Selective grazing modifies previously anticipated responses of plant community composition to elevated CO2 in a temperate grassland

Our limited understanding of terrestrial ecosystem responses to elevated CO₂ is a major constraint on predicting the impacts of climate change. A change in botanical composition has been identified as a key factor in the CO₂ response with profound implications for ecosystem services such as plant production and soil carbon storage. In temperate grasslands, there is a strong consensus that elevated CO₂ will result in a greater physiological stimulus to growth in legumes and to a lesser extent forbs, compared with C3 grasses, and the presumption this will lead in turn to a greater proportion of these functional groups in the plant community. However, this view is based on data mainly collected in experiments of three or less years in duration and not in experiments where defoliation has been by grazing animals. Grazing is, however, the most common management of grasslands and known in itself to influence botanical composition. In a long‐term Free Air Carbon Dioxide Enrichment (FACE) experiment in a temperate grassland managed with grazing animals (sheep), we found the response to elevated CO₂ in plant community composition in the first 5 years was consistent with the expectation of increased proportions of legumes and forbs. However, in the longer term, these differences diminished so that the proportions of grasses, legumes and forbs were the same under both ambient and elevated CO₂. Analysis of vegetation before and after each grazing event showed there was a sustained disproportionately greater removal (‘apparent selection’) of legumes and forbs by the grazing animals. This bias in removal was greater under elevated CO₂ than ambient CO₂. This is consistent with sustained faster growth rates of legumes and forbs under elevated CO₂ being countered by selective defoliation, and so leading to little difference in community composition.     

Maintenance of leaf N controls the photosynthetic CO2 response of grassland species exposed to 9 years of free‐air CO2 enrichment

Determining underlying physiological patterns governing plant productivity and diversity in grasslands are critical to evaluate species responses to future environmental conditions of elevated CO₂ and nitrogen (N) deposition. In a 9‐year experiment, N was added to monocultures of seven C₃ grassland species exposed to elevated atmospheric CO₂ (560 μmol CO₂ mol^?1) to evaluate how N addition affects CO₂ responsiveness in species of contrasting functional groups. Functional groups differed in their responses to elevated CO₂ and N treatments. Forb species exhibited strong down‐regulation of leaf N_mass concentrations (?26%) and photosynthetic capacity (?28%) in response to elevated CO₂, especially at high N supply, whereas C₃ grasses did not. Hence, achieved photosynthetic performance was markedly enhanced for C₃ grasses (+68%) in elevated CO₂, but not significantly for forbs. Differences in access to soil resources between forbs and grasses may distinguish their responses to elevated CO₂ and N addition. Forbs had lesser root biomass, a lower distribution of biomass to roots, and lower specific root length than grasses. Maintenance of leaf N, possibly through increased root foraging in this nutrient‐poor grassland, was necessary to sustain stimulation of photosynthesis under long‐term elevated CO₂. Dilution of leaf N and associated photosynthetic down‐regulation in forbs under elevated [CO₂], relative to the C₃ grasses, illustrates the potential for shifts in species composition and diversity in grassland ecosystems that have significant forb and grass components.     

Floristic composition of a Swedish semi‐natural grassland during six years of elevated atmospheric CO2

Abstract. A semi‐natural grassland in Sweden was exposed to an elevated CO₂ concentration during a six‐year open‐top chamber experiment. Vegetation composition was assessed twice a year using the point‐intercept method. The field had been grazed previously, but when the experiment started this was replaced with a cutting regime with one cut (down to ground level) each year in early August. From the third to the sixth year of the study the harvested material was divided into legumes, non‐leguminous forbs and grasses, dried and weighed. Elevated CO₂ had an effect on species composition (as analysed by Principal Component Analysis) that increased over time. It also tended to increase diversity (Shannon index) in summer, but reduce it in spring. However, the effects of the weather and/or time on species composition and diversity were much more prominent than CO₂ effects. Since the weather was largely directional over time (from dry to wet), with the exception of the fifth year, it was difficult to distinguish between weather effects and changes caused by a changed management regime. In all treatments, grasses increased over time in both mass and point‐intercept measurements, whereas non‐leguminous forbs decreased in mass, but not in point‐intercept measurements. Legumes increased in the point‐intercept measurements, but not in biomass, at elevated CO₂, but not in the other treatments. Overall, we found that elevated CO₂ affected species composition; however, it was only one of many factors and a rather weak one.     

