Inhibition of DNA topoisomerase I by natural and synthetic mono- and dimeric protoberberine alkaloids

A series of natural (i.e., 1-7) and synthetic (i.e., 8-23) protoberberine alkaloids were evaluated for their inhibitory activities towards DNA topoisomerase I. Both the natural, monomeric protoberberine alkaloids and their mono-modified congeners showed only minor activities. In contrast, most of the dimeric protoberberine alkaloids, especially compounds 12-22, were highly active, with a similar cleavage efficiency as camptothecin (CPT), a well-known, potent topoisomerase-I inhibitor. Thus, these dimeric compounds are promising candidates to be further elaborated as anticancer leads. The mechanism of topoisomerase-I inhibition seems to be dependent on drug concentration for the dimeric protoberberines. At low concentration, they exhibit similar characteristics as CPT. At high concentration, this ability is mostly lost, and the dimers inhibit the relaxation activity of topoisomerase I. Thus, we suppose that the active, dimeric protoberberines strongly bind to plasmid DNA at elevated drug concentration. This most likely results in blocking the enzyme's access to plasmid DNA, thus inhibiting its relaxation.     

Substituted benz[a]acridines and benz[c]acridines as mammalian topoisomerase poisons

Coralyne and several other synthetic benzo[a,g]quinolizium derivatives related to protoberberine alkaloids have exhibited activity as topoisomerase poisons. These compounds are characterized by the presence of a positively charged iminium group, which has been postulated to be associated with their pharmacological properties. The objective of the present study was to devise stable noncharged bioisosteres of these compounds. Several similarly substituted benz[a]acridine and benz[c]acridine derivatives were synthesized and their relative activity as topoisomerase poisons was determined. While the benz[c]acridine derivatives evaluated as part of this study were devoid of topoisomerase poisoning activity, several dihydrobenz[a]acridines were able to enhance DNA cleavage in the presence of topo I. In contrast to certain protoberberine derivatives that did exhibit activity as topo II poisons, none of the benz[a]acridines derivatives enhanced DNA cleavage in the presence of topo II. Among the benz[a]acridines studied, 5,6-dihydro-3,4-methylenedioxy-9,10-dimethoxybenz[a]acridine, 13e, was the most potent topo I poison, with comparable potency to coralyne. These data suggest that heterocyclic compounds structurally related to coralyne can exhibit potent topo I poisoning activity despite the absence of an iminium cation within their structure. In comparison to coralyne or other protoberberine derivatives, these benz[a]acridine derivatives possess distinctly different physicochemical properties and represent a novel series of topo I poisons.     

Substituted benzo[i]phenanthridines as mammalian topoisomerase-targeting agents

Several benzo[c]phenanthridine and protoberberine alkaloids, such as nitidine and berberrubine, are known to induce DNA cleavage in the presence of either topoisomerase I or II. Structure-activity studies performed on various analogues related to benzo[c]phenanthridine and protoberberine alkaloids have provided insights into structural features that influence this topoisomerase-targeting activity. Modifications within the A-ring of benzo[c]phenanthridine and protoberberine alkaloids can significantly alter their ability to enhance the cleavable complex formation that occurs between DNA and topoisomerases. Select benzo[i]phenanthridines were synthesized as potential bioisosteres of nitidine and its analogues. In the present study, 2,3-methylenedioxy-8,9-dimethoxybenzo[i]phenanthridine, 2,3-methylenedioxy-8,9-dimethoxy-5-methylbenzo[i]phenanthridine, 2,3,8,9-tetramethoxybenzo[i]phenanthridine and 5-methyl-2,3,8,9-tetramethoxybenzo[i]phenanthridine were synthesized. These benzo[i]phenanthridine derivatives were evaluated for their ability to enhance cleavable complex formation in the presence of topoisomerases and DNA as well as for their cytotoxicity against the human lymphoblastoma cell line, RPMI8402. 2,3-Methylenedioxy-8,9-dimethoxybenzo[i]phenanthridine (4a) and its 5-methyl derivative (4b) are active as topoisomerase I-targeting agents. In contrast to nitidine, the presence of the 5-methyl substituent in the case of 4b is not associated with enhanced activity. Consistent with previous structure-activity studies on nitidine and protoberberine alkaloids, 2,3,8,9-teramethoxybenzo[i]phenanthridine, 5a, and its 5-methyl derivative, 5b, are inactive as topoisomerase I-targeting agents. These studies were extended to an evaluation of the relative pharmacological activities of 2,8,9-trimethoxybenzo[i]phenanthridine, 3,8,9-trimethoxybenzo[i]phenanthridine, and 2,3-methylenedioxy-8,9-methylenedioxybenzo[i]phenanthridine.     

