In vitro generation from the trans-Golgi network of coatomer-coated vesicles containing sialylated vesicular stomatitis virus-G protein

We describe an in vitro system in which post-Golgi vesicles containing metabolically labeled, sialylated, vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) G protein molecules (VSV-G) are produced from the trans-Golgi network (TGN) of an isolated Golgi membrane fraction. This fraction is prepared from VSV-infected Madin-Darby canine kidney (MDCK) cells in which the (35)S-labeled viral envelope glycoprotein was allowed to accumulate in the trans-Golgi network during a prolonged incubation at 20 degrees C. The vesicles produced in this system are separated from the remnant Golgi membranes by differential centrifugation or by velocity sedimentation in a sucrose gradient. Vesicle production, quantified as the percentage of labeled VSV-G released from the Golgi membranes, is optimal at 37 degrees C and does not occur below 20 degrees C. It requires GTP and the small GTP-binding protein Arf (ADP-ribosylation factor), as well as coat protein type I (COPI) coat components (coatomer) and vesicle scission factors-one of which corresponds to the phosphatidylinositol transfer protein (PITP). Formation of the vesicles does not require GTP hydrolysis which, however, is necessary for their uncoating. Thus, vesicles generated in the presence of the nonhydrolyzable GTP analogs, GTPgammaS or GMP-PNP, retain a coatomer coat visible in the electron microscope, sediment more rapidly in sucrose density gradients than those generated with ATP or GTP, and can be captured with anticoatomerantibodies. The process of coatomer-coated vesicle formation from the TGN can be dissected into two distinct sequential phases, corresponding to coat assembly/bud formation and vesicle scission. The first phase is completed when Golgi fractions are incubated with cytosolic proteins and nonhydrolyzable GTP analogs at 20 degrees C. The scission phase, which leads to vesicle release, takes place when coated Golgi membranes, recovered after phase I, are incubated at higher temperatures in the presence of cytosolic proteins. The scission phase does not take place if protein kinase C inhibitors are added during the first phase, even though these inhibitors do not prevent membrane coating and bud formation. The phosphorylating activity of a protein kinase C, however, plays no role in vesicle formation, since this process does not require ATP.     

Scission of COPI and COPII Vesicles Is Independent of GTP Hydrolysis

Intracellular transport and maintenance of the endomembrane system in eukaryotes depends on formation and fusion of vesicular carriers. A seeming discrepancy exists in the literature about the basic mechanism in the scission of transport vesicles that depend on GTP‐binding proteins. Some reports describe that the scission of COP‐coated vesicles is dependent on GTP hydrolysis, whereas others found that GTP hydrolysis is not required. In order to investigate this pivotal mechanism in vesicle formation, we analyzed formation of COPI‐ and COPII‐coated vesicles utilizing semi‐intact cells. The small GTPases Sar1 and Arf1 together with their corresponding coat proteins, the Sec23/24 and Sec13/31 complexes for COPII and coatomer for COPI vesicles were required and sufficient to drive vesicle formation. Both types of vesicles were efficiently generated when GTP hydrolysis was blocked either by utilizing the poorly hydrolyzable GTP analogs GTPγS and GMP‐PNP, or with constitutively active mutants of the small GTPases. Thus, GTP hydrolysis is not required for the formation and release of COP vesicles.     

Differential roles of ArfGAP1, ArfGAP2, and ArfGAP3 in COPI trafficking

The formation of coat protein complex I (COPI)–coated vesicles is regulated by the small guanosine triphosphatase (GTPase) adenosine diphosphate ribosylation factor 1 (Arf1), which in its GTP-bound form recruits coatomer to the Golgi membrane. Arf GTPase-activating protein (GAP) catalyzed GTP hydrolysis in Arf1 triggers uncoating and is required for uptake of cargo molecules into vesicles. Three mammalian ArfGAPs are involved in COPI vesicle trafficking; however, their individual functions remain obscure. ArfGAP1 binds to membranes depending on their curvature. In this study, we show that ArfGAP2 and ArfGAP3 do not bind directly to membranes but are recruited via interactions with coatomer. In the presence of coatomer, ArfGAP2 and ArfGAP3 activities are comparable with or even higher than ArfGAP1 activity. Although previously speculated, our results now demonstrate a function for coatomer in ArfGAP-catalyzed GTP hydrolysis by Arf1. We suggest that ArfGAP2 and ArfGAP3 are coat protein–dependent ArfGAPs, whereas ArfGAP1 has a more general function.     