Elevated CO2 effects on decomposition processes in a grazed grassland

The effects of elevated atmospheric CO₂ (475 μL L^?1) on in situ decomposition of plant litter and animal faecal material were studied over 2 years in a free air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) facility. The pasture was grazed by sheep and contained a mixture of C₃ and C₄ grasses, legumes and forbs. There was no effect of elevated CO₂ on decomposition within plant species but marked differences between species with faster decomposition in dicots; a group that increased in abundance at elevated CO₂. Decomposition of mixed herbage root material occurred at a similar rate to that of leaf litter suggesting that any CO₂‐induced increase in carbon allocation to roots would not reduce rates of decomposition. Sheep faeces resulting from a ‘high‐CO₂ diet’ decomposed significantly slower during summer but not during winter. The overall outcome of these experiments were explored using scenarios that took account of changes in botanical composition, allocation to roots and the presence of herbivores. In the absence of herbivores, elevated CO₂ led to a 15% increase in the rate of mass loss and an 18% increase in the rate of nitrogen (N) release. In the presence of herbivores, these effects were partially removed (11% increase in rate of mass loss and 9% decrease in N release rate) because of the recycling occurring through the animals in the form of faeces.     

Seed production and seed quality in a calcareous grassland in elevated CO2

In diverse plant communities the relative contribution of species to community biomass may change considerably in response to elevated CO₂. Along with species‐specific biomass responses, reproduction is likely to change as well with increasing CO₂ and might further accelerate shifts in species composition. Here, we ask if, after 5 years of CO₂ exposure, seed production and seed quality in natural nutrient‐poor calcareous grassland are affected by elevated CO₂ (650 μ L L^?1 vs 360 μ L L^?1) and how this might affect long‐term community dynamics. The effect of elevated CO₂ on the number of flowering shoots (+ 24%, P < 0.01) and seeds (+ 29%, P = 0.06) at the community level was similar to above ground biomass responses in this year, suggesting that the overall allocation to sexual reproduction remained unchanged. Compared among functional groups of species we found a 42% increase in seed number (P < 0.01) of graminoids, a 33% increase (P = 0.07) in forbs, and no significant change in legumes (? 38%, n.s.) under elevated CO₂. Large responses particularly of two graminoid species and smaller responses of many forb species summed up to the significant or marginally significant increase in seed number of graminoids and forbs, respectively. In several species the increase in seed number resulted both from an increase in flowering shoots and an increase in inflorescence size. In most species, seeds tended to be heavier (+ 12%, P < 0.01), and N‐concentration of seeds was significantly reduced in eight out of 13 species. The fraction of germinating seeds did not differ between seeds produced in ambient and elevated CO₂, but time to germination was significantly shortened in two species and prolonged in one species when seeds had been produced in elevated CO₂. Results suggest that species specific increases in seed number and changes in seed quality will exert substantial cumulative effects on community composition in the long run.     

Contrasting growth response of an N2-fixing and non-fixing forb to elevated CO2: dependence on soil N supply

With the ability to symbiotically fix atmospheric N₂, legumes may lack the N-limitations thought to constrain plant response to elevated concentrations of atmospheric CO₂. The growth and photosynthetic responses of two perennial grassland species were compared to test the hypotheses that (1) the CO₂ response of wild species is limited at low N availability, (2) legumes respond to a greater extent than non-fixing forbs to elevated CO₂, and (3) elevated CO₂ stimulates symbiotic N₂ fixation, resulting in an increased amount of N derived from the atmosphere. This study investigated the effects of atmospheric CO₂ concentration (365 and 700 mol mol^–1) and N addition on whole plant growth and C and N acquisition in an N₂-fixing legume (Lupinus perennis) and a non-fixing forb (Achillea millefolium) in controlled-chamber environments. To evaluate the effects of a wide range of N availability on the CO₂ response, we incorporated six levels of soil N addition starting with native field soil inherently low in N (field soil + 0, 4, 8, 12, 16, or 20 g N m^–2 yr^–1). Whole plant growth, leaf net photosynthetic rates (A), and the proportion of N derived from N₂ fixation were determined in plants grown from seed over one growing season. Both species increased growth with CO₂enrichment, but this response was mediated by N supply only for the non-fixer, Achillea. Its response depended on mineral N supply as growth enhancements under elevated CO₂ increased from 0% in low N soil to +25% at the higher levels of N addition. In contrast, Lupinus plants had 80% greater biomass under elevated CO₂ regardless of N treatment. Although partial photosynthetic acclimation to CO₂ enrichment occurred, both species maintained comparably higher A in elevated compared to ambient CO₂ (+38%). N addition facilitated increased A in Achillea, however, in neither species did additional N availability affect the acclimation response of A to CO₂. Elevated CO₂ increased plant total N yield by 57% in Lupinus but had no effect on Achillea. The increased N in Lupinus came from symbiotic N₂ fixation, which resulted in a 47% greater proportion of N derived from fixation relative to other sources of N. These results suggest that compared to non-fixing forbs, N₂-fixers exhibit positive photosynthetic and growth responses to increased atmospheric CO₂ that are independent of soil N supply. The enhanced amount of N derived from N₂ fixation under elevated CO₂ presumably helps meet the increased N demand in N₂-fixing species. This response may lead to modified roles of N₂-fixers and N₂-fixer/non-fixer species interactions in grassland communities, especially those that are inherently N-poor, under projected rising atmospheric CO₂.     

