Structure of the gene of tum- transplantation antigen P35B: presence of a point mutation in the antigenic allele.

Mutagen treatment of P815 tumour cells produces tum- variants that are rejected by syngeneic mice because they express new transplantation antigens. These 'tum-' antigens elicit a cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) response but no detectable antibody response. The DNA of tum- variant P35 was transfected into P815 cell line P1.HTR. Transfectants expressing tum- antigen P35B were identified on the basis of their ability to stimulate anti-P35B CTL. This was repeated with a cosmid library and a cosmid carrying the sequence encoding antigen P35B was recovered from a transfectant expressing the antigen. Gene P35B is 6 kb long and contains 11 exons. The sequence shows no homology with the previously identified tum- gene P91A nor with any gene presently recorded in the data banks. The antigenic allele of gene P35B differs from the normal allele by a point mutation located in exon 5. This mutation, which replaces a Ser by an Asn residue, was shown by site-directed mutagenesis to be responsible for the expression of the antigen. A synthetic decapeptide covering the sequence surrounding the tum- mutation rendered P815 cells sensitive to lysis by anti-P35B CTL. Surprisingly, the homologous peptide corresponding to the normal sequence of the gene had the same effect, indicating that this tum- mutation does not exert its effect by generating the aggretope or the epitope of the antigenic peptide. As observed previously with gene P91A, we found that fragments of gene P35B containing only exons 4 and 5, which were cloned in non-expression vectors, transferred efficiently the expression of the antigen.     

Efficient expression of tum− antigen P91A by transfected subgenic fragments

Mutagen treatment of mouse P815 tumor cells produces immunogenic mutants that express new transplantation antigens (tum^– antigens) recognized by cytolytic T cells. The gene encoding tum^– antigen P91A comprises 12 exons and a mutation located in exon 4 is responsible for the production of a new antigenic peptide. Transfection experiments showed that the expression of the antigen could be transferred not only by the entire gene but also by gene segments comprising only the mutated exon and parts of the surrounding introns. This was observed with subgenic regions that were not cloned in expression vectors. Antigen expression did not require the integration of the transfected gene segment into a resident P91A gene by homologous recombination. It also occurred when the subgenic segment was transfected without the usual selective gene, which comprises an eucaryotic promoter, and also without plasmid sequences, which are known to contain weak promoters. When a stop codon was introduced at the beginning of exon 4, the expression of the antigen was maintained and evidence was obtained that an ATG codon located in this region served as initiation site for the translation of the antigenic peptide. But we have not obtained evidence indicating that antigenic peptides are direct translation products rather than degradation products of entire proteins. Address correspondence and offprint requests to: T. Boon.     

Immunogenic variants obtained by mutagenesis of mouse mastocytoma P815. VII. Dominant expression of variant antigens in somatic cell hybrids

After mutagenesis of mouse mastocytoma P815, it is possible to obtain at high frequency stable tumor cell variants (tum-) that are rejected by syngeneic DBA/2 mice. Most of the variants express one or more new individual antigens specific for each variant, that are detectable in vitro by cytolytic T cells (CTL). Somatic hybrids were prepared either between tum- variants and the original P815 clone, or between different variants. Antigen expression of the hybrids was assessed by using long-term CTL clones that recognize specifically the new antigen present on the variants. Expression of tum- variant antigens behaved as a dominant trait in the hybrids. By submitting the somatic hybrids to selection with CTL clones, it was possible to obtain antigen-loss hybrid variants. The analyses of these antigen-loss variants showed that two variant-specific antigenic determinants associated with one of the variant fusion partners could be lost independently. Like the parental tum- variants, both the (tum+ X tum-) and (tum- X tum-) hybrids failed to form tumors in normal mice but formed tumors in irradiated mice.     

Tum—mutation P35B generates the MHC-binding site of a new antigenic peptide

Immunogenic tumor cell variant P35 was obtained by mutagen treatment of mouse mastocytoma P815. It express a potent new antigen recognized by syngeneic cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL). This antigen is the result of a point mutation in a gene that is expressed by most healthy cells. A decapeptide encoded by the region spanning the mutation sensitized P815 cells to the relevant CTL, whereas the homologous decapeptide corresponding to the normal sequence did not. Only the mutant decapeptide was capable of enhancing the expression of the D^d-presenting molecule at the cell surface, indicating that the mutation generates a motif which enables the antigenic peptide to bind to D^d. Correspondence to: T. Boon.     

