Early development, adult mass, and reproductive success in bighorn sheep

Despite considerable empirical and theoretical work on the individualand population consequences of early development, little isknown about the correlations between early mass and adult sizeor lifetime reproductive success of free-ranging mammals. Usinga 26-year study of bighorn sheep (Ovis canadensis), we examinedhow mass as a lamb and mass gain as a yearling affected adultmass for both sexes, horn length of males and lifetime reproductivesuccess of females at different population densities. Mass asa 3-week-old lamb was either weakly or not correlated withadult mass, horn length of adult males, or the number of lambsweaned over a ewe's lifetime. Weaning mass was correlated withmost of these variables when the number of ewes in the populationwas taken into account. When weaning mass was controlled throughpartial correlation, mass as a yearling was correlated with adult mass of ewes but not with ewe reproductive success orwith adult mass or horn length of rams. Lamb mass and numberof ewes explained more of the variance in adult characteristicsfor males than for females. Our results suggest that mass gainduring lactation, possibly but not necessarily related to theamount of maternal care received, affects adult mass and reproductive success. Females appear better able than males to compensatefor poor early development, likely by postponing their firstreproduction. Mass gain over several years and the number ofewes in the population strongly affect adult mass of both sexesand therefore can have profound effects on reproductive successof this long-lived species with a multi-year growth period.     

Grooming in desert bighorn sheep (Ovis canadensis mexicana) and the ghost of parasites past

Ectoparasites such as ticks have a negative effect on host fitness,whereas parasite-defense grooming is effective in removing ticks.The central control (programmed grooming) model proposes thatanimals engage in preventive tick-defense grooming in responseto an internal timing mechanism, even in the absence of peripheralstimulation from parasites. This model predicts that smalleranimals will groom more frequently than larger ones becauseof the higher cost of parasitism for a small animal (body sizeprinciple). The peripheral stimulation (stimulus driven) modelpredicts no size-related differences in grooming rate in theabsence of tick bite irritation. We observed grooming behaviorin a Chihuahuan desert population of bighorn sheep (Ovis canadensismexicana), where ticks have been absent for perhaps thousandsof years. Although not exposed to ticks, bighorns self groomedby means of oral and scratch grooming, albeit at very low ratescompared to size-matched ungulates in both tick-infested andtick-free environments. Logistic regression and general linearmodels revealed both the probability that grooming was performedduring a 10-min focal sample and the rate of grooming when itoccurred was greater for younger, smaller age/sex categoriesof less body mass. Oral and scratch grooming were negativelyassociated with body mass during both years, with juveniles(X = 15 kg) grooming the most frequently and the oldest males(X = 70–85 kg) grooming the least. Assuming that programmedgrooming evolved in a tick-infested environment, the currentgrooming behavior of this population is a relict of their ancestralenvironment, an adaptation to the "ghost of parasites past."     

Behavioral dynamics between caring males and females in a beetle with facultative biparental care

In families in which both parents care for multiple offspring,the amount of care a parent provides can be simultaneously influencedby multiple social interactions (i.e., parent-parent and parent-offspring).In this study, we first tested for sex differences in the parents'contribution to care and then used path analysis to addressthe simultaneous impact of parent-parent and parent-offspringinteractions on male and female care in the burying beetle,Nicrophorus vespilloides. In this species, both parents provisiontheir offspring predigested carrion from a vertebrate carcass,and the larvae beg for food from their parents. We found thatfemales were more involved in direct care for the larvae andspent more time than did males provisioning the larvae withfood. By using path analysis, we found a negative relationshipbetween male and female provisioning, suggesting that parentsadjust their behavior to that of their mate. Furthermore, wefound that both social interactions (i.e., larval begging) andnonsocial factors (i.e., brood size) significantly influencedmale provisioning, but had no significant effect on female provisioning.We suggest that the difference in the relative contributionof the two sexes to the care of the offspring explains why onlymales seemed to adjust their care to variation in social andnonsocial factors. For example, females may be less able toadjust their care to variation in larval begging and brood sizebecause they were already working near their maximum capacity.     

