Metastability in the inhibitory mechanism of human alpha1-antitrypsin

Metastability of the native form of proteins has been recognized as a mechanism of biological regulation. The energy-loaded structure of the fusion protein of influenza virus and the strained native structure of serpins (serine protease inhibitors) are typical examples. To understand the structural basis and functional role of the native metastability of inhibitory serpins, we characterized stabilizing mutations of alpha1-antitrypsin in a region presumably involved in complex formation with a target protease. We found various unfavorable interactions such as overpacking of side chains, polar-nonpolar interactions, and cavities as the structural basis of the native metastability. For several stabilizing mutations, there was a concomitant decrease in the inhibitory activity. Remarkably, some substitutions at Lys-335 increased the stability over 6 kcal mol-1 with simultaneous loss of activity over 30% toward porcine pancreatic elastase. Considering the location and energetic cost of Lys-335, we propose that this lysine plays a pivotal role in conformational switch during complex formation. Our current results are quite contradictory to those of previously reported hydrophobic core mutations, which increased the stability up to 9 kcal mol-1 without any significant loss of activity. It appears that the local strain of inhibitory serpins is critical for the inhibitory activity.     

Cavities of α1-antitrypsin that play structural and functional roles

The native form of inhibitory serine protease inhibitors (serpins) is strained, which is critical for their inhibitory activity. Previous studies on stabilizing mutations of alpha(1)-antitrypsin, a prototype of serpins, indicated that cavities provide a structural basis for the native strain of the molecule. We have systematically mapped the cavities of alpha(1)-antitrypsin that play such structural and functional roles by designing cavity-filling mutations at residues that line the walls of the cavities. Results show that energetically unfavorable cavities are distributed throughout the alpha(1)-antitrypsin molecule, and the cavity-filling mutations stabilized the native conformation at 8 out of 10 target sites. The stabilization effect of the individual cavity-filling mutations of alpha(1)-antitrypsin varied (0.2-1.9 kcal/mol for each additional methylene group) and appeared to depend largely on the structural flexibility of the cavity environment. Cavity-filling mutations that decreased inhibitory activity of alpha(1)-antitrypsin were localized in the loop regions that interact with beta-sheet A distal from the reactive center loop. The results are consistent with the notion that beta-sheet A and the structure around it mobilize when alpha(1)-antitrypsin forms a complex with a target protease.     

Distribution of the native strain in human alpha 1-antitrypsin and its association with protease inhibitor function

Serine protease inhibitors (serpins) are metastable in their native state. This strain, which is released upon binding to target proteases, is essential for the inhibitory activity of serpins. To understand the structural basis of the native strain, we previously characterized stabilizing mutations of alpha(1)-antitrypsin, a prototypical inhibitory serpin, in regions such as the hydrophobic core. The present study evaluates the effects of single point mutations throughout the molecule on stability and protease inhibitory activity. We identified stabilizing mutations in most secondary structures, suggesting that the native strain is distributed throughout the molecule. Examination of the substitution patterns and the structures of the mutation sites revealed surface hydrophobic pockets as a component of the native strain in alpha(1)-antitrypsin, in addition to the previously identified unusual interactions such as side chain overpacking and cavities. Interestingly, many of the stabilizing substitutions did not affect the inhibitory activity significantly. Those that affected the activity were confined in the regions that are mobilized during the complex formation with a target enzyme. The results of our study should be useful for designing proteins with strain and for regulating the stability and functions of serpins.     

Viscous drag as the source of active site perturbation during protease translocation: insights into how inhibitory processes are controlled by serpin metastability