Specific DNA cleavage and binding by vaccinia virus DNA topoisomerase I

Cleavage of a defined linear duplex DNA by vaccinia virus DNA topoisomerase I was found to occur nonrandomly and infrequently. Approximately 12 sites of strand scission were detected within the 5372 nucleotides of pUC19 DNA. These sites could be classified as having higher or lower affinity for topoisomerase based on the following criteria. Higher affinity sites were cleaved at low enzyme concentration, were less sensitive to competition, and were most refractory to religation promoted by salt, divalent cations, and elevated temperature. Cleavage at lower affinity sites required higher enzyme concentration and was more sensitive to competition and induced religation. Cleavage site selection correlated with a pentameric sequence motif (C/T)CCTT immediately preceding the site of strand scission. Noncovalent DNA binding by topoisomerase predominated over covalent adduct formation, as revealed by nitrocellulose filter-binding studies. The noncovalent binding affinity of vaccinia topoisomerase for particular subsegments of pUC19 DNA correlated with the strength and/or the number of DNA cleavage sites contained therein. Thus, cleavage site selection is likely to be dictated by specific noncovalent DNA-protein interactions. This was supported by the demonstration that a mutant vaccinia topoisomerase (containing a Tyr----Phe substitution at the active site) that was catalytically inert and did not form the covalent intermediate, nevertheless bound DNA with similar affinity and site selectivity as the wild-type enzyme. Noncovalent binding is therefore independent of competence in transesterification. It is construed that the vaccinia topoisomerase is considerably more stringent in its cleavage and binding specificity for duplex DNA than are the cellular type I enzymes.     

Effects of modification of the active site tyrosine of human DNA topoisomerase I

The human topoisomerase I-mediated DNA relaxation reaction was studied following modification of the enzyme at the active site tyrosine (position 723). A series of unnatural tyrosine analogues was incorporated into the active site of human topoisomerase I by utilizing misacylated suppressor tRNAs in an in vitro protein synthesizing system. The relaxation activities of the modified human topoisomerase I analogues having varied steric, electronic, and stereochemical features were all greatly diminished relative to that of the wild type. It was found that modifications involving replacement of the nucleophilic tyrosine OH group with NH2, SH, or I groups eliminated DNA relaxation activity, as did changing the orientation of the nucleophilic tyrosine OH group. Only tyrosine analogues having the phenolic OH group in the normal position with respect to the protein backbone were active; the relative activities could be rationalized in chemical terms on the basis of the H-bonding and the electronic effects of the substituents attached to the meta position of the aromatic ring. In addition, the poisoning of one of the modified human topoisomerase I analogues, as part of covalent binary complexes with DNA, by CPT and 20-thio CPT was evaluated.     