Immunogenic (tum−) variants obtained by mutagenesis of mouse mastocytoma P815

Mutagen treatment of mouse mastocytoma P815 produces highly inununogenic tum^– variants. Most of these variants express potent transplantation antigens which are not present on the original P815 tumor cells. These tum^– antigens, which appear to be specific for each variant, elicit a strong cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) response, but do not seem to induce a specific antibody response. As a first step in the isolation of the gene of a tum^– antigen, we attempted DNA-mediated gene transfer. As a DNA recipient cell we used P1.HTR, a highly transfectable P815 cell line, whose selection has been previously described. For the detection of antigen-expressing cells in transfected populations we developed a procedure that relies on the ability of these cells to stimulate the proliferation of the relevant CTL. Using DNA from tum^– variant P91 mixed with a plasmid carrying an antibiotic resistance gene, we obtained several independent transfectants expressing a tum^– antigen, at a frequency of approximately 1 in 13 000 antibiotic-resistant transfectants. These transfectants express only one of the two tum^– antigens that were identified on P91, suggesting that these tum^– antigens correspond to different genes. We expect that the detection procedure described here will be-suitable for the identification of transfectants for any gene that determines the expression of an antigen recognized by CTL.     

Identification of a second major tumor-specific antigen recognized by CTLs on mouse mastocytoma P815

Murine mastocytoma P815 induces CTL responses against at least four distinct Ags (AB, C, D, and E). Recent studies have shown that the main component of the CTL response against the P815 tumor is targeted against Ags P815AB and P815E. The gene P1A has been well characterized. It encodes the P815AB Ag in the form of a nonameric peptide containing two epitopes, P815A and P815B, which are recognized by different CTLs. Here, we report the identification of the P815E Ag. Using a cDNA library derived from tumor P815, we identified the gene coding for P815E. We also characterized the antigenic peptide that anti-P815E CTLs recognize on the MHC class I molecule H-2Kd. The P815E Ag results from a mutation within an ubiquitously expressed gene encoding methionine sulfoxide reductase, an enzyme that is believed to be important in the protection of proteins against the by-products of aerobic metabolism. Surprisingly, immunizing mice i.p. with syngeneic tumor cells (L1210) that were constructed to express B7-1 and P815E did not induce resistance against live P815, even though a strong anti-P815E CTL response was observed with splenocytes from immunized animals.     

Structural characterization and chromosomal localization of the MAGE-E1 gene

Genes of the melanoma-associated antigen (MAGE) family are characterized by the expression of tumor antigens on a malignant melanoma recognized by autologous cytolytic T lymphocytes. We have previously identified novel members of the MAGE gene family expressed in human glioma and named them MAGE-E1a-c. In the present study, we have revealed the genomic structure of MAGE-E1 by sequence analysis of a human chromosome bacterial artificial chromosome clone containing the MAGE-E1 gene. The MAGE-E1 gene is composed of 13 exons, and three of these (exon 2, exon 3 and exon 12) are alternatively spliced in each variant (E1a-c). The open reading frame encoding the MAGE-E1 peptides initiates in exon 2 and ends in exon 13. We have also demonstrated that the MAGE-E1 gene is located in Xp11 through the analysis of radiation hybrid panels. The genomic structure of MAGE-E1 is markedly similar to that of MAGE-D and its chromosomal locus is also identical to that of MAGE-D, but these features contrast with those of other MAGEs. These results suggest that MAGE-D and -E1 may be evolutionarily distant from other members of the MAGE family, and the two may be ancestral genes for the others.     

Cytolytic activity of Ia-restricted T cell clones and hybridomas: evidence for a cytolytic mechanism independent of interferon-gamma, lymphotoxin, and tumor necrosis factor-alpha