In Vitro Generation from the trans-Golgi Network of Coatomer-Coated Vesicles Containing Sialylated Vesicular Stomatitis Virus-G Protein

We describe an in vitro system in which post-Golgi vesicles containing metabolically labeled, sialylated, vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) G protein molecules (VSV-G) are produced from the trans-Golgi network (TGN) of an isolated Golgi membrane fraction. This fraction is prepared from VSV-infected Madin–Darby canine kidney (MDCK) cells in which the ³⁵S-labeled viral envelope glycoprotein was allowed to accumulate in the trans-Golgi network during a prolonged incubation at 20°C. The vesicles produced in this system are separated from the remnant Golgi membranes by differential centrifugation or by velocity sedimentation in a sucrose gradient. Vesicle production, quantified as the percentage of labeled VSV-G released from the Golgi membranes, is optimal at 37°C and does not occur below 20°C. It requires GTP and the small GTP-binding protein Arf (ADP-ribosylation factor), as well as coat protein type I (COPI) coat components (coatomer) and vesicle scission factors—one of which corresponds to the phosphatidylinositol transfer protein (PITP). Formation of the vesicles does not require GTP hydrolysis which, however, is necessary for their uncoating. Thus, vesicles generated in the presence of the nonhydrolyzable GTP analogs, GTPγS or GMP–PNP, retain a coatomer coat visible in the electron microscope, sediment more rapidly in sucrose density gradients than those generated with ATP or GTP, and can be captured with anticoatomerantibodies. The process of coatomer-coated vesicle formation from the TGN can be dissected into two distinct sequential phases, corresponding to coat assembly/bud formation and vesicle scission. The first phase is completed when Golgi fractions are incubated with cytosolic proteins and nonhydrolyzable GTP analogs at 20°C. The scission phase, which leads to vesicle release, takes place when coated Golgi membranes, recovered after phase I, are incubated at higher temperatures in the presence of cytosolic proteins. The scission phase does not take place if protein kinase C inhibitors are added during the first phase, even though these inhibitors do not prevent membrane coating and bud formation. The phosphorylating activity of a protein kinase C, however, plays no role in vesicle formation, since this process does not require ATP.     

COPI budding within the Golgi stack

The Golgi serves as a hub for intracellular membrane traffic in the eukaryotic cell. Transport within the early secretory pathway, that is within the Golgi and from the Golgi to the endoplasmic reticulum, is mediated by COPI-coated vesicles. The COPI coat shares structural features with the clathrin coat, but differs in the mechanisms of cargo sorting and vesicle formation. The small GTPase Arf1 initiates coating on activation and recruits en bloc the stable heptameric protein complex coatomer that resembles the inner and the outer shells of clathrin-coated vesicles. Different binding sites exist in coatomer for membrane machinery and for the sorting of various classes of cargo proteins. During the budding of a COPI vesicle, lipids are sorted to give a liquid-disordered phase composition. For the release of a COPI-coated vesicle, coatomer and Arf cooperate to mediate membrane separation.     

Several ADP-ribosylation factor (Arf) isoforms support COPI vesicle formation

Newly synthesized proteins and lipids are transported in vesicular carriers along the secretory pathway. Arfs (ADP-ribosylation factors), a family of highly conserved GTPases within the Ras superfamily, control recruitment of molecular coats to membranes, the initial step of coated vesicle biogenesis. Arf1 and coatomer constitute the minimal cytosolic machinery leading to COPI vesicle formation from Golgi membranes. Although some functional redundancies have been suggested, other Arf isoforms have been poorly analyzed in this context. In this study, we found that Arf1, Arf4, and Arf5, but not Arf3 and Arf6, associate with COPI vesicles generated in vitro from Golgi membranes and purified cytosol. Using recombinant myristoylated proteins, we show that Arf1, Arf4, and Arf5 each support COPI vesicle formation individually. Unexpectedly, we found that Arf3 could also mediate vesicle biogenesis. However, Arf3 was excluded from the vesicle fraction in the presence of the other isoforms, highlighting a functional competition between the different Arf members.     