The native form of serine protease inhibitors (serpins) is kinetically trapped in a metastable state, which is thought to play a central role in the inhibitory mechanism. The initial binding complex between a serpin and a target protease undergoes a conformational change that forces the protease to translocate toward the opposite pole. Although structural determination of the final stable complex revealed a detailed mechanism of keeping the bound protease in an inactive conformation, it has remained unknown how the serpin exquisitely translocates a target protease with an acyl-linkage unhydrolyzed. We previously suggested that the acyl-linkage hydrolysis is strongly suppressed by active site perturbation during the protease translocation. Here, we address what induces the transient perturbation and how the serpin metastability contributes to the perturbation. Inhibitory activity of alpha1-antitrypsin (alpha1AT) toward elastase showed negative correlations with medium viscosity and Stokes radius of elastase moiety, indicating that viscous drag directly affects the protease translocation. Stopped-flow measurements revealed that the change in the inhibitory activity is primarily caused by the change in the translocation rate. The native stability of alpha1AT cavity mutants showed a negative correlation with the translocation rate but a positive correlation with the acyl-linkage hydrolysis rate, suggesting that the two kinetic steps are not independent but closely related. The degree of active site perturbation was probed by amino acid nucleophiles, supporting the view that the changes in the acyl-linkage hydrolysis rate are due to different perturbation states. These results suggest that the active site perturbation is caused by local imbalance between a pulling force driving protease translocation and a counteracting viscous drag force. The structural architecture of serpin metastability seems to be designed to ensure the active site perturbation by providing a sufficient pulling force, so the undesirable hydrolytic activity of protease is strongly suppressed during the translocation.     

Complementary structural mass spectrometry techniques reveal local dynamics in functionally important regions of a metastable serpin

Serpins display a number of highly unusual structural properties along with a unique mechanism of inhibition. Although structures of numerous serpins have been solved by X-ray crystallography, little is known about the dynamics of serpins in their inhibitory active conformation. In this study, two complementary structural mass spectrometry methods, hydroxyl radical-mediated footprinting and hydrogen/deuterium (H/D) exchange, were employed to highlight differences between the static crystal structure and the dynamic conformation of human serpin protein, alpha(1)-antitrypsin (alpha(1)AT). H/D exchange revealed the distribution of flexible and rigid regions of alpha(1)AT, whereas footprinting revealed the dynamic environments of several side chains previously identified as important for the metastability of alpha(1)AT. This work provides insights into the unique structural design of alpha(1)AT and improves our understanding of its unusual inhibition mechanism. Also, we demonstrate that the combination of the two MS techniques provides a more complete picture of protein structure than either technique alone.     

Concerted regulation of inhibitory activity of alpha 1-antitrypsin by the native strain distributed throughout the molecule

The native forms of common globular proteins are in their most stable state but the native forms of plasma serpins (serine protease inhibitors) show high energy state interactions. The high energy state strain of alpha(1)-antitrypsin, a prototype serpin, is distributed throughout the whole molecule, but the strain that regulates the function directly appears to be localized in the region where the reactive site loop is inserted during complex formation with a target protease. To examine the functional role of the strain at other regions of alpha(1)-antitrypsin, we increased the stability of the molecule greatly via combining various stabilizing single amino acid substitutions that did not affect the activity individually. The results showed that a substantial increase of stability, over 13 kcal mol(-1), affected the inhibitory activity with a correlation of 11% activity loss per kcal mol(-1). Addition of an activity affecting single residue substitution in the loop insertion region to these very stable substitutions caused a further activity decrease. The results suggest that the native strain of alpha(1)-antitrypsin distributed throughout the molecule regulates the inhibitory function in a concerted manner.     

Circular dichroism of chemically modified human plasma alpha1-antitrypsin. Interaction with porcine elastase.

