274°) was significantly different from that of controls and the 51° counterclockwise shift is consistent with that predicted by a time-compensated sun compass model.     

Magnetic Orientation in the Savannah Sparrow

Although magnetic compass orientation has been reported in a number of invertebrate and vertebrate taxa, including about a dozen migratory bird species, magnetic orientation capabilities in animals remain somewhat controversial. We have hand-raised a large number of Savannah sparrows (Passerculus sandwichensis) to study the ontogeny of orientation behavior. Young birds with a variety of early experience with visual and magnetic orientation cues have been tested for magnetic orientation during their first autumn migration. Here we present data from 80 hand-raised sparrows, each tested several times in both normal and shifted magnetic fields. Birds reared indoors with no experience with visual orientation cues showed axial north-south orientation that shifted by almost exactly the magnitude of 90° clockwise and counterclockwise shifts in the direction of magnetic north. Other groups of birds with varying early experience with visual orientation cues showed different preferred orientation directions, but all groups shifted orientation direction in response to shifts in the magnetic field. The data thus demonstrate a robust magnetic orientation ability in this species.     

The Influence of Fat Stores on Magnetic Orientation in Day-migrating Chaffinch,Fringilla coelebs

Earlier experimental studies have demonstrated the ability of day-migrating birds to perform migration under overcast skies, thereby indicating use of cues other than solar. The orientation behaviour of the chaffinch, a diurnal migrant, was investigated in orientation cage experiments during the autumn migration period. The aim of our experiments was to examine the relationship between different orientation cues and the influence of body condition on directional choices. We obtained the following results: 1. Chaffinches displayed a bimodal distribution of headings along a SW-NE axis when tested in the local geomagnetic field (controls); 2. When the geomagnetic field was experimentally deflected 90° counterclockwise, the chaffinches responded by changing their preferred axial orientation to SE-NW; and 3. The predictive power of stored fat reserves became evident when both the control and experimental samples were subdivided into fat and lean individuals. The majority of fat controls orientated towards a seasonally appropriate SW direction, whereas lean controls chose mean directions towards the NE. Experimentals followed the same pattern, but with the expected deflection, i.e. fat birds selected SE headings and lean individuals chose a NW mean direction.     

Solar cues in the migratory orientation of the Savannah sparrow, Passerculus sandwichensis

Results clearly implicate the setting sun as a critical source of directional information in the migratory orientation of the savannah sparrow, Passerculus sandwichensis. Savannah sparrows allowed a view of both sunset and stars displayed oriented behaviour in biologically meaningful directions during spring and fall seasons. When the same individuals were denied a view of sunset, and tested under the stars alone, disorientation characterized their behaviour. Furthermore, birds allowed a view of sunset, but tested under ‘overcast’ night skies (no stars visible), displayed well-oriented behaviour indicating the sufficiency of sunset. Experiments in which the migrant's internal chronometer was shifted suggested a fixed-angle (menotactic) response to the sunset cue rather than a time-compensating compass mechanism. I believe stars are valuable to this migrant as celestial reference points. Orientational information gained at the time of sunset is transferred to stars on a nightly basis. The relationship between solar and stellar cues is apparently hierarchical in the savannah sparrow. Information necessary to select the appropriate migratory direction is gained from the primary cue, the setting sun, while maintenance of that heading is dependent on a secondary cue, probably the stars.     

Compass orientation and possible migration routes of passerine birds at high arctic latitudes

The use of celestial or geomagnetic orientation cues can lead migratory birds along different migration routes during the migratory journeys, e.g. great circle routes (approximate), geographic or magnetic loxodromes. Orientation cage experiments have indicated that migrating birds are capable of detecting magnetic compass information at high northern latitudes even at very steep angles of inclination. However, starting a migratory journey at high latitudes and following a constant magnetic course often leads towards the North Magnetic Pole, which means that the usefulness of magnetic compass orientation at high latitudes may be questioned. Here, we compare possible long‐distance migration routes of three species of passerine migrants breeding at high northern latitudes. The initial directions were based on orientation cage experiments performed under clear skies and simulated overcast and from release experiments under natural overcast skies. For each species we simulated possible migration routes (geographic loxodrome, magnetic loxodrome and sun compass route) by extrapolating from the initial directions and assessing a fixed orientation according to different compass mechanisms in order to investigate what orientation cues the birds most likely use when migrating southward in autumn. Our calculations show that none of the compass mechanisms (assuming fixed orientation) can explain the migration routes followed by night‐migrating birds from their high Nearctic breeding areas to the wintering sites further south. This demonstrates that orientation along the migratory routes of arctic birds (and possibly other birds as well) must be a complex process, involving different orientation mechanisms as well as changing compass courses. We propose that birds use a combination of several compass mechanisms during a migratory journey with each of them being of a greater or smaller importance in different parts of the journey, depending on environmental conditions. We discuss reasons why birds developed the capability to use magnetic compass information at high northern latitudes even though following these magnetic courses for any longer distance will lead them along totally wrong routes. Frequent changes and recalibrations of the magnetic compass direction during the migratory journey are suggested as a possible solution.     