Biodiversity effects of elevated CO2 in species-rich model communities from the semi-arid Negev of Israel

Species‐specific responses to atmospheric CO₂ enrichment may affect biodiversity, which in turn may alter ecosystem functioning. Here we have explored biodiversity effects in model assemblages of semi‐arid grassland of the northern Negev, Israel, at 280 ppm (pre‐industrial era), 440 ppm (early 21st century) and 600 ppm CO₂ (mid to late 21st century). Thirty‐two mostly annual species were grown together in large containers (ca 400 kg each) on native soil and under a dynamic simulation of the Negev winter climate. CO₂ enrichment increased concentrations of total non‐structural carbohydrates and C/N ratios, and reduced specific leaf area and nitrogen concentrations in leaves of all species. In contrast to these uniform CO₂ effects on leaf quality, biomass and reproductive output remained unchanged in most species, and varied greatly among the few responsive ones (?80 to +145%). Biomass was significantly increased at elevated CO₂ in Onobrychis crista‐galli (one of the six legume species) and was reduced in Biscutella didyma (Brassicaceae). Seed yield increased in three out of six legumes and in the root hemiparasite Parentucellia flaviflora, and decreased in the grass Aegilops peregrina. Fruit dry matter tended to be reduced in two Brassicaceae. Onobrychis, the largest and most responsive species present, was the most ‘mesic’ legume, and might have profited most from the higher soil moisture induced by CO₂ enrichment. The significant CO₂ response of only 5–6 out of 32 species, in particular their altered seed yield, suggests a potential shift in biodiversity. In a future CO₂‐enriched atmosphere, ‘mesic’ legumes and root hemiparasites might be favored, while some Brassicaceae and grasses might decline. As indicated by significant 280‐ vs 440‐ppm differences, reductions in leaf nitrogen concentration of grasses and legumes are likely to be under way right now, and may negatively affect grazers. Altered seed yields were more pronounced between 440 and 600 ppm, suggesting that these changes could intensify as the atmospheric CO₂ concentration continues to rise.     

The type of competition modulates the ecophysiological response of grassland species to elevated CO2 and drought

The effects of elevated CO₂ and drought on ecophysiological parameters in grassland species have been examined, but few studies have investigated the effect of competition on those parameters under climate change conditions. The objective of this study was to determine the effect of elevated CO₂ and drought on the response of plant water relations, gas exchange, chlorophyll a fluorescence and aboveground biomass in four grassland species, as well as to assess whether the type of competition modulates that response. Elevated CO₂ in well‐watered conditions increased aboveground biomass by augmenting CO₂ assimilation. Drought reduced biomass by reducing CO₂ assimilation rate via stomatal limitation and, when drought was more severe, also non‐stomatal limitation. When plants were grown under the combined conditions of elevated CO₂ and drought, drought limitation observed under ambient CO₂ was reduced, permitting higher CO₂ assimilation and consequently reducing the observed decrease in aboveground biomass. The response to climate change was species‐specific and dependent on the type of competition. Thus, the response to elevated CO₂ in well‐watered grasses was higher in monoculture than in mixture, while it was higher in mixture compared to monoculture for forbs. On the other hand, forbs were more affected than grasses by drought in monoculture, while in mixture the negative effect of drought was higher in grasses than in forbs, due to a lower capacity to acquire water and mineral nutrients. These differences in species‐level growth responses to CO₂ and drought may lead to changes in the composition and biodiversity of the grassland plant community in future climate conditions.     