Ten different helper T cell (Th) hybridomas that are specific to Ia or antigen plus Ia were found to express nonspecific cytolytic activity toward the cytotoxin (CT)-resistant P815 cells upon activation with either Con A or a monoclonal anti-T3 antibody (T3-mAb). In contrast to cytolytic Th1 clones which secrete high levels of interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) and cytotoxin (CT) (lymphotoxin (LT, also known as TNF-beta) or tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha], these Th hybridomas produce low or undetectable levels of IFN-gamma and CT. No inhibitory activity of IFN-gamma and CT was observed in culture supernatants of activated Th hybridomas. Double-chamber experiments demonstrated that CT-sensitive L929 cells when physically separated from activated Th1 clones were killed by membrane-permeable CT. Under identical experimental conditions, lysis of P815 cells did not occur. Moreover, activation of Th hybridomas directly in wells containing the CT-sensitive L929 cells failed to induce target cell lysis. This confirms that these Th hybridomas produce little CT and argues against high local concentrations of CT being responsible for Th hybridoma-mediated killing of P815 cells. Finally, a polyclonal rabbit antiserum to rTNF-alpha, which strongly and specifically inhibited CT-mediated and Th1 clone-mediated killing of L929 cells, failed to inhibit P815 lysis by activated Th1 clones and Th hybridomas. These observations establish that a cytolytic mechanism independent of IFN-gamma, LT, and TNF-alpha is responsible for lysis of CT-resistant target cells.     

Regulation of cytolytic activity in CD3- and CD3+ killer cell clones by monoclonal antibodies (anti-CD16, anti-CD2, anti-CD3) depends on subclass specificity of target cell IgG-FcR

Anti-CD3 MAb can inhibit MHC-restricted cytolytic activity of CD3+ mature cytotoxic T cells. In particular effector-target cell combinations, however, anti-CD3 MAb enhance or induce cytolysis by cross-linking CD3+ effector and IgG-FcR+ target cells. Virtually all natural killer (NK) cells or NK cell-derived clones are CD3-4-8- but do express CD2 and CD16 (IgG-FcR) antigens. We have studied how these cell surface molecules are involved in the regulation of cytolytic activities. The addition of anti-CD2 MAb to effector and target cells was found to induce conjugate formation of the IgG-FcR+ target cells with the effector cell and nonspecific cytolysis of, for instance, the P815 mouse mastocytoma cells. Enhancement or induction of conjugate formation and cytolysis of IgG-FcR+, P815, U937, and Daudi cells was also accomplished by using anti-CD16 MAb (e.g., Leu-11c (B73.1) or CLB Fc-gran 1 (VD2) MAb). Some human and mouse tumor cell lines (K562, P815, and U937) appear to express distinct types of IgG-FcR, showing different affinities for distinct subclasses of MAb (e.g., IgG1, IgG2a), but another line (Daudi) expresses only one type of IgG-FcR preferentially binding IgG1 MAb. Here we demonstrate that IgG-FcR on the effector cells can act as activation sites because anti-CD3 as well as anti-CD16 MAb of IgG1 and IgG2a subclasses can induce lytic activity of target cells bearing the relevant IgG-FcR. These data demonstrate that induction of conjugate formation and cytolysis by MAb occur when the target cells bear IgG-FcR with "specificity" for those MAb. Thus, besides via CD3, cytolytic activity by mature T and NK cells also can be induced via the CD2 and CD16 antigens on these cells.     

Contribution of the T cell receptor BJ gene to recognition of the P91A tumor antigen in DBA/2 mice

 To understand specific immune responses against a tumor, it is important to characterize T cells that recognize the tumor antigen. The mouse P91A antigen is one of the well-defined tumor antigens that is expressed on the P911 cell line, and T cells responding to the antigen in DBA/2 mice were reported to be restricted to BV8S2/S3 families in their T cell receptor (TCR) BV gene usage. We have further characterized the P91A-responding T cells in DBA/2 mice, focusing on TCR BJ gene usage and using the polymerase chain reaction/enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and DNA sequencing studies of their third complementarity-determining (CDR3) regions. As a result, T cells with cytotoxic activity to the P91A antigen, induced from murine spleen cells both in vivo and in vitro, showed predominant use of the BJ2S1 gene segment in both BV8S2 and BV8S3 T cells compared to unmanipulated murine spleen cells. Sequencing studies of the CDR3 regions in the BV8S3 T cells revealed clonal expansion of T cells with the BV8S3-BJ2S1 combination in two of three DBA/2 mice tested. In the remaining mouse, clonal expansion was not detected despite predominant use of the BJ2S1 segment by these T cells. These data suggest that P91A-recognizing T cells would predominantly use the BV8S2/S3-BJ2S1 combination. Analysis of T cells with these TCR BV-BJ gene combinations may contribute to the evaluation, monitoring and development of a T-cell-mediated immunotherapeutic strategy. Received: 3 July 1997 / Accepted: 17 November 1997     