Magnetic versus celestial cues: cue-conflict experiments with migrating silvereyes at dusk

To assess the relative importance of celestial and magnetic cues for orientation at dusk, Australian silvereyes, Zosterops l. lateralis, were subjected to artificial magnetic fields under the natural evening sky, beginning 30 min before sunset. Control birds tested in the local geomagnetic field preferred their normal south-southwesterly migratory direction. Birds tested in a magnetic field with north deflected counterclockwise to 240°WSW showed northeasterly tendencies from the first test onward. Birds subjected to a corresponding clockwise deflection to 120°ESE, in contrast, first showed southerly directions, but from the 7th test onward shifted towards the northwest. Hence, both experimental groups followed the shift in magnetic north, one immediately, the other after a delay. When the birds were later tested in a vertical magnetic field without directional information, the two experimental groups continued in the direction they had preferred in the artificial magnetic fields, presumably by celestial cues alone. This indicates that they had not simply ignored celestial cues, but had recalibrated them according to the altered magnetic fields. The reasons for the initial difference between the two experimental groups remain unclear. Delayed responses to deflections of magnetic north have also been observed in previous studies. They appear to be the main reason why studies that expose birds only once to a cue-conflict situation often seem to indicate a dominance of celestial cues, whereas studies exposing the birds repeatedly usually indicate a dominance of magnetic cues. Accepted: 17 September 1997     

Why do migrating robins,Erithacus rubecula,captured at two nearby stop-over sites orient differently?

The orientation of robins captured during autumn and spring migration at two different sites, Falsterbo and Ottenby, in southern Sweden was investigated by cage experiments during the twilight period after sunset. The robins were tested under clear skies with skylight from sunset visible, and under simulated total overcast. The robins from the two sites differed in orientation, especially during autumn migration. While robins from Ottenby generally oriented in their expected migratory direction, the birds from Falsterbo under clear skies oriented towards the sunset direction with a narrow scatter in individual mean headings. Under simulated total overcast the robins from Falsterbo perferred northerly directions in autumn. Short-distance recoveries, one or only a few days after ringing, show that robins in autumn regularly fly 20–80 km from Falsterbo on northerly courses, indicating that they have temporarily reoriented from their normal migratory direction when confronted with the Baltic Sea. In contrast, most robins arrive at Ottenby by extensive flights across the Baltic Sea, and rapidly continue their sea crossing in the normal migratory directions. Mean fat deposits in autumn robins were significantly larger at Ottenby than at Falsterbo. These results indicate that migrating birds may show markedly different orientational dispositions depending on body condition and on their situation with respect to preceding and impending migration over land and sea, respectively.     

The Direction of Celestial Rotation Affects the Development of Migratory Orientation in Pied Flycatchers,Ficedula hypoleuca

The migratory direction in young passerine migrants is based on innate information, with the geomagnetic field and celestial rotation as references. To test whether the direction of celestial rotation is of importance, hand-raised pied flycatchers in Latvia were exposed during the premigratory period to a planetarium rotating in different directions. During autumn migration, when their orientation behavior was recorded in the local geomagnetic field in the absence of celestial cues, birds that had been exposed to a sky rotating in the natural direction showed a unimodal preference of their south-westerly migratory direction. Birds that had been exposed to a sky rotating in the reversed direction, in contrast, showed a bimodal preference of an axis south-west-north-east. Their behavior was similar to that of pied flycatchers that had been raised without access to celestial cues. In Latvia, the magnetic field alone allows only orientation along the migratory axis, and celestial rotation enables birds to select the correct end of this axis. Our findings show that the direction of rotation is of crucial importance: celestial rotation is effective only if the stars move in the natural direction.     