Analysis of stereoelectronic properties of camptothecin analogues in relation to biological activity

Camptothecin and four of its 10,11-methylenedioxy analogues were examined for their activity against the pathogenic protozoan Leishmania donovani in vitro. The methylenedioxy analogues were 36- to 180-fold more potent than the parent camptothecin, possessing IC50 values ranging from 160 to 32 nM against the parasite. Our finding that the methylenedioxy camptothecins possess greater activity than camptothecin, which is also the case for other cell types and for the generation of cleavable complex in the presence of DNA and purified mammalian topoisomerase I, prompted us to examine the molecular features of camptothecin and methylenedioxy camptothecin analogues. A delocalization of positive potential was observed in the methylenedioxy camptothecin analogues, which could increase the affinity of these molecules for DNA. In addition, geometrical and electronic differences between the E ring of camptothecin and its methylenedioxy analogues were noted. One or both of these factors may contribute to the superior biological activity of the methylenedioxy camptothecin analogues.     

Sequence-selective topoisomerase II inhibition by anthracycline derivatives in SV40 DNA: relationship with DNA binding affinity and cytotoxicity

Topoisomerase II mediated double-strand breaks produced by anthracycline analogues were studied in SV40 DNA. The compounds included doxorubicin, daunorubicin, two doxorubicin stereoisomers (4'-epimer and beta-anomer), and five chromophore-modified derivatives, with a wide range of cytotoxic activity and DNA binding affinity. Cleavage of 32P-end-labeled DNA fragments was visualized by autoradiography of agarose and polyacrylamide gels. Structure-activity relationships indicated that alterations in the chromophore structure greatly affected drug action on topoisomerase II. In particular, removal of substituents on position 4 of the D ring resulted in more active inducers of cleavage with lower DNA binding affinity. The stereochemistry between the sugar and the chromophore was also essential for activity. All the active anthracyclines induced a single region of prominent cleavage in the entire SV40 DNA, which resulted from a cluster of sites between nucleotides 4237 and 4294. DNA cleavage intensity patterns exhibited differences among analogues and were also dependent upon drug concentration. Intensity at a given site depended on both stimulatory and suppressive effects depending upon drug concentration and DNA sequence. A good correlation was found between cytotoxicity and intensity of topoisomerase II mediated DNA breakage.     

8,9-methylenedioxybenzo[i]phenanthridines: topoisomerase I-targeting activity and cytotoxicity

Substituted benzo[i]phenanthridines that have incorporated within their structure an 8,9-methylenedioxy group can exhibit topoisomerase I-targeting activity. Structure-activity studies were performed to examine the influence of saturation at the 11,12-positions of several substituted 8,9-methylenedioxybenzo[i]phenanthridines. The activities of these dihydro analogues were compared to those of their unsaturated analogues. In addition, the influence of varying substituents at the 2- and 3-positions within the A-ring of these 8,9-methylenedioxybenzo[i]phenanthridines on their relative potency as topoisomerase I-targeting agents and cell proliferation as determined using the MTT assay was investigated. 2,3-Dimethoxy-8,9-methylenedioxybenzo[i]phenanthridine and its 11,12-dihydro derivative were among the more potent analogues evaluated with regard to topoisomerase I-targeting activity and cytotoxicity.     

Thermophilic topoisomerase I on a single DNA molecule

Control of DNA topology is critical in thermophilic organisms in which heightened ambient temperatures threaten the stability of the double helix. An important role in this control is played by topoisomerase I, a member of the type IA family of topoisomerases. We investigated the binding and activity of this topoisomerase from the hyperthermophilic bacterium Thermotoga maritima on duplex DNA using single molecule techniques, presenting it with various substrates such as (+) plectonemes, (-) plectonemes, and denaturation bubbles. We found the topoisomerase inactive on both types of plectonemes, but active on denaturation bubbles produced at increased stretching forces in underwound DNA. The relaxation rate depended sensitively on the applied force and the protein concentration. These observations could be understood in terms of a preference of the topoisomerase for single-stranded DNA over double-stranded DNA and allowed for a better understanding of activity of the topoisomerase in bulk experiments on circular plasmids. Binding experiments on a single duplex molecule using a mutant unable to perform cleavage confirmed this interpretation and suggested that T.maritima topoisomerase I behaves like an SSB by lowering the denaturation threshold of underwound DNA. Finally, experiments with a unique single-stranded DNA showed that both ends of the cleaved DNA are tightly maintained by the enzyme, supporting an enzyme-bridged mechanism for this topoisomerase.     

