Gene Finding on the Y: Fruitful Strategy in Drosophila does not Deliver in Anopheles

The Anopheles gambiae genome project yielded almost complete sequences for the autosomes and for a large part of the X chromosome, however, no information for the Y chromosome was obtained. Yet, by design, fragmented Y chromosome sequences should be present in the resulting assembly. Here we report the search for Anopheles Y chromosome genes using a strategy successfully applied for identification of Y genes in Drosophila. A complete set of the unmapped scaffolds was targeted in a broad TBLASTN search using both A. gambiae predicted genes and all proteins from nr database as query sequences. After filtering of the BLAST report, we selected 181 scaffolds possibly containing fragments of Y chromosome genes to experimentally test their Y-linkage. Surprisingly, none of the tested sequences appeared to originate from the Y chromosome. Several factors could account for the failure to detect Y genes, including their different organization in A. gambiae compared to Drosophila and the suboptimal quality of the assembly and annotation of the Anopheles genome. Regardless of the cause, our results illuminate problems associated with the genome analysis of outbred organisms.     

Sexual development in marsupials: genetic characterization of bandicoot siblings with scrotal and testicular maldevelopment

In marsupials testis determination requires the presence of a Y chromosome. The sex determining region on the Y gene (SRY) is necessary for testicular development in eutherians and it is assumed to play a similar role in marsupials. Relatively few studies have investigated the genetic basis of sexual development, and as yet there is no direct evidence that SRY is required for testis development in marsupials. Studies on intersexual marsupials have revealed a fundamental difference between marsupial and eutherian sex determination. The scrotum of marsupials is analogous, not homologous, to the eutherian scrotum and is under the control of X-linked genes not androgens. The current study describes two bandicoot (Isoodon macrourus) siblings. Both siblings had underdeveloped male reproductive tracts and testicular dysgenesis, one was ascrotal and the other had a diminutive scrotum. Their karyotypes were normal for this species which eliminates the Y chromosome from some somatic tissues. SRY was detected by Southern blotting. SRY, ubiquitin activating enzyme-1 on the Y (UBE1Y) and glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD) gene expression were examined. UBE1Y was widely expressed in many tissues. SRY gene expression was much lower than normal in the abnormal siblings and may be responsible for their failure of testicular and epididymal development. The cause of their scrotal abnormalities is unknown. It is possible that the separate defects of scrotal and testis development in the two siblings, which had normal relatives, were due to a mutation in a gene common to both developmental pathways.     

Autosomal genes involved in mammalian primary sex determination

Beginning with findings made during the late 1950s and early 1960s, evidence continues to accumulate in support of the hypothesis that the mammalian Y chromosome carries a gene that induces the undifferentiated foetal gonad in XY individuals to develop as a testis. Recently a DNA sequence has been isolated from the human Y chromosome that appears to be the hypothesized Y-linked testis-determining gene, and advances have also been made toward identifying genes that interact with the Y-linked testis-determining (Tdy) gene to initiate testis formation. These loci have been identified in specific stocks of mice carrying the mutant Thp or TOrl allele at the T locus located on chromosome 17, and in crosses involving the transfer of a Y chromosome from two populations of Mus domesticus into the genomes of specific inbred strains of mice. The data in both cases support the hypothesis that there are several loci involved in testis determination and that abnormal interaction of these loci disrupts initiation of testis determination, resulting in development of ovarian tissue in XY individuals.     

Characterization and sequencing of the sex determining region Y gene (Sry) in Akodon (Cricetidae) species with sex reversed females

The sex determining region Y gene (Sry) is the strongest candidate to be the testis determining factor gene (Tdy). Several South-American Akodon species have two varieties of Y chromosome. One type transmitted via male specimens induces testis development. The second Y variety fails to induce male gonadal differentiation and gives rise to fully fertile XY females. These variant females test positive for Sry. Moreover, sequencing of a partial open reading frame of the conserved region of Sry from males and XY females shows no sequence difference. Sry is two- to sixfold amplified in six of eight akodont species tested. Since Sry amplification was found in species having and not having XY females, amplification apparently does not in itself play a primary role in the origin of sex reversal. The development of fully fertile ovaries in XY Akodon females is not due to a deletion of Sry or to mutations in the Sry segment analyzed in this report. Sex reversal may be due to abnormal expression of this gene at the stage of gonadal differentiation. Alternatively, other genes in the sex-determining pathway may be involved. Several of the Akodon species showing Sry amplification also have amplification of Zfy, which may map to the same region of the Akodon Y chromosome.     