B7-H3 enhances tumor immunity in vivo by costimulating rapid clonal expansion of antigen-specific CD8+ cytolytic T cells

B7-H3 is a B7 family molecule with T cell costimulatory function in vitro. The in vivo role of B7-H3 in the stimulation of tumor immunity is unclear. We report here that expression of B7-H3 by transfection of the mouse P815 tumor line enhances its immunogenicity, leading to the regression of tumors and amplification of a tumor-specific CD8+ CTL response in syngeneic mice. Tumor cells engineered to express B7-H3 elicit a rapid clonal expansion of P1A tumor Ag-specific CD8+ CTL in lymphoid organs in vivo and acquire the ability to directly stimulate T cell growth, division, and development of cytolytic activity in vitro. Our results thus establish a role for B7-H3 in the costimulation of T cell immune responses in vivo.     

Induction of cytolytic T lymphocytes by immunization of mice with an adenovirus containing a mouse homolog of the human MAGE-A genes

The genes of the MAGE-A family code for antigens that are strictly tumor-specific and are shared by many human tumors. Melanoma patients have been immunized against these antigens and some tumor regressions have been observed. However, no unequivocal evidence of cytolytic T cell responses has been obtained by analyzing the blood lymphocytes of these patients. Hence it was considered worthwhile to examine in mouse systems whether or not immunization against antigens derived from the mouse Mage homologs can produce cytolytic T cell responses. We have identified an antigenic peptide encoded by mouse gene Mage-a2, and here we show that immunization of DBA/2 mice with a recombinant adenovirus containing either just the sequence encoding this peptide or a large part of the Mage-a2 coding sequence produces strong cytolytic T cell responses. The Mage-a2 system should prove useful for the comparison of vaccination modalities that could be applied to human patients in therapeutic vaccination trials with MAGE antigens. Received: 1 June 2000 / Accepted: 17 August 2000     

Retrovirus antigens recognized by cytolytic T lymphocytes activate tumor rejection in vivo

We have initiated the molecular definition of the antigens recognized by Gross MuLV-specific cytolytic T lymphocytes on the surface of Gross MuLV-induced tumor cells. A panel of target cells was obtained by the double transfection and expression of a retrovirus gene and a foreign H-2 gene in recipient mouse fibroblasts. Our results show that class I H-2 transplantation antigens have a directive influence in determining the antigenicity of proteins encoded by the gag and env MuLV genes. Genes not linked to H-2 influence the intensity and the specificity of the cytolytic T lymphocyte response to Gross MuLV-induced tumors. Finally, MuLV-induced antigens expressed by transfected fibroblasts induce tumor immunity and lead to accelerated tumor rejection in vivo.     

Characterization of an anti-idiotypic T cell hybridoma involved in the regulation of the immune response to the P815 mastocytoma

We report the isolation and characterization of a T cell hybridoma (A29) which secretes a factor that exhibits anti-idiotypic and immune-modulating characteristics. The A29 cell line is thought to represent the hybrid analog of the Ts2 suppressor cell population in the cascade regulating the immune response to the P815 tumor in DBA/2 mice. The putative TsF2 molecule is reactive with the monoclonal antibody B16G, shown previously by us to bind a public specificity of T suppressor factors (TsF). A29 TsF also exhibits specific binding to a TsF1 secreted by another T cell hybridoma, A10, which shows specificity for antigen from the P815 tumor (this has been described previously). A29 itself does not exhibit binding to P815 antigens. Affinity-purified material from A29 appears to share characteristics with A10 molecules in that the predominant material has an apparent m.w. of 70,000. Studies with calcium flux of A29 cells showed that they respond significantly and specifically on exposure to A10 TsF stimulus. We showed further that affinity-purified A29 TsF molecules can specifically suppress the in vitro generation of syngeneic CTL to the P815 tumor, and that panning of DBA/2 splenocytes over A29-TsF-coated plates renders cell populations capable of generating a higher in vitro CTL response to P815 than appropriately treated controls.     

Enhancement by IL-12 of the cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) response of mice immunized with tumor-specific peptides in an adjuvant containing QS21 and MPL.