Seed traits,seed‐reserve utilization and offspring performance across pre‐industrial to future CO2 concentrations in a Mediterranean community

Atmospheric CO₂ enrichment can affect plants directly via impacts on their performance, and indirectly, by environment‐specific traits passed down from the mother plant to the offspring. Such maternal effects can significantly alter plant species composition, especially in annual ecosystems where the entire community is recruited from seeds each year. This study assessed impacts of future, high CO₂ (440 and 600 ppm) and pre‐industrial, low CO₂ (280 ppm) on seed traits and offspring performance in three plant functional groups (grasses, legumes, forbs) comprising 17 annual species of a semi‐arid Mediterranean community. In grasses, seed size and seed‐reserve utilization as expressed by root elongation tended to be higher at high than at low maternal CO₂, but total seed protein concentration and protein pool decreased with increasing maternal CO₂. The response of seed size to high CO₂ increased with increasing leaf‐mass fraction in grasses, and decreased with decreasing concentration of leaf non‐structural carbohydrates in legumes. Offspring development was studied at ambient CO₂, and showed reduced emergence success of high‐CO₂ progeny compared with low‐CO₂ progeny in forbs. Total biomass was lower in high‐CO₂ than in low‐CO₂ offspring across all functional groups. The biomass response to high maternal CO₂ in legume offspring correlated inversely with seed size, resulting in up to 25% lower biomass in large‐seeded species. Under the scenario of maternal effects combined with projected changes in biomass and seed production under direct exposure to high CO₂, legumes might gain and forbs and grasses might lose from future CO₂ enrichment. Most changes in seed traits and offspring performance were greater between pre‐industrial and near‐future CO₂ than between near‐ and remote‐future CO₂ concentrations. Hence, maternal effects of increasing CO₂ may contribute to current changes in plant productivity and species composition, and they need to be considered when predicting impacts of global change on plant communities.     

CO2‐caused change in plant species composition rivals the shift in vegetation between mid‐grass and tallgrass prairies

Atmospheric CO₂ enrichment usually changes the relative contributions of plant species to biomass production of grasslands, but the types of species favored and mechanisms by which change is mediated differ among ecosystems. We measured changes in the contributions of C₃ perennial forbs and C₄ grasses to aboveground biomass production of tallgrass prairie assemblages grown along a field CO₂ gradient (250–500 μmol mol^?1) in central Texas USA. Vegetation was grown on three soil types and irrigated each season with water equivalent to the growing season mean of precipitation for the area. We predicted that CO₂ enrichment would increase the forb contribution to community production, and favor tall‐grasses over mid‐grasses by increasing soil water content and reducing the frequency with which soil water fell below a limitation threshold. CO₂ enrichment favored forbs over grasses on only one of three soil types, a Mollisol. The grass fraction of production increased dramatically across the CO₂ gradient on all soils. Contribution of the tall‐grass Sorghastrum nutans to production increased at elevated CO₂ on the two most coarse‐textured of the soils studied, a clay Mollisol and sandy Alfisol. The CO₂‐caused increase in Sorghastrum was accompanied by an offsetting decline in production of the mid‐grass Bouteloua curtipendula. Increased CO₂ favored the tall‐grass over mid‐grass by increasing soil water content and apparently intensifying competition for light or other resources (Mollisol) or reducing the frequency with which soil water dipped below threshold levels (Alfisol). An increase in CO₂ of 250 μmol mol^?1 above the pre‐industrial level thus led to a shift in the relative production of established species that is similar in magnitude to differences observed between mid‐grass and tallgrass prairies along a precipitation gradient in the central USA. By reducing water limitation to plants, atmospheric CO₂ enrichment may alter the composition and even structure of grassland vegetation.     