A mode of differentiation based on genes of variable expression

Temperature sensitive genes inDrosophila, namelyscute, Dichaete, Freckled, andvestigial were used for these investigations. The sex variation in these genes is described. The Y chromosome has a marked effect on the expression of the genes, also of those which are not associated with a position effect of the variegation type. The effects of temperature and the effects of the Y chromosome are superimposed. Increasing temperature has the same effect on the expression of some genes as addition of Y chromosome material; on other genes both have exactly the contrary effect.Crowding produces the same kind of effect as low temperature or subtraction of Y chromosomes. The genes may be quite sensitive to such environmental conditions.The influences tested, except for the influence of the Y chromosome, act on the rate of development. The data are interpreted to mean that an extragenic agent, possibly of ribosomal nature, acts on the expression of the genes through a differential rate of reproduction of the genes and this extragenic agent.This investigation was supported by N.S.F. Grant No. GB 1332.     

The mammalian Y chromosome: a new perspective

For several decades, the mammalian Y chromosome was considered a genetic “desert,” with the testis determinant being the sole survivor of the attrition that followed the chromosome's inception. Aside from the addition of a genetic factor required for spermatogenesis to the human Y chromosome in 1976, this view held sway until the mid-1980s. The ensuing molecular genetic analysis, culminating in the recent paper in Science by Lahn and Page,¹ has identified more than 20 genes or gene families on the human Y. This has led to a reappraisal of the evolution and functions of this unique chromosome. BioEssays 20 :363–366, 1998. © 1998 John Wiley & Sons Inc.     

Genetic dissection of testis weight in mice: quantitative trait locus analysis using F2 intercrosses between strains with extreme testis weight, and association study using Y-consomic strains

In the present study, dissection of genetic bases of testis weight in mice was performed. Autosomes and the X chromosome were searched using traditional quantitative trait locus (QTL) scans, and the Y chromosome was searched by association studies of Y-consomic strains. QTL analysis was performed in ??DDD?×???CBA F₂ mice; the inbred mouse DDD has the heaviest testes, whereas the inbred mouse CBA has the lightest testes. Two significant testis weight QTLs were identified on chromosomes 1 and X. A DDD allele was associated with increased and decreased testis weight at the locus on chromosomes 1 and X, respectively. In the reciprocal cross ??CBA?×???DDD F₂ mice, QTL on chromosome 1, and not on chromosome X, had a significant effect on testis weight. The DDD allele at the X-linked locus could not sustain testis weight in combination with the Y chromosome of the CBA strain. The Y chromosome per se had a significant effect on testis weight, i.e., DH-Chr Y^DDD had significantly heavier testes than DH-Chr Y^CBA. On the basis of the results of Y-chromosome-wide association studies using 17 Y-consomic strains, variations in Uty, Usp9y, and Sry were significantly associated with testis weight. Thus, testis weight is a complex quantitative phenotype controlled by multiple genes on autosomes and sex chromosomes and their interactions.     

Comparative mapping of ZFY in the hominoid apes

Summary Within our project of comparative mapping of candidate genes for sex-determination/testis differentiation, we used a cloned probe from the human ZFY locus for comparative hybridization studies in hominoids. As in the human, the ZFY probe detects X- and Y-specific restriction fragments in the chimpanzee, the gorilla, the orangutan, and the gibbon. Furthermore, the X-specific hybridization site in the great apes resides in Xp21.3, the same locus defining ZFX in the human. The Y-specific locus of ZFY maps closely to the early replicating pseudoautosomal segment in the telomeric or subtelomeric position of the Y chromosomes of the great apes, again as found in the human. Thus, despite cytogenetically visible structural alterations within the euchromatic parts of the Y chromosomes of the human species and the great apes, a segment of the Y chromosome defined by the pseudoautosomal region and ZFY seems to be more strongly conserved than the rest of the Y chromosome.     