Chemical modifications of human plasma alpha1-antitrypsin with reagents which modify lysyl residues (citraconic anhydride, acetic anhydride, formaldehyde and 2,4,6-trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid) and arginyl residued (1,2-cyclohexanedione) were examined with regard to their effect upon the elastase inhibitory capacity of the glycoprotein. 2,4,6-Trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid was employed to quantitate the remaining free amino groups (epsilon-NH2 groups of lysine) and the extent of modifications. Amino acid analysis was utilized in the same capacity for the guanidino groups of arginyl residues. The elastase inhibitory capacity of alpha1-antitrypsin was destroyed following trinitrophenylation, citraconylation and acetylation. Circular dichroism of the native and modified derivatives revealed major changes in conformation following trinitrophenylation and citraconylation while CD profiles of acetylated and reductively methylated derivatives differed from that of the native profile considerably less. Reductively methylated alpha1-antitrypsin retained its elastatse inhibitory capacity. The reaction of 1,2-cyclohexanedione with alpha1-antitrypsin did not effect in a loss in inhibitory capacity. Gel filtration studies of native and modified alpha1-antitrypsin on Sephadex G-100 demonstrated an increased molecular weight presumably through molecular aggregation, in the citraconylated and trinitrophenylated derivatives, but not in the cases of the other derivatives. Based upon these studies and previous investigations of our laboratory, it was concluded that (1) alpha1-antitrypsin is a lysyl inhibitor type (i.e., the reactive site is a Lys-X bond), (2) its interaction with elastase follows a pattern similar to trypsin and chymotrypsin, and (3) the positively charged epsilon-NH2 group of lysine is essential for the maintenance of elastase inhibitory capacity.     

Structural factors affecting the choice between latency transition and polymerization in inhibitory serpins

Plasminogen activator inhibitor-1 (PAI-1), a member of the serine protease inhibitor (serpin) protein family, is unique among the serpins in its conformational lability. This lability allows spontaneous conversion of the active form to a more stable, latent conformation under physiological conditions. In other serpins, polymerization, rather than latency transition, is induced under pathological conditions or upon heat treatment. To identify specific factors promoting latency conversion in PAI-1, we mutated PAI-1 at various positions and compared the effects with those of equivalent mutations in alpha(1)-antitrypsin, the archetypal serpin. Mutations that improved interactions with the turn between helix F and the third strand of beta-sheet A (thFs3A) or the fifth strand of beta-sheet A (s5A), which are near the site of latency transition-associated insertion of the reactive center loop, retarded latency conversion but did not greatly increase structural stability. Mutations that decreased interactions with s2C facilitated conformational conversion, possibly by releasing the reactive center loop from beta-sheet C. Mutations of Thr93 that filled a hydrophobic surface pocket on s2A dramatically increased structural stability but had a negligible effect on the conformational transition. Our results suggest that the structural features controlling latency transition in PAI-1 are highly localized, whereas the conformational strain of the native forms of other inhibitory serpins is distributed throughout the molecule and induces polymerization.     

Conformational changes in serpins: I. The native and cleaved conformations of alpha(1)-antitrypsin

The serpins (SERine Proteinase INhibitors) are a family of proteins with important physiological roles, including but not limited to the inhibition of chymotrypsin-like serine proteinases. The inhibitory mechan- ism involves a large conformational change known as the S-->R (stressed-->relaxed) transition. The largest structural differences occur in a region around the scissile bond called the reactive centre loop: In the native (S) state, the reactive centre is exposed, and is free to interact with proteinases. In inhibitory serpins, in the cleaved (R) state the reactive centre loop forms an additional strand within the beta-sheet. The latent state is an uncleaved state in which the intact reactive centre loop is integrated into the A sheet as in the cleaved form, to give an alternative R state.The serpin structures illustrate detailed control of conformation within a single protein. Serpins are also an unusual family of proteins in which homologues have native states with different folding topologies. Determination of the structures of inhibitory serpins in multiple conformational states permits a detailed analysis of the mechanism of the S-->R transition, and of the way in which a single sequence can form two stabilised states of different topology.Here we compare the conformations of alpha(1)-antitrypsin in native and cleaved states. Many protein conformational changes involve relative motions of large rigid subunits. We determine the rigid subunits of alpha(1)-antitrypsin and analyse the changes in their relative position and orientation. Knowing that the conformational change is initiated by cleavage at the reactive centre, we describe a mechanism of the S-->R transition as a logical sequence of mechanical effects, even though the transition likely proceeds in a concerted manner.     