A structure-based mechanism for Arf1-dependent recruitment of coatomer to membranes

Budding of COPI-coated vesicles from Golgi membranes requires an Arf family G protein and the coatomer complex recruited from cytosol. Arf is also required with coatomer-related clathrin adaptor complexes to bud vesicles from the trans-Golgi network and endosomal compartments. To understand the structural basis for Arf-dependent recruitment of a vesicular coat to the membrane, we determined the structure of Arf1 bound to the γζ-COP subcomplex of coatomer. Structure-guided biochemical analysis reveals that a second Arf1-GTP molecule binds to βδ-COP at a site common to the γ- and β-COP subunits. The Arf1-binding sites on coatomer are spatially related to PtdIns4,5P(2)-binding sites on the endocytic AP2 complex, providing evidence that the orientation of membrane binding is general for this class of vesicular coat proteins. A bivalent GTP-dependent binding mode has implications for the dynamics of coatomer interaction with the Golgi and for the selection of cargo molecules.     

Kinetic analysis of Arf GAP1 indicates a regulatory role for coatomer

Arf GAPs are a family of enzymes that catalyze the hydrolysis of GTP bound to Arf. Arf GAP1 is one member of the family that has a critical role in membrane traffic at the Golgi apparatus. Two distinct models for the regulation of Arf GAP1 in membrane traffic have been proposed. In one model, Arf GAP1 functions in a ternary complex with coat proteins and is inhibited by cargo proteins. In another model, Arf GAP1 is recruited to a membrane surface that has defects created by the increased membrane curvature that accompanies transport vesicle formation. Here we have used kinetic and mutational analysis to test predictions of models of regulation of Arf GAP1. We found that Arf GAP1 has a similar affinity for Arf1.GTP as another Arf GAP, ASAP1, but the catalytic rate is approximately 0.5% that of ASAP1. Coatomer stimulated Arf GAP1 activity; however, different from that predicted from the current model, coatomer affected the K(m) and not the k(cat) values. Effects of most mutations in Arf GAP1 paralleled those in ASAP1. Mutation of an arginine that aligned with an arginine presumed to be catalytic in ASAP1 abrogated activity. Peptide from the cytoplasmic tail of cargo proteins inhibited Arf GAP1; however, the unrelated Arf GAP ASAP1 was also inhibited. The curvature of the lipid bilayer had a small effect on activity of Arf GAP1 under the conditions of our experiments. We conclude that coatomer is an allosteric regulator of Arf GAP1. The relevance of the results to the two models of Arf GAP1-mediated regulation of Arf1 is discussed.     

ArfGAP1 Activity and COPI Vesicle Biogenesis

Golgi-derived coat protein I (COPI) vesicles mediate transport in the early secretory pathway. The minimal machinery required for COPI vesicle formation from Golgi membranes in vitro consists of (i) the hetero-heptameric protein complex coatomer, (ii) the small guanosine triphosphatase ADP-ribosylation factor 1 (Arf1) and (iii) transmembrane proteins that function as coat receptors, such as p24 proteins. Various and opposing reports exist on a role of ArfGAP1 in COPI vesicle biogenesis. In this study, we show that, in contrast to data in the literature, ArfGAP1 is not required for COPI vesicle formation. To investigate roles of ArfGAP1 in vesicle formation, we titrated the enzyme into a defined reconstitution assay to form and purify COPI vesicles. We find that catalytic amounts of Arf1GAP1 significantly reduce the yield of purified COPI vesicles and that Arf1 rather than ArfGAP1 constitutes a stoichiometric component of the COPI coat. Combining the controversial reports with the results presented in this study, we suggest a novel role for ArfGAP1 in membrane trafficking.     