Individual variation in reproductive costs of reproduction: high-quality females always do better

1. Although life-history theory predicts substantial costs of reproduction, individuals often show positive correlations among life-history traits, rather than trade-offs. The apparent absence of reproductive costs may result from heterogeneity in individual quality. 2. Using detailed longitudinal data from three contrasted ungulate populations (mountain goats, Oreamnos americanus; bighorn sheep, Ovis canadensis; and roe deer, Capreolus capreolus), we assessed how individual quality affects the probability of detecting a cost of current reproduction on future reproduction for females. We used a composite measure of individual quality based on variations in longevity (all species), success in the last breeding opportunity before death (goats and sheep), adult mass (all species), and social rank (goats only). 3. In all species, high-quality females consistently had a higher probability of reproduction, irrespective of previous reproductive status. In mountain goats, we detected a cost of reproduction only after accounting for differences in individual quality. Only low-quality female goats were less likely to reproduce following years of breeding than of nonbreeding. Offspring survival was lower in bighorn ewes following years of successful breeding than after years when no lamb was produced, but only for low-quality females, suggesting that a cost of reproduction only occurred for low-quality females. 4. Because costs of reproduction differ among females, studies of life-history evolution must account for heterogeneity in individual quality.     

Genomic consequences of genetic rescue in an insular population of bighorn sheep (Ovis canadensis)

Genetic rescue is a management intervention whereby a small population is supplemented with individuals from other populations in an attempt to reverse the effects of inbreeding and increased genetic load. One such rescue was recently documented in the population of bighorn sheep (Ovis canadensis) within the National Bison Range wildlife refuge (Montana, USA). Here, we examine the locus-specific effects of rescue in this population using a newly developed genome-wide set of 195 microsatellite loci and first-generation linkage map. We found that the rate of introgression varied among loci and that 111 loci, 57% of those examined, deviated from patterns of neutral inheritance. The most common deviation was an excess of homozygous genotypes relative to neutral expectations, indicative of directional selection. As in previous study of this rescue, individuals with more introduced alleles had higher reproductive success and longevity. In addition, we found 30 loci, distributed throughout the genome, which seem to have individual effects on these life history traits. Although the potential for outbreeding depression is a major concern when translocating individuals between populations, we found no evidence of such effects in this population.     

Selfish mothers: reproductive expenditure and resource availability in bighorn ewes

We present a marginal value model explaining intraspecific andinterspecific variation of mating systems in nonterritorialungulates. The model takes into account the simultaneous effectsof spatial and temporal distribution of females, female groupsize, male-male competition, female choice, and the operationalsex ratio (i.e., the proportion of estrous females). The modelpredicts that higher numbers of females per group increasesthe average exploitation time of such groups by males. An increasein female group density, operational sex ratio, and age-specificfighting success of males are predicted to reduce the averageexploitation time of female groups, leading to roving of males(i.e., moving between female groups). In contrast, an increasein die female rejection rate of males and in the time spentby males on nonmating activities (i. e., foraging, lying down,ruminating, migrating) are predicted to increase the averageexploitation time of female groups and to favor staying behaviorof males (i.e., defending a female group over a longer periodof time). Consequently, die model predicts that young maleswill tend to be "stayers," whereas middle-aged and old malesare expected to be "rovers." Model predictions were tested widifield data collected on muskoxen Ovibos moschatus in a naturalpopulation in west Greenland. Observed correlations betweenbull exploitation times of cow groups and the six above-mentionedsocial and environmental parameters were all in die predicteddirection and statistically significant in five of die six cases.Overall, 69% of die observed variation in exploitation timeof cow groups by males was explained by die model predictions.Stepwise regression suggested that, of die six parameters, variationin sex ratio (R² = .56) and time spent on nonmating activities(R² = .35) had the largest effects on male exploitation time.Also, die observed age-specific variation in bull exploitationtime of cow groups was as predicted.     

