Neonatal splenic suppressor cells in the chicken. I. In vivo suppression of the immune response to bovine serum albumin by normal and tolerized neonatal spleen cells

The presence of active splenic suppressor cells in neonatal chickens, either normal or tolerant to bovine serum albumin (BSA), was examined by assessment of their effect on both primary and adoptively transferred secondary responses to BSA or sheep red blood cells (SRC). Both normal and BSA tolerized spleen cells were shown to be highly suppressive of secondary anti-BSA responses generated by specifically primed adult spleen cells in inert recipients. Suppression of the secondary anti-BSA response by normal spleen cells was slightly less effective than that seen with BSA tolerant spleen cells. Transfer of BSA tolerant spleen cells into normal recipients, followed by BSA challenge, prevented any significant primary anti-BSA response. In contrast, transfer of normal spleen cells into normal recipients, followed by BSA challenge, failed to show any suppression of the resulting primary response. Neither normal nor BSA tolerant neonatal spleen cells were capable of suppressing either primary or secondary responses to SRC. Thus, chickens tolerized to BSA have suppressor cells specific for the tolerizing antigen. We present evidence that both the tolerance associated suppressors and the suppressors detected in normal neonatal chickens are T cells.     

Effects of Corynebacterium parvum on depressed immunological reactions in EL-4-tumor-bearing mice

Summary Effects of Corynebacterium parvum on the development of plaque-forming cells (PFC), cell-mediated cytotoxicity (CMC), and delayed footpad reaction (DFR) to chicken erythrocytes (CRBC) were investigated in EL-4-bearing syngeneic mice. PFC, CMC, and DFR responses after the primary immunization were suppressed in tumor-bearing mice and restored by C. parvum treatment. PFC and CMC responses in tumor-bearing mice were restored by the transfer of spleen cells of C. parvum-treated normal mice. Such powers of recovery were abrogated by the removal of glass-adherent cells but not by the removal of -positive or Ig-positive cells. DFR was suppressed not only in the primary but also in the secondary immunization, in contrast to PFC and CMC; the secondary responses of these types were not suppressed in tumor-bearing mice. Positive DFR was not elicited in tumor-bearing mice after adoptive transfer of sensitized lymphocytes from normal immune donors. The DFR became positive in such tumor-bearing recipients when they were treated by C. parvum. Macrophage functions in the induction phase of the immune response as accessory cells and in the expression of DFR as secondary cells appear to be suppressed in tumor-bearing mice and restored by C. parvum.     

Suppression of cell-mediated immunity by street rabies virus infection.

An attempt to define a severe suppression of cell-mediated immunity by street rabies virus infection was undertaken by using the mice lethally and peripherally infected with a street rabies virus (1088 strain). The cell-mediated cytotoxic (CMC) activity of the spleen cells from those mice once slightly increased until day 4 after infection but declined rapidly thereafter until their death on days 10 to 12 after infection. In parallel with a decrease of CMC response of the spleen cells from 1088-infected mice, proliferative response to Con A, IL-2 activity in the culture supernatants of Con A-induced proliferation, responsiveness to exogenously added IL-2 and to Con A to express IL-2R, of those cells became suppressed, and the marked decrease of the total number of spleen cells was observed. Selective depletion of CD4+ and CD8+ cells in the spleens, abnormalities of IL-1 and E-type prostaglandins (PGE2) production or production of inhibitory component able to block IL-2 activity by spleen cells were not observed and these factors did not appear to be associated with the suppression of proliferative response to Con A. However, an apparent association of CD8+ cells in the suppression of differentiation of pre-cytotoxic lymphocytes (CTL) into CTL was demonstrated in the co-culture experiments of the spleen cells from 1088-infected mice with spleen cells of mice infected with an attenuated rabies virus (ERA strain) which can induce higher levels of CMC response. There was no evidence of the productive replication of rabies virus in thymus and spleen of 1088-infected mice. The relationship of these observations to current theories on virus-induced immunosuppression was discussed.     

Immune response in malnutrition. Differential effect of dietary protein restriction on the IgM and IgG response to alloantigens

The capacity for humoral immune response was evaluated in C57BL/6 mice fed diets with low (8%) or normal (27%) protein content upon primary and secondary stimulation with allogeneic cells from the DBA/2 strain. Primary antibody response was assessed by titration of serum hemagglutinins and by quantitation of direct plaque forming cells (PFC) in immune spleen suspensions, with lymphoma cells L5178Y of the DBA/2 strain as target. Secondary antibody response was assessed by titration of serum hemagglutinins. The following results were obtained: 1) Significant decrease in the total number of spleen cells was observed in protein deficient animals while the numbers of IgM PFC/spleen did show small reduction. 2) The number of direct alloantibody PFC/10⁷ spleen cells was increased in the protein deficient animals in comparison to the normally fed controls. 3) The above effect was observed even after short periods (1 week) of protein depletion. 4) Titers of serum hemagglutinins in protein deficient mice were similar or higher than in normal mice during the primary response but markedly depressed during the secondary response. 5) The synthesis of IgG hemagglutinins was depressed in protein deficient mice during both the primary and secondary responses. The results indicated that cells producing IgM alloantibodies are not affected by protein deficiency starting during the fourth week of age, while one or more of the cell populations interacting in the IgG response to alloantigens is markedly depressed by similar protein restriction. It was suggested also that protein deficient animals present a failure in the regulatory mechanism(s) of the IgM response to alloantigens.     

Contrasting effects of alloantiserum and xenoantiserum on cell-mediated lysis of tumor cells

The effect of anti-EL-4 serum on antibody-dependent cytotoxicity (ADCC) and cell-mediated cytotoxicity (CMC) was studied in allogeneic and xenogeneic systems. Inbred strains of BALB/c mice and Lewis rats were immunized with EL-4 tumor cells. Using microcytotoxic assays of ⁵¹Cr release from labeled EL-4 cells, complement-dependent cytolysis, ADCC, and CMC were determined. Complement-dependent cytolysis was observed in both systems. Although ADCC was demonstrated in both systems, the kinetics of cytolysis were different. Xenoantisera and alloantisera had opposite effects on CMC. Incubation of EL-4 target cells with BALB/c anti-EL-4 serum resulted in inhibition of CMC by immune BALB/c spleen cells. In contrast, treatment of EL-4 target cells with Lewis anti-EL-4 serum potentiated the CMC of immune Lewis spleen cells. It is thought that differences in the strength of response, antibody characteristics, and effector cells may determine the degree of inhibition or potentiation observed in these systems.     

In Vitro Studies on the Immunological Memory for Antibody Response to Bovine Serum Albumin

Immunological memory for T and B cells was studied in an in vitro culture system with spleen cells from mice primed with bovine serum albumin (BSA). Spleen cells taken from mice immunized at various times previously with a single intravenous injection of alum-precipitated (AP) BSA and bacterial endotoxin (ET) were cultured in Marbrook's system with dinitrophenylated (DNP) BSA as the in vitro antigen. In the cultures of spleen cells obtained from mice primed more than 14 days previously, an IgG-predominant anti-BSA response was generated. However, no anti-BSA response was observed in the culture of spleen cells taken from mice primed 7 days previously (day 7 spleen cells). The failure of day 7 spleen cells to generate an antibody response in vitro was shown to be attributable to both the lack of B memory cells and the effect of “suppressive” macrophages induced by ET. On the other hand, anti-BSA memory in the spleen of mice primed with AP-BSA plus ET and 2 months later challenged with AP-BSA matured within 7 days and declined rather quickly by 30 days after the challenge. The difference in the time course of the generation of memory between the spleen cells from primary and from secondary immunized mice might be attributable to the difference in the maturation of memory B cells, since the time course of the development of memory T cells after the secondary immunization was similar to that observed after primary immunization.     

Cell-mediated immunity to Friend virus-induced leukemia. III. Characteristics of secondary cell-mediated cytotoxic response.

By employing the 125IUdR release cytotoxicity assay, we have been able to measure the primary and secondary cell-mediated cytotoxic response of C57BL/6 mice to FBL-3 cells, a syngeneic Friend virus-induced leukemia. It was found that the secondary cell-mediated cytotoxic response occurred more rapidly after challenge (within 3 days) than the primary response, and the levels of reactivity were considerably higher. As in the primary response, the secondary cytotoxic reactivity of spleen cells was T cell dependent, being eliminated by pretreatment with anti-theta antibody plus complement. However, the secondary reactivity of pertioneal exudate (PE) cells was not entirely T-cell dependent. The specificity of the secondary cytotoxic response was analyzed by primary or secondary immunization with various tumor cells and by testing of cytotoxic lymphocytes against a variety of target cells. When spleen cells were used for testing, only tumor cells induced by Friend, Moloney, or Rauscher (FMR) leukemia viruses could produce secondary cell-mediated cytotoxic responses against FBL-3 cells. This correlated well with the specificity observed in the in vivo tumor transplantation protection studies. Similarly, spleen cells immune to FBL-3 had appreciable cytotoxicity against tumor cells induced by FMR viruses. The FBL-3 immune mice also gave significant protection against the challenge of FMR leukemias. When PE cells were used for testing, they gave higher levels of cytotoxicity against tumor cells induced by FMR viruses, but also gave less, but appreciable, cytotoxicity against non-FMR tumors. The latter reactivity might be related to the antigens induced by the murine endogenous type C viruses.     

In situ activation of syngeneic tumour-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes: Intra-pinna immunization followed by restimulation in the peritoneal cavity

Summary Tumour-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) are usually obtained after immunization in vivo and restimulation of immune cells in vitro. We here describe the generation of syngeneic tumour-specific CTL within no more than 9 days by priming and restimulation in vivo. This is achieved only if the correct sites are used both for primary immunization (ear pinna) and for restimulation (peritoneal cavity). The kinetics of immune T cell induction and of the secondary response in vivo will be reported. While a secondary CTL response could be generated in the peritoneal cavity, this was not possible in the spleen, no matter which routes of antigen restimulation were used. Upon transfer of immune spleen cells into the peritoneal cavity but not into the spleen, a secondary response could be generated upon in situ restimulation, indicating the importance of the correct microenvironment for this type of response. The peritoneal effector cells were true T cells and recognized a tumour-associated antigen in association with the K^d major histocompatibility (MHC class I) antigen. Finally the activated tumour-specific peritoneal exudate cells were able to transfer protective immunity without exogenous interleukin-2 into normal syngeneic mice.     

In vitro distinction between primary and secondary cellular response to alloantigens by means of a subcellular antigenic preparation]

Living spleen cells and a subcellular product of spleen cells have been compared, in mice, for their ability to elicit, for a long term culture (4-5 days), a cellular cytotoxic response against alloantigens. Contrary to living spleen cells which could induce the same high level of cytotoxic activity in a primary or in a secondary response, the antigenic preparation was only able to mount a very low primary response while it could render highly cytotoxic a lymphoid population proved to be able to mount in vitro an anamnestic response.     

Immunosuppressive effect of Entamoeba histolytica extract on hamsters

The immune response to sheep red blood cells (SRBC) in mice and hamsters injected with an extract of entamoeba histolytica was studied. Both the primary and secondary immune response, measured by anti-SRBC antibody titers, were unaltered in the mouse, while a significant depression of the primary, but not the secondary, response was observed in the hamster. The effect was greatest when the amebic extract (AE) and SRBC were injected on the same day. The number of anti-SRBC rosettes formed in the spleen cells of hamsters treated with both AE and SRBC on day 0 was measured from days 1-16. The response peaked on day 13, while cells from animals injected with SRBC alone gave a maximal response on day 5. The formation of anti-SRBC rosettes in T-lymphocyte-enriched spleen cells treated with anti-gamma globulin serum and complement was almost abolished for the duration of the experiment. It is suggested that the mechanism responsible for this immunosuppressive phenomenon could involve early interference in the afferent limb of the immune response.     

Requirements for stimulation of T cell responses against virus-infected cells: nature of ectromelia virus-infected cells capable of stimulating cytotoxic T cells in a secondary response in vitro.

The nature of infected stimulator cells in the in vitro secondary cytotoxic T cell response to ectromelia infection was investigated. It was found that macrophages were better stimulator cells than spleen cells. B cells (Ig-positive cells) were superior to T cells (Ig-negative cells) both on a relative proportion and on a cell-to-cell basis. Concanavalin A and lipopolysaccharide-stimulated lymphocytes were also effective stimulator cells but appeared to be slightly inferior to spleen cells. Spleen cells depleted of Ia-positive cells were markedly inferior to normal spleen cells as stimulators. It was also found that primary and secondary cytotoxic T cells were largely Ia-negative. These findings are discussed in relation to the likely events during T cell responses to infection in vivo.     

Cellular requirements for the expression of IgM. Immunological memory in vitro

In vitro culture techniques have been used to compare the direct (IgM) plaqueforming cell (PFC) response to heterologous erythrocytes (RBC) by normal mouse spleen cells and spleen cells from mice injected intravenously with 5 × 10⁴ RBC ten days previously [low dose primed (LDP)]. Although LDP mice fail to undergo a significant primary PFC response, their spleen cells are capable of a secondary or enhanced PFC response in vitro. The secondary PFC response is shown to be a function of: (A) an increase in the frequency of immunocompetent cells or units (IU) due to in vivo priming, and (B) an increased number of PFC generated per IU subsequent to in vitro stimulation. The latter increase is shown to be mediated through a shorter PFC doubling-time during logarithmic expansion of the PFC population. Analysis of nonadherent spleen cell dose response experiments indicate that two nonadherent cell types interact in the secondary response. Subsequent cocultivation experiments suggested that both of these cell types must be “primed” to allow induction of a secondary response. Although adherent cells are required for the secondary response, normal splenic adherent cells serve as equivalent substitutes for LDP adherent cells.     

Systemic administration of Corynebacterium parvum during sensitization to tumor alloantigen-modified response to rechallenge

Summary Intravenous administration of Corynebacterium parvum (C. parvum) to mice during a primary immune response against tumor alloantigens impairs their ability to generate memory cell-mediated cytotoxicity (CMC) in response to an intraperitoneal rechallenge with the same tumor alloantigens. Decreased CMC was observed in spleen and mesenteric lymph nodes, whereas CMC of lymphoid populations from the peritoneal cavity was merely delayed, reaching comparable levels to those found in control animals by day 5. Serum levels of cytotoxic antibody were unaffected, indicating that C. parvum administered during a primary immune response has selective effects on the cytotoxic memory response.     

CD8 T cell recall responses are regulated by the tissue tropism of the memory cell and pathogen

Whether memory CD8 T cells can be reactivated in nonlymphoid tissues is unclear. Using mice lacking the spleen, lymph nodes, or both, we show that the secondary T cell response, but not homeostatic maintenance of memory cells, required lymphoid tissue. Whereas primary and secondary CD8 T cell responses to vesicular stomatitis virus infection were lymph node dependent, responses to Listeria monocytogenes infection were driven primarily in the spleen. Memory cell subset reactivation was also regulated by location of the responding population and the pathogen. Thus, CD62Llow effector memory T cells (TEM) cells responded nearly as well as CD62Lhigh central memory T cells (TCM) and TCM cells after L. monocytogenes infection, and both subsets generated equivalent populations of secondary memory cells. In contrast, TCM cells, but not TEM cells, mounted a robust response to vesicular stomatitis virus infection. TCM and TEM cells also required lymphoid tissue to mount recall responses, and the bone marrow did not contribute significantly to the response of either subset. Our findings indicated that characteristics of the infectious agent and the migratory preferences of memory cells dictated the secondary lymphoid tissue requirement for the recall response to infection.     

Human recombinant IL-6/B cell stimulatory factor 2 augments murine antigen-specific antibody responses in vitro and in vivo

The effects of human rIL-6/B cell stimulatory factor 2 (hrIL-6/BSF-2) from Escherichia coli on murine Ag, SRBC-specific antibody responses were examined in vitro and in vivo. HrBSF-2 was effective in augmenting the primary and the anamnestic plaque-forming cells response to SRBC in vitro. The augmentation of the primary response was apparent when B cell-enriched spleen cells (B cells) were cultured with BSF-2 in the presence of IL-2. On the other hand, hrBSF-2 alone strongly enhanced the anamnestic response in a dose-dependent manner when spleen cells from SRBC-immunized mice were used. These effects of BSF-2 were abolished completely by anti-BSF-2 antibody, but not by normal rabbit Ig. Cell depletion experiments indicated that L3T4 (CD4)+ T cells, but not Lyt-2(CD8)+ T cells, and adherent cells (macrophages) have an important role in this BSF-2-induced augmentation of the response. In addition, kinetic studies showed that hrBSF-2 acts on B cells in the anamnestic response even when added relatively late in the culture. Finally, it was determined whether BSF-2 also could be active in modulating antibody responses in vivo. BSF-2 was shown to enhance the primary and secondary antibody responses in mice. The most apparent effect of BSF-2 was observed in the secondary response.     

Studies on the induction and expression of T cell-mediated immunity. IV. Non-overlapping populations of alloimmune cytotoxic lymphocytes with specificity for tumor-associated antigens and transplantation antigens.

Two non-overlapping populations of alloimmune cytotoxic T cells with specificity for tumor-associated antigens (TAA) and for histocompatibility antigens (H-2) were characterized by two independent methods. The heterogeneity of cytotoxic cells was demonstrated in spleen cells derived from BALB/c (H-2d) mice sensitized to EL-4 (H-2b) tumor and from C57BL/6 (H-2b) mice sensitized to G-35 (H-2d) tumor cells. Adsorption of immune lymphocytes on monolayers prepared with cells bearing the sensitizing H-2 antigens abrogated the in vitro cell-mediated cytotoxicity (CMC) directed against 51Cr-labeled normal target cells (spleen cells or ConA-activated spleen blasts), whereas significant cytolytic activity to the corresponding 51Cr-tumor cells was still retained. Likewise, in competitive inhibition assays, CMC to 51 Cr-tumor target cells was only partially inhibited by unlabeled normal cells, whereas CMC to 51Cr-normal target cells was completely abrogated. These results suggested that alloimmune cytotoxic lymphocytes are heterogeneous and can be subdivided into two independent populations of restricted specificity. Several experiments suggested that the effector cell population directed against TAA can no longer elicit a graft-vs-host (GVH) reaction in vivo. This was demonstrated by adoptive transfer into lethally-irradiated allogeneic recipients of cytotoxic or primed spleen cells fractionated on host target cell monolayers. Furthermore, these results demonstrated that both effector cells and memory cells possess high affinity binding receptors to corresponding H-2 antigens. The potential use of fractionated immune lymphocytes sensitized to tumor allografts in adoptive immunotherapy is discussed.     

Suppression of the cytotoxic T-lymphocyte response in mice by pertussis toxin

Pertussis toxin (PT), the major toxin produced by Bordetella pertussis, has been reported both to enhance and to suppress immune responsiveness. These findings suggested that PT contributes to the virulence of B. pertussis through mechanisms involving immune regulation. We report that PT suppressed both the primary and the secondary cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) responses of mouse spleen cells cultured against two different allogeneic stimulator spleen cells in vitro. This suppression was dependent on the dose of PT used. PT must be present during the initial stages (within the first 24 hr) of CTL generation. Soluble factor(s) obtained from spleen cells preexposed to PT did not suppress the CTL response. Suppression of the CTL response observed was not due to depletion of the antigen by PT. The cytotoxic activity of CTL clones could not be suppressed by PT. The analysis of responder spleen cells, fractionated by anti-immunoglobulin panning techniques, provided evidence that L3T4-, Lyt 2+ cells mediate the PT-induced immunosuppression. We propose that suppression of the CTL response by PT is generated through the activation of L3T4-, Lyt 2+ suppressor T lymphocytes.     

CD4-positive T lymphocytes are required for the generation of the primary but not the secondary CD8-positive cytolytic T lymphocyte response to herpes simplex virus in C57BL/6 mice.

To understand the cellular basis for recovery from HSV infection, it is critical to identify functional interactions between HSV-specific T lymphocyte subpopulations involved in the generation of the optimal response. To this end, the requirement for CD4+ (L3T4+) T lymphocytes in the development of the primary and secondary CD8+ (Lyt-2+) cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) response following HSV infection in C57BL/6 mice was investigated. It was found that chronic depletion of CD4+ cells in vivo by treatment with the mAb GK1.5, which resulted in greater than 95% depletion of peripheral CD4+ T lymphocytes in treated animals, caused a profound decrease in the levels of cytolytic activity obtained during the primary response in the draining popliteal lymph nodes of mice responding to infection in the hind footpads. However, treatment did not affect the levels of in vivo secondary CTL activity in the popliteal lymph nodes, nor the in vitro secondary response in the spleen. The decreased CTL activity observed during the primary response was not due to an inability to prime HSV-specific CTL precursors (CTLp), as full cytolytic activity was obtained following culture of lymphocytes in the presence of exogenous IL-2 and antigen, and the response could be reconstituted by treatment with recombinant IL-2 in vivo. Analysis of the secondary CTL response in the spleen indicated that CD4+ cells were not required for either the generation or maintenance of this aspect of the response. However, blockade of IL-2 utilization by CTL using anti-IL-2R antibodies indicated that this lymphokine was absolutely essential for secondary CTL expansion in vitro. Finally, mice that had been infected 12 months previously exhibited a decreased ability to generate secondary HSV-specific CTL in vitro following CD4-depletion in vivo. Taken together, these results suggest two distinct stages of CTL development during the response: an early primary stage dependent upon the presence of CD4+ cells, and a later, CD4-independent stage operative during the secondary response, which decays with time postinfection.     

Cytolytic T lymphocyte responses to metabolically inactivated stimulator cells. II. Effect of a soluble "costimulator" factor(s) in primary and secondary mixed leukocyte culture

The ability of a concanavalin A-stimulated spleen cell supernatant (“costimulator”) to overcome the effects of impaired CD and LD antigen presentation by metabolically inactivated stimulator spleen cells was examined in the primary and secondary cytolytic T lymphocyte (T_c) response. (i) Cells inactivated by ultraviolet irradiation or mild glutaraldehyde treatment, which were unable to stimulate primary cytolytic activity on their own, generated near maximal responses in the presence of costimulator. The 30-fold lower efficiency of splenic membrane fragments as antigen in primary MLC with the supernatant indicated that the damage to immunogenicity caused by membrane isolation was not equivalent to that caused by uv light and glutaraldehyde, as has previously been assumed. (ii) Comparison of the relative effects of antigen and costimulator demonstrated that costimulator played the dominant regulatory role in primary MLC, increasing sensitivity to suboptimal antigen doses 10- to 30-fold; neither antigen nor the supernatant appeared preferentially to control the strength of the secondary response. (iii) Metabolically inactivated adult and untreated neonatal spleen cells failed to release costimulator activity in response to concanavalin A. However, the ability of the neonatal cells to induce a primary cytolytic response suggested that costimulator production by the stimulator cells themselves is not essential for primary T_c activation, and supports the hypothesis that the lack of primary immunogenicity of inactivated spleen cells reflects their failure to induce costimulator production by the responder population.     

In vitro induction of polyclonal killer T cells with 2-mercaptoethanol and the essential role of macrophages in this process.

Killer T cells against allogeneic and syngeneic tumor cells were generated in vitro by the addition of 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME) to the murine spleen cell culture in the absence of any antigenic stimulation. The maximum activity of T cell-mediated cytotoxicity (CMC) induced with 2-ME was observed on day 4 of culture and the induction of CMC was completely inhibited by the addition of inhibitor of DNA synthesis, hydroxyurea, or cytosin arabinoside. CMC induced with 2-ME was specifically inhibited by the addition of unlabeled target cells to the 51Cr-release assay system. These results indicated that killer T cells were generated in the presence of 2-ME as a result of nonspecific polyclonal activation of precursors into cytotoxic effector cells and that they recognized target cells with antigen-specific recognition receptors. Spleen cells deprived of adherent cells showed impaired induction of CMC with 2-ME. The addition of peritoneal exudate macrophages to splenic T cells restored this response. The result indicated that macrophages were essential for the induction of CMC with 2-ME. The possibility that the function of macrophages was mediated by soluble factor(s) released from macrophages was demonstrated by the separate culture of splenic T cells and macrophages in double-chambered, Marbrook-type vessels and by the addition of supernatants from macrophage cultures to splenic T cells. 2-ME and soluble factor(s) released from macrophages seemed to be required for the activation of precursors into killer cells.