Consumption rates and food preferences of slugs in a calcareous grassland under current and future CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> conditions

This study explored consumption of a generalist herbivore feeding on leaf tissue of various plant species of a calcareous grassland, and tested whether consumption levels and preferences changed when plants were exposed to 5 years of in situ CO₂ enrichment. The first part of this experiment tested whether the consumption patterns of slugs (Deroceras reticulatum) observed in single-species feeding tests were altered when slugs were given a choice of food sources. Overall consumption increased 270% when slugs were given a choice, and they preferred having a choice of food sources more than they preferred having any one food source. Surprisingly, slugs consumed fewer legumes and grasses and more non-leguminous forbs when given a choice. In the second part of this experiment, feeding behaviors of slugs in response to elevated CO₂ were investigated by feeding them leaves of two legumes, one grass, and a non-leguminous forb (Trifolium medium, Lotus corniculatus, Bromus erectus, and Sanguisorba minor, respectively) in two or four species combinations. In the leguminous species mix, the non-leguminous species mix, and the combined mix (legumes and non-legumes), neither overall consumption by herbivores nor species preference was significantly altered by long-term CO₂ enrichment. In the combined species mix, slugs preferred legumes to non-legumes (P=0.012) and exhibited a weak functional group preference shift from non-legumes to legumes (P=0.089) in response to CO₂ enrichment. This is the first time such a shift has been observed, and provides evidence that there may be multiple herbivore responses to rising atmospheric CO₂ concentrations. Numerous single-species feeding tests using insects have shown that consumption by herbivores may increase when herbivores are fed plants grown in enriched CO₂ atmospheres. This study clearly demonstrates the limited applicability of non-choice feeding trials to generalist herbivores in species-rich communities. Received: 19 August 1999 / Accepted: 20 April 2000     

Legumes regulate grassland soil N cycling and its response to variation in species diversity and N supply but not CO2

Legumes are an important component of plant diversity that modulate nitrogen (N) cycling in many terrestrial ecosystems. Limited knowledge of legume effects on soil N cycling and its response to global change factors and plant diversity hinders a general understanding of whether and how legumes broadly regulate the response of soil N availability to those factors. In a 17‐year study of perennial grassland species grown under ambient and elevated (+180 ppm) CO₂ and ambient and enriched (+4 g N m^?2 year^?1) N environments, we compared pure legume plots with plots dominated by or including other herbaceous functional groups (and containing one or four species) to assess the effect of legumes on N cycling (net N mineralization rate and inorganic N pools). We also examined the effects of numbers of legume species (from zero to four) in four‐species mixed plots on soil N cycling. We hypothesized that legumes would increase N mineralization rates most in those treatments with the greatest diversity and the greatest relative limitation by and competition for N. Results partially supported these hypotheses. Plots with greater dominance by legumes had greater soil nitrate concentrations and mineralization rates. Higher species richness significantly increased the impact of legumes on soil N metrics, with 349% and 505% higher mineralization rates and nitrate concentrations in four‐species plots containing legumes compared to legume‐free four‐species plots, in contrast to 185% and 129% greater values, respectively, in pure legume than nonlegume monoculture plots. N‐fertilized plots had greater legume effects on soil nitrate, but lower legume effects on net N mineralization. In contrast, neither elevated CO₂ nor its interaction with legumes affected net N mineralization. These results indicate that legumes markedly influence the response of soil N cycling to some, but not all, global change drivers.     

Elevated CO2 enhances water relations and productivity and affects gas exchange in C3 and C4 grasses of the Colorado shortgrass steppe.

Six open‐top chambers were installed on the shortgrass steppe in north‐eastern Colorado, USA from late March until mid‐October in 1997 and 1998 to evaluate how this grassland will be affected by rising atmospheric CO₂. Three chambers were maintained at current CO₂ concentration (ambient treatment), three at twice ambient CO₂, or approximately 720 μmol mol^?1 (elevated treatment), and three nonchambered plots served as controls. Above‐ground phytomass was measured in summer and autumn during each growing season, soil water was monitored weekly, and leaf photosynthesis, conductance and water potential were measured periodically on important C₃ and C₄ grasses. Mid‐season and seasonal above‐ground productivity were enhanced from 26 to 47% at elevated CO₂, with no differences in the relative responses of C₃/C₄ grasses or forbs. Annual above‐ground phytomass accrual was greater on plots which were defoliated once in mid‐summer compared to plots which were not defoliated during the growing season, but there was no interactive effect of defoliation and CO₂ on growth. Leaf photosynthesis was often greater in Pascopyrum smithii (C₃) and Bouteloua gracilis (C₄) plants in the elevated chambers, due in large part to higher soil water contents and leaf water potentials. Persistent downward photosynthetic acclimation in P. smithii leaves prevented large photosynthetic enhancement for elevated CO₂‐grown plants. Shoot N concentrations tended to be lower in grasses under elevated CO₂, but only Stipa comata (C₃) plants exhibited significant reductions in N under elevated compared to ambient CO₂ chambers. Despite chamber warming of 2.6 °C and apparent drier chamber conditions compared to unchambered controls, above‐ground production in all chambers was always greater than in unchambered plots. Collectively, these results suggest increased productivity of the shortgrass steppe in future warmer, CO₂ enriched environments.     