Novel gene acquisition on carnivore Y chromosomes

Despite its importance in harboring genes critical for spermatogenesis and male-specific functions, the Y chromosome has been largely excluded as a priority in recent mammalian genome sequencing projects. Only the human and chimpanzee Y chromosomes have been well characterized at the sequence level. This is primarily due to the presumed low overall gene content and highly repetitive nature of the Y chromosome and the ensuing difficulties using a shotgun sequence approach for assembly. Here we used direct cDNA selection to isolate and evaluate the extent of novel Y chromosome gene acquisition in the genome of the domestic cat, a species from a different mammalian superorder than human, chimpanzee, and mouse (currently being sequenced). We discovered four novel Y chromosome genes that do not have functional copies in the finished human male-specific region of the Y or on other mammalian Y chromosomes explored thus far. Two genes are derived from putative autosomal progenitors, and the other two have X chromosome homologs from different evolutionary strata. All four genes were shown to be multicopy and expressed predominantly or exclusively in testes, suggesting that their duplication and specialization for testis function were selected for because they enhance spermatogenesis. Two of these genes have testis-expressed, Y-borne copies in the dog genome as well. The absence of the four newly described genes on other characterized mammalian Y chromosomes demonstrates the gene novelty on this chromosome between mammalian orders, suggesting it harbors many lineage-specific genes that may go undetected by traditional comparative genomic approaches. Specific plans to identify the male-specific genes encoded in the Y chromosome of mammals should be a priority.     

Inefficient purifying selection: the mammalian Y chromosome in the rodent genus Mus

Two related genes with potentially similar functions, one on the Y chromosome and one on the X chromosome, were examined to determine if they evolved differently because of their chromosomal positions. Six hundred fifty-seven base pairs of coding sequence of Jarid1d (Smcy) on the Y chromosome and Jarid1c (Smcx) on the X chromosome were sequenced in 13 rodent taxa. An analysis of replacement and silent substitutions, using a counting method designed for samples with small evolutionary distances, showed a significant difference between the two genes. The different patterns of replacement and silent substitutions within Jarid1d and Jarid1c may be a result of evolutionary mechanisms that are particularly strong on the Y chromosome because of its unique properties. These findings are similar to results of previous studies of Y chromosomal genes in these and other mammalian taxa, suggesting that genes on the mammalian Y evolve in a chromosome-specific manner.     

Normal structure and expression of Zfy genes in XY female mice mutant in Tdy.

Zfy-1 and Zfy-2 are candidate genes for Tdy, the testis-determining gene in mice. We have analysed these genes in a line of XY female mice that have been shown to be mutated in Tdy. We have used Southern blot analysis to show that the Zfy genes have not undergone any major structural alterations, and have also demonstrated that both genes are transcribed normally from the mutant Y chromosome (Y) in both adult XYY testis and XY female embryonic gonads. The fact that these genes show a normal structure and expression pattern in mice with a Y chromosome known to carry a mutation in Tdy and that mutant embryos develop into females despite Zfy-1 expression, strongly supports other recent evidence that Zfy genes are not directly involved in primary testis determination.     

The process of a Y-loss event in an XO/XO mammal, the Ryukyu spiny rat

The Ryukyu spiny rat, Tokudaia osimensis, has an XO/XO sex chromosome constitution, lacking a Y chromosome and the mammalian sex-determining gene SRY. To investigate the Y-loss event, we traced three proto-Y-linked genes, RBMY1A1, EIF2S3Y, and KDM5D, in the genome. The original Y-linked RBMY1A1 was lost as well as SRY, and the remaining RBMY1A1 was a processed pseudogene on autosome. In contrast, EIF2S3Y and KDM5D were conserved in genomes of both sexes as a result of their translocation from the Y chromosome to the X chromosome and/or autosomes. Furthermore, these genes were expressed in gonads and brains of both sexes. Our study indicated a loss of Y-linked genes with important male functions to be necessary for the Y chromosome to disappear. These functions might have been retained through the acquisition of new genes, and therefore, the Y-loss has had no harmful effect on the maintenance of this species.     