Coatomer vesicles are not required for inhibition of Golgi transport by G-protein activators

The G-protein activators guanosine 5'-O-(3-thiodiphosphate) (GTPΓS) and aluminum fluoride (AlF) are thought to inhibit transport between Golgi cisternae by causing the accumulation of nonfunctional coatomer-coated transport vesicles on the Golgi. Although GTPΓS and AlF inhibit transport in cell-free intra-Golgi transport systems, blocking coatomer vesicle formation does not. We therefore determined whether inhibition of in vitro Golgi transport by these agents requires coatomer vesicle formation. Depletion of coatomer was found to completely block coated vesicle formation on Golgi cisternae without affecting inhibition of in vitro transport by either GTPΓS or AlF. Depletion of ADP-ribosylation factor (ARF) prevented inhibition of transport by GTPΓS, but not by AlF, suggesting that the AlF-sensitive component in transport may not be a GTP-binding protein. Surprisingly, depletion of cytosolic ARF did not prevent the GTPΓS-induced formation of Golgi-coated vesicles, whereas ARF was required for AlF-induced vesicle formation. Although ARF or coatomer depletion caused an increase in the fenestration of cisternae, no other utrastructural changes were observed that might explain the inhibition of transport by GTPΓS or AlF. These findings suggest that ARF-GTPΓS and AlF act by distinct and coatomer-independent mechanisms to inhibit membrane fusion in cell-free intra-Golgi transport.     

Multiple and stepwise interactions between coatomer and ADP-ribosylation factor-1 (Arf1)-GTP

The small GTPase ADP-ribosylation factor-1 (Arf1) plays a key role in the formation of coat protein I (COP I)-coated vesicles. Upon recruitment to the donor Golgi membrane by interaction with dimeric p24 proteins, Arf1's GDP is exchanged for GTP. Arf1-GTP then dissociates from p24, and together with other Golgi membrane proteins, it recruits coatomer, the heptameric coat protein complex of COP I vesicles, from the cytosol. In this process, Arf1 was shown to specifically interact with the coatomer beta and gamma-COP subunits through its switch I region, and with epsilon-COP. Here, we mapped the interaction of the Arf1-GTP switch I region to the trunk domains of beta and gamma-COP. Site-directed photolabeling at position 167 in the C-terminal helix of Arf1 revealed a novel interaction with coatomer via a putative longin domain of delta-COP. Thus, coatomer is linked to the Golgi through multiple interfaces with membrane-bound Arf1-GTP. These interactions are located within the core, adaptor-like domain of coatomer, indicating an organizational similarity between the COP I coat and clathrin adaptor complexes.     

Endocytosis: clathrin-mediated membrane budding

Clathrin-dependent endocytosis is the major pathway for the uptake of nutrients and signaling molecules in higher eukaryotic cells. The long-held tenet that clathrin-coated vesicles are created from flat coated plasma membrane patches by a sequential process of invagination, bud formation and fission recently received strong support from the results of advanced live cell fluorescence microscopy. The data on the critical components that deform the plasma membrane locally into a coated bud suggest that membrane bending is a team effort requiring membrane-curving protein domains, actin dynamics and, last but not least, clathrin. The scission step requires the mechano-enzymatic function of dynamin, actin dynamics and possibly myosin motor proteins. Finally, a burst of auxilin/GAK initiates the uncoating of the vesicle.     

Insights into the Mechanisms of Membrane Curvature and Vesicle Scission by the Small GTPase Sar1 in the Early Secretory Pathway

The small GTPase protein Sar1 is known to be involved in both the initiation of COPII-coated vesicle formation and scission of the nascent vesicle from the endoplasmic reticulum. The molecular details for the mechanism of membrane remodeling by Sar1 remain unresolved. Here, we show that Sar1 transforms synthetic liposomes into structures of different morphologies including tubules and detached vesicles. We demonstrate that Sar1 alone is competent for vesicle scission in a manner that depends on the concentration of Sar1 molecules occupying the membrane. Sar1 molecules align on low-curvature membranes to form an extended lattice. The continuity of this lattice breaks down as the curvature locally increases. The smallest repeating unit constituting the ordered lattice is a Sar1 dimer. The three-dimensional structure of the Sar1 lattice was reconstructed by substituting spherical liposomes with galactoceramide lipid tubules of homogeneous diameter. These data suggest that Sar1 dimerization is responsible for the formation of constrictive membrane curvature. We propose a model whereby Sar1 dimers assemble into ordered arrays to promote membrane constriction and COPII-directed vesicle scission.     