Strong photosynthetic acclimation and enhanced water‐use efficiency in grassland functional groups persist over 21 years of CO2 enrichment,independent of nitrogen supply

Uncertainty about long‐term leaf‐level responses to atmospheric CO₂ rise is a major knowledge gap that exists because of limited empirical data. Thus, it remains unclear how responses of leaf gas exchange to elevated CO₂ (eCO₂) vary among plant species and functional groups, or across different levels of nutrient supply, and whether they persist over time for long‐lived perennials. Here, we report the effects of eCO₂ on rates of net photosynthesis and stomatal conductance in 14 perennial grassland species from four functional groups over two decades in a Minnesota Free‐Air CO₂ Enrichment experiment, BioCON. Monocultures of species belonging to C₃ grasses, C₄ grasses, forbs, and legumes were exposed to two levels of CO₂ and nitrogen supply in factorial combinations over 21 years. eCO₂ increased photosynthesis by 12.9% on average in C₃ species, substantially less than model predictions of instantaneous responses based on physiological theory and results of other studies, even those spanning multiple years. Acclimation of photosynthesis to eCO₂ was observed beginning in the first year and did not strengthen through time. Yet, contrary to expectations, the response of photosynthesis to eCO₂ was not enhanced by increased nitrogen supply. Differences in responses among herbaceous plant functional groups were modest, with legumes responding the most and C₄ grasses the least as expected, but did not further diverge over time. Leaf‐level water‐use efficiency increased by 50% under eCO₂ primarily because of reduced stomatal conductance. Our results imply that enhanced nitrogen supply will not necessarily diminish photosynthetic acclimation to eCO₂ in nitrogen‐limited systems, and that significant and consistent declines in stomatal conductance and increases in water‐use efficiency under eCO₂ may allow plants to better withstand drought.     

A field study of the effects of elevated CO2 on plant biomass and community structure in a calcareous grassland

The effects of elevated CO₂ on plant biomass and community structure have been studied for four seasons in a calcareous grassland in northwest Switzerland. This highly diverse, semi-natural plant community is dominated by the perennial grass Bromus erectus and is mown twice a year to maintain species composition. Plots of 1.3 m² were exposed to ambient or elevated CO₂ concentrations (n = 8) using a novel CO₂ exposure technique, screen-aided CO₂ control (SACC) starting in March 1994. In the 1st year of treatment, the annual harvested biomass (sum of aboveground biomass from mowings in June and October) was not significantly affected by elevated CO₂. However, biomass increased significantly at elevated CO₂ in the 2nd (+20%, P = 0.05), 3rd (+21%, P = 0.02) and 4th years (+29%, P = 0.02). There were no detectable differences in root biomass in the top 8 cm of soil between CO₂ treatments on eight out of nine sampling dates. There were significant differences in CO₂ responsiveness between functional groups (legumes, non-leguminous forbs, graminoids) in the 2nd (P = 0.07) and 3rd (P < 0.001) years of the study. The order of CO₂ responsiveness among functional groups changed substantially from the 2nd to the 3rd year; for example, non-leguminous forbs had the smallest relative response in the 2nd year and the largest in the 3rd year. By the 3rd year of CO₂ exposure, large species-specific differences in CO₂ response had developed. For five important species or genera the order of responsiveness was Lotus corniculatus (+271%), Carex flacca (+249%), Bromus erectus (+33%), Sanguisorba minor (no significant CO₂ effect), and six Trifolium species (a negative response that was not significant). The positive CO₂ responses in Bromus and Carex were most closely related to increases in tiller number. Species richness was not affected by CO₂ treatment, but species evenness increased under elevated CO₂ (modified Hill ratio; P = 0.03) in June of the 3rd year, resulting in a marginally significant increase in species diversity (Simpson's index; P = 0.09). This and other experiments with calcareous grassland plants show that elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentrations can substantially alter the structure of calcareous grassland communities and may increase plant community biomass. Received: 12 July 1997 / Accepted: 14 September 1998     