Synthesis,topoisomerase-targeting activity and growth inhibition of lycobetaine analogs

The plant alkaloid lycobetaine has potent topoisomerase-targeting properties and shows anticancer activity. Based on these findings, several lycobetaine analogs were synthesized mainly differing in their substituents at 2, 8 and 9 position and their biological activities were evaluated. The topoisomerase-targeting properties and cytotoxicity of these structural analogs were assessed in the human gastric carcinoma cell line GXF251L. Performing a plasmid relaxation assay, an increased inhibition of topoisomerase I was found with N-methylphenanthridinium chlorides bearing a 8,9-methylenedioxy moiety or a methoxy group in 2-position. Furthermore, quaternized phenanthridinium derivatives bearing either a 2-methoxy or a 8,9-methylenedioxy moiety in conjunction with a 2-hydroxy or 2-methoxy group display potent topoisomerase II inhibition as shown by decatenation of kinetoplast DNA. In general, the N-methylphenanthridinium chlorides possess more potency in inhibiting topoisomerase I than topoisomerase II. All quaternized derivatives also exhibited potent inhibition of tumor cell growth in the low micromolar concentration range. Hence, N-methylphenanthridinium compounds were found to represent a promising class of compounds, potently inhibiting both, topoisomerases I and II, and may be further developed into clinically useful topoisomerase inhibitors.     

Sequence specific interaction of Mycobacterium smegmatis topoisomerase I with duplex DNA.

We have identified strong topoisomerase sites (STS) for Mycobacteruim smegmatis topoisomerase I in double-stranded DNA context using electrophoretic mobility shift assay of enzyme-DNA covalent complexes. Mg2+, an essential component for DNA relaxation activity of the enzyme, is not required for binding to DNA. The enzyme makes single-stranded nicks, with transient covalent interaction at the 5'-end of the broken DNA strand, a characteristic akin to prokaryotic topoisomerases. More importantly, the enzyme binds to duplex DNA having a preferred site with high affinity, a property similar to the eukaryotic type I topoisomerases. The preferred cleavage site is mapped on a 65 bp duplex DNA and found to be CG/TCTT. Thus, the enzyme resembles other prokaryotic type I topoisomerases in mechanistics of the reaction, but is similar to eukaryotic enzymes in DNA recognition properties.     

Recombinogenic flap ligation mediated by human topoisomerase I

Aberration of eukaryotic topoisomerase I catalysis leads to potentially recombinogenic pathways by allowing the joining of heterologous DNA strands. Recently, a new ligation pathway (flap ligation) was presented for vaccinia virus topoisomerase I, in which blunt end cleavage complexes ligate the recessed end of duplex acceptors having a single-stranded 3'-tail. This reaction was suggested to play an important role in the repair of topoisomerase I-induced DNA double-strand breaks. Here, we characterize flap ligation mediated by human topoisomerase I. We demonstrate that cleavage complexes containing the enzyme at a blunt end allow invasion of a 3'-acceptor tail matching the scissile strand of the donor, which facilitates ligation of the recessed 5'-hydroxyl end. However, the reaction was strictly dependent on the length of double-stranded DNA of the donor complexes, and longer stretches of base-pairing inhibited strand invasion. The stabilization of the DNA helix was most probably provided by the covalently bound enzyme itself, since deleting the N-terminal domain of human topoisomerase I stimulated flap ligation. We suggest that stabilization of the DNA duplex upon enzyme binding may play an important role during normal topoisomerase I catalysis by preventing undesired strand transfer reactions. For flap ligation to function in a repair pathway, factors other than topoisomerase I, such as helicases, would be necessary to unwind the DNA duplex and allow strand invasion.     