Conformational changes in serpins: I. The native and cleaved conformations of alpha(1)-antitrypsin

The serpins (SERine Proteinase INhibitors) are a family of proteins with important physiological roles, including but not limited to the inhibition of chymotrypsin-like serine proteinases. The inhibitory mechan- ism involves a large conformational change known as the S-->R (stressed-->relaxed) transition. The largest structural differences occur in a region around the scissile bond called the reactive centre loop: In the native (S) state, the reactive centre is exposed, and is free to interact with proteinases. In inhibitory serpins, in the cleaved (R) state the reactive centre loop forms an additional strand within the beta-sheet. The latent state is an uncleaved state in which the intact reactive centre loop is integrated into the A sheet as in the cleaved form, to give an alternative R state.The serpin structures illustrate detailed control of conformation within a single protein. Serpins are also an unusual family of proteins in which homologues have native states with different folding topologies. Determination of the structures of inhibitory serpins in multiple conformational states permits a detailed analysis of the mechanism of the S-->R transition, and of the way in which a single sequence can form two stabilised states of different topology.Here we compare the conformations of alpha(1)-antitrypsin in native and cleaved states. Many protein conformational changes involve relative motions of large rigid subunits. We determine the rigid subunits of alpha(1)-antitrypsin and analyse the changes in their relative position and orientation. Knowing that the conformational change is initiated by cleavage at the reactive centre, we describe a mechanism of the S-->R transition as a logical sequence of mechanical effects, even though the transition likely proceeds in a concerted manner.     

Retarded protein folding of deficient human alpha 1-antitrypsin D256V and L41P variants

alpha(1)-Antitrypsin is the most abundant protease inhibitor in plasma and is the archetype of the serine protease inhibitor superfamily. Genetic variants of human alpha(1)-antitrypsin are associated with early-onset emphysema and liver cirrhosis. However, the detailed molecular mechanism for the pathogenicity of most variant alpha(1)-antitrypsin molecules is not known. Here we examined the structural basis of a dozen deficient alpha(1)-antitrypsin variants. Unlike most alpha(1)-antitrypsin variants, which were unstable, D256V and L41P variants exhibited extremely retarded protein folding as compared with the wild-type molecule. Once folded, however, the stability and inhibitory activity of these variant proteins were comparable to those of the wild-type molecule. Retarded protein folding may promote protein aggregation by allowing the accumulation of aggregation-prone folding intermediates. Repeated observations of retarded protein folding indicate that it is an important mechanism causing alpha(1)-antitrypsin deficiency by variant molecules, which have to fold into the metastable native form to be functional.     

Bypassing the kinetic trap of serpin protein folding by loop extension

The native form of some proteins such as strained plasma serpins (serine protease inhibitors) and the spring-loaded viral membrane fusion proteins are in a metastable state. The metastable native form is thought to be a folding intermediate in which conversion into the most stable state is blocked by a very high kinetic barrier. In an effort to understand how the spontaneous conversion of the metastable native form into the most stable state is prevented, we designed mutations of alpha1-antitrypsin, a prototype serpin, which can bypass the folding barrier. Extending the reactive center loop of alpha1-antitrypsin converts the molecule into a more stable state. Remarkably, a 30-residue loop extension allows conversion into an extremely stable state, which is comparable to the relaxed cleaved form. Biochemical data strongly suggest that the strain release is due to the insertion of the reactive center loop into the major beta-sheet, A sheet, as in the known stable conformations of serpins. Our results clearly show that extending the reactive center loop is sufficient to bypass the folding barrier of alpha1-antitrypsin and suggest that the constrain held by polypeptide connection prevents the conversion of the native form into the lowest energy state.     

Inactivation of human plasma serine proteinase inhibitors (serpins) by limited proteolysis of the reactive site loop with snake venom and bacterial metalloproteinases

Human plasma serine proteinase inhibitors (serpins) gradually lost activity when incubated with catalytic amounts of snake venom or bacterial metalloproteinases. Electrophoretic analyses indicated that antithrombin III, C1-inhibitor, and alpha 2-antiplasmin had been converted by limited proteolysis into modified species which retained inhibitory activity. Further proteolytic attack resulted in the formation of inactivated inhibitors; alpha 1-proteinase inhibitor (alpha 1-antitrypsin) and alpha 1-antichymotrypsin were also enzymatically inactivated, but active intermediates were not detected. Sequence analyses indicated that the initial, noninactivating cleavage occurred in the amino-terminal region of the inhibitors. Inactivation resulted in all cases from the limited proteolysis of a single bond near, but not at, the reactive site bond in the carboxy-terminal region of the inhibitors. The results indicate that the serpins have two regions which are susceptible to limited proteolysis--one near the amino-terminal end and another in the exposed reactive site loop of the inhibitor.     