Food affects the potential reproductive rates of sand goby females but not of males

The interspawning interval of female sand gobies, Pomatoschistusminutus, a batch-spawning fish with paternal care, was significantlyshorter when the fish were fed daily than when they were fedevery fourth day. The incubation time of males was not affectedby feeding, nor was the interbrood interval Males have an equalor higher potential reproductive rate than females. As femalesreproduce more slowly when food is scarce than when it is abundant,and males do not, the difference between the sexes in potentialreproductive rate increases when there is food shortage. Becauseof this difference, both male bias in operational sex ratioand intensity in male-male competition for mates are predictedto increase as food availability decreases. Furthermore, a tradeoffbetween current and future reproduction is demonstrated to operateonly when resources are limited, because the correlation betweenegg number of the first and second clutch was positive amonghigh-food females but negative among low-food females. The numberof eggs per female clutch did, however, not differ between treatmentsin first or second dutch. I conclude that operational sex ratioand sexual selection are expected to vary within and betweensand goby populations in accordance with prey availability     

Relative allocation to horn and body growth in bighorn rams varies with resource availability

Males may allocate a greater proportion of metabolic resourcesto maintenance than to the development of secondary sexual characterswhen food is scarce, to avoid compromising their probabilityof survival. We assessed the effects of resource availabilityon body mass and horn growth of bighorn rams (Ovis canadensis)at Ram Mountain, Alberta, Canada over 30 years. The number ofadult ewes in the population tripled during our study, and theaverage mass of yearling females decreased by 13%. We used theaverage mass of yearling females as an index of resource availability.Yearling female mass was negatively correlated with the bodymass of rams of all ages, but it affected horn growth only duringthe first three years of life. Yearly horn growth was affectedby a complex interaction of age, body mass, and resource availability.Among rams aged 2–4 years, the heaviest individuals hadsimilar horn growth at high and at low resource availability,but as ram mass decreased, horn growth for a given body massbecame progressively smaller with decreasing resource availability.For rams aged 5–9 years, horn growth was weakly but positivelycorrelated with body mass, and rams grew slightly more hornfor a given body mass as resource availability decreased. Whenfood is limited, young rams may direct more resources to bodygrowth than to horn growth, possibly trading long-term reproductivesuccess for short-term survival. Although horn growth of olderrams appeared to be greater at low than at high resource availability,we found no correlation between early and late growth in hornlength for the same ram, suggesting that compensatory horn growthdoes not occur in our study population. Young rams with longerhorns were more likely to be shot by sport hunters than thosewith shorter horns. Trophy hunting could select against ramswith fast-growing horns.     

Inbreeding affects sexual signalling in males but not females of Tenebrio molitor

In many species of animals, individuals advertise their quality with sexual signals to obtain mates. Chemical signals such as volatile pheromones are species specific, and their primary purpose is to influence mate choice by carrying information about the phenotypic and genetic quality of the sender. The deleterious effects of consanguineous mating on individual quality are generally known, whereas the effect of inbreeding on sexual signalling is poorly understood. Here, we tested whether inbreeding reduces the attractiveness of sexual signalling in the mealworm beetle, Tenebrio molitor, by testing the preferences for odours of inbred and outbred (control) individuals of the opposite sex. Females were more attracted to the odours produced by outbred males than the odours produced by inbred males, suggesting that inbreeding reduces the attractiveness of male sexual signalling. However, we did not find any difference between the attractiveness of inbred and outbred female odours, which may indicate that the quality of females is either irrelevant for T. molitor males or quality is not revealed through female odours.     

Reproductive costs of sons and daughters in Rocky Mountain bighorn sheep

Differential maternal investment theory predicts that in sexuallydimorphic and polygynous species mothers should invest morein sons than in daughters. We tested the hypothesis that bighornewes that raise sons incur greater reproductive costs than ewesthat raise daughters. Although ewe mass gain during lactationand subsequent winter body mass loss were independent of lambsex, lambs born the year following the weaning of a son hadlower survival than lambs born after a daughter. The effectsof lamb sex on subsequent reproductive success of ewes becamemore evident at high population density. Lamb sex did not affectmaternal survival. Population density, weather, and ewe agedid not alter the relationship between lamb sex and subsequentreproductive success of the ewe. The year after weaning a son,ewes were more likely to have a daughter than a son, while ewesthat had previously weaned a daughter had similar numbers ofsons and daughters. Our results show that for bighorn sheepewes, sons have a greater life-history cost than daughters,suggesting a differential maternal investment in the sexes.     