Biomass responses in a temperate European grassland through 17 years of elevated CO2

Future increase in atmospheric CO₂ concentrations will potentially enhance grassland biomass production and shift the functional group composition with consequences for ecosystem functioning. In the “GiFACE” experiment (Giessen Free Air Carbon dioxide Enrichment), fertilized grassland plots were fumigated with elevated CO₂ (eCO₂) year‐round during daylight hours since 1998, at a level of +20% relative to ambient concentrations (in 1998, aCO₂ was 364 ppm and eCO₂ 399 ppm; in 2014, aCO₂ was 397 ppm and eCO₂ 518 ppm). Harvests were conducted twice annually through 23 years including 17 years with eCO₂ (1998 to 2014). Biomass consisted of C3 grasses and forbs, with a small proportion of legumes. The total aboveground biomass (TAB) was significantly increased under eCO₂ (p = .045 and .025, at first and second harvest). The dominant plant functional group grasses responded positively at the start, but for forbs, the effect of eCO₂ started out as a negative response. The increase in TAB in response to eCO₂ was approximately 15% during the period from 2006 to 2014, suggesting that there was no attenuation of eCO₂ effects over time, tentatively a consequence of the fertilization management. Biomass and soil moisture responses were closely linked. The soil moisture surplus (c. 3%) in eCO₂ manifested in the latter years was associated with a positive biomass response of both functional groups. The direction of the biomass response of the functional group forbs changed over the experimental duration, intensified by extreme weather conditions, pointing to the need of long‐term field studies for obtaining reliable responses of perennial ecosystems to eCO₂ and as a basis for model development.     

The Role of White Clover in the Loss of Diversity in Grassland Habitat Restoration

A field experiment was designed to recreate a species‐rich mesotrophic grassland community of conservation worth. Trifolium repens (white clover) was observed to increase significantly in both frequency and abundance in sown plots grazed by cattle, but not in plots cut in June and subsequently grazed by cattle. In both these treatments permanent quadrats containing clover patches were found to be lower in species richness than were quadrats without clover. In both treatments botanical diversity was seen to decline over time. In the grazed‐only treatment the loss of diversity may be linked to the increase in clover. In the cut and grazed plots, T. repens did not become so abundant but diversity was still seen to decline, possibly due to the loss of low growing species from the taller sward. A pot experiment which varied the sowing density of a mix of seven wild flower species in full factorial combination with cutting frequency was established on soils from an arable field also sown with a single density of clover. T. repens was seen to decline from initial high cover estimates in infrequently cut and uncut treatments. In the pot experiment where a grass component to the vegetation was absent, clover was seen to have less impact on the other forbs than it did in the field. It is suggested that, being a nitrogen fixer, T. repens may have a competitive edge in ex‐arable soils low in available nitrogen. The observed reduction in botanical diversity may be a result of this increase in available nitrogen, facilitating the spread of the sown grasses and preventing the recovery of the sown forbs that were excluded by the invasion of T. repens. It is suggested that reducing the proportion of grass in the seed mixtures during grassland habitat creation on these soils may help reduce or delay this effect.     

Effects of elevated CO2, nitrogen deposition, and decreased species diversity on foliar fungal plant disease

Three components of global change, elevated CO₂, nitrogen addition, and decreased plant species richness (‘diversity’), increased the percent leaf area infected by fungi (pathogen load) for much to all of the plant community in one year of a factorial grassland experiment. Decreased plant diversity had the broadest effect, increasing pathogen load across the plant community. Decreased diversity increased pathogen load primarily by allowing remaining plant species to increase in abundance, facilitating spread of foliar fungal pathogens specific to each plant species. Changes in plant species composition also strongly influenced community pathogen load, with communities that lost less disease prone plant species increasing more in pathogen load. Elevated CO₂ increased pathogen load of C₃ grasses, perhaps by decreasing water stress, increasing leaf longevity, and increasing photosynthetic rate, all of which can promote foliar fungal disease. Decreased plant diversity further magnified the increase in C₃ grass pathogen load under elevated CO₂. Nitrogen addition increased pathogen load of C₄ grasses by increasing foliar nitrogen concentration, which can enhance pathogen infection, growth, and reproduction. Because changes in foliar fungal pathogen load can strongly influence grassland ecosystem processes, our study suggests that increased pathogen load can be an important mechanism by which global change affects grassland ecosystems.     