Probing the local conformational change of alpha1-antitrypsin

The native form of serpins (serine protease inhibitors) is a metastable conformation, which converts into a more stable form upon complex formation with a target protease. It has been suggested that movement of helix-F (hF) and the following loop connecting to strand 3 of beta-sheet A (thFs3A) is critical for such conformational change. Despite many speculations inferred from analysis of the serpin structure itself, direct experimental evidence for the mobilization of hF/thFs3A during the inhibition process is lacking. To probe the mechanistic role of hF and thFs3A during protease inhibition, a disulfide bond was engineered in alpha(1)-antitrypsin, which would lock the displacement of thFs3A from beta-sheet A. We measured the inhibitory activity of each disulfide-locked mutant and its heat stability against loop-sheet polymerization. Presence of a disulfide between thFs3A and s5A but not between thFs3A and s3A caused loss of the inhibitory activity, suggesting that displacement of hF/thFs3A from strand 5A but not from strand 3A is required during the inhibition process. While showing little influence on the inhibitory activity, the disulfide between thFs3A and s3A retarded loop-sheet polymerization significantly. This successful protein engineering of alpha(1)-antitrypsin is expected to be of value in clinical applications. Based on our current studies, we propose that the reactive-site loop of a serpin glides through between s5A and thFs3A for the full insertion into beta-sheet A while a substantial portion of the interactions between hF and s3A is kept intact.     

The role of strand 1 of the C β-sheet in the structure and function of α1-antitrypsin

Serpins inhibit cognate serine proteases involved in a number of important processes including blood coagulation and inflammation. Consequently, loss of serpin function or stability results in a number of disease states. Many of the naturally occurring mutations leading to disease are located within strand 1 of the C beta-sheet of the serpin. To ascertain the structural and functional importance of each residue in this strand, which constitutes the so-called distal hinge of the reactive center loop of the serpin, an alanine scanning study was carried out on recombinant alpha(1)-antitrypsin Pittsburgh mutant (P1 = Arg). Mutation of the P10' position had no effect on its inhibitory properties towards thrombin. Mutations to residues P7' and P9' caused these serpins to have an increased tendency to act as substrates rather than inhibitors, while mutations at P6' and P8' positions caused the serpin to behave almost entirely as a substrate. Mutations at the P6' and P8' residues of the C beta-sheet, which are buried in the hydrophobic core in the native structure, caused the serpin to become highly unstable and polymerize much more readily. Thus, P6' and P8' mutants of alpha(1)-antitrypsin had melting temperatures 14 degrees lower than wild-type alpha(1)-antitrypsin. These results indicate the importance of maintaining the anchoring of the distal hinge to both the inhibitory mechanism and stability of serpins, the inhibitory mechanism being particularly sensitive to any perturbations in this region. The results of this study allow more informed analysis of the effects of mutations found at these positions in disease-associated serpin variants.     

Ovalbumin and angiotensinogen lack serpin S-R conformational change.

Cleavage of ovalbumin and angiotensinogen at sites homologous to the reactive centre loop of alpha 1-antitrypsin is not accompanied by the increase in heat-stability associated with the transition from the native stressed (S) structure to a cleaved relaxed (R) form that is typical of other serpins. Failure to undergo the S-R change in ovalbumin is not due to phosphorylation of Ser-344 near the sites of cleavage on the loop. The suggested explanation is the unique presence of bulky side chains at the P10-P12 site in ovalbumin and angiotensinogen.     