Distamycin inhibition of topoisomerase I-DNA interaction: a mechanistic analysis.

Inhibition of eukaryotic DNA topoisomerase I by the minor groove binding ligand, distamycin A, was investigated. Low concentrations of the ligand selectively prevented catalytic action at a high affinity topoisomerase I binding sequence. A restriction enzyme protection assay indicated that the catalytic cycle was blocked at the binding step. Distamycin binding sites on DNA were localized by hydroxyl radical footprinting. A strongly preferred site mapped to a homopolymeric (dA).(dT)-tract partially included in the essential topoisomerase I binding region. Mutational elimination of the stable helix curvature associated with this ligand binding site demonstrated that (i) the intrinsic bend was unessential for efficient binding of topoisomerase I, and (ii) distamycin inhibition did not occur by deformation of a stable band. Alternative modes of inhibition are discussed.     

Eukaryotic topoisomerase I-DNA interaction is stabilized by helix curvature.

The influence of DNA structure on topoisomerase I-DNA interaction has been investigated using a high affinity binding site and mutant derivatives thereof. Parallel determinations of complex formation and helix structure in the absence of superhelical stress suggest that the interaction is intensified by stable helix curvature. Previous work showed that a topoisomerase I binding site consists of two functionally distinct subdomains. A region located 5' to the topoisomerase I cleavage site is essential for binding. The region 3' to the cleavage site is covered by the enzyme, but not essential. We report here that the helix conformation of the latter region is an important modulator of complex formation. Thus, complex formation is markedly stimulated, when an intrinsically bent DNA segment is installed in this region. A unique pattern of phosphate ethylation interferences in the 3'-part of the binding site indicates that sensing of curvature involves backbone contacts. Since dynamic curvature in supercoiled DNA may substitute for stable curvature, our findings suggest that topoisomerase I is able to probe DNA topology by assessment of writhe, rather than twist.     

DNA substrate specificity of reverse gyrase from extremely thermophilic archaebacteria

It has been shown earlier that eukaryotic type I DNA topoisomerases act on duplex DNA regions, while eubacterial type I topoisomerases require single-stranded regions. The present paper demonstrates that the type I topoisomerase from extremely thermophilic archaebacteria, reverse gyrase, winds DNA by binding to single-stranded DNA regions. Thus, type I topoisomerases, both relaxing one in eubacteria and reverse gyrase in extremely thermophilic archaebacteria share a substrate specificity to melted DNA regions. The important consequence of this specificity is that the cellular DNA superhelical stress actively controlled by bacterial topoisomerases is confined to a narrow range characterized by a low stability of the double helix. Hence we suppose that bacterial topoisomerase systems control duplex stability near its minimum, for which purpose they create an appropriate negative superhelicity at moderate temperatures or a positive one at extremely high temperatures, the feedback being ensured by the aforesaid specificity of type I bacterial topoisomerases.     

2,3-Dimethoxybenzo[i]phenanthridines: topoisomerase I-targeting anticancer agents

Appropriately substituted benzo[i]phenanthridines structurally related to nitidine, a benzo[c]phenanthridine alkaloid with antitumor activity, are active as topoisomerase I-targeting agents. Studies on benzo[i]phenanthridines have indicated analogues that possess a 2,3-methylenedioxy moiety and at least one and preferably two methoxyl groups at the 8- and 9-positions, such as 8,9-dimethoxy-2,3-methylenedioxybenzo[i]phenanthridine, 2, are active as topoisomerase I-targeting agents. Tetramethoxylated benzo[i]phenanthridines, wherein the 2,3-methylenedioxy moiety is replaced with methoxyl groups at the 2- and 3-position, are inactive as a topoisomerase I-targeting agent. These results initially suggested that the 2,3-methylenedioxy moiety was critical to the retention of potent activity. Further studies revealed that 2,3-dimethoxy-8,9-methylenedioxybenzo[i]phenanthridine, 7a, is more potent than 2 as a topoisomerase I-targeting agent. The observation that 2,3-dimethoxylated benzo[i]phenanthridines can actually exhibit enhanced activity prompted the present study in which several 8-substituted 2,3-dimethoxybenzo[i]phenanthridines were prepared and their pharmacological activities evaluated. The influence of NH(2), CN, CH(2)OH, OBn, OCH(3), OH, and NHCOCH(3 )substituents at the 8-position on the relative activity of these 2,3-dimethoxybenzo[i]phenanthridines was examined. Relative to these derivatives, 7a was the most potent topoisomerase I-targeting agent, possessing similar cytotoxicity to that of nitidine in the human lymphoblast tumor cell line, RPMI8402.     