Immunization of cancer patients with tumor-specific antigenic peptides is currently being tested in several clinical studies. We have examined the induction of CTL responses in mice after various modalities of peptide vaccination, to explore protocols that could be applied to humans. Our first model antigen was P198, which results from a point mutation in a normal gene. While two immunizations with peptide P198 in SBAS-1c adjuvant induced measurable CTL responses in less than 10% of DBA/2 mice, the addition of IL-12 to the peptide adjuvant mixture resulted in high CTL responses in nearly all mice. This strong enhancing effect of IL-12 was observed with 1,000 and 300 units and decreased gradually as the doses were reduced to 30 units. When IL-12 was replaced by other cytokines acting on T cells or antigen-presenting cells, such as IFN-gamma, IL-2, IL-6, IL-7, GM-CSF or MCP-3, no significant enhancing effect was observed. The same effect of IL-12 was obtained with peptide P1A, which is a major tumor-specific antigen of mastocytoma P815 and is encoded by a gene that is specifically activated in tumors.     

Human allospecific cytolytic T lymphocyte lysis of a murine cell transfected with HLA-A2

A variety of molecules are involved in the interaction of human allospecific cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) with target cells. Monoclonal antibodies specific for these molecules inhibit CTL-target conjugate formation and/or lysis. To further study recognition and lysis of targets by human CTL, we used a murine mastocytoma cell line transfected with the histocompatibility leukocyte antigen (HLA)-A2 gene (P815-A2+) as a target for human HLA-A2-specific CTL. We find that only a subset of human HLA-A2-specific CTL can lyse murine P815-A2+ cells, suggesting that the murine cells may lack one or more accessory molecules needed for CTL recognition and lysis.     

The case of the midwife scientist.

Genes controlling both testis determining and expression of the male-specific transplantation antigen, HY, are located on the short arm of the mouse Y chromosome, and on the X and Y-linked translocation, Sxr(a). A mutation of Sxr(a) was discovered in a cross between an Sxr carrier male and a T16H/X female. This was designated Sxr(b) and found to affect both the expression of HY and spermatogenesis, but not testis differentiation, thereby disproving Ohno's hypothesis that HY controlled testis determination. Molecular genetic analysis showed the mutation to be caused by fusion of two duplicated genes, Zfy1 and Zfy2, deleting the intervening DNA. This deletion interval, deltaSxr(b), contained a number of genes, each a candidate HY gene. Expression cloning with HY-specific T cell clones identified Smcy, Uty and Dby as encoding peptide epitopes of this transplantation antigen. The human homologues SMCY and UTY likewise express HY antigens and these are targets of damaging graft-versus-host (GVH) responses and potentially therapeutic graft-versus-leukaemia (GVL) responses following bone marrow transplantation (BMT). Knowledge of the peptide identity of HY epitopes allows monitoring of immune responses following BMT, using fluorescent tetramers, and also offers the possibility of inducing immunological tolerance.     

Epstein-Barr virus-specific cytotoxic T-cell recognition of transfectants expressing the virus-coded latent membrane protein LMP

Cytotoxic T cells from Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-immune individuals specifically kill EBV-transformed B cells from HLA class I antigen-matched donors even though the latently infected cells express only a restricted set of virus genes. The virus-induced target antigens recognized by these immune T cells have not been identified. In our experiments, EBV DNA sequences encoding the virus latent gene products Epstein-Barr nuclear antigen (EBNA)1, EBNA 2, and EBNA-LP and the latent membrane protein (LMP) were individually expressed in a virus-negative human B-lymphoma cell line, Louckes. Transfected clones expressing LMP were killed by EBV-specific cytotoxic T-cell preparations from each of three virus-immune donors HLA matched with Louckes through HLA-A2, B44 antigens; control transfectants or clones expressing one of the EBNA proteins were not recognized. Expression of LMP in a second virus-negative B-cell line, BL41, sensitized these cells to EBV-specific cytolysis restricted through the HLA-A11 antigen. To distinguish between the viral protein and an induced human B-cell activation antigen as the target for T-cell recognition, LMP was then expressed in a murine mastocytoma cell line, P815-A11-restricted human T cells. The LMP-expressing P815-A11 transfectants were susceptible to lysis by EBV-specific cytotoxic T cells from three HLA-A11-positive individuals. Both Louckes and P815-A11 cells were also transfected with constructs capable of encoding a truncated form of LMP (Tr-LMP) which lacks the N-terminal 128 amino acids of the full-length protein. Tr-LMP-expressing transfectants were not recognized by the above T-cell preparations. The results suggest that LMP, and, in particular, epitopes derived from the N-terminal region of the protein, provides one of the target antigens for the EBV-induced human cytotoxic T-cell response.