Early growth in male and female fallow deer fawns

In this paper we present data from a long-term study on earlygrowth and related variables in fallow deer fawns living inlarge enclosures. Pre-winter body mass was constantly higherand more strongly correlated to subadult body mass in malesthan in females. To find out the mechanism for this higher pre-wintermass in males, we analyzed the variation in pre-winter massin relation to sex, year, mother's body mass, age and parityof mother, birth date, birth mass, growth rate, suckling behavior,and other behaviors. Birth mass was higher for male fawns, andgestation length, birth date, and weaning date did not differbetween the sexes. Consequently, both pre- and postnatal growthwere faster in males than in females. No behavioral differenceswere found between the sexes that could explain the differencein postnatal growth. Pre-winter mass was positively relatedto mother's body mass. Heavy mothers gave birth earlier andto larger offspring who grew at a higher rate, independent ofoffspring sex. However, male fawns born to primiparous mothershad relatively lower growth than male fawns born to multiparousmothers. This was not the case for female fawns. Suckling timeafter the first 2 weeks was positively related to mother's bodymass and growth of offspring. However, no measurements of sucklingbehavior differed between male and female fawns. Our results,except for the effect of parity on male and female growth, indicatethat selection has not acted on mothers to promote faster earlygrowth in males.     

Choosy females and indiscriminate males: mate choice in mixed populations of sexual and hybridogenetic water frogs (Rana lessonae, Rana esculenta)

For several decades, behavioral ecologists have studied theeffects of the environment on the behavior of individuals;but only fairly recently they have started to ask the reversequestion: how do the behavioral strategies of individuals affectthe composition and dynamics of populations and communities?Although intuitively obvious, this feedback from individualto higher levels is difficult to demonstrate, except in systemswith exceptionally fast and marked responses of the populationsto the behavior of its members. Such a system exists in sperm-dependentspecies. In European water frogs, for instance, successfulreproduction of a hybrid species (R. esculenta, genotype LR)requires mating with one of its parental species (R. lessonae,genotype LL), except in the rare cases where hybrids are triploid.The sexual host LL, however, should avoid matings with the sexual parasite LR, because the resulting LR offspring willeliminate the L genome from their germ line. In this studywe investigate how this conflict is solved. Since water froghybrids come in both sexes, rather than as females only likein other sperm-dependent systems, we performed the tests withboth females and males. One individual was given a choice betweentwo individuals of the opposite sex, one an LL and the otheran LR. In both species, females showed the predicted preferencefor LL males, whereas males did not discriminate between LLand LR females. On the individual level, we interpret the sexdifference in choosiness by the lower costs from mating withthe wrong species (LR) and the higher benefits from matingwith large individuals in males than in females. In "normal"species, male preference for large (i.e. more fecund) femalesis advantageous, but in this system such a choice can resultin mating with the larger LR females. With respect to the structureand dynamics of mixed populations, we discuss that the observed female preference is consistent with the higher mating successof LL males found in nature. Hence, mate female choice is astrong candidate for a mechanism promoting coexistence of thesperm-dependent hybrid and its sexual host. This confirms predictionsfrom previous theoretical models.     

Fathers, fat, and maternal energetics in a biparental hamster: paternal presence determines the outcome of a current reproductive effort and adipose tissue limits subsequent reproductive effort

Djungarian hamster females, Phodopus campbelli, are severely constrained in their ability to reproduce successfully and lose 20% of their body weight by the time pups are weaned. In the wild and in the laboratory, biparental care improves maternal reproductive success. Two experiments quantified the effects of paternal presence and partial lipectomy [surgical depletion of parametrial white adipose tissue (PWAT) on day 8 of the 18-day gestation] on maternal energy balance, reproductive success, and investment in a subsequent reproductive attempt. Paired females reproduced successfully, maintained body weight, and invested in a second litter. Removal of the male decreased pup survival, growth, and readiness for dispersal by 18 days of age. Solitary females lost 10% of their body weight by the birth and a further 10% by day 18 after the birth. Thus, paternal presence balanced maternal energy budgets during reproduction and prevented a 20% loss in body weight. Equivalent weight loss occurs in response to other maternal stressors, therefore 20% may be the maximum tolerable weight loss in this species. Fresh weight of interscapular brown adipose tissue was predicted by the extent of maternal hyperthermia but not by maternal energy balance or lipectomy. Partial lipectomy did not adversely affect the female or the first litter but decreased the probability of investment in a second reproductive attempt and halved the size of the second litter. This effect may have been due to the 0.1% of body weight amount of lipid removed or may reflect a specialized role for PWAT in adjusting maternal investment.