Synthesis and cytotoxic activity of benzo[c][1,7] and [1,8]phenanthrolines analogues of nitidine and fagaronine

Fagaronine and nitidine are natural benzo[c] phenanthridinium alkaloids, which display antileukemic activity. Both act as topoisomerase I and topoisomerase II inhibitors. The objective of the present study was to prepare noncharged isosters of these compounds, with replacement of the aromatic A ring by a pyridine ring, present in other topoisomerase I inhibitors. Various 7,8- and 8,9-dimethoxy and metylenedioxy benzo[c][1,7] and [1,8]phenanthrolines were readily synthesized by benzyne-mediated cyclization of the corresponding substituted N-(2-halobenzyl)-5-quinolinamines or 5-isoquinolinamines. In both series, compounds bearing oxygenated substituents at positions 8 and 9 exhibited cytotoxic properties towards L1210 murine leukemia cells, which may result from their capacities to intercalate into DNA. Topoisomerase I inhibition was observed for all active compounds.     

Interaction of bleomycin A2 with deoxyribonucleic acid: DNA unwinding and inhibition of bleomycin-induced DNA breakage by cationic thiazole amides related to bleomycin A2

The association of the antitumor antibiotic bleomycin A2 with DNA has been investigated by employing several 2-substituted thiazole-4-carboxamides, structurally related to the cationic terminus of the drug. With a 5'-32P-labeled DNA restriction fragment from plasmid pBR322 as substrate, these compounds have been shown to inhibit bleomycin-induced DNA breakage. Analogues possessing 2'-aromatic substituents on the bithiazole ring were more potent inhibitors than those carrying 2'-aliphatic groups, e.g., the acetyl dipeptide A2. The degree of inhibition was similar at all scission sites on DNA, and inclusion of the analogues did not induce bleomycin cleavage at new sites. DNA binding of bithiazole derivatives has also been studied by two complementary topological methods. Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis using a population of DNA topoisomers and DNA relaxation experiments involving calf thymus DNA topoisomerase I and pBR322 DNA reveal that bleomycin bithiazole analogues unwind closed circular duplex DNA. The inhibition and unwinding studies together support recent NMR studies suggesting that both bleomycin A2 and synthetic bithiazole derivatives bind to DNA by an intercalative mechanism. The results are discussed in relation to the DNA breakage properties of bleomycin A2.     

Inhibition of poly(ADP-ribose)polymerase binding to DNA by thymidine dimer

The ability of poly(ADP-ribose)polymerase to bind damaged DNA was assessed by electrophoretic mobility shift assay. DNA binding domain of poly(ADP-ribose)polymerase (PARPDBD) binds to synthetic deoxyribonucleotide duplex 10-mer. However, the synthetic deoxyribonucleotide duplex containing cys-syn thymidine dimer which produces the unwinding of DNA helix structure lost its affinity to PARPDBD. It was shown that the binding of PARPDBD to the synthetic deoxyribonucleotide duplex was not affected by O6-Me-dG which causes only minor distortion of DNA helix structure. This study suggests that the stabilized DNA helix structure is important for poly(ADP-ribose)polymerase binding to DNA breaks, which are known to stimulate catalytic activity of poly(ADP-ribose)polymerase.