Arf GAP2 is positively regulated by coatomer and cargo

Arf GAP2 is one of four Arf GAPs that function in the Golgi apparatus. We characterized the kinetics of Arf GAP2 and its regulation. Purified Arf GAP2 had little activity compared to purified Arf GAP1. Of the potential regulators we examined, coatomer had the greatest effect, stimulating activity one to two orders of magnitude. The effect was biphasic, with half-maximal activation observed at 50 nM coatomer and activation peaking at ≈ 150 nM coatomer. Activation by coatomer was greater for Arf GAP2 than has been reported for Arf GAP1. The effects of phosphoinositides and changes in vesicle curvature on GAP activity were small compared to coatomer; however, both increased coatomer-dependent activity. Peptides from p24 cargo proteins increased Arf GAP2 activity by an additional 2- to 4-fold. The effect of cargo peptide was dependent on coatomer. Overexpressing the cargo protein p25 decreased cellular Arf1?GTP levels. The differential sensitivity of Arf GAP1 and Arf GAP2 to coatomer could coordinate their activities. Based on the common regulatory features of Arf GAP1 and 2, we propose a mechanism for cargo selection in which GTP hydrolysis triggered by cargo binding to the coat protein is coupled to coat polymerization.     

Induction of mutant dynamin specifically blocks endocytic coated vesicle formation

Dynamin is the mammalian homologue to the Drosophila shibire gene product. Mutations in this 100-kD GTPase cause a pleiotropic defect in endocytosis. To further investigate its role, we generated stable HeLa cell lines expressing either wild-type dynamin or a mutant defective in GTP binding and hydrolysis driven by a tightly controlled, tetracycline- inducible promoter. Overexpression of wild-type dynamin had no effect. In contrast, coated pits failed to become constricted and coated vesicles failed to bud in cells overexpressing mutant dynamin so that endocytosis via both transferrin (Tfn) and EGF receptors was potently inhibited. Coated pit assembly, invagination, and the recruitment of receptors into coated pits were unaffected. Other vesicular transport pathways, including Tfn receptor recycling, Tfn receptor biosynthesis, and cathepsin D transport to lysosomes via Golgi-derived coated vesicles, were unaffected. Bulk fluid-phase uptake also continued at the same initial rates as wild type. EM immunolocalization showed that membrane-bound dynamin was specifically associated with clathrin-coated pits on the plasma membrane. Dynamin was also associated with isolated coated vesicles, suggesting that it plays a role in vesicle budding. Like the Drosophila shibire mutant, HeLa cells overexpressing mutant dynamin accumulated long tubules, many of which remained connected to the plasma membrane. We conclude that dynamin is specifically required for endocytic coated vesicle formation, and that its GTP binding and hydrolysis activities are required to form constricted coated pits and, subsequently, for coated vesicle budding.     

Physical aspects of COPI vesicle formation

Coat proteins orchestrate membrane budding and molecular sorting during the formation of transport intermediates. Coat protein complex I (COPI) vesicles shuttle between the Golgi apparatus and the endoplasmic reticulum and between Golgi stacks. The formation of a COPI vesicle proceeds in four steps: coat self-assembly, membrane deformation into a bud, fission of the coated vesicle and final disassembly of the coat to ensure recycling of coat components. Although some issues are still actively debated, the molecular mechanisms of COPI vesicle formation are now fairly well understood. In this review, we argue that physical parameters are critical regulators of COPI vesicle formation. We focus on recent real-time in vitro assays highlighting the role of membrane tension, membrane composition, membrane curvature and lipid packing in membrane remodelling and fission by the COPI coat.     