Manipulations of polarized skylight calibrate magnetic orientation in a migratory bird

1. Young migratory birds enter the world with two representations of the migratory direction, one coded with respect to the magnetic field, the other with respect to celestial rotation. The preferred magnetic direction of migratory orientation is malleable early in life: it may be calibrated by celestial rotation, observed either in daytime or at night.
2. Previous experiments showed that early experience with skylight polarization was necessary for calilbration to occur in daytime. In this study, we performed a direct manipulation of patterns of polarized skylight at dawn and dusk.
3. Hand-raised Savannah sparrows (Passerculus sandwichensis) were allowed to observe the clear sky for 1 h prior to local sunrise and for one h following local sunset. They never saw the Sun nor stars. The birds observed the sky through bands of polarizing material (HNP'B) aligned with the e-vector axis in one of three orientations with respect of the azimuth of sunrise and sunset: group 1) 90°; group 2) 45° CW; group 3) 45° CCW.
4. Tested indoors in covered cages in both shifted and unshifted magnetic fields, the autumn migratory orientation of the three groups differed significantly. Group 1 oriented magnetic N-S, group 2 oriented magnetic NW-SE, and group 3 oriented magnetic NNE-SSW. These observed orientation directions are very close to those predicted by the manipulations of polarized skylight.
5. These results indicated that a fairly simplified, static polarized light pattern viewed a limited number of times only in dawn and dusk snapshots is sufficient to produce calibration of the preferred magnetic migratory orientation direction.

     

Dramatic orientation shift of white-crowned sparrows displaced across longitudes in the high Arctic

Advanced spatial-learning adaptations have been shown for migratory songbirds, but it is not well known how the simple genetic program encoding migratory distance and direction in young birds translates to a navigation mechanism used by adults. A number of convenient cues are available to define latitude on the basis of geomagnetic and celestial information, but very few are useful to defining longitude. To investigate the effects of displacements across longitudes on orientation, we recorded orientation of adult and juvenile migratory white-crowned sparrows, Zonotrichia leucophrys gambelii, after passive longitudinal displacements, by ship, of 266-2862 km across high-arctic North America. After eastward displacement to the magnetic North Pole and then across the 0 degrees declination line, adults and juveniles abruptly shifted their orientation from the migratory direction to a direction that would lead back to the breeding area or to the normal migratory route, suggesting that the birds began compensating for the displacement by using geomagnetic cues alone or together with solar cues. In contrast to predictions by a simple genetic migration program, our experiments suggest that both adults and juveniles possess a navigation system based on a combination of celestial and geomagnetic information, possibly declination, to correct for eastward longitudinal displacements.     

The role of skylight polarization in the orientation of a day-migrating bird species

To assess the role of skylight polarization in the orientation system of a day-migrating bird, Yellow-faced Honeyeaters (Lichenostomus chrysops, Meliphagidae) were tested in funnel cages for their directional preferences. In control tests in the natural local geomagnetic field under the clear natural sky, they preferred their normal migratory course. Manipulations of the e-vector by depolarizing the skylight or rotating the axis of polarization failed to affect the orientation as long as the natural geomagnetic field was present. When deprived of magnetic information, the birds continued in their normal migratory direction as long as they had access to information from the natural sky, or when either the sun or polarized light was available. However, when sun was hidden by clouds, depolarizers caused disorientation. — These findings indicate that polarized skylight can be used for orientation when no other known cues are available. However in the hierarchy of cues of this species, the polarization pattern clearly ranks lower than information from the geomagnetic field.     

Magnetic Orientation in Solenopsis sp. Ants

It is known that magnetic fields affect ants behavior. It has been shown that Solenopsis ants are sensitive to magnetic fields but there is no experimental evidence for magnetic orientation. In this paper experiments were done to verify the magnetic orientation of Solenopsis sp. ants. The spontaneous orientation of ants in a circular arena was studied in two different magnetic conditions: in the natural geomagnetic field and under an altered magnetic field, with the horizontal geomagnetic axis shifted in 90?o. Our results show that ants consistently change their orientation direction when the magnetic field was altered. Axial circular statistics analysis showed that, in the absence of other cues, ants orient spontaneously to the horizontal geomagnetic field axis. The present paper shows for the first time magnetic orientation in Solenopsis sp. ants.