Soil‐ and plant‐water dynamics in a C3/C4 grassland exposed to a subambient to superambient CO2 gradient

Plants may be more sensitive to carbon dioxide (CO₂) enrichment at subambient concentrations than at superambient concentrations, but field tests are lacking. We measured soil‐water content and determined xylem pressure potentials and δ¹³C values of leaves of abundant species in a C3/C4 grassland exposed during 1997–1999 to a continuous gradient in atmospheric CO₂ spanning subambient through superambient concentrations (200–560 µmol mol^2?1). We predicted that CO₂ enrichment would lessen soil‐water depletion and increase xylem potentials more over subambient concentrations than over superambient concentrations. Because water‐use efficiency of C3 species (net assimilation/leaf conductance; A/g) typically increases as soils dry, we hypothesized that improvements in plant‐water relations at higher CO₂ would lessen positive effects of CO₂ enrichment on A/g. Depletion of soil water to 1.35 m depth was greater at low CO₂ concentrations than at higher CO₂ concentrations during a mid‐season drought in 1998 and during late‐season droughts in 1997 and 1999. During droughts each year, mid‐day xylem potentials of the dominant C4 perennial grass (Bothriochloa ischaemum (L.) Keng) and the dominant C3 perennial forb (Solanum dimidiatum Raf.) became less negative as CO₂ increased from subambient to superambient concentrations. Leaf A/g—derived from leaf δ¹³C values—was insensitive to feedbacks from CO₂ effects on soil water and plant water. Among most C3 species sampled—including annual grasses, perennial grasses and perennial forbs—A/g increased linearly with CO₂ across subambient concentrations. Leaf and air δ¹³C values were too unstable at superambient CO₂ concentrations to reliably determine A/g. Significant changes in soil‐ and plant‐water relations over subambient to superambient concentrations and in leaf A/g over subambient concentrations generally were not greater over low CO₂ than over higher CO₂. The continuous response of these variables to CO₂ suggests that atmospheric change has already improved water relations of grassland species and that periodically water‐limited grasslands will remain sensitive to CO₂ enrichment.     

Long-term responsiveness to free air CO2 enrichment of functional types, species and genotypes of plants from fertile permanent grassland

To test inter- and intraspecific variability in the responsiveness to elevated CO₂, 9–14 different genotypes of each of 12 perennial species from fertile permanent grassland were grown in Lolium perenne swards under ambient (35 Pa) and elevated (60 Pa) atmospheric partial pressure of CO₂ (pCO₂) for 3 years in a free air carbon dioxide enrichment (FACE) experiment. The plant species were grouped according to their functional types: grasses (L. perenne, L. multiflorum, Arrhenatherum elatius, Dactylis glomerata, Festuca pratensis, Holcus lanatus, Trisetum flavescens), non-legume dicots (Rumex obtusifolius, R. acetosa, Ranunculus friesianus), and legumes (Trifolium repens, T. pratense). Yield (above a cutting height of 4.5 cm) was measured three times per year. The results were as follow. (1) There were highly significant differences in the responsiveness to elevated pCO₂ between the three functional types; legumes showed the strongest and grasses the weakest yield increase at elevated pCO₂. (2) There were differences in the temporal development of responsiveness to elevated pCO₂ among the functional types. The responsiveness of the legumes declined from the first to the second year, while the responsiveness of the non-legume dicots increased over the 3 years. During the growing season, the grasses and the non-legume dicots showed the strongest response to elevated pCO₂ during reproductive growth in the spring. (3) There were no significant genotypic differences in responsiveness to elevated pCO₂. Our results suggest that, due to interspecific differences in the responsiveness to elevated pCO₂, the species proportion within fertile temperate grassland may change if the increase in pCO₂ continues. Due to the temporal differences in the responsiveness to elevated pCO₂ among species, complex effects of elevated pCO₂ on competitive interactions in mixed swards must be expected. The existence of genotypic variability in the responsiveness to elevated pCO₂, on which selection could act, was not found under our experimental conditions. Received: 11 May 1997 / Accepted: 11 August 1997