The role of dynamin and its binding partners in coated pit invagination and scission

Plasma membrane clathrin-coated vesicles form after the directed assembly of clathrin and the adaptor complex, AP2, from the cytosol onto the membrane. In addition to these structural components, several other proteins have been implicated in clathrin-coated vesicle formation. These include the large molecular weight GTPase, dynamin, and several Src homology 3 (SH3) domain-containing proteins which bind to dynamin via interactions with its COOH-terminal proline/arginine-rich domain (PRD). To understand the mechanism of coated vesicle formation, it is essential to determine the hierarchy by which individual components are targeted to and act in coated pit assembly, invagination, and scission.To address the role of dynamin and its binding partners in the early stages of endocytosis, we have used well-established in vitro assays for the late stages of coated pit invagination and coated vesicle scission. Dynamin has previously been shown to have a role in scission of coated vesicles. We show that dynamin is also required for the late stages of invagination of clathrin-coated pits. Furthermore, dynamin must bind and hydrolyze GTP for its role in sequestering ligand into deeply invaginated coated pits.We also demonstrate that the SH3 domain of endophilin, which binds both synaptojanin and dynamin, inhibits both late stages of invagination and also scission in vitro. This inhibition results from a reduction in phosphoinositide 4,5-bisphosphate levels which causes dissociation of AP2, clathrin, and dynamin from the plasma membrane. The dramatic effects of the SH3 domain of endophilin led us to propose a model for the temporal order of addition of endophilin and its binding partner synaptojanin in the coated vesicle cycle.     

The LEA proteins and trehalose loving couple: a step forward in anhydrobiotic engineering

Arf family GTP-binding proteins function in the regulation of membrane-trafficking events and in the maintenance of organelle structure. They act at membrane surfaces to modify lipid composition and to recruit coat proteins for the generation of transport vesicles. Arfs associate with membranes through insertion of an N-terminal myristoyl moiety in conjunction with an adjacent amphipathic alpha-helix, which embeds in the lipid bilayer when Arf1 is GTP-bound. In this issue of the Biochemical Journal, Lundmark et al. report that myristoylated Arfs in the presence of GTP bind to and cause tubulation of liposomes, and that GTP exchange on to Arfs is more efficient in the presence of liposomes of smaller diameter (increased curvature). These findings suggest that Arf protein activation and membrane interaction may initiate membrane curvature that will be enhanced further by coat proteins during vesicle formation.     

Physical aspects of COPI vesicle formation

Abstract

Coat proteins orchestrate membrane budding and molecular sorting during the formation of transport intermediates. Coat protein complex I (COPI) vesicles shuttle between the Golgi apparatus and the endoplasmic reticulum and between Golgi stacks. The formation of a COPI vesicle proceeds in four steps: coat self-assembly, membrane deformation into a bud, fission of the coated vesicle and final disassembly of the coat to ensure recycling of coat components. Although some issues are still actively debated, the molecular mechanisms of COPI vesicle formation are now fairly well understood. In this review, we argue that physical parameters are critical regulators of COPI vesicle formation. We focus on recent real-time in vitro assays highlighting the role of membrane tension, membrane composition, membrane curvature and lipid packing in membrane remodelling and fission by the COPI coat.     

A role for phosphatidic acid in COPI vesicle fission yields insights into Golgi maintenance

Proteins essential for vesicle formation by the Coat Protein I (COPI) complex are being identified, but less is known about the role of specific lipids. Brefeldin-A ADP-ribosylated substrate (BARS) functions in the fission step of COPI vesicle formation. Here, we show that BARS induces membrane curvature in cooperation with phosphatidic acid. This finding has allowed us to further delineate COPI vesicle fission into two sub-stages: 1) an earlier stage of bud-neck constriction, in which BARS and other COPI components are required, and 2) a later stage of bud-neck scission, in which phosphatidic acid generated by phospholipase D2 (PLD2) is also required. Moreover, in contrast to the disruption of the Golgi seen on perturbing the core COPI components (such as coatomer), inhibition of PLD2 causes milder disruptions, suggesting that such COPI components have additional roles in maintaining Golgi structure other than through COPI vesicle formation.