The origin and function of the mammalian Y chromosome and Y-borne genes – an evolving understanding

Mammals have an XX:XY system of chromosomal sex determination in which a small heterochromatic Y controls male development. The Y contains the testis determining factor SRY, as well as several genes important in spermatogenesis. Comparative studies show that the Y was once homologous with the X, but has been progressively degraded, and now consists largely of repeated sequences as well as degraded copies of X linked genes. The small original X and Y have been enlarged by cycles of autosomal addition to one partner, recombination onto the other and continuing attrition of the compound Y. This addition–attrition hypothesis predicts that the pseudoautosomal region of the human X is merely the last relic of the latest addition. Genes (including SRY) on the conserved or added region of the Y evolved functions in male sex determination and differentiation distinct from the general functions of their X-linked partners. Although the gonadogenesis pathway is highly conserved in vertebrates, its control has probably changed radically and rapidly in vertebrate – even mammalian – evolution.     

Gene SRY et anomalies de la determination genetique du sexe chez l’homme

Normal sexual development in man is the consequence of a complex process. This review focuses on the translation of genedal sex (XX or XY karyotype) into gonadal sex (testis or ovary). During the last three years attempts to identify and clone the testis determining factor (TDF) have exploited detailed maps of the Y chromosome established by geneticists over the last decade. A candidate gene, named SRY (sex determining region, Y) located at the tip of the short arm of the Y chromosome, shows many characteristics in common with TDF in that it is the sole element of the Y chromosome required for male development. The discovery of TDF led us to analyse sex-reversed individuals, i.e. XX males and XY females, with the aim of constructing a model for the processes regulating the development of an organ as complex as the testis. This SRY gene is now the subject of intense molecular biological effort by various groups, effort which we hope will elucidate the mechanism(s) of sex determination.     

A Single Genetic Determinant that Prevents Sex Reversal in C57BL-YPOS Congenic Mice

Sex determination in the mammalian embryo begins with the activation of a gene on the Y chromosome which triggers a cascade of events that lead to male development. The mechanism by which this gene, designated SRY in humans and Sry in mice (sex determining region of the Y chromosome), is activated remains unknown. Likewise, the downstream target genes for Sry remain unidentified at present. C57BL mice carrying a Y chromosome from Mus musculus musculus or molossinus develop normally as males. In contrast, C57BL/6 mice with the Y chromosome from M. m. domesticus often show sex reversal, i.e., develop as XY females. It has been documented that C57BL mice with the Y chromosome from Poschiavinus (Y^POS), a domesticus subtype, always develop as females or hermaphrodites. This suggests that a C57BL gene either up- or downstream of Sry is ineffective in interacting with Sry, which then compromises the processes that lead to normal male sex development. Nonetheless, by selective breeding, we have been able to generate a sex reversal-resistant C57BL/6-congenic strain of mice in which the XY^POS individuals consistently develop as normal males with bilateral testes. Because the resistance to sex reversal was transferred from strain 129S1/Sv (nonalbino) by simple selection over 13 backcross generations, it is inferred that a single autosomal gene or chromosomal region confers resistance to the sex reversal that would otherwise result. XY^POS normal males generated in these crosses were compared to XY^POS abnormal individuals and to C57BL/6 controls for sexual phenotype, gonadal weight, serum testosterone, and major urinary protein (MUP) level. A clear correlation was found among phenotypic sex, MUP level, and testis weight in the males and in the incompletely masculinized XY^POS mice. The fully masculinized males of the congenic strain resemble C57BL/6 males in the tested parameters. DNA analysis confirmed that these males, in fact, carry the Y^POS Sry gene.     

Function of the sex chromosomes in mammalian fertility

The sex chromosomes play a highly specialized role in germ cell development in mammals, being enriched in genes expressed in the testis and ovary. Sex chromosome abnormalities (e.g., Klinefelter [XXY] and Turner [XO] syndrome) constitute the largest class of chromosome abnormalities and the commonest genetic cause of infertility in humans. Understanding how sex-gene expression is regulated is therefore critical to our understanding of human reproduction. Here, we describe how the expression of sex-linked genes varies during germ cell development; in females, the inactive X chromosome is reactivated before meiosis, whereas in males the X and Y chromosomes are inactivated at this stage. We discuss the epigenetics of sex chromosome inactivation and how this process has influenced the gene content of the mammalian X and Y chromosomes. We also present working models for how perturbations in sex chromosome inactivation or reactivation result in subfertility in the major classes of sex chromosome abnormalities.