Cooperative unfolding of a metastable serpin to a molten globule suggests a link between functional and folding energy landscapes

Alpha-1 antitrypsin (alpha(1)-AT) is a member of the serpin class of protease inhibitors, and folds to a metastable state rather than its thermodynamically most stable native state. Upon cleavage by a target protease, alpha(1)-AT undergoes a dramatic conformational change to a stable form, translocating the bound protease more than 70 A to form an inhibitory protease-serpin complex. Numerous mutagenesis studies on serpins have demonstrated the trade-off between the stability of the metastable state on the one hand and the inhibitory efficiency on the other. Studies of the equilibrium unfolding of serpins provide insight into this connection between structural plasticity and metastability. We studied equilibrium unfolding of wild-type alpha(1)-AT using hydrogen-deuterium/exchange mass spectrometry to characterize the structure and the stability of an equilibrium intermediate that was observed in low concentrations of denaturant in earlier studies. Our results show that the intermediate observed at low concentrations of denaturant has no protection from hydrogen-deuterium exchange, indicating a lack of stable structure. Further, differential scanning calorimetry of alpha(1)-AT at low concentrations of denaturant shows no heat capacity peak during thermal denaturation, indicating that the transition from the intermediate to the unfolded state is not a cooperative first-order-like phase transition.. Our results show that the unfolding of alpha(1)-AT involves a cooperative transition to a molten globule form, followed by a non-cooperative transition to a random-coil form as more guanidine is added. Thus, the entire alpha(1)-AT molecule consists of one cooperative structural unit rather than multiple structural domains with different stabilities. Furthermore, our results together with previous mutagenesis studies suggest a possible link between an equilibrium molten globule and a functional intermediate that may be populated during the protease inhibition.     

Role of the connectivity of secondary structure segments in the folding of alpha(1)-antitrypsin

The native form of serpins (serine protease inhibitors) is metastable, which is critical to their biological functions. Spontaneous conversion from the native form of serpins into a more stable conformation, called the "latent" form, is restricted. To examine whether the connectivity of strand 1 of beta-sheet C to the hydrophobic core is critical to the serpin's preferential folding to the metastable native conformation, we designed a circularly-permuted mutant of alpha(1)-antitrypsin, the prototype serpin, in which strand 1C is disconnected from the hydrophobic core. Conformation of the circular permutant was similar to that of the latent form, as revealed by equilibrium unfolding, limited proteolysis, and spectroscopic properties. Our results support the notion that rapid folding of the hydrophobic core with concomitant incorporation of strand 1C into beta-sheet C traps the serpin molecule into its native metastable conformation.     

The effect of amino acid substitutions at position 342 on the secretion of human alpha 1-antitrypsin from Xenopus oocytes

A glutamic acid to lysine change in the Z variant of human alpha 1-antitrypsin is associated with a failure to secrete the protein from synthesising cells. The block in export of the protein may be caused either by the loss of an acidic residue or the introduction of a basic one at this point in the polypeptide chain. Site-directed mutagenesis has been used to construct novel alpha 1-antitrypsin mutants which show that the side chain interactions from Glu-342 are not obligatory for protein export and it is rather the introduction of a basic residue at this point which produces the intracellular accumulation of the protein.     

Aeropin from the extremophile Pyrobaculum aerophilum bypasses the serpin misfolding trap

Serpins are metastable proteinase inhibitors. Serpin metastability drives both a large conformational change that is utilized during proteinase inhibition and confers an inherent structural flexibility that renders serpins susceptible to aggregation under certain conditions. These include point mutations (the basis of a number of important human genetic diseases), small changes in pH, and an increase in temperature. Many studies of serpins from mesophilic organisms have highlighted an inverse relationship: mutations that confer a marked increase in serpin stability compromise inhibitory activity. Here we present the first biophysical characterization of a metastable serpin from a hyperthermophilic organism. Aeropin, from the archaeon Pyrobaculum aerophilum, is both highly stable and an efficient proteinase inhibitor. We also demonstrate that because of high kinetic barriers, aeropin does not readily form the partially unfolded precursor to serpin aggregation. We conclude that stability and activity are not mutually exclusive properties in the context of the serpin fold, and propose that the increased stability of aeropin is caused by an unfolding pathway that minimizes the formation of an aggregation-prone intermediate ensemble, thereby enabling aeropin to bypass the misfolding fate